Letter To The International Herald Tribune

LETTER TO THE INTERNATIONAL HERALD TRIBUNE
Rick Jones, Prague
The International Herald Tribune, France
September 10, 2005 Saturday
LETTERS TO THE EDITOR;
Europe in Turkey
Foreign Minister Jack Straw of Britain laid out a very compelling
case for Turkey’s admission to the European Union (“Shift Europe’s
boundary,” Views, Sept. 8).
Not only was Turkey’s long membership in NATO cited, but Turkey’s
recent efforts at making massive internal reform were noted as a
further reason to endorse the country’s bid for EU membership. What
Straw did not address was how EU membership would change Turkey.
In the near past, Turkey’s major cities, like other cities in
the Middle East, were multilingual, multicultural, with competing
religions. Major cities in Turkey were enclaves where foreign culture
ruled the day.
This did not come to pass by accident. It was the result of hundreds
of years of economic development and each non-Turkish group filled
in a gap in the marketplace.
Today, ethnic Turks or integrated minorities who have adopted the
culture dominate all spheres of life. Do Turks realize that one of
the major results of EU membership would be an opening up of Turkey
to foreign influences? Does the average Turkish citizen know that
alternative cultures, religions and languages will set up shop
in Turkey?
A European Turkey will not look like the Turkey we all know today. It
will be less Turkish, more Greek, more Armenian, more French,
more Italian.
On the road to prosperity many Turks will not only be exposed to
strange and foreign cultures but they will be required to accept
them. Are the people of Turkey up for that ?
Istanbul will once again become the cosmopolitan center for Eurasia.
The conservative and family oriented values that are prevalent in
Turkey are likely to come into conflict with modern European culture
in which almost anything goes. This may be a shock.
I fear that the Turkish government has painted a very rosy picture
and left out how Turkey will be transformed into a country that many
citizens would not recognize.

CSTO Chief To Watch Joint Russian-Armenian Drill

CSTO CHIEF TO WATCH JOINT RUSSIAN-ARMENIAN DRILL
ITAR-TASS News Agency
TASS
September 12, 2005 Monday 5:23 AM Eastern Time
Secretary General of the Collective Security Treaty Organization
(CSTO) Nikolai Bordyuzha flew to Armenia on Monday to watch a joint
Russian-Armenian drill, the CSTO’s secretariat told Itar-Tass.
The exercise practices protection and defense of CSTO member-states
by Russian-Armenia units,” Bordyuzha told reporters before flying
to Yerevan.
“Taking part in the military exercise are two motorized rifle
regiments, representing each of the party, as well as support units.
This drill is important for us as an element of combat training,”
he underlined.
Bordyuzha praised Armenia’s contribution to collective security
efforts.
The exercise will take place in Armenia from September 10 throughout
September 13, in line with bilateral accords. It involves Armenian land
troops and Air Force units and units from Russia’s 102nd military base,
the CSTO secretariat said.

Azerbaijan Blaming Again

AZERBAIJAN BLAMING AGAIN
A1+
| 14:40:04 | 12-09-2005 | Politics |
In the session of the UN Combat against drug trafficking sub-committee
which is taking place in September 12-18 in Baku, Azerbaijan is
going to raise the issue of drug trafficking “in the lands captured
by Armenia”.
Head of the State Committee for Combat Against Drug Trafficking,
deputy Prime Minister Ali Hasanov has announced that drug trafficking
puts the political, economic and social stability of the region at
hazard. According to Hasanov, the UN member countries must pay greater
attention to this problem.

ANKARA: Turkey Unwilling To Reach Friendly Settlement On MinorityFou

TURKEY UNWILLING TO REACH FRIENDLY SETTLEMENT ON MINORITY FOUNDATIONS
Anatolia news agency
12 Sep 05
Ankara, 12 September: Turkey has no intention to reach a friendly
settlement agreement at this stage regarding the hearing before the
European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) about real estate held by some
minority foundations, it was reported on Monday [12 September]. The
issue will be debated on 20 September.
Turkish MFA said the ECHR would hear the cases submitted by Yedikule
Surp Pirgic Armenian Hospital Foundation and Fener Greek Boys High
School Foundation, against Turkey.
Sources said MFA requested information, documents and views from
the related institutions pertaining to their allegations, and that
the jurists prepared a document reflecting the views of the Turkish
government.
Sources recalled that ECHR decided to hold a joint hearing on the
two applications, and stated: “Turkey has no intention for a friendly
settlement at this stage.”
The minority foundations claim that articles of the European Convention
on Human Rights about protection of property, anti-discrimination
and on right to a fair judgment, were violated by Turkey.
Related chamber of the ECHR will make its decision at a later date
after listening to the pleas of the lawyers of the foundations and
the Turkish government.

