Uber die Verbrechen spricht niemand

Hamburger Abendblatt

23.04.2005

“Über die Verbrechen spricht niemand”
Armenische Familie kam Ende der 60er Jahre nach Hamburg. Ihre
Vergangenheit läßt sie nicht los.

Von Anne Klesse

Ein türkischer Arbeitskollege in Hamburg erzählte Oskian Karabulut
(65) einmal von den “Heldentaten” seines Onkels in der Türkei. Der
habe 1915 während der Todesmärsche Armenier gezwungen, auf einem Feld
ein großes Loch zu graben. “Sie wurden zu fünft zusammengebunden”,
erinnerte der Kollege. Dann hätten die türkischen Soldaten
losgeschossen. Fiel einer aus der Gruppe getroffen ins Grab, riß er
die anderen mit. Zum Pausenbrot brüstete sich der Kollege: “Mein Onkel
hat die meisten Armenier getötet in seiner Kompanie.” Zum Dank gab es
einen Füllfederhalter vom Offizier.

“Der Kollege wußte nicht, daß ich Armenier bin”, sagt Oskian
Karabulut. Keiner merkt auf Anhieb, daß die Familie aus Jenfeld
armenischer Abstammung ist. Die Eltern von Oskian Karabult hießen
eigentlich Maraslian. Doch dann kamen Regierungsbeamte in ihr Haus und
zwangen ihnen einen türkischen Nachnamen auf. “Mein Vater entschied
sich für Karabulut. Das bedeutet ,Dunkle Wolke’.”

Oskians Vater, Mesrop Karabulut, lebte ein friedliches Landleben in
einem Dorf nahe der Stadt Sivas, im Osten der heutigen Türkei. Eines
Tages im Sommer 1915 kamen Soldaten und befahlen allen armenischen
Familien umzusiedeln. “Die Regierung habe einen entsprechenden Erlaß
unterzeichnet, hieß es.” Ihre Pferde durften die armenischen Bauern
nicht mitnehmen, nur Esel und Ochsen, auf denen sie nicht flüchten
konnten. Den Großvater von Oskian Karabulut zitierten die Soldaten zu
sich. “Er war Pfarrer, etwa 40 Jahre alt.” Die Soldaten wollten
wissen, wo Kirchenschätze waren und folterten ihn. Er verriet nichts,
aber er bezahlte mit dem Leben: “Die Soldaten klemmten seinen Kopf
zwischen die Räder eines Ochsenwagens und trieben die Tiere zum
Galopp.” Der achtjährige Sohn, Oskian Karabuluts Vater, mußte mit
ansehen, wie sein Vater starb.

Mehr als eine Million Armenier wurden im Osmanischen Reich in den
Jahren 1915 und 1916 umgebracht. Zeugen berichten von Todesmärschen in
die syrische Wüste. Armenische Mädchen und Frauen seien wie Sklavinnen
als Dienstmädchen oder Ehefrau ausgesucht und abgeführt wurden.
Verantwortlich war das Komitee für Einheit und Fortschritt um
Kriegsminister Enver Pascha und Innenminister Talaat Pascha – der
sich, vom türkischen Gericht nach Kriegsende zum Tode verurteilt, nach
Berlin absetzte, wo ihn 1921 ein armenischer Student erschoß.

Das damals verbündete Deutsche Reich schwieg. Die Türkei leugnet den
Genozid noch heute. “Nach dem Mord an meinem Großvater töteten die
Soldaten weitere Männer”, erzählt Oskian Karabulut. “Sie hatten
Bajonette, Säbel und Gewehre.” Sein Vater hatte Glück. “Ein
befreundeter türkischer Großbauer bestach die Wachen. Meine
Großmutter, Vater, zwei Brüder und eine Schwester konnten fliehen.”
Eine zweite Schwester sah Mesrop Karabulut sah nie wieder. Eineinhalb
Jahre versteckte sich die Familie auf dem Gutshof des Großbauern.
Immer wieder kamen Soldaten. Einmal nahmen sie einen der Brüder mit.
Er blieb verschwunden.

Als die Karabuluts 1917 endlich in ihr altes Dorf zurückkehren
konnten, war nichts wie vorher: Türken wohnten in ihren Häusern.
Alles, was ihnen lieb gewesen war, war weg, die Kirche eine Ruine. Die
direkte Gefahr war vorüber, aber Anfeindungen blieben. Oskian
Karabulut wurde geboren im Nachbardorf von Seyranus Atilmis, ebenfalls
Armenierin. Später heirateten die beiden und wanderten Ende der 60er
Jahre nach Hamburg aus.

