International Community Party To Nagorno-Karabakh Conflict, Armenian

INTERNATIONAL COMMUNITY PARTY TO NAGORNO-KARABAKH CONFLICT, ARMENIAN MP SAYS

new.am
Feb 22 2011
Armenia

The West is taking consistent steps to break the Armenian side`s
political will and force it into lowering the level of its demands with
respect to the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict, Stepan Safaryan, Chairman
of the Heritage Parliamentary faction, told Armenian News-NEWS.am
as he commented on statements by a number of Western officials,
particularly by U.S. Ambassador to Azerbaijan Matthew Bryza, who said
that official Washington supports Azerbaijan`s territorial integrity,
as well as by Ian Brzezinski, who said that Azerbaijan`s increasing
military budget is fraught with short- and long-term instability.

“In the context of other global tendencies, the statements are aimed
at intimidating the Armenian side into concessions,” Safaryan said. He
pointed out that Armenia has a number of ways of resisting the pressure
at its disposal.

“First, it was a major blunder by Armenian diplomacy to allow the West
to openly support either of the conflicting parties. Under all the
three presidents Armenia failed to prevent it,” Safaryan said. He
stressed that Armenia should have recognized Nagorno-Karabakh to
prevent such developments. “No matter how many times the Armenian
President or Foreign Minister or any other officials state that it
is Azerbaijan that has caused the negotiations to reach s stalemate,
their statements will never produce any effect. Both in the domestic
and international arenas, Azerbaijan, by means of various statements
and resolutions, has stated that it `has done with` such issues as
its territorial integrity and Nagorno-Karabakh`s status. Armenia too,
by recognizing Nagorno-Karabakh, should have clearly shown the issue
of Nagorno-Karabakh`s status had been settled for it,” Safaryan said.

That would have put an end to the abnormal situation created by
Azerbaijan, he said. The problem is impossible to resolve without
Nagorno-Karabakh`s participation.

As regards the possibility of new hostilities, Safaryan said: “Besides
Azerbaijan, it is the international community that will be responsible
for resumed hostilities, human casualties and devastation. It is
time to recognize the international community too is an equal party
to the conflict, which assumed certain commitments. It must be viewed
as a fact, just as the fact that Sheik-President Ilham Iliyev must be
committed to international tribunal and punished with all the rigors
of the law should he once more attempt to annihilate a whole people,”
Safaryan said.

From: A. Papazian

Armenian Performance Series Makes It Way To Watertown

ARMENIAN PERFORMANCE SERIES MAKES IT WAY TO WATERTOWN

Watertown TAB & Press
Feb 22 2011
MA

WATERTOWN – The Eastern USA Region of the Hamazkayin Armenian
Educational and Cultural Society in collaboration with its chapters
will present a performance series to celebrate the 20th anniversary
of independence of the Republic of Armenia in Boston (hosted by
Boston and Providence chapters), Englewood, NJ (hosted by the NJ/NY
and Philadelphia chapters), and Washington DC (hosted by Greater
Washington DC chapter).

This performance series, held under the auspices of His Excellency,
Tatoul Markarian, the Ambassador of the Republic of Armenia to the
United States, will feature the Element Bandfrom California along
with welcoming performances by local groups.

The children from the St. Stephen’s Armenian Elementary Schoolin
Watertown will welcome the guests in Boston, and in New Jersey,
the Akhtamar Dance Ensemble of Saint Thomas Armenian Church, the
Yeraz Dance Ensemble of Saint Sarkis Armenian Church and the Arekag
Children’s Chorus of Hamazkayin (NJ) will perform for the occasion.

Element Band’s greatest aspiration has been to apply new styles
and innovation to musical traditions. Under the direction of Ara
Dabandjian, the band’s music has met that challenge, in the process
immediately gaining a unique identity. The bold arrangements partner
rock melodies, traditional American, French, Spanish, Bulgarian,
Italian, Portuguese, Greek, and Armenian renditions, as well as the
warm sounds of the Mediterranean; fiery and passionate notes waft
in and out of the music with pulsing cadences, infusing listeners
with an upbeat energy unique to Element Band. Today, Element Band
has evolved into an unprecedented experience

For more information about the event and/or the band, please visit
or

From: A. Papazian

http://east.hamazkayin-usa.org
http://www.elementband.com.

