ASBAREZ ONLINE
TOP STORIES
10/12/2005
TO ACCESS PREVIOUS ASBAREZ ONLINE EDITIONS PLEASE VISIT OUR
WEBSITE AT <;HTTP://
1) Georgia, Azerbaijan, Turkey open Georgian Section of Caspian Oil Pipeline
2) Governor Signs Senator Scott's Armenia Trade Office Bill
3) ARF Armenia Youth Organization Gains 42 New Members
4) Catholicos Aram I Blesses New Western Prelacy Building
1) Georgia, Azerbaijan, Turkey open Georgian Section of Caspian Oil Pipeline
TBILISI (AP)--The presidents of Georgia, Azerbaijan, and Turkey on Wednesday
ceremonially opened the valves on the Georgian section of a US-backed Caspian
pipeline that is seen as key to cutting Western dependence on Mideast oil.
They said the new route would help their countries prosper.
Georgian President Mikhail Saakashvili, AzeriPresident Ilham Aliyev, and
Turkish President Ahmet Necdet Sezer each pushed a button opening valves at a
pumping station for the Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan pipeline in the Gardaban district
outside the capital, Tbilisi.
`What does this pipeline mean for Georgia? Economically, it means
investment,'
Saakashvili said at the ceremony. `But the significance of this pipeline is
first of all political. Georgia's significance is growing on the world map and
in this region.'
`Next year we'll get a gas pipeline, which means economic and energy
independence for Georgia,' he added.
Known as the Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan, or BTC pipeline, the $3.2 billion project
aims to boost the energy-hungry West's access to the rich Caspian fields,
estimated to hold the world's third-largest reserves. Iran, Russia,
Azerbaijan,
Turkmenistan and Kazakhstan all claim shares of the Caspian's undersea
wealth.
The three leaders opened the first section, transiting Azerbaijan, in May.
By year's end, the 1,100-mile project is to ship up to 1 million barrels a
day
to Turkey's Mediterranean port of Ceyhan. It will take approximately 10
million
barrels of crude to fill the entire pipeline.
Most Caspian oil exports currently go through Russian pipelines to the Black
Sea port of Novorossiisk, where the oil is loaded onto tankers that squeeze
through the crowded Bosporus Strait.
2) Governor Signs Senator Scott's Armenia Trade Office Bill
SACRAMENTO(Combined Sources)Senator Jack Scott's bill that extends the sunset
date for the operation of a privately funded trade office in Armenia has been
signed by Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger.
California, home to about half-a-million Armenian-Americans, conducts most of
the nearly 50 million in trade between Armenia and the United States. The
trade
office is expected to increase business and trade and tourism between
California and Armenia.
`This is an important step forward in cementing ties between the people of
California and Armenia,' said Senator Scott. `It is also a responsible step in
these tight economic times. This office is the first privately funded trade
office for the state and it will be a win-win for California and Armenia.The
trade office will open new and large growth markets for California businesses
and investors. For Armenia and its neighbors, the office will generate
much-needed business and investment.'
The state's trade office in Armenia opened last week in the capitol city of
Yerevan. It was funded with $75,000 in private donations. The Glendale-based
Foundation for Economic Development helped create the trade office.
Because the money was raised privately, the state was able to open the office
in Armenia even though California's other foreign trade offices were closed
recently because of state budget woes. That could be a model for the state if
it opens other foreign trade offices, officials said.
Senator Scott recently completed a fact-finding trip to Armenia where he met
with President Robert Kocharian and foreign minister Vartan Oskanian to
announce the opening of the trade office.
`The Armenian officials that I met with are very excited about it because
they
recognize that one of the ways as a developing country they're going to
progress is to count on the expertise and the products that would come from a
place like California,' said the Senator Scott, who was in Armenia September
19-23. `We will be the first in the nation to reap the trade benefits of the
enormous economic potential of this region.'
Officials expect that the office will facilitate in the export of information
technology and health products going into Armenia and help Armenian businesses
export foodstuffs and other products to California.
3) ARF Armenia Youth Organization Gains 42 New Members
YEREVAN (Aztagdaily.com)--Forty-two youth recently joined the Armenian
Revolutionary Federation's (ARF) Agbal Aghbalian Student Union in Armenia at a
ceremony that took place at the grave of Aram Boghosian who died fighting for
the Liberation of Mountainous Karabagh.
The October 7 swearing-in took place at Yerablur Military Cemetery in
Yerevan.
ARF Parliamentary faction secretary Hrair Garabedian noted the symbolism of
the
students taking their oath in the `presence of dedicated and martyred ARF
members.'
He asked the students to continue the mission of those who have sacrificed
themselves, `because the ARF is a party that carries out strugglesnot only on
the battlefield,' but also in professions the students have chosen in their
various fields of study, he stressed.
Speaking to the new members, ARF-Armenia Supreme Body member Hratch
Tadevosian
said the people gave birth to the ARF at the end of the 19th century, and
during the subsequent 115 years, the party led a resolute fight to protect the
rights of Armenians. `But there remain many unresolved issues, and they await
you; we must be able to pursue these together, step-by-step. I hope that you
will provide force to the ARF.'
4) Catholicos Aram I Blesses New Western Prelacy Building
LOS ANGELES--Saturday, October 8 marked a historic day for the Western Prelacy
as His Holiness Aram I, Catholicos of the Great House of Cilicia, blessed the
new building that will house the Western Prelacy headquarters. The ceremony
began with His Holiness blessing a large cross that was then lifted with a
crane and placed on top of the dome of the St. Dertad and St. Ashkhen
Chapel in
the new building in La Crescenta.
While construction is not yet fully completed, several hundred guests and
clergy attended to witness the Pontiff's blessing of the new structure, to
usher in a new era of expanded spiritual leadership for the church in the
western United States.
Many of the major benefactors who made the building possible were on hand to
take part in the special occasion including Mrs. Ashken Pilavjian and Mr. and
Mrs. John and Asdghig Bedrossian. Following the blessing and placement of the
cross, the Catholicos led a procession of clergy and benefactors into the
building to officially bless the alter inside and the overall building.
`This marks a historic day,' said Archbishop Moushegh Mardirossian,
Prelate of
the Western United States. The Archbishop thanked the benefactors who
facilitated the construction of the building, as well as the tireless efforts
of the Prelacy Executive Council, the Building Committee and others who have
worked tirelessly to make the building a reality. `When our people work
together for the common good of the community no resources are beyond the
reach
of those who take initiative,' the Archbishop continued. The Archbishop also
noted the presence of a representative from the Forest Lawn memorial park that
also made a sizeable donation for the Prelacy building.
His Holiness declared that this is not just a building that will house the
Prelacy's offices, rather `the home of our faith and nation which will serve
our church and people.' The Catholicos also noted the integral role played by
Archbishop Mardirossian and the various benefactors and committee members who
drove the idea and realization of the structure. `May God bless and look over
all those who will care for and work in this building and the Armenian
American
community who will support this effort,' the Pontiff concluded.
The building is expected to be completed within a year at which time all
Prelacy functions will be consolidated at this location from their temporary
location in Encino.
All subscription inquiries and changes must be made through the proper carrier
and not Asbarez Online. ASBAREZ ONLINE does not transmit address changes and
subscription requests.
(c) 2005 ASBAREZ ONLINE. All Rights Reserved.
ASBAREZ provides this news service to ARMENIAN NEWS NETWORK members for
academic research or personal use only and may not be reproduced in or through
mass media outlets.
AAA: U.S.: Turkey Exerts Excessive Control Over Religious Activity
Armenian Assembly of America
1140 19th Street, NW, Suite 600
Washington, DC 20036
Phone: 202-393-3434
Fax: 202-638-4904
Email: [email protected]
Web:
PRESS RELEASE
October 12, 2005
CONTACT: Christine Kojoian
Email: [email protected]
U.S.: TURKEY EXERTS EXCESSIVE CONTROL OVER RELIGIOUS ACTIVITY
Says Citizens Don’t Have Right to Practice Faith Freely
Washington, DC – A recent report by the United States Mission to the
Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE) criticized
Turkey for exerting excessive state control over minority religions,
saying the Muslim country risks eroding the centuries-old Ecumenical
Patriarchate of Istanbul, as well as the historic Syriac and Armenian
Orthodox churches.
