Armenia asks CSTO to remove country assistance document from agenda

Belarus – Nov 20 2023

MINSK, 20 November (BelTA) – Armenia asked the Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO) to remove the country assistance document from the agenda, CSTO Secretary General Imangali Tasmagambetov said as he met with Belarusian President Aleksandr Lukashenko on 20 November, BelTA has learned.

Imangali Tasmagambetov expressed gratitude to the Belarusian head of state for the opportunity to discuss the current work of the CSTO and issues related to the organization's activities ahead of the upcoming important events. On 22 November, Minsk will host meetings of the CSTO Defense Ministers Council, the CSTO Foreign Ministers Council and the CSTO Committee of Secretaries of Security Councils. The CSTO Collective Security Council session is scheduled for 23 November.

“As for the status of the action plan to the decisions of the Collective Security Council adopted at the November session last year and the priority areas of Belarus, I would like to report that 32 out of 34 measures have been implemented. Two measures have not been fulfilled unfortunately. These are, first of all, our international contacts with European international organizations, such as the OSCE, primarily because of their stance. The second item was the Armenia assistance document which the Collective Security Council instructed us to finalize. Armenia, although all other member states supported the document, did not express any interest in it and, in the final part of our work, asked us to remove the document from the agenda,” the CSTO secretary general said.

As BelTA reported earlier, at the CSTO summit in Yerevan in November 2022, Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan refused to sign the draft decision of the Collective Security Council on joint assistance measures for Armenia. The then CSTO Secretary General Stanislav Zas told the media that the document had been generally agreed upon and a set of measures to assist Armenia had been defined. However, the draft document needed finalization on a number of positions. The heads of state instructed to finalize the document and submit it to them for approval.

https://eng.belta.by/society/view/armenia-asks-csto-to-remove-country-assistance-document-from-agenda-163453-2023/

EU and Armenia sign agreement on European Union Mission in Armenia

Nov 20 2023

Today, the Republic of Armenia and the European Union signed an agreement on the Status of the European Union Mission in Armenia (EUMA).

The document was signed in Yerevan by Vassilis Maragos, Head of EU Delegation to Armenia, and Paruyr Hovhannisyan, Deputy Foreign Minister of Armenia. 

The agreement regulates the legal status of the EUMA.

EUMA is a non-executive, non-armed civilian Common Security and Defence Policy (CSDP) Mission. EUMA observes and reports on the security situation along the Armenian side of the international border with Azerbaijan. It contributes to human security in conflict-affected areas in Armenia and aims to build confidence between Armenia and Azerbaijan. 

The Mission was deployed on 20 February 2023 with a two-year mandate and 103 international staff from the EU Member States, including EU experts and monitors.

Find out more

Press release

https://euneighbourseast.eu/news/latest-news/eu-and-armenia-sign-agreement-on-european-union-mission-in-armenia/

Lara Alexander Named Armenian-Australian Community’s Friend of the Year for 2023

Tasmanian Times
Australia – Nov 20 2023

Media release – Independent Member for Bass, Lara Alexander MP, 20 November 2023

The Armenian National Committee of Australia (ANC-AU) executive director Michael Kolokossian announced the award to Mrs Alexander at the ANC-AU Gala dinner in Sydney on Saturday evening.

The Friend of the Year award honours individuals who have stood with the Armenian community and worked to give greater public recognition to issues of great importance to that community.

Past recipients include former NSW Premiers Bob Carr and Gladys Berejiklian, Federal MPs Julian Leeser, Paul Fletcher, Joel Fitzgibbon, Tim Wilson, Trent Zimmerman, John Alexander and Joe Hockey, writer and broadcaster Phillip Adams, former South Australian attorney-general Michael Atkinson and Professor Colin Tatz, among others.

Mr Kolokossian said Mrs Alexander had been chosen in honour of her efforts to secure Tasmanian parliamentary recognition of the 1915 Armenian, Assyrian and Greek genocides.

He said Mrs Alexander had made an “extraordinary contribution” in securing the Tasmanian recognition, an achievement he said would not have been possible without her “friendship, guidance, commitment and dedication”.

