ANKARA: ‘Hollande Spring’ In Turkish-EU Relations

‘HOLLANDE SPRING’ IN TURKISH-EU RELATIONS

Hurriyet
June 22 2012
Turkey

FM Davutoðlu hails a thaw in Turkey-EU ties as the bloc pledges to
ease Turks’ visa procedures while Ankara ends sanctions against France

Turkey has ended sanctions against France thanks to newly elected
French President Francois Hollande’s positive approach toward Turkey
in a restoration of ties that had deteriorated under the rule of
ex-French leader Nicholas Sarkozy.

The decision to end eight measures – mostly military – was given by
Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoðan after his meeting with Hollande
in Brazil late June 20, Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoðlu said.

“Yesterday’s meeting [between Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoðan
and Hollande] is a new beginning,” Davutoðlu said in a televised
interview yesterday. “Sanctions will drop from the agenda thanks to
this new stance adopted by France.”

Turkey closed its airspace and territorial waters to the French
army and reduced military ties late last December in reaction to
French Parliament’s Foreign Affairs Committee’s approval of a law
criminalizing the denial of the alleged Armenian genocide. Hollande,
who had met Turkish President Abdullah Gul in Chicago during the
NATO summit, held a meeting with Erdoðan in Rio de Janeiro on the
sidelines of another international summit.

New chapter

The two leaders agreed to open “a new chapter” in relations, according
to reports. Erdoðan said there had been no official state visit
to Turkey by a French president in the last 20 years, and Hollande
replied that his future trip to Turkey would be a great privilege.

Davutoðlu said he would make an official visit to Paris on July 5.

“After these talks, this stagnation in bilateral ties will hopefully
be over.” One of the main expectations from France is the removal of
French blockage of five EU accession negotiation chapters. Diplomatic
sources are optimistic that Paris will lift its blockage as the French
Socialist Party is not against Turkish accession to the EU. The
normalization of ties between Turkey and France will also help the
two countries’ cooperation in the international scene, particularly
with the crisis in Syria. Davutoðlu said he would participate in the
Friends of the Syrian People group meeting to be held in Paris July 6.

Coming from Mexico, where Erdoðan held important meetings with the
U.S. and Russian presidents, Davutoðlu said Moscow also shared the
international community’s concerns regarding Syria. “There is no
question that Russia admits that [Syrian President] Bashar al-Assad
committed grave mistakes. We share the same opinions, but we differ
on the methodology,” he said. “Moscow is against foreign intervention,
so are we.”

In response to Israeli Deputy Prime Minister Shaul Mofaz, who said
Turkey was a superpower and Israel needed to come to terms with Turkey,
Davutoðlu said it was a clear indication of the rise of Turkey as
the regional power.

ANKARA: Turkey Discontinue Armenian Genocide Sanctions On France

TURKEY DISCONTINUE ARMENIAN GENOCIDE SANCTIONS ON FRANCE

National Turk
June 21 2012

Turkey announced it will discontinue sanctions on France over bill
criminalizing denial of the events of 1915 as genocide after former
French President Sarkozy’s attempted to pass it.

Istanbul / NationalTurk – Turkish PM Recep Tayyip Erdogan and new
French President Francois Hollande agreed to turn new page after
Sarkozy-era deterioration in relations, especially after Turkey had
applied a series of sanctions on France following the French Senate’s
approval last December of a bill criminalizing the denial of so-called
Armenian genocide claims for the events of 1915.

France’s Constitutional Court- France’s top constitutional court – then
overturned the Armenian Genocide bill, preventing it from becoming law
and Sarkozy faced defeat in the French presidential elections earlier
this year. Sarkozy was replaced by Francois Hollande, despite trying
hard to gain the Armenian vote in France.

Turkish-French relations deteriorated under Hollande’s predecessor
Nicolas Sarkozy(an) was in power, who angered Turkey when he tried
his luck at the upcoming elections with a bill to criminalise denial
of the events of 1915.