Hier sitzen die beiden Rentner nun in ihrem zitronengelb gestrichenen
Wohnzimmer. Sie essen Kuchen, trinken Kaffee. In der Vitrine steht ein
Osterhase neben Familienfotos und Porzellan. Es wird türkisch
gesprochen. Trotzdem: “Wir sind Armenier, unser Herz gehört unserem
Volk, das ist uns wichtig.” Ihren Glauben haben die Karabuluts sich
bewahrt. Sie blieben armenisch-orthodoxe Christen, trotz vieler
Zwangskonvertierungen. Sie sagen, was sie denken, und stehen damit
weitgehend allein. “Egal ob in der Türkei oder in Deutschland – wenige
Türken sprechen über die damaligen Verbrechen”, sagt Oskian Karabuluts
Tochter Kristin (37). “Dabei vermeiden alle das Wort ,Genozid'”. Wer
es doch tut, wird angefeindet – wie der türkische Schriftsteller Orhan
Pamuk.

http://www.abendblatt.de/

Kuban cossacks take part in procession to memorial to the Genocide

Pan Armenian News

KUBAN COSSACKS TAKE PART IN PROCESSION TO MEMORIAL TO ARMENIAN GENOCIDE
VICTIMS

24.04.2005 04:57

/PanARMENIAN.Net/ April 22 the delegation of Cossacks of Korenov region of
Krasnodar Territory arrived in Yerevan to take part in the procession
heading for the Memorial to Victims of the Armenian Genocide. The delegation
is headed by ataman of Kuban Cossack Society of Korenov region of the
Territory Mikhail Timchenko. The Cossacks of Korenov region of Kuban have
long-standing friendly relations with the local Armenian community, as the
409-th Armenian riffle division liberated Sergiyevskaya Stanitsa of Korenov
region from fascist invaders. Annually marking the day of liberation of
their Stanitsa residents of Sergiyevskaya lay flowers to the monument to
major S. Ayvazian and soldiers of the Armenian division, who died in battles
for the Stanitsa. The monument was erected on the initiative of Korenov
Cossacks and their ataman.

Turkey Confirms Contacts With Armenia

Turkey Confirms Contacts With Armenia

Agence France Presse, Arab News

ISTANBUL, 23 April 2005 – Turkish Foreign Minister Abdullah Gul
yesterday urged him his Armenian counterpart Vardan Oskanian to
respond to goodwill gestures he made at unofficial meetings between
the two countries that have no diplomatic relations. `I’ve met the
Armenian foreign minister six times, it’s no secret. We have no
diplomatic relations but we do have contacts,’ said Gul.

Turkish daily Milliyet yesterday said meetings had been held over the
past three years in neutral locations with the aim of establishing a
raft of ten confidence-building measures between the two. Relations
between Turkey and Armenia have been dogged by, among other events,
the mass killings of Armenians during the fall of the Ottoman Empire
(the predecessor of modern Turkey) 90 years ago.

Armenians say up to 1.5 million of their kinsmen perished in
orchestrated killings between 1915 and 1917 as the Ottoman Empire was
falling apart.

Ankara counters that 300,000 Armenians and thousands of Turks were
killed in `civil strife’ during World War I when the Armenians rose
against their Ottoman rulers and sided with invading Russian
troops. `We have made one gesture after another, but they have not
reciprocated. They too (the Armenians) have to take steps,’ said
Gul. Gul pointed to the opening of air routesbetween the two countries
as one gesture made by Turkey, and a regional trade initiative for
Black Sea cooperation as another.

`In Turkey there are 40,000 Armenians working and saving money to send
home,’ said Gul. Turkey wants Armenia to hand back the Nagorno-Karabakh
enclave to Azerbaijan. Armenia seized the Armenian-majority territory
in 1994 after a regional conflict with Azerbaijan. Turkey recognized
Armenia on its 1991 independence but has never established diplomatic
relations with it. Ankara closed its frontier with Armenia in 1993 in
solidarity with Turkish-speaking Azerbaijan.

