Immediate Withdrawal, Gradual Status Achievement

IMMEDIATE WITHDRAWAL, GRADUAL STATUS ACHIEVEMENT
By Tatoul Hakobian
AZG Armenian Daily #164
14/09/2005
Karabakh issue
International Crises Group Made Two Reports on Karabakh Regulation
The International Crises Group will make public its first report
“Viewing the Conflict from the Ground” on Wednesday. The second report
“Voices from Negotiations’ Table” will be put out by the end of this
month. Alan Deletroz, the Vice-President of the ICG, and Sabina
Friesner, President of the Caucasus project, held meetings with
Armenian and Azeri authorities these days.
“Seven Armenian and Azeri experts have been working on these two
reports for the last 9 months. Hundreds of interviews were conducted
in Armenia, Nagorno Karabakh and Azerbaijan”, Friesner told a press
conference Monday. Deletroz refused to reveal the names of Armenian and
Artsakhi experts that took part at the preparation of the reports. The
first report, Deletroz said, deals with “current situation in Nagorno
Karabakh, in occupied territories and Azerbaijan”.
Though presenting Armenian and Azerbaijani alternatives of the
conflict settlement, the report leaves no room for the past. It’s
not only neglect to the centuries-long history but also the post-war
period as well. Deletroz said that as a starting point they take the
current status quo. The rights of half a million Armenians who lost
their property in Azerbaijan are not taken into consideration. The
same is true for 170.000 Azeris who left Armenia.
Deletroz and Friesner stated that they keep in touch with the Minsk
Group and are aware of the conflict details. They urge the conflicting
sides to follow the Prague principles. Deletroz thinks that Armenia
should stop inhabiting the territories under its control. The ICG
suggest the following: Armenian forces withdraw from the occupied
territories leaving the status of Nagorno Karabakh to be decided in
10-15 years. Deletroz emphasized that security issues should be the
cornerstone of the regulation. He also explained why the status, being
the key element of the conflict, is set aside for future. Deletroz
said that positions of the sides are far from each other and it is
not likely to bring them together in near future.
“A special status of Nagorno Karabakh” is how Deletroz sees Karabakh’s
future. Deletroz seems to be suggesting that Armenians and Azeris
live together in Karabakh and neighboring territories before the
status is achieved. As evidence of possible peaceful co-existence
of the Armenians and Azeris he indicated the relative peace at the
contact line of Armenian-Azeri and Artsakhi-Azeri borders maintained
without international peacekeepers.
The ICG thinks that the communities representing the conflicting sides
are not ready to accept either of the settlement options that Armenian
and Azeri foreign ministers discuss. ICG thinks it is important that
both peoples are informed about details of peace process. “There is
no way to success for any peace process unless all sides actively
sell this idea to their people”, Deletroz stated.
In mid-July, the ICG organized a closed-door meeting in Tbilisi,
Georgia, with the participation of 10 experts from Azerbaijan, 8 from
Armenia and 2 from Karabakh. The Azeri side not only made discussions
public but also complained of the report. Parliamentarian Gyultekin
Hajiyeva told mass media that the document does not mention “the
fact of occupation and tends to legalizing de facto administration
of Nagorno Karabakh”. “The bill mentions of dangerous proposal of
referendum. That’s why we need to review this document”, she said.
Only the publication of the ICG report will show to what extent
it reflects the real state of things. It should be noted that the
formulations of ICG officials at the press conference were not very
different from those that official Yerevan has been articulating
lately.

Children With Special Needs To Go To Theater

CHILDREN WITH SPECIAL NEEDS TO GO TO THEATER
A1+
|18:38:23 | 13-09-2005 | Politics |
November 15-18 orphans and children with special needs will be given
an opportunity to go to the puppet theater. The fact is that on the
occasion of the 7th anniversary of the theater the administration
has organized 4 charitable performances.
The repertoire will be renewed this year. The Little Prince, The Cat
in Boots and the fairy tales by Hovhannes Tumanyan will be staged. To
note, director of the theater Ruben Babayan says that children enjoy
The Red Cap, Three Little Pigs and The Gold Fish.
Dramas and pantomimes for adults will be also included in the
repertoire soon.
Presently over 300 puppets sent from 17 states are kept in the
theater museum while the puppets of the Armenian masters are used in
the performances.
A book by actor and dramatist Derenik Martirosyan dedicated to
outstanding cultural workers of Armenia will be also dated to the
jubilee of the theater.