In May of this year Mrs Alexander introduced a motion to State Parliament calling on the Tasmanian parliament to formally acknowledge and recognise the 1915 Armenian, Assyrian and Greek genocides at the hands of the then Ottoman Empire.

(An estimated 1.2 million Armenian, and Assyrian and Greek Christian, lives were lost either through mass killings or on forced marches after the Ottoman Empire – now modern-day Turkey – embarked on a campaign of systematic ethnic cleansing in the early years of WW1.)

The motion, with the support of Premier Jeremy Rockliff, Opposition leader Rebecca White and then Greens leader Cassy O’Connor unanimously passed the Lower House, allowing Tasmania to join New South Wales and South Australia as Australian states to formally recognise the genocides.

Mrs Alexander said she was deeply honoured to receive the award and was humbled to be able to play a small role in a battle for recognition that the Armenian community had been fighting for more than 100 years.

“It has been a long, hard road for the Armenian, Assyrian and Greek communities, who have toiled for more than 100 years to gain acknowledgement of the terrible losses their communities suffered in 1915,” she said.

“Compared to countless others, my role has been a very minor one and for the community to give me this honour is a very humbling experience.”

Mrs Alexander said while she was the recipient of the award, she felt strongly that she was accepting it on behalf of the Tasmanian Parliament and people. She said she was grateful to the Premier, Ms White and particularly Ms O’Connor for their support.

“It wouldn’t have been possible without the support of the Premier and the Opposition leader, but it would be remiss of me to not thank Cassie in particular, for her support, advice and encouragement,” she said.

“I also know that it was very comforting for the Armenian and Greek delegations present in the House that day to hear all MPs – Government, Opposition and crossbench – make genuinely heartfelt contributions to the debate and come together as one voice to support the Armenian, Assyrian and Greek communities.”

Ms Lindsey Snell received the Ben Bagdikian Media Award. An American journalist with a long background of covering active war zones and crises, particularly in the Middle East.

Dr Hugh McDermott MP: State Member for Prospect, NSW received the Freedom Award for his tireless work in support of Artsakh and the Armenian community. In 2023, Dr McDermott co-led the third ANC-AU Australian Parliamentary Delegation to the Republic of Armenia, visiting the city of Goris and delivering on-the-ground humanitarian assistance to Artsakh refugees during one of the most critical junctures in the Armenian people’s history.

After Indian MLRS, Anti-Drone System, France Supplies Armored Vehicles To Armenia Planned For Ukraine

Nov 20 2023

After making it clear that France will not be sitting on the sidelines as war ravages Caucasian countries, French-made armored vehicles have reportedly been delivered to Armenia instead of Ukraine, as initially intended. France is now home to Europe’s most prominent Armenian diaspora community.

Armenia’s bolstered defense ties with the West and India have come at a time when it is decoupling with Russia, which remains preoccupied with its invasion of Ukraine. Most recently, Yerevan decided against attending events of the Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO) because it received no aid that it had requested during an Azerbaijani military incursion on its sovereign territory in May 2021.

The CSTO is a Russia-led inter-governmental security alliance of six post-Soviet states. The other members of CSTO, formed in 2002, are Armenia, Belarus, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, and Tajikistan.

According to a French media outlet, “The first confirmed delivery (to Armenia) is of Bastion light armored vehicles manufactured by the equipment manufacturer Arquus. The Bastion can carry a battle group of eight soldiers, protecting against small arms fire and mines.”

The report indicated that France could also supply 50 VAB MK3 armored vehicles manufactured by Renault Trucks Defense. It provides armed forces with high-level protection and multi-mission capabilities.

Georgian authorities confirmed that France dispatched ACMAT Bastion armored personnel carriers to Armenia via the Port of Poti, also verified by APM Terminals Poti to RFE/RL’s Georgian service.

Azerbaijan’s Foreign Ministry spokesman, Ayhan Hajizadeh, strongly criticized France’s supply of armored vehicles to Armenia. He expressed concern that this equipment transfer would bolster Armenia’s military strength.