Turkey to drop sanctions on France over Armenia

The move to lift the sanctions on France was based on Prime Minister
Recep Tayyip Erdogan’s orders, Turkish Foreign Minister Davutoglu
declared during an interview on Turkish Tv.

Turkey praised the positive attitude adopted by the new French
president Hollande toward relations with Ankara administration,
stating that sanctions imposed on France would no longer be applied.

Newly elected French President Francois Hollande promised to open a
“new page” in Turkey-France relations, which hit a low over French
objections to Turkey’s bid to join the EU and controversial legislation
alteration in France seeking to criminalize denying the Armenian
genocide on French soil.

Erdogan Holland Meeting in Brazil opens a new page in Turkey France
Relations

On Wednesday, Turkey’s Prime Minister Erdogan met with his French
counterpart Hollande on the sidelines of a UN meeting in Brazil,
when the two leaders agreed to turn a “new page” in Turkish French
relations.

‘ We can see that Mr. President Francois Hollande has the will to
work through issues,’ FM Davutoglu expressed, defining the future of
Hollande’s presidency in France as a new page in bilateral relations
between Turkey and France.

Turkey France Relations to be restored after Erdogan Hollande meeting

Turkey had recalled its ambassador to Paris and put an end to all
bilateral and international cooperation on political basis with France,
including projects running under the European Union. Military contracts
were also canceled and ports were closed to French Navy ships.

Tayyip Erdogan also invited Francois Hollande to make the first
official visit to Turkey by a French president for 20 years, and
received a positive response from him.

Lawsuit Filed Against Turkish Government For Exam Question On ‘trait

LAWSUIT FILED AGAINST TURKISH GOVERNMENT FOR EXAM QUESTION ON ‘TRAITOR-ARMENIANS’

NEWS.AM
June 22, 2012 | 00:04

A Turkish professor Serdar Kaya filed lawsuit against the Turkish
Ministry of Education for the question describing Armenians and Greeks
as traitors of Turkey.

The question was included in the exam test intended for the eighth
grade at Turkish schools. The professor informed Turkish Taraf
newspaper that his daughter answered such a question during her exams.

“Such question is simply a crime. My daughter answered positively on
the question about ‘traitor-Armenians’, which means, the xenophobia
has been embedded in her as well,” stressed Kaya.

As Armenian News-NEWS.am informed earlier, the exams on social sciences
on June 9 and intended for the eighth grade of the Turkish public
schools included questions describing Armenians and Greeks as traitors.

US Ex-Ambassadors To Armenia And Azerbaijan Claim Russia Interested

US EX-AMBASSADORS TO ARMENIA AND AZERBAIJAN CLAIM RUSSIA INTERESTED IN NEITHER WAR NOR PEACE IN KARABAKH

news.am
June 21, 2012 | 15:26

WASHINGTON. – The Johns Hopkins School of Advanced International
Studies in Washington held on Wednesday debates on Averting Conflict
in the Caucasus: Is Russia a partner or a Spoiler? which brought
forward great interest among diplomats and U.S. administration,
faculty and students.

Former U.S. Ambassador to Armenia John Evans and former Ambassador
to Azerbaijan Richard Kauzlarich were the rapporteurs. The debates
led to two main conclusions, including (i) the United States will
consider Russia on the South Caucasus and (ii) will not take acute
measures to irritate Moscow, Turan agency reports.

At the same time if Armenia and Azerbaijan want to escape war, they
should run dialogue, secure transparency, get nations prepared for
peace and reinforce democracy in their countries.

“Those countries which lack freedom of media and opposition, are
impossible to bring to peace due to the OSCE Minsk Group mechanisms,”
Evans said.

Both ambassadors believe that ‘tone and expressions’ should be changed
in the talks. The sides should once and for all refuse the idea of
100 percent victory. Otherwise the region will be involved in a more
devastating war.

“Moscow is interested in neither war nor peace in the Nagorno-Karabakh
issue,” the two diplomats believe.

