Emigration And "Independence": Realities And Regret In A Remote Vill

EMIGRATION AND “INDEPENDENCE”: REALITIES AND REGRET IN A REMOTE VILLAGE

SOCIETY | 13.09.13 | 14:20

NAZIK ARMENAKYAN
ArmeniaNow

By GAYANE MKRTCHYAN
ArmeniaNow reporter

The aroma of basil and mint blend in the air excites the senses as
the royal purple of basil catches the eye, the cuddled bright green
mint leaves show the way from the garden to the house.

A gray woolen shawl is wrapped tightly around the waist of the
woman in red sweater. Drops of sparkling sweat roll down her face,
her complexion as fair as the snows of Ararat. She tries to stop the
sweat-flood with a sleeve, while constantly stirring the deep-red
dewberry jam cooking on a wooden stove.

Enlarge Photo Greta and Grisha Mnatsakanyans Enlarge Photo

“Blackberry, cornel, 15 kg of honey to each… I send when someone
agrees to take it with them. You know how it feels missing someone?

It’s killing me, if you say more I will start crying,” says 72-year-old
Greta, her fair eyelids turning red as if reflecting the color of
the jam she is cooking, tears mix with the sweat streaming down her
face, as her mind takes her to her sons and grandchildren living,
as she says, ‘in those Moscows…’ for 18 years now.

husband, 76-year-old Grisha Mnatsakanyan puts a dish with just picked
fresh figs on the table and says with stubbornness and rebellion
written all across his face: “No way we are leaving, too. That place
is not fit for living. Whether we are sick or helpless or alone,
we are staying in our house. Our home is here.”

Their home is Syunik, Tchakaten, their small village, giant mountains
and deep gorges, the forest sounds, apples, cornels, blackberry,
medlar…

In Tchakaten, 328 km from Yerevan, silence generates anxiety, gray,
rusty locks on the doors seem to mock or, maybe, miss the house hosts
who have been away for a long time now. Life in Tchakaten is being
somehow dragged like a spiral by the village elders, well aware,
though, that if nobody comes to replace them, the spiral won’t last.

Looking at the Yerevan-Meghri highway crossing this remote village,
Grisha says: “This road is a source of life, of breath; when cars
pass we rejoice, it means humanity is still alive.”

Tchakaten has 45 households and 144 residents. For six years now the
village has not heard the first cry of a newborn baby, for four years
the first bell has not rung at the village school – no first-grades.

“There are around five families left in the village. And they’d leave,
too, if given a chance. In a decade the village will cease to exist,
the elderly are dying. In order to keep the young there must be
micro-workshops producing milk, cheese, clothes, but there aren’t any.

The second most important issue is that there is no irrigation water
here. Thirdly, the whole year long villagers work hard to produce
something, then sell for pennies to resellers, return with nothing,
feeling cheated and resentful,” says village head Artsrun Harutyunyan.

The heartbeat in the village is bound to stop one day, that’s the
inevitable obvious bitter reality here. Still, officials, in this case
Seyran Avetisyan, head of department of regional administration and
republican executive bodies at Syunik local government, assures there
is inflow of people in the villages of Armenia’s southern province.

“There have been inflow of migrants over the recent years, they come
and start businesses. Emigration was the case here in the post-war
period, they left for good and settled elsewhere, not temporarily, say,
for six months of labor. Our small villages are like nursing homes,
because the youth leave for Kajaran (with developing mining industry)
and Kapan (regional center) with higher employment chances,” he says.

Emigration from remote villages of Armenia is like a machine that’s
slowly gaining speed – from Kapan to Yerevan to Moscow. The majority
of those who have left Tchakaten are now in Moscow.

Greta says two families have left the village this September.

“Our neighbors haven’t left, up there Varuzh’s family has not left,
but the others are mostly gone,” says Greta, who has worked as an
accountant for years at the local vocational school for construction,
and points to the lonely houses flanking the village. “I would never
have guessed that we’d be spending our last years in such solitude. I
thought we’d hold our grandchildren’s hands and take them for a walk
in our yard, in our splendid forest.”

The refreshing smell of just brewed mint tea saturates the air. Greta
pours it from an old-fashioned soviet thermos. Grisha brings honey
with bee wax pieces he collected himself, and the ripe figs sitting
in a corner of the table have cracked from pleasure, the honey-sweet
juice drop sparkling in the crack like a morning dew in the sun. Greta
fetches her photo albums and tells about her grandchildren, this way
feeling a bit closer to them.