The Bastion armored personnel carriers were initially intended to be supplied to Ukraine. But Kyiv rejected the 12.5-ton vehicles, contending they would be inadequately protected against artillery and anti-tank missiles. La Tribune had previously disclosed France’s plans to provide Kyiv with 20 Bastion vehicles in October 2022.

Following the declaration to bulwark Armenian defenses in October 2023, France has inked the deals for supplying Thales-manufactured Ground Master 200 (GM200) radars and signed a memorandum of understanding to deliver the Mistral short-range air defense system. According to France’s Ministry of the Armed Forces, a second contract was for Yerevan to acquire night vision goggles and equipment manufactured by Safran.

Speaking to reporters, French Defense Minister Sébastien Lecornu said that Armenia would buy three Ground Master 200 (GM200) radar systems from the French defense group Thales without providing financial details. The system, already used in Ukraine, is known for its “remarkable detection capabilities,” Lecornu asserted at a press conference alongside Armenian Defense Minister Suren Papikyan.

In the coming months, the French government will send a French military official to act as a defense consultant for the Armenian executive branch on issues such as armed forces training, Lecornu said. France will be training Armenian soldiers and helping Yerevan audit Armenia’s air defense to identify blind spots.

Armenia has almost doubled its defense investments over the last year. In 2022, the spending was around US$700 million to US$800 million; now, in 2024, it will be US$1.4 billion or US $1.5 billion.

Armenia-Azerbaijan conflict

The defense contracts with India alone account for a billion dollars. In the latest order, as reported by the EurAsian Times, Armenia contracted Zen Technologies for INR340 crore (US$41.5 million) for the anti-drone system that includes both training solutions and the system.

Armenia, a small landlocked nation nestled in the South Caucasus region of Eurasia, has emerged as a strategic partner for India. In 2022, when India inked the deal to supply Pinaka multi-barrel rocket launchers (MBRL), anti-tank munitions, and ammunition worth US$250 million to Armenia, it was seen as New Delhi taking a position in the conflict. It was the first export of PINAKA by India.

Armenia opted for Pinaka MBRLs, considered at par with the American HIMARs, for its shoot and scoot capability. The mobility is an advantage as adversary Azerbaijan has been deploying drones, including suicide drones.

For some time now, Yerevan has sought to diversify its arms imports and find new allies after Russia failed to provide the country with ordered weapons worth around US$400 million (it has not yet returned the money).

The failed arms deal was an additional trigger in the worsening Russia-Armenia relations, which made Armenia seek to diversify the sources of its arms imports, looking at the West and India.

The European Union has also discussed providing non-lethal military aid to Armenia. During its November 13 meeting, the EU Foreign Affairs Council deliberated on enhancing the EU monitoring mission by sending more observers and patrols to the Armenian border. The Council emphasized vigilance against destabilization in Armenia and warned Azerbaijan against compromising its territorial integrity.

Armenia stopped participating in CSTO events after the 2020 war when the CSTO said that Nagorno-Karabakh was not a sovereign part of Armenia and the organization had no mandate to deal with such issues.

The Armenian government has said, “Azerbaijani troops entered the sovereign territory of Armenia in May 2021. We turned to the CSTO for help and have not received it until now,” Secretary of the Armenian Security Council Armen Grigoryan said on November 15.

  • Ritu Sharma has been a journalist for over a decade, writing on defense, foreign affairs, and nuclear technology.
https://www.eurasiantimes.com/france-supplies-armored-vehicles-to-armenia-planned/

The Third Nagorno-Karabakh War: A 6 month outlook

Grey Dynamics
Nov 20 2023

Nagorno-Karabakh is a landlocked mountainous region in the southern Caucasus that has been subject to a lengthy territorial dispute between Azerbaijan and neighbouring Armenia. While it is internationally recognized as part of Azerbaijan, it was governed by the unrecognised Nagorno-Karabakh Republic, also referred to as the Republic of Artsakh. Nagorno-Karabakh consists of a large ethnic Armenian majority.

On September 19th, Azerjabaijani forces overwhelmed the defenders of the Nagorno-Karabakh Republic, whose government believes it will cease to exist by January 2024. The conflict has caused a humanitarian crisis and mass exodus of ethnic Armenians from the territory. Azerbaijan has rejected accusations of ethnic-cleansing in the region. 

