STATUS OF U.S. AMBASSADOR TO ARMENIA QUESTIONED
By Lisa Friedman, Washington Bureau
Los Angeles Daily News
Pasadena Star-News, CA
March 21 2006
WASHINGTON – Members of California’s congressional delegation are
questioning reports that the U.S. ambassador to Armenia is being
recalled because he referred to the 1915 massacre of Armenians in
Ottoman Turkey as a genocide.
In separate letters sent to Secretary of State Condoleeza Rice,
Reps. Adam Schiff, D-Pasadena and Grace Napolitano, D-Santa Fe Springs,
demanded answers about Ambassador John Marshall Evans’ status. Both
strongly opposed recalling him.
Schiff said he reiterated that message last week in a closed-door
meeting with State Department officials.
“I expressed my opposition to any disciplinary action being taken
against the ambassador for speaking the truth,” Schiff said. “I made
it very clear I thought any action taken against him would merely
compound the erroneous policy of the administration.’
A State Department spokesman insisted that Evans has not submitted
his resignation nor told to return. That, however, hasn’t quelled
persistent rumors in California’s sizable Armenian-American community.
“It’s a big issue here. It’s very concerning and very upsetting,”
said Zaku Armenian, a member of the Armenian National Committee’s
board in Glendale.
“The word that we have is pretty clear that this is in the works,”
Armenian said about Evans’ recall. “It’s clear that the State
Department is bowing to pressure from Turkey.”
Evans attracted wide attention in Armenian-American communities
last year when he unequivocally called the massacre of Armenians in
post-World War I Ottoman Turkey a genocide.
“I think it is unbecoming of us as Americans to play word games
here,” Evans said in February 2005 during a stop at the University of
California at Berkeley. “I will today call it the Armenian genocide.”
In doing so, Evans became the first U.S. administration official to
use the loaded word in an Armenian context. The Bush administration,
like its predecessors, refers to the killings as a massacre and a
tragedy, but never genocide.
“It felt like a breakthrough moment,”
Armenian said. “It felt like we were getting somewhere.”
Armenians contend the Ottoman Empire began a centrally planned
slaughter in 1915 under cover of World War I in which about 1.5
million Armenians were killed. Turkey, a key U.S. and NATO ally,
strongly opposes the genocide label.
Tuluy Tanc, minister counsel at the Turkish embassy in Washington,
D.C., called the killing and deportation of Armenians “terrible
events.” But, he said, it was precipitated by Armenians taking up
arms in eastern Anatolia and siding with invading Russian troops.
“For genocide to occur, there has to be a plan to annihilate a people
based on their ethnicity. That was not the case at all,” he said.
Tanc called Evans’ comments “personal views” and not a reflection
of U.S. policy. He said he did not have any knowledge about Evans
being recalled.
But Aram Hamparian, executive director of the Armenian National
Committee of America, said the State Department already is quietly
vetting a new ambassador to replace Evans in late spring or early
summer.
“I think it’s pretty clear he’s being ushered out the door,” Schiff
said.
Evans, for his part, has sidestepped questions about his tenure in
Armenia. In response to a query during a press conference last week,
he replied, “I serve at the pleasure of the president. Period.”
Nagorno-Karabakh: The Long Shadow Of Joseph Stalin
NAGORNO-KARABAKH: THE LONG SHADOW OF JOSEPH STALIN
Written by Rene Wadlow
Toward Freedom, VT
March 21 2006
The president of Azerbaijan, Ilhan Aliyev, son of the long-time
president Heydar Aliyev and Robert Kocharian, president of Armenia,
met outside Paris, in Rambouillet February 10-11, 2006 to discuss the
stalemated conflict over Nagorno-Karabakh. Rambouillet had also been
the scene for the last-chance negotiations on Kosovo just before the
NATO bombing of Serbia began in 1999.
During the two years of fighting in Nagorno-Karabakh, 1992-1994,
at least 20,000 people were killed and more than a million persons
displaced from Armenia, Azerbaijan and the 12,000 square miles
of Nagorno-Karabakh itself. Armenian forces now control the
Nagorno-Karabakh area – an Armenian-populated enclave within
Azerbaijan. Since 1994, there has been a relatively stable
ceasefire. Nagorno-Karabakh has declared its independence as a
separate state. No other state -including Armenia – has recognized
this independent status, but, in practice, Nagorno-Karabakh is a de
facto state with control over its population and its own military
forces. Half of the government’s revenue is raised locally; the other
half comes from the government of Armenia and especially the Armenian
diaspora, strong in the United States, Canada, Lebanon, and Russia.
