SAUDI SHEIKH GRANTED LAND IN "EMINENT DOMAIN" DEAL
2010/05/17 | 15:16
Feature Stories economy
Sheikh Muhammed Musallami Wants to Bottle Water and Build Hotels
Villagers of Artavaz in the Kotayk Marz have been promised $4,200 for
each hectare of the 96 hectares delineated by the Armenian government
as public domain lands. This works out to 160 AMD per square meter.
Former Artavaz mayor Yervand Naltakyan said that the lands would be
taken from the residents a few days later, even though most don’t
find the terms acceptable.
Artavazr esidents have launched a petition drive and 99% of the land
owners affected have signed. They are now preparing to take their
claims to the courts to appeal the government’s decision.
However, current Artavaz Mayor Rem Hovhannisyan has rejected the
villagers’ claims about the appraisal.
"The villagers are lying", he told us. He said that due to the recent
heavy rains, the appraisers weren’t able to complete their survey
and that no final evaluation was made. This would have to wait for
Mayor Hovhannisyan said that one appraiser named Hrach had visited
the village but that nothing final was done.
When he asked if the villagers wanted to turn over their lands, the
mayor replied, "Some do and some don’t. Some want $10 per square meter,
others want $30 and some just $3."
1.5 hectares of this land in the "prevailing public interest" is
owned by former MP Sasun Mikayelyan, Commander of the Sasun Unit who
was sentenced to eight years in the March 1st "Trial of Seven".
It was back when Andranik Margaryan was prime minister that the
government decided to re-zone 1.5 hectares of Artavaz communal
agricultural land for energy and communications usage in order to
construct a hydro-electric unit and supplemental facilities.
(Government Decision 1610-N, November 9, 2006)
Mr. Mikayelyan’s land is registered as a production facility and he was
planning to construct a hydro-electric station there but it didn’t work
out. At the cabinet meeting on February 25 of this year ( and we have
the transcripts), Economics Minister Nerses Yeritsyan said that the
issue had been discussed at the Ministry for Territorial Administration
and that talks had been conducted with local community representatives.
"There is an overall consensus by the regional and local leaders,"
said Minister Yeritsyan, who added that the project had been presented
to the government as agreed upon.
An Arab Sheikh and a Swiss company
On February 25, the government decided to allocate 85.1 hectares of
land of the Artavaz community in Kotayk Marz containing fresh water
and mineral water springs of the Ulashik River basin to the company
"A&M Rare, Ltd." for the purpose of building a water bottling plant.
"A&M Rare" was founded by "A&M Investment", a company registered
in Luxembourg. The executive director of A&M Rare, Ltd. is Aram
Abrahamyan; the son of Republican Party MP Gagik Abrahamyan, who,
in turn, is the brother of Ara Abrahamyan, president of the Union of
Armenians in Russia and a wealthy entrepreneur to boot.
Hetq sent a letter to the government, requesting the investment
proposal made by the company to build a water bottling plant. We
received a reply from Minister Nerses Yeritsyan.
It turns out that the investment plan was presented to the government
by "Swiss Rare S.A.", a Swiss firm whose president is Saudi Arabian
Sheikh Muhammed Musallami.
He is also a stockholder of the company. Till now, we have been able
to identify only one other Armenian official who owns shares in the
company; MP Gagik Abrahamyan.
The "Swiss Rare" investment company is registered in Geneva and
engages in industrial, agricultural and hotel construction.
According to the minister’s reply, during a visit to Armenia by the
company’s representatives, an interest was expressed in constructing
a bottling plant for fresh and mineral water.
Several sweet and mineral water springs were selected during the
visit and samples were tested by the Swiss laboratory "GEOTEST".
Is Sheikh Musallami building a water bottling plant or a hospital?
In the Sheikh’s notes made during his visit to Armenia, he mentions
an interest in entering the hotel business in the country. Sheikh
Musallami visited Armenia during July of last year.
During his meeting with Economic Monister Yeritsyan, the Sheikh said
that there were several Saudi businessmen who wanted to invest in
Armenia, especially in the hotel and agricultural sectors.
The minister gave an overview of the hotel business in Armenia and
noted that the idea of building world-class hotels in Yerevan and
hotel complexes in the regions was most welcome.
On the same day, Sheikh Musallami weas received by RA Prime Minister
Tigran Sargsyan. MP Gagik Abrahamyan was also present at the meeting.
PM Sargsyan commented that Armenia was keen to improve its commercial
ties with Saudi Arabia and to implement investment projects of mutual
Sheikh Musallami, in turn, told PM Sargsyan that he was interested
in building a hotel complex in Armenia.
We can infer another reason for the Sheikh’s visit from the minutes of
the October 29, 2009 meeting that took place between him and Minister
Yeritsyan, which resulted in a "Letter of Intent" signed by both.
There was no mention of a hotel but rather a plant to be built
Prior to this, in September 2009, the firm "Swiss Rare S.A." presented
an proposal to build the plant to the Ministry of Economics in the
hope of receiving government assistance and backing. The proposal
was debated by the appropriate government agencies and was given the
green light to proceed.
"Swiss Rare" had preliminary delineated about 1,400 hectares of land in
the vicinity of the Ulashik River basin in the north-western section
of the Artavaz community district. Only forty of the hectares had
been envisaged for necessary infrastructure and the plant itself.
The large expanse of te remaining area is explained by the need to
form a buffer zone according to international standards to ensure
the quality of the waters. This are includes state, municipal as
well as private lands zoned for agricultural use, according to the
What investment project is Sheikh Musallami proposing?
According to the "Letter of Intent", the Ministry of Economics assumed
the responsibility on the part of the RA government to assist in the
implementation of the investment project.
"Swiss Rare", for its part, assumed the obligation of realizing the
project in Armenia to buil;d a modern technology plant that would
bottle high quality water to the highest international standards,
that would employ local labor and retrain workers, that would build
adequate facilities for the workers, and that the plant would bottle
40 million liters of water per year.
The target market for the water would be Russia, the European Union
countries and later on, Iran and the Gulf states. The product would
carry the "Rare Water" Armenia brand.
During the government session, Minister Yeritsyan noted that according
to laboratory testing, the water could be bottled without filtration,
using modern technological processes.
The proposal calls for up to $50 million in investment and 50-100
jobs at the plant itself. Minister Yeritsyan hinted that the number
of new jobs created could be much higher.
Minister Yeritsyan also mentioned the possibility of producing bottled
water infused with the fragrance of various botanicals and that this
would create more jobs.
The government attempts to clarify
We will remind readers that "A&M Rare" received state registration
on the very same day that the government passed the "public domain"
decision to allocate the land to the company.
When we asked how it was possible for "A&M Rare" to receive
registration on the same day, Minister Yerisyan replied that by taking
into account the fact that work on the plant had begun back in 2009
and that the company name "A&M Rare" had been registered on February
19, 2010, the government considered it appropriate to recognize "A&M
Rare" as the beneficiary in the decision, since it had, in effect,
already received state registration.
As to the question how the 85.1 hectares specified at the government
session turned into 96 hectares, Minister Yeritsyan replied that
modifications to the original decision had been presented and that
as a result of a review carried out with the participation of the
Kotayk Regional Governor, the RA Real Estate Cadastre and Artavaz
municipal officials, amendments were made resulting in an increase of
certain private holdings to be declared "public domain". The re-edited
decision was then presented to the government for final approval.
It would appear from this reply that the interested parties sat down at
the table and resolved all outstanding issues in a matter of minutes.
>>From the transcripts of the meeting, it becomes clear that the
specific amount of land was 85.1 hectares, but that an issue arose
regarding certain lands belonging to private individuals.
Deputy Prime Minister Armen Gevorgyan, who is also the Minister for
Territorial Administration, proposed that these issues be resolved
and that the proposal be resubmitted to the government so that the
process not be halted.
In this case, the decision of Prime Minister Sargsyan should have
been dated not as February 25, the day of the session, but days later,
when the changes had been made.
The entire issued will only be clarified when we know the identities
of the Sheikh’s other Armenian partners.