Azerbaijan’s Foreign Minister, Jeyhun Bayramov, expressed that the military operation has created “genuine prospects for a prompt peace treaty between Azerbaijan and Armenia. On October 26th, a potential agreement between Armenia and Azerbaijan was brokered. The “Crossroads of Peace” agreement would reopen roads and railways with Armenia’s neighbours, including Azerbaijan, that have been closed for decades.

Key Judgement 1. Western nations will likely confine their opposition to Azerbaijan’s intervention to diplomatic protest and humanitarian support in the next 6 months.  

Key Judgement 2. In the next 6 months, Iran will likely play a key role in mitigating Armenia-Azerbaijan negotiations. 

Key Judgement 3. In the next 6 months, Turkey will likely continue to maintain its military support for Azerbaijan despite the numerous humanitarian concerns in Karabakh.

a. Armenia asked the EU for humanitarian aid, including medical supplies and temporary shelters after the outbreak of the conflict in September. The office of Italian PM Giorgia Meloni said in a statement that Rome is working to promote stabilisation in the region [source]

b. While France promises to boost Armenia air defence with anti-air missiles, it is the only Western nation to do so. However, this escalation will not likely to renew any kind of military conflict. [source]

c. On October 3rd, the German government  called for a ‘permanent presence’ in Nagorno-Karabakh, calling for the need for ‘transparency’ and ‘trust’ in Azerbaijan to protect the rights of its residents. [source]

d. In September, Armenia asked the ICJ to order Azerbaijan to withdraw all its troops from civilian establishments in Nagorno-Karabakh and to give the UN access. However it is now unlikely that the ICJ will intervene. [source]

a. On October 23rd, Iran hosted talks between Turkey, Russia, Armenia, and Azerbaijan regarding this conflict. Following these talks, both sides agreed that Nagorno-Karabakh belongs to Azerbaijan. [source]

b. Iran is carefully navigating negotiations between both Armenia and Azerbaijan. Since the initial breakout of the conflict, Iran has been calling for resolution through dialogue. [source]

c. From 2016 to 2020, Iran supplies Azerbaijan with an estimated 70 percent of its arms. [source]

d.  Iranian General Mohammad Baqeri said Azerbaijan was restoring its ‘territorial integrity” in its operation in Karabakh in September. [source]

a. In the week of October 22nd, Turkey and Azerbaijan participated in a joint military simulation on rural settlement combat. The exercise allegedly took place in Nagorno-Karabakh. [source]

b. The construction of the Nakhchivan gas pipeline will likely be completed in 2024, connecting through the Turkey, Azerbaijan border. On September 25th, Edrohan and Aliyev attended a ceremony to launch its construction. [source]

c. A long-time ally of Azerbaijan, Turkey has pledged its support for the military intervention in Nagorno-Karabakh. [source]

d. Erdohan has mentioned that Iran is warming up to a joint Turkish-Azeri transport corridor that would connect Turkey to Azerbaijan through Armenia. [source]

We are confident in our assessment that Nagorno-Karabakh will continue being a humanitarian crisis to the greater Caucasus region. This is based on our judgement of local and international press reports as well as NGO and Think Tank reporting. We assume that the “Crossroads of Peace” agreement will go through as planned.

Should this assumption be incorrect, we would expect to see a drawn out negotiation process. We considered the alternative that French military aid to Armenia will escalate the conflict, but judged it unlikely due to the ongoing communication efforts between Armenia and Azerbaijan. Should this happen, we will reconsult with our sources and adjust our assessment accordingly.

Intelligence Cut-off Date:


Samkharadze: Georgia Ready to Facilitate Dialogue Between Armenia and Azerbaijan

Messenger, Georgia
Nov 20 2023
By Liza Mchedlidze

Monday,


The delegation from the Parliament of Georgia actively participated in the 21st autumn meeting of the OSCE Parliamentary Assembly held in Yerevan.

As per the Parliament's press service, Nikoloz Samkharadze, Chairman of the Foreign Relations Committee and leader of the permanent Georgian Parliament delegation, discussed the visit of OSCE President Pia Kauma and the delegation to Georgia, along with highlighting Georgia's regional role in his address.