They are analyzing the recent political developments – the Customs
Union or the European family.

“The factory was functional during the Soviet times. Part of the
production was sent to Kazakhstan, the other part to the Ukraine. They
can’t do it now… they should have treated economy with great care,
whereas recovering a crashed economy is a tough task. Independence
is good, but we are a small nation,” says Grisha.

It’s hard to say whether it is Tchakaten that holds the mountains
in its embrace or it’s the mountains that embrace Tchakaten, so
harmoniously intertwined they seem.

“That high spot is Sal Qar. That part over there, we call it Mtes Khut
(Great Ledge), the other part is Kndzorut, and the forest is our home,”
says Grisha.

Having just met, it is still not easy to leave Greta. Her eyes say
“don’t go; it is so rare to meet new people.” She holds me tight and
says: “Come stay, there is plenty of room in this house, you only
come. Here, write down our telephone number.”

Memories of Tchakaten follow the return to Yerevan: Greta in her red
sweater and metallic ladle, stirring the scarlet jam; her grandchildren
smile at her from a photograph, she asks them questions and responds
in their stead.

“Independence shouldn’t mean being alone, independence has to be while
living with a family, that’s what our state officials should think
about,” she said. “I give away quince, I give figs, I give to those
who don’t have, I do it for free, I give and say ‘take and enjoy’,
my children are not here, let God help them in a foreign land.”

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

http://www.armenianow.com/society/48506/emigration_armenia_syunik_tchakaten_village

Armenian Ruling Party Leadership Signals Unanimous Support For Custo

ARMENIAN RULING PARTY LEADERSHIP SIGNALS UNANIMOUS SUPPORT FOR CUSTOMS UNION

NEWS | 13.09.13 | 12:03

All of about two dozen members of the executive body of the ruling
Republican Party of Armenia (RPA) support the decision to join the
Russia-led Customs Union, spokesman Eduard Sharmazanov said.

Talking to media after the body’s meeting late on Thursday Sharmazanov,
who is one of the leading members of the RPA and also occupies the
post of deputy speaker of parliament, said: “I can’t speak for all
150,000 members of the party, but all members of the executive body
are for joining the Customs Union.”

The RPA spokesman disagreed with opinions that it constitutes a
policy U-turn considering that Armenia has negotiated an Association
Agreement with the European Union for nearly four years before opting
for integration with Russia. He called it a “clear calculation”,
according to RFE/RL’s Armenian Service.

Earlier, the Armenian leadership signaled its readiness also to
continue political dialogue with Brussels as far as it did not run
counter to Yerevan’s commitments regarding the Russia-led union.

http://www.armenianow.com/news/48492/armenia_eu_customs_union_rpa_sharmazanov

Armenia-EU: Seeking Ways Of Continued Partnership Amid Pro-Russian S

ARMENIA-EU: SEEKING WAYS OF CONTINUED PARTNERSHIP AMID PRO-RUSSIAN SLANT

ANALYSIS | 13.09.13 | 10:04

Photolure

By NAIRA HAYRUMYAN
ArmeniaNow correspondent

The first EU backlash over Armenia’s policy U-turn and move towards
Russian integration appears to have been left behind as the sides
have embarked on the way of seeking acceptable forms of cooperation.

After nearly four years of negotiations with the EU regarding the
signing of an Association Agreement with the possibility of creating
a Deep and Comprehensive Free Trade Area (DCFTA) with the 28-nation
bloc, President Serzh Sargsyan declared on September 3 that Armenia
has decided to join the Russia-led Customs Union and later participate
in the formation of a Eurasian economic union.

Officials in Brussels immediately warned that such integration with
Russia is incompatible with DCFTA and also criticized Moscow for
putting pressure on its former Soviet allies, among which are also
Ukraine and Moldova.

Yerevan has been hosting an informal meeting of foreign ministers of
EU Eastern Partnership member states and EU Commission for Enlargement
and European Neighborhood Policy Stefan Fule was scheduled to meet
with President Sargsyan in Yerevan. As Armenian Parliament Speaker
Hovik Abrahamyan said, the meeting would determine the format of
future cooperation between Yerevan and Brussels.

Two days before that, the European Parliament passed a special
resolution condemning Moscow’s pressure on the members of Eastern
Partnership. Ukraine and Moldova, in fact, acknowledge this pressure,
but the Armenian government insists that it is joining the Customs
Union “out of national interests”. Armenia may as well be reserving
the possibility of making a statement about being pressurized and
giving up its plans to enter the Customs Union in future.