Envisioning The First Foundation Stone Of The New Republic Of Southe

ENVISIONING THE FIRST FOUNDATION STONE OF THE NEW REPUBLIC OF SOUTHERN SUDAN
Written by Joseph Deng Garang, The New Sudan Vision (NSV),

New Sudan Vision

Feb 22 2011

(OMAHA, Nebraska) – IT IS without a doubt the people of Southern Sudan
will go through periods of healing after half a century of civil wars,
the most decimating being the second war, which cost over 2 million
lives. The journey to consolidate and translate the triumph of peace
has just begun. And although the region is on a short wait to formally
declare independence on July 9, 2011, the people have already witnessed
a historic moment of the birth of Africa’s newest nation.

It is a moment that became magnified when the final results of the
January 9-15 referendum were announced and made permanent on Monday,
February 7, 2011. And, never in the shortest course of my human
journey, have I seen so many people jolt into prestige as a result of
the recent participation at the ballot box. I did not know the kind
of respect that a single vote could command until I cast it last month.

But in order not to be blindsided by the giddiness of the moment,
I would like to turn a laser focus on the work that lies ahead of us
by looking at the following recurring themes as we begin to lay that
first foundation stone of the new republic.

A watershed moment for Africa and the world

Evidently, the world is waiting for July and for sovereign borders to
be drawn before the new republic joins the community of nations. But
the referendum vote has already bestowed international recognition
upon South Sudan. The successful outcome of a January plebiscite is
the subject of secession overtures by scholars across much of Africa.

And of course it bears mentioning that many people are scrambling for
clues as to what Africa and the world can teach the new republic of
Southern and vice versa

When asked about the impact of the French Revolution of 1789, former
Chinese premier Zhou Enlai famously said: “It is too early to say.”

This was in 1972, 183 years after the said revolution took place. But
time has a different way of capturing moments of eloquence
for different generations. In 2005, the man who brought us the
Comprehensive Peace Agreement best articulated that Sudan was not
going to be the same. Six years later, the sweeping wave of human
dignity echoed by the January 9 the self-determination vote is indeed
one for the rivers of history.

For some time to come, the world will learn many great things about
the liberation movement that waged a relentless revolution in Sudan.

For now, the 2005 peace blue print on power sharing and the fact
that the war went on for over 50 years really stands out and the
liberation struggle waged by the marginalized people of Sudan will
be the talk and study of the century by realists and idealists, both
in the global north and global south. The Sudan Peoples’ Liberation
Movement will not only be credited by history for its articulation of
the liberation for the marginalized masses but also for being one of
few if not the only guerrilla movement in the course of human history
that allowed back into its rank leaders and members who turned on
their own civilians after they had joined the enemy.

As student of geopolitics of the Central Eurasia, I was also
pleased to see the sacrosanct self-determination vote in Southern
Sudan being cited as precedent by the top leadership in Armenia
and Nagorno-Karabakh republic. They were the first to congratulate
Southern Sudan when the preliminary results were announced in January
and they are planning to bring up the case of self-determination for
Nagorno-Karabakh, which was botched back in 1991 when it failed to
win the recognition of the international community. The region had
been a source of dispute between Armenia and Azerbaijan.

As I wrote in my last column, a new chapter is unfolding for us in
Southern Sudan but it is not chapter 11. It is a chapter where we
will have clashes of priorities as we try to build and provide for
everyone. But it is one full of belief that children and women will
have to come first. We will face many competing priorities when it
comes to our approach to development. But I also get the sense that
the one thing that our leadership will have in large supply is advice.

They are poised to receive a torrent of free advice from Southerners
and foreigners on how to build the new nation.

By way of extrapolation, much has been said about the key lessons
Southern Sudan must learn from African countries that have been
plagued by pitfalls since independence. The list of things to avoid
has ranged from anemic institutions to corruption to lack of solid
policy projects on social, economic and political development. But
there is one pressing observation I can also add: free expression,
which is the least understood aspect of liberation in Africa. More
on the need for free expression next.

For those Southern Sudanese who love reading and are interested
in reading up about political, and socio-economic development or
philosophies of any given nation, I highly recommend three books
for you: The Wealth of Nations by Adam Smith; Democracy in America
by Alexis de Tocqueville; and the most recent and my favorite book
Start-Up Nation: The Story of Israel’s Economic Miracle co-authored
by Dan Senor and Saul Singer. Building partnerships and a network of
global solidarity will be critical at every turn for us in Southern
Sudan. It will dictate how the new nation begins to build an educated
workforce that will in turn create a 21st- century economy.