According to Kauzlarich, Russia fears for the regional peace to put
an end to Moscow’s influence and removal from the region, hence,
Kremlin cares not for peace but an imitation of peace process.

In his turn, Evans said that Moscow is concerned about the possibility
of war, which will damage its interests. At the same time, Russia
considers necessary to continue talks and bring closer Armenian-Turkish
ties. Besides, weakening Moscow’s ambitions may influence positively
on achieving peace. Anyway, peace will be problematic to achieve
unless societies inside are not free.

Serzh Sargsyan Convenes Consultation On Judicial System

SERZH SARGSYAN CONVENES CONSULTATION ON JUDICIAL SYSTEM

ARMENPRESS
21 June, 2012
YEREVAN

YEREVAN, JUNE 21, ARMENPRESS: President of Armenia Serzh Sargsyan
convened today a consultation on issues and reforms of the
judicial system. Chairman of the Constitutional Court of Armenia
Gagik Harutyunyan, Prosecutor General of Armenia Aghvan Hovsepyan,
Director of the National Security Service Gorik Hakobyan, Chief of
Police Vladimir Gasparyan, Chief Judge of Armenia’s Court of Appeals
Arman Mkrtumyan, Justice Minister of Armenia Hrayr Tovmasyan, Military
Prosecutor Gevorg Kostanyan, Chairman of the Criminal Chamber of the
Cassation Court Davit Avetisyan and Armenian Chamber of Advocates
Chairman Ruben Sahakyan participated in the consultation, president’s
press service told Armenpress. The President of Armenia said that as
previously, the reforms process of the judicial system will be in the
focus of his attention, and he personally will participate in all
stages of its implementation. Serzh Sargsyan stressed that all the
participants of the consultation and the employees of the systems
they head should realize that the reform is not only the matter of
the judicial system, but an issue of making the works of all state
structures in compliance with up-to-date requirements. In the scope
of the agenda issues the participants of the consultation presented
their viewpoints, considerations and proposals on the draft programme
of judicial reforms. After making relevant amendments and changes
in the programme on the basis of these proposals and considerations,
Judicial Reforms Programme for 2012-2016 will be confirmed with the
decree of the president. Among the main goals of Serzh Sargsyan’s
programme, the issue of ensuring the full independence of the judicial
power was stressed. Wrapping up the consultation, Serzh Sargsyan gave
relevant assignments on a number of issues.

Turkey To Drop Sanctions On France Over Armenia

TURKEY TO DROP SANCTIONS ON FRANCE OVER ARMENIA
by Naharnet Newsdesk

Naharnet

June 21 2012
Lebanon

Turkey on Thursday praised the positive attitude adopted by the new
French president toward relations with Ankara, saying that sanctions
imposed on Paris would no longer be implemented.

“Sanctions will drop from the agenda thanks to this new stance
adopted by France,” Turkish Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoglu said in a
televised interview, adding that he would be visiting Paris next month.

New French President Francois Hollande promised to open a “new page”
in relations, which hit a low over French objections to Turkey’s bid
to join the European Union and controversial legislation in France
seeking to make it a crime to deny the Armenian genocide.

Turkish-French relations deteriorated under Hollande’s predecessor
Nicolas Sarkozy, who angered Ankara when he pushed ahead with a bill
to criminalize denial of the Armenian genocide in 1915.

After the contentious bill passed in the National Assembly in December
Turkey retaliated by suspending military and political cooperation
with Paris.

But France’s top constitutional court struck down the bill in February,
saying it violated freedom of expression, in a ruling welcomed by
Ankara. Sarkozy vowed to launch new legislation but was defeated at
the polls first.

Armenians say up to 1.5 million of their forebears were killed in
a 1915-16 genocide by Turkey’s former Ottoman Empire. Turkey says
500,000 died and ascribes the toll to fighting and starvation during
World War I.

During the interview, Davutoglu said he soon would pay an official
visit to Paris for talks with French officials.

“After the talks on July 5, this stagnation in bilateral ties will
hopefully be over,” he added.

