Armenia: domestic violence and the pandemic, houses are a prison

Jan 28 2021


ita eng


28/01/2021 -  Armine Avetysian

“For me, paradoxically, work was when I could rest. There was a phase in my life when I lived in a state of constant alarm”, says Anna, 35 (the name was changed at her request).

Since March 2020, due to the coronavirus epidemic, a state of emergency was declared in Armenia and many started to work remotely, including Anna, who worked in a call centre.

“The nature of my work is such that we also started working from home. I have to answer the phone, register an order, and then manage the delivery process. I constantly talk on the phone and imagine doing that in the presence of my drunkard husband, who is just looking for a chance to curse and hit me”.

Anna got married 7 years ago. On the first day of her married life her husband, out of nothing, broke some dishes and beat her. If in the past he would hit her once or twice a month, during the quarantine it would be a few times a week.

“No week would go without a fight in our house. Sometimes I talked on the phone and he pulled my hair and slapped me. Eventually I had to ask for leave, I was ashamed and risked being fired from work”.

Anna's husband does not have a permanent job. He is a builder who works from time to time. Trying to justify her husband, she notes that because of the coronavirus life in the world stopped, and so did her husband's work. Thus he got depressed and started getting drunk almost every day, becoming more aggressive.

Due to the coronavirus pandemic, many countries introduced restrictions on movement, calls were made to stay at home, sometimes quarantine was declared. Shortly afterwards, the first reports came of an increase in domestic violence cases.

"While addressing the healthcare emergency, states must not forget to protect the right of women and children to live without violence. It is necessary to take proper measures to ensure their safety when families are in isolation", OSCE Secretary General Thomas Greminger said.

The problem was exacerbated in Armenia as well. As shown by several studies, domestic violence cases increased since March 15, 2020, when almost everyone was at home for about a month after declaring a state of emergency. Between March 16 and April 20, member organisations of the "Coalition to stop violence against women" registered 803 reports of domestic violence – about 30% more than the same period in the previous year.

The NGO "Women's Support Center" had 79 calls in April – 50% more than in the same period of 2019. About 50% of calls are requests for social assistance for victims of domestic violence.

In the first days of the declaration of the state of emergency, the Office of the Human Rights Defender of the Republic of Armenia also registered an increase in cases of domestic violence: particularly, in the period from March 15 to April 20, 15 reports of domestic violence were registered (5 in March 2019).

“Violent men became more aggressive during the lockdown. It is also a psychological problem. They were at home, locked up, losing their jobs, which made them even more nervous. Women did not go to work either, they stayed home, victims”, notes Hasmik Gevorgyan, head of the Women's Support Center.

In the fall, however, the situation in Armenia changed. In small steps, life was going back to normal. In September 2020, the pandemic seemed to ease in Armenia, new cases were decreasing day by day. Many were going back to work outside the home, schools would open. The positive trend, however, did not last long. The conflict initiated by Azerbaijan over Nagorno-Karabakh did not help.

Meanwhile, the pandemic was raging in Armenia. In terms of infection rates, Armenia was returning to June's records, when the highest numbers of infections were registered and the healthcare system was fully committed to managing the epidemic. Specialists explained the increase in infections mainly with the situation at the border. Worried about the tension on the front lines and the news of the victims and the wounded, people became less vigilant.

In November, the military actions were over. In parallel, the number of new cases of coronavirus began to decrease. The healthcare system began to breathe. Although numbers have remained manageable since the beginning of the year, the Ministry of Health announced that emergency measures will remain in place until July 11.

At the same time, taking into account the current situation, some restrictions have been mitigated. For example, foreigners may enter the country via land border crossing points, but only with a negative test result from the previous 72 hours. It is also possible to test at the border and self-isolate until the results come. However, some restrictions will remain, namely the mandatory wearing of face masks.

“Armenia is open, but the world is getting closed”, says Anna, whose husband is still in Armenia. “He can’t go abroad for work because Russia does not accept him. Russia also announced some mitigations, but my husband cannot travel there yet – workers like him are not allowed”.

Anna's husband is doing private work these days. She says he also took part in the military actions. Although the episodes of violence have now decreased, she does not rule out that they will happen again.

