Turkey hints may shun EU talks, Britain urges compromise

Agence France Presse — English
September 28, 2005 Wednesday 4:20 PM GMT
Turkey hints may shun EU talks, Britain urges compromise
ANKARA
Turkey hinted Wednesday that it may shun the start of EU membership
talks next week as political tensions rose over the country’s place
in Europe, leading Britain to warn of a “huge betrayal” if the door
was slammed shut on Ankara.
Raising the risk of a political showdown, the European Parliament
issued a stern warning to Ankara to recognize Cyprus and acknowledge
that the Ottomans committed “genocide” against Armenians during World
War I, two highly sensitive issues that have already strained ties.
The parliament did, however, endorse the start of talks set for
Monday.
The EU’s British presidency, meanwhile, battled to resolve a deadlock
over the negotiating framework — the guiding procedures and
principles of the talks — with Austria insisting on a reference to
an eventual “partnership” instead of full membership for Turkey.
“It is natural that we shall make the necessary evaluations following
the clarification of the negotiating framework and take our final
step accordingly,” Turkish foreign ministry spokesman Namik Tan told
reporters.
“It is out of the question that we accept any formula or suggestion
other than full membership,” he said.
EU ambassadors were scheduled to meet later Wednesday and throughout
Thursday to try to end the dispute before the talks, which were given
a green light by the EU at a December 17 summit, get under way in
Luxembourg.
Noting the atmosphere of uncertainty and possible last-minute
wrangling, a senior Turkish diplomat said that it was not even clear
when Foreign Minister Abdullah Gul would fly to Luxembourg.
“The airplane will be waiting at the airport and when everything is
resolved, we will go,” he told AFP on condition of anonymity.
Other than the Austrian obstacle, he explained, some EU countries are
pushing for tougher terms that go beyond the principles outlined in
the EU’s December 17 decisions concerning Turkey, but declined to
elaborate.
Turkish newspapers reported that one draft provision that
particularly irked Ankara was a demand that Turkey abstain from
obstructing the membership of EU countries in other international
organizations.
The provision is widely interpreted as an attempt to block a Turkish
veto to an eventual bid by Cyprus to join NATO.
Turkey’s refusal to recognize Cyprus is a major obstacle to its EU
hopes, with the EU demanding that Ankara endorse the
internationally-recognized Greek Cypriot government of the
long-divided island during the accession process.
Throwing Britain’s weight behind Turkey, Foreign Secretary Jack Straw
warned that “it would now be a huge betrayal of the hopes and
expectations of the Turkish people and of Prime Minister (Recep
Tayyip) Erdogan’s program of reform if, at this crucial time, we
turned our back on Turkey.”
“Anchor Turkey in the West and we gain a beacon of democracy and
modernity, a country with a Muslim majority, which will be a shining
example across the whole of its neighboring region,” he told the
Labour Party’s annual conference in Brighton.
Turkey has been trying to join the EU for decades but its place in
Europe has come increasingly into question, particularly since French
and Dutch voters rejected a planned EU constitution, partly over
concerns about the membership of this sizeable and relatively poor
Muslim country.
Underscoring increasingly hostile public opinion in parts of Europe,
the heated debate Wednesday at the European Parliament also saw
deputies harshly criticize Turkey’s record on human rights and
religious freedoms.
Ankara urged EU countries to reflect on a “strategic vision.”
“Our membership carries great importance with respect to the
contribution (it would make) to the future of Europe as well as the
Middle East and the Caucasus and particularly to the building of an
alliance between civilizations,” Tan said.

