ANKARA: Turkey sees negative, positive Sides in EU progress report

Anatolia news agency, Ankara,
27 Sep 06

Turkey sees negative, positive Sides in EU progress report

Ankara, 27 September: "Although we consider the EP [European
Parliament] report unsatisfactory in regard to the positive
contribution that we have expected it to make to our EU process, we
find it important the EP’s efforts to prevent Turkish-EU relations
from being inflicted further harm by removing a part of our
uneasiness regarding with the report," Turkish Ministry of Foreign
Affairs said.

Releasing a statement on Wednesday [27 September], the ministry said:
"We hope that the sensitivity shown by the EP would contribute
positively to the continuation of the process. We appreciate the EP
members exerting efforts in this direction."

Recalling that European Parliament approved today Turkey report – on
the progress that Turkey has made regarding its accession process
since 3 October 3rd – which was prepared by Dutch parliamentarian
Camiel Eurlings, it stated that Turkish authorities have exerted
great efforts since 4 September 2006 to remove factors which did not
comply with the facts of Turkey and which might affect negatively
Turkish-EU relations.

The statement said: "Some of unfavourable components included in the
report have been eliminated. On the other hand, it still has some
elements which don’t have a direct connection with Turkey’s EU
process and which will not contribute to this process. Refusal of the
article which makes recognition of so-called Armenian genocide a
precondition of our membership, and support given to Turkey in its
fight with terrorism by condemning the terrorist organization PKK
[Kurdistan Workers’ Party], and underlining that the target of talks
is full membership, are important. It is also important that Turkey
has a functioning free market economy has been included in EP
documents."

ANKARA: NA passes law on private schools for minorities, foreigners

Anatolia news agency, Ankara,
27 Sep 06

Turkish parliament passes law on private schools for minorities,
foreigners

Ankara, 26 September: The Private Educational Facilities Bill has
been passed into law by the Turkish parliament.

The bill defines minority schools as: "Pre-schools, primary schools
and secondary schools established by the Greek, Armenian and Jewish
minorities, assured by the Treaty of Lausanne, and which are attended
by students of Turkish nationality who are members of their own
minorities."

According to the bill, the term "foreign schools" covers private
schools opened by foreigners.

The terms dershane [privately run education centre], private
education school, drivers licence course, student study and education
centre, private training and rehabilitation centre, international
private teaching institution and distance learning institution are
all separately defined.

Treaty of Lausanne

The "qualities that must be demonstrated" by minority schools covered
by the 23 August 1923 Treaty of Lausanne and Law No 340 will be
defined by a directive. This directive will be drawn up by taking
into consideration the regulations and practices adopted by the
respective countries in these areas. Only the children of Turkish
citizens who are members of their own minorities will be able to
study in these schools.

International schools

Private international education establishments that are outside the
Turkish higher education system and attended only by students of
foreign nationality may be set up by foreign nationality real or
juristic persons or in partnership with Turkish nationals with the
permission of the cabinet in accordance with the Law on Direct
Foreign Investments.

Real persons of Turkish nationality, private law juristic persons or
juristic persons governed by the provisions of private law may set up
private international educational establishment in their own names
for the same purpose.

No teaching or instruction shall be given at these schools that is
counter to the indivisible unity of the country and nation of the
Turkish state, its security or interests, or that runs counter to the
national, moral, humanitarian, spiritual and cultural values of the
Turkish nation.

Foreign schools

Foreign schools may obtain new land with the permission of the
cabinet and increase their capacities by a maximum factor of five.

They may increase or renew the student and equipment capacity of
buildings on existing land by a maximum of one floor with cabinet
permission and providing that the land on which they are built is not
expanded.

Outside of these conditions foreign schools may not expand their
buildings, open branches, construct new buildings in place of
existing buildings, or obtain or lease land for this purpose.
Buildings may be repaired and renovated subject to the permission of
the provincial governor.

The immovable assets of foreign schools may on proposal by the
founders or authorities and with Cabinet permission be transferred
over to the Ministry [of Education] or to foundations set up for the
purposes of education in accordance with the Turkish Civilization
Law.