"I count the days when the borders of the world will open. I feel that peace in our family will not last long. If my husband stays home a little more, maybe we will break up. Our lifestyle is arranged so that from time to time we need to live apart from each other. Maybe the coronavirus will eventually destroy our family”, says this woman that – like many others – unfortunately has not yet found the help she needs to be free from her nightmare.

https://www.balcanicaucaso.org/eng/Areas/Armenia/Armenia-domestic-violence-and-the-pandemic-houses-are-a-prison-207957





Turkish press: Turkish-Russian Nagorno-Karabakh monitoring center to open Saturday

Azerbaijani police officers patrol an area after sunset a week after the city was turned over to the Azerbaijani military, in Aghdam, Azerbaijan, Nov. 25, 2020, (AP Photo)

Ajoint Turkish-Russian center to observe the cease-fire in Nagorno-Karabakh will come into operation as of Saturday, Turkish Defense Minister Hulusi Akar said on Friday.

One Turkish general and 38 personnel will work at the center to support efforts to ensure that the cease-fire lasts, Akar said in a statement.

Turkey and Russia agreed to set up the joint center to monitor the cease-fire reached between Azerbaijan and Armenia in November.

“The works on establishing the joint center have been completed. The joint center, where Turkish and Russian soldiers are to operate, will start its activities tomorrow,” Akar said.

The minister told Anadolu Agency (AA) that he has discussed matters of defense and security with his Azerbaijani counterpart Zakir Hasanov over the phone.

Noting that the latest developments were discussed with Hasanov, Akar said “we believe that the joint center will make great contributions to the continuity of the ceasefire and to ensuring peace and stability in the region.”

He vowed to continue to defend the rights of Azerbaijani people, and said: “We have sided with our Azerbaijani brothers/sisters in line with the concept of one nation and two states, and we will continue to do so.”

A Russian-brokered deal on Nov. 10 halted a six-week conflict between Azerbaijani and Armenian forces over the region of Nagorno-Karabakh and its surrounding areas, securing territorial gains for Azerbaijan.

Nagorno-Karabakh is internationally recognized as part of Azerbaijan but had been under the occupation of ethnic Armenian separatists for nearly three decades.

Under the agreement, Armenia must provide Azerbaijan with a safe transport link through its territory to the exclave of Nakhchivan, which borders Turkey.

Russian peacekeepers were also deployed to the region under the deal.

Turkish press: Joining 6-nation forum Armenia’s only option: Experts

Gulsum Incekaya   |30.01.2021

ISTANBUL

If Armenia joins a six-country regional platform, she will benefit from regional opportunities, reach economic stability and its dependence on the West will decrease, which will be favorable for Russia, experts said Friday. 

Countries in the region supported Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan and his Azerbaijani counterpart Ilham Aliyev’s request to join the platform that includes Russia, Turkey, Azerbaijan, Iran and Georgia, as well as Armenia, if it accepts.

“The six-country platform is an enterprise that will provide a win-win opportunity for everyone. If Armenia joins this process and takes positive steps, Turkey-Armenia relations can have a new turn,” said Erdogan. “Undoubtedly, Armenia’s gains will increase considerably as new opportunities emerge.”

Experts told Anadolu Agency that the six-country platform will contribute greatly to stability and development in the region.

Muhittin Ataman, a faculty member at the Social Sciences University of Ankara said Turkey and Azerbaijan’s roles in the Caucasus increased after the victory in the Nagorno-Karabakh region.

“There is no problem of cooperation in terms of politics, economics or security. In case Armenia, which does not have a coast, is not involved in the six-country platform, it will be her loss,” Ataman said.

Underlining that the Armenian diaspora has been harming Armenia for 30 years, Ataman said, “The diaspora instrumentalizes the Armenian state for its own goals and to influence the politics of countries where they live. The diaspora in Western countries is living through Armenia's victimization.”

He noted that the platform offers Armenia an opportunity for normalization.

“Armenia is very similar to Israel. In a sense, the occupation of Karabakh was like the occupation of Palestine. More importantly, Armenia is a state with no clear borders, like Israel,” he said. “Armenia presents an image as if she demands territories both from Azerbaijan and Turkey. Thus, she puts herself in a state of war and this will definitely prevent her normalization in this region.”