EU lawmakers back Turkey talks, but demand ‘genocide’ recognition

Agence France Presse — English
September 28, 2005 Wednesday 3:42 PM GMT
EU lawmakers back Turkey talks, but demand ‘genocide’ recognition
STRASBOURG
The European Parliament issued Wednesday a stern warning to Turkey to
recognise Cyprus and a “genocide” of Armenians, days ahead of the
start of start of EU entry talks with the huge Muslim country.
While giving cautious backing to the opening of European Union
membership talks with Ankara next Monday, the EU lawmakers’ demands
underscore nagging reservations in the EU about the country one day
joining the European club.
EU leaders gave Turkey a green light in December to start talks. But
strains flared after the country issued a declaration in July
reaffirming its refusal to recognize the government of Cyprus.
Turkey has also come under pressure to recognize a “genocide” against
Armenians under the Ottoman Empire during World War I, a highly
sensitive issue for Ankara.
A text adopted by MEPs said the EU legislative assembly “calls on
Turkey to recognise the Armenian genocide” and that it “considers
this recognition to be a prerequisite for accession to the European
Union”.
Armenians say that up to 1.5 million of their people were slaughtered
in mass killings under the Ottoman Empire, but Ankara denies that the
Ottomans committed genocide against Armenian subjects.
Turkey’s refusal to recognise EU member Cyprus has so far proved the
main stumbling block to the opening of talks, which could last for 10
to 15 years even if all goes well.
In the adopted text, MEPs stressed “that the rapid normalisation of
relations between Turkey and all EU member states, including Turkey’s
recognition of the Republic of Cyprus, is a necessary component of
the accession process”.
Turkey has steadfastly refused to endorse the internationally
recognised Greek-Cypriot government since its troops occupied the
island in 1974 in response to a Greek-engineered coup.
The EU parliament’s motion, which will not delay the scheduled
opening of the entry talks, received the backing of 356 members of
parliament while 181 voted against and 125 abstained.
In a debate, the head of the European People’s Party, the biggest in
the parliament, Hans-Gert Pottering, voiced reservations about
opening negotiations amid concerns over Turkey’s record on human
rights and respect for minorities.
“We know that torture is still ongoing and if that does not stop,
then we should be prepared to break off or suspend negotiations,” he
said. “We cannot turn a blind eye to these abuses and infringements
on human rights.”
Greens party leader Daniel Cohn-Bendit said that the debate over
Turkey had been tainted by racism towards Muslims.
“Not everyone who is against Turkey is a racist, but the people who
are against Turkey are sometimes riding or can surf on a wave of
racism”, he warned.
Speaking to the MEPs ahead of the vote, British Europe Minister
Douglas Alexander, whose country holds the EU’s rotating presidency,
tried to allay fears about the costs of absorbing the relatively poor
country.
“The negotiations with Turkey will be the most rigorous yet,
reflecting lessons learnt from the previous wave of enlargement. They
are also expected to take many years to conclude,” he said.
Amid ongoing unease among some member states about starting the
talks, British Foreign Secretary Jack Straw warned that it would be a
disaster if the EU were suddenly to slam the door on Turkey’s bid to
join the bloc
“It would now be a huge betrayal of the hopes and expectations of the
Turkish people…. if, at this crucial time, we turned our back on
Turkey,” he told the Labour Party’s annual conference in Brighton,
southeast England.

Britain: stalling Turkey’s EU membership bid would be a ‘betrayal’

Agence France Presse — English
September 28, 2005 Wednesday 1:11 PM GMT
Britain warns stalling Turkey’s EU membership bid would be a
‘betrayal’
BRIGHTON, England
It would be “a huge betrayal” if the European Union were suddenly to
slam the door on Turkey’s bid to join the bloc, British Foreign
Secretary Jack Straw said Wednesday.
Straw told the Labour Party’s annual conference in Brighton,
southeast England, that launching accession talks with Turkey next
Monday was one of the “highest priorities” of Britain’s turn at the
rotating EU presidency.
“It would now be a huge betrayal of the hopes and expectations of the
Turkish people and of Prime Minister (Recep Tayyip) Erdogan’s
programme of reform if, at this crucial time, we turned our back on
Turkey,” he said.
Straw will chair an EU foreign ministers’ meeting in Luxembourg next
Monday that is to finalise a negotiating framework, or set of guiding
principles, for the accession talks that would start the same day,
but last many years.
EU leaders gave Turkey a green light at a summit in Brussels last
December for the talks to begin. But strains flared anew after Ankara
reaffirmed last July its refusal to recognize the government of
Cyprus.
Turkey has also come under pressure to recognize what Armenians call
a genocide against their people in the final days of the Ottoman
Empire during World War I — an event that remains highly sensitive
for Turks.
Worries about overwhelmingly Muslim Turkey was a key factor as well
in the stunning rejection of the EU constitution by French voters in
a referendum last May.
Straw said Wednesday: “The decision on Turkey will be made by EU
foreign ministers next Monday, under our presidency… But the test
next week will be of the EU as a whole.”
“Like the United Nations, the EU has to change with a changing
world… Turkey would lose from a ‘no’ decision — but Europe and its
people would lose even more.”
Straw drew a round of applause from Labour delegates when he linked
Turkey’s EU aspirations to the need for the West to engage the Muslim
world, particularly the Middle East.
“Anchor Turkey in the West and we gain a beacon of democracy and
modernity, a country with a Muslim majority, which will be a shining
example across the whole of its neighbouring region,” he said.
Earlier Wednesday in Strasbourg, the European Parliament gave its
cautious backing to next week’s start of talks with Turkey, while
demanding that Ankara recognise Cyprus and the Armenian “genocide”
during the negotiations.
Turkey’s refusal to recognise Cyprus, which joined the EU last year,
has so far proved to be the main stumbling block to the opening of
talks, which could last for 10 to 15 years even if all goes well.
Turkey has steadfastly refused to endorse the internationally
recognised Greek-Cypriot government since Ankara’s troops occupied
the island in 1974 in response to a coup aimed at uniting Cyprus with
Greece.
Speaking to the European Parliament, Britain’s Europe Minister
Douglas Alexander sought to allay fears about the financial burden of
absorbing Turkey, a developing country in relation to the rest of
Europe.
“The negotiations with Turkey will be the most rigorous yet,
reflecting lessons learnt from the previous wave of enlargement. They
are also expected to take many years to conclude,” he said.