Strategic communications as an effective tool of governance

Free expression has struck me as the least understood aspect of
liberation.Take for example the many countries in Africa, where
majority of citizens cannot speak freely either for fear of reprisal
or because they are not well informed on how to exercise. Too often
those who speak out vocally either risk their own lives or get
exiled for life. What is more, the military sometimes meddles in the
politics of several states in Africa. And if history is any guide,
the lesson we can quickly take away is that in nations where citizens
are never fully vested or not involved at the outset, people have
become disillusioned when expectations are not managed well.

As ethnically diverse as Southern Sudan is, it is true we have not
learned how to openly and honestly describe ourselves as a people
given how busy we were dealing with the north. Let’s face it, this
is the one area that remains worrisome and we will have to think hard.

The only thing that kept us united during the war was the rallying
cry of marginalization. Now that we are free, we have the daunting
task of defining who we are. It is true much of the post-referendum
challenge will fall to our leadership who will have to shoulder the
heavy duty of strategic communications—making sure the message,
all channels of communicating and the audience are in line.

In Southern Sudan, there are xenophobic talks that relate to different
groups. And Southern Sudan, sincerely, of all places, given its epic
struggle for freedom, where people are still hungry for change, must
not be a place where people are advised to talk cautiously because
of fear. So for us who are about to build a new nation, this must
give us pause and ask ourselves the question: what role will free
expression play in rebuilding Southern Sudan?

After decades in which we were virtually allowed no role to play in
determining the course or direction of the country, times during which
our voices were categorically marginalized in the decision-making
process, I believe the best and precious gift this new independence
must give every Southerner is the ability, the right and responsibility
to speak his or her mind freely, because doing otherwise will serve
to bring back the vestiges of a system we have fought to replace.

The citizens must be allowed to speak without fear provided what
they speak is reasonable and devoid of treasonous acts. Of course no
society or nation can let the right to speak go astray into the realm
of speaking without any basis in facts, which is why it is going to
demand each person’s responsibility to stay well informed. Speaking
freely does not mean dealing in wholesale rumor mongering. Ditto
for irrelevant schools of thought supported by outdated world views
or prophecies.

Maybe if we are not too fearful, the conversation can be made easy
given the way information technology has revolutionized the way
societies do things. Our new government can partner with all sorts
of media on matters of positive cultural programming as well as
disseminating key policy information to our society.

Free expression can accomplish for us a few things. For example, we
can learn to hold ourselves accountable and demand that of our leaders
regardless of whether or not we are related, because protecting members
of one’s tribe either through condoning of their scandals or by failing
to correct or point out their leadership weaknesses just because of the
relationship or loyalty is tantamount to promoting gross incompetency.

In matters of self-governance, Southern Sudanese can find an agreement
that improper defense of leaders has nothing to do with true patriotism
and everything to do with blind patriotism. It cannot serve our new
nation well. Leaders, too, must learn to resist temptation that seeks
unquestioning obedience from their subjects because that, too, will
not do us any good. If anything, leaders must not lead by fear but
rather through moral example.

The terap phenomenon

Terap is the word our leaders drilled into us when we were little. It
is an arabic word for seed, used a lot during the struggle to refer
to children as future of the liberation movement. The bulk of nation
building agenda will require that we all commit by developing a sense
of national consciousness—a shared responsibility to forge a national
character—the collective embrace and a true sense of citizenship,
where all the young people will be called upon to play their part. The
youth will build bridges of understanding for the postwar society.

Before we tap into our vast natural resources,and indulge the talk of
all the grand buildings or wealth, our leadership must enshrine basic
rights for everyone and develop a capacity to communicate all the core
values to the post war society: ensuring there is fairness in public
sector and that climbing all the social and economic ladders is done
through meritocracy. It is the cheapest policy project I can think of.

It costs nothing. It just requires leadership and a change of
attitudes. It is one that can serve us well for generations.

As I previewed on Martyrs’ Day last year in an article published by The
New Sudan Vision, Southern Sudan needs a 21-for-21 national project,
where we will commit to another 21 years of hard work, the same number
of years it took to bring about liberation. It is the only way we will
make the fallen heroes proud. It is the simplest, most meaningful
and lasting honor we all can give our late leader John Garang and
all the martyrs who will always guide and lead us from their graves.