In addition to Nagorno-Karabakh, the Armenian forces hold seven small
districts around Nagorno-Karabakh, some 5,500 square kilometres that
had been populated by Azeris and that are considered as “occupied
territory”. One of the ideas being floated during these negotiations
is an Armenian withdrawal from these occupied territories accompanied
by international security guarantees and an international peacekeeping
force, probably under the control of the Organization for Security
and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) which has been the major forum for
negotiation on the Nagorno-Karabkh conflict.
The USA, France, and Russia are the co-chairmen of a mediating effort
called the “Minsk Group” after an OSCE conference on Nagorno-Karabakh
which was to have been held in Minsk, but then indefinitely postponed
as there was no clear basis for a compromise solution. Part of the
negotiating guidelines of the Minsk Group meetings is that no official
report is made on the negotiations, so that analysis is always an
effort at putting pieces together from partial statements, leaks,
and ‘off-the-record’ interviews with the press. This blackout on
direct statements opens the door to highly partisan analysis in both
countries where the press has always been hard line. There are those
who believe that both presidents are ‘ahead of their people’ in their
willingness to compromise and to move beyond the current “no war,
no peace” situation which is a drain on economic and social resources.
However, in both countries, the media is under tight control of the
respective governments so that the militaristic tone of the press
is not against government policy. The blackout on press statements
is also due to the monopoly on both sides of a small, tight group of
people responsible for the negotiations. Informal, Track Two, meetings
are very difficult and the few held were met by general suspicion or
hostility. There is a need for a broader-based peacemaking public to
counter the current narrow militant rhetoric.
The Nagorno-Karabakh issue arises from the Post-Revolution-Post-Civil
War period of Soviet history when Joseph Stalin was Commissioner for
Nationalities. Stalin came from neighboring Georgia and knew the
Caucasus well. His policy was a classic ‘divide and rule’ carried
out with method so that national/ethnic groups would need to depend
on the central government in Moscow for protection. Thus in 1922,
the frontiers of Azerbaijan, Armenia and Georgia were hammered out
in what was then the Transcaucasian Federative Republic.
Nagorno-Karabakh, an Armenian majority area, was given a certain
autonomy within Azerbaijan but was geographically cut off from
Armenia. Likewise, an Azeri majority are, Nakkickevan, was created
as an autonomous republic within Armenia but cut off geographically
from Azerbaijan. Thus both enclaves had to look to Moscow for
protection. This was especially true for the Armenians. Many Armenians
living in what had been historic Armenia but which became Turkey had
been killed during the First World War; Armenians living in “Soviet
Armenia” had relatives and friends among those killed by the Turks,
creating a permanent sense of vulnerability and insecurity. Russia
was considered a historic ally of Armenia.
These mixed administrative units worked well enough or, one should
say, there were few criticisms allowed until 1988 when the whole
Soviet model of nationalities and republics started to come apart.
In both Armenia and Azerbeijan, natioanlistic voices were raised, and
a strong “Karabakh Committee” began demanding that Nagorno-Karabakh be
attached to Armenia. In Azerbaijan, anti-Armenian sentiment was set
aflame. Many Armenians who were working in the oil-related economy
of Baku were under tension and started leaving. This was followed
somewhat later by real anti-Armenian pogroms. Some 160,000 Armenians
left Azerbaijan for Armenia and other went to live in Russia.
With the break up of the Soviet Union and the independence of Armenia
and Azerbaijan, tensions focused on Nagorno-Karabakh. By 1992, full
scale conflict broke out in and around Nagorno-Karabkh and went on
for two years causing large-scale damage. The Armenian forces of
Nagorno-Karabakh helped by volunteers from Armenia kept control of
the area, while Azerbaijan faced repeated political crises.
The condition of “no peace, no war” followed the ceasefire largely
negotiated by Russia in 1994. This status quo poses few problems to
the major regional states who are preoccupied by other geo-political
issues. Informal and illicit trade within the area has grown.
However, interest in a settlement of the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict
has grown as the Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan oil pipeline opened in May 2005.
The pipeline is sheduled to carry one million barrels of oil a day
from the Caspian to the Mediterranean by 2009. The pipeline passes
within 10 miles of Nagorno-Karabakh.