He noted that the two main terms that Armenia needs to accept if she becomes a part of the platform are retreating from lands that she occupied and officially acknowledging her borders.

Ataman indicated that if Armenia joins, she will be able to benefit from already relations between Azerbaijan and Turkey.

“Definitely Armenia will have economic stability and economic prosperity will be possible. Consequently, she will be in a position to benefit from all regional opportunities. Normalization in Armenia’s relations with Azerbaijan and Turkey will decrease Armenia’s dependence on the West, and that will be a favorable situation for Russia,” he added.

Ege University International Relations faculty member Aydin Ibrahimov said Armenia does not have an option but to join the platform.

“Armenia must take a significant step to join the platform. If she takes this step, she can have the chance to open new pages in her relations with Azerbaijan and Turkey.”

Reminding that the Russian Foreign Ministry announced a trilateral negotiation joined by Armenia and Azerbaijan to be soon held, Ibrahimov said, “The negotiation between Russia, Azerbaijan and Armenia will be about opening railroads from Nakchivan to Baku and from Armenia to Russia. Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan leans toward it. But the opposition and the Armenian diaspora object to all sorts of agreements with Turkey. Western countries will want to use Armenia against Russia, Azerbaijan and Turkey.”

Ibrahimov noted that in case Armenia does not step back in terms of borders, continues its aggressive policies and does not recognize Azerbaijan’s territorial integrity, it might be difficult for Armenia to join the platform.

Hazar University academic Telman Nusretoglu said cooperation between Turkey and Azerbaijan created a new geopolitical power in the South Caucasus.

He said Armenia is the biggest obstacle before the cooperative atmosphere that can be established in the region due to her aggressive approaches as well as her hostile attitude toward Turkey and Azerbaijan.

Relations between the former Soviet republics, Armenia and Azerbaijan, have been tense since 1991 when the Armenian military occupied Upper Karabakh, also known as Nagorno-Karabakh, internationally recognized as Azerbaijani territory, and seven adjacent regions.

New clashes erupted Sept. 27, 2020, and during the six-week-long conflict, Azerbaijan liberated several cities and nearly 300 settlements and villages. At least 2,855 of its soldiers were martyred.

There are differing claims about the number of casualties on the Armenian side, which sources and officials say could be as high as 5,000.

The two countries signed a Russian-brokered agreement Nov. 10 to end the fighting and work toward a comprehensive resolution.  

* Writing by Dilan Pamuk in Ankara

U.S. Ambassador to Baku Congratulates Azerbaijan for ‘Restoring Territorial Integrity’

January 29,  2020



U.S. Ambassador to Azerbaijan Earle Litzenberger meets with Azerbaijan’s Economy Minister Mikayil Jabbarov

ANCA Rebukes Ambassador in Baku for ‘Celebrating Azerbaijani Aggression.’

The United States Ambassador to Azerbaijan Earle Litzenberger has reportedly congratulated Azerbaijan for “restoring its territorial integrity” and has expressed the U.S.’s readiness to take part in rebuilding lands that came under Baku’s control after the war, reported Azernews.az on Thursday.

Litzenberger made the remarks during a meeting with Azerbaijan’s Economy Minister Mikayil Jabbarov, according to a press statement issued by the ministry on Wednesday.

According to Azernews, Litzenberger also said that American companies are ready to participate in reconstruction efforts, especially in management of water resources, road and other infrastructure efforts, as well as cooperation in the fields of digital and information technologies.

“We are troubled by unconfirmed reports that our Ambassador in Baku is celebrating Azerbaijani aggression and – even worse – enlisting Americans in the commercial exploitation of indigenous Armenian lands,” said Armenian National Committee of America Executive Director Aram Hamparian.

“In light of published accounts characterizing his comments in this regard, Ambassador Litzenberger should set the record straight – explaining whether he is in fact pushing U.S. investments in areas of Artsakh seized by Azerbaijan,” added Hamparian.

Azernews reported that Jabarov told Litzenberger that his ministry is developing programs to attract foreign investors in Baku’s reconstruction efforts.