For his upcoming major speech in July, President Salva Kiir should
talk to us and the world, in declarative terms, by calling for the
rule of law, one that is anchored by a national constitution and an
independent branch of Southern Sudan judiciary, where every person
shall be treated equally under the law. His recent promise to take
up the gauntlet with those who threaten misuse of public resources
is a welcome break.

So to all those who would like to start making careers of these great
causes on behalf of educating our new nation, the time is ripe to
get to work. Let’s make sure the dream of an independence is fully
expressed—let’s envision the day when Southern Sudan will become the
most welcoming place to live—a society that accommodates the views
of minority—where all citizens are encouraged to be assertive and
able to question their business and political leaders without fear
whatsoever. And when that day arrives, we all will proudly say in
unison: ode to all the imaginings and the triumph of peace.

Joseph Deng Garang is the President of The New Sudan Vision

From: A. Papazian

http://www.newsudanvision.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=2327:envisioning-the-first-foundation-stone-of-the-new-republic-of-southern-sudan&catid=5:columns&Itemid=14
www.newsudanvision.com

BAKU: ‘World Community Concerned Over Running Karabakh Conflict To F

‘WORLD COMMUNITY CONCERNED OVER RUNNING KARABAKH CONFLICT TO FORCED SETTLEMENT’

news.az
Feb 22 2011
Azerbaijan

Optimistic statements of US new ambassador in Azerbaijan show that
the world community is concerned over running conflict to the forced
settlement.

The next trilateral meeting of the presidents of Azerbaijan, Russia and
Armenia in Sochi will be held on 5 March, US ambassador in Azerbaijan
Matthew Bryza told journalists recently.

Milli Majlis deputy, political scientist Rasim Musabeyov commented on
the importance of the meetings of the three presidents amid growing
tensions on the Karabakh front.

“Until recently most experts believed that there is no meaning to
continue presidential meetings under the Russian mediation, since no
effect was achieved from such a format of negotiations in the past
two years.

There is an impression that further attempts to continue peace talks
become senseless due to the position of the Armenian side, which
ignores the new proposals of the OSCE Minsk Group”, Musabeyov said.

“However, the recent new phase of activeness of the Minsk Group
co-chairs, their arrival to the region, optimistic statements of US new
ambassador in Azerbaijan Matthew Bryza show that the world community
is concerned over running the conflict to the forced settlement.

I think if the parties have agreed to one more meeting in Sochi, it
means there is a subject for discussion and there is a need to hear
opposite opinion. However, a greater part of the expert community is
growing pessimistic about the recent effectiveness of the activity
of the OSCE Minsk Group and Russian initiatives on holding trilateral
meetings on a higher level”, the MM deputy said.

It should be noted that Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev told in an
exclusive interview with Russian Mir television and radio company:
“If we are asked to agree on independence of Nagorno Karabakh, the
negotiations will have no prospects”.

“According to Rasim Musabeyov, this message has already been voiced
by the president of Azerbaijan to explain that Azerbaijan’s position
is changeless. The Armenian side also voice statements of the opposite
nature.

However, if the presidents meet in Sochi, there are conditions
to continue talks on peace settlement of the Karabakh conflict”,
Musabeyov concluded.

From: A. Papazian

Armenia Abolishes Visa Regime With Argentina

ARMENIA ABOLISHES VISA REGIME WITH ARGENTINA

news.am
Feb 22 2011
Armenia

Armenian Ministry of Foreign Affairs presented a project to the
Government, under which the visa regime between Armenia and Argentina
is canceled. According to it, nationals of Armenia and Argentina may
visit two countries without a visa.

The Armenian Government will discuss the issue at the Feb. 24 session.

Argentina will become the first country besides CIS states, Armenia
abolishes a visa regime with.

This will serve an example for other countries in the region,
particularly Brazil, Chile and Uruguay. It is noteworthy these
countries have large Armenian communities.

The regime does not contain a serious risk of migration, since
Armenia and Argentina are far enough geographically from each other,
the ministry said in a statement.