BAKU: Azeri military won’t attend NATO seminar in Armenia

Azeri military won’t attend NATO seminar in Armenia – spokesman
MPA news agency, Baku, in Russian
28 Sep 05
BAKU
Representatives of the Azerbaijani armed forces will not take part in
NATO’s Rose-Roth seminar due in Armenia on 6-7 October, Azerbaijani
Defence Ministry spokesman Ramiz Malikov has told MPA news agency.
Malikov described as wide of the mark a report by [Armenian] Arka news
agency which quoted the head of the [Armenian] parliamentary
commission on defence, national security and internal affairs, Mger
Shakhgeldyan, as saying that an Azerbaijani armed forces
representative was expected to take part in the seminar and his
security would be ensured at a high level.

Armenian parliament adopts constitutional changes

Armenian parliament adopts constitutional changes
Mediamax news agency, Yerevan, in Russian
28 Sep 05
Yerevan, 28 September: The Armenian National Assembly adopted the
draft constitutional amendments in its third, final reading today.
The draft will be put up for a nationwide referendum [in November
this year].
The draft was adopted by 90 votes to none. The factions of the
opposition Justice bloc and the National Unity Party did not take
part in the voting, Mediamax news agency reported.
Addressing the parliament on 27 September, the Armenian president’s
representative for constitutional amendments, Armen Arutyunyan, said
that the draft constitutional changes “is a step forward from the
semi-presidential form of rule to parliamentarism”. He expressed the
hope that the constitutional reforms will unite society and play a
positive role in the country’s future development.
The draft constitutional changes will be submitted to the president
for approval and then he will set a date for the referendum.
The draft constitutional changes were prepared by the ruling
coalition and agreed with the Venice Commission of the Council of
Europe. The main purpose of the reforms is to ensure the equality of
all branches of power.
The constitutional reforms were one of the key points of Armenian
President Robert Kocharyan’s election programme and one of the
country’s basic commitment to the Council of Europe.
The role of the parliament will increase in the country if the
constitutional reforms are adopted in the referendum. In particular,
the National Assembly will play the main role in forming the
government, appoint the prosecutor-general, and the president will
not be able to individually adopt a decision to dismiss the prime
minister.

