AZG Armenian Daily #181, 08/10/2005
Karabakh issue
WILL KARABAKH GET AN INTERMEDIATE STATUS?
Regnum agency quoted Sabine Freizer, the International Crisis Group director
for South Caucasus, as saying that the ICG will soon represent its second
report to Armenia, Azerbaijan and Nagorno Karabakh that puts forward 20
options for the conflict regulations. Freizer said, in particular, that the
ICG offers holding referendum among the Armenians of Karabakh and the Azeris
who are bound to return to their former homes to decide the status of the
region. “While talking about a referendum we need to be sure that Baku will
recognize its results”, she said. Freizer thinks that it is the
international community that has to set the date of the referendum and not
Armenia and Azerbaijan. The international community will assess “as to what
extent Nagorno Karabakh is a sovereign state and to what extent the
authorities of Karabakh are ready to protect national minorities”.
Freizer underscored that a solution to the conflict can be found if the
sides leave aside the status issue for now and get down to other issues.
Freizer looks optimistically at the fact that the sides understood that
“package regulation is impossible and some territories need to be returned
inviting international peacekeepers to locate there”. “That way the people
of Karabakh will get an intermediate status of independence”, she said.
Armenian journalist convicted for `insulting Turkish identity’
Kathimerini, Greece
Oct 8 2005
Armenian journalist convicted for `insulting Turkish identity’
ISTANBUL (AFP) – An Istanbul court yesterday sentenced
Turkish-Armenian journalist Hrant Dink to a six-month suspended
sentence for `insult to the Turkish national identity,’ his lawyer
told AFP. Both the lawyer, Fethiye Cetin, and Dink said they would
appeal the decision. Dink, editor of the bilingual Turkish-Armenian
weekly Agos, was on trial for a February 2004 article calling on
Armenians to `turn to the new blood of independent Armenia, which
alone can free them of the burden of the diaspora.’ In the article,
which dealt with the collective memory of the Armenian massacres of
1915-1917 under the Ottoman Empire, Dink also called on Armenians to
symbolically reject `the adulterated part of their Turkish blood.’
On flogging poets and catching fish
The Globe and Mail, Canada
Oct 8 2005
FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION: ONE AUTHOR SPEAKS
On flogging poets and catching fish
At a recent writers’ festival in Iceland, MARGARET ATWOOD spoke out
about the Orhan Pamuk case. Here’s what she had to sayBy MARGARET
ATWOOD
Saturday, October 8, 2005 Page R13
REYKJAVIK — I’ve been asked to say a few words about writers’
festivals, and why we might have such things. There’s also a fish
conference here at this time — I hope none of you have come to the
wrong place. Here’s how to tell them apart: At the fish conference,
they’re talking about fish — an important subject, in my view, as
some kinds of fish are threatened — whereas at the writers’
conference we are talking about writing . . . in many areas of the
world, under threat as well.
Iceland is a highly fitting place to be talking about writing,
because most of the earliest writing of the medieval period took
place here. There has been much discussion of why this was, but two
of the elements must have been an appreciative and discerning
audience, and the desire to learn and create. Any society needs both
of these to produce a vigorous literary tradition, but it also needs
a third element — the public policy we refer to as freedom of
speech.
It was intensely moving for me to visit Thingvallir, the volcanic
rift valley where the Althing met, in Iceland’s earliest days, when
it was a self-governing country. Here points of view were hotly
debated, speakers were heard, and decisions were reached. The memory
of this kind of freedom — freedom from absolutism, freedom to
express your mind without being thrown into a dungeon — this memory
died hard in Iceland. Difficult times arrived, and the country fell
under the rule of Denmark, in that era a hard-handed monarchy; but
finally Iceland regained its independence, a quality that its
citizens as individuals had never lost. Parliamentary democracy as we
know it today owes much to Iceland.