European officials have said bluntly that if Armenia joins the Customs
Union, the signing of DCFTA with the EU will become impossible,
since the matter concerns completely different customs systems. This
agreement is a key document in the Association package that Yerevan
and Brussels planned to initial in November.

Now Armenia suggests that it can still initial the Association
Agreement without its economic component, and, apparently, Europe
may agree to such a watered-down version of cooperation not to lose
its ties with Armenia.

It is remarkable that Belarus Foreign Minister Vladimir Makey has
also arrived in Yerevan. Belarus for a long time was de facto out of
the Eastern Partnership process, but after the latest round of trade
war with Russia Minsk began to show a special interest in Europe. And
despite the ‘victories’ of Vladimir Putin in the Syrian issue, there
is more talk in the world about the failure of Russian foreign policy,
including in the former Soviet space.

Armenia in this regard is likely to play for time. Armenian Parliament
Speaker Hovik Abrahamyan yesterday announced the possible dates of
the signing of the Treaty of Accession to the Customs Union – he said
that it could be done in 2014. Abrahamyan also acknowledged that there
is still no final text of the treaty, and it is likely that Armenia
will not accept the text and the parliament will vote against it.

Thus, the Armenian government reserves some room for maneuver for
itself, and Europe may well accept these rules of the game, by
initialing an agreement on political association, using sanctions
against Moscow because of its pressure, forging ahead with the
signing of Association Agreements with Ukraine, Moldova and Georgia
and focusing additional efforts on Armenia.

It is obvious that it won’t work without money here. In case
of Armenia’s signing a Customs Union agreement Moscow promised
investment, which many experts consider amorphous. Moreover, it was
clearly stated that Russia is not going to reduce the price of natural
gas for Armenia. Money is now extremely important for Armenia, which
customarily appears in the ‘social pit’ at the end of every year.

Prime Minister Tigran Sargsyan traveled to China for investments
earlier this week, but China promised only a $16-million grant to
support joint reforms.

Against the backdrop of this situation, the appointment of the date
for a European donors conference for Armenia can play an important
role in terms of Armenia’s decision.

http://www.armenianow.com/commentary/analysis/48479/armenia_eu_customs_union_russia_dcfta

Info Availability Research: Websites Of State Bodies In Armenia Moni

INFO AVAILABILITY RESEARCH: WEBSITES OF STATE BODIES IN ARMENIA MONITORED FOR TRANSPARENCY

HUMAN RIGHTS | 13.09.13 | 09:25

Photolure

By Gohar Abrahamyan
ArmeniaNow reporter

A monitoring of official websites has revealed that the highest
availability of information is ensured by the websites of the Ministry
of Territorial Administration, the Syunik province, as well as the
National Assembly and the Prosecutor-General’s Office. The least
information is available on the official websites of the National
Commission on Television and Radio and the Nuclear Safety Regulatory
Committee.

The Committee to Protect Freedom of Expression (CPFE), which has
conducted the monitoring of websites since 2010, this year conducted
the survey from May 1 to August 15. During this period, using 152
criteria, of which 131 relate to the contents and 21 are technical,
it examined a total of 51 websites.

CPFE Chairman Ashot Melikyan said at a meeting with media on Thursday
that the 51 sites had been divided into three conventional groups, of
which 34 were the sites of ministries and departments, 10 of regional
administrations, and the third group was a general group in which
the websites of state institutions like the president, the National
Assembly, the government, the Constitutional Court, the Prosecutor’s
Office, the Ombudsman and the Yerevan City Hall are included.

“Of the 51, 32 have improved this year compared to the performance
in previous years, but there are still many flaws, which shows that
state bodies are not yet ready for presenting information of public
importance to the public in full,” said Melikyan.

According to the media expert, like it was last year the Ministry of
Territorial Administration remains the leader among the ministries and
departments: improving its showing by 15 percent it has now reached
a 83-percent transparency level.

“The second best institution, the State Migration Service, has
registered the biggest progress, improving by 23 percent. It has
outdone the Ministry of Justice, which is ranked third,” said Melikyan,
adding that the three leaders are followed by a group of institutions
that have managed to pass the 50-percent mark. While this is a pretty
good result, Melikyan says there are still few such websites.