The crucial question for a settlement is the acceptance by all
parties and by the wider OSCE of an independent ‘mini-state’. An
independent Nagorno-Karabakh might become the ‘Liechtenstein of the
Caucases’. After 15 years of independence, Karabakh Armenians do not
want to be at the mercy of decisions made in distant centers of power
but to decide their own course of action. However, the recognition
of Nagorno-Karabakh as an independent states raises the issue of the
status of other de facto mini-states of the area such as Abkhazia
and South Ossetia in Georgia, Transnistria in Moldova and Kosovo in
Serbia. Close attention must continue to be paid to the potential
restructuring of the area. Can mini-states be more than a policy of
divide and rule? The long shadow of Joseph Stalin still hovers over
the land.
#####
Rene Wadlow is editor of the online journal of world politics
and an NGO representative to the
UN, Geneva. Formerly, he was professor and Director of Research of
the Graduate Institute of Development Studies, University of Geneva.
For a good analysis of Stalin’s nationality policies see Helene
Carrere d’Encausse “The Great Challenge: Nationalities and the
Bolshevik State 1917-1930” (New York: Holmes and Meier, 1992, 262pp.)
For the need to have a wider peace constituency for negotiations
see Laurence Broers (Ed). “The limits of leadership: Elites and
societies in the Nagorny Karabakh peace process.” (London: Conciliation
Resources, 2006, 104pp.)
Comments READING FEW BOOKS!
Written by Guest on 2006-03-21 07:37:21
—————————————– —————————————
Rene deserves thanks for attempting to raise awareness about the
Karabakh issue. Yet, a lack of knowledge about the details of the
conflict is apparent.
During the Soviet Union, Nakhichevan remained an autonomous region
within Azerbaijan, not Armenia! It is still an Azerbaijani exclave
located between Armenia, Turkey and Iran – thus separated from
Azerbaijan proper.
Moreover, Azerbaijan was an independent state between 1918-1920,
and its territories included not only Karabakh and Nakhichevan but
also Zengezur, which was later transfered to Armenia by the Soviet
Central Government.
Yes, Soviet did carved out the Armenian populated regions within
Azerbaijan and granted that region an autonomy. But th phrase “was
cut off Armenia” misleads the reader as if Karabakh was a part of
Armenia and was cut off by the Soviet – which is not the case.
Karabakh has always been an integral part of Azerbaijan and was a
part of Azerbaijan Democratic Republic in 1918-1920.
Stalin was nobody when the decision was made about Karabakh autonomous
status. A little closer examination will reveal that it is not really
Stalin’s fault.
Myths about Karabakh Written by Guest on 2006-03-21 12:28:40
—————————————– —————————————
Myth #2: Stalin gave Karabakh (Qarabagh) to Azerbaijan.
This is a gross falsification; the truth is quite the opposite. After
the Soviets took over Azerbaijan in 1920, right from the beginning,
Azerbaijan began losing territory to Armenia [see the map of the
Azerbaijan Democratic Republic (ADR), e.g., one prepared in 1920
by Russian MFA or the one presented in Versailles Peace Conference
(France) in 1919]. Azerbaijan’s territory was reduced from 114,000
sq. km. during ADR (1918-1920) — which was, along with Armenia, de
facto recognized by the League of Nations in those borders in 1920 —
to its present size of 86,600 sq. km., which is actually less now
because of the Armenian military occupation.
The Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous Oblast (NKAO), inside Azerbaijan, was
created in July 1923, after years of intense debates and opposition
from the Azerbaijani people to its transfer. An oblast, the Russian
term for “province,” was purely a Soviet administrative division,
which meant that in all aspects it was subordinated to the union
republic, Azerbaijan SSR.
Unlike an “oblast”, such as Karabakh (NKAO), Naxcivan, for example, was
an “autonomous republic” (ASSR within Azerbaijan SSR), which had much
broader rights, its own parliament, constitution and other privileges.
Carving out enclaves in the various Soviet republics exacerbated ethnic
tensions and was deliberately practiced. It served the Soviet Union
well by distracting the republics from seeking their own independence
because they were always occupied with ethnic tensions brewing inside
their own borders.
Myth #3. Stalin gave Naxcivan (Nakhchivan) to Azerbaijan.
