TURKEY: JOURNALIST CONVICTED ON CHARGE OF ‘INSULTING TURKISH IDENTITY’
CPJ Press Freedom Online, NY
Oct 13 2005
New York, October 12, 2005-The Committee to Protect Journalists
condemns the conviction of a Turkish-Armenian journalist on a charge
of “insulting and weakening Turkish identity through the media” An
Istanbul court on Friday sentenced Hrant Dink, 52, editor-in-chief of
the bilingual Turkish-Armenian weekly Agos, to a six-month suspended
term. Dink and his lawyer, Fethiye Cetin, plan to appeal.
The charges stemmed from a series of articles Dink wrote in early
2004 dealing with the collective memory of the Armenian massacres of
1915-1917 under the Ottoman Empire. He called on Armenians to move
beyond historical anger toward Turks and “turn to the new blood of
independent Armenia.”
Turkish law, even under recent legal reforms, allows for journalists
to be criminally prosecuted and imprisoned for their work. Dink was
prosecuted under a provision of the new penal code that states:
“A person who insults Turkishness, the Republic, or the Turkish
Parliament will be punished with imprisonment ranging from six months
to three years.” Turkish authorities did not elaborate on what they
considered insulting in Dink’s work.
Dink, who founded Agos in 1996, was sentenced the same week talks
began on Turkey’s application to join the European Union.
“This is a political decision because I wrote about the Armenian
genocide and they detest that, so they found a way to accuse me of
insulting Turks,” Dink told CPJ. He said he is prepared to take the
case to the European Court of Human Rights to clear his name.
Turkey does not acknowledge as genocide the killings of Armenians
by Ottoman Turks at the beginning of the 20th century. The European
Parliament has conditioned Turkey’s entry to the EU on its formal
recognition of the killings as genocide.
“Despite official promises, Turkish journalists continue to be
criminally prosecuted for their work,” CPJ Executive Director Ann
Cooper said. “At the heart of this case are the dozens of laws in
Turkey that can make free expression a crime. Free expression will
remain limited in Turkey as long as these laws are on the books.”
Award-winning Turkish novelist Orhan Pamuk was indicted in September
under the same penal code provision after an interview he gave to
a Swiss magazine earlier this year in which he said, “one million
Armenians were killed in Turkey.” His trial is set for December 17.
Dink faces additional charges for making critical comments at a
2002 human rights conference about Turkey’s national anthem and
a daily oath taken by Turkish schoolchildren in which they say,
“Happy is the one who says, ‘I am a Turk.’ ” Dink said then that he
did not feel like a Turk, but like an Armenian who is a citizen of
Turkey. He will appear in court in February for those remarks.