In the bottom of the rating table where websites mainly failed to
reach even a 30-percent transparency level, i.e. posting less than a
third of expected information, the worst performers are the National
Commission on Television and Radio and the State Nuclear Safety
Regulatory Committee.

Melikyan says that eight of the ten regional administration’s
websites have improved, but the performance of the Shirak Regional
Administration’s website has declined and the Lori Regional
Administration’s website has remained almost at the same level. The
Syunik region’s official website still remains the leader.

In the last group, according to the monitoring results, all websites
have improved their work as compared to 2012. Remarkable is progress by
the Yerevan Municipality’s website that has improved by 17 percent,
reaching the level of 54 percent. The best in this group are the
websites of the National Assembly and the Prosecutor’s Office, which
crossed the 50-percent level still last year.

Melikyan said that the data are still considered preliminary, since,
according to their methodology, hereon begins the stage of cooperation
when websites are improved following discussions between state body
representatives and freedom of expression committee experts.

“We do this work not to name and shame, but to make state bodies
feel responsible to the public and publish the information that
is of importance to the public,” said Melikyan, adding that
since 2011 Armenia has been a member of the International Open
Government Partnership initiative where one of the obligations is the
standardization of the contents of state websites. Therefore, he said,
the research may be useful also for the state bodies themselves.

CPFE lawyer Olga Safaryan said that by law state bodies must disclose
information that is of interest to the public.

“Since 2003 Armenia has had a law on freedom of information. Our
monitoring is based on the Armenian legislation, the law requires that
websites be transparent, we just want the law to work in the country,”
said Safaryan.

From: A. Papazian

http://www.armenianow.com/society/human_rights/48473/armenia_monitoring_websites_news

Armenian Government, Leading US Computer Technology Corporation Sign

ARMENIAN GOVERNMENT, LEADING US COMPUTER TECHNOLOGY CORPORATION SIGN MOU

IT AND TELECOM | 13.09.13 | 12:00

Armenian Prime Minister Tigran Sargsyan today received a delegation
led by Alain Blanc, Senior Vice President of the American multinational
computer technology corporation, Oracle.

During the meeting, as reported by the government press office,
Sargsyan said: “The information technology sphere is one of the
priorities of the Armenian government. It annually expands by 15-20
percent. We welcome our emerging cooperation with Oracle and believe
that our bilateral partnership will give a new impetus to further
development of the IT industry in our country.”

The two sides reportedly discussed plans for long-term cooperation
between the Armenian side and the American company in the fields of
innovations, scientific and technological research, as well as issues
related to the application of innovative technologies and solutions
by Oracle on the Armenian market.

Oracle’s Senior Vice President Blanc expressed confidence that the
American company’s entry to the market will be successful, which will,
in turn, stimulate various innovation programs.

Then in the presence of the Armenian prime minister a memorandum of
understanding was signed between the Government of Armenia and Oracle.

The signatories were Chief of Government Chief, Minister Vache
Gabrielyan and Oracle’s Senior Vice President Alain Blanc.

The document envisages support to the development of the IT sector
in Armenia within the framework of the Oracle educational program,
assessment and expansion of the application of Oracle solutions in
state bodies, foundation of the American corporation’s excellence
center in Armenia, etc..

Agreement on cooperation between the Armenian side and Oracle was
reached still on December 7, 2012 during a meeting between Prime
Minister Sargsyan and heads of the American corporation in Frankfurt,
Germany.

The Oracle Company was founded in 1977 in the United States. The
company has more than 390,000 customers and its software products
are presented in more than 145 countries.

From: Baghdasarian

http://www.armenianow.com/economy/it_and_telecom/48488/armenia_government_oracle_mou

Unclear How Joining Customs Union Will Affect Karabakh Issue – ARF

UNCLEAR HOW JOINING CUSTOMS UNION WILL AFFECT KARABAKH ISSUE – ARF

September 13, 2013 | 13:06

YEREVAN. – The arrangements that Armenia and EU had before September
3 are not feasible, since the Customs Union and initialing of the
Association Agreement is incompatible, ARF Dashnaktsutyun MP said.

Armen Rustamyan believes the Armenian authorities are trying to be
smart saying they will continue cooperation with EU and are ready to
sign the agreement.

“I do not rule out that the agreement can be signed, but it will not
be the Association Agreement, which Armenia had to initial in Vilnius.

Europe is cooperating with many countries, for example African states,
and is signing many agreements, but not the Association Agreement,”
Rustamyan told a briefing on Friday.