From: A. Papazian

Armenian Judoists Win 3 Gold, 2 Silver And 4 Bronze Medals In Tehran

ARMENIAN JUDOISTS WIN 3 GOLD, 2 SILVER AND 4 BRONZE MEDALS IN TEHRAN

news.am
Feb 22 2011
Armenia

Armenian judo national team won 3 gold, 2 silver and 4 bronze medals
in the judo youth championship in Tehran.

Garik Harutyunyan (55 kg, Vanadzor), Gor Harutyunyan (60 kg, Vanadzor)
and David Ghazaryan (66 kg, Vanadzor) won gold medals.

Artyusha Aydinyan (55 kg, Yerevan), Arsen Tovmasyan (60 kg, Yerevan),
Vaspurak Lazarian (66 kg, Hrazdan) and Hovhannes Serobyan (73 kg,
Armavir) won bronze medals, the Armenian Judo federation informed
Armenian News-NEWS.am.

From: A. Papazian

Armenian Army Most Battle Worthy In South Caucasus – Expert

ARMENIAN ARMY MOST BATTLE WORTHY IN SOUTH CAUCASUS – EXPERT

Aysor.am
Tuesday,February 22

Discipline is the most important issue in the army; we should condemn
suicide and killing cases, meanwhile we should appreciate all reforms
already implemented and still proceeding in the army, ACNIS Director,
political analyst Richard Giragosian noted addressing a discussion
on human rights in the Armenian army on February 22 in Yerevan.

According to him, Armenian citizens trust the army and Defense
Ministry for the latters to protect soldiers and correctly implement
their duties.

“Currently the Armenian army is the most battle worthy in the South
Caucasus,” Giragosian stressed.

The expert highly assessed the reforms implemented by Defense Minister
Seyran Ohanyan, particularly, the hotline enabling servicemen to
regularly keep in touch with their families.

“We must not tolerate violation of disciplinary rules,” Giragosian said
attaching importance to creation of a Disciplinary Code for the army.

From: A. Papazian

Discussion On Human Rights In Armenian Army Start

DISCUSSION ON HUMAN RIGHTS IN ARMENIAN ARMY START

Aysor.am
Tuesday,February 22

Roundtable discussion on human rights in the Armenian army has been
launched in Yerevan.

The roundtable aims to continue Armenian society~Rs discussions on
human rights in the army, focusing on the role of democratic control
and international commitments, as well as alternative service problems.

The event is attended by Head of OSCE Office in Yerevan, Ambassador
Sergey Kapinos, Armenian Deputy Defense Minister Ara Nazaryan and
Deputy Director for Programs of the Open Society Foundations ~VArmenia
David Amiryan.

From: A. Papazian

Haig Merian, 92; WWII POW Preserved Armenian Culture

HAIG MERIAN, 92; WWII POW PRESERVED ARMENIAN CULTURE
By Gil Bliss

Boston Globe

Feb 22 2011
MA

Many immigrant groups in the United States strive mightily to
preserve their cultural heritage, but few do so as fervently as
Armenian-Americans who escaped the attempted annihilation of their
people.

Haig Merian ~W a POW during World War II who became displaced,
wandered through Europe, and ended up in the Boston area with a new
wife and a new life ~W embodied the Armenian story.

Mr. Merian was a champion of Armenian culture through his church
and also organized dancing and singing groups that kept the old
ways alive. The Newton Highlands resident died Feb. 1 at his home,
following a period of declining health. He was 92.

His story was similar to many postwar accounts. Homeless and devoid
of family, he made it to Ellis Island in New York to begin life anew.

He reflected the strong desire of Armenian-Americans to keep alive
a culture that has survived numerous attempts to bring about its
extinction.

~SArmenia has always been at the crossroads of different cultures
and different empires, whether it be the Hittites, Greeks, Romans,
Persians, or Arabs,~R~R said Father Antranig Baljian, pastor of St.

Stephen~Rs Armenian Apostolic Church in Watertown. ~SIt is located in
a very desirable area, and many invading hordes have come and gone.~R~R

The Turkish Ottoman Empire made several attempts to wipe out the
native population, most famously through a period of genocide from
1915 until about 1922, Baljian said.

~SMany people were forced to flee that area,~R~R settling outside
their homeland, including in the United States; and Watertown became
a Boston-area destination for many, Baljian said.

Mr. Merian was born in Tzovinar, Armenia, attended the University of
Yerevan, and taught elementary school until he was drafted by the
Soviet Army. He served as a captain during World War II and spent
three years in a German POW camp before being liberated.