Assistant principals of foreign schools

The assistant principals who will work at schools opened by
foreigners where the language of instruction is not Turkish must be
Turkish citizens, must be qualified to teach Turkish and Turkish
culture, and will speak the language of instruction. In the event
that nobody with these qualifications can be found, this duty may be
given to teachers of Turkish nationality who have had specialist area
education in the school’s language of instruction.

Additional employment opportunities for teachers

Should the need arise then teachers at state schools may give up to
30 hours a week tuition at private schools. These teachers may only
work at schools with the permission of the institution they actually
work for and on condition that they do not suspend their actual
duties and do complete the requisite number of weekly classroom
hours. These teachers may give paid lessons for up to half the number
of weekly classroom hours they must teach in return for a monthly
wage.

In private educational establishments the job of giving paid lessons
may be given to specialist teachers, expert teachers and to other
civil servants who fulfil the requirements of teaching with the
permission of the pertinent units for a maximum of 10 hours a week.
The provincial governor’s office shall provide permission for
suitably qualified managers, teachers, specialist teachers and expert
teachers. The Provincial Governor’s Office will also be able to
revoke permission.

Teachers’ pay will not be less than state schools

Those working in an administrative or instructional capacity at
private schools will not be given less pay than the monthly wage and
additional social aid payments paid at equivalent state schools in
accordance with the teacher’s seniority (with the exception of
retired teachers).

Additional social aid payments will be paid to school teachers and
staff in accordance with the rights given to school teachers and
staff at state schools under budget laws. Income tax will be taken
from additional payments. The amount of pay for additional lessons at
these institutions will not be less than the amount worked out for
state schools.

Private educational establishments may only advertise and promote
themselves in accordance with their aims. These establishments shall
not make false statements in their advertisements or notices, and
they shall not advertise or broadcast notices on television.

The water, natural gas and electricity bills for these schools shall
be applied at the same rate as for state schools.

Religious education

Private educational establishments that are the same or similar to
military schools, police-affiliated schools and institutions
providing religious education and instruction shall not be opened.

Anybody who wants to open or take over a private school must not have
served more than six months in prison for a disgraceful or
premeditated crime, even if they have been released on amnesty.

Public places such as bars, coffee-houses, card game cafes, video
game arcades, and places where open alcohol beverages are served must
not be located close than 100 meters from school premises.

Education fees

The education and other fees shall be worked out every year by the
institution, and will be notified starting in January but no later
than May.

A directive will state the criteria for determining, allocating,
advertising and collecting fees.

All institutions are obliged to teach a minimum of 3 per cent of
their students for free. The ministry may see this figure rise up to
10 per cent. The percentage of students who will study for free,
their selection and conditions of acceptance will be stated in a
directive. Institutions may also give scholarships. The number of
foreign national students that may be taught in a school must not
exceed 30 per cent of the number of Turkish national students at that
school.

Permission to open

In order for an institution to begin teaching it must receive
permission to open. The relevant national education director’s office
will handle the requests to open. Permission may be given to
institutions outside those schools deemed fit to open following an
inspection by the Provincial Governor’s Office. The requests for
permission to open will be sent to the Ministry for permission to be
given. Should the request to open an institution be rejected by the
Governor’s Office, the founder or their representative may appeal to
the Ministry within 15 working days of the notification of rejection
being received.

The curriculum and weekly lesson programme to be applied at private
educational establishments will be determined in accordance with the
procedures and principles applied at state schools. Different
curricula and weekly lesson programmes may be applied if the Ministry
sees fit.

If no teaching is begun within two years of permission being given to
open a private educational establishment that permission will be
revoked.

If the number of personnel in the regulations are not employed or if
personnel are employed in contravention of the regulations, the
institution may be closed down temporarily for between 15 days and
three months. Any institution not complying with the general and
specific aims and basic principles of the Basic Law for National
Education; any institution that does not close down in accordance
with regulations; any institution that receives a provisional closure
penalty but then repeats the same fault shall be closed down
permanently.

ANKARA: Turk MFA: Impossible to accept Armenian genocide allegations

Anatolia news agency, Ankara,
27 Sep 06

Turkish Foreign Ministry: Impossible to accept Armenian genocide
allegations

Ankara, 28 September: "We are deeply worried about the one-sided
approach of our ally Netherlands’ political parties on so-called
Armenian genocide as this puts a limit on the freedom of expression,"
said Namik Tan, spokesman of the Turkish Foreign Ministry, on
Thursday [28 September].

