TROUT FISHING IN ARMENIA
Institute for War and Peace Reporting, UK
IWPR Caucasus Reporting #733
April 29 2014
Environmentalists see commercial fish farms as latest threat to
By Lilit Arakelyan – Caucasus CRS Issue 733,
Environmentalists in Armenia are alarmed at plans to introduce fish
farming in Lake Sevan, the region’s biggest freshwater resource. They
say the industrial feeding process could cause pollution.
In February, Armenian president Serzh Sargsyan said fish farming was
a government priority because it would create jobs and income.
For Lake Sevan, the plan is to breed large numbers of the endemic
species of lake, using artificial food rich in phosphorus and
nitrogen. There could be nearly 80 fish farms around the lake within
the next ten years. The project’s backers say it will create 5,000
to 6,000 jobs and boost exports.
A dozen environmental groups have written to the president asking
him to block the plans, although that seems unlikely to happen.
Armen Yeganyan, head of the industrial policy department at the economy
ministry, told IWPR that the farmed trout would go to Russia, Ukraine,
Kazakstan and Georgia.
According to Yeganyan, fish enclosures will occupy just 0.03 per
cent of the lake – “one-fiftieth of the international standard”. In
addition, he said, the density of eight kilogrammes of fish per cubic
metre of water was “five times less than the average for caged or
netted fish farms”.
Green activists like Liana Asoyan of the Aarhus Centre dispute the
claim that the impact of commercial fish farming can be contained
“They intend to make money at the cost of water purity, even though
this lake is our reservoir of clean drinking water,” Asoyan told IWPR.
“If they go through with this programme, we’ll end up with a waste
dump full of fish. The water in Lake Sevan will be good for nothing
after it’s had so much artificial feed poured into it,” she said.
In recent years, environmentalists have raised concerns about
successive government programmes, warning of pollution from mining
projects, water supplies blocked behind hydroelectric dams, and
increased volumes being drawn off for irrigation. (See Setback for
Lake Sevan and Greens Take On Hydro-Schemes.)
The latest plan potentially contravenes a law passed in 2001 to
preserve Armenia’s largest lake.
Gagik Tadevosyan, a former member of parliament who helped draft the
law, argues that it is illegal to engage in any kind of commercial
activity that could harm the ecosystem. In the case of fish farming,
he said, “The fish won’t be able to totally absorb all of the nitrogen
and phosphorus feed that will be poured into the lake. The remains
of the feed will sink to the bottom of the lake and form a layer of
chemical waste that will rot and stagnate. The organic elements will
then enter the water.”
Artashes Ziroyan, head of the environment ministry’s bioresources
agency, denied that feeding methods would lead to pollution.
“They will use European, ecologically pure kinds of feed, and these
will not just be dumped into the lake, but added gradually. I am sure
that 98 percent of the feed will be consumed,” he said.
Ziroyan argued that commercial fish breeding would have a positive
effect on the lake’s eco-balance since wild stocks of Sevan trout
were currently badly depleted, but would be replenished as part of
the new scheme. The commercial fish farms would release between five
and ten per cent of their stocks into the wild each year.
He said a final environmental assessment was now being carried out,
and if this was positive, fish farming would start this year.
The government intends to create a Sevan Protection Fund, built
up from a percentage of the revenues from sales of farmed fish and
expected to hit nearly 60 million dollars within a decade.
Inga Zarafyan, head of the Ecolur group, believes the economic
assumptions behind government projections are questionable.
“It isn’t clear whether they’ll have so many fish, or whether prices
will change,” she said. “There’s a high possibility that in such a
large project, fish will start dying, diseases will spread among them,
and medication will need to be bought.”
Lilit Arakelyan works for Araratnews.am in Armenia.