Samkharadze conveyed Georgia's readiness to facilitate peace dialogue between Armenia and Azerbaijan, offering Tbilisi as a potential venue for negotiations. He expressed hope that, with the commitment publicly expressed by both sides, lasting peace between the two brotherly neighboring countries could be achieved in the coming months.

"I believe it was a very timely visit to assess the current situation and explore the possibilities of establishing lasting peace in the South Caucasus. It was also crucial for the delegation to visit the occupation line and the settlements of internally displaced persons-individuals who have been unable to return to their homes for more than 15 years, with some enduring displacement for up to 30 years due to the Russian occupation. I would like to emphasize that Georgia is ready to facilitate the peace dialogue between Armenia and Azerbaijan.

We are prepared to offer Tbilisi as a venue for negotiations, and we hope that, with the commitment that both sides have publicly expressed and made, we will be able to celebrate lasting peace between our two brotherly neighboring countries in the coming months. From our side, Georgia is ready to facilitate the dialogue," said Samkharadze.

In response to the leader of the Georgian parliamentary delegation, Pia Kauma, the president of the OSCE Parliamentary Assembly, expressed her pleasure in visiting Georgia and highlighted the significance of the moment. She noted that Georgia has been granted the status of a candidate for the European Union, with the official announcement expected in December.

Pia Kauma reaffirmed the OSCE's full support for Georgia's territorial integrity and emphasized the organization's commitment to promoting peace in the region, particularly between Armenia and Azerbaijan.

Armenia not planning to attack anyone, higher defense spending is preparation for peace – says Pashinyan

 11:36, 16 November 2023

YEREVAN, NOVEMBER 16, ARMENPRESS. Defense expenditures in Armenia under the 2024 budget will be doubled compared to 2018, Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan told lawmakers during debates of his administration’s budget request for next year.

“This is not a preparation for war, but for peace, because the sense of protection among our citizens is the most important guarantee for peace and stability,” Pashinyan said.

“I am convinced that all neighboring countries are sure that we don’t intend to attack anyone,” Pashinyan added.

He dismissed the concerns on the expenditures as dishonest, noting : “First of all, any sovereign state has not only the right but also the obligation to reform and strengthen its military, something we are doing. And secondly, in the last ten years, Azerbaijan’s defense spending was on an average three times higher than ours. And basically it remains the same,” Pashinyan said.

Turkey paroles convicted assassin of Hrant Dink

 12:04, 16 November 2023

YEREVAN, NOVEMBER 16, ARMENPRESS. The convicted murderer of Armenian-Turkish journalist Hrant Dink has been released on parole after serving 16 years in prison, Ermeni Haber reports.

According to the report, the murderer Ogun Samast was paroled for good conduct.

Samast was sentenced to 22 years in prison for killing Agos Editor-in-Chief Hrant Dink. 

He was tried by a juvenile court as he was under 18 at the time of the murder.

Hrant Dink was assassinated in Istanbul in front of his newspaper’s office on January 19, 2007.

Reason of not signing peace treaty with Azerbaijan is mutual distrust, says Pashinyan

 12:22, 16 November 2023

YEREVAN, NOVEMBER 16, ARMENPRESS. Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan has explained why Armenia is not signing a peace treaty with Azerbaijan when, as he said earlier, the principles of the treaty are agreed upon.

“By and large the reason is the distrust between the sides, because every time, we see in Azerbaijan’s statements and certain actions, and perhaps they see in ours, intentions to abandon agreements and plan aggressive actions, which negatively impacts the text work of the peace treaty,” Pashinyan said.

He said that several other key issues are yet to be clarified, one of which is the development of a mechanism for overcoming the possible misinterpretations of the content of the peace treaty.

“Unfortunately that’s the reality, that sometimes every sentence can be interpreted differently, therefore we must have very clear interpretations as to how we will overcome it in case of differing interpretations. The other [issue] is the creation of security guarantees, so that no escalation will be possible after the signing of the peace treaty,” Pashinyan said.

PM Pashinyan said his administration intends to intensify diplomatic and political work to overcome these issues.