17th century Armenian church on preservation list demolished in western Turkey

Jan 30 2021

An Armenian church dating to 1603 in the western province of Kütahya that was on the Turkish Ministry of Culture and Tourism’s preservation list was demolished after it was acquired by a private party, the Turkish-Armenian bilingual Agos weekly reported.

The old church was an important heritage site for the Armenian community because famous Armenian priest and musicologist Gomidas Vartabed was baptized there. Garo Paylan, a deputy from the Peoples’ Democratic Party, a left-wing party with majority-Kurdish support, submitted a parliamentary question on how a heritage site registered for protection could be demolished.

The church was on private property and was previously used as a theatre and party venue. The Armenian community had called on the authorities to restore the church to its original purpose.

In his question Paylan said Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan had previously said his government would not interfere with “anyone’s belief, rituals or sacred artifacts.” He pointed out that Vice President Fuat Oktay had also said that churches were as important as mosques in Turkey.

Paylan asked whether the authorities would help rebuild the church in accordance with its original architecture. He requested to know if the officials who allowed the demolition were investigated and why the parliament was silent when Armenian heritage symbols were being eradicated.

Concerns about the preservation of Armenian cultural and religious sites have recently been growing. On January 17, Agos reported that a 19th century Armenian church was put up for sale on a Turkish real estate website. In the ad, the church, which is located in Bursa province, was described as “perfect for a touristic attraction because it is in a UNESCO protected area.”

The seller, whose name was not disclosed, also said the church was a good investment as it could be “used as a hotel, museum or art gallery.”

Paylan criticized the sale of the Armenian church on Twitter, asking how the authorities and the society could allow the sale of a house of worship.

Azerbaijan Ignores Armenian POWs

Jan 30 2021

01/30/2021 Nagorno-Karabakh (International Christian Concern) –  Media reports that only five Armenian prisoners of war have been returned by Azerbaijan following international attention to the status of Nagorno-Karabakh’s prisoners of war. Armenia has reportedly returned all Azeri captives from the 44-day war.

However, until January 28, no Armenian prisoners of war had yet been brought home. According to Article 8 of the Russian-brokered truce agreement this past November, there was supposed to be a  full “exchange of prisoners of war and other detained persons and bodies of the dead.” Though Armenian has proactively been fulfilling these obligations, Azerbaijan has not reciprocated.  

Russia had to broker the agreement to bring home the five Armenian captives held by Azerbaijan. A comprehensive plan for Armenian POW return was not completed during an earlier meeting this month. It was also reported that an additional 62 Armenian POWs talked with relatives on the phone.

Though not solely motivated for religious reasons, the war ignited by Azerbaijan and Turkey has strong religious freedom implications. The ethnic Armenian community in Nagorno-Karabakh is predominately Christian, and was indeed the first Christian nation in history. Azerbaijan and Turkey are united in their shared Turkic Muslim identity. Both the ethnic and religious elements factor heavily throughout this conflict. For more information, read ICC’s report on Nagorno-Karabakh, Anatomy of a Genocide. ICC’s petition for the return of Armenian POWs can be found at this link.

Zarif hoping for lasting peace in region after Karabakh war

Mehr News Agency, Iran
Jan 30 2021

TEHRAN, Jan. 30 (MNA) – The Iranian Foreign Minister expressed hope that with the cooperation of Iran and other regional countries everlasting peace would be brought into the region after the conflict between the Republic of Azerbaijan and Armenia.

In continuation of his regional tour, Iranian Foreign Minister Mohammad Javad Zarif arrived in the Nakhchivan Autonomous Republic on Saturday. 

“In the last part of the trip to 5 regional countries, we came to Nakhchivan so as to review the transit facilities and cooperation in the region after the end of the Nagorno-Karabakh war”, Zarif said upon his arrival.

He also expressed hope that with the cooperation of regional countries and the Islamic Republic of Iran, ever-lasting peace will be brought to the region after the unfortunate war between the Republic of Azerbaijan and Armenia.

RHM/FNA13991111000388

Russia, Turkey Open Monitoring Center for Nagorno-Karabakh

Tasnim News Agency, Iran
Jan 30 2021
  • January, 30, 2021 – 16:04
– Other Media news –

The center, which both countries agreed to set up in November, was officially opened in the Agdam region of Azerbaijan. It will be staffed by up to 60 servicemen each from Turkey and from Russia, the defense ministry said in a statement, Reuters reported.