Melal Orchestra To Perform At Persepolis In Late September

MELAL ORCHESTRA TO PERFORM AT PERSEPOLIS IN LATE SEPTEMBER
Payvand, Iran
Sept 12 2005
TEHRAN, Sept. 12 (Mehr News Agency) — Persia’s ancient capital
Persepolis is to host Iran’s Melal Orchestra for a three-night concert
series which will begin on September 28, the Iranian Students News
Agency (ISNA) reported on Monday. The orchestra will perform the
program Anitra’s Dance of the Norwegian composer Edvard Hagerup Grieg
(1843-1907) and some pieces composed by Romanian musician Bela Bartok
as well as the national anthem of Iran during the reign of the Qajar
dynasty king Mozaffar ad-Din Shah, which was composed by a French
musician.
The 85-piece orchestra also plans to perform folk songs of Fars
Province and compositions by Vivaldi, Mozart, and some Iranian
musicians, including Morteza Naydavud and Aref Qazvini.
Conductor Peyman Soltani has also announced that ten Armenian musicians
will accompany the orchestra for the shows.
The program is being held in line with an agreement signed by Soltani
and the Cultural Heritage and Tourism Organization (CHTO).
However, Soltani said in early August that the changes that the CHTO
made to the contract may lead to the cancellation of the group’s
planned concert tour of major Iranian monuments.
According to the original contract, the CHTO had agreed to allocate
15 billion rials for the orchestra’s one-year concert tour and to
arrange the sound, lighting, and filming facilities at the monuments
where the performances were to be held. It had also agreed to pay the
wages of the orchestra and road crew and to cover other expenditures
of the programs.
The CHTO then decided to reduce the funding to 200 million rials for
only the concerts at Persepolis. According to the original agreement,
the CHTO was to purchase half of the tickets for all of the concerts,
but this article has been omitted from the new contract.
The group had been scheduled to continue its tour with shows at the
Chehel Sotun Palace in Isfahan, Ferdowsi’s tomb in Tus, Gonbad-e
Kavus Tower in Golestan Province, El-Goli in Tabriz, Dolatabad Garden
in Yazd, Chogha Zanbil Ziggurat near Shush (Susa), Shazdeh Garden in
Kerman, the ancient site of Ecbatana in Hamedan, and Takht-e Soleiman
in East Azarbaijan.

GB Ambassador To Armenia

GB Ambassador to Armenia
The Times (London)
September 10, 2005, Saturday
Diplomatic appointment
Anthony Cantor has been appointed Ambassador to the Republic of
Armenia, in succession to Miss Thorhilda Abbott-Watt, who will be
transferring to another Diplomatic Service appointment. Mr Cantor,
59, is a former Ambassador in Asuncion and deputy consul-general in
Osaka. He will take up his appointment in January.

Turkey Must Relent

TURKEY MUST RELENT
The Spectator, UK
September 10, 2005
The issue of how best to approach a friend who has badly let you
down is one more commonly dealt with at the back of this magazine,
by our agony aunt on etiquette, Mary Killen. But this week it is one
that needs to be addressed here. Over the past years this magazine
has been a staunch defender of Turkey and its right to join the
European Union, negotiations for which begin on 3 October. We have
praised its economy, its founder-membership of Nato, and condemned
the many Turkophobes within the EU most notably Frits Bolkestein,
the EU internal market commissioner, who last year fatuously claimed
that the liberation of Vienna from the Ottoman Turks in 1683 ‘would
have been in vain’ were Turkey allowed to join the EU.
Our point is that while Turkey is far from a perfect democracy, and
still falls short of the standards we have come to expect of Western
European nations, it is essentially a benign country travelling in
the right direction.
Alone among nations with Muslim majorities, it holds proper elections
and, for the most part, maintains a legal system which Britons would
regard as fair. It has 70 million industrious citizens who are keen
to trade with us on equal terms. Moreover, as we have argued before,
admitting Turkey to the EU would make it perfectly clear that, contrary
to what some imams may say, the West has no desire to suppress Islam,
only the malignant regimes which co-exist with it in the Middle East.
It would be a tragedy, therefore, if Turkish membership of the
EU were to be jeopardised by Turkey’s ugly treatment of its most
prominent novelist, Orhan Pamuk. Last week Mr Pamuk was charged under
Article 301/1 of the Turkish penal code, which makes it an offence to
insult the Republic of Turkey, punishable with between six months’
and three years’ imprisonment increased by a third if the offence
was committed abroad.
Mr Pamuk’s crime was to make reference, in an interview with Swiss
newspaper Tagesanzeiger in February, to Turkey’s ethnic cleansing
of Armenians between 1915 and 1917 and to its ill-treatment of Kurds
since 1984. ‘Thirty thousand Kurds and a million Armenians were killed
in these lands and nobody but me dares to talk about it, ‘ he said.
It goes without saying that jailing people for raising such issues is
unacceptable in a modern democracy. Orhan Pamuk is no traitor. On the
contrary, he is seen in the literary world as a great ambassador for
his homeland, whose work shows a deep love of his country and who has
been able to straddle the gap between East and West. He simply wishes
to be free to discuss a couple of dark episodes in Turkey’s history.
To jail him for doing so would be akin to our own courts sending down
a novelist who dared to mention the Irish potato famine.
To give it some credit, the Turkish government does not entirely deny
that a large number of Armenians came to a sticky end around 1915.
The prime minister, Tayyip Erdogan, recently announced his desire to
establish a commission of historians to judge whether or not genocide
took place. Yet no properly functioning democracy seeks to legislate
in favour of one official version of history.
Rather it tolerates a free market in ideas, knowing full well that
it is lively debate which best ensures that the truth eventually
seeps out.
Orhan Pamuk’s accusations of the scale of Turkish maltreatment of
Armenians and Kurds are supported by eyewitness accounts.
An American diplomat filed a report at the time speaking of Ottoman
soldiers, aided by Kurdish tribesmen, ‘sweeping the countryside,
massacring men, women and children and burning their homes. Babies were
shot in their mothers’ arms, small children were horribly mutilated,
women were stripped and beaten.’ Pamuk’s accusations are supported,
too, by Halil Berktay, a professor at Sabanci University, who puts
the numbers of dead at between 800,000 and one million.
But even if Pamuk’s charges were nonsense, it would be no excuse
for jailing him. A confident nation has no need to suppress free
speech, knowing that anyone who makes false accusations against their
country’s past for political reasons will rapidly be crushed beneath
the weight of counter-evidence. It is very irritating when some
left-wing firebrand pops up blaming the British empire for Aids,
using the tortuous argument that the buggery of black slaves by
their British masters induced Afro-Caribbeans to violent homophobia,
thereby suppressing condom-use in latterday Africa. But to bung them
behind bars? Apart from the abuse of the firebrand’s human rights,
it would merely serve to suggest that Britain had never got over its
loss of empire.
Admittedly, Turkey’s problem over Armenia and the Kurds is not
limited to the government: 80 per cent of respondents to a recent
opinion poll said they could do without EU membership if it meant
having to admit to past genocide. But if Turkey wants to join the EU,
and become a full member of the wider club of Western democracies,
it simply has to face up to its past, and to its present democratic
failings. Article 301/1 of its penal code must go.