"It is not possible to accept allegations on so-called Armenian
genocide as historical reality," told Tan.

The candidacy of several individuals of Turkish background were
annulled in the Netherlands as they refused to accept the so-called
Armenian genocide before the upcoming elections on 22 November.

"Turkey has opened all archives, including military ones, so that the
incidents of 1915 can be studied from a scientific perspective.
Turkey offered to establish a committee of historians from both
Turkey and Armenia to study the incidents of 1915," stressed Tan.

Chirac: Peculiar Inner Commonality b/w Armenian and French nations

ARMINFO News Agency, Armenia
September 28, 2006 Thursday

THERE IS SOME PECULIAR INNER COMMONALITY BETWEEN ARMENIAN AND FRENCH
NATIONS: FRENCH PRESIDENT

There is some peculiar inner commonality between the Armenian and
French nations, French President Jacques Chirac says in an interview
to Hayastani Hanrapetoutyun daily (Armenia) on the eve of his visit
to Yerevan.

French-Armenian relations go back from the Crusades when king of
Jerusalem Baldwin of Boulogne married Armenian princess Morphia of
Melitene. Since then both nations have had many ups and down: WWI,
the Armenian Genocide, the collapse of empires, joint fight during
WWII. As a result, the two nations have become much alike. Both are
adherent to indepedence, religion, spiritual wisdom in arts and
culture, both have beautiful and sacred languages.

Chirac says that 500,000 French citizens of Armenian origin have
given France their courage, talent and generosity. At the same time,
they have preserved their ties with Armenia and are actively involved
in thousands of projects for strengthening relations between the two
nations. One such project is French University of Armenia – this is
an exemplary project enjoying support of the French authorities and
French regions and cities with big Armenian communities.

TBILISI: Georgian TV reports arrest of two more spy suspects

Radio 1, Tbilisi,
28 Sep 06

GEORGIAN TV REPORTS ARREST OF TWO MORE SPY SUSPECTS

The Interior Ministry yesterday [27 September] arrested two more
members of Russian intelligence services. Aziz Aslanyan, an ethnic
Armenian citizen of Georgia, born in 1973, was arrested in Batumi.
Ruslan Skrylnikov was arrested in Tbilisi. Both are suspected of
spying.

Another suspect, Zia Samnidze, remains at large.

[In a report at 0401 gmt on 28 September, Interfax news agency
referred to Aslanyan and Skrylnikov as "Russian servicemen".]

Turkey must face up to past, says EU

The Daily Telegraph (LONDON)
September 28, 2006 Thursday

Turkey must face up to past, says EU

David Rennie in Strasbourg

THE European Parliament voted yesterday to tell Turkey it must "face
up to its past”, in the context of the alleged genocide of Armenians
during the First World War, if it wanted EU membership.

MEPs meeting in Strasbourg also agreed to warn Ankara that talks on
EU membership could be frozen unless it opens its ports to Cypriot
ships.

Armenians say that as many as 1.5 million of their ancestors were
killed in a campaign by Ottoman Turks. Turkey disputes the figure by
1.2 million, and says a combination of war, disease, famine and
ethnic conflict were responsible.

The report "stresses that although the recognition of the Armenian
genocide as such is formally not one of the Copenhagen criteria
[setting out conditions for EU membership] it is indispensable for a
country on the road to membership to come to terms with and recognise
its past”.

"Lack of progress” on Turkey opening its ports would have "serious
implications concerning the negotiation process and could even stop
it,” the report said.

The report’s author, Camiel Eurlings, a centre-Right Dutch MEP, said
the Turkish government was heading "toward a cliff”.

The report was immediately rejected by Recep Tayyip Erdogan, the
Turkish prime minister, who said it was "unacceptable” for any extra
conditions to be attached to Turkey’s EU entry.

"You cannot change the rules halfway through the match,” Mr Erdogan
said. "The game has started and the rules are there.”