Meanwhile, 17 Turkish coal miners died from methane gas poisoning on
Thursday after an explosion trapped them beneath rubble, the state-run
Anatolian news agency said. Two people were earlier found alive, but
rescue workers had ruled out any more survivors after finding the
bodies of 17 men some 300 meters underground.

The cause of the blast at the state-owned mine near the western town
of Gediz was not immediately clear. A lack of investment in Turkish
mines hasbeen blamed for poor maintenance and shoddy construction that
have led to a series of accidents in the past.

In September, 19 workers were burned to death in the collapsed tunnel
of a copper mine in northern Turkey. The country’s worst mining
disaster was in 1992, when 270 miners were killed in a methane gas
explosion near the Black Sea.

ANKARA: An Armenian Autobiography Refutes Claims of Genocide

Journal of Turkish Weekly
April 23 2005

An Armenian Autobiography Refutes Claims of Genocide

SOURCE: Hurriyet, 23 April 2005

An autobiographical book of an American citizen of Armenian roots is
being promoted in the US by Ata Erim, the Chairman of the Federation
of Turkish American Associations. The author, Edward Tashji, friend
of the Turks, has written a real life account of what happened. In an
interesting turn of events the book refutes claims of genocide
against the Armenians.

The book, which is titled, “Armenian Allegations – The Truth Must Be
Told”, will be sent to American senators, parliamentarians,
governors, mayors, TV anchormen, newspaper editors, university and
high school libraries, members of European Parliament and all members
of the United Nations.

Unfortunately, the author couldn’t attend the book promotion as he is
lies in intensive care for three weeks, however, Tashji’s wife, Mary
Tashji and relatives were there.

A Turkish group is planned to march in Washington on April 24, to
protest the Armenian claims of genocide.

ANKARA: Striking Remarks by Erich Feigl (On the Armenian “Genocide”A

Hurriyet via BYEGM, Turkey
April 22 2005

Striking Remarks by Erich Feigl (On the Armenian “Genocide”
Allegations)

Tufan Turenc

Columnist Tufan Turenc comments on the Armenian “genocide” claims
and Professor Erich Feigl’s remarks on the issue. A summary of his
column is as follows:

“A panel on ‘Turkish-Armenian Relations and Historical Facts’ was held
earlier this week at Istanbul Technical University (ITU). Among the
speakers at the panel was well-known Austrian author and documentary
filmmaker Professor Erich Feigl, who made various incisive remarks
during his speech.

Feigl is an expert on Middle Eastern, Central Asian and American
cultures and religions. He has produced several documentaries which
have attracted worldwide attention. He became acquainted with the
events of 1915 while doing historical research, and he quickly
developed an interest in the issue. Meanwhile, Turkish Attaché for
Labor and Social Affairs in Vienna Erdogan Ozen, a close friend of his,
was murdered by the terrorist Armenian Secret Army for the Liberation
of Armenia (ASALA) in 1984. Ozen’s murder affected him so much that
he wrote a book on Armenian terror called ‘A Myth of Terror.’

In his speech, Feigl lamented that Turkey has been unable to counter
the psychological war waged by the Armenians. Feigl said that the
total number of Armenians who lived under Ottoman rule was 1.7 million,
and only 700,000 of them were sent away by the Ottomans. Therefore,
their assertion that 1.5 million Armenians were killed is nonsensical.

Feigl also presented a new document, in which Boghos Nubar, leader
of the Armenians in exile early in the last centrury, admits that
the Armenians took sides with the enemy during the war. ‘It’s most
fortunate that I could discover this document before the Armenians
could find and destroy it,’ Feigl said. ‘Because they have successfully
destroyed almost every document against them.’

Feigl also urged that Turkey not agree to discuss their claims, let
alone recognize them. ‘If you recognize their claims or even agree
to discuss the issue with them, next they will demand your money and
land. You should never ever do that,’ he said.

Feigl ended his speech with a striking statement: ‘This land is
yours. You didn’t settle in Anatolia after the Battle of Malazgirt.
Archeological findings at Catalhoyuk prove that you have been here
for more than 10,000 years’.”