New Iranian Military Attache To Armenia Appointed

NEW IRANIAN MILITARY ATTACHE TO ARMENIA APPOINTED
A1+
| 20:20:16 | 13-09-2005 | Official |
Today Secretary of the National Security Council at the RA President,
Defense Minster Serge Sargsyan received Iranian Ambassador to RA
Alireza Haqiqyan and newly appointed military attache, Colonel Bizhan
Hamzeil Hashame.
At the beginning of the meeting the Ambassador conveyed to Serge
Sargsyan the greetings of the Iranian Security Council Secretary and
Defense Minister and expressed hope that the joint programs will be
successfully launched.
Congratulating the newly appointed attache the Defense Minister
thanked Col.
Eshkhifor his activities at the post.

Armenia Obliged Not To Stymie Azerbaijan’s Membership To WTO

ARMENIA OBLIGED NOT TO STYMIE AZERBAIJAN’S MEMBERSHIP TO WTO
AZG Armenian Daily #164
14/09/2005
Neighbors
As far as the Nagorno Karabakh issue is on the agenda of Armenia
and Azerbaijan, Baku will not cooperate with Yerevan within the
frameworks of World Trade Organization, Mediamax agency quoted deputy
foreign minister of Azerbaijan as saying. “It does not contradict
the standards of WTO; besides Armenia assumed an obligation not to
stymie Azerbaijan’s membership to that organization”, deputy minister
Mahmud Mamedkuliyev said. The WTO will solve the issue of Azerbaijan’s
membership not earlier than spring of 2006.
Armenia is a WTO member since 2003.

UN Protecting Human Rights

UN PROTECTING HUMAN RIGHTS
A1+
| 17:51:15 | 13-09-2005 | Official |
Human Rights Defender Larissa Alaverdyan met with members of the UN
mission that arrived in Armenia for discussing the National Action
Plan for Human Rights. International expert of human rights Bill Barker
and regional advisor of the UN Development Program Sergey Sirotkin.
The guests showed interest in the legal situation in Armenia,
constitutional amendments and freedom of speech and press. The
interlocutors also touched upon the place and role of the institute
of ombudsman in the elaboration of the National Action Plan on Human
Rights, potential participation of various state organizations and
choice of key structures in charge for elaboration and implementation
of the Plan. It was emphasized that Armenia is the first country in
the South Caucasian region (including Russia) to start the discussions
over the National Plan.
Bill Barker also noted that the political will of the authorities is
essential for the elaboration and realization of the National Plan
on Human Rights as a priority line of the domestic policy.

‘Colorful Revolutions’ Swallow Prime Ministers

‘COLORFUL REVOLUTIONS’ SWALLOW PRIME MINISTERS
By Tatoul Hakobian
AZG Armenian Daily #164
14/09/2005
Analysis
Yulia Timoshenko, former Prime Minister of Ukraine, was one of
the “lucky” prime ministers who came to power through “a velvet
revolution.” Though she was sacked of her position, she wasn’t killed
or died in suspicious conditions. The velvet revolutions that took
place in various countries during the recent 15 years “swallowed” the
key figures of those revolutions, as a rule. It’s worth representing
several interesting facts without making any comments.
Vazgen Manukian, first Prime Minister of the third Republic of Armenia,
was one of the key figures of All Armenian Movement that struggled
against the Communist Party. After the communists lost power, Levon
Ter-Petrosian and Vazgen Manukian occupied the two key positions of
the newly born republic.
The first became chairman of RA Supreme Council, while the
second became the republics Prime Minister. Vazgen Manukian was
dismissed. The whole power in the republic appeared in the hands of
Levon Ter-Petrosian and his allies.
In 1991, Eduard Shevardnadze seized the power from Zviad Gamsakhurdia
with the help of his allies Jaba Ioseliani, criminal authority,
and Tengiz Kitovani, untalented artist. Soon, Zviad Gamsakhurdia was
killed in the Megrelia woods. Shevardnadze returned to Tbilisi, in
1992. Ioseliani, head of the Armed Forces and Kitovani, representative
of coalition, were dismissed and sent to prison.
In the summer of 1993, Heydar Aliyev, head of Nakhijevan’s Supreme
Council, rebelled against Abulfaz Elchibey and soon his forces entered
Baku. Suret Huseynov, one of Karabakh war participants, was among his
allies and played active part in the rebellion against Elchibey. Aliyev
forget the assistance of Huseynov already next year. Accusing Huseynov
of coup d’etat, Aliyev sent him to the prison.
In late 997 and in early 1998, Levon Ter-Petrosian had to resign
under the pressure of Vazgen Sargsian and the military branch of
the power. Robert Kocharian came to power. In 1999, as a result of
parliamentary elections, Sargsian and Karen Demirchian, his new ally,
won the victory. Sargsian became RA Prime Minister, while Demirchian
was appointed Chairman of Ra National Assembly. In few months, Sargsian
and Demirchian, as well as 6 other high ranked officials and deputies,
were killed in a terrorist act.
Serbian revolution took place in Belgrade, on October 5-6, 2000. Zoran
Djindjic, one of the key figures of the revolution, managed to
seize the power from Slobodan Miloshevic. Next year, Djindjic passed
Miloshevic to the Hague Criminal Court. Zoran Djindjic, Serbian Prime
Minister, was killed in Belgrade, in March, 2003.
Eduard Shevardnadze had to resign as a result of the so-called
“revolution of roses” in November, 2003. Zurab Zhvania, Mikheil
Saakashvili and Nino Burjanadze were the key figures of the
revolution. Saakashvili became the president, while Zhvania was
appointed the Prime Minister. In the February of 2005, Zhvania was
found dead in one of his Tbilisi apartments.