Earlier this week there was an angry reaction in Turkey to comments
from José Manuel Barroso, the European Commission president, saying
that further enlargement of the EU should wait until member states
agreed to revive major changes to the internal power structures of
the EU, originally contained in the now defunct EU constitution.
From: Baghdasarian

EP report on Turkey tough but fair, says Eurlings

European Report
September 28, 2006

EU/TURKEY : EP REPORT ON TURKEY TOUGH BUT FAIR, SAYS EURLINGS

The European Parliament approved the report on Turkey’s progress
towards EU accession on 27 September by a large majority (429 in
favour, 71 against and 125 abstentions) The final version of this
document is "still tough but more balanced", said rapporteur Camiel
Eurlings (EPP-ED, NL), commenting on the vote.

After a stormy discussion in the EP Foreign Affairs Committee (AFET)
two weeks ago, the report triggered turbulent dispute at the plenary
session on 26 September too. The MEPs were to decide on that day on
the final wording of the report, assessing Turkey’s preparation for
EU accession. The last version of the report, approved by AFET on 4
September, drew strong criticism from most of the political groups in
the Parliament for its "exceptionally critical tone" and "unbalanced
approach". Eurlings’s assessment was harshly criticised also in
Ankara. Commenting on the document, a Turkish Foreign Ministry
spokesman said that "We think that some elements in the report are
written with political motives and without realism and are not in
accordance with the European Parliament’s credibility and
seriousness."

Most controversial for both Ankara and Brussels was Paragraph 49,
which sets the recognition by Turkey of an alleged genocide of
Armenians as a precondition for its full EU membership. Commenting on
this particular paragraph, Camiel Eurlings admitted that it was
adopted against his will. "The Armenian genocide was added as a
precondition for accession at the very last moment. That was against
my will," said the rapporteur in an interview with the Turkish Daily
News on 25 September.

The amendments (80 in total), which were discussed at the plenary
session on 26 September, referred, in particular, to Paragraph 49.
The members of the PES and ALDE Groups intended to delete it. The
ALDE Group also suggested a modification of Paragraph 50 by deleting
its last sentence, which states that Turkey should establish good
relationships with the Greeks of Pontos and the Assyrians to fulfil
EU accession requirements. The ALDE Group tabled in total fourteen
amendments with a general aim to make the report more balanced and
objective. A similar approach was taken by the Socialist Group. They
intended, in particular, to change the wording of paragraphs
referring to the situation of the divided island of Cyprus by
stressing that both "Turkey and Cyprus should undertake new
initiatives to strengthen the ties between the two communities" and
underlining that it is the government of Cyprus which is responsible
for the continuing isolation of northern Cyprus.

The EPP-ED Group, known for its critical attitude towards Turkey’s EU
candidacy, tabled five amendments, including a proposal for a new
paragraph (31 a), referring to the forthcoming visit by Pope Benedict
XVI to Turkey. Taking into consideration recent events after the
Pope’s recent speech, in which he quoted a 14th century Christian
emperor and caused a wave of anger in the Muslim world, including
Turkey, the EPP-ED Group suggested that the report emphasise the hope
that "the visit will contribute to strengthening dialogue between the
Christian and Muslim worlds".

The vote at the EP’s plenary session resulted in "further improvement
of the report", said Eurlings. He expressed his satisfaction that the
Parliament decided to delete Paragraph 49 (322 in favour, 283 against
and 40 abstentions), stressing that there are no extra preconditions
for the accession of Turkey except for those conditions which were
set 13 years ago in Copenhagen. "If Turkey complies with them, it
will become a fully-fledged member of the EU," said Eurlings. He also
strongly defended the final wording of Paragraph 50, saying that it
does not set a new condition but just puts pressure on Turkey to
establish good relations with such minorities as the Greeks of Pontos
and the Assyrians. The MEPs also voted in favour of the new Paragraph
31 a.

Despite the adopted amendments, the report is still very rigorous. It
calls on the government in Ankara to recognise the Republic of
Cyprus, withdraw its forces from the island and lift its embargo on
Cypriot vessels and aircraft. It reminds Turkey that a lack of
progress in implementing the Ankara Protocol "will have serious
implications for the negotiation process, and could even bring it to
a halt". It also calls on "both Greece and Turkey to refrain from
tension-prone military activities". Moreover, the MEPs stressed that
Ankara has to introduce freedom of expression and amend Article 301
of its Penal Code.