Now I am going to make a connection that will be a surprise to some
— a connection between Iceland and Turkey. Oddly, in the Prose Edda
— which deals with the supposedly ultra-Norse pre-Christian
mythology — there’s a Christian-era cover story. This story
identifies the Aesir — Odin, Thor, Baldur, and all the rest — as
having come originally from Troy, “known to us,” says the Icelandic
Edda writer, “as Turkey.” It’s a curious thought — that the Norse
Gods came from Turkey. I mention it here because the world-famous
Turkish writer Orhan Pamuk, who has done more than anyone to
encourage a sympathetic view of Turkey in the West, is about to stand
trial in his own country for having spoken about the deaths of
Armenians and Kurds in Turkey at the time of the First World War.
Perhaps Iceland should make Orhan Pamuk, if not a god, at least an
honorary Icelander, as exemplified by his independence of mind and
expression.
Advertisements
The Icelandic Nobel laureate Halldor Laxness begins his novel
Iceland’s Bell — a novel that circles around the losing and the
recovering of the ancient Icelandic manuscripts — with an act in
which free speech is punished. A poor farmer has said that the Danish
monarch then ruling Iceland had a fat mistress. That the man who is
flogged for stating a widely circulated truth is also an accomplished
oral poet is no accident.
Why are repressive governments so afraid of writers? Why do they
arrest and imprison and torture and kill them, all around the world?
It’s for much the same thing — for saying what everyone knows, but
nobody dares voice, and for saying it well. Imposed silence is a
favoured weapon of tyrants. To own up to the real history of one’s
country is an act of courage, because real histories are never
spotless; they are also seldom popular with the authorities of the
day. But true writers like Orhan Pamuk and Halldor Laxness are not
placed among us to flatter and conceal.
To flog the poets is not in the best interests of any country, much
less one that wants to join an association — in this case, the
European Union — where flogging the poets is not viewed well. Let us
hope that Turkey comes to its senses, and takes up again the destiny
ascribed to it by the old Icelandic Edda writer — as a place where
“the people are most endowed with all blessings: wisdom and strength,
beauty, and every kind of skill.”
And let us, as writers, celebrate our own particular skill — and the
freedom we have to practise it — during this exceptional writers’
festival. In Ireland, where many Icelandic genes originated, there
was a mythical fish known as the Salmon of Wisdom. I hope that is the
kind of fish we will all try to catch.
A writer fights the war of words
The Globe and Mail, Canada
Oct 8 2005
FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION ONE MAN’S BATTLE
A writer fights the war of words
Turkey’s Orhan Pamuk was charged with ‘denigrating’ his beloved
countryBy CONSTANCE ROOKE
Saturday, October 8, 2005 Page R12
Last February, Turkey’s most celebrated writer, Orhan Pamuk, told a
Swiss newspaper that “thirty thousand Kurds and a million Armenians
were killed in these lands and almost no one dares talk about it.
Therefore, I do.” This caused a furor within Turkey, with liberals
defending Pamuk’s right to free speech and/or the critical importance
of speaking out about this particular matter, and reactionaries
branding Pamuk a traitor, burning his books, and issuing the
anonymous death threats that have forced the writer to flee his
country.
In general, the liberal camp passionately supports Turkey’s bid for
admission to the European Union, while reactionary nationalist forces
fiercely oppose it — and the terrible story of what has happened to
Pamuk is strongly linked to this struggle within Turkey.
In July, the prosecutor’s office in Istanbul determined that Pamuk’s
words were indeed protected by free speech. However, in late August,
a district prosecutor laid charges against Pamuk — a world-famous
writer whose deep love of Turkey is palpable in all he writes — and
the furor became international. External opponents and supporters of
Turkey’s admission to the EU were appalled, and the European
Parliament launched an initiative to monitor the legal process
against Pamuk. His trial on charges of “denigrating Turkey” is
scheduled to begin on Dec. 16. Turkey’s penal code cites a penalty of
up to three years in jail for this offence, and one-third more if, as
in Pamuk’s case, the supposed insult was voiced outside Turkey.
The charge against Pamuk is in direct opposition to the United
Nations International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, and the
European Convention on Human Rights. Turkey is a signatory to both.
