PARTY IS OVER FOR ELTON’S FIXER
Robert Mendick
This is London
March 6 2009
UK
A party organiser to the stars has been made bankrupt after being
accused by one of his wealthiest clients of cheating over the bill.
Matthew James arranged events for such celebrities as Sir Elton John,
Kevin Spacey, Elvis Costello and Stella McCartney. But his glittering
business collapsed after he lost a High Court battle over the fees
for a party he organised for one of Britain’s richest men, property
tycoon Rafi Manoukian.
Mr Manoukian withheld the final £200,000 instalment of the £825,000
bill for the party at Sir Elton’s home, unhappy with aspects of
the service and angry that Mr James was making a further £50,000 in
commission from suppliers. DNA Productions sued to recover the money
but found itself on the losing end of a costly High Court battle,
which ended last year.
This week, Mr James was declared bankrupt, unable to pay Mr Manoukian’s
legal costs of about £450,000. DNA Productions (Europe) has also
been wound up. At his home in Earl’s Court, Mr James today said:
"I am no cheat. It’s a complicated matter."
Mr James, 33, a former drama student, made his name organising Sir
Elton’s White Tie and Tiara Ball, held annually at the pop star’s
home in Windsor. These events were increasingly outlandish. At one,
he recreated a scene from an 18th-century French painting during
which staff wore powdered wigs. Mr James even introduced zebras and
giraffes at a safari-themed party.
For Spacey, he designed an airport lounge to celebrate the Hollywood
actor’s tenure at the Old Vic. He also arranged Stella McCartney’s
wedding and a party to celebrate the first anniversary of her fashion
shop. Other celebrities who had sung his company’s praises included
P Diddy, George Michael and the Duchess of York.
But Mr James, who set up his business 10 years ago, came unstuck over
Mr Manoukian’s party in December 2006. The Armenian businessman, said
to be worth up to £250 million, and his wife Jo, 35, a former model,
hired DNA to stage a joint celebration for his 50th birthday and the
christening of their daughter Fimi, now aged four. The party was a
typically extravagant affair. The 200 guests included the couple’s
close friends David and Victoria Beckham, Elizabeth Hurley, Gordon
Ramsay and Elle Macpherson. They drank Dom Perignon champagne, ate
chocolates served in chocolate "glass slippers" and danced on a floor
made out of mirrors.
The court effectively ruled that DNA had grossly overcharged Mr
Manoukian and had routinely concealed the true costs of events to
other clients. MrJames said: "The party seemed to go very well. It
was only afterwards he said he was upset with some of it."
He added: "People’s perceptions of me are always very
over-glorified. We were not some super-slick outfit. We had stumbled
into it. People like Sir Elton were not my friends. They were my
clients."
Mr James’s legal case was not helped by an email, accidentally sent
to Mr Manoukian, which revealed how he hid costs from his clients. The
email, meant for a supplier, said: "When you do quote, could you also
just include 10 per cent commission to us hidden in the quote? We
have to show the client our invoices which is why we need the written
quote and also the commission included."
Mr Justice Evans-Lombe said: "Matthew James accepted it was DNA’s
practice to conceal from its clients that it was receiving commissions
or discounts in addition to an event management fee." DNA went into
voluntary liquidation last year. It was £200,000 short on the party,
and owed about £100,000 to its own lawyers and about £450,000 for Mr
Manoukian’s costs. On Monday in the High Court, Mr Manoukian had Mr
James made personally bankrupt too.
A source close to the case said today: "Matthew James was
double-dipping. He got caught out and has gone bust. He has got just
what he deserved."