The truth is that Nakhchivan, just as Karabakh, is historically part
of Azerbaijan. After Soviets gained power (1920), the foundation
stone for the autonomy of Naxcivan was laid by the Moscow and Kars
international treaties of March 16, 1921 and October 13, 1921,
respectively. These treaties are still in force. They stipulated
that Naxcivan remain within Azerbaijan, a legal fact that prevented
the Soviets from giving Naxcivan to Armenia. This did not, however,
prevent from giving small bits of territory to Armenia in the 1920s
and 1930, as well as occupation of the Kerki village in the north of
Naxcivan by Armenia in 1990. The status of Naxcivan Autonomous Republic
(ASSR) within Azerbaijan SSR was established in 1924.
Naxcivan used to be “connected” to the rest of Azerbaijan by the
Zangezur district, which was given to Armenia in December 1920.
Effectively, assigning this strip (46 km) to Armenia separated
Azerbaijan in two sections cutting off Turkey from the other
Turkic-speaking peoples in Central Asia.
Zangezur was continuously emptied of its indigenous residents.
According to the official Russian censuses, in 1897 its population
was 51.7% Azerbaijani but by 1926, the population had declined to
6.4%. During the same period, the ratio of Armenians increased from
46.1% to 87%! Tens of thousands of Azerbaijanis had to flee for their
lives in much the same way as they have had to do in the 1990s.
By the way, as more documents see light and archives get open, the
researchers have discovered shocking USSR Council of Ministers decrees,
dated 23 December 1947 (No. 4083) and 10 March 1948 (No.
754), signed by Stalin himself, with advise from top officials L.
Beria and A. Mikoyan, ordering a forced “resettlement” of more than
100,000 Azerbaijani nationals from Armenian SSR to Azerbaijan SSR in
the period of 1948-1951 (half of them died in the process). Settling
in their homes were to be incoming Armenian expatriates from abroad….
view/773/
Pope Voices Desire To Mend A 1,500-Year Split
POPE VOICES DESIRE TO MEND A 1,500-YEAR SPLIT
Zenit News Agency, Italy
March 21 2006
Promotes Unity With Armenian Apostolic Church
VATICAN CITY, MARCH 20, 2006 (Zenit.org).- Benedict XVI signals
his desire to promote unity with the Armenian Apostolic Church,
a Christian confession that separated from Rome in the fifth century.
The Pope expressed his desire for unity today when he received in
audience His Beatitude Nerses Bedros XIX Tarmouni, Catholic patriarch
of Cilicia of the Armenians, Lebanon, with members of the patriarchal
synod and a group of pilgrims.
The Mideast-based patriarch leads 600,000 Catholic faithful in
communion with Rome, assisted by 120 priests and about 90 women
religious, according to Vatican Radio.
By contrast, more than 90% of the Armenian Christians are under the
Armenian Apostolic Patriarchate, which separated from Rome after
the Council of Chalcedon in 451. A key step toward overcoming this
division was taken in 1996 when Pope John Paul II and Patriarch
Karekin I signed a joint declaration on the nature of Jesus.
Benedict XVI, in his address to guests of the Armenian Catholic Church
in communion with Rome, recalled the sufferings of the Armenian people
“in the name of the Christian faith.”
At the same time the Holy Father manifested his satisfaction because
in recent years “a cordial and fruitful dialogue” has begun among
the Armenian Christians for unity with Rome.
“I encourage this renewed fraternity and collaboration hoping that it
may give rise to new initiatives for a joint journey towards full
unity,” he said, “with its own hierarchy, in fraternal interior
harmony and full communion with the Bishop of Rome.”
Benedict XVI concluded: “We all wish to be instruments at the disposal
of Christ. May he — who is the Way, Truth and Life — enable us to
continue with all our strength, so that, as soon as possible, there
may be one flock with one pastor.”
From: Baghdasarian
ANKARA: American Professor: Armenian Genocide Is British Propaganda
AMERICAN PROFESSOR: ARMENIAN GENOCIDE IS BRITISH PROPAGANDA
NTV MSNBC, Turkey
March 20 2006
Renown U.S. historian and expert on Ottoman affairs, Professor Justin
McCarthy said allegations of Armenian genocide are British propaganda.
Professor Justin McCarthy, speaking at a conference in London,
said that a source known as the “Blue Book” chosen by Armenians to
prove their claims of genocide is one of the products of British war
propaganda bureau’s efforts of misinformation during first world war.
