Asbarez: A Fundamental Shift in Armenia–Diaspora Relations (Part 3)

Diverging Visions, Shared National Responsibilities

Garo Madenlian

BY GARO R. MADENLIAN

One of the most significant developments in recent years has been the transformation in how the relationship between the Republic of Armenia and the Armenian Diaspora is defined and understood.

While successive Armenian governments traditionally characterized the Diaspora as a strategic national partner, they fell short, to varying degrees, of fully implementing that principle. The first administration, led by Levon Ter-Petrosyan, went so far as to harass the Armenian Revolutionary Federation and shut down its offices in Armenia. Subsequent administrations expressed greater willingness to cooperate but failed to meaningfully incorporate Diaspora institutions into policymaking, particularly on pan-Armenian issues, as demonstrated by the Armenian-Turkish Protocols, which sparked widespread Diaspora protests.

However, the current administration has gone considerably further, fundamentally redefining and diminishing the Diaspora’s role, both in principle and in practice. Rather than recognizing it as an integral component of the Armenian nation and a partner in shaping its collective future, the government increasingly treats the Diaspora as an external community whose role is largely limited to providing financial and occasional professional support.

Although institutions dedicated to Diaspora engagement remain in place, their activities focus largely on administrative and cultural programs, without meaningful participation by established Diaspora organizations in national policymaking. These structures are also increasingly used to advance domestic political interests and government narratives that conflict with longstanding Diaspora priorities.

This is particularly evident in the government’s approach to Artsakh, the Armenian Genocide, and relations with Turkey and Azerbaijan, where Diaspora institutions have been largely excluded from meaningful consultation, while government policies have increasingly contradicted the national priorities advocated for over a century by much of the organized Diaspora.

Marginalization of the Organized Diaspora
Since 2018, and particularly following the 2020 Artsakh War and the forced displacement of Artsakh’s Armenian population in 2023, Diaspora organizations that have devoted generations to political advocacy, humanitarian assistance, and the Armenian Cause have found themselves not only marginalized from major national discussions but have even been told to refrain from expressing opinions contrary to government positions.

The government’s preference for engaging individual professionals, investors, and selected community figures rather than established Diaspora institutions and political organizations reflects a broader effort to weaken the organized Diaspora’s collective influence and de facto the national interests advocated since 1915. Its rhetoric distinguishing citizens of Armenia from Armenians living abroad further undermine the traditional understanding of shared national identity and responsibility.

The Armenian Revolutionary Federation (ARF), founded in 1890, has been a central pillar of the organized Diaspora, establishing an extensive network of educational, youth, cultural, humanitarian, and political institutions throughout the world. During the decades when no independent Armenian state existed, the ARF and its affiliated organizations played a vital role in preserving Armenian identity, national consciousness, and the Armenian Cause. The ARF remained a standard-bearer of the Armenian tricolor, independence, and historical justice despite Soviet efforts to divide the Diaspora and discredit the Party similar to the current Armenian regime.

The current government’s hostility toward the ARF represents more than political disagreement. It reflects a broader challenge to the independence and institutional foundations of the organized Diaspora and its priorities, similar to past Soviet attempts to influence and control Armenian communities abroad.

Other traditional political parties, including the Ramgavars and Hunchaks, as well as longstanding institutions such as the Armenian General Benevolent Union (AGBU) and other Diaspora organizations, have faced similar criticism and harassment when their positions conflict with government policies, particularly regarding Artsakh, the Armenian Genocide, and relations with Turkey and Azerbaijan.

Undermining these institutions means weakening the very structures that sustained Armenian national identity, aspirations and the Armenian Cause for more than a century.

Diverging Visions of Nationhood
At the heart of this growing divide are fundamentally different understandings of Armenian nationhood.

The Armenian nation is global and indivisible. The Republic of Armenia is its sovereign state, but it does not encompass the entirety of the Armenian nation, nor can its government claim exclusive authority over the historical rights and national aspirations of Armenians worldwide. With a substantial majority of Armenians living beyond the Republic’s borders, the Diaspora possesses both the moral authority and national responsibility to participate in shaping the collective future of the Armenian people.