The report, which was delivered to the OSCE Human Dimension
Implementation Meeting in Warsaw on September 28, also called on
Turkey to clarify the legal status of 55 Protestant Churches that have
been unable to register in Turkey and are vulnerable to closure and
harassment.
“We regret that [Turkish]..authorities continue to inhibit the opening
of places of worship outside the Sunni Muslim mainstream and
systematically disregard the OSCE’s 1990 Bonn Document by
expropriating the properties of religious groups without
compensation,” the U.S. statement said.
Concurrently, the European Court of Human Rights is weighing a
decision on the property rights of two minority foundations in Turkey.
The Soorp Purgich Armenian Hospital Foundation and the Fener Greek
Boys High School Foundation filed cases against Turkey arguing that
they are in compliance with the provisions of the Treaty of Lausanne.
The 1923 Treaty affords protection to foundations that provide public
services for religious minorities.
In both cases, property gifted to the Armenian and Greek foundations
were seized as the Turkish courts upheld orders declaring that the
bequest violated a decree disallowing non-Muslims from donating real
estate. If the court rules in favor of the foundations, hundreds of
buildings seized in the past may be returned.
“The Armenian Assembly commends the OSCE for continuing to closely
monitor religious freedom and minority rights in Turkey,” said
Assembly Board of Directors Chairman Anthony Barsamian. “Rather than
thwart freedom, Turkey must conform to EU standards where individual
freedoms are protected and respected.”
The Armenian Assembly of America is the largest Washington-based
nationwide organization promoting public understanding and awareness
of Armenian issues. It is a 501 (c) (3) tax-exempt membership
organization.
###
NR#2005-102
Editor’s Note: The full text of the U.S. statement can be accessed at
the following link:
_28_05.pdf
Armenian heirs settle $17 million AXA insurance class action
Diane Rumbaugh
Rumbaugh Public Relations
2166 Flintridge Court
Thousand Oaks, CA 91362
805-493-2877
[email protected]
CONTACTS:
Brian S. Kabateck Diane Zakian Rumbaugh
Kabateck Brown Kellner LLP
Rumbaugh Public Relations
213-217-5000
805-493-2877
[email protected]
[email protected]
PRESS RELEASE
October 12, 2005
ARMENIAN HEIRS SETTLE
AXA CLASS ACTION LAWSUIT
Los Angeles, CA – Descendants of victims of the 1915
Armenian Genocide will share a $17 million settlement in a class action
lawsuit brought against French insurance giant AXA for unpaid life
insurance benefits. (Kyurkjian, et. al. v. AXA, Case No: CV 02-01750 and
Ouzounian, et. al., v. AXA, Case No: CV 05-02596, U.S. District Court,
Central District of California).
The class includes Armenians living in the United States and
abroad who are descendants and heirs of policyholders who perished in
what is considered the first genocide of the 20th century. The
settlement, subject to court approval, will be administered in France,
which was one of the first countries to recognize the Armenian Genocide.
AXA is headquartered in France and does business in the United States
through various subsidiaries.
Under the terms of the $17 million settlement, AXA will
donate a minimum of $3 million dollars to various France-based Armenian
charitable organizations and will contribute $11 million towards a fund
designed to pay, under procedures to be determined later, valid claims
of heirs of policyholders and beneficiaries of policies issued by AXA
Group subsidiaries that did business in the Turkish Ottoman Empire prior
to 1915. Certain of these policyholders and beneficiaries were among
the 1.5 million Armenians who perished and were unable to obtain their
insurance proceeds in the ensuing chaos.
The suit is the second of its kind. Class Counsel Vartkes
Yeghiayan, Brian S. Kabateck and Mark J. Geragos–all of Armenian
descent–are internationally representing Armenian descendants in
similar cases. Earlier this year in another class action (Martin
Marootian, et al. v. New York Life Insurance Company), New York Life
agreed to pay $20 million to descendants of Armenian policyholders
killed during the genocide. Attorneys representing the class against AXA
also represented class members in the New York Life case.
Class Counsel praised the efforts of U.S. District Court
Judges Christina Snyder and Dickran Tevrizian for their assistance in
fostering the dialogue that ultimately led to the settlement and also
praised AXA for dealing in a transparent and responsible manner in
bringing this matter to a successful conclusion.
“This is an example where dead men can’t speak but they can
file lawsuits,” says Yeghiayan of Yeghiayan & Associates. “It writes
another chapter about persistence and hope. The resolution of the case
helps the healing process.”
“The AXA and New York Life settlements are important
building blocks not only toward seeking financial recovery for the
losses resulting from the Armenian Genocide but also in our ultimate
goal, which is for Turkey and the U.S. to officially acknowledge the
genocide,” says Geragos of Geragos & Geragos. “These cases are
historical because they are the only cases ever brought on behalf of
genocide survivors.”
“My grandparents lost their entire families in the genocide.
Our continued legal efforts to bring attention to the terrible events of
90 years ago honor their memories,” says Kabateck of Kabateck Brown
Kellner. “Today, AXA made the right decision by agreeing to establish a
claims fund for the heirs of those killed in the Armenian Genocide.”
An announcement will be made shortly on when and how
individuals can file claims under this settlement.
###
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress
AUA Building Bridges with Silicon Valley
PRESS RELEASE
American University of Armenia Corporation
300 Lakeside Drive, 5th Floor
Oakland, CA 94612
Tel: (510) 987-9452
Fax: (510) 208-3576
Email: [email protected]
Web: <;
October 12, 2005
Building a Bridge Between the Silicon Valley and the American University of
Armenia (AUA)
Oakland, CA - Mr. and Mrs. Papken and Claire Der Torossian opened their home
in Saratoga, California, for AUA to host a unique evening dedicated to
promoting cooperation and communication between Silicon Valley executives
and the AUA School of Business and Management.
Dr. Rubina Ohanian, the Dean of the School of Business and Management, an
accomplished marketing solutions specialist with over fifteen years of
consulting and corporate experience, was among the guests. She gave a brief
overview of the MBA program, emphasizing that the School of Business and
Management strives to provide its students with quality instruction and a
state-of-the-art curriculum to help them achieve their professional goals.
Dr. Ohanian spoke very highly of the MBA students' aptitude and the
potential that they have to make a difference to Armenia's future. She
invited the Silicon Valley leaders to support the University, get involved
in the future of its students. Outsourcing of successful Silicon Valley
businesses to Armenia will create job opportunities for our youth.
President Haroutune Armenian shared with the guests that AUA is an
institution of change and transformation, offering its students quality
education, technology and know-how for entrepreneurial endeavors. "As a
student-centered university, the top priority is our students, and our most
important objectives are maintaining academic excellence, becoming a
knowledge enterprise and developing regional role", said Dr. Armenian.
This was an emotional evening for Seta Karamardian, the widow of Stepan
Karamardian, who was the founding Dean of the School of Business and
Management. "Seeing AUA Business School prosper is the realization of my
husband's dream and vision", said Mrs. Karamardian.
Yervant Zorian, Vice President and Chief Scientist at Virage Logic
Corporation, also a member of the American University of Armenia Corporation
(AUAC) Board of Trustees, highlighted the main purpose of the evening, which
is to establish a permanent bridge between the Silicon Valley Armenian
Community and AUA, that will be beneficial to both groups over the years to
come. "AUA is one of the best fruits that the independence of Armenia
resulted in", said Dr. Zorian. "It fully realizes the vision of its three
founders and it has been materialized with the great patronage of AGBU".
Dr. Zorian told the guests that he has had the chance to witness the growth
of AUA at different intervals during the past decade, and has been impressed
with the quality of its programs that Virage Logic employees in Armenia were
offered as part of their continuing education.
It was an informative evening. Some of the guests rediscovered AUA. Many
valuable ideas were exchanged, and pledges for continuous support renewed.
This will help the American University of Armenia to improve its
entrepreneurship programs to enhance the leadership and organization skills
of the students, and to prepare them for active participation in building a
brighter future for Armenia.
W Prelacy: His Holiness Aram I Blesses New Western Prelacy Building
PRESS RELEASE
Western Prelacy
of the Armenian Apostolic Church of America
Archbishop Moushegh Mardirossian
Prelate, Western United States
6252 Honolulu Avenue
La Crescenta, CA 91214
Tel: (818) 248-7737
Fax: (818) 248-7745
Email: [email protected]
For more information:
Zanku Armenian (818) 243-3557
Mercata Group
Catholicos Aram I Blesses New Western Prelacy Building
New Building to Usher in Era of Expanded Spiritual Role in Community
(Los Angeles, CA – October 12, 2005) – Saturday, October 8 marked a historic
day for the Western Prelacy as His Holiness Aram I, Catholicos of the Great
House of Cilicia, blessed the new building that will house the Western
Prelacy headquarters upon completion. The ceremony began with His Holiness
blessing a large cross that was then lifted with a crane and placed on top
of the dome that will house the St. Dertad and St. Ashkhen Chapel in the new
building in La Crescenta. While the building is not yet fully completed,
several hundred guests and clergy attended to witness the Pontiff’s blessing
of the new structure ushering in a new era of expanded spiritual leadership
for the church in the western United States.
Many of the major benefactors who made the building possible were on hand to
take part in the special occasion including Mrs. Ashken Pilavjian and Mr.
and Mrs. John and Asdghig Bedrossian. Following the blessing and placement
of the cross, the Catholicos led a procession of clergy and benefactors into
the building to officially bless the alter inside and the overall building.
“This marks a historic day,” said Archbishop Moushegh Mardirossian, Prelate
of the Western United States. The Archbishop thanked all the benefactors
who made the building possible as well as the tireless efforts of the
Prelacy Executive Council, the Building Committee and others who have worked
very hard to make the building a reality. “When our people work together
for the common good of the community no resources are beyond the reach of
those who take initiative,” the Archbishop continued. The Archbishop also
noted the presence of a representative from the Forest Lawn memorial park
that also made a sizeable donation for the Prelacy building.
His Holiness declared that this is not just a building that will house the
Prelacy’s offices but rather “it is the home of our faith and nation which
will serve our church and people.” The Catholicos also noted the integral
role played by Archbishop Mardirossian and the various benefactors and
committee members who drove the idea and realization of the structure. “May
God bless and look over all those who will care for and work in this
building and the Armenian American community who will support this effort,”
the Pontiff concluded.
The building is expected to be completed within a year at which time all
Prelacy functions will be consolidated at this location from their temporary
location which is currently in Encino.
CENN Weekly Digest – October 12, 2005
Caucasus Environmental NGO Network
(CENN)
Weekly Digest
October 12, 2005
News from Georgia
Italian Businessmen Interested in Agriculture, Food Industry and Tourism
Source: News Agency Sakre (`Mirror’), October 4, 2005
Italy Deputy Minister of Foreign Trade and Productive Activities, Adolfo
Urso has said at an opening ceremony of the second business forum of
Italy and Georgia today, Italian businessmen are interested in
Georgia’s
<; more
Oil spill on Baku-Supsa western pipeline
Source: AssA-Irada News Agency, October 5, 2005
An oil spill took place on the Baku-Supsa western pipeline in the
Gardabani district of Georgia on Wednesday.
<; more
Georgia and Kazakhstan Decided to Continue Cooperation Within
BТС Framwork
Source: Black Sea Press-Turan, October 5, 2005
On October 4 Kazakhstan President Nursultan Nazarbayev and Georgian
President Mikhail Saakashvili signed the joint communiqué on
results of top-level bilateral negotiations in Tbilisi.
<; more
Georgia to Get $20 Million from Wild Bank to Eradicate Poverty
Source: The Georgian Times, October 10, 2005
Georgian state budget will receive USD 20 million from Wild Bank (WB)
this year for primary activities which will lead to eradication of
poverty.
<; more
Georgian Section of BTC to be Commissioned October 12
Source: The Messenger, October 10, 2005
The Georgian section of the Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan (BTC) main export
pipeline will be commissioned on October 12, Georgian President Mikhail
Saakashvili told journalists.
<; more
Dogfights
Source: Nika Tsiklauri, October 10, 2005
On Sunday, 9th of October, near Tbilisi Reservoir, dogfights were held
with participation of about 50 Caucasian Sheepdogs.
<; more
Transportation through Batumi Oil Terminal will be Reduced
Source' `24 Saati' (`24 Hours'),
October 10, 2005
>From the end of October the amount of petroleum transported through
Batumi oil terminal will be significantly reduced. As Prime News was
informed by the representative of oil terminal George Kharazishvili, the
member of BTC consortium
<; more
BTC pipeline's poverty reduction credentials rubbished by new report
Source: Press Release of Bankwatch Network, October 11, 2005
Tbilisi, Georgia A new report out today reveals the real impacts of
BP's Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan (BTC) pipeline and catalogues the
Georgian people's unfulfilled hopes of increased welfare and development
arising from BP's billion dollar project, hopes which have been
fuelled by project backers the World Bank and the European Bank for
Reconstruction and Development (EBRD).
<; more
News From Azerbaijan
Birdwatch Day Held in Azerbaijan
Source: State Telegraph Agency of the Republic of Azerbaijan, October 4,
2005
A Birdwatch Day was held in Gizilgol (Golden Lake) wetland and the
Heydar Aliyev Deepwater Jackets Fabrication territory, Caspian Sea, by
<; more
New Platform to be on Gunashli Filed
Source: State Telegraph Agency of the Republic of Azerbaijan, October 4,
2005
Construction of the new platform in Gunashli structure, one of the
largest oil and gas field of the Azerbaijan sector of the Caspian, will
start in 2006, State Oil Company of Azerbaijan / SOCAR/ has announced.
<; more
ILham Aliyev Has Stated About Reliable Providing of Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan
Source: Turan Informational Agency, October 5, 2005
<; On October 5 the president Ilham Aliyev visited administrative building
of State Guard Service (SGS) and meets with personal staff of the
department. He familiarized with samples of arms, devices that can be
used while acts of terrorism, as well as cars and equipment bought for
protection of export pipelines.
<; more
9-Month Oil and Gas Production Targets Beaten
Source: State Telegraph Agency of the Republic of Azerbaijan, October 6,
2005
According to the State Oil Company of Azerbaijan Republic /SOCAR/, oil
production exceeded the targets by 178,1 thousand tons and made up
6.723.1 thousand tons in January-September, thus, beating 9-month target
by 102,7 percent.
<; more
News From Armenia
Armenia signs deal to upgrade nuclear waste facility
Source: RIA Novosti, Gamlet Matevosyan, October 3, 2005
An agreement to upgrade the radioactive waste management facility at the
Armenian Nuclear Power Plant (NPP) was signed Monday, a senior official
said.
<; more
Armenian Agriculture Minister Calls on U.S. Counterpart
Source: Press Release of Armenian Republic Embassy, October 4, 2005
On September 26, 2005, Armenia's Agriculture Minister Davit Lokian met
with U.S. Agriculture Secretary Mike Johanns to discuss U.S.-Armenian
cooperation in the area of agriculture. Ambassador Tatoul Markarian also
took part in the meeting. Minister Lokian expressed his appreciation for
the past USDA programs in Armenia, which he said strengthened
<; more
Gold Plant Near Lake Sevan
Source: ARMENPRESS, October 5, 2005
Armenian nature protection minister Vartan Ayvazian has endorsed today
the arguments of local ecological non-governmental organizations who
claim that construction of a gold ore processing plant in Vardenis near
Sotk mines would prove catastrophic for environment and especially
Armenia's biggest lake of Sevan, located some miles off.
<; more
Two Ministers: Who Will Win in Fight for Shikahogh Reserve
Source: ARMINFO, October 6, 2005
Minister for Transport and Communication of Armenia Andranik Manukyan
has submitted a project of Armenia-Iran highway to the Ministry of
Nature Protection. The project provides for construction of the highway
via Mtnadzor, 3.5 km area of Shikahogh reserve.
<; more
Aarhus Centers to open in Armenian regions with OSCE support
Source: Latest press release from the Organization for Security and
Co-operation in Europe (OSCE), 6 October, 2005
Local public environmental information Centers (Aarhus Centers) will
soon open in the capitals of the Syunik, Tavush and Lori regions of
Armenia with the help of the OSCE Office in Yerevan, which today signed
an agreement with the Ministry of Nature Protection and local
administrations.
<; more
Armenian-Georgian Working Group Will be Formed to Prepare Feasibility
Study for Fourth Power Line Armenia-Georgia
Source: ARMINFO, October 7, 2005
An Armenian-Georgian working group will be formed shortly to prepare a
feasibility study for construction of a fourth power line
Armenia-Georgia. Armenian Energy Minister Armen Movsisyan told ARMINFO.
<;
more
International News
Preservation of Caspian Sea natural resources is important task for
Government: Kazakhstan Environmental Minister
Source: Kazinform: By Serik Koshkenov, October 3, 2005
During the live broadcast with the Kazakhstan President he was asked
about the situation in the Caspian region, where hydrocarbon production
is performed. The Head of the State noted, the country would always take
care of ecological clearness and enormous fish resources of the Caspian
Sea. First of all every investor should undertake environmental
commitments. Alongside with earth interior exploration we are to
preserve natural resources.
<; more
US Government Unveils Energy Hog to Promote Conservation
Source: Planet Ark, October 4, 2005
Washington - With US heating bills expected to hit record highs this
winter, the Bush administration on Monday launched a conservation
campaign featuring a cartoon mascot "Energy Hog," which critics said
does little to discourage energy use.
<; more
IUCN helps set up transboundary cooperation on water resources
management in White Volta Basin
Source: The World Conservation Union (IUCN), October 4, 2005
`Water is life but it can also be a source of conflict if the two
partners sharing the resource are not collaborating'. As a response
to these opening words of Mr. Gilbert Nuriteg, District Coordinating
Director of Ghana's Garu Tempane Municipality at the first White
Volta Basin Community Consultative Forum, the Forum delegates agreed to
set up a joint transboundary committee of water management associations.
<;
more
Breaking waste laws costs Worcestershire company more than £42,000
Source: Environment Agency: By Oliver Blackburn, October 4, 2005
On Friday (30 September 2005) a Worcester company which ran two illegal
waste dumps was fined £39,000 by Worcester Magistrates.
<; more
Demolition company fined for illegal waste burning
Source: Environment Agency: By Mike Dunning, October 4, 2005
A Dorset demolition company has been ordered to pay £4,079 in fines
and costs after neighbors were plagued by thick black smoke from burning
rubbish. The case was brought by the Environment Agency.
<; more
UK Government to Decide Within Year on New Nuclear Build
Source: Planet Ark, October 4, 2005
London - Britain must decide within a year whether it will invest in a
new wave of nuclear power generation, but no conclusions have yet been
reached, the government said on Sunday.
In a speech to his ruling Labor party's conference last week, Prime
Minister Tony Blair pledged an assessment next year of all Britain's
energy options, including civil nuclear power.
<; more
The CMS Secretariat hosts the 4th meeting of the Biodiversity Liaison
Group
Source: Conservation on Migratory Species (CSM), October 4, 2005
<; The
biodiversity liaison group was established in response to a request from
the Conference of the Parties to the Convention on Biological Diversity
( <; CBD), in order to increase the
collaboration and synergies among biodiversity-related Conventions. The
Convention on Migratory Species was asked to join with CBD, the
Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Flora
and Fauna ( <; CITES), the Ramsar Convention on
Wetlands ( <; Ramsar) and the World Heritage
Convention ( <; WHC) and regularly meet to discuss
priorities and options for collaboration.
<; more
Kyoto Agreement Implementation in Russia will Cost 2 Million Euros
Source: Bellona News, October 5, 2005
Russia will present 2 million euros project for Kyoto agreement
implementation to the European Commission on October 6th.
<; more
Denmark clean but not spotless
European Environmental Agency, October 5, 2005
Denmark is among the European leaders in environmental performance in
areas such as renewable energies, water protection and organic farming,
but there are other areas which could still be improved, says EEA
Executive Director Jacqueline McGlade in an interview in the latest
issue of "MiljøDanmark" in connection with the launch of the Danish
state of the environment report 22 September.
<; more
Bush Pushes For US Oil Refinery Construction
Source: Planet Ark, October 5, 2005
Washington - President Bush Tuesday repeated his call for more oil
refineries to be built in the United States, a need he said was
highlighted by "tight" petroleum supplies and high energy prices caused
by hurricanes Rita and Katrina.
<; more
Climate change and pollution are killing millions, says study
Source: John Vidal, Environment Editor, October 6, 2005
· Poor sanitation to blame, says World Bank report
· Economic growth stalled by environmental factors
Almost a fifth of all ill health in poor countries and millions of
deaths can be attributed to environmental factors, including climate
change and pollution, according to a report from the World Bank.
<; more
NGO News
WWF launches forest and trade network in Vietnam
Source: WWF News, October 3, 2005
Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam - WWF, in partnership with Vietnam's
Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development, will launch the Vietnam
Forest & Trade Network (VFTN), the first ever network to promote
business links between producers of responsible forest products in
Vietnam and concerned buyers around the world.
<; more
Many Dangerous Chemicals in European Blood - WWF
Source: Planet Ark, October 7, 2005
Geneva - European children are absorbing dangerous chemicals into their
blood from computers, textiles, cosmetics and electrical appliances,
according to a new study released on Thursday.
The conservation body WWF said results of its first European Union-wide
family testing survey found a total of 73 man-made hazardous compounds
in the blood of grandmothers, mothers and children from 13 families in
12 countries.
<; more
Legal News
Amendment of Georgian Law on Entrepreneurship
On October 11, 2005 the Ministry of Justice held the Round Table in the
hotel `Tbilisi Marriott'. On the meeting the
representatives of the Corporate Management Group of International
Finance Corporation (IFC) and German Association for Technical
Cooperation (GTZ) represented
<; more
Job, Internship and Study Opportunities
Translator/ Interpreter
Source: The Messenger, October 10, 2005
For the purpose of BP pipeline projects, and under the BP management
supervision, IRA Ltd is seeking to recruit a suitable qualified
individual for the short-term position of Translator/ Interpreter.
Translator/ Interpreter will be a third-party contractor for BP pipeline
construction project in Georgia working under BP management supervision.
<;
more
EASY ECO Training - open online application
Dear Colleagues,
I am happy to announce the next EASY-ECO event, the EASY-ECO Szentendre
Training which will be held from 25th January-3rd February, 2006 here at
the REC. The course explores key elements in sustainability evaluations
and is specifically focused towards bringing together young researchers
with evaluation practitioners as well as local and international experts
in the field. Participants will gain knowledge applicable in practice
and will be able to conduct actual sustainability evaluation projects
after attending the training.
<; more
Seminars, conference and meetings
Health & Wellness Convention 2005 in Costa Rica COSTA RICA
Source: World-Wire, October 5, 2005
There are few environmentalists today who are not aware of how the
increasing proliferation of pollutants, poisons, and toxic compounds in
our earth, air, and water are drastically affecting our physical health.
The medical and pharmaceutical industries have side-stepped the issue,
preferring to market symptom-masking drugs rather than confront the
corporate takeover of our health and well-being.
<; more
Announcement
BP Publishes Sustainability Report 2004
Source: The Messenger, October 10, 2005
According to a report released by BP on October 7, the oil giant has
spent nearly USD 2 million on social projects through out the country,
funding everything from repair to heritage projects in an effort to
encourage `sustainability' in the country.
<; more
Courageous Baku-Ceyhan pipeline film wins festival prizes
Source: Media Advisory, October 10, 2005
Prague, Czech Republic -- A documentary film about the social and
environmental implications of BPs Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan (BTC) pipeline in
Azerbaijan was awarded prizes at two prestigious film festivals this
weekend. The Source, a joint Bionaut-CEE Bankwatch Network production
shot by Czech director Martin Marecek, received the international jury
prize and an award from the Czech Ministry of Environment at the Ekofilm
festival in Cesky Krumlov, Czech Republic and was also awarded the prize
<;
more
**************************************************************************
Subscribing Information
CENN lists are created to maintain e-mail discussions of Caucasus
Environmental NGO Network members. CENN has been distributing
information since 1998.
All the published digests and bulletins issued in both English and
Russian languages present incredibly rich environmental information base
that give the reader the whole picture of the environmental process
taking place during the recent 5 years in the South Caucasus region as
well as abroad.
To subscribe or unsubscribe from CENN mailing list service, please send
an email to
`subscribe’ or `unsubscribe’ command as
the first line of the message body.
If you would like the information about your organization and activities
to be distributed via the CENN mailing lists (the current number of CENN
mailing list members represents 11049), if you want your voice to be
heard around the world, please send your information at the following
email:
For more information about the program, please visit CENN web-page:
<;
CENN INFO
Caucasus Environmental NGO Network (CENN)
Tel:++995 32 75 19 03/04
Fax:+995 32 75 19 05
E-mail:
URL:
The Vatican: Summary Of Synod Of Bishops: October 11 – 12
Vatican Information Service
10.12.2005
SUMMARY OF SYNOD OF BISHOPS: OCTOBER 11 – 12
Fourteenth General Congregation
Fifteenth General Congregation
VATICAN CITY, OCT 11, 2005 (VIS) – During the Fourteenth General
Congregation of the Eleventh Ordinary General Assembly of the Synod of
Bishops, held this afternoon in the Vatican’s Synod Hall, apart from
speeches by the Synod Fathers, the fraternal delegates were given an
opportunity to address the gathering. The president delegate on duty was
Cardinal Juan Sandoval Iniguez.
At the start of this afternoon’s session, Archbishop Nikola Eterovic,
secretary general of the Synod of Bishops, recalled that today is the 43rd
anniversary of the opening of Vatican Council II and the feast of Blessed
John XXIII.
Following are excerpts of some of the speeches delivered by fraternal
delegates and Synod Fathers:
METROPOLITAN JOHANNIS ZIZIOULAS OF PERGAMO, GREECE. “It is a great honor for
me to be given the opportunity to address this venerable episcopal Synod and
bring to it the fraternal greetings and best wishes of the Ecumenical
Patriarch Bartholomew and the Church of Constantinople. The invitation to
our Church to send a fraternal delegate to this Synod is a gesture of great
ecumenical significance. We respond to it with gratitude and love. We
Orthodox are deeply gratified by the fact that your Synod also regards the
Eucharist as the source and summit of the life and mission of the Church. It
is extremely important that Roman Catholics and Orthodox can say this with
one voice. There may still be things that separate our two Churches but we
both believe that the Eucharist is the heart of the Church. It is on this
basis that we can continue the official theological dialogue of our two
Churches, which is now entering a new phase. Eucharistic ecclesiology can
guide us in our efforts to overcome a thousand years of separation. For it
is a pity to hold the same conviction of the importance of the Eucharist but
not be able to share it at the same table.”
REV. FILIPPO VAYLTSEV OF THE PATRIARCHATE OF MOSCOW, RUSSIA. “The Eucharist
is the central and most important point of the life of the Church and of
every Christian. Hence, the weakening of Eucharistic awareness leads to a
destruction of ecclesiastic awareness, … and to errors in the
understanding of Christian values. … We would be very pleased if our
experience of Eucharistic life, both past and present, proves useful and
helpful to the Roman Catholic Church. … It must not be forgotten that
preparation for communion in the Russian Orthodox Church also includes,
apart from inner preparation, ‘The Rule’ (strict fasting for three days,
visits to Church during these three days, prayers for communion, and special
Eucharistic fasting after midnight), and Confession is also compulsory.
However, these strict rules are seen by the Church not as an obligation, but
as a measure that was formed historically in accordance with tradition, and
that people apply to themselves.”
MOR SEVERIUS MALKE MOURAD OF THE SYRO-ORTHODOX PATRIARCHATE, SYRIA. “In our
Syrian Orthodox Church, we celebrate the divine liturgy in Syriac-Aramaic,
the language of our Lord Jesus; and during the divine liturgy the very same
words which Jesus said in the Upper Room are recited. And the priest who
celebrates this Sacrament, has to celebrate it alone. I feel proud that I
live in the Monastery of St. Mark in the Old City of Jerusalem, where Jesus
had His Last Supper. … The presence of Christ in the Holy Eucharist is not
only His bodily presence, but all His fullness in humanity and divinity. So
Lord Jesus is present in all parts of the two elements. … St. Paul the
Apostle exhorts the believer to spiritually prepare himself before he comes
to receive holy communion with faith, reverence and a pure conscience, and
should cleanse his body and observe the pre-communion fast at 12 midnight.
We used to give the sacraments of holy communion to the children immediately
after they receive the sacraments of Baptism and Confirmation.”
BISHOP NAREG (MANOUG) ALEMEZIAN, ECUMENICAL OFFICIAL OF THE GREAT HOUSE OF
CILICIA, ARMENIA. “The Armenian word used to designate the Holy Eucharist is
‘Surp Patarag,’ which means holy sacrifice. In the liturgical life of the
Church we are at God’s service (liturgy) and offer sacrifice of thanksgiving
(Eucharist) for gifts received from Him. Holy Eucharist is centered on the
sacrificial giving of our Savior and generating a communion of love with God
and our fellow beings by the power of the Holy Spirit. … In assessing the
constructive role of bilateral and multilateral ecumenical dialogues in
discussing the theme of ‘Church as Communion,’ I encourage all of us to
engage in the study of Eucharistic ecclesiology, which situates the unity of
the Church in the local celebration of the Holy Eucharist presided over by
the bishop in communion with his brother bishops. In this respect, the
distinctive role of the bishop is underlined as the one who takes care of
the flock entrusted to him by the Good Shepherd, tending it with a love that
is most fully revealed in the Eucharistic partaking of the one bread for a
spiritual and universal communion in the mystical Body of Christ.”
BISHOP LUIGI PADOVESE O.F.M. Cap., APOSTOLIC VICAR OF ANATOLIA, TURKEY. “I
speak as bishop of the Church of Anatolia, an area that saw the first great
expansion of Jesus’ message and in which Christians are now reduced to just
a few thousand. The only Christians in the city of Tarsus, homeland of the
Apostle Paul, are three nuns who welcome pilgrims; pilgrims who must get a
permit in order to celebrate the Eucharist in the only remaining
church-museum. The same is true for the church-museum of St. Peter in
Antioch. In that city was born John Chrysostom, the 16th centenary of whose
death in exile falls in 2007. With his homilies, Chrysostom reminds us that
the Eucharist was and is the privileged place for announcing Christ. His
memory, as well as the more recent recollection of bishops such as Clemens
von Galen and Oscar Romero, is a living testimony of the bond between the
memorial of Jesus’ sacrifice and the people who found therein the motivation
and strength for a proclamation undertaken with intelligence and courage and
frankness.”
Raffi Hovannisian continues political consultations
Noyan Tapan Highlights” N41
October, 2005
October 10, 2005
Raffi Hovannisian continues political consultations and starts meetings in
Armenian regions
Yerevan–Raffi Hovannisian, founder and head of the Armenian Center for
National and International Studies, Chairman of the Zharangutiun
(“Heritage”) party, starts a series of meetings with representatives of
public and his supporters in different regions of the country. Raffi
Hovannisian informed representatives of mass media about it at the reception
in honor of the 11th anniversary of foundation of the Center. It’s supposed
that during these meetings he will explain party’s negative position on
draft constitutional amendments put to the referendum. Other issues worrying
the Armenian society will be also discussed during the numerous scheduled
meetings.
In his open address, R.Hovannisian also confirmed that he continues
political consultations on the issue of cooperation with both
representatives of opposition and civil society and the representatives of
Armenian power who realize the seriousness of the situation formed in the
country and the necessity in radical changes.
Mr. Hovannisian considers that the most important task at the current stage
is to hold the referendum exactly in correspondence with the international
obligations assumed by Armenia. He especially emphasized that all the stages
of the process should be democratic and transparent, starting from the
moment of agitation up to the calculation of votes, which should guarantee
the trust of the society in the referendum results.
At best Turkey may Become EU member only together with Armenia.
“We have to state loud and clear that Turkey’s aspirations to become a
member of the European Union correspond with Armenia’s political interests,”
Raffi Hovannisian stated. “It is foreseeable that in its best-case scenario
Turkey can only become an EU member in synchronization with the Republic of
Armenia, and in the process it will have to undergo serious and irreversible
reforms, confront its history, reject any imperial ambitions, and so forge a
comprehensive resolution of all outstanding matters with Armenia,” he
stressed.
In the opinion of R. Hovannisian, the animosity may and should grow into a
partnership, of which the past and current relations between Germany and
Russia, Germany and France, Germany and Israel, or the US and Japan bear
evidence. “In order completely to uncover and acknowledge the historical
truth, we must support Turkey’s pioneers, the growing intellectual movement
which is the brave resumption of those exceptional precedents in 1915 and
beyond when thousands of Turkish families, at the risk of losing their own
lives, endeavored to hide and save individual Armenians from certain death.
My grandmother owed her life to one such righteous family of heroes, who to
this day remain unsung because of official Turkish denialism,” R.
Hovannisian stated.
He proposed the following peace initiative of the Armenian side: ” As a
means of building mutual trust, Armenia might invite bilateral consideration
of the idea of creating, under UN or UNESCO auspices, an international and
demilitarized free economic and cultural Belt of Civilization around the
medieval Armenian capital of Ani and the Biblical slopes of Mt. Ararat.” In
his view, in a short period of time this zone may become an international
tourist center, thus developing the deserted regions of both countries and
creating an opportunity for an uunprecedented bilateral cooperation.
“Foreign policy is privatized just like country’s economy”
“We simply do not have the right to entrust our nation’s destiny to those
who have appropriated its foreign policy in the same way as they have done
with the economy, turning one and the other into a shadow structure driven
by personal gain,” Raffi Hovannisian declared in his open address. According
to him, such a conduct became the reason of the fact that “this mode of
operation has made a mockery of the national interest, has alienated the
country’s citizens from their authorities, and has shaken the foundations of
our once-national solidarity. From the standard-bearer of democracy and
liberty in the region, Armenia is now retreating to the backwaters of
cynical authoritarian dominion.”
Monopoly in policy is so much dengerous as in economy, Raffi Hovannisian
highlighted. In summer we became the witnesses and victims of destructive
consequences of such a monopoly. The telephone and computer sphere having
strategic importance is meant here.
In reply to a possible question, why the subject of complete political and
economic monopoly doesn’t become an occasion for everyday anxiety of mass
media, Raffi Hovannisian said: “Because after the shutdown of “A1+” and
“Noyan Tapan” an indirect monopoly has been established in the public
information realm as well.”
“The weakening of democracy gives birth to monopoly, whereas monopoly
strangles the economy, diplomacy, and ultimately democracy itself,” first RA
Foreign Minister emphasized.
R.Hovannisian declared that “as the incumbent administration continues to
pacify itself and the public with economic growth figures, prestigious
international bodies confirm that more than half of the country’s national
product, and thus of its taxation sphere, is hidden in the shadow,
consequently circumventing the official budget and the citizens’ shares in
it.”
One more chance to connect struggle against terrorism with Artsakh conflict
was missed
“This summer the world was shocked by the attacks of terror in London. The
voices of Armenia and Armenians were all but unheard among the many which
condemned those violent acts,” Raffi Hovannisian mentioned. While, according
to him, “the Armenian leaders’ ineptitude in taking our decisive say on the
anti-terrorism front to the world and duly underscoring our commitment is
sidelining the nation from global developments and is belittling the value
and meaning of our casualties to the common cause.”
In R.Hovannisian’s opinion, the authorities missed one more opportunity to c
onnect the general struggle against terrorism with the Artsakh conflict in
the best way. “It was the opportune time to remind the civilized world that,
only a few years ago, the people of Artsakh who were battling for their
right to live also had come face to face with Afghan mujahaddins and
mercenary pilots bombing civilian targets in peaceful towns. By failing to
present to the world the captured foreign mercenaries and the documents
confiscated from them as hard evidence of our noteworthy contribution to the
war on international terror, the mediocre official and his obsequious
diplomacy once again turned out to be spineless.”
“While abroad they were telling duplicitous tales about their own integrity,
they failed widely to publicize the fact that during the
Karabagh-Azerbaijani war the adversary’s positions in Shushi were defended
by the notorious Shamil Bassaev, who later on organized the pogrom of
hundreds of innocent people in allied Russia. Not surprisingly, the heroic
stand of Artsakh in the name of human rights and liberties, which once
enjoyed worldwide support, has turned into a mere territorial issue being
examined within the strictures of international bureaucracy,” Raffi
Hovannisian declared.
F18News: Turkey – Is there religious freedom in Turkey?
FORUM 18 NEWS SERVICE, Oslo, Norway
The right to believe, to worship and witness
The right to change one’s belief or religion
The right to join together and express one’s belief
================================================
Wednesday 12 October 2005
TURKEY: IS THERE RELIGIOUS FREEDOM IN TURKEY?
The European Union (EU) must make full religious freedom for all a core
demand in the EU membership negotiations with Turkey which have just
begun, argues Otmar Oehring of the German Catholic charity Missio
<; in
this personal commentary for Forum 18 News Service
<;. Dr Oehring also calls for people inside and
outside Turkey who believe in religious freedom for all to honestly and
openly raise the continuing obstructions to the religious life of Turkey's
Muslim, Christian and other religious communities. He analyses the limited,
complex and changing state of religious freedom in the country. In
particular, he notes that Christians of all confessions, devout Muslim
women, Muslim minorities, and other minority religions face official
obstacles in practicing their faith and (in the case of non-Muslims)
strong social hostility.
TURKEY: IS THERE RELIGIOUS FREEDOM IN TURKEY?
By Otmar Oehring, head of the human rights office of Missio
<;
Go to any mosque or church in Turkey and you will see people worshipping.
So clearly some religious freedom exists. Yet serious problems persist.
Religious communities are not allowed to organise themselves as they
choose. Individual religious freedom exists up to a point. For example,
you are entitled by law to change your religion and to have the change
recorded on your identity documents, but people who have done so have
faced hostility from fellow-citizens. As soon as a religious community
wants to organise itself, problems arise. This holds just as much for
Muslims as for communities of other faiths.
Although many Turks dislike the term "State Islam", it has to be stated
that Islam is organised by the state. Sunnis who consider this an
unacceptable innovation are not allowed to organise. Although Sufi orders
exist, some even with a vast membership, they have been officially
forbidden banned since the 1920s.
The main problem religious communities identify is their lack of legal
status as religious communities. In the late Ottoman period some religious
minorities had legal status under the millet system, but the Islamic
community had no separate legal status as the state was considered to be
Islamic. But since the founding of the Turkish republic, any such status
has disappeared. Some Muslims are concerned about this lack of legal
status, especially minority Muslim groups within the dominant Sunni
majority, as well as the Alevis, Shias and the Sufi orders. But few
Muslims are prepared to voice their demands for legal status openly, for
fear of imprisonment, although in recent years the Alevis have become more
vocal. This has led to their gaining some recognition as associations,
though not as religious bodies.
Religious meetings and services without authorisation remain illegal,
though it remains unclear in law what constitutes legal and illegal
worship. The Ottoman millet system recognised some religious minorities
and the 1923 Lausanne Treaty spoke vaguely of religious minority rights
without naming them, but the Turkish authorities interpret this to exclude
communities such as the Roman Catholics, Syriac Orthodox and Lutherans,
even though these communities have found ways to function. Protestant
Christian churches functioning quietly in non-recognised buildings are
generally tolerated, but Muslims gathering outside an approved mosque are
viewed as a threat to the state and police will raid them.
It is not possible for most Protestant Christian churches to be recognised
as churches under current Turkish law. But in one bizarre case, a German
Christian church was recognised in Antalya, but only by calling itself a
"chapel" not a "church." Most Evangelical Protestant churches in Turkey do
not meet in private homes, but in rented facilities such as office
buildings or other non-residential buildings. These can be fairly large.
The Law on Associations - adopted by Parliament in October 2004 - does not
allow the founding of associations with a religious purpose, so founding a
religious discussion group or even a religious freedom group is
impossible, even if some religious communities do try to register as
associations. Some Sufi orders and new Islamic movements have registered
as businesses, even with religious names.
However, the government has changed the building planning laws, replacing
the word "mosque" with "place of worship". The government indicated to
Protestant churches that individuals cannot ask for buildings to be
designated as a place of worship, but individual congregations should try
to get recognition as a legal personality first (as a "Dernek" or society)
and then try to get their meeting place designated as a place of worship.
At least two Protestant churches are now trying this route.
There are currently two Protestant churches that are legally recognised by
the Turkish state, one of which is in Istanbul. It was recognised as a
"Vakf" (charitable foundation) several years ago, after a long court
battle, making it a legal entity. Several weeks ago, they finally had
their building officially designated as a place of worship. The second
example is the Protestant church in Diyarbakir, which has legal
recognition as a house of worship under the Ministry of Culture, as a
heritage site.
Religious education remains tightly controlled. In law such education must
be carried out by the state, although in practice Christian churches -
Armenian Apostolic, Orthodox, Catholic and Protestant - have been able to
provide catechetical training to their children on church premises. The
state turns a blind eye to this. But Koranic courses are different.
Officially they should take place only under the guidance of the state,
yet some 6,000 such courses are widely spoken of as existing
clandestinely. Many officials and police officers have good contacts with
them, while many senior officials and parliamentarians have been members
of Sufi orders which officially do not exist or are forbidden.
It is generally impossible to found higher education establishments for
Muslims, Christians and others. The Armenian Apostolic and the Greek
Orthodox seminaries were closed down in the 1970s and the government has
resisted all attempts to reopen them. Protestants cannot normally
establish Bible colleges. However, an Evangelical Bible college functions
in Selcuk; it is not government recognised and accredited, but it has been
providing theological training for several years. Christian clergy and
pastors mostly have to train abroad. Alevi Muslims do not tend to demand
religious colleges, as they are led not by imams but by elders who are
initiated by other elders.
The Law on Construction - which came into force into July 2003 - makes it
possible to "establish" places of worship. But the law - probably
deliberately - does not define if this means "build", "rent" or "buy".
Protestant churches face problems trying to build. Any community wishing
to build a place of worship officially can do so in an area with a minimum
number of adherents of their faith - but the state decides if the community
has enough members to get the land it needs. There is no authoritative
definition of how the law should be interpreted. The Justice Minister said
recently that religious communities intending to establish a place of
worship should apply, but how can religious communities apply if
officially they cannot exist?
Government officials do not want to acknowledge that Alevi Muslims cannot
officially establish places of worship. The government is building Sunni
mosques in many Alevi villages, but Alevis will not go to them. Instead
they meet openly for worship in cemevis (meeting houses), not only in
central Anatolia but even in Istanbul. The government stated in parliament
in 2004 that such Alevi cemevis are not to be considered as places of
worship. Although many of them still function unimpeded, some have been
closed down in recent years.
Conversion from one faith to another is possible, even from Islam, under
the law on personal status (though you cannot be listed officially as an
atheist or agnostic). If you convert from Islam you can change your faith
on your identity papers, but being Muslim on your identity card makes
day-to-day life easier. Christians, Baha'is or Jehovah's Witnesses are
often unable to find employment, especially in rural areas. So many who
have converted from Islam to another faith prefer to leave their religious
designation on their identity papers unchanged. According to information
given by the Minister of State in charge of Religious Affairs this autumn,
during the last ten years fewer than 400 people officially converted to
Christianity and only about 10 to Judaism.
Islam is controlled by the Presidency of Religious Affairs, or Diyanet
<;, which is directed
from the Prime Minister's office. This was deliberately established not as
a government ministry, as Turkey claims to be a secular state. Some Muslims
do object to this state control, especially those from newer groups, such
as the Nurcu movement, the Suleymanci, followers of Fethullah Gulen, and
members of Sufi orders.
Some religious communities can officially invite foreign religious
workers. The Catholics can under the 1923 Lausanne Treaty invite foreign
priests up to a certain number, though even then the government makes this
difficult, asking why the Church needs so many priests when there are so
few Catholics. It is more difficult for Protestant communities, as
officially they do not exist as religious communities. Foreign religious
workers who come to Turkey under some other guise can face problems, if
the government finds out about them. As long as the state does not have to
know about their activity they can function, but as soon as the state is
forced to take official notice of them, they can face problems. The
government knows about most, if not all, Protestant missionaries, because
these made a conscious decision to be open about what they are doing.
Occasionally they experience some problems but - with occasional
exceptions - the government merely monitors what they do, leaving them
otherwise undisturbed.
All religious communities are under state surveillance, with religious
minorities facing the closest scrutiny. Christian leaders know they are
listened in to and their telephones are tapped. The Ecumenical Patriarch
states that "walls have ears," even when speaking within his own
Patriarchate in the Fener district of Istanbul. Police visit individual
Christian churches to ask who attends, which foreigners have visited, what
they discussed. They are particularly interested in which Turkish citizens
attend.
Are such visits a threat, or do the intelligence agencies just want to
know what is going on? When the police attend Catholic services in Ankara,
they say they are there to protect Christians. From my conversations with
church members, I'm sure this is not true.
When secularism was proclaimed as a guiding state principle in line with
French laïcité it was sincerely meant. Kemal Ataturk and his followers
aimed to crush Islam. Later on, officials understood that society was not
willing to follow this line. Slowly, Islam returned to schools and other
areas of life. Now Turkey is a Sunni Muslim state. All those whose mother
tongue is Turkish and are Sunni Muslims are considered Turks. Alevis,
Kurds, Christians and all other minorities are not considered Turks - they
are considered as foreigners.
The furore over headscarves - a genuine concern to devout Muslim women -
was exploited as a political issue by Islamist parties, eager to
demonstrate their opposition to the military authorities which had banned
Islamic dress after the 1980 coup. Had there been no headscarf ban, there
would have been no problem. This point was illustrated by the case of a
non-political devout Muslim, Leyla Sahin. She was barred from wearing a
headscarf in Istanbul University in her fifth year of medical studies and
subsequently successfully completed medical studies at Vienna University
in Austria. This disturbing ban - which de jure bars devout Muslim women
from universities - is currently under consideration by a Grand Chamber of
the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR). (See
<; for more on this and other ECHR
cases.)
In rural Sunni areas women have always worn headscarves - though not the
type seen in Iran or Saudi Arabia - which some women have tried to wear in
towns. In some cases, supporters of the Refah (Welfare) party and others
have paid women to wear such scarves. Even nationalist politicians say
that if women are free to choose whether to wear a headscarf or not, many
who have worn them for political reasons would no longer wish to do so.
Societal opposition to minorities of all sorts does impact on religious
freedom. Such social pressure is felt most keenly among the poor. Members
of the urban middle class who convert from Islam to other faiths can
freely practise their new faith. In Izmir a Christian church exists where
many young converts of university background attend unchallenged. But
openly converting to and practising a non-Islamic faith is often
impossible in poor neighbourhoods. In former Armenian-populated areas of
Anatolia - where there are also people of Syriac descent - many families
changed their formal identification to Muslims, but did not convert in
reality. Their attempts to practise Christianity face enormous obstacles
unless they move to Istanbul or even to Ankara. Back in these towns and
villages are no Christian churches, so anyone wanting to meet for
Christian worship could be dragged off to the police or suffer beatings.
One former Interior Minister stated that Christians should only conduct
missionary activity among such people of Christian descent. He estimated
the numbers of such people at between 800,000 and three million people.
You have to be very courageous to set up a Protestant church in remote
areas, as pastor Ahmet Guvener found in Diyarbakir. Problems can come from
neighbours and from the authorities. Even if not working hand in hand,
neighbours and officials share the same hostility. They cannot understand
why anyone would convert to Christianity. People are not upset seeing old
Christian churches - Syriac Orthodox and other Christian churches have
always existed in Anatolia - but seeing a new Protestant church, even when
housed in a shop or private flat, arouses hostility.
Officials vary in their attitudes. The Kemalist bureaucracy follows
Ataturk's secularist line and is against anything religious. There is a
nationalist, chauvinistic wing of officialdom which believes that anything
not Turkish is a threat to be countered. The security and intelligence
services, including the powerful military, are both Kemalist and
nationalist. Anyone considered not to be Turkish and not Sunni Muslim
faces problems. Even Sunni Muslim Kurds are excluded, while Alevi Kurds
are regarded as even worse.
It is very difficult to imagine that in the next decade or so Turkish
society will change to allow full religious freedom. To take one example,
for the change to be conceivable the chauvinistic content of primary and
secondary school education - constant praise of Ataturk, Turkey and all
things Turkish - will have to change. Unless this happens, it is very hard
to imagine Turkey evolving into an open society that is truly ready to
accept European Union (EU) human rights requirements. One non-religious
illustration of the lack of openness in Turkish society is the near
impossibility of free discussion of the genocide of 1.5 million Armenians
and Assyrians in the last years of the Ottoman empire, along with
continued official denial that the genocide took place.
Christian churches have welcomed the prospect of Turkish EU accession,
often due to their own communities' experience and hopes. If negotiations
last for more than a few years some improvements for religious minorities
- including Islamic minorities - might be possible.