Armenian Arms Smuggling Case Transferred To City Court

ARMENIAN ARMS SMUGGLING CASE TRANSFERRED TO CITY COURT
RIA Novosti
September 09, 2005
MOSCOW, September 9 (RIA Novosti) – The case involving Samvel
Avestisyan, accused of smuggling arms from Armenia to sell to the
United Arab Emirates, has been transferred to the city court of
Domodedovo in the Moscow region from the Moscow Region Prosecutor’s
Office.
The press service of the prosecutor’s office said that on March 26,
2005, Avestisyan was arrested in the customs hall of Domodedovo
Airport with 16 devices used in weapons navigation systems.
Avetisyan is accused of entering Russia with equipment that could
be used as means of launching weapons of mass destruction, the press
service said.
“Because such equipment can be used to create the means of launching
weapons of mass destruction, the government has instituted particular
laws for their transport through Russia’s customs borders.”
The accused is currently in custody.

A Russian-Armenian Military Exercise Begins In Armenia

A RUSSIAN-ARMENIAN MILITARY EXERCISE BEGINS IN ARMENIA
Agency WPS
DEFENSE and SECURITY (Russia)
September 9, 2005, Friday
Servicemen of the Russian group of forces in the Trans-Caucasian
region and the Armenian Armed Forces will conduct a joint exercise
on the Bagramyan firing range (Armenia) from September 7-14.
Vladimir Kuparadze, an official representative of the Russian group
of forces, said, “We conduct the exercise within the framework of the
Collective security treaty signed by Russia and Armenia. Russian and
Armenian ground and air units will be involved.”

Estonia, Armenia Start Defense Cooperation

ESTONIA, ARMENIA START DEFENSE COOPERATION
Baltic News Service
September 9, 2005
Estonian Defense Minister Jaak Joeruut and his Armenian counterpart
Serge Sargsyan signed a memorandum of understanding on defense
cooperation between the two countries in Tallinn on Friday.
The ministers spoke about possibilities for cooperation in defense
and developments regarding the NATO Individual Partnership Action
Plan (IPAP) for Armenia, spokespeople for the Estonian Defense
Ministry said.
Within the framework of the IPAP, Armenia is soon about to carry out
a reform of its defense forces. In this respect the country expects to
secure a development similar to that of Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania
and make its defense forces compatible with the standards of NATO
and the European Union, the Armenian minister said.
Sargsyan said Armenia values its participation in the NATO Partnership
for Peace program and the experience gained by participating in
multinational missions in Kosovo and Iraq.
“Estonia welcomes the completion of Armenia’s first IPAP and is
offering Armenia as a NATO partner its help and reform experience in
the implementation of the IPAP,” the Estonian defense minister said.
As part of his stay in Estonia, the Armenian minister of defense
visited the Baltic Defense College in the southern city of Tartu,
meeting with its chief, Lithuanian Brig. Gen. Algis Vaiceliunas.
“In Baltic Defense College we have an excellent example of very good
regional cooperation,” Sargsyan said.
Sargsyan also met in Estonia with the chairman of the parliamentary
national defense committee, Toivo Tootsen.
Armenia wishes to learn from Estonia’s experience, Sargsyan said,
underscoring that a long-time relationship in the former Soviet Union
helped Estonia and Armenia better understand each other.
The Armenian minister backed the Estonian stance that EU membership
talks with Turkey should start already this year.