–Boundary_(ID_qmMXHlSwoFyRznIefm/fZw)–

http://www.byegm.gov.tr/yayinlarimiz/chr/ing2005/04/05x04x22.htm

Turkey Blackmails and Interferes In Internal Affairs Of Germany,Prev

TURKEY BLACKMAILS AND INTERFERES IN INTERNAL AFFAIRS OF
GERMANY, PREVENTING LOBBYING OF ARMENIAN PROBLEMS

YEREVAN, APRIL 20. ARMINFO. Turkey blackmails and always interferes in
the internal affairs of Germany, hindering the lobbying of Armenian
problems. Tessa Hoffman, Professor of Berlin’s Freie University,
author of 13 books dedicated to history and culture of Armenia,
stated in the interview to ARMINFO.

According to her, the evidence of this policy is the number f
recent incidents in Germany, among which the attempt to remove from
text-books the topic of Armenian Genocide. Besides, recently the
Armenian diaspora of Berlin appealed to the parliament of Berlin with
a request to commemorate the 90th anniversary of Armenian Genocide,
where the former mayor of Berlin must have a speech. The documentary
film “Genocide of Armenians” was demonstrated in France recently,
and in Germany the same film was demonstrated under the name “Turks
against Armenians”. “Why Germany submits to this blackmail and permits
Turkey constantly to interference in its affairs, and what facts of
general history it is afraid of? One may only surmise whether it is
fear of possible compensation to Armenians or simply accusations of
participation in this tragedy”, the scientist said.

Armenian clergy to depart for Vatican

ARMENIAN CLERGY TO DEPART FOR VATICAN

A1plus

| 18:49:25 | 21-04-2005 | Official |

April 23 the delegation of the Armenian Apostolic Church will depart
for Vatican to take part in the Mass for the solemn inauguration of
pontificate Benedict 16th to be celebrated at St. Peter’s on Sunday,
April 24 at 10 a.m

The delegation is composed of Armenian Partiarch of Constantinople,
Archbishop Mesrop Mutafyan, Archbishop Nerses Pozapalyan from Holy
Echmiadzin and priest Trdat Uzunyan.

GenEd: New Teaching Kit on the Armenian Genocide

PRESS RELEASE

The Genocide Education Project
“Learning the Past, Building the Future”
51 Commonwealth Avenue
San Francisco, CA 94118
(415) 264-4203
[email protected]

Contact: Sara Cohan (415) 264-4203

April 18, 2005

NEW TEACHING KIT ON THE ARMENIAN GENOCIDE

San Francisco, CA – A new teaching kit about the Armenian Genocide
is now available through The Genocide Education Project. The Genocide
Education Project has teamed up with Facing History and Ourselves to
provide teaching guides, lesson plans, and audio/visual aids together
as one comprehensive kit for teachers seeking to include the Armenian
Genocide in their classrooms. The kit includes a resource book,
step-by-step lesson plans, five large posters, and a television
news video for $59.00 + S/H. Educators interested in incorporating
the Armenian Genocide into their curriculum can purchase this
teacher-tested resource kit online at

Below are brief descriptions of the resources in this kit.

RESOURCE BOOK

Facing History and Ourselves’ new resource book, “Crimes Against
Humanity and Civilization: The Genocide of the Armenians,”
combines the latest scholarship on the Armenian Genocide with
an interdisciplinary approach to history, enabling students and
teachers to make the essential connections between history and their
own lives. By concentrating on the choices that individuals, groups,
and nations made before, during, and after the genocide, readers have
the opportunity to consider the dilemmas faced by the international
community in the face of massive human rights violations.

LESSON PLANS

“Human Rights and Genocide: A Case Study of the First Genocide of
the 20th Century” was developed by The Genocide Education Project and
the San Francisco Unified School District. Using the History-Social
Science Framework for California Public Schools as its foundation,
this comprehensive teachers’ manual focuses on the Armenian Genocide
of 1915, during which 1.5 million Armenians, half of the Armenian
population, were systematically annihilated. It includes a One Day,
Two Day, and Ten Day unit, with all the materials teachers will
need, including more than two dozen overheads, interactive classroom
exercises and more.

The lesson plans also approach the Armenian Genocide in the context
of WWI and the international political-social upheavals of the
time, and also considers the links between the Armenian Genocide
and the Holocaust. Other major human rights violations such as the
Transatlantic Slave Trade, the Rape of Nanking, and the Cambodian and
Rwandan genocides are also used in the lessons to draw parallels and
engender contemplation and discussion about the phenomenon of genocide
and human rights abuses.

VIDEO

“The Century: The Forgotten Genocide” is a 5-minute news program
produced by ABC News for the news broadcast World News Tonight with
Peter Jennings. Beginning with a comparison by Jennings of the scene
of death marches during the Armenian Genocide at the beginning of
the 20th century with lines of refugees leaving Bosnia at the end of
the 20th century, the piece includes survivor interviews, historians,
and archival footage to give a brief synopsis of the century’s first
genocide. The video can be used as a good introductory visual aid,
and is available in DVD and VHS formats along with a transcript
through The Genocide Education Project

POSTERS

Designed for classroom use, teacher workshops, exhibits, and displays,
this set of 5 theme-oriented instructional posters tell the story
of the Armenian Genocide, providing a visual overview of key events
related to the genocide, its prelude, methodology, and aftermath. Each
illustrated poster measures 19″ x 25″ and includes photographs, text,
graphics and a chronology, allowing teachers and students to easily
grasp essential facts related to each theme. The posters also provide
teachers with a template for further instruction, exploration and
study. These educational are available through The Genocide Education
Project.

For more information about the efforts of The Genocide Education
Project please visit their Web site at

—-

The Genocide Education Project is a nonprofit organization that
assists educators in teaching about human rights and genocide,
particularly the Armenian Genocide, by developing and distributing
instructional materials, providing access to teaching resources and
organizing educational workshops.

http://www.genocideeducation.org/pr/2005/04_18_2005.htm
www.GenocideEducation.org
www.TeachGenocide.org
www.TeachGenocide.org.
www.GenocideEducation.org.

In Athens film about Armenian Genocide shown

In Athens film about Armenian Genocide shown

A1plus
| 21:07:42 | 20-04-2005 | Social |

On April 19 in the Athens Armenian Church Primacy hall the documentary
film made by the Lebanon LBC TV company was shown. The film was
dedicated to the 90th anniversary of the Great Armenian Genocide.

In the film there were documentary frames from the 1915 massacres,
shots of the Historical Armenia (Van, Kars, Ani, Sis, Aghtamar) in
past and now, and interviews with those who have survived the Genocide.

Many Germans Resentful To Learn About Armenian Genocide… After 90Y

MANY GERMANS RESENTFUL TO LEARN ABOUT ARMENIAN GENOCIDE… AFTER 90 YEARS

AZG Armenian Daily #069, 19/04/2005

Armenian Genocide

Since January, the Armenian Genocide has caught the spotlight of
major and minor mass media in Germany, and an Armenian scholar can
do nothing but study all the printed material under a magnifying
glass. And a common German TV viewer or a paper reader keeps on
asking why they were unaware of it till now. My 50-year-old friend
who speaks 7 languages and claims to have good command of history
keeps on amazing that neither he nor his 80-year-old father have
ever come across a single sentence about the Armenian Genocide in
any German or English history textbooks. “Why did they withhold the
truth from us?”, he asks and adds that Hitler was, in fact, the first
one to acknowledge it as genocide. A documentary by Laurence Jourdan
“Turks vs. Armenians” that was shown by French-German arte TV on
April 13 for the first time deeply affected my German friend (and
not only he) with its historicity.

There are still many more photos and films in different corners of
the world that are unfamiliar to us. Survivors from Canada to Syria as
well as notifications of western ambassadors of the time tell us about
the Genocide. Writings of German consul Walter Roessler in Aleppo, US
consul Lesley Davis in Kharput (perhaps Kharberd), German ambassador to
Constantinople Conrad von Wangenheim, US ambassador Henry Morgenthau
and Wangenheim’s successor Wolf Metternich testify to the fact that
the described events fall under Lemkin’s definition of genocide.

German ARD TV aired a program on Armenian Genocide on April 14 during
which it was said that the en masse and systematized elimination of
the Armenians assumes to be defined as genocide. Sound arguments of
German historians, horrible stories of survivor Zepyur Metsbaqian,
Turkish lawmakers’ negations and journalists’ blunt questions
interrupted the reportage. Turkey and its ally Germany have never
mentioned of responsibility. The suit on Armenian Genocide at the
Bundestag was canceled 4 years ago and now it again gives in under
Turkish diplomacy’s pressure.

By the way, authors of the program reminded that only Germany voted
against a resolution on Armenian Genocide at the European Parliament
in 1985.

Now is the time to tell the truth after 90 years of negation. It’s
hard to predict what will be Bundestag’s response to the program’s
appeal. Let’s have patience to see the outcome.

By Anahit Hovsepian in Germany