While in that army, he exercised his interest in music and dance,
performing with the Red Army Red-Bannered Song and Dance Ensemble of
the USSR.

After wandering France and Belgium, suffering from starvation and
typhoid fever, Mr. Merian was taken in by an Armenian family in
Belgium. He learned the rudiments of rug weaving there and pursued
the trade after he entered the United States in 1946.

According to Armenia historian Roger Hagopian of Lexington, Soviet
soldiers had to sign a statement promising to commit suicide if
captured and Mr. Merian lived in fear of Soviet authorities learning
he was alive and persecuting family members who were still in Armenia.

As a result, Mr. Merian never contacted his family until the country
achieved independence from the Soviet Union. He returned with his wife
in 1992 to find that all his family had died, except two sisters. When
he died earlier this month, Mr. Merian was the last of nine siblings

~SHe always feared the Soviets were looking for him and in the
beginning, he didn~Rt feel safe until he left New York City and came
to Boston, then Watertown,~R~R Hagopian said.

Both Mr. Merian~Rs and Hagopian~Rs families came from Van, a city that
was legendary among Armenians for its stiff resistance to takeover.

~SHaig was thankful for his life and opportunity to live here,~R~R
said Hagopian, who has created documentary films about the Armenian
experience in America. ~SThese people really know what freedom
means.~R~R

Mr. Merian was described as a pillar of the local Armenian community.

He was a founder of the Watertown church and cofounded a popular
singing and dancing troupe that appeared at the New York World~Rs
Fair in the 1960s.

~SHe had varied interests and his faith really kept him going,~R~R
said Hagopian. At the center of his life was his family.

His daughter Sonya of Framingham said her father was ~San extremely
intelligent man who gave 150 percent to his family. He was highly
disciplined and organized and that got him through all the traumas
in his early life.~R~R

~SEach holiday we would gather together, and he always carried on a
tradition of offering a toast at the meal, ~QMay we always remain as
one,~R ~R~R she recalled.

That spirit carried over into the dance troupe, said Markar Markarian
of Belmont. ~SWe wanted to help Armenian dance and music not die out
and it was in your blood; you couldn~Rt just stop and say, ~QForget
about it.~R ~R~R Even now, at 87, she said, ~Sthe music gets to me
and I get up on the dance floor.~R~R

Baljian said, ~SBecause of people like [Mr. Merian], who kept the
spirit alive, our culture has been preserved and promoted for the
following generations.~R~R

When Mr. Merian first came to the Boston area, he worked for Paine
Furniture, but soon took his knowledge of rugs and started Merian
Carpet Service, where he was a favorite of Red Sox owner Tom Yawkey
and did all the rug work for that organization.

His son, Daniel of Framingham, runs the business, sales, installation,
repair, and cleaning, but his father still helped out after retirement.

Dan said his father instilled the importance of family in his
children. ~SHe didn~Rt have his family here, so he really appreciated
and cherished the family he created in America.~R~R

His daughter Susan Bécam of Newton said he never wanted to talk
about the war, and her mother would recall Mr. Merian waking up with
nightmares for many years.

~SHe loved to sing and dance because in his native Armenia, he was
surrounded by that,~R~R she said. ~SAt our New Year~Rs dinner last
month, he again emphasized the importance of family, saying that ~Qwe
are all together and you have to take care of each other.~R ~R~R

Mr. Merian had earned a 50-year Veterans Medal from the Masons, for
whom he was master of the Norumbega Lodge for several years and a
member of the Scottish Rite. He was also a member of the Armenian
Revolutionary Federation, a group that supported an independent
Armenia.

Besides his daughters Sonya and Susan and his son, Daniel, Mr. Merian
leaves his daughter Diane of Newton; six grandchildren; and many
nieces and nephews. His wife of 60 years, the former Alice Sarafian,
died in 2008.

Services have been held.

From: A. Papazian

http://www.boston.com/bostonglobe/obituaries/articles/2011/02/22/haig_merian_92_wwii_pow_preserved_armenian_culture/

Harut Sassounian: Three Questions Turkey’s Ambassador Would Not Answ

HARUT SASSOUNIAN: THREE QUESTIONS TURKEY’S AMBASSADOR WOULD NOT ANSWER…
By Harut Sassounian

Noyan Tapan
22.02.2011 | 11:34

Articles and Analyses

Turkey’s Ambassador to the United States, Namik Tan, spoke at the
University of Southern California’s Center on Public Diplomacy on
February 16. His topic was: “Public Diplomacy: The Turkish Experience.”