The Blue Book written by Viscount Bryce and Arnold Toynbee has been
used as proof that Armenians and the victims of the Jewish Holocaust
suffered the same fate in history. This book has been said to be a
product of British intelligence designed to promote and promulgate
lies during World War I. Britain had set up the war propaganda
bureau at Wellington House for the sole purpose of promoting lies and
misinformation on Germany and the Ottoman Empire. The British were
in full co-operation with American missionaries in Anatolia and the
American Embassy in Istanbul conjured a so called Armenian genocide
based on gossip, hear-say and erroneous information.
The real purpose behind this exercise was to create and strengthen
an image in the minds of British military officers that the Turk were
evil, horrible and untrustworthy McCarthy adds.
PROFESSOR JUSTIN MCCARTHY…
HISTORIAN AND EXPERT ON OTTOMAN AFFAIRS
All documents at the Wellington House where the British carried out
their propaganda were destroyed when the war ended. One document that
survived, however, was the Blue Book (it is documented that many more
of these books were published and copied for other countries). This
book is currently being used around the world as a legal document on
the genocide.
AMERICAN HISTORIAN PROVES THE FACTS
The American historian and expert on Ottoman affairs was a recent
speaker at the London School of Oriental and African Studies. He
commented on a few of the stomach churning activities of the British
during the first world war. He stated, When the war began, a secret
propaganda unit was set up at Wellington House, London (on September
2, 1914). This units sole aim was to provide support for Britain,
smear Britains enemies, obtain support for the British view through
the use of Americans, and to keep British morale high during the war.
This unit was headed by Charles Masterman a Liberal m.p. He was a
close friend of Lloyd George. There also was an American intellectual
named Viscount Bryce working in this bureau who had many influential
friends in the U.S. Arnold Toynbee, young historian, meanwhile was
one of Bryces close friends at the time.
SEVEN MILLION DOCUMENTS
At the end of the war all documents and records of work at the war
propaganda bureau were destroyed, and its existence was only admitted
in 1935. However, the sources of the propaganda bureau were discovered
due to one records book surviving until present day.
Publications prepared in this bureau and the existence of seven
million documents which were very efficiently sent to the United States
after the war were also exposed. Many famous authors of the time as
Arnold Bennett and John Buchan were also employed by the Wellington
House, where they published brochures, books and statements for the
war effort.
GERMANY, THE ACTUAL TARGET
Although Germany was the actual target of activities at Wellington
House, the Ottoman Empire, having sided with Germany during the war
received its fair share of false propaganda. No matter how sympathetic
the British officers felt towards their Turkish compatriots, the
image that Turkish officers were bad, evil and untrustworthy was
strengthened by such slanderous data.
NON-REAL NAMES
Work carried out by those at Wellington House on Ottomans involved many
so called authors and writers whose existence could not be verified
and thus, the information remains unconfirmed. For example, there
was apparently a Syrian member of the Ottoman Committee of Union and
Progress Party, named Faiz whose memoirs are mentioned in publications
of the Wellington House. This persons existence is totally make-belief
and his statements on Talat Pasha, a complete fallacy since he never
existed. Wellington House also proves the close co-operation which
existed between them and the American diplomats and missionaries based
in Turkey during that time. Since it is documented that these groups
were close to the Armenians in Turkey, their so called information
from Turkey is a total fabrication.
BLUE BOOK ORDERED BY LLOYD GEORGE
Public law and order was severely disrupted as a result of Armenians
revolting against Ottoman authority in eastern Anatolia, which led
Bryce and Toynbee to concoct material to document alleged atrocities
committed by Ottomans. Lloyd George asked to collect these documents
in the Blue Book. This document was later submitted to the British
parliament and has since been used as a classic documentation by
radical nationalist Armenian groups.
TOYNBEE WAS AN ANTI-TURK
It is thought that Toynbee believed in the authenticity and
truthfulness of material received from American missionaries in
Anatolia. However, he also added some spice to these imaginary stories,
since it was his country that was at war with Turkey and he thought
it would be right to lie in his reports. As was proved in his late
career, Toynbee was indeed an avid Turk hater, but was too far away
from the events of eastern Turkey in 1916 to document anything.
It is easy to see far away from such events Armenians living in
Turkey were and in looking at Toynbees data. Toynbee also seems to
have exaggerated their relýabýlýty for they turned and fought against
their former protector for promises made by outsiders. For example
so many anecdotes mentioned by western observers are not by western
travelers but by a local Armenians travelling only short distances.
One tenth of the anecdotes do not even have a source of any kind.
Other sources are generally hearsay and have no witnesses who can
attest to the so called crimes.
NO REACTIONS FROM TURKEY
All propaganda against Germany by Wellington House has been forgotten,
yet unfortunately Bryce – Toynbee documents have been recognized
as true in Britain and U.S. These documents have always been used
by radical militant Armenians to pursue their goals. There is no
information at hand about whether Turkey has shown any reactions
against the impact of these documents. The mentioned Blue Book has
been published more then once. Ara Sarafian who is to publish the
book for the third time does not mention the fact that the books
contents were prepared at Wellington House and that its sources are
untrustworthy. Thus, propaganda carried out by the British during
World War I continues to spread its venom against all Turkish people
living around the world.
–Boundary_(ID_O4/CBmpEje8KUOb4VLSTbg)–
ANKARA: Talat Pasha Rally Held In Berlin
TALAT PASHA RALLY HELD IN BERLIN
Anatolian Times, Turkey
March 20 2006
BERLIN – Thousands of Turkish people attended the rally organized
by the Talat Pasha Movement in German capital Berlin on Saturday to
protest a decision made by the German parliament to recognize the
so-called Armenian genocide.
The rally started from An der Urania avenue and ended in Ernst
Reuter Square.
Speaking at the rally, Workers’ Party leader Dogu Perincek said,
“no one can accuse Turkish people of massacring Armenian people. The
recent decision made by the German parliament will play havoc with
the friendly relations between the two countries. We call on German
authorities to correct this serious mistake.”
Nearly 5 thousand Turkish people were in attendance at the rally.
They carried banners and photographs of Turkish diplomats who were
killed by Armenian terrorists.
The Turkish Dilemma
THE TURKISH DILEMMA
By George Gregoriou
Greek News, New York
March 20 2006
At a party the other day a French woman who was connected with the
United Nations said to me “Turkey will not be in the European Union”.
I said “I will not loose any sleep over it. If Turkey does change she
does not deserve to be in the EU”. Maybe the cynical among us will
not loose any sleep. But, Washington and London will, and the Turkish
corporate interests and the left, who want to move in the direction of
Europe. Official Athens and Nicosia also want Turkey to be in Europe. A
more civilized Turkey will be a better neighbor in the Aegean, even
settle the Cyprus problem in a way which is acceptable to the Greek and
Turkish Cypriots. At least, this has been the official line from the
moment Ankara became a candidate for membership in the European Union.
Not all Turks want to join the European Union. Not just nationalists
and Islamicists. Secularists are not eager, especially if Turkey
will pay a price for membership in the EU. PM Embarkan, PM Erdogan’s
predecessor/head of the Islamist movement, wanted to redirect Turkey
towards the Islamic Middle East, even form an Islamic “NATO”. He
was booted out of power by the military. PM Erdogan has managed to
tip-toe around this issue, maintaining his Islamic credentials but
maneuvering in the direction of the EU, for the economic benefits.
The recent crisis over the trial and possible jailing of the prominent
novelist Orhan Pamuk is only the tip of the iceberg. Pamuk is not the
real issue. Turkey is on trial, stated Oli Rehn, the EU enlargement
commissioner. The charge against Pamuk is over his statement in an
interview with Das Magazin, a Swiss publication, that the Ottoman
Turks committed genocide against the Armenians in 1915.
Over a million Armenians were massacred. The Kurds, who were “promised”
Armenian land and property, hand a hand in this massacre, until
Ataturk turned his guns on these “mountain Turks”. Pamuk’s other
“crime” was his statement that thousands of Kurds were killed in
the war against the separatist P.K.I. in the 1980s. These comments
“denigrate Turkishness”. Any criticism of the state, the army, or the
founder of the Turkish Republic, Kemal Ataturk, are crimes which can
send one to prison. Pamuk is not the first to be charged. According to
the NYTimes(12/17/05) nearly 60 intellectuals have been charged with
this crime. On his way to court Pamuk was confronted by protestors
hurling eggs and insults “Traitor Pamuk!”
The Islamic religion in Turkey is not the only issue. Those who
brought the charges against Pamuk are known secularists who brought
charges against women wearing the shroud, which violates the Ataturk
legacy of modernization. So, if we were to add the Islamists and the
nationalists/secularists who will defend Turkish “honor” against
free speech and democratic rights, who among the 70 million Turks
is eligible to be in the EU at a time when the wave of anti-Muslim