After six weeks of fighting, Azerbaijan and Armenia signed a Russia-brokered ceasefire for the enclave, which is internationally recognized as part of Azerbaijan but mainly populated by ethnic Armenians.

Turkey said on Friday that one Turkish general and 38 personnel will work at the centre.

The Russian Defense Ministry, quoted by Interfax, said that “monitoring will be carried out through the use of unmanned aerial vehicles as well as the evaluation of data received from other sources”.

Turkey backs Azerbaijan over Nagorno-Karabakh, and has criticized the co-chairs of the OSCE’s so-called Minsk Group for not resolving the long-running conflict in decades of mediation. The Minsk Group is led by the United States, France and Russia.

Russia, Turkey set up joint peacekeeping center in Nagorno-Karabakh

Press TV, Iran
Jan 30 2021

Russia and Turkey have opened a joint center to monitor a ceasefire in the Nagorno-Karabakh region, under a truce that ended six weeks of fighting between Azerbaijan and Armenia over the disputed south Caucasus territory.

The leaders of Azerbaijan, Armenia, and Russia signed a statement on ending the war in Nagorno-Karabakh in November last year.

A memorandum on setting up a joint peacekeeping center by Turkey and Russia was signed later.

The center that was officially opened in the Agdam region of Azerbaijan will be staffed by up to 60 servicemen each from Turkey and from Russia, the Russian Defense Ministry said Saturday.

It said that the center was set up “to collect, summarize and verify information on the observance of the ceasefire and actions that violate the agreements reached by the parties.”

“The control will be carried out through the use of unmanned aerial vehicles and by means of evaluating data received from other sources," the ministry said.

Turkey, an ally to Azerbaijan, said on Friday that one Turkish general and 38 troops will work at the center.

Russia deploys peacekeepers to Nagorno-Karabakh as war draws to close

Russia is deploying peacekeepers to the disputed region of Nagorno-Karabakh following a new ceasefire agreement between Azerbaijan and Armenia.

Russia, which supports Armenia, has already deployed peacekeeper troops as as well as armored personnel carriers and other military equipment last year, to monitor the truce deal there.

Karabakh is internationally recognized as part of Azerbaijan, but it has been held by ethnic Armenian separatists backed by Armenia since 1992, when they broke from Azerbaijan in a war that killed some 30,000 people.

Last year’s fighting, the worst in decades, started in late September and came to an end in mid-November, after Moscow brokered the ceasefire that leaves Baku largely in control of the territory.

Armenia handed over disputed territories to Azerbaijan, back then.

Russian-Turkish center to monitor Nagorno-Karabakh ceasefire opens in Azerbaijan

TASS, Russia
Jan 30 2021
The control will be carried out through the use of unmanned aerial vehicles and by means of evaluating data received from other sources

KIYAMADDINLI /Azerbaijan/. A joint Russian-Turkish center to monitor the ceasefire in the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict zone has opened near the Kiyamanddinli populated locality in Azerbaijan’s Aghdam district.

"The center will collect, summarize and verify information on the observance of the ceasefire and actions that violate the agreements reached by the parties. The control will be carried out through the use of unmanned aerial vehicles and by means of evaluating data received from other sources," the Russian Defense Ministry told reporters on Saturday.

Azerbaijani Defense Minister Zakir Hasanov, Russian Deputy Defense Minister Alexander Fomin and Turkish Deputy Defense Minister Yunus Emre Karaosmanoglu took part in the opening ceremony.

On November 9, 2020, Russian President Vladimir Putin, Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev and Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan signed a joint statement on a complete ceasefire in Nagorno-Karabakh starting from November 10. The Russian leader said the Azerbaijani and Armenian forces would maintain the positions that they had held and Russian peacekeepers would be deployed to the region. A memorandum on setting up a joint Russian-Turkish center to monitor the ceasefire in Nagorno-Karabakh was signed on November 11 following talks between Russian Defense Minister Sergei Shoigu and his Turkish counterpart Hulusi Akar.