Liberals in Turkey are rightly concerned that worldwide attention to
this outrageous charge, and suppression of debate on the darkest
chapters of their country’s history, may lead to rejection by the EU.
A powerful minority of Turks on the far right, however, have welcomed
— indeed, probably engineered — the charges against Pamuk largely
for that reason. The timing is certainly suspicious: Prime Minister
Tayyip Erdogan began his talks with the EU on Oct. 3, just over a
month after charges were brought against Pamuk.
Writers around the world have been quick to defend Pamuk and to
express their outrage. Michael Ondaatje, for example, has issued this
statement through PEN Canada: “Orhan Pamuk is one of the great
writers of our time and is also one of the most generous chroniclers
of the glories of Turkey and its culture. From The White Castle to
Snow to his recent memoir Istanbul, it is clear that this is a writer
who loves his country. That he should be accused of ‘denigrating’
Turkey and threatened with a prison term is shocking. It is an
appalling example of censorship in a country seeking admission to the
EU and clearly signals a lack of freedom of expression in Turkey.”
Within Turkey, the battle for and against free speech continues. Last
spring a group of Turkish academics tried to hold an international
conference in Istanbul on the Armenian massacres of 1915. They hoped
by ‘owning’ this issue to signal to the European community that
Turkey is a maturing democracy, intent on protecting freedom of
expression. But Turkey’s Justice Minister called the conference “a
dagger in the back of the Turkish people,” and the conference was
postponed. Then the Prime Minister voiced his support for the
conference, which was rescheduled for September so as to precede his
talks with the EU. To the Prime Minister’s great embarrassment, a
last-minute court order again prevented the conference from starting.
Organizers circumvented this by moving it to another venue, and the
conference opened the next day with stormy demonstrations for, and
against it.
Turkey’s Foreign Minister has “announce[d] to the world that there is
free speech in Turkey,” and pointed out that no verdict has been
reached on the charges against Pamuk. But the charges were brought,
and they have not been dropped. Moreover, as International PEN
reports, despite a recent decline in convictions and prison sentences
under laws penalizing free speech, there are currently over fifty
writers and publishers before the Turkish courts. In several senses,
Orhan Pamuk is not alone.
Writer and academic Constance Rooke is the president of PEN Canada.
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress
Sounds of cymbals are heard in the Q-C
Quad City Times, IA
Oct 8 2005
Sounds of cymbals are heard in the Q-C
By Tamara Fudge
Master cymbal specialist Mark Love and other artists of a premiere
cymbal company called Sabian spent an afternoon earlier this week
under the awning of West Music’s Davenport store on Brady Street as
part of the group’s Vault tour.
Customers were able to have a cymbal custom-made, watch hand
hammering and lathing demonstrations, and test or purchase the many
cymbals on display. For a small donation to Hurricane Katrina
victims, black Sabian wristbands also were available.
`A lot of cymbals are developed working with the artists, taking a
sound or vision in their heads and turning it into an instrument,’
Love said.
Jeff Cook/QUAD-CITY TIMES Allie Cougle of Sabian, a company that
makes cymbals, uses a hammer to shape a custom cymbal during a
company tour visit this week to West Music in Davenport.
`The real secret we have at Sabian is the process added downstream
from the metallurgical process,’ said Bill Zildjian, part owner and
an executive in the company his father created. `It’s the attitude of
our people, who are willing to tinker and experiment. The
possibilities are limitless.’
He listed the number of bronze alloys, patterns of hammering,
lathing, shapes and sizes, all of which affect the cymbal’s sound.
His family’s name has been connected with cymbal making for
centuries. Zildjian said that his name is Turkish-Armenian for cymbal
(zil) – smith or maker (dj) – son (ian) and can be dated back to at
least the 1670s.
