Reporters without borders, France
May 25 2005
Call for major amendments to new criminal code that threatens press
freedom
Reporters Without Borders said it shared the concerns of Turkish
journalists over threats to press freedom from a new criminal law
that still needed major amendments before coming into force on 1st
June. . Despite revisions voted by parliament after it was adjourned
on 31 March 2005 following strong media protests, the organisation
repeated its call for the removal of prison sentences for press
offences.
“Far from bringing Turkish law into line with European law on freedom
of expression, some articles of the code on the contrary would
facilitate arbitrary legal action against journalists and entailing a
climate of self-censorship damaging to press freedom”, it said.
Several articles of the new code are particularly perilous. Article
305 which punishes acts that go against “fundamental national
interests” by prison sentences of three to ten years, threatens
journalists and the right of the public to be informed. Any claim to
do with the “Armenian genocide” or “withdrawal of Turkish armed
forces in Cyprus” would be considered as against “fundamental
national interests”.
Dozens of journalists have been imprisoned in the past for having
simply expressed their opinion on this type of subject. Turkish
deputies did nevertheless agree to remove paragraph 2 of the article
which set out a 50 % increase in sentences if the offence was
committed via the press.
Article 301 that is to replace 159 has been used in the past to
severely punish any criticism of parliament, the justice system or
the security forces. It will be termed in future “Humiliation of
Turkish identity, the Republic, state institutions and bodies”. It
will allow wide scope for interpretation and threaten anyone
criticising Turkish identity, the state or parliament with a prison
sentence of six months to three years. Any person who attacks the
government, justice system or the security forces moreover faces six
months to two years in prison.
Article 285 threatens with four and half years in prison anyone
“violating the confidentiality of an investigation”. This could be a
serious threat to the right of journalists to protect their sources.
Article 277 punishes anyone trying to “sway the justice system” with
two to four years in prison and potentially puts in danger
journalists covering court proceedings.
Under Article 267 of the new code, defamation in the press with the
aim of exposing someone to a judicial investigation is liable to a
one to four-year prison sentence.
Article 216, formerly 312, punishes with one to three years in prison
“deliberate incitement of a section of the population to hatred and
hostility through discrimination on the basis of race, region or
membership of a religious group, against another section of the
population” that causes “a clear and direct danger to the public”
(paragraph 1).
“Humiliation of a section of the population due to social, religious,
sexual or regional differences” is liable to a sentence of six months
to one year in prison (paragraph 2). “Overt humiliation of a person
because of their religious principles is liable to six months to one
year in prison if the offence threatens social peace” (Paragraph 3).
This “humiliation”, a very vague legal concept, capable of being
interpreted very widely by jurisprudence, directly threatens freedom
of expression both for journalists and for the general public.
This is not an exhaustive list. Turkish journalists and press freedom
organisations see parliamentary amendments drawn up ahead of 1st June
to the version of the code as it was to have been applied on 1st
April, as very inadequate. They consider that only six of the 20
problematic points have been revised Recep Tayyip Erdogan’s
government.