He also noted that if Armenia has no alternative to the Customs Union,
it is not clear what to expect in the Karabakh peace process.

“It is not clear how Armenia’s joining the Customs Union will affect
settlement of Karabakh conflict, the international recognition of
Karabakh. Nagorno-Karabakh should not remain outside the Customs
Union,” he emphasized.

Photo by Arsen Sargsyan/NEWS.am

News from Armenia – NEWS.am

Prosperous Armenia And ARF Not Going To Join Ruling Coalition

PROSPEROUS ARMENIA AND ARF NOT GOING TO JOIN RULING COALITION

September 13, 2013 | 13:50

YEREVAN. – The reports alleging that Prosperous Armenia will join
the ruling coalition are far from reality, secretary of party’s
faction said.

Naira Zohrabyan assured reporters the issue is off the table.

“We do not have a task to join the ruling coalition,” she told a
briefing in parliament on Friday.

Head of the ARF Dashnaksutyun faction Armen Rustamyan ruled out his
party’s joining the collation, too.

“Appointment of MP Vahan Hovhannisyan to the post of an Armenian
Ambassador to Germany and cooperation with the authorities on
foreign policy issues are not indicating an intention to join ruling
coalition,” he added.

News from Armenia – NEWS.am

France Will Assist Armenia Moves In Direction Of Close Interaction W

FRANCE WILL ASSIST ARMENIA MOVES IN DIRECTION OF CLOSE INTERACTION WITH EU – AMBASSADOR

September 13, 2013 | 12:55

YEREVAN. – Armenia obviously wants to continue cooperation with EU
in all areas and formats, French Ambassador said.

“We are pleased with Armenia’s determination to continue dialogue
with European structures,” Henri Reynaud said during the event in
“L’Alliance francaise d’Armenie” educational center. “We want Armenia
to remain on the EU agenda and encourage Yerevan to further pursue
policy of close interaction with the European Union.”

Ambassador Reynaud noted that Armenia realizes that France will
continue assisting all moves in this direction.

Asked about possible initialing of the Association Agreement, the
French diplomat said: “We shall see.”

Following the talks that were held on September 3 in Moscow between
Armenian and Russian Presidents Serzh Sargsyan and Vladimir Putin,
Sargsyan had announced that Armenia plans to join the Customs Union and
subsequently engage in the formation of the Eurasian Economic Union.

Photo by Arsen Sargsyan/NEWS.am

News from Armenia – NEWS.am

Armenia’s Nuclear Plant Will Operate Until 2026 – Energy Minister

ARMENIA’S NUCLEAR PLANT WILL OPERATE UNTIL 2026 – ENERGY MINISTER

September 13, 2013 | 12:41

YEREVAN. – The activity period of the second energy unit of Armenia’s
Metsamor Nuclear Power Plant (NPP) will be extended until the year
2026.

Energy and Natural Resources Minister Armen Movsisyan noted the
abovementioned during a briefing with news reporters on Friday.

This statement is quite noteworthy in the context that the Government
of Armenia on Friday removed from the agenda the decision on extending
the period for the operation of the NPP.

The aforesaid decision assumed cooperation with the Rosatom Nuclear
Energy State Corporation (Rosatom) of Russia.

To note, the government wishes to extend the period for the operation
of the plant, in parallel with the construction of a new energy unit.

News from Armenia – NEWS.am

EU Wants To Continue Cooperation With Armenia – EU Official

EU WANTS TO CONTINUE COOPERATION WITH ARMENIA – EU OFFICIAL

September 13, 2013 | 12:39

YEREVAN. – In recent years the Eastern Partnership has formed as an
effective interaction format and as a tool for promoting reforms in
the member countries.

The aforesaid was noted Friday during the talk between Edward
Nalbandian, Armenia’s Foreign Affairs Minister, and Helga Schmidt,
Deputy Secretary General for the European Union External Action Service
(EU EAS).

Nalbandian noted that Armenia intends to continue cooperation with
the EU, and Armenian capital city Yerevan’s hosting the meeting of the
FMs of the Eastern Partnership member states is a proof of this fact,
informs the Armenian MFA press service.

Conveying the greetings by Catherine Ashton, EU High Representative
for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy, in turn Schmidt noted that
the EU likewise wishes to continue cooperation with Armenia.

The interlocutors exchanged views on the topical matters that are on
the international agenda.

News from Armenia – NEWS.am