According to the Percussive Arts Society’s Web site, Bill’s father,
Robert Zildjian, worked for his father’s cymbal business. Upon the
older man’s death, Robert and his brother, Armand, shared the company
until deciding to split in 1982. Armand kept the original company’s
name, Zildjian, and younger brother Bob created his own company in
Meductic, a small village in New Brunswick, Canada.
`Sabian’ is a combination of the names of Robert’s children: `Sa’ for
Sally, `bi’ for Bill and `an’ for Andy. `We found out later that it
is actually the name of a tribe of people in Turkey,’ Zildjian said.
Sabian cymbals, carefully hand-hammered in the Turkish tradition, now
can be found all over the world, and are used by amateurs and
professionals from the Royal Opera House in London to jazzmaster Jack
deJohnette and rock star Phil Collins.
The idea of this kind of tour came because `whenever drummers make
the pilgrimage to Meductic, they have a great time seeing how cymbals
are made,’ Zildjian said. `They can select from a variety not
available in a store.’
At West’s showing, there were prototypes – unique cymbals that never
had seen store shelves.
`It’s a time-honored tradition,’ said Justin Beahm, combo manager for
West.
`It shows people how they’re made from scratch. They had some
unmarked, unique cymbals for sale that no one else in the world has.’
Why stop in Davenport?
`West Music is one of the premier percussion vendors,’ Zildjian said.
`They have high quality and an aggressive program.’
`It’s interesting to see how they craft these plates, demonstrating
this ancient method, into something that’s still integral in music
today,’ said Shawn Lafrenz, general manager of West’s Percussion
Source division. `Watching them is an amazing process, a show in
itself. The tour brings something quite special to Iowa.’
`Our real competitors are not the other cymbal companies,’ Zildjian
said. `It’s Nintendo, DVD players, and those kinds of things.’
Journalist Guilty of ‘Insulting Turkishness’
Kurdish Info, Germany
Oct 8 2005
Journalist Guilty of ‘Insulting Turkishness’
Erol Onderoglu
Bianet /7 October 2005 /-Hrant Dink, the editor of the Istanbul based
Armenian language weekly newspaper Agos, has been sentenced to
suspended 6 months imprisonment for “insulting Turkishness” in a
series of articles he wrote on Armenian identity.
Hrant Dink, who was charged with “insulting Turkishness” in an
article on Armenian identity published in the weekly newspaper Agos,
has been sentenced to a 6-month term in prison, but the penalty has
been suspended.
Dink was also one of the organizers of the conference on Ottoman
Armenians that was recently held in Istanbul. The newspaper’s general
coordinator Karin Karakasli, who was charged along with Dink, was
acquitted on the grounds that she was exempt under a provision of the
Press Law. The journalists’ lawyer, Fetiye Cetin, told Bianet that
they are appealing the court’s decision.
The decision hearing took place today (7 October 2005) at the Second
Criminal Court in Sisli, and was attended by the journalists, their
lawyers, and other supporters. The prosecutor, Muhittin Ayata, argued
that Dink’s article had been written with the intent to criticize and
humiliate Turkish national identity. The court suspended the sentence
on the grounds that Dink had no previous convictions and on the
condition that he does not repeat the offense.
The suit was filed against Dink and Karakasli on 16 April 2004 for a
series of articles starting in February 2004 that criticized diaspora
Armenians for focusing on the history of Turkish crimes against
Armenians and not doing enough for the needs of Armenians in the
present. Reporters Without Borders, PEN International, and other
civil society groups have criticized the lawsuit.
DM: Armenia Can’t do Professional Army While Azerbaijan Belligerent
A1+
| 19:48:15 | 07-10-2005 | Politics |
ARMENIA CANNOT KEEP A PROFESSIONAL ARMYON THE BACKGROUND OF BELLIGERENT
STATEMENTS
«United integrity and development is impossible in case the President of our
State sees the solution of the problem only in the principle of peace and
conditions the cooperation with neighbour country on regulation of
conflict», RA Minister of Defence Serj Sargsyan during Rose-Roth NATO PA
seminar.