A sour mood as Ankara stands on the threshold

Financial Times (London, England)
September 28, 2005 Wednesday
London Edition 1
A sour mood as Ankara stands on the threshold
By VINCENT BOLAND
Last Saturday morning, a few hundred protesters gathered outside
Istanbul Bilgi University and threw eggs and insults at a group of
historians and human rights workers as they rushed between riot
police into the sanctuary of the university’s main building. Amid the
shouts of “treason” and “lies”, it seemed that, despite many
indicators to the contrary, the battle between progressives and
reactionaries that has been such a notable characteristic of modern
Turkey has not yet been won.
The cause of the most recent outbreak of hostilities was a conference
on the mass killing of Armenians that took place as the Ottoman
empire broke apart in 1915. A court ruling banning the conference
forced its relocation and sparked a ferocious row over free speech at
an especially sensitive moment, barely a week before Turkey begins
the long and arduous process of joining the European Union. It is
little wonder that Abdullah Gul, Turkey’s foreign minister, was moved
at the height of the controversy to observe that “no country can
shoot itself in the foot like Turkey can”.
The incident was revealing of the sour mood that Turkey is in as it
stands on the threshold of Europe. The country was desperate to be
asked to join the EU; now that the invitation has been extended, it
seems unsure whether to accept. In this, Turkey differs from the
former communist countries of eastern Europe. For Poles, Czechs and
Hungarians, accession to the Union was a moment of destiny, the
righting of a wrong caused by the second world war.
There is no comparable feeling in Turkey. The country was the vision
of one man – Mustafa Kemal Atatu
It is because so many Turks are suspicious of what the EU wants from
Turkey, and of what it is prepared to offer in return, that there
seems to be so little enthusiasm for the accession process. In a
public opinion survey published this month, the German Marshall Fund
of the US found that the proportion of Turks who believed that EU
membership would be a good thing had declined in a year from 73 per
cent to 63 per cent.
Onur Oymen, a veteran diplomat who is now a senior official in the
opposition Republican People’s Party, sums up the ambivalence of many
Turks. “The day Turkey joins the EU as a full member will be a
historic day,” he says. “It would be premature to celebrate anything
before then.” Ural Akbulut, rector of Middle East Technical
University, adds: “I believe the accession process will succeed but I
am less optimistic now than I was a year ago.”
For many Turks, the experience of the EU since December 17 last year,
when the Union’s leaders invited urkey to join, has not been happy,
involving too many concessions for too little gain. Cyprus has
bedevilled relations between Ankara and Brussels throughout 2005, as
European governments put pressure on Turkey to recognise the Greek
Cypriot administration in the south of the divided island while, in
the eyes of many in Turkey, ignoring the isolation of Turkish
Cypriots in the north.
That has been a gift to opponents within Turkey of EU accession. Many
Turks also complain that Europeans put too much focus on the plight
of Turkey’s ethnic Kurdish minority. Amid an upsurge in Kurdish
separatist violence in recent weeks, these issues have fuelled a rise
in nationalism and euroscepticism. These were the sentiments that
Saturday’s protesters against the Armenia conference undoubtedly
sought to exploit.
According to Guler Sabanci, head of the Sabanci family conglomerate
and Turkey’s leading businesswoman, there has always been a segment
of Turkish society opposed to EU membership. “These people will find
a reason, any time and anywhere, to be against this journey, and they
have reasons right now,” she says. Still, she insists, they do not
represent the broad mass of Turkish society. “Now and in the future
there is a bigger consensus that they should not get away with it any
more.”
If the rise of nationalism in Turkey is behind the fall in support
for EU entry, the government must take part of the blame, according
to some commentators. Recep Tayyip Erdogan, the prime minister,
returned from last December’s summit in Brussels in Ã‚ – triumph. Yet
he failed to follow through, they say, and lost the reform momentum
that led to significant political and economic modernisation in 2003
and 2004.
A certain amount of reform fatigue was probably understandable. But
Mr Akbulut believes the prime minister underestimated the chances of
success last December. “Erdogan and his team were not prepared for
the success of December 17 and its challenges,” he says. “We can see
that they did not have the plans and people and programmes in place
to build on the momentum and this damaged his image in Europe.”
If Mr Akbulut is right, the EU has as much reason to be disappointed
with Turkey as Turkey has to be disappointed with the EU. The
negotiating process will undoubtedly provide opportunities for mutual
misunderstanding, perhaps even the reason for one side or the other
to walk away. Nevertheless, for some observers, joining the EU is
less important for Turkey than the accession process and the pressure
it puts on Turkey to lose its inhibitions about the outside world,
recognise its democratic shortcomings, reform its institutions and
strengthen its still-shaky civil society.
Dogan Cansizlar, chairman of the Capital Markets Board of Turkey, a
financial markets watchdog, says: “The EU is a direction, an
indicator, a light that Turkey can move towards.” Many Europeans, he
says, judge Turkey by the Turkish communities in their countries,
which are often more conservative and hidebound than Turks in Turkey.
Ms Sabanci believes the process of joining the EU will change Turkey
and make it fit better into the union that, she is convinced, it will
eventually join. She had a personal stake in the dispute over free
speech, because a university founded and funded by her family was one
of the organisers of the Armenia conference. She also believes the
dispute over free speech is symptomatic of a growing awareness of the
importance of such things, not just for Turkey’s EU aspirations but
for the country as a whole.
“This is a very long journey, and during this journey Turkey will
change,” Ms Sabanci says. “The Turkey that will enter the European
Union is not the Turkey we have today.”