Iran energy leader heads to Armenia

UPI Energy
September 28, 2006 Thursday 4:30 PM EST

Iran energy leader heads to Armenia

Iranian Energy Minister Parviz Fattah is set to meet with Armenian
officials Thursday to hold trilateral talks on bolstering energy
projects.

Officials from Iran, Armenia and Georgia will discuss joint border
projects and a bilateral agreement for a supply of electricity to
Armenia, the Islamic Republic News Agency reported.

Fattah said a third of the 230-kilovolt transmission line being set
up by the Iranian Sanir company in Armenia is expected to become
operational by the end of this year.

Electricity networks between the three countries will be linked up in
the near future so Tehran can have greater access to international
networks via Georgia, he said.

7 Azerbaijani soldiers wounded in mine blast near disputed territory

Associated Press Worldstream
September 28, 2006 Thursday 11:03 AM GMT

Officials: 7 Azerbaijani soldiers wounded in mine blast near disputed
territory

A mine blast near the disputed Nagorno-Karabakh territory wounded
seven Azerbaijani soldiers, officials said Thursday.

The explosion occurred in the Agdam region not far from the so-called
line of control separating Azerbaijani and Karabakh forces, federal
de-mining agency spokeswoman Sabina Jalalova told The Associated
Press. She said she could not immediately provide further details.

The Defense Ministry could not be immediately reached for comment.

Local television channels reported the blast took place Wednesday
night and the soldiers have been hospitalized.

Nagorno-Karabakh is a mountainous territory inside Azerbaijan, but it
has been controlled along with some surrounding areas by Karabakh and
Armenian forces since 1994. A shaky cease-fire in 1994 ended the
six-year conflict, in which 30,000 people were killed and about 1
million driven from their homes.

The lack of resolution over Nagorno-Karabakh’s final status has
hampered development in the strategic South Caucasus region.

Turkish report ‘critical but fair’

The Irish Times
September 28, 2006 Thursday

Turkish report ‘critical but fair’

by Tim O’Brien

EU/Strasbourg reports: The European Parliament yesterday adopted a
"critical but fair" assessment of Turkey’s progress towards EU
accession yesterday, in a bid to avert fears that the parliament
would undermine those who are driving reforms in Turkey.

The report by Camiel Eurlings upheld the parliament’s view that the
pace of judicial and social reforms in Turkey has slowed over the
last year. It also expressed the view that negotiations with Turkey
are "open-ended" and that the country should recognise the Republic
of Cyprus and withdraw its forces from the island.

In a dissenting view, Dublin MEP Proinsias de Rossa said the report
was "unbalanced" and warned against driving Turkey away from the EU,
"strengthening the hands of those who oppose reform in Turkey".

Green MEP Joost Lagendijk, who chairs the European Parliament’s
delegation to Turkey, said the report had been "tempered" by a number
of amendments, which were fair but tough. He said recognition of the
Armenian genocide by Turkey should no longer be presented as
precondition for EU accession. Mr Lagendijk maintained this was a
crucial point, claiming it would have strengthened the hands of those
in Turkey opposed to reforms.

In his report Mr Eurlings welcomed some progress in Turkey, including
"the opening of broadcasting in Kurdish" while remaining critical of
the "continued intimidation" of civil society representatives in the
southeast of the country. Also acknowledged was the recent steps in
the fields of combating torture, fighting corruption and extending
women’s rights.

Despite the recent acquittal of novelist Elif Shafak on trial for
allegedly denigrating Turkishness, a number of speakers said they
remained critical of continuing barriers to free speech.

Mr Eurlings defended the criticism of Turkey in his report, saying it
was centred on the main political reforms the EU wishes to see in
place. This sentiment was echoed by the Finnish EU presidency during
the debate. "We share the concerns over reforms," Paula Lehtomaki,
Finnish minister for Europe, said. "Turkey needs to give fresh
impetus to reforms."

"I said that formal recognition of the past is important but not a
criterion. I do hope for Turkish accession and I hope my tough but
fair report will be seen as an encouragement for Turkey."

The parliament agreed not to make recognition of the genocide a
precondition for accession.