A Turkish foreign ministry diplomat told Agence France Presse that
whether sanctions against France would be dropped would depend on
the upcoming meeting.

Davutoglu will stay an extra day in Paris where he will participate
in the third “Friends of Syria” meeting on July 6, noted the diplomat
speaking on condition of anonymity.

Turkey and France have the strength to overcome problems in their
bilateral relationship, said Davutoglu.

“We have a clear attitude. The Turkish republic respects all nations
if it is respected by all,” he said. “But if it is disrespected,
it takes necessary steps in return to protect its nation’s honor and
national interests.”

On Wednesday, Turkey’s Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan met with
Hollande on the sidelines of a U.N. meeting in Brazil, when the two
leaders agreed to turn a “new page” in relations, the Anatolia news
agency reported.

Erdogan also invited Hollande to make the first official visit to
Turkey by a French president for 20 years, and received a positive
response, Anatolia said.

http://www.naharnet.com/stories/en/44192-turkey-to-drop-sanctions-on-france-over-armenia

Bribe-Formed Parliament, Government Have Nothing To Do With Dignity

BRIBE-FORMED PARLIAMENT, GOVERNMENT HAVE NOTHING TO DO WITH DIGNITY – OPPOSITION REP

tert.am
21.06.12

Dignity can neither be bought nor sold, and the parliament formed
due to election bribes, as well as the government formed by this
parliament, has nothing in common with dignity, Armen Martirosyan,
a Heritage party member, told journalists on Thursday.

He is highly critical of the government program for 2012-2017.

To substantiate his statement, Martirosyan quoted “one beautiful
phrase” from the government program: “the government program is
based on the idea that it is the government’s duty to create the
best conditions for a life of dignity and creative activities for
its citizens.”

The government attaches importance to the development of Armenia’s
mining industry and, on the other hand, of tourism. “But it is
impossible to develop the mining industry and tourism at the same
time. Tourists want to spend their holidays in a clean environment,
they do not come to breathe in the air full of heavy metals,”
Martirosyan said.

He believes that this government is unable to implement institutional
reforms. Also, the government must promise to create hundreds of
thousands of jobs, not only 100,000, because they must consider
emigration.

Road construction is at the bottom of the “agricultural section” of
the government program. However, poor roads are one of the factors
conducive to emigration from Armenia’s rural areas.

The ruling authorities’ “cynicism” is in that the ruling Republican
Party of Armenia (RPA) is always “well aware” of any problems raised
by the opposition.

Martirosyan will be happy if his forecasts about the government program
prove false. However, the past five years have shown he has been right.

National Assembly Of Armenia Approved The Program Of Government

NATIONAL ASSEMBLY OF ARMENIA APPROVED THE PROGRAM OF GOVERNMENT

ARMENPRESS
21 June, 2012
YEREVAN

YEREVAN, JUNE 21, ARMENPRESS: National Assembly of Armenia approved
the Government’s program for 2012-2017. Armenpress reports that with
75 for, 47 against and 1 abstain votes the National Assembly confirmed
the program. ANC, ARF, “Heritage” and “PAP” voted against the program.

Republican Party of Armenia and Rule of Law Party which are a part
of Armenian coalition Government will vote for the program of the
Government. On behalf of RPA with a speech performed the leader of
the parliamentary group of the party Galust Sahakyan. He highlighted
that during the two-day discussions in the Parliament the opposition
did not present any healthy criticism. “That criticism was rather
law-grade” mentioned Sahakyan. He also added that the real criticism
was included in the speech of the Prime Minister. He said that
opposition was against Prime Minister and the Government but not
against the program. On Behalf of Rule of Law party’s parliamentary
group with a speech performed Heghine Bisharyan who stressed that the
development of the society and country will depend on the productive
implementation of the program. “The provisions of our party’s electoral
campaign are also included in the program” stressed Bisharyan. Rule of
Law stresses the importance of returning the deposits in former USSR
banks. One of the priorities is the development of agriculture which
can be favorable for preventing the emigration” summarized Heghine
Bisharyan adding that based on abovementioned Rule of Law Party will
vote for the program.

It Is Possible To Reach Progress In Nagorno-Karabakh Conflict Only I

IT IS POSSIBLE TO REACH PROGRESS IN NAGORNO-KARABAKH CONFLICT ONLY IN CASE OF NKR FULLY PARTICIPATION IN NEGOTIATIONS: NKR MFA

ARMENPRESS
21 June, 2012
YEREVAN

YEREVAN, JUNE 21, ARMENPRESS: The Foreign affairs ministry of
Nagorno-Karabakh Republic expresses its support to the joint statement
of Russia, France and USA issued in Los Cabos on Azerbaijani-Karabakh
conflict. Armenpress was informed from NKR Foreign affairs ministry
that in the statement is mentioned:

“The Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Nagorno Karabakh Republic
supports the joint statement of the Presidents of Russia, the USA,
and France on the Azerbaijani-Karabakh conflict issued in Los Cabos. We
always had a positive attitude to such initiatives aimed at a peaceful
solution to the issue, taking into account all the principles of
international law, and reaffirm our readiness to follow the appeals and
recommendations of the leaders of the OSCE Minsk Group co-chairing
states. At the same time, we have to state that the Azerbaijani
party continues to interpret the statement of the mediators in a way
favorable for itself and to set pre-conditions, thus torpedoing these
initiatives. Azerbaijan continues to boycott the implementation of
key confidence-building measures in the region, such as elaboration
of corresponding mechanisms for investigating the incidents at the
borderline, withdrawal of snipers from the contact-line, and others.

Unfortunately, official Baku hasn’t refused yet of the initially
assumed force method of solving the conflict. Azerbaijan, representing
a non-permanent member of the UN Security Council, the responsibilities
of which include fighting for the security in the region, refuses of
civilized ways of solving the issue.

The Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Nagorno Karabakh Republic
expresses hope that this time the authorities of Azerbaijan
will display constructivism and abandon their futile policy of
military-force blackmail and sabotage threatening the fragile regional
security and stability. We believe that only through a political
dialogue, with the equal participation of the Nagorno Karabakh
party, it is possible to achieve progress in the negotiations on the
Azerbaijani-Karabakh conflict settlement and to establish lasting
peace in the region”.

Georgia Scales Up Helicopter Force

GEORGIA SCALES UP HELICOPTER FORCE
By Yurii RAIKHEL

No.38, Thursday, 21 2012

During the visit of Hillary Clinton US Secretary of State to Georgia
among other important issues there were discussed possibilities of
military and technical cooperation. After Russia’s aggression in 2008
it has become the main component of national security for Tbilisi. We
should not forget that the Russian military group is only a short
distance away from the Georgian capital.

There is also an international dimension to it. It is known
that tension has significantly increased on the contact line of
Nagorno-Karabakh. Explosions and gunshots can be heard there and
actions of Special Forces units have been reported in the region. Many
experts and observers do not rule out a transition of the conflict into
its hot phase. In this situation Armenia, which has been Russia’s ally,
is in geographical isolation. Moscow is somewhat limited in providing
possible assistance to this country because it has no common border
with Yerevan. That is why a number of military experts in Moscow
started talking about the possible breakthrough of Russian troops
through the territory of Georgia. In any case, this can be expected
through Georgian airspace.

That is why at the meeting of the bilateral working group, which
was held in Batumi within the framework of the Charter on Strategic
Partnership signed in January 2009, Georgia and the United States
represented by the Secretary of State Hillary Clinton there were
discussed possible variants of assisting Georgia in developing its
surveillance of air, air defense, as well as surveillance in the
shoreline zone. While this process will take on from analysis and
evaluation to implementation in the following months the United States
will consider the request made by Georgia for purchasing materials
of defensive nature in addition to the training and assistance that
has been already provided. This was reported in the document of the
US Foreign Affairs Agency.