Armenia’s elected government has authority to govern the Republic and determine state policy. However, the Armenian state and the Armenian nation are not synonymous. No government, regardless of its electoral mandate however large or small it may be, has exclusive authority to define, diminish, or relinquish the collective historical rights and national aspirations of Armenians throughout the world.

This distinction is particularly important regarding pan-Armenian issues, including the rights of Artsakh Armenians, Armenian prisoners held in Baku, justice and reparations for the Armenian Genocide, historical claims relating to Western Armenia, and relations with Turkey and Azerbaijan.

These are not merely matters of domestic state policy. They transcend the Republic’s borders and require a coordinated national approach based on shared responsibility and a national purpose.

Artsakh and the Armenian Genocide: Enduring National Responsibilities
The loss of Artsakh and the ethnic cleansing of its Armenian population in 2023 is a continuation of the Armenian Genocide by the same perpetrators and must not mark the end of Armenian political advocacy concerning the region. Rather, it represents an immense national setback that must be confronted collectively, with determination to preserve Armenian rights and ultimately recover what has been lost.

The Armenian government’s dismissive approach and continued concessions have placed an even greater responsibility on the Diaspora to advocate for displaced Artsakh Armenians, defend their right of return, preserve their historical and legal claims, and protect Armenian cultural and religious heritage through international institutions.

Any effort to remove Artsakh from Armenian national discourse is strategically and morally unacceptable and serves the longstanding objectives of Azerbaijan and Turkey. At a minimum, the Armenian government should cease undermining these efforts and instead support the rights and legitimate aspirations of Artsakh’s Armenian population.

Similarly, the Armenian Genocide remains an ongoing national, historical, legal, and political issue requiring continued international recognition, accountability, reparations, and preservation of historical claims relating to Western Armenia.

Unfortunately, the current government’s pursuit of regional normalization with Turkey and Azerbaijan has increasingly diminished the importance of historical justice, at times treating even Genocide recognition as an obstacle to diplomacy. Its policies have created the growing perception that it is prepared to abandon longstanding Armenian national claims in pursuit of immediate and temporary personal political objectives at the expense of the national purpose.

Yet these rights belong to the Armenian nation as a whole, not to any particular government or administration. Lasting peace in the region with Turkey or Azerbaijan cannot be built on the abandonment of historical truth, justice, or the legitimate national rights of Armenians worldwide.

For the Diaspora, much of which emerged directly from the Armenian Genocide, preserving historical memory and advancing the Armenian Cause are not optional and temporary political positions. They are enduring national responsibilities inherited from generations of sacrifice, survival, and struggle.

The Future Role of the Diaspora
Armenia’s geopolitical, demographic, economic, and security challenges cannot be addressed by the government alone. Meeting them requires a coordinated national effort in which the Republic of Armenia and the organized Diaspora function as complementary pillars of one Armenian nation.

This requires genuine institutional cooperation, recognition of the Diaspora as a strategic partner in international advocacy and national development, expanded participation in education and economic planning, and continued support for Armenian-language education and community institutions abroad. Equally important, the Armenian Cause, including Artsakh, the Armenian Genocide, historical justice, and national rights, must remain integral to Armenian education, national consciousness, and the broader national agenda.

At the same time, the Diaspora’s national role and responsibilities cannot depend upon the willingness of any government in Yerevan to cooperate. The Diaspora has demonstrated, through generations of adversity, its ability to preserve Armenian identity, sustain national institutions, and advance the Armenian Cause independently.

The organized Diaspora must therefore preserve its institutional autonomy while strengthening its political, educational, cultural, humanitarian, and advocacy organizations. It must invest in younger generations, revitalize community institutions, develop future leadership, protect and develop Armenian culture and the language especially Western Armenian, and remain united around fundamental national principles while respecting the diversity of its communities in and within various regions.

Next, Part 4: The Political Importance of the Armenian Diaspora and the Future





—

Disclaimer: This article was contributed and translated into English by Emil Karabekian. While we strive for quality, the views and accuracy of the content remain the responsibility of the contributor. Please verify all facts independently before reposting or citing.

Direct link to this article: https://www.armenianclub.com/2026/11/19/asbarez-a-fundamental-shift-in-armenia-diaspora-relations-part-3/

Leave a Reply