Mr. Sargsyan considers impossible united regional reforms of the sphere of
defence. `Neither war nor peace promote the regional development, it is a
result of non-solved conflict, and that is why military factor has a big
role in state formation. Belligerent statements of our neighbour country
prevent Armenia from comprehensive development. Serj Sargsyan noted that
Armenia can’t realize defence reforms while Azerbaijan comes up with martial
declarations from the highest tribunes; a reform suggests reduction of
strength or a professional army. «Today having powerful armed forces becomes
a priority, and the problem of national interest and population security is
a priority’, – Mr. Sargsyan said adding that we can’t refrain from actions
while Azerbaijan doubles its military expenses and technical means».
That is why Armenia has a close alliance with Russia, cooperates with U. S.
and NATO
Armenian-Azeri Trade
Panorama
15:45 07/10/05
ARMENIAN-AZERI TRADE
`There is lack of energetic recourses in Armenia, but here there is product
that azeris can be interested in’, said the USA ambassador in Armenia John
Evans concerning to the future expectations of Armenian-azeri economic
cooperation.
During NATO PA seminar the ambassador voiced the following opinion, ‘When
the economic situation improves, the conflict risks will reduce’.
J. Evans also talked about the USA policy in Armenia. According to him there
are three directions. `Firstly, we are anxious for security and stability
consolidation. Here the assistance of Yerevan and Baku is very important for
the conflict resolution in Nagorno Karabakh. The second direction is, that
we want the strengthening of economics not only in Armenia but also in three
countries of South Caucasus. The last one is, to strengthen the democratic
institutions. I think at least in Armenia we have invested huge recourses in
this field’,- added Mr. Evans. /Panorama.am/
Luzhkov Ponders, Zakharyan Waits
A1+
| 18:30:09 | 07-10-2005 | Economy |
LUZHKOV PONDERS, ZAKHARYAN WAITS
`I’ll think about it’, mayor of Moscow Yuri Luzhkov said to journalists
about buying an apartment in the centre of Yerevan city.
Of course, that was not the aim of Mr. Luzhkov’s visit. At 2 Argishti str.,
Yerevan, Moscow Culture and Business Centre will have been built by
September 1st, 2006. Mayor of Moscow Yuri Luzhkov and mayor of Yerevan
Yervand Zakharyan signed today à corresponding memorandum.
Due to tradition the memorandum was placed in a small bottle, which
simvolized the first stone of the building.
Yervand Zakharyan noted, that about 10 million dollars will go on the
building and added: «Beginning from today Moscow days start in Yerevan. The
fact that Culture and Business centre will be located near the city
administration talks to the friendship and brotherhood of two countries.
Mr. Luzhkov added, that `the centre will promote the development of
cultural, commercial and economic relations and business’. `This is what we
are expected to do’.
The architect of the building is Levon Vardanyan.
Yuri Luzhkov also stated, that before long similar territories are planned
to be given to Armenia for founding Yerevan Centre in Moscow.
Different Views
A1+
| 18:06:49 | 07-10-2005 | Economy |
DIFFERENT VIEWS
RA will need about 367 years to return the population deposits of Soviet
years. To this conclusion came member of United Labor Party Grigor Ghonjeyan
after making simple arithmetic calculations.
Next year the parliament foresees for the repayment of deposits 1 mlrd
drams, that is to say $2 mln 200 thousands. General debt counts about 8
miliard roubles /800 mln dollars/. Dividing the last figure into the second
one Grigor Ghonjeyan got 367.
Armenian PM Andranik Margaryan thinks that `all this is just a farce’,
taking into account that there’s no clear indexation, program approach, and
continuance is also under doubt.
Leader of Republican Party of Armenia Galoust Sahakyan doesn’t agree with
this view, «as in this case there are neither elected nor voters». Mr.
Sahakyan thinks if this should be done in 2007, on the threshold of next
general elections.
Galoust Sahakyan considers returning of deposits non-efficient both for the
state and the population, though PM Andranik Margaryan had noted that 1
milliard drams will be marked out on that purpose in the budget of 2006.