Russian Sailors Released From Nigerian Prison

RUSSIAN SAILORS RELEASED FROM NIGERIAN PRISON
By Petros Keshishian
AZG Armenian Daily #164
14/09/2005
Russia
Azg informed on September 10 that the Nigerian court decided to release
12 Russian sailors charged with smuggling. Our newspaper also cited
the words of Ara Abrahamian, Goodwill Ambassador of UNESCO, who said
that the sailors will be released on Monday and will be waiting for
the final decision of the court at RF Embassy to Nigeria or at the
Russian Trade Office.
RIA agency informed that the court decided to release the Russian
sailors.
“My representative in Nigeria and the new lawyer of the Russian
sailors went to the prison to transfer them to RF Trade Office so
that they can stay there until the court takes its final decision,”
Ara Abrahamian said in his interview to Azg.
Ara Abrahamian who closely cooperates with RF Foreign Ministry
considers the release of the Russian sailors the victory of Russian
diplomats. “No matter what the Nigerian court decided, the final
decision is after the President of Nigeria,” Mr. Abrahamian emphasized.
RF Embassy prepared apartments and all the required furniture for
the stay of the Russian sailors at the RF Trade Office in Lagos.

United States Earmarks $295 Million For Georgia

UNITED STATES EARMARKS $295 MILLION FOR GEORGIA
By Tatoul Hakobian
AZG Armenian Daily #164
14/09/2005
Neighbors
$102 Million of This To Be Spent On Reconstruction of Infrastructures
and Road Network in Javakhk
The US government confirmed September 12 the size of financial
assistance to Georgia within the frameworks of Millennium Challenges. A
press release of the Millennium Challenges Program says that the
$295.3 million for the Georgian government aim at reducing poverty
and spurring economic growth in Georgia.
The greater part of the US financial support, $102.2 million, will
be spent to rebuild infrastructures and roads in Samtskhe-Javakhk
region. The Georgian authorities will assign additional $20 million
from the state budget for the needs of this Armenian-populated
southern region. The roads to be reconstructed are Ninotsminda-Bavra
highway connecting Armenia with Georgia, Akhalkalak-Karzakh,
Akhalkalak-Akhaltskha and Akhaltskha-Tsalka-Tbilisi stretching in
total 245 kms.
$60 million of the sum will be spent on development of various
infrastructures of Georgia, $49.5 million will be spent on
reconstruction of Russia-Armenia gas pipeline, investments in
enterprises out of Tbilisi will demand another $32.5 million and $15
million will go to agriculture, tourism and irrigation water system.
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Loose Association Of Former Soviet States Hasn’t Replaced USSR: They