Sadly, there appears to be not enough interest among diplomats in Ankara
from EU member states - or in their foreign ministries back home - in
promoting religious freedom in Turkey. The EU has forced the Turkish
government to change the Law on Foundations. This law governs inter alia
community foundations (cemaat vakıflar) that act as the owners of the
real estate of Armenians, Bulgarians, Greeks and Jews, who are treated by
the government as minorities within the meaning of the Treaty of Lausanne
as well as some of the properties of the Chaldean Catholic, Syrian
Catholic and Syrian Orthodox Christians, who are not treated by the
government as minorities within the meaning of the Treaty of Lausanne. But
reforms will have to go much deeper for Turkey to meet the EU's stated
'Copenhagen criteria' of being "a stable democracy, respecting human
rights, the rule of law, and the protection of minorities." The EU must
make full religious freedom for all, including for Muslims, a core demand.
Full religious freedom would bring with it an increase in the influence of
Islam, which some think would endanger the western orientation of Turkey.
Possibly this is the reason that the EU has not pushed Turkey harder on
religious freedom. However, it is unwise to see the relationship with
Turkey through such "war-against-terror spectacles." It is vital for the
future of Turkey that full religious freedom be a core demand, so that
Turkish democracy can be strengthened to the point that it can in
democratic ways cope with the hostility of some Islamic groups.
With so little apparent interest in pushing for full religious freedom
from within the EU, local religious communities within Turkey will have to
take the lead. They are starting to challenge the denial of their rights
through the courts. Protestant Christians have been doing this for almost
10 years, usually with success. The Ecumenical Patriarchate, however, has
failed to regain a former orphanage it ran on an island near Istanbul
through the High Court in Ankara. It is now taking the case to the
European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) in Strasbourg, to which Turkey is
subject as a member of the Council of Europe. I believe this is the right
way for such communities to defend their rights and others are already
following. The Alevi Muslims have told the government that, if they
continue to be denied religious education in state schools to their
children according to their own teaching, they too will go to the ECHR.
Denial of legal status to religious communities is another possible ECHR
case.
The most important thing is to put religious freedom on the agenda and
talk openly of the problems with full knowledge of the nuances and
complexities of the situation.
It is important to challenge Turkey's restrictions on religious freedom
using Article 9 of the European Convention on Human Rights, which Turkey
signed in 1954. This article guarantees "freedom of thought, conscience
and religion; this right includes freedom to change his religion or
belief, and freedom, either alone or in community with others and in
public or private, to manifest his religion or belief, in worship,
teaching, practice and observance." This should be the basis for all
discussion of religious freedom, not the 1923 Lausanne Treaty, with its
highly restrictive approach to religious freedom.
Turkish religious communities will have to speak more on the importance of
religious freedom to the outside world, though they will have to be wise in
the way they do this. Religious minority leaders are in a difficult
situation: they believe that they have to argue in favour of negotiations
on EU membership, however sceptical they might be about how ready Turkish
society is to make the necessary changes.
Foreign churches and religious communities should be talking to their own
governments, to press them to promote religious freedom in Turkey. They
will have to convince them they are not simply advocating greater rights
for their co-religionists but truly advocate religious freedom for all in
Turkey, including Muslims.
The big question remains: do the Turkish government and people have the
will to allow full religious freedom for all? The Turkish media speculates
that the current government might not be in favour of EU membership, but is
merely using this as a way to introduce domestic developments to achieve
Islamist aims. The suggestion put forward in the media is that, if
democracy develops, the military will be prevented from mounting a coup
and so there will no longer be any obstacle to Islamist aims.
Whether or not this media speculation reflects reality, all those who
believe in religious freedom in Turkey - both within the country and
abroad - must keep the issue on the domestic and international agenda -
and be honest about the continuing obstructions to religious life of
Turkey's Muslim, Christian and other religious communities.
(END)
Dr Otmar Oehring, head of the human rights office at Missio
<;, a
Catholic mission based in the German city of Aachen, contributed this
comment to Forum 18 News Service. Commentaries are personal views and do
not necessarily represent the views of F18News or Forum 18.
A printer-friendly map of Turkey is available at
<;Rootmap=turkey>
For a personal commentary on religious freedom under Islam, see
< gt;
For a personal commentary assessing western European "headscarf laws," see
<;.
(END)
© Forum 18 News Service. All rights reserved. ISSN 1504-2855
You may reproduce or quote this article provided that credit is given to
F18News
Past and current Forum 18 information can be found at
x/12
Sunday, October 09, 2005
********************************
To understand is to forgive. But since human understanding, unlike divine understanding, is limited, our forgiveness is bound to be tainted. The best we can do is to say we will not allow our enemy’s character and conduct to define our sentiments and thoughts.
*
To understand another means to see oneself in him because “nothing human is alien to me.” Which may explain why Dostoevsky wrote with some understanding and sympathy about an ax-murderer of old ladies (CRIME AND PUNISHMENT), Nabokov about a child molester (LOLITA), and Richard Stark (real name Donald Westlake) about a ruthless killer (POINT BLANK).
*
To be brainwashed means to have a fraction of our brain paralyzed.
*
Prejudice is like a knife that maims and castrates our thinking organ.
*
I have been exposed to too many patriotic speeches by charlatans to have any respect for verbal professions of patriotism.
#
Monday, October 10, 2005
***********************************
TWO MEN OF INTEGRITY
************************************
Thomas Bernhard was an Austrian writer who hated his fellow Austrians with a passion. No other writer has been as relentless as he in his excoriations of his fellow countrymen. Our Raffi too was very critical of Armenians but in his fiction he also created a good number of heroes and noble specimens of humanity. Baronian, Odian, and Massikian couched their attacks in humor and satire. Zarian’s trajectory from great expectations to despair and disgust was gradual and he was careful to confide his denunciations in his correspondence with friends, diaries and notebooks that were published only posthumously. Thomas Bernhard’s hatred seems to have been born in his cradle and continued all the way to his grave at the age of 58. But since he was widely translated and admired throughout the world, the Austrians had little choice but to award him a prestigious literary prize in the hope of that flattery may mollify him. It had the opposite effect. In his acceptance speech Bernhard delivered such a scathing attack on Austrian double-talk, mediocrity, intolerance, and fascism that the Austrian Minister of Culture and half of the audience walked out on him. I dare you not to love and admire such a man!
*
When a prominent Soviet official died, a good number of Soviet personalities in the arts, among them Shostakovich, were invited to deliver eulogies. As it was to be expected, all the brown-nosers emphasized the positive and ignored the negative in the deceased, all except Shostakovich who chose to emphasize only the negative by exposing the man’s dishonesty and opportunism. Which is why, ever since I read this, I have had a soft spot for Shostakovich, whose music I also love not because it is elegant, refined, deep, intricate, or noble but because it has a propulsive and sometimes gut-wrenching forward drive.
#
Tuesday, October 11, 2005
***********************************
Bad news for our massacre pundits: as the number of tragedies around the world rises, the magnitude of our own goes down. This phenomenon is also known as “compassion fatigue.” As a result, the more we talk about our tragedy, the more sympathizers we lose. I suggest therefore, “Less is more.”
*
Our massacre pundits remind me of the survivors of another holocaust in the Old Testament who looked back and turned into pillars of salt.
*
If a friend “is a masterpiece of nature” (Emerson), what is an enemy if not a curse from hell.
*
It is not easy educating those who are infatuated with their own ignorance.
*
I have written over a thousand commentaries and letters and I am proud to announce none of them ends with Comrade Panchoonie’s punch line, “Mi kich pogh oughargetsek” (Send us a little money). I am thus in a position to say to my readers, “If dissatisfied, your money will be cheerfully refunded.”
#
Wednesday, October 12, 2005
************************************
What’s wrong with assimilation, an assimilated reader demands to know. Nothing, if the assimilation is driven by necessity such economic conditions, unemployment and destitution. But if the economic conditions are results of a corrupt and incompetent administration, then emigration and assimilation become our collective responsibility. Assimilation in the Diaspora is less a result of economic conditions and more of internal conflicts, divisions, mutual intolerance, and inept leadership. In which case, assimilation or “white massacre” may be said to be the death of a thousand self-inflicted cuts.
*
Another reader wants to know why I am against millionaires? I am not, provided they mind their own business and don’t get involved in culture and politics, because where benefactors enter, brown-nosers rise to the top. It is worth remembering that plutocracy and democracy are mutually exclusive concepts, and a developed wallet means an underdeveloped intellect.
#