Canberra Times Webpage
Aug 6-8 2005
******************************************** *************************
The article about armenian man shot the Pope
Houry Aguilian
Monday, 8 August 2005
Dear Rosslyn,
I wish you would have investigated a little bit more before writing
this article of yours, the man who shot the Pope is turkish not
armenian, and if you know a little bit of history you will know that
Turks and Armenians are 2 enemies till this day. I would suggest you
search the google or any documentary before writing any article, to
avoid such huge mistakes.
Regards
;opinion_id=100894
********************************************************************
Error in Pope John Paul II Article!
Marie Injeyan
Monday, 8 August 2005
Dear Editor,
Recently your paper published an aritcle “Pope shot by Armenian
gunman” (Canberra Times – Australasia; Aug 04, 2005), which
identified the man who attempted to asassinate Pope John Paul II as
an Armenian. This is an undeniable error!! The man who you identify
in your article was a Turk, born January 9, 1958 in Yesiltepe,
Turkey. It pains me, as a Canadian Armenian, to discover such errors
in a reputable paper such as yours. Please correct this statement to
clarify the details of this important moment in history.
Thank you kindly,
Marie Injeyan
Toronto, Canada
;opinion_id=100891
********************************************************************
Mehmet the Armenian
John Avedian
Monday, 8 August 2005
Dear Editor,
A journalist at your esteemed organization, Ms. Rosyln Beeby made a
very critical error in her August 4th article “Pope shot by Armenian
gunman”. The Gunman Mr. Mehmet Ali Agcam is, has been, and always
will be Turkish in origin, blood and citizenship. Armenians, as well
as Bugarians, Serbs, Macedonians and Greeks were second class
citizens in the Ottoman Empire. As the first Christian nation in the
world in 301 c.e. Armenians have always been victims of Turkish
brutality, culminating in the Armenian Genocide of 1915 in which
1,500,000 Armenians perished, 8 of whom were my relatives.
Recently, Pope John Paul II was in Armenia celebrating the 1700
anniversary of Christianity (2001) and visiting a dear friend of his
at Holy Etchmiadzin, Armenia – his Holiness Catholicos of all
Armenians – Garekin II.
Even the most elementary research (such as a google query) would have
presented Ms. Beeby with a wealth of information attesting to Mehmet
Ali Agcam’s Turkish identity.
By overlooking a most standard form of journalistic integrity, Ms.
Beeby has deeply concerned our Armenian Communities in Lansing, MI
and abroad.
We expect an explanation and an apology.
Regards,
John Avedian
Armenian Community Leader
Michigan State University
Lansing, Michigan
;opinion_id=100889
********************************************************************
“Pope shot by Armenian gunman”
Joe
Sunday, 7 August 2005
Could you please provide a piece of evidence or a proof how can a
person by the name of “Mehmet Ali Agca” can be an Armenian?
How could you publish such a piece of garbage?
;opinion_id=100849
********************************************************************
Amernian error
Ron Boyadjian
Sunday, 7 August 2005
I wonder how the editor of a famous (?) paper can avoid such error.
It’s a obligation to write in your same editorial page to correct
your professional error and say that Ali Akca is nothing but a muslim
turk, may be closer to Australians than to Armenians, because all
Armenians are christians, but not all Australians. This country
collect more and more muslims and give them australian nationality,
unfortunately as they do in Europe and North America !!!
;opinion_id=100846
********************************************************************
Have your say
B.Batmanian
Sunday, 7 August 2005
Rosslyn Beeby needs to replenish her knowledge of history and change
the sources of her informations before making any elementary and
serious mistakes in her articles.
Your paper owes an apology to Armenians concerning this matter.
Regards
;opinion_id=100845
********************************************************************
Not an Armenian
Caroline Simon
Sunday, 7 August 2005
Regarding your article “Pope shot by Armenian gunman”
The gunman was a Muslim Turk. The name ” Mehmet Ali Agca” is a Muslim
name. Armenians are Christians. How many Christians do you know that
go by “Ali”? Your editors can’t distinguish between the two? The
gunman had absolutely no Armenian ancestry. This is a horrible
mistake to make!
;opinion_id=100843
********************************************************************
No Armenian
Artin Arzoumanian, MD
Saturday, 6 August 2005
In your August 4, 2005 issue, the article “Pope shot by Armenian
gunman” raises a serious concern about the integrity of your
columnist Rosslyn Beeby. Even the simplest layman anywhere in the
world would know that a Turkish born man named Mehmet Ali Agcam
cannot be an Armenian, let alone the journalist of a prestigeous
paper in a civilized country. But the disturbing question is, why
does Ms. Beeby bring up now the subject of the late Pope John Paul
II’s shooting incident 24 years later? What is the occasion? If this
is a new discovery, what is the evidence? Who is behind this blatant
racist remark?
Artin Arzoumanian, MD
Montreal, Canada
;opinion_id=100841
********************************************************************
Outrageous Armenian claim
Seb Z Tashjian
Saturday, 6 August 2005
Your article:Pope shot by Armenian gunman of 4 Aug.05
Dear editor,
How can a renowned paper such as yours print such an outragious and
offending article. Beeby should have done her homework much better
and how come this article was passed through the editing section?
Mehmet Ali Agca is a Turk and not a christian Armenian. His name is
screaming that he is a muslim. Please correct this article asap and
print an apology to the Armenians.
Awaiting your correction,
;opinion_id=100837
********************************************************************
ignorant correspondent
ARPIE MARGORIAN
Saturday, 6 August 2005
Dear Editor:
Re: article “Pope shot by Armenian gunman” by Rosslyn Beeby (Aug 4).
How can your correspondent be so ignorant? She does not know the
difference between a Turk an Armenian? For your correspondent’s and
your readers’ information Mehmet Ali Agca is a Muslim name. Mehmet is
the Turkish equivalent name of Mohammad , the prophet of all Moslems.
Not exactly a Christian name. Is it?
Again for your and your readers’ information
Armenia was the first nation in the world to adopt Christianity in
301 A.D. and no
Armenian child is named Mehmet or Mohammad.
You owe an apology to all Armenians who are outraged by this
disgraceful error .
Arpie Margorian
;opinion_id=100833
********************************************************************
Pope shot by Armenian gunman
Arsen Kalaidjian
Saturday, 6 August 2005
Yes, everyone knows that Armenians shot JF Kennedy, crucified Jesus
Christ, genocided 1500000 turks and shot John Paul II
;opinion_id=100831
********************************************************************
Armenian or Turk? know your facts!!
Vartex Nicolian
Saturday, 6 August 2005
We’re still waiting for a public apology by The Canberra Times to
Armenians for the article about Pope’s assassination attempt, and an
acknowledgement about the shameful error on the publication.
;opinion_id=100828
********************************************************************
Armenian disgrace
Maria Boyadjian
Saturday, 6 August 2005
In reference to your article “Pope shot by Armenian gunman”, any
decent journalist would have checked the facts before printing such
an important information….
Armenians cannot be called Mehmet or Ali…
This journalist is a disgrace to her profession…. I wonder what
would her professor say….
;opinion_id=100814
********************************************************************
Congratulations
Marc MARDIROSSIAN
Saturday, 6 August 2005
I would like to congratulate you for your article about the
assasination attempt of the Pope by an Armenian.
“Pope shot by Armenian gunman”
We must never forget this kind of teachery by people from a country
that pretends being the first christian country of the world.
regards
Marc Mardirossian
;opinion_id=100811
********************************************************************
Armenian mistake
Kiffer Louise
Saturday, 6 August 2005
There is a big mistake in your article “Pope shot by Armenian gunman”
Australasia Aug. 4th 2005
Mehmed Ali Agca was not Armenian.
He was Australian, everybody
will know that.
;opinion_id=100808
********************************************************************
A grevious error!
Dennis R. Papazian, Ph.D.
Saturday, 6 August 2005
On August 4, 2005, your esteemed newspaper published an article by
Roslyn Beeby carrying the libelous title, “Pope Shot by Armenian
Gunman.”
A modicum of research would show Ms. Beeby that Mehmet Ali Agca was a
Turkish national and a Turkish citizen. All contemporary reports
presented that factual information.
Mehmet Ali Agca is a Turk and a Muslim. He is not Armenian nor is he
a Christian. 99.999% of Armenian are Christians, and 99.9% of Turks
are Muslims.
The editor who let this grevous error remain in the story owes the
public a correction, and Ms. Beeby owes Armenians an apology!
Sincerely,
Dennis R. Papazian, Ph.D.
Professor of History
Director, Armenian Research Center, The University of Michigan,
Dearborn.
;opinion_id=100805
********************************************************************
Article: Armenian Shot The Pope
Albert Peltekian
Saturday, 6 August 2005
In your August 4, 2005 issue you have a ridiculous article that the
man who shote Pope Paul II was an Armenian.
Armenians became Christians in 301 AD and the name Mehmet is a
derivative of the name Mohammed, the prophet of Islam. No Armenian
could carry two distinctive moslem names, “mehmet” and “Ali”. The
whole World knows that Mehmet Ali Agca is Turkish, but the exception
seems to be your own journalists.
Please correct the mistake; an apology to the Armenian people would
be quite in order.
;opinion_id=100804
********************************************************************
Respect to your readers demands journalistic integrity
Dickran Malatjalian
Friday, 5 August 2005
In the story “Pope shot by Armenian gunman”, Canberra Times, August
4, 2005, your reporter rosslyn.beeby made a serious error by
identifying Mehmet Ali Agca as an Armenian. You owe it to your
readers to publish informed and accurate facts. The names “Mehmet”
and “Ali” are Islamic names pure and simple. Armenians are
Christians, and they have been so since Armenia became the first
nation to adopt Christianity as the official state religion in 301
AD. No Christian, whether Armenian, Australian, Italian, or Lebanese,
would use the names “Mehmet Ali”. Memhet Ali had been identified as a
Turk ever since the incident with the Pope John Paul II.
“rossyln.beeby” is the first and only person to erroneously referred
to him as “Armenian”. This might have been be a simple ignorance on
her part, but it might also have been a malicious act to discredit
Armenians. Ignorance is not an excuse for lack of journalistic
integrity, and if for any reason she dislikes Armenians please make
sure not use your media to disseminate falsehoods against them.
Dickran Malatjalian, MD
Halifax, Nova Scotia,
Canada.
;opinion_id=100799
ANKARA: Armenian Participant: Turkey Much Different To What I Heard
Turkish Press
Sept 14 2005
Armenian Participant Sarkisian: Turkey Is Much Different Compared To
What I Heard
EDIRNE – Young women from 22 countries are rehearsing and getting
ready to compete in the ”First Edirne International Peace &
Friendship Beauty Contest” which will take place on September 16th.
Culture & Art Consultant of the city of Edirne Serdar Iyiiz has
informed AA that his city will be sending messages of peace to the
world on September 16th.
”China is participating in a Turkish beauty contest for the first
time in history. At a time when relations between Turkey and Armenia
are cold, we have an Armenian contender Suzanna Sarkisian in the
contest. Edine Demirovic of Bosnia-Herzegovina and Jelena Pejic of
Serbia-Montenegro have become good friends during the rehearsals,”
noted Iyiiz.
Armenian Sarkisian commented that she found Turkey much different
compared to what she had heard in Armenia. ”I am in Turkey for the
first time. I had heard that all women in Turkey wear headscarves and
use black veils. However, I found both women and men in Turkey to be
very modern,” expressed Sarkisian.
Antelias: WCC Exec Urges Churches to Exercise “Unique Potential”
PRESS RELEASE
Catholicosate of Cilicia
Communication and Information Department
Contact: V.Rev.Fr. Krikor Chiftjian, Communications Officer
Tel: (04) 410001, 410003
Fax: (04) 419724
E- mail: [email protected]
Web:
PO Box 70 317
Antelias-Lebanon
Armenian version:
WCC EXECUTIVE URGES CHURCHES TO EXERCISE “UNIQUE POTENTIAL” FOR PEACE
WCC, 16/09/2005
Full text of WCC public statements available, see below
Churches must take responsibility to nurture healing in broken societies and
to promote peace, urged leaders of the World Council of Churches (WCC) in
public statements on Haiti and small arms released today.
The 25-member WCC executive committee was meeting at the WCC’s Bossey
Ecumenical Institute, near Geneva, 13-16 September 2005, in its last full
meeting prior to the WCC 9th Assembly in 2006.
> A public voice against gun violence
In a statement on small arms and light weapons, the WCC executive committee
urged churches to exercise their “unique potential” to curb demand for guns
and “to affirm God’s vision of life in peace and fullness” by “changing
public attitudes, shaping community values and becoming a public voice
against gun violence.”
Small arms are used in the vast majority of the estimated 350,000 of the
world’s deaths by violence annually. In 2006, the WCC will lead an
ecumenical delegation at the United Nations Small Arms Review Conference.
> New social contract for Haiti
Referring to the critical situation in Haiti, the committee acknowledged the
“enormous challenges faced by the people and the witness of the churches in
the country”. It also underlined its “concern for the current unstable
political situation”, as well as the extreme poverty, violence and human
suffering experienced by the population.
The committee asked member churches to express solidarity and to support
churches in Haiti to develop a monitoring team during forthcoming elections.
Churches are called to “support processes towards genuine popular
participation and a new social contract” for the benefit of all, the
statement says.
The committee called on the churches in Haiti to “intensify ecumenical
initiatives” for justice, peace and reconciliation. The WCC has closely
followed developments in Haiti in recent years and has led ecumenical
efforts for mediation and healing in the divided society. The WCC general
secretary Rev. Dr Samuel Kobia met with church and political authorities in
Haiti in August 2005.
> Hurricane Katrina: the vulnerability of power
In his report to the committee, Kobia commented on the consequences of
Hurricane Katrina, which ravaged the southern USA in early September. “The
disaster has provoked widespread expressions of compassion and solidarity
among churches worldwide,” Kobia stated. “It also exposes profound weakneses
and wounds in American society, and pertinent questions of racism, poverty
and the impact of global warming, that need to be addressed with urgency and
determination. The disaster confronts us with the vulnerability of power,
and should challenge states to shift policies and reconsider international
relationships.”
> WCC programme and Assembly matters
The committee reviewed the Council’s programmatic work in 2005, and
evaluated major initiatives in the areas of mission and interreligious
dialogue. It also welcomed a continued stabilization in the financial
situation of the organization. Among key actions agreed by the executive
committee:
> WCC 9th Assembly
The executive committee finalized arrangements for the WCC 9th Assembly, to
be held in Porto Alegre, Brazil in February 2006. The committee confirmed
nominations made by member churches and reviewed plans for the agenda,
leadership and organization of the event, which is expected to gather over
3,000 church and ecumenical representatives from all regions.
Alongside work on themes such as church unity, economic justice and
overcoming violence, the committee proposed that the Assembly delegates also
focus on international issues, including the responsibility to protect, UN
reform, Latin America, and nuclear non-proliferation.
> Membership
The executive committee recommended that the Lao Evangelical Church, the
first from this country, be accepted for membership by the WCC central
committee in 2006. Six other applications for membership will also be
processed after the Assembly.
The committee supported the application of a series of church agencies and
organizations to be recognized by the central committee as “specialized
ministries in working relationship with the WCC” under new rules taking
effect in 2006.
> Alliance for development
Plans for a new global ecumenical platform for development, involving the
WCC, were affirmed, and greater consultation and information-sharing within
the WCC constituency was encouraged.
Concluding the meeting of the executive committee, the general secretary
expressed his thanks to the officers and members of the committee, and
particularly to the moderator Catholicos Aram I, for his “wise counsel,
theological depth and grasp of global issues,” which guided the Council over
the last seven years.
The full text of the statement on Small Arms and Light Weapons:
The full text of the statement on Haiti:
tml
##
The Armenian Catholicosate of Cilicia is one of the two Catholicosates of
the Armenian Orthodox Church. For detailed information about the Ecumenical
activities of the Cilician Catholicosate, you may refer to the web page of
the Catholicosate, The Cilician Catholicosate, the
administrative center of the church is located in Antelias, Lebanon.
Dutch Daily: U.S. must recognise Armenian Genocide
NRC HANDELSBLAD
Dutch daily Newspaper
16 September 2005
‘U.S. must recognise Armenian Genocide’
WASHINGTON, 16 SEPT. Over the strong objections of the US government, a
congressional panel yesterday endorsed a resolution calling the President to
recognise the deaths of 1.5 million Armenians during their violent
deportation by Ottoman Empire as Genocide.
This is a very sensitive issue in the relations with Turkey, an important
strategic ally of the United States.
The House of Representatives’ International Relations Committee voted 35-11
to approve a resolution calling on Turkey to acknowledge the culpability of
its predecessor state, the Ottoman Empire in the 1915-1923 killings. A
second resolution passed 40-7, calling for the President to recognise the
deaths as Genocide and for U.S. foreign policy to reflect an understanding
of the Armenian Genocide.
Armenians say that Ottoman Turks caused the deaths of Armenians in a planned
Genocide. Turkey says that not 1.5 million, but at most 300,000 Armenians
were killed or displaced in civil unrest during the collapse of the Ottoman
Empire.
The State Department sent a letter to committee members saying the debate
“could damage U.S.-Turkish relations and could undermine progress by Ankara
and Yerevan (Armenia) as they begin quiet talks to address the issue and
look to the future.”
The sponsor of the first resolution, Democratic Rep. Adam Schiff, said he
was sensitive to Turkey’s importance and that he considers it an ally of the
United States. But “that alliance cannot be used as a tool to escape from
the past no matter how uncomfortable that past is.” Rep. Tom Lantos, the
panel’s top Democrat, said he was supporting the resolution to punish Turkey
for its refusal in 2003 to allow U.S. troops to open a second front in the
war against Iraq. He said Turkey needed to show more solidarity with the
United States. (AP)
His Holiness Congratulates Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak
PRESS RELEASE
Mother See of Holy Etchmiadzin, Information Services
Address: Vagharshapat, Republic of Armenia
Contact: Rev. Fr. Ktrij Devejian
Tel: (374 10) 517 163
Fax: (374 10) 517 301
E-Mail: [email protected]
September 16, 2005
His Holiness Congratulates Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak
On September 15, His Holiness Karekin II, Supreme Patriarch and Catholicos
of All Armenians, sent a congratulatory letter to His Excellency Mohammed
Hosni Mubarak on the occasion of his re-election as President of the Arab
Republic of Egypt.
In the letter, His Holiness praised the developing ties between the newly
independent Republic of Armenia and the Arab Republic of Egypt and confirmed
that the relationship benefited not only the two countries, but the entire
region as well. The Pontiff of All Armenians also expressed his
appreciation on behalf of the Armenian people to the president and the
authorities of the government of Egypt for their caring and kind attitude
towards the Armenian people, who for decades have been the worthy and honest
citizens of Egypt, working alongside their neighbors to create a progressing
and modern country.
His Holiness concluded the letter asking God to grant peace and
reconciliation to all nations and all peoples, and to reinforce the
friendship and solidarity between the Armenian and Egyptian peoples.
##
ANKARA: Religions, civilizations to meet in Hatay in late September
anasayfa
17 Sept 2005
Religions, civilizations to meet in Turkish city of Hatay in late September
The eyes of the world will turn to the Turkish city of Hatay from September
25-30, when religious leaders of five different faiths come together there
for a Meeting of Civilizations. Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan, who
will officially open up the meeting, is expected to make a call for an
“international platform against global terrorism.”
An invitation to the Meeting of Civilizations was issued to Pope Benedict
XVI by the Foreign Ministry, and though the Pope himself will not be
attending, the Vatican is sending four high ranking members to the event. A
variety of other religious leaders are also expected to attend, including
Armenian Patriarch Mesrob Mutafian, Greek Orthodox Patriarch Bartholomeus,
Syrian Orthodox Patriarch Ignatius Zekka Ayyvaz, and Turkish Jewish
community leader Silvio Ovadio.
The Turkish Foreign Ministry is giving active support to the Meeting of
Civilizations, hoping among other things that it will have a positive effect
in the days leading up to the October 3 start to EU accession talks.
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress
Schedule of the Istanbul Conference [Sept. 23-24-25,2005]
Ottoman Armenians during the Demise of the Empire:
Issues of Democracy and Scientific Responsibility
23 – 24 – 25 September 2005
Boðaziçi University
Garanti Cultural Center
Ayhan Þahenk Conference Room
Organizing Committee
Murat Belge (Professor and Chair, Bilgi University Department of
Comparative Literature),
Halil Berktay (Associate Professor and Coordinator, Sabancý University
History Program),
Selim Deringil (Professor and Chair, Boðaziçi University History
Department),
Edhem Eldem (Professor, Boðaziçi University History Department),
Çaðlar Keyder (Professor, Boðaziçi University Sociology Department),
Cemil Koçak (Associate Professor, Sabancý University History Program),
Nükhet Sirman (Professor, Boðaziçi University Sociology Department)
Akþin Somel (Assistant Professor, Sabancý University History Program)
Advisory Committee
Fikret Adanýr (Professor, Bochum Ruhr University, Germany)
Engin Akarlý (Professor, Brown University, USA),
Taner Akçam (Associate Professor, University of Minnesota, USA),
Ayhan Aktar (Professor, Marmara University),
Þeyla Benhabib (Professor, Yale University, USA),
Üstün Ergüder (Professor and Director, Sabancý University, Ýstanbul
Policy Center),
Fatma Müge Göçek (Associate Professor, University of Michigan, USA)
Nilüfer Göle (Professor, Ecole des Hautes Etudes en Sciences Sociales,
France),
Cemal Kafadar (Professor, Harvard University, USA),
Metin Kunt (Professor, Sabancý University),
Þerif Mardin (Professor, Sabancý University),
Oktay Özel (Assistant Professor, Bilkent University),
Ýlhan Tekeli (Professor, Middle East Technical University),
Mete Tunçay (Professor, Bilgi University),
Stefan Yerasimos (Professor, Paris VIII University, France)
23 September Friday
Registration 08:30 a.m.
Opening Statements 09:15
Selim Deringil (Boðaziçi University History Department Chair)
Session 1 09:30-10:40
A Collective View of the Issues
Þerif Mardin
Session Chair
Halil Berktay
What Does the Official Narrative Comprise?
Selim Deringil
Archives and the Armenian Question: ‘Grabbing the Document by the Throat’
Murat Belge
The Armenian Problem from the Standpoint of Democracy
Coffee Break 10:40-11:10
Session 2 11:10-13:00
Differences in Knowledge and Perception between Turkey and the World
Üstün Ergüder
Session Chair
Osman Köker
Armenian Presence in the Ottoman State before the Deportation
Fikret Adanýr
Massacre, Genocide and the Historical Profession
Fatma Müge Göçek
What the World Knows but Turkey Does Not:
The Chicago-Salzburg Turkish-Armenian Workshop Process as an
Accumulation of Knowledge
Nazan Maksudyan
The 1915-1916 Events according to the Historians of the 20th century and
the world
Lunch 13:00-14:00
Session 3. 14:00-15:40
The ‘Old Order’ before the Balkan Wars
Hakan Erdem
Session Chair
Akþin Somel
Armenian Schools and the Regime of Abdülhamid (1876-1908)
Oktay Özel
Locals, Refugees and non-Muslims: some observations on the boundaries
of social harmony in the Black Sea Region during the late Ottoman period
Edhem Eldem
The Istanbul Armenian Incidents of 1895-96
Meltem Toksöz
Adana Armenians and the 1909 “Disturbance”
Coffee Break 15:40-16:10
Session 4. 16:10-18:00
The Point of Rupture: 1912-1915
Mete Tunçay
Session Chair
Stefan Yerasimos
Approaching
1915: Armenian Autonomy and the Zeytun and Van Incidents
Nesim Þeker
The Armenian Question and ‘Demographic Engineering’
Rober Koptaþ
The Unionist-Dashnak Negotiations and the 1914 Armenian Reform from
the pens of Krikor Zohrab, Vahan Papazyan and Karekin Pastýrmacýyan
Elif Þafak
Zabel Yesayan and the list of ‘marked Armenian intellectuals’
24 September 2005 Saturday
Registration 09:00
Session 5. 09:30-11:00
The Deportation and its Aftermath
Taha Parla
Session Chair
Fuat Dündar
The
Settlement Policy of the Union and Progress (1913-1918)
Taner Akçam
The Intent and Organization of Genocide, with both the survivors and the
destroyed, among the leaders of the Union and Progress in light of the
Ottoman documents
Cemil Koçak
How Do You Know of the Special Secret Organization (Teþkilt-ý Mahsusa)?
Coffee Break 11:00-11:30
Session 6. 11:30-13:20
Tales of Tragedy and Escape
Ferhunde Özbay
Session Chair
Sarkis Seropyan
Landscapes of conscience from within a Painful History
Fethiye Çetin
>From Heranuþ to Seher, the tale of a ‘liberation’
Ýrfan Palalý
Fatma Ane, the Child of Deportation
Aykut Kansu
Thinking through the Tales of Those Who Survived the Deportation
Lunch 13:20-14:20
Session 7. 14:20-16:00
Witnesses and Memories
Ayþe Öncü
Session Chair
Hülya Adak
The Armenian Question in Memoirs
Ahmet Kuyaþ
What Do the Unionists Say?
Gündüz Vassaf
Armenians in the Educational Calendar (Saatli Maarif Takvimi)
Cevdet Aykan
The Meaning of Memories and The Responsibility of Politics and the Times
Coffee Break 16:00-16:30
Session 8. 16:30-18:00
>From the Threshold of Confrontation to the Formation of Taboos
Selçuk Esenbel
Session Chair
Ayhan Aktar
The Armenian Question in the Ottoman Assembly, November-December 1918
Erol Köroðlu
Examples of Remembrance and Forgetting in Turkish Literature:
the Different Breaking Points of Taciturnity
Baskýn Oran
The
Roots of a Taboo: the Historical-Psychological Suffication of
Turkish Public Opinion on the Armenian Problem
25 September Sunday
Registratio 09:00
Session 9. 09:30-11:30
The States of Armenianhood
Nükhet Sirman
Session Chair
Hrant Dink
The New Sentences of Armenian Identity in Turkey and the World
Ferhat Kentel
Turkish and Republican Armenian Societies: Boundaries and Prejudice
Karin Karakaþlý,
To Be an Armenian in Turkey: community, individual, citizen
Ferhat Kentel,
Günay Göksu Özdoðan,
Füsun Üstel
Melissa Bilal
An Identity Trapped In Between the Past and Present:
the Experience of Being an Armenian in Turkey
Ayþe Gül Altýnay
Two Books and an Exhibit: The Rediscovery of Turkish Armenians
Coffee Break 11:30-12:00
Session 10. 12:00-13:40
Turkish Democracy and the Armenian Question
Murat Belge
Session Chair
Ali Bayramoðlu
Views and Approaches to the Armenian Question in Turkish Society
Etyen Mahcupyan
The Relationship between Historical Perception and Mentality as
Founding Principle of National Identity in Turkey
Ahmet Ýnsel
The Armenian Question and the Concept of the Enemy Within in Turkish
Politics
Murat Paker
Turkish Armenian Issue in the Context of a Psychoanalytic Evaluation of
Turkey’s Dominant Political Culture
Þahin Alpay
What Can Be Done to Reinstitute Turkish-Armenian Friendship?”
Lunch 13:40-14:40
Session 11. 14:30-16:00
Panel: Armenian Question and the Freedom of the Press
Ýsmet Berkan
Session Chair
Yavuz Baydar
(Sabah) newspaper
Kürþat Bumin
(Yeni Þafak)
Oral Çalýþlar
(Cumhuriyet)
Ahmet Hakan
(Hürriyet)
Fehmi Koru
(Yeni Þafak)
Coffee Break 16:00-16:30
Session 12. 16:30-18:30
Panel: Today and the Future
Halil Berktay
Session Chair
A diplomat :
Temel Ýskit
A lawyer:
Turgut Tarhanlý
A publisher:
Ragýp Zarakolu
A politician:
Cem Özdemir
A historian:
Mete Tunçay
Participants other than those on the Organizing and Advisory Committees
Hülya Adak
Sabancý University:
Assistant Professor (Comparative Literature, Cultural Studies)
Þahin Alpay
Bahçeþehir University:
Assistant Professor (Political Science); Zaman newspaper
Ayþe Gül Altýnay
Sabancý University :
Assistant Professor (Comparative Literature, Cultural Studies)
Cevdet Aykan
Mediical doctor; former deputy of Tokat and Minister of Health
Ali Bayramoðlu
Yeni Þafak newspaper
Yavuz Baydar
Sabah newspaper
Ýsmet Berkan
Radikal newspaper
Melissa Bilal
Chicago University Ph.D. student (ethnomusicology)
Kürþat Bumin
Yeni Þafak newspaper
Ahmet Hakan Coþkun
Hürriyet newspaper
Oral Çalýþlar
Cumhuriyet newspaper
Fethiye Çetin
lawyer, author of the book entitled Anneannem (My Grandmother)
Hrant Dink
Agos newspaper
Fuat Dündar
Ecole des Hautes Etudes en Sciences Sociales (Paris) : Ph.D. student
Hakan Erdem
Sabancý University: Assistant Professor (History)
Selçuk Esenbel
Boðaziçi University: Professor (History)
Ahmet Ýnsel
Galatasaray University: Professor (Economics)
Temel Ýskit
retired ambassador
Aykut Kansu
Bilgi University: Associate Professor (History)
Karin Karakaþlý
Agos newspaper
Ferhat Kentel
Bilgi University: Assistant Professor (Sociology)
BRober Koptaþ
Boðaziçi University: Ph.D. student (Atatürk Institute)
Fehmi Koru
Yeni Þafak newspaper
Osman Köker
editor in chief, Birzamanlar Publications
Erol Köroðlu
Sabancý University:
Assistant Professor (History of Literature, Cultural Studies)
Ahmet Kuyaþ
Galatasaray University: Assistant Professor (History, Political Science)
Etyen Mahcupyan
Zaman newspaper
Nazan Maksudyan
Sabancý University: Ph.D. student (History)
Baskýn Oran
Ankara University: Professor (Political Science)
Ayþe Öncü
Sabancý University: Professor (Comparative Literature, Cultural Studies)
Ferhunde Özbay
Boðaziçi University: Professor (Sociology)
Cem Özdemir
Deputy of the Green Party, Germany
Günay Göksu Özdoðan
Marmara University: Professor (Political Science and International Relations)
Murat Paker
Bilgi University: Assistant Professor (Psychology)
Ýrfan Palalý
Ege University: Associate Professor (Neurophysiology)
Taha Parla
Boðaziçi University:
Professor (Political Science and International Relations)
Sarkis Seropyan
Agos newspaper
Elif Þafak
writer, literary person; University of Arizona (USA) : Assistant Professor
(Near Eastern Studies)
Nesim Þeker
Middle East Technical University: Assistant Professor (History)
Turgut Tarhanlý
Bilgi University: Professor (Comparative Law)
Meltem Toksöz
Boðaziçi University: Assistant Professor (History)
Füsun Üstel
Marmara University: Professor (Public Administration)
Gündüz Vassaf
Associate Professor (Psychology); Radikal columnist
Ragýp Zarakolu
editor in chief, Belge Publications
ASBAREZ Online [09-16-2005]
ASBAREZ ONLINE
TOP STORIES
09/16/2005
TO ACCESS PREVIOUS ASBAREZ ONLINE EDITIONS PLEASE VISIT OUR
WEBSITE AT <;HTTP://
1) Yerevan Lauds US Lawmakers for Affirming Armenian Genocide
2) Virginia's Armenian Commission Holds First Meeting
3) 2005 ANCA-WR Annual Banquet Sells out
4) His Holiness Aram I to Preside Over USC Symposium
6) Senator Jack Scott Travels to Armenia
7) AYF Eastern Region Holds Successful Olympic Games in Washington, DC
8) Shushi Music School Society's 2005 Summer Camp a Success
9) Critics' Forum
10) First Sierra Summit
1) Yerevan Lauds US Lawmakers for Affirming Armenian Genocide
YEREVAN (RFE/RL)--Armenia welcomed the endorsement by a US congressional panel
of two resolutions on Friday recognizing the Armenian genocide and expressed
hope that they would pass the full House of Representatives.
"We welcome the decision by the House International Relations Committee and
consider it to be yet another step towards international recognition of the
Armenian Genocide," commented Armenia's Foreign Ministry spokesman Hamlet
Gasparian.
"We hope that the issue will be put before the full House of Representatives
and that it will discuss and adopt the resolutions," Gasparian said.
The resolutions urge President Bush to "accurately characterize the
systematic
and deliberate annihilation of 1,500,000 Armenians as genocide" and call on
Turkey to "acknowledge the culpability of its predecessor state, the Ottoman
Empire."
The overwhelming approval by the House panel on Thursday was also welcomed by
leaders of Armenia's main political parties represented in parliament.
There was no immediate reaction to Thursday's congressional votes from Turkey
which denies that what happened in its territory 90 years ago constituted a
genocide and has condemned 16 countries that have recognized the Armenian
tragedy. In a letter to House International Relations Committee members,
the US
State Department warned that the debate "could damage US-Turkish relations and
could undermine progress by Ankara and Yerevan as they begin quiet talks to
address the issue and look to the future."
But Gasparian disagreed. "I wouldn't like to link the resolutions adopted by
third countries to Turkish-Armenian relations," he said. "As far as I know,
the
parliaments that have recognized the Armenian genocide urged Turkey in one way
or another to normalize its relations with Armenia."
2) Virginia's Armenian Commission Holds First Meeting
August 23, 2005 was a historic day for the Armenian-American community in
Virginia and the United States, when the Governor's Commission on Armenian
Affairs held its first meeting in the Patrick Henry Building on the grounds of
the State Capitol of Virginia. Bedros Bandazian was appointed to chair the
committee.
The goal of the Commission on Armenian Affairs will be to create a
relationship between the Commonwealth of Virginia, the Armenian-American
Community of Virginia and the Republic of Armenia by creating projects and
initiatives that will forge a greater bond. Various proposals were presented
and adopted by the commission in the fields of medicine, academia, culture,
government, business trade and networking. The designated mission will be to
advise the Governor regarding development of economic, professional,
educational and governmental links between the Commonwealth of Virginia, the
Virginia Armenian-American Community and the Republic of Armenia.
The commission is empowered to undertake studies, symposiums, research,
factual reports and initiatives in order to work with the Governor of Virginia
in the implementation of its mission. It also has the task of creating mutual
exchange of cultural and historical information between the citizens of the
Commonwealth of Virginia and the citizens of the Republic of Armenia.
Barkev Baronian will work with the 400th Anniversary Commemoration of the
founding of Jamestown, Virginia in 1607 and will research the history of the
first Armenian on American soil, Martin the Armenian. The Jamestown 2007
Commemoration will celebrate America's 400th Anniversary of the first
permanent
English colony in Virginia with new museum exhibits, films, programs and rare
treasures on loan from major museums and international collections. The
activities of Martin the Armenian, as well as other early Armenian
settlers in
the 17th Century, have been documented in various archives. Research is being
conducted into their contributions to the Jamestown settlement and their role
in the early growth of America. Ideally, there will some type of exhibit in
Jamestown to recognize this first relationship between Armenians and America.
All Commission meetings are open to the public. The next scheduled meetings
will be October 13, 2005, and November 17, 2005, from 10:30 AM until 3:00PM in
the first floor meeting room of the Patrick Henry Building at 1111 East Broad
Street, Richmond, Virginia.
It is the hope of all that the Governor's Commission on Armenian Affairs will
be able to create positive projects that will benefit the Commonwealth of
Virginia, the Armenian-American Community of Virginia and the Republic of
Armenia. For more information, please contact Louise Arnatt at
[email protected] or Bedros Bandazian at [email protected].
3) 2005 ANCA-WR Annual Banquet Sells out
Additional State and Local Officials Confirmed Attendance
LOS ANGELES--The Armenian National Committee of America-Western Region
(ANCA-WR) announced today that all tickets to its 2005 Annual Banquet have
been
completely sold. The Annual Banquet will be attended by a distinguished
list of
elected officials on September 18th at the Renaissance Hollywood Hotel in Los
Angeles.
This year, Congressman Ed Royce and State Senator Jackie Speier will be
honored for their long-lasting support of issues of concern to the Armenian
American community. Alex Sardar, who served as the ANCA-WR's Executive
Director
from 2000 to 2002 and who currently represents Counterpart International in
Armenia, will be the Master of Ceremonies for the event. Mayor Antonio
Villaraigosa will present special remarks during the evening's program.
Some of the most recently confirmed officials are member of California State
Board of Supervisors John Chiang, Assemblywoman Fran Pavely, Mayor of
Montebello William Molinari, Los Angeles City Councilmembers Wendy Greuel and
Bernard Parks, Glendale City Councilmembers Ara Najarian and Frank Quintero,
and former Mayor of Glendale Larry Zarian.
The ANCA-WR Annual Banquet regularly draws over 700 individuals, including a
long list of dignitaries, such as prominent Members of Congress and state
legislators, as well as a vast number of Armenian American community leaders
and political activists. The annual event is the largest of its kind and helps
raise funds to operate the nation's largest and most influential Armenian
American grassroots and political advocacy organization.
The ANCA is the largest and most influential Armenian American grassroots
political organization. Working in coordination with a network of offices,
chapters, and supporters throughout the United States and affiliated
organizations around the world, the ANCA actively advances the concerns of the
Armenian-American community on a broad range of issues.
4) His Holiness Aram I to Preside Over USC Symposium
Important Conference Will Focus on Christian Response to Violence
LOS ANGELES--The University of Southern California will be the site of a
major
conference that His Holiness Aram I, Catholicos of the Great House of Cilicia,
will preside over, focusing on the Christian response to violence with a
special emphasis on the Armenian Genocide. Co-sponsored by the Western Prelacy
of the Armenian Apostolic Church, the USC Institute of Armenian Studies and
the
USC Center for Religion & Civic Culture, the conference is one of several
public forums during which His Holiness will address such issues under the
theme of his visit "Towards the Light of Knowledge."
Many notable scholars will speak on various related topics covering events
ranging from the Armenian Genocide of 1915 to the current impact of
violence on
the daily lives of communities, families and youth today. His Holiness is
deeply involved in the World Council of Churches where he has demonstrated
leadership in confronting issues of violence throughout the world and it is
his
desire to drive discussions on this issue within Armenian communities as well.
He will address the symposium with a presentation entitled "Christian
Stewardship in Violent Times--The Quest for Peace."
"The church has been witness to the racial violence the Armenian people have
suffered throughout the course of history and especially with the Armenian
Genocide," said Prelate, His Eminence Archbishop Moushegh Mardirossian. "With
this year marking the 90th anniversary of the Armenian Genocide, the church
has
an even more important role to play today in addressing many of these violence
issues facing our communities and families throughout the world."
Among the scholars presenting at the conference will be Professor Hrair
Dekmejian of the USC Department of Political Science and Director of the USC
Institute of Armenian Studies who will speak about "Christian Perspectives on
War and Political Violence;" Professor Donald Miller, Director of USC
School of
Religion & Center for Religion & Civic Culture who will set the parameters of
the conference and moderate one of the panels; and Simon Payaslian, Professor
of Armenian Genocide Studies, Clark University on "The Church Bearing Witness
to the Genocide of 1915: Martyrdom, Resistance, Remembrance." There will also
be two panel discussions during the symposium including "The Church's Response
to Political Violence in Today's World" with presenters Dr. Rubina Peroomian,
UCLA and member of the World Affairs Council central committee and Mrs. Lorna
Tourian, and "The Church's Role in Combating Community Violence" with
presenters Dr. Levon Jernazian, Dr. Viken Yacoubian and Dr. Garbis Der
Yeghiayan. Following the symposium will be an exhibit by Research on Armenian
Architecture (RAA) on "Cultural Genocide--The Destruction of Armenia's
Religious and Cultural Heritage."
The USC Symposium will be held on October 15, 2005 10:00 AM to 3:30 PM at
USC's Davidson Conference Center, in the Embassy Room, on the corner of
Jefferson and Figueroa Streets in Los Angeles. Space is limited, so those
interested in attending should call the Prelacy office at (818) 248-7737, or
e-mail: [email protected].
5) Garcetti Makes First Trip to Armenia
Councilmember Working to Create Sister City Program
Ever since Councilmember Eric Garcetti took office in 2001, he has been
encouraged by leaders in the Armenian community and many of his
constituents of
Armenian heritage to visit Armenia. As a former professor of international
relations, he has been a student of Armenian history for some years.
Councilmember Garcetti will share memories from his trip with community
leaders at a special reception on September 25 at 1 p.m., at St. Garabed
Church Hall, 1614 N. Alexandria Ave., Los Angeles, CA 90027. The community is
invited to attend. Garcetti will also discuss the creation of a committee to
formalize a sister city agreement with the city of Yerevan.
As a candidate for City Council, Councilmember Garcetti made it one of his
priorities to reach out to the Armenian community, from well-established
schools, churches and institutions like St. John Garabed, Alex and Rose
Philibos, ANC, AGBU, ARS, Homenetmen, as well as newer immigrants who
sometimes
were not yet part of more organized entities. Garcetti campaigned in Armenian
and Russian and many of the young people who walked door to door with him were
Armenian-American youth from Council District 13 and nearby neighborhoods.
Since being in office, Councilmember Garcetti has made the revitalization of
the Little Armenian neighborhood of East Hollywood one of his top priorities.
"We have organized and joined clean-ups, neighborhood walks, encouraged new
economic development, created parks, put up street banners that welcome people
to Little Armenia, and helped to make the area safer, cleaner, and more
beautiful," Garcetti said. "I have also sought to make sure that we never
forget the Armenian Genocide of last century and I have helped the yearly
youth
march get city permits and joined in other organizations' events that
commemorate one of humanity's darkest hours."
This past winter, Garcetti and his Hollywood field deputy, Baydsar Thomasian
(one of three Armenian-Americans in the CD13 office), decided to make the
dream
of visiting Armenia a reality and to take a trip to Armenia in the summer
2005.
In preparation, Garcetti talked to city officials and Armenian-American
leaders about some of the ways in which Los Angeles and Armenia could
strengthen ties of friendship, commerce, and exchange.
"Early this summer, I had the idea that perhaps Los Angeles, the
second-biggest Armenian city in the world, could be twinned with Yerevan, the
largest Armenian city in the world, as a Sister City," Garcetti said. "Yerevan
already had a Sister City agreement with Cambridge, Massachusetts, so I
went to
Cambridge in early August to explore whether or not Cambridge might want to
`share' Yerevan and the wonderful Sister City Committee and the Cambridge City
Government agreed!"
The trip to Armenia began on August 17. About a dozen people joined the
delegation. Earlier in the year, Garcetti invited Governor Howard Dean, the
chairman of the Democratic National Committee, to join the group and he
accepted the invitation.
City Planning Commissioner Mike Mahdesian, Baydsar Thomasian, Armen Orujian,
Vahag Thomasian, Lynnette Amerian (Garcetti's executive assistant), Garcetti's
partner Amy Wakeland, and others all joined together in Armenia.
The delegation stayed in Armenia until August 27, and were able to accomplish
many important objectives.
Garcetti met with the Mayor of Yerevan and signed an agreement to form a
Sister City Relationship. Garcetti also met with members of Parliament to
discuss ways to cooperate with one another in several areas. Garcetti
discussed
the new trade office that the State of California is opening a trade office in
Yerevan.
"We also talked to the US Ambassador about helping him restore a valuable
film
archive in Yerevan, which was an early filmmaking center last century and
has a
nascent film industry now," Garcetti said.
Garcetti also met with the deputy foreign minister and also went to major
sites, including Echmiadzin, Khor Virap, Sanahin, Hagpat, Garni, and
Sardarabad
to learn about the history. Garcetti also visited the Genocide Memorial in
Yerevan.
"We also ate incredible meals--the reddest tomatoes I have ever seen, some of
the best pork chops, yogurt with honey, fresh berries (blackberries, choke
cherries, currants, plums, etc.), and of course sampled some of the Armenian
wine, where wine first originated," Garcetti said. "The hospitality of
everyone
was incredible--I have not eaten so much in a long time."
Join Councilmember Garcetti
Sunday, Sept. 25 - 1PM at St. Garabed Church Hall
1614 N. Alexandria Ave., Los Angeles, CA 90027
6) Senator Jack Scott Travels to Armenia
PASADENA--State Senator Jack Scott (21st State Senate District -
Glendale/Pasadena) will be traveling to Armenia on a fact-finding trip
aimed at
furthering relations between California and Armenia.
Senator Scott leaves Los Angeles for Yerevan, Armenia on Saturday, September
17 - returning Saturday, September 24, 2005.
While in Armenia, Senator Scott will be meeting with representatives of the
Armenian government including President Robert Kocharian and Parliament
President Arthur Baghdanarian. The Senator is scheduled to participate in
Armenian Independence Day activities on September 21 and tour historic
parts of
the country. The following day he is scheduled to visit Holy Etchmiadzin and
nearby churches.
7) AYF Eastern Region Holds Successful Olympic Games in Washington, DC
WATERTOWN, Mass--From September 2 -5, approximately 2,500 Armenians from the
East and West Coasts and Canada gathered for the annual AYF-YOARF Olympic
Games, hosted by the Washington Ani chapter.
100 athletes from chapters in Boston, Providence, Philadelphia, Washington,
DC, New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Racine, Detroit, Granite City, Fairfield
and
Toronto competed in swimming, track and field, golf, tennis, and softball
games
over Labor Day weekend.
On September 1, before the official start of the games, around 150
Armenian-Americans, led by the AYF Eastern Region, held a protest in front of
the Azeri Embassy in Washington, DC, calling to attention the ongoing threats
by Azerbaijani government officials to use military force to deny
self-determination to the people of Karabagh.
That evening, guests of the Olympic games went on a "Monuments by Moonlight
Tour" around the capital city, which was followed by a party at Blue Gin
lounge
bar.
The Andrews Air Force Base East Golf Course was the gathering place the
following morning, where AYF members and alumni competed in the golf
tournament. Matches of tennis also took place that day at Catholic
University.
Attendees also enjoyed the opportunity for a tour of Washington, DC organized
by the Olympics Steering Committee. Later that night, AYF athletes competed in
swimming races in front of a large crowd cheering them on in the stands at
Catholic University.
By night, AYF alumni and supporters gathered for the annual alumni dance at
the official hotel of the games, Grant Hyatt Washington. Meanwhile, AYF
members
and guests danced the night away to the music of the Michael Gostanian
Enesemble and DJ Terk, followed by performances by Nune Yesayan.
On September 3, AYF members woke up early to start the all-day softball
tournament, where teams from New York, Boston, Philadelphia, Washington, DC,
Granite City/Racine, New Jersey, Chicago, Detroit, Providence and Toronto
battled it out, until around 6:00 p.m., when the Providence chapter beat out
the team from New Jersey in an action-packed final game.
Singer Nersik Ispiryan, along with the Aravod Ensemble and DJ Terk, provided
the entertainment for the evening.
"I thoroughly enjoyed the variety of music we heard this year. Each musician
and band that performed this weekend brought their own unique sound to us each
evening and the end result was the same, a jam-packed dance floor," said
Washington AYF chapter member Nora Keomurjian.
Track and field events rounded out the athletic competitions, beginning at
9:00 a.m. on September 4, at the Archbishop Carroll High School in Washington.
An enthusiastic crowd cheered runners and field athletes, as they competed in
relay races and individual races, as well field events including shot put,
discus and long jump.
Midway through the day, athletes marched with their teams onto the field for
the opening ceremonies. Guests addressing the gathering included ARF Eastern
Region Central Committee chairman Hayg Oshagan; Archbishop Oshagan Choloyan;
AYF Central Executive chairman Antranig Kzirian; and Armenian Ambassador to
the
U.S. Tatoul Markarian.
Then, members of last year's hosting chapter, the Chicago Ararat chapter,
carried the torch around the track, eventually passing it on to two members of
the Washington Ani chapter, who lit the torch as the official start of the AYF
Olympic games. Prior to the running of the torch, AYF athletes recited the
Olympic oath, pledging good sportsmanship and to stay "loyal to the traditions
of the AYF Olympics and applaud the victor and defeated alike."
On Monday, guests attended a farewell picnic near the hotel. "The games
brought our organization together. I felt that everyone participated in the
activities and games during the day, and the dances at night. Our chapters
were
especially united this year, during the protest that we held at the Azeri
Embassy before the start of the games," said Greater Boston AYF chapter member
Anny Deirmenjian.
Founded in 1933, the Armenian Youth Federation (AYF) serves as the youth
organization of the Armenian Revolutionary Federation (YOARF). The AYF stands
on five pillars that guide its activities: education, political awareness,
fellowship, athletics and culture. Moreover, the AYF promotes a fraternal
attitude of respect for the diversity of ideas and individuals amongst its
membership. Unity and cooperation are essential traits that allow members of
the organization to work together and realize its objectives.
8) Shushi Music School Society's 2005 Summer Camp a Success
Founded in 1994 in Los Angeles, the Shushi Music School Society aims to
support
the Daniel Ghazaryan School located in Shushi, in the heart of Mountainous
Karabagh Republic.
Following years of Azeri occupation and the ensuing depopulation of Shushi,
the institution, with a current student body of 100, aims to enable future
generations to use their superior background in music to contribute to the
much
needed cultural reawakening and strengthening of the ancient city of Shushi.
To date, the Shushi Music School Society has accomplished much--thanks to the
generous contributions of many individuals and organizations in the community.
Some of these accomplishments include the complete renovation of the main
building of the school where instruction and performances take place. The
children can thus pursue their education in an environment that is
conducive to
student learning. The construction of a concert Hall within this main building
was also completed this past May.
Aside from the vast physical improvements to the campus, a basketball court
with a sitting capacity of 150 and a soccer field accommodating 200 spectators
were built since 2003. These facilities are truly unique amidst an area where
rubbles are a constant reminder of the devastation caused by the war and were
constructed not only for the students of Daniel Ghazaryan, but also for the
children of Shushi and its neighboring villages. An outdoor playground will
also be completed by summer of 2006.
In 2004, a group of five volunteers from the Los Angeles area ran a three day
long summer basketball camp at Daniel Ghazaryan for the children of Shushi and
Stepanakert.
The camp generated so much enthusiasm amongst the camp attendees and the
volunteers that the Shushi Music School Society Board of Directors decided to
organize a six day long Summer Camp on the school premises from July 15 to
July
21 2005.
A total of 23 volunteers from Los Angeles, mostly college students, lead the
various programs for over 70 camp participants. The travel expenses of many of
the student volunteers were subsidized thanks to various individuals and
businesses in Los Angeles.
Daily activities at the camp included clinics and games in basketball,
volleyball and soccer, and classes in English language, computers, arts and
crafts, and dance. Moreover, to educate the camp attendees on important health
issues, lectures were presented on the harmful effects of tobacco and smoking
and the importance of maintaining proper oral hygiene.
Following an opening ceremony, various teams from Shushi and Stepanankert
also
competed in basketball and soccer tournaments. The winning teams were
presented
with trophies and all camp participants received the official Summer Camp 2005
T-Shirts.
On the final day of camp, a gathering was held at the school's Concert Hall.
The campers who had attended the English language classes sang a song in
English. The dance students performed a dance they had learned. Finally, the
students of Daniel Ghazaryan School entertained the volunteers as they
performed on various musical instruments.
Summer Camp 2005 was a unique experience not only for the Children of Shushi,
but it also had a great impact on the lives of the young volunteers from Los
Angeles.
Lena Berghoudian, a freshman student at Pierce College, describes the
children's amazing dedication to further their knowledge in various arenas as
follows: "The children were bright, alert and prepared. I was extremely
astounded by their eagerness to acquire knowledge, whether in learning a new
dance step, a new language, or even a new sport. Furthermore, their
productivity and progress throughout the course of the camp encouraged me, as
well as my fellow volunteer peers, to challenge their abilities. Soon, the
English class exceeded its plan to teach the basic principles of the language
by developing into an extensive study of composition and grammar. The computer
lessons, which were aimed at teaching the fundamentals of operating a
computer,
transformed into complex sessions exercising a variety of programs,
challenging
their learning, reading and typing capabilities. Their ability and willingness
to learn new information in such little time astonished me."
Andrew Vartanian, a freshman student at UC Irvine, gives the following
description of the character of the children of Shushi: " The children, who
don't have much to look forward to, are the happiest and most cunning children
I have ever met, as they roam around in the rubbles of Shushi. It was truly
astonishing to see what great minds could develop of such kids that are so
much
less fortunate. I comprehended how granted we take life and not appreciate
it."
And as for the camp attendees' parents' reactions to the camp experience, he
adds the following:" The hardest part of all was having a mother come up to
us,
hug us and tell us with tears in her eyes how grateful she was that we were
able to bring joy to these kids' lives and make this camp experience one that
will forever remain in their hearts."
Reflecting on her moving conversations with the children of Shushi, Paleny
Topjian, a freshman at UCLA reminisces: "While watching one of the soccer
games, a little girl sat next to me and started inquiring. The questions were
so many and her curiosity was so genuine, I was moved and began to accumulate
questions myself. Questions like, what did this place have to offer all these
children? What was their everyday life like in this land of ruins? Our
presence was so exciting for them, and our departure so devastating, that I
felt a little guilty for giving them something that we had to take away so
quickly. The most touching question that I'll never forget was one posed by a
girl a few years younger than me: she asked, 'Why are you guys so good?' At
first, this question didn't make sense to me, and I thought I didn't
understand
because of the differences in our dialects; but, when I asked her to repeat
herself, I understood that she was asking why we were so generous and I began
to think: have I really gone so out of my way? I mean, there I was with my
best friend, and a group of wonderful people my age, having one of the most
memorable times of my life, and a girl half way across the world thought that
we were one of the most generous group of people in the world to do the things
we were doing, and again I felt guilty. I promised a lot of children I would
return next year and stay longer. I hope I can keep my promise, and bring
more
joy and hope into their lives. I know I can't make all their dreams come
true,
but I know I can make a little difference in their lives. I know because I
already have."
Maral Der-Sarkissian, a freshman college student at Berkeley, says at the
conclusion of Summer Camp 2005: "I will forever remember the two weeks I spent
in Shushi before going off to college. Even though I was there to touch the
lives of children living in Karabagh, I find myself reflecting on the
experience and realizing that they affected me so much more than I could have
ever affected them. A new vigor awakened within me."
Finally, Gohar Mkrtichyan, the principal of Daniel Ghazaryan, evaluates the
Summer Camp 2005 project as follows: "I sincerely hope that this wonderful
project organized by the Shushi Music School Society will become a yearly
tradition, as it has for the past two years. Indeed, amidst the ruins that we
live in, this summer camp experience, albeit a short one, brings a ray of
sunshine into our lives and is a unique opportunity to bring young Armenians
living in different areas of the world together. The children's only
consolation at the completion of the program is the promise that it will
repeat
itself again next summer."
For more information about the Society's projects, including additional
pictures about the summer camp, or to make a tax-deductible donation for a
specific project, visit <; or
contact the Society at:
Shushi Music School Society
6000 Topeka Dr.,
Tarzana, CA 91356.
9) Critics' Forum
Theater
Homelands Faraway, So Close
By Aram Kouyoumdjian
Just as I was preparing to reread Leslie Ayvazian's `Nine Armenians,' I was
handed a copy of a new anthology that surveys plays written in English by
authors of Armenian ancestry. `Contemporary Armenian American Drama,'
edited by
Nishan Parlakian and published by Columbia University Press, is a handsome
volume comprised of eight plays culled from the past three decades. It opens
with Raffi (Ralph) Arzoomanian's short `Ellis Island 101' and closes with
Joyce
Van Dyke's `A Girl's War.' It also includes `Nine Armenians.'
This high-quality publication merits further discussion, and I will return to
it at a later date. Today, I wish to take up Ayvazian's entry--a 1995 work
that
has been staged at some of the most prestigious American regional theaters,
coast to coast. Along with Richard Kalinoski's `Beast on the Moon,' it is
probably the most widely produced play by or about Armenians in recent years.
I had read `Nine Armenians' some years back in the no-frills acting edition
published by Dramatists Play Service (which eschews such trifle matters as,
say, proofreading). I had also seen two stage versions a polished,
professional mounting at the Mark Taper Forum in Los Angeles and a
disappointing, dismal effort (by Golden Thread Productions) at the Magic
Theater in San Francisco. I decided to revisit the text after reviewing
Turkish-American dramatist Sinan Unel's `Pera Palas,' which led me to
contemplate how ethnic playwrights portray their ancestral homelands in their
scripts. In my previous article (`Culture Clash in `Pera Palas''), I had
equated Unel's play to `a love letter to Turkey,' even though it negotiated
the
delicate terrain between a country's past and present problems, and its future
promise.
As I approached Ayvazian's text anew, I primarily focused on its depiction of
Armenia. What imagery, I wondered, had Ayvazian used to evoke a country
that is
both distant and near?
Ayvazian's affinity for her ancestral nation was obvious. Yet, the writing was
shaped by a perspective fraught by a tendency to lament and pity. And it began
in the very first scene:
`The Armenians are starving.'
Not a page went by when I was struck with `Aman ... we are dying.'
Similar images appeared in subsequent scenes, with characters describing
Armenia as a `dangerous,' `uncomfortable,' and `cold' place, where `[t]he
children draw black suns ... [a]lways black suns in the sky.'
In all fairness, Ayvazian's play is set in 1992 and unfolds within the
context
of the devastating economic blockade of Armenia by its hostile neighbors,
which
deprived the country of essential food and fuel. Certainly, Ayvazian has a
writer's prerogative to offer an artistic response to that dire situation. The
language she employs for this purpose, however, verges on the melodramatic, as
illustrated by such emotional outbursts as `Armenia has no allies! It is
unprotected!' Occasionally, the writing even becomes condescending when, for
instance, Ayvazian reduces the sole character in the play who actually
lives in
Armenia to a starving man who begs for bread. This condescension is compounded
by the self-importance Ayvazian attaches to her diasporan characters, who
consider themselves saviors of their beleaguered homeland because they will
`help' by bearing witness:
Ani: What will you do there [in Armenia], Mom?
Armine: I will sit.
Ani: Sit?
Armine: Ya, I will sit.
Ani: Sit?
Armine: Ya. I will sit with the children in the orphanages.
Louise: She will watch.
In truth, Ayvazian's diasporan characters are ineffective onlookers,
unable to
do more than `sit' and `watch.' But as she opts to write in earnest tones,
without a hint of irony, Ayvazian misses the falsity of the solace these
characters derive from their noblesse oblige.
Ayvazian does allude to aspects of Armenia's beauty, although most of them
are
associated with ancient history or tradition. She momentarily revels in the
vistas of Ararat, casts an affectionate glance on the craft of sewing lace,
and
lovingly accentuates her words with instances of Armenian song and dance.
Incomprehensibly enough, however, she sidesteps modern triumphs. She ignores
the fact that only a year before the events of her play, Armenia had attained
independence after 70 years of Soviet rule; its borders were once again
open to
its dispersed people; and sweeping changes in all fabrics of life were afoot.
The play shies away from the complex issues raised by the phenomenal shifts in
the country's political, economic, and social landscapes. Instead, it takes a
more simplistic approach one that embraces the oft-repeated notion that
`suffering' is fundamental to the Armenian experience.
And therein lies the true pity.
Aram Kouyoumdjian is the winner of Elly Awards for playwriting (`The
Farewells') and directing (`Three Hotels'). You can reach him or any of the
other contributors to Critics' Forum at [email protected].
10) First Sierra Summit
By Garen Yegparian
Last weekend was quite an experience as I attended the first ever
convention-expo organized by the Sierra Club.
The first of its four components was organizational. The Sierra Club priority
setting was conducted by consulting with some 700 delegates gathered from
around the country. Ultimately, energy issues became the top priority with
liveable communities (enviro-speak for rational, well planned,
non-sprawl-based
cities and towns) coming in second. Of course, saving wildlands, water issues,
pollution and others rounded out the list. Subsequently, how these might best
be tackled was addressed by querying the delegates as to the perceived
strengths of the Club. This was a first effort, and procedurally lacking, and
will undoubtedly improve in the future.
The exposition was, simply, an environmental "trade show." Not only were
various products- from hybrid cars to snack food bars- displayed, but
adventure
tourism outfitters, publishers of outdoors and environmental books, and Google
were on hand. You could even have your body's mercury levels checked- think
coal burning power plants spewing that poison into the air, thence through the
food chain into YOU. Supporting all this were the exhibits of accomplishments
prepared by dozens of Sierra Club entities from local groups to countrywide
campaigns.
Fifty-six panels addressed classes of issues ranging from living well to
environmental expression through art, from engaging youth to outdoor adventure
and more. Speakers came from a dizzying variety of backgrounds, including a
Starbuck's representative, Sierra Club activists and staff, people earning
their living by engaging in environmentally positive activities, government
officials, hunters, and professors. In the last of these categories was the
most interesting, George Lakoff, whose book "Don't Think of An Elephan"t I'd
long wanted, purchased, and got his autograph on. It's a fascinating,
informative, and guiding analysis of frames- ideas that shape perceptions and
use the power of language. The best example is that every time the Turks say
"there was no genocide," they're using the word genocide and shooting
themselves in the foot! Every activist of conscience should read this book,
written as a "field guide" based on a more detailed Lakoff study of underlying
principles driving Americans' political understandings, leanings, and actions.
Finally, the inspirational component of this gathering was truly potent and
moving: Al Gore, Bobby Kennedy Jr., Bill Maher, and Arianna Huffington, in
order of appearance. If Gore had spoken during his presidential campaign the
way he did to the Sierra Club, the world would not be burdened with the
murderous, incompetent, profiteering, and immoral cabal that now holds the
reins of power in Washington, DC. Bill Maher slew the audience with his
scathing critique of the current US regime, remarking that the only person to
lose his/her job as a result of the September 11 attacks was... himself. Arianna
was, as usual, right on point and biting with her wry presentation of our
political plight. However, Kennedy stole the show, despite his late arrival
while Liisa Margossian led 2000+ people in a yoga session. He had people in
tears. The amalgamation of facts, first-principles, patriotism, humanity, and
the gift of oratory (Kennedy clan's built-in legacy?) made for an incredibly
powerful speech that had people riveted for over an hour (no ADD there...)
Hurricane Katrina's human exacerbated havoc became a natural focus of
discussion since our destructive doings- reckless disregard for the
ramifications of increased CO2 in the atmosphere (global warming) and
destruction of coastal wetlands made the hurricane stronger and the coast
less
able to withstand its onslaught, respectively. These and other warnings of the
dangers of treading too heavily on our planet have been written off as
alarmist. Perhaps now enough of a global consensus will arise since people are
asking how and why this could have happened. This of course is the Sierra
Club's bread and butter, "To Explore, Enjoy, and Protect" our planet.
With regard to government incompetence, Carl Pope, the Sierra Club's
executive
director, told an interesting story; he happened to be in India shortly before
the Sierra Summit, when Bombay was hit with torrential rains, in excess of
three feet in about half a day. In less than a day, everyone had food and
water. Those needing evacuation were out in a handful of hours, through the
use
of every bus in the city being conscripted to this life-saving use. The US
of A
has not the ability to do the same for a much smaller city?
As a nation that's lived through a similar human exacerbated tragedy- the
Sbeedag earthquake- we would do well and wisely to heed the warnings of
climate
and other scientists. We should join our fellow humans to save the planet,
Armenia- liberated and occupied- and all that lives thereon from
'civilization's' century-long, callous abuse of the natural world.
All subscription inquiries and changes must be made through the proper carrier
and not Asbarez Online. ASBAREZ ONLINE does not transmit address changes and
subscription requests.
(c) 2005 ASBAREZ ONLINE. All Rights Reserved.
ASBAREZ provides this news service to ARMENIAN NEWS NETWORK members for
academic research or personal use only and may not be reproduced in or through
mass media outlets.
AAA: Rep. Radanovich Praises House Cmte for Passing Genocide Resol.
Armenian Assembly of America
1140 19th Street, NW, Suite 600
Washington, DC 20036
Phone: 202-393-3434
Fax: 202-638-4904
Email: [email protected]
Web:
MEDIA ALERT
September 16, 2005
CONTACT: Christine Kojoian
Email: [email protected]
Radanovich Praises House Committee for Passing Armenian Genocide
Legislation
9/15/05
WASHINGTON – Congressman George Radanovich (R-Mariposa) today praised
the House International Relations Committee for passing a resolution
he sponsored reaffirming the United States’ record on the Armenian
Genocide. The resolution was approved by a vote of 40-7.
“The U.S. National Archives is replete with thousands of pages
documenting the premeditated extermination of the Armenian people,”
Congressman Radanovich said. “As the Armenia Genocide was being
committed, the United States launched an unprecedented diplomatic,
political, and humanitarian struggle to end the carnage and protect
the survivors.
“I appreciate the bipartisan support for this resolution, which
properly acknowledges the Armenian Genocide, reaffirms the proud and
groundbreaking chapter in U.S. history to halt the Genocide, and
renews our commitment to preventing other occurrences of man’s
inhumanity to man.”
Congressman Radanovich introduced the legislation, House Resolution
316, with Congressmen Joe Knollenberg (R-MI), Frank Pallone (D-NJ) and
Adam Schiff (D-CA). House Resolution 316 has the support of 140
cosponsors.
“Congressman Radanovich has been a tremendously powerful voice for
Armenian Genocide reaffirmation for over 10 years. Armenian Americans
from around the country are grateful for his unwavering resolve to see
the United States Congress reaffirm this crime against humanity,” said
Aram Hamparian, Executive Director, Armenian National Committee of
America. “We look forward to building on the Committee’s action and to
working with all members of Congress to secure a full floor vote on
Armenian Genocide legislation at the earliest opportunity.”
“On behalf of the Armenian Assembly of America and the pan-Armenian
community, we commend Congressman Radanovich for his steadfast
leadership and tenacity in championing this critical measure,” said
Armenian Assembly Executive Director Bryan Ardouny. “Throughout his
distinguished career, he has repeatedly fought for U.S. reaffirmation
of this crime against humanity, sponsoring other legislative
initiatives that would properly recognize the attempted annihilation
of the Armenian people as genocide.”
The resolution calls upon the President to ensure that the foreign
policy of the United States reflects appropriate understanding and
sensitivity concerning issues related to human rights, ethnic
cleansing, and a genocide documented in the United States record
relating to the Armenian Genocide.
In addition, the bill calls upon the President – in the President’s
annual message commemorating the Armenian Genocide – to accurately
characterize the systematic and deliberate annihilation of 1.5 million
Armenians as genocide and to recall the proud history of United States
intervention in opposition to the Armenian Genocide.
Congressman Radanovich said that President George W. Bush has already
set forth the textbook definition of genocide in his successive April
24th commemorative statements the past few years by using the
expressions “annihilation” and “forced exile and murder” to
characterize the decimation of the Armenian population.
The bill is supported by the Armenian National Committee of America,
Armenian Assembly of America and the Armenian American Community.
Also approved in the International Relations Committee today was a
bill by Rep. Adam Schiff. H. Con. Res. 195 commemorates the Armenian
Genocide of 1915-1923, urges the Government of the Republic of Turkey
to acknowledge the culpability of its predecessor state, the Ottoman
Empire, for the Armenian Genocide and engage in rapprochement with the
Republic of Armenia and the Armenian people.
The Armenian Assembly of America is the largest Washington-based
nationwide organization promoting public understanding and awareness
of Armenian issues. It is a 501(c)(3) tax-exempt membership
organization.
NR#2005-097
When to talk to Turkey
When to talk Turkey
Sep 15th 2005
The Economist print edition
Wrangling over Turkey’s entry talks reflects broader doubts about the
European Union’s direction
ENLARGEMENT has been one of the European Union’s great successes,
bringing stability and democracy to parts of the continent which have
had too little of either. But the policy is about to be put to its
biggest test. On October 3rd, the EU is due to open negotiations with
the biggest and most important country to have asked for membership so
far. That country is Turkey.
Turkey first applied to join what was then the EEC in 1959. The two
sides signed an association agreement in 1963 (implicitly accepting that
Turkey could be a candidate); a customs union in 1995; and the EU
officially accepted Turkey as a candidate for entry in 1999. Turkey has,
in short, been asking to join Europe for so long that its application is
starting to look old and moth-eaten-so much so that some diplomats and
politicians seem to have forgotten the strategic reasons for
entertaining it.
The long period of fobbing off Turkey is now over. Last December, EU
heads of government promised to start negotiations on October 3rd if
Turkey met just two more conditions (which it has done). To get this
far, Turkey has taken such dramatic steps as abolishing the death
penalty, accepting Kurdish as a language in schools, scrapping state
security courts, revising the penal code and tightening civilian control
over the army.
This is a last chance, for both sides. Turkish patience with EU
obstructiveness is running out, as is European willingness to accept new
members. Last December, the French, German and Dutch leaders, among
others, agreed to start talks. They might not do so now-France and the
Netherlands after their lost referendums on the EU constitution, Germany
because of its impending election. Angela Merkel, the most likely
winner, has said she will respect European processes that are under way
when she takes office, which would include the Turkish talks if they
start on October 3rd. But if the date slips, Ms Merkel might want to
reconsider: she is strongly against Turkey’s membership.
All this makes it worrying that, as curtain-up nears, the EU is
suffering from a bad case of stage fright. Two issues threaten to abort
the talks: Turkey’s refusal to recognise Cyprus, and the desire of some
countries to offer Turkey something less than full membership. It is
obvious to all (including the Turks) that Turkey must recognise Cyprus
eventually; indeed, that is one reason why the Cypriots and Greeks have
supported the entry talks. The question is whether it must do so before
they even start. This week, the French government accepted a diplomatic
declaration that would let the talks begin without recognition. Cyprus
still objects, but nobody pays much heed to its views.
Yet even if this first problem responds to treatment, it is not certain
the second will. This is the threat that some members might insist on
putting a “privileged partnership” into the framework document for
negotiations, as a back-up in case membership talks fail. The Turks see
this as an insult. Wrangling is likely to continue until the last
minute. The best that can be said is that the chances of the talks
starting on time are greater than they were two weeks ago and probably
better than 50:50.
Answering the eastern question
All of these last-minute wobbles reflect an underlying ambiguity about
Turkey. Clearly, it is a special case. By 2015 it will be larger than
any other EU state by population, which has unsettling implications for
its voting weight and representation in the European Parliament. The EU
spends most of its money on farming and aid to poor regions-and Turkey
is amply provided with both. In every previous enlargement, there were
doubts about the readiness of the applicants to assume the obligations
of membership. This time the biggest doubts may be about the ability of
the club to absorb the would-be member.
Yet rejecting Turkey’s bid for membership would do little to solve the
difficulties its application raises. The budget needs to be reformed
whether Turkey is in or out. Europe’s economies must create more jobs
whether or not Turkish workers get free movement of labour (which they
probably won’t). Popular dissatisfaction with the EU exists regardless
of Turkish membership. A majority of Europeans say they are undecided
about Turkey, rather than actively hostile.
Were Turkish membership to be rejected, the EU’s existential problems
would not disappear. Indeed, they might get worse. For a start,
rejection would cause a crisis in Turkey. The government is an uneasy
coalition of religious nationalists and westernising moderates. It is
under strain from a renewed upsurge of Kurdish terrorist violence. A
simultaneous failure of the government’s EU policy might break apart the
coalition, and even lead some Turks to look for an alternative such as a
link with Russia or other countries to Turkey’s east.
The problems for Europe would be less dramatic but no less profound.
After September 11th, taking Turkey into the club is no longer just a
question of helping a big and strategically important country to
modernise. It is a test of whether the EU, and the West as a whole, has
any role in encouraging moderate and democratic Islam. To precipitate a
crisis in the nearest big Muslim country, and one that is both
democratic and secular, would be a colossal blunder. Turkey may not be a
model for democracy throughout the Middle East: Arabs certainly do not
see it as such. But rejecting Turkey would still be taken by many Arab
countries as rank hypocrisy or even racism by the West.
A few Europeans might justify the wreckage as a necessary cost of
defending EU integration. But since the problems of popular support, the
budget and so on exist regardless of Turkey, its rejection is unlikely
to produce the “deeper” Europe they crave. The French and Dutch
referendums have kyboshed further integration for quite a while, and
perhaps for ever. Rejecting Turkish membership would probably halt other
enlargements too. Europe would end up neither wider nor deeper; merely
static, and with its south-eastern border in turmoil.