Armenia bought ten new Russian SU-27 for its army

Agency WPS
DEFENSE and SECURITY (Russia)
September 28, 2005, Wednesday
ARMENIA BOUGHT TEN NEW RUSSIAN SU-27 FOR ITS ARMY
Armenia bought ten new Su-27 Russian fighters. Colonel Seyran
Shakhsuvaryan, the press secretary of the Armenian Minister of
Defense, confirmed the information. Colonel Shakhsuvaryan didn’t
specify which country sold the operational aircraft. Earlier deputy
Armenian Minister of Defense, Lieutenant General Artur Agabekyan
stated that, “Armenia buys new or refurbishes the possessed military
equipment as and when needed, and at this point the military
equipment of the Armenian Armed Forces is in normal condition”. Some
Armenian sources with reference to Agabekyan reported that the new
fighters were purchased from Slovakia.
Source: Regnum news agency, September 26, 2005
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Armenia in spotlight

Waverley Gazette (Australia)
September 27, 2005 Tuesday
Armenia in spotlight
by Luke Holmesby
THE Highway Gallery is hosting an exhibition marking the 90th
anniversary of the Armenian genocide.
More than half the three million Armenian population was killed in
the 1915 genocide.
The Republic of Armenia borders on Turkey and Iran.
A small group of artists in the Melbourne Armenian community worked
to bring their history to light and to preserve their culture,
stories, memories and family links.
Titled An Armenian Journey, it is the fifth annual Hye Art exhibition
to be held at the gallery. The word ‘Hye’ means Armenian.
Works by Armenian-Australian artists and young art prizewinners will
be featured. Paintings, ceramics, glass works, wood carvings,
photography and paintings will be shown.
A power-point slide presentation in the gallery will introduce
visitors to a highly decorative Armenian alphabet from the 5th
century, Armenian architecture, miniatures, and works by master
Armenian painters.
Works by famous Berlin-based Armenian artist Sam Grigorian will also
be on display.
The exhibition opens on Saturday, October 1, but will be officially
opened at 1pm the following day. Exhibition dates: October 1-13.
Gallery hours: Tuesday-Saturday, 11am to 5pm; Sunday, 1-5pm. Phone:
9807 7261.

Incumbent prefect of Armenian capital’s community re-elected

Mediamax news agency, Yerevan, in Russian
26 Sep 05
Incumbent prefect of Armenian capital’s community re-elected
Yerevan, 26 September: According to preliminary results of the
Armenian Central Electoral Commission [CEC], the incumbent head of
Yerevan’s Kentron [Centre] community, Gagik Beglaryan, has been
re-elected.
Gagik Beglaryan received 32,484 votes; a representative of the
opposition Justice bloc, Ruzanna Khachatryan, won 4,430 votes, the
CEC press secretary, Tsovinar Khachatryan, said. Forty three per cent
of voters took part in the election.
[Passage omitted: other details]

Russia Armenians Days in Armenia and Nagorno-Karebakh

ITAR-TASS News Agency
TASS
September 28, 2005 Wednesday 3:09 PM Eastern Time
Russia Armenians Days in Armenia and Nagorno-Karebakh
By Tigran Liloyan
YEREVAN
The days of the Union of Armenians of Russia and of the World
Armenian Congress in Armenia and Nagorno-Karabakh began with a
concert in the Yerevan Opera House on Wednesday.
The Union of Armenians of Russia, which observes its fifths
anniversary this year “extended hope and faith in the future of the
Armenian diaspora in the Russian Federation.” The diaspora counts
over 2 million people, Ara Abramyan, the president of the two
organizations, prominent Russian public figure and entrepreneur,
UNESCO good offices ambassador, said on Wednesday. The Union now has
240 chapters in 72 subjects in the Russian Federation. It sponsors an
institute engaged in research into international politics and the
history of Armenian genocide.
“We enjoy much respect because of our deeds not only in Russia and in
Armenia but also far beyond their boundaries,” Abramyan said.
“Russo-Armenian economic cooperation strengthens and broadens due to
the efforts of the Union of Armenians of Russia”.
During the meeting with Armenian President Robert Kocharyan on
Thursday, Abramyan, as head of the Union, is going to “discuss
mechanisms of systemic work” with the republic. Harmonious
interaction is lacking so far, Abramyan believes.
Abramyan said he would continue implementing his programme of
Armenia’s computerization. In its framework, 1,000 computers will be
distributed among institutes of higher learning, schools and other
educational establishments in Armenia. Every year Abramyan provides
several hundred thousand dollars for the National Academy of
Sciences, the Writers’ Union and Artists’ Union in Armenia. Abramyan
will be one of the benefactors contributing to the construction of a
temple of the Armenian Apostolic Church in Moscow.
“The Union of Armenians of Russia does not busy itself with politics,
and because of being Russian citizens, its members have no right to
intervene in Armenia’s political life,” Abramyan stressed. At the
same time, the organization cannot but participate, in the framework
of Armenian laws, in the republic’s social and political life,
Abramyan said.