Two Survivors Share Horror And Hope

TWO SURVIVORS SHARE HORROR AND HOPE
by: Tomi Obaro

The Washington Post
August 6, 2012 Monday
Suburban Edition

At first glance, Freddy Mutanguha and Margit Meissner couldn’t be
more different.

Mutanguha, 36, is tall and black, with a round face, high cheekbones
and quiet voice. Meissner, 90, is short and white, with a beak-shaped
nose and a frank, disarming manner.

But they both work in museums. They both have Facebook profiles.

And they are both genocide survivors.

Meissner was 16 years old when she fled Czechoslovakia for France,
just as the Nazis were annexing Austria. Mutanguha was 18 when he
fled Rwanda’s western province for the southern part of the country,
leaving behind two dead parents and four dead sisters.

Meissner, a volunteer at the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum,
lives in Bethesda.

Mutanguha, director of the Kigali Genocide Memorial, lives in Rwanda.

And this weekend, they both were in Washington, where Meissner gave
Mutanguha a tour of the Holocaust Museum – and they both reflected
on their mutual hope that educating people about genocides that have
already occurred might prevent others.

The two survivors first met in June when Meissner visited the Kigali
Genocide Memorial as part of a trip she was taking with Women for
Women International, an organization that teaches women in eight
war-torn countries basic economic skills. Meissner sponsors a young
Rwandan woman as part of the program, but because Women for Women
International’s relationship with the Kigali Genocide Memorial was
so informal, Mutanguha didn’t even know about Meissner’s visit.

“When [a colleague] said, ‘Did you know there was a Holocaust survivor
that came to the memorial,’ I said . . . ‘It’s not possible,’ââ~B”
exclaimed Mutanguha.

The two finally met for breakfast, on the last day of Meissner’s trip.

“We became friends; we get along very well,” Mutanguha says.

Meissner convinced Mutanguha to come to Washington.

On his way to a conference in Los Angeles on preventing genocide,
Mutanguha spent 24 hours in Washington with support from Women for
Women International and a bed for the night in Meissner’s home.

Meissner has been a museum guide for the past six years. She spent
30 years working in special education administration in Montgomery
County. It was only after writing her memoirs – encouraged by her
children – that she realized the significance of her story.

“As a survivor, I realized I was in a unique position. There are
thousands of people who could do [special education advocacy], but
there are not a lot of Holocaust survivors left.”

Mutanguha got involved in genocide prevention work as a volunteer with
a student association at his university. He helped gather testimony
and photographs from thousands of survivors of the 1994 slaughter,
which left an estimated 800,000 Rwandans dead. After graduating with a
degree in biography and geography, Mutanguha was offered a volunteer
job with Aegis Trust, a genocide prevention organization that was
tapped to create a memorial museum in Kigali. In 2006, Mutanguha was
offered the post of director of the Kigali Genocide Memorial.

“If you want to understand what happened and you don’t listen
to survivors, you will never have full, relevant information,”
Mutanguha says.

Their shared interest in survivor testimonies is clear as Meissner
takes Mutanguha through the Holocaust Museum. Mutanguha watches a
screening in the “From Memory to Action” installation, waiting for
a taped interview with Carl Wilkens, a humanitarian aid worker who
was one of the few Americans to stay in Rwanda when the genocide
took place.

After the tour, Mutanguha and Meissner share their thoughts. Mutanguha
is gentle with his praise, while Meissner isn’t afraid to disagree. He
appreciates the way the museum touches on other genocides in the world,
but Meissner disagrees.

“[The Holocaust Museum] doesn’t have anything about Armenia. The main
exhibit is only about the Jews, so I was very impressed with the
[Kigali Genocide Memorial]. You talk about the Holocaust, you talk
about Bosnia, you talk about Armenia, you talk about Cambodia. This
museum doesn’t talk about Cambodia at all,” Meissner says.

Some of their opinions seem to reflect generational differences:
“The messages on the table, this is good,” Mutanguha says about an
exhibit in “From Memory to Action” that lights up with information
when touched.

“I don’t know that it is good.” says Meissner, as Mutanguha laughs.

Meissner continues, “I personally think that it is a distraction.”

What emerges most is the emotional bond that quickly developed between
two people who have shared atrocity.

“Margaret . . .” Mutanguha begins.

“Margit!” Meissner interrupts him.

“Margarit, sorry my English . . . ”

They laugh.

“Margit is like a mother to us,” Mutanguha continues.

The shared pain of their past has left Mutanguha and Meissner keenly
aware of the ways in which the world has failed to prevent other
genocides. But Mutanguha is cautiously optimistic about the impact
this museum and others like it could have.

“This memorial in Washington, it’s very well done,” he says. “It covers
everything we need to know about. So let’s see what the world will do.”

Russia Sees Settlement Within OSCE Minsk Group

RUSSIA SEES SETTLEMENT WITHIN OSCE MINSK GROUP

Mediamax
Aug 8 2012
Armenia

Yerevan/Mediamax/. Russia thinks efforts toward settlement of Karabakh
conflict should be focused on OSCE Minsk Group as before.

Deputy Foreign Minister of Russia Grigory Karasin said this speaking on
“Golos Russia” radio station, Mediamax reports.

“Armenia and Azerbaijan are our close partners within CIS. We value
our relations both with Yerevan and Baku and do our best fairly and
honestly to bring the positions of both sides on Nagorno Karabakh
together. It’s an extremely difficult and complex topic which has
its roots and its history. I think we should focus our efforts on the
Minsk Group as before. There is Minsk Group comprising Co-Chairs and
representatives of France, United States, Russia, OSCE representatives
which work very conscientiously: they travel to the region, meet with
Armenian and Azerbaijani leaders, help them find acceptable wording
for future documents. We support this activity in every possible
way and expect it to yield a definite result in the nearest future”,
said the Russian diplomat.

He noted that electoral cycles in Armenia and Azerbaijan affect the
settlement process but he expressed the hope that “we may begin to
move forward in 2012-2013”.

Russian And Armenian Presidents Meet

RUSSIAN AND ARMENIAN PRESIDENTS MEET

Vestnik Kavkaza
Aug 8 2012
Russia

Armenian President Serzh Sargsyan is on a visit to Moscow where
he met Russian President Vladimir Putin and discussed key issues
of bilateral cooperation. Putin thanked Sargsyan for the positive
investment climate for Russian business. They decided to organize
a Russian-Armenian intergovernmental commission in autumn 2012 for
economic cooperation until 2020, RIA Novosti reports.

Russian-Armenian trade turnover reached $1 billion in 2011 and
increased by 32% in Q1 2012. Armenians working in Russia bring about
$1 billion back to Armenia every year. Sargsyan expressed hope for
doubling or tripling trade turnover in the next 2-3 years.

Gazprom (Russia) and the Armenian Ministry for Energy and Natural
Resources are rumoured to be negotiating adjustments to gas prices.

Gazprom is expected to increase gas prices from $180 per 1000 cubic
meters today to $280 on October 1 and $320 on January 1, 2013.

Armenian Minister for Energy and Natural Resources Armen Movsisyan
confirmed the negotiations without giving details. Higher gas prices
may cause public discontent in the light of the presidential polls
of 2013.

Yerevan is in need of loans, because the EU postponed the consideration
of the issue. Aykakan Zhamanak said that Armenia is having unofficial
negotiations with Russia to receive a loan of $0.8-1 billion.

105 Passengers To Arrive In Armenia From Aleppo Today

105 PASSENGERS TO ARRIVE IN ARMENIA FROM ALEPPO TODAY

Panorama.am
08/08/2012

Armavia Air Company will operate Yerevan-Aleppo-Yerevan additional
flight today, August 8. According to preliminary information, 105
passengers will arrive in Armenia on Armavia plane, the air company
told Panorama.am.

Beginning August 9, Armavia, jointly with the Armenian government,
will operate flights to transport Syrian-Armenian children to Armenia.

The flights will be implemented as part of Armenian Diaspora Ministry’s
program.

>From August 9, Armavia will operate Yerevan-Damascus-Yerevan and
Yerevan-Aleppo-Yerevan special flights.

Deux Armeniens Tues Lundi a Alep

DEUX ARMENIENS TUES LUNDI A ALEP
Krikor Amirzayan

armenews.com
mercredi 8 aout 2012

Lundi la guerre civile a fait deux nouvelles victimes armeniennes
a Alep (Syrie). Lors des combats qui faisaient rage dans certains
quartiers de la ville, un Armenien d’une quarantaine d’annees, Vicken
Kalaïdjian a trouve la mort, ainsi qu’un autre dont l’identite n’a pas
ete revele. On denombre egalement parmi les victimes de la journee de
lundi a Alep trois arabes chretiens. Tôt dans la matinee de 4 heures
jusqu’a 9 heures les combats entre les forces gouvernementales et
les rebelles faisaient rage a proximite des quartiers armeniens de
la ville. De nombreux membres de la communaute armenienne a du fuir
leurs habitations. Des bâtiments militaires se trouveraient dans les
quartiers armeniens et furent donc la cible d’attques des rebelles.

Public Union Of Azerbaijani Community Of Nagorno Karabakh Issues Sta

PUBLIC UNION OF AZERBAIJANI COMMUNITY OF NAGORNO KARABAKH ISSUES STATEMENT PROTESTING RESETTLEMENT OF SYRIAN ARMENIANS IN AZERBAIJAN’S OCCUPIED TERRITORIES

APA
Aug 7 2012
Azerbaijan

Baku – APA. Public Union of Azerbaijani community of Nagorno Karabakh
issued statement in a protest regarding the reports released by
Armenian press about resettlement of Syrian Armenians in occupied
Nagorno Karabakh region of Azerbaijan.

APA reports that the statement reads: “Armenians supporting the
Syria regime due to situation in the country escape Syria in fear of
further developments, the issue of their resettlement in Azerbaijan’s
occupied territories has been recently discussed in Armenia. According
to information, it was proposed to establish a “Public Council
for resettlement” for resettling the Syrian Armenians encamping
in the occupied territories. All of these caused a sharp protest
by Azerbaijani people, including Azerbaijani community of Nagorno
Karabakh region, these initiatives were discussed and condemned at
the meeting of board of directors of the Public Union of Azerbaijani
community of Nagorno Karabakh region of Azerbaijan Republic.

It was noted that the Azerbaijanis, who lived historically in Nagorno
Karabakh region, assess this artificial “resettlement” policy as
a flagrant violation of Azerbaijani Constitution and norms and
principles of the international law, as well as the initiatives
to increase artificially the Armenian population in Azerbaijani
lands as a purposeful step: “Namely, Armenian government considers
that the resettlement of Syrian Armenians in Karabakh will have an
effect in certain manner on ethnic composition of the region, it will
let Armenian nationalists to claim that the number of Armenians in
Karabakh is more than Azerbaijanis. Undoubtedly, Armenians resettling
from Syria represent mostly the poor and middle class of population.

That is why the government of Armenia that has been keeping Azerbaijani
lands under occupation for 20 years and reduced Armenian people
to poverty, considers that the Armenians, who escape Syria, can be
resettled in Nagorno Karabakh. The Armenian government grants certain
discounts and renders assistances to Armenians resettling in Karabakh.

We consider that by such illegal acts Armenia brings to naught all
peaceful talks held within the OSCE Minsk Group, the initiatives of
international unions to create peace and cooperation in the region
and the possibilities of dialog between the communities. The entire
world knows that unrecognized separatist regime in the occupied
territories of Azerbaijan is based on ethnic cleansing of Azerbaijani
population and is a criminal organization established by Armenia. We
consider that the initiatives of Armenia implemented for maintaining
the status-quo as long as possible and concealing the essence of
its occupying policy, were put forward earlier. The resettlement of
Armenians from different countries, including Syria seriously damages
not only the negotiation process, but the region’s future status and
development. The Azerbaijani community of Nagorno Karabakh expresses
hope that the international community will strongly condemn Armenia’s
non-constructive actions and take the most effective measures to put
an end to this country’s “resettlement” and occupation policy.

Russia Won’t Take Part In Kavkaz 2012 Military Drills

RUSSIA WON’T TAKE PART IN KAVKAZ 2012 MILITARY DRILLS

Voice of Russia
Aug 7 2012

Russian troops deployed in Abkhazia, Armenia and South Ossetia will not
take part in the Kavkaz-2012 strategic command-post exercise, Russian
General Staff Deputy Head Col. Gen. Alexander Postnikov has announced.

“Russian troops based in Armenia, South Ossetia and Abkhazia will
not be involved in the drill. Nor will foreign participants. The
exercise will take place in Russian territory,” Postnikov said at a
news conference at Interfax on Tuesday.

The Russian military bases located in Abkhazia, Armenia and South
Ossetia are subordinated to Russia’s Southern Military District. The
4,500-strong 102nd military base is deployed in Gyumri in Armenia,
the 7th military base has been located in Gudauta, Abkhazia, since
2009, and the 4th base in Dzhava and Tskhinvali in South Ossetia
since February 2009.

The Georgian foreign minister earlier said that Georgia is concerned
about the upcoming Kavkaz-2012 war games and by the Russian offensive
weapons located in Abkhazia, South Ossetia and Armenia.

Armavia Cancels Purchase Of Superjet 100 Due To Financial Problems

ARMAVIA CANCELS PURCHASE OF SUPERJET 100 DUE TO FINANCIAL PROBLEMS

Vestnik Kavkaza
Aug 7 2012
Russia

Russian Deputy Minister for Industry and trade Yuri Slyusar said that
the refusal by Armavia to buy Superjet 100 is a result of financial and
economic problems of the Armenian company, Rossiyskaya Gazeta reports.

Armavia was the first company to purchase the jet in April 2011. The
jet for small and medium-range flights is currently being repaired
at the Civil Planes of Sukhoi.

Armavia signed a contract for the purchase of two Superjet 100s,
cancelling the purchase of the second one later. The company explained
that it is a good plane, but Airbus and Boeing planes fly 330-350
hours a month, while Superjet 100 flies only 150 hours. Moreover,
the company had to spend 4 days resolving passing customs procedures
with Russia only to repair the plane for two days at Zhukovsky.

One Sukhoi Superjet 100 crashed in Indonesia on May 9, 2012. It
was being demonstrated to 6 Asian states. 48 people were killed in
the flight.

Is Armed Rebellion Being Planned In Javakheti?

IS ARMED REBELLION BEING PLANNED IN JAVAKHETI?
by Tamta Virsaladze’s

Rezonansi
July 31 2012
Georgia

Arnold Stepanyan: ‘There are groups that are interested in straining
Georgian-Armenian relations’

Azerbaijani news portal Azglobus.net has predicted an armed
rebellion in Samtskhe-Javakheti. Zaal Kasrelishvili, chairman of the
Confederation of the Peoples of the Caucasus, has urged the Georgian
special services to check this information and has said that this
kind of a threat is not unrealistic in a Georgian province populated
with ethnic minorities.

According to Azglobus.net, the Armenians living in Georgia’s southern
province of Samtskhe-Javakheti are planning an armed rebellion against
the Georgian state with Armenia’s active and comprehensive aid.

“Armenian media have waged an information war on Georgia so far.

Hundreds of materials prepared by the ideologists of the Dashnak
terrorist organization have been posted on the Internet. They are
also conducting ideological and propaganda work among the Armenian
population of this Georgian province.

“There are reports that young Armenians living in Javakheti are forming
units that are being sent to Armenia and Nagornyy Karabakh for combat
training in the camps of ASALA (Armenian Secret Army for the Liberation
of Armenia),” the website wrote. Several videos were also posted there.

According to the Medianews agency, Azerbaijani Vice President Ali
Hasanov has spoken about the sending of people to Russia and Georgia
with the subversive mission of fomenting national hatred.

“According to Azerbaijani Vice President Ali Hasanov, Armenia is
training terrorist groups on Azerbaijan’s occupied territories and
sending them not only to Azerbaijan, Russia, and Turkey but also to
the Middle East and Europe.

“According to Hasanov, they are sending those people on subversive
missions to Russia and Georgia in order to foment national hatred
there. The Azerbaijani Government representative claims that they
are also using the occupied territories for drug trafficking,” the
news agency’s report said.

Arnold Stepanyan, head of the Common Civil Movement -Multiethnic
Georgia union, believes that the dissemination of such reports is
advantageous for Azerbaijan and they have nothing to do with reality.

“One could have taken this information seriously had it been
disseminated by some Armenian media entity. However, if the
Azerbaijani side has so much information as to what is being planned
in Samtskhe-Javakheti, it does not bode well for Georgia, Armenia,
and Javakheti.

“There are no plans for a rebellion and there cannot be any. The
ethnic Armenians living in Javakheti did not do this when they had
the opportunity. I am talking about the time when there were problems
in Abkhazia and South Ossetia. I believe that we do not need to talk
about this subject because it is unrealistic.

“We have a strong suspicion that interested circles are disseminating
this kind of information and the topographic materials depicting a
great Armenia that includes Abkhazia. Georgia is surrounded by groups
that are interested in the straining of Georgian-Armenian relations
but I am deeply convinced that this is impossible,” Stepanyan told
Rezonansi.

Zaal Kasrelishvili, chairman of the Confederation of the Peoples of the
Caucasus, does not rule out the threat of separatism in Javakheti and
says that such activities are usually planned by people in the Kremlin.

“We believe that this information needs to be checked without fail. We
made a statement two or three months ago, saying that Javakhk is
starting some secret activities,” he told Rezonansi.

“Azerbaijanis have always been careful as far as Georgian-Armenian
relations are concerned. They have always tried to be polite and not
to interfere in Georgia’s and Armenia’s internal political affairs
from the ethnic angle because they know very well that there is no
conflict between the Azerbaijanis and Armenians living in Georgia.

“Certainly, Azerbaijan is interested in securing Georgia’s strategic
partnership in the Karabakh matter. It is always trying to obtain
information about the activities of the so-called Javakhk [Armenian
name for Georgia’s Javakheti region][public movement seeking local
autonomy] and send it to the Georgian authorities.

“I cannot tell you for certain whether or not this information is
true. The Confederation of the Peoples of the Caucasus made a statement
two or three months ago and we said that the Moscow-based leaders of
the Javakhk movement had made serious statements regarding Georgia’s
territorial integrity which went unnoticed for some reason.

We have not heard such a blunt statement and categorical attitude
since then.

“I believe that this statement is sufficient reason for the Georgian
political leadership and the country’s special services to start an
investigation and check those reports.

“This statement is not unrealistic. It is simply up to the special
services to investigate it and to determine how big a problem this
could be in the future. It does not matter whether the organization is
called Javakhk or something else and whether it has many people and
strong influence or not. What matters is that they will use the name
of this organization to carry out unconstitutional actions against
the Georgian state.

“Their headquarters could be located near the Georgian border in
Armenia, but it is clear that they are receiving their instructions
from the Kremlin,” Zaal Kasrelishvili said.

Arnold Stepanyan believes that a rebellion is also impossible in
Samtskhe-Javakheti because, in his opinion, the social and economic
situation has improved considerably in the region since 2003.

“I criticize the government very often over human rights violations.

Ethnicity is not the sole factor behind these problems because human
rights in general are being violated very seriously. Javakheti and
Samegrelo are the worst regions in this regard.

“However, if we discuss the economic and the social conditions,
there is a huge difference between 2003 and the current situation.

Communications are better, roads have been repaired, and people can
travel to Tbilisi faster than they could before. There is the problem
of water but it is not as serious as it used to be. The infrastructure
is improving. I would not say that 90 per cent of the locals support
the government but this support is likely to be stronger now than it
was before.

“The problem that the locals face is that they continue to live in an
information vacuum, just like the people in Georgia’s other provinces.

The information that is disseminated there in Georgian comes from
the government-controlled news sources. There are local TV stations
but the government controls them too. People also watch Armenian and
Russian TV stations. They cannot watch neutral TV stations like Maestro
[Tbilisi-based private pro-opposition TV channel] or read a newspaper
like Rezonansi,” Arnold Stepanyan told us.

However, Zaal Kasrelishvili believes that, despite some progress,
the government does not pay sufficient attention to the province
populated with ethnic minorities.

“The Georgian political leadership has always tried to establish
good relations with the local population in Samtskhe-Javakheti, or
at least they have made such a declaration. However, I still think
that the Georgian political leadership has paid as little attention
to Samtskhe-Javakheti as it has to other provinces.

“The statements that everything is supposedly all right in
Samtskhe-Javakheti are part of ordinary PR. The government may have
better relations with the residents of Samtskhe-Javakheti than it
did in [former President Eduard] Shevardnadze’s time but this is not
enough and it does not mean that the problem has been solved there,”
Zaal Kasrelishvili said.

[translated from Georgian]

Karabakh Authorities Deny Claims Of Settlements In Disputed Areas

KARABAKH AUTHORITIES DENY CLAIMS OF SETTLEMENTS IN DISPUTED AREAS

Interfax
Aug 2 2012
Russia

The Foreign Ministry of the breakaway Republic of Nagorno-Karabakh
has dismissed reports about settlements in the republic, as claimed
earlier by the OSCE (Organization for Security and Co-operation in
Europe) permanent mission in Azerbaijan.

“Despite the obvious fact that accepting migrants in one’s own
territory is the sovereign right of the Republic of Nagorno-Karabakh,
the distributed disinformation is absolutely baseless, which is proved
by the results of a monitoring of the situation in these territories,
conducted by the OSCE mission in 2010. As for the 2005 report by the
OSCE fact-finding mission, invoked by Azerbaijan’s permanent mission,
we consider it necessary to remind that according to a statement by
the co-chairs of the OSCE Minsk Group, the mission has not found any
obviously organized settlement and has not found the settlement to
be a result of a deliberate policy,” the Nagorno-Karabakh foreign
ministry said.

Azerbaijan has already started settlements in a number in disputed
territories, it also said.

“Moreover, Azerbaijan has for many years refused to agree to a similar
monitoring being conducted in these areas, which is indisputable
proof of their settlements and should raise serious concerns with
the OSCE and other international organizations,” the Nagorno-Karabakh
ministry said.