The document also mentions US willingness to assist in the
modernization of the Georgian utility helicopters. Clinton said:
“We will improve multipurpose helicopters of Georgia, so that they
could transport goods and people across the country easier. We also
intend to help Georgia to ensure training of officers, which is
necessary in today’s changing environment.”

The reports on the US possible assistance to Georgia coincided in time
with the news that after withdrawal of American and NATO troops from
Afghanistan in 2014 all the military equipment will be granted at no
cost to Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, and Uzbekistan. According to sources
close to the military departments of the Central Asian republics these
will be armored vehicles, as well as trailers for transporting tanks,
trucks, tankers, specialized graders, bulldozers, and water carriers.

Besides, the Pentagon is ready to give medical equipment, communication
and fire fighting equipment, and even portable gyms and other devices
for military life to Afghanistan’s neighbors. It also became known
that the US plans to deploy military equipment that was used in
Afghanistan in Central Asia.

This act of charity is absolutely justified from a technical and
economic point of view. Equipment has deteriorated greatly, is
partially or completely worn out and it makes no sense to transport
it for thousand miles, especially now, when US will soon put into
service new models of military equipment.

But there is also another aspect. The equipment received at no cost
will have to be repaired, maintained, and possibly upgraded. And
it can only be done by American companies that supply weapons
for their army. In any case, the US position in Central Asia will
be strengthened. Besides, it will shake Russia’s monopoly for the
supply of arms to countries in Central Asia, which is important both
from military and political perspective. Especially since this has
already happened in the South Caucasus. Georgia and Azerbaijan have
adopted Western standards in arms, although the latter still purchases
Russian military equipment in some quantities, but these supplies
do not determine the general state of country’s arsenal. The only
customer for Russian weapons in significant quantities in the region
is Armenia. It purchases weapons on favorable terms or even for free.

It is interesting that Moscow strongly opposes the transfer of weapons
used by American and NATO army to countries in Central Asia. Somehow
it has a right to perform such charity acts towards Armenia but would
not let anyone else do the same. Even though some of the countries
in the regions are the members of the CSTO and have the right, just
like Armenia, to get the same attitude. Perhaps Moscow doesn’t think
like that and it ranks its allies according to some vague criteria.

The big neighbor of Ukraine also did not leave without attention
the fact that Georgian military helicopters that were repaired in
Ukraine have been sent to Tbilisi. Georgian Ambassador to Ukraine
Grigol Katamadze reported that all the issues related to financing
the repair works have been resolved. Ambassador said: “We continue
our cooperation in military and technical spheres.”

Gela Bezhuashvili, Georgian Defense Minister said that the helicopters
were sent for repair to Ukraine back in 1999. According to him, two
ASW helicopters Mi-14 and three helicopters Mi-24 have been repaired so
far. Repair of two Georgian helicopters Mi-2 has not been finished yet.

In this regard, one can say firmly that, despite the continuing
successful military and technical cooperation between Ukraine and
Azerbaijan, Ukraine has not been realizing its potential in arms
sales and providing technical service to full capacity.

In this situation we can speak about the fact that Ukraine has
not yet been able to overcome the complex of a “younger brother”
in relation to the neighboring country. Recently we began hearing
more about the restoration of cooperation ties of times of the Soviet
military-industrial complex. On the other hand, clearly there is fear
of making neighbors angry in any way. But it doesn’t make much sense.

They do not hesitate to compete with their Ukrainian rivals on the
weapons market. They are in no way limited by discussion of the
brotherhood, common past, and frustrated cooperation. Instead they
try to find ways to replace the import of weapons and accessories
from Ukraine, but, to their regret, it never just works out the way
they want.

And the last thing. In the not so clear economic and financial
situation in the world the military and technical cooperation and
arms sales could be of significant importance for Ukraine’s economy.

Government need to be guided by this. Moreover, because even in the
CIS arms market we can still make some good money. The examples of
Georgia and Azerbaijan are a good proof of that.

http://www.day.kiev.ua/230297