The Turkish Ambassador assumed his post in Washington last February,
but shortly after his arrival was recalled to Ankara when the House
Foreign Affairs Committee adopted a resolution acknowledging the
Armenian Genocide.

Amb. Tan is no stranger to Washington, where he served as the
Embassy’s Counselor from 1991 to 1995 and First Counselor from 1997
to 2001. During his long diplomatic career, he also was Ambassador
to Israel, Second Secretary at the Turkish Embassy in Russia, and
Deputy Undersecretary at the Foreign Ministry in Ankara.

During his first visit to Los Angeles this month, the smooth-talking
Ambassador managed to meet with Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa, spoke to
the World Affairs Council, and held meetings with the American Jewish
Committee, Turkish community leaders, and the Editorial Board of the
Los Angeles Times.

Prior to his arrival, the Association of Turkish-Americans of Southern
California had posted a note on its website, urging local Turks to
attend the Ambassador’s public appearances and “show visible support…

especially in the face of usual anticipated detractors.”

Running the risk of being labeled “a detractor,” I decided to attend
the Ambassador’s talk which ironically was held at USC’s Ronald Tutor
Campus Center — named after its Armenian benefactor, the son of Al
Tutor (Varjabedian), a genocide survivor. I made my way through scores
of U.S. Secret Service agents, campus security, and Turkish bodyguards
who almost outnumbered the guests at the event. Even more surprising
was the fact that there were only a handful of Armenians and Turks
among the attendees, consisting mostly of USC students and professors.

Amb. Tan, who spoke in fluent English for half an hour, presented
his country in the best possible light.. Since he had not addressed
Armenian issues, I decided to pose the following interrelated
questions:

The Turkish government recently renovated a couple of Armenian
churches. There were thousands of Armenian churches and monasteries
throughout Turkey before the genocide, most of which were converted
into mosques, warehouses and stables, and many were destroyed. Isn’t it
time for the Turkish government to turn over these Armenian churches
to the Armenian Patriarchate of Istanbul? Also, after Armenians
were deported and killed, they left behind their houses, lands and
belongings. Isn’t time for the Turkish government to return these
properties to the heirs of their original Armenian owners?

Finally, regarding the Armenian Genocide issue, Pres. Obama declared in
his statement of last April 24: “95 years ago, 1.5 million Armenians
were massacred or marched to death in the final days of the Ottoman
Empire.” If you say that is not true, wouldn’t you be calling the
President of the United States a liar?

Here is Amb. Tan’s response:

“This hate should end. We should put it behind as early as possible.

That’s why we are trying to reach out to our Armenian friends and
we have signed the [Armenia-Turkey] Protocols. In these Protocols,
one of the suggestions that we put is that we want an independent
historical inquiry commission which will include representatives
from every country — from US, France, and whichever country you
like. They will study those claims and we will see the decision all
together. But history cannot be legislated. This is not the way that
history could be judged. So, I think this has created a lot of ill
feelings in our societies. Armenians have given a lot of contribution
to our social life historically. Therefore we need to continue such
kind of engagements, but this hate should be stopped.”

I politely reminded Amb.. Tan that he had not answered my questions.

He responded by saying: “That is my answer.” He probably was not
prepared to face such politically sensitive questions. By sidestepping
my queries, he left a negative impression on his audience, despite
his highly-skilled diplomatic credentials.

At the program’s conclusion, Amb. Tan walked over, shook my hand,
and thanked me for my questions. I told him that his assessment was
inaccurate, as the Armenian issue had nothing to do with “hatred.” I
explained that a great crime was committed by Turkey against the
Armenian nation, and that Armenians are not blinded by “hatred,” but
simply demanding “justice.” The Ambassador turned around and walked
away with a mysterious smile on his face!

Even though Amb. Tan avoided answering my questions, our public
exchange had the beneficial effect of exposing the university
audience, the Ambassador and his entourage to the just demands of
the Armenian people for the crimes committed by Turkey. Indeed, it is
also imperative to challenge Turkish officials at every opportunity,
so that neither they nor their audience would be able to ignore the
Armenian grievances.

From: A. Papazian

www.nt.am