LOOSE ASSOCIATION OF FORMER SOVIET STATES HASN’T REPLACED USSR: THEY CAN’T EVEN UNITE FOR A COMMON CAUSE
by David Marples, Freelance
Edmonton Journal (Alberta)
September 12, 2005 Monday
Final Edition
Is the CIS dead? The recent summit, held in Kazan, Tatarstan, despite
official publicity making much of an occasion that coincided with
the 1,000th anniversary of the city, provided clear signs that the
association has become practically defunct, and little more than
ceremonial.
The Commonwealth of Independent States was founded in December 1991
by the leaders of three former Soviet republics — Russia, Ukraine
and Belarus — as a means to accelerate the collapse of the Soviet
Union and to ensure that the Soviet president, Mikhail Gorbachev,
was deprived of any meaningful function. At that time Gorbachev had
tried to persuade several republics to sign a document that would have
prolonged the Soviet Union through decentralization while allowing
Moscow to control defence and foreign policy.
The founders of the CIS anticipated that it would be of benefit to the
various republics (the Baltic States never participated) to continue
to maintain close economic and security links.
Initially the informal capital of the CIS was to be Minsk, Belarus.
Yet, from the outset, there were some serious problems. For one thing,
the legal basis of the new organization was never clarified.
The three leaders who had signed the deal had no consent from their
parliaments, and its secretive nature carried all the hallmarks of
a well-laid plot.
Ukraine never accepted formal membership, though it attended meetings
as an observer. The first Russian president, Boris Yeltsin, never
took the organization very seriously, other than during elections,
when he would use the CIS as a symbol of a Russian-led entity in what
he termed the Near Abroad.
As the Russian 14th Army established a breakaway republic at Tiraspol
in Moldova, several states feared that Russia intended to use the
CIS to control its former partners and to establish a new power base.
Other organizations developed outside and parallel to the CIS from
1996, the most serious being the GUUAM, a partnership that received
support from the United States and consisted of countries around
the Black Sea region (Georgia, Uzbekistan, Ukraine, Azerbaijan and
Moldova); the Russia-Belarus Union (Russia and Belarus); and the Common
Economic Space Group (CES — Russia, Belarus, Ukraine and Kazakhstan).
Other states have maintained a preference for bilateral relations
outside these entities.
According to U.S.-based Russian analyst Sergei Blagov, Russian
president Vladimir Putin has veered from supporting the idea of a
“divorce” among CIS states, to promoting greater unity after the 60th
anniversary of Victory Day in Moscow last May.
However, the Kazan summit appeared to make it plain that the CIS will
soon be dissolved. There are several reasons why.
First, Turkmenistan declined to attend the occasion, and its president,
Saparmurat Niyazov, declared that his state would become no more than
an observer in the future. Second, Georgia, one of the more activist
republics under President Mikhail Saakashvili, has initiated the
formation of what is termed a group of “democratic states” on the
border of Russia that would be oriented toward the United States
and the EU in particular. Third, Ukraine under Viktor Yushchenko has
stalled on the signing of 29 documents on the Common Economic Space,
agreeing to only about half of them.
The presence of Ukraine in Kazan at all was something of a surprise.
A meeting between Yushchenko and Belarusian president Alyaksander
Lukashenka produced few results and a proposed exchange of visits to
each other’s capitals failed to materialize.
Other states that might have resolved longstanding issues also failed
to do so, most notably Armenia and Azerbaijan over the disputed
territory of Nagorno-Karabakh; and the Republic of Moldova and its
separatist enclave, the Transdniester Republic.
Though the separation of the CIS states into authoritarian and
democratic regimes is somewhat facile, there is little doubt that
the states that have undergone political changes in recent times
–Ukraine, Kyrgyszstan and Georgia — are perceived by several others
as dangerously subversive, particularly by the virtual dictatorships of
Uzbekistan, Turkmenistan and Kazakhstan, and the genuine dictatorship
in Belarus.
But such states have not found a natural home under Moscow’s influence
either.
Russia indeed remains the most enigmatic of the CIS states, as
Putin appears to have accepted a smaller role on the world stage and
focused more on consolidating his own authority and removing internal
enemies. To date, he has tried to maintain cordial relations with the
United States while increasing his control over parliament and the
media through his security forces. He may thus decline to take steps
to dissuade Turkmenistan from its departure, and other republics are
thus likely to follow.
That still leaves scope for Russia to tighten its links with its
closest allies, Kazakhstan and Belarus, while exerting pressure
on its former closest partner, Ukraine, through economic pressure,
particularly the threat to raise oil and gas prices to world levels.
The CIS served the essential function of legitimizing the rise of
Russia over the Soviet Union, and what was essentially an internal
coup d’etat by former president Yeltsin. But as a loose association
of willing partners, it has failed manifestly to replace the USSR,
or even to unite the former republics in a common cause.
David Marples is a professor of history at the University of Alberta
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

BAKU: Eldar Mahmudov:”National Safety Ministry Won’t Admit Instabili

ELDAR MAHMUDOV: “NATIONAL SAFETY MINISTRY WON’T ADMIT INSTABILITY IN COUNTRY”
Today, Azerbaijan
Sept 13 2005
Eldar Mahmudov, the Azerbaijani National Safety Minister, said that
if the opposition holds any action within law, security bodies will
not hinder them.
As Trend reports, according to Mahmudov, any illegal action of the
opposition will be prevented.
The Ministry will not admit instability on the eve of the parliamentary
elections. It is capable to prevent similar violations.
Mahmudov also informed journalists about the two Armenian citizens
kept in prison. He noted that handing over them to other country was
very difficult and long process. “We’re working in this direction,
hold negotiations with some countries. It is seems to me that positive
solution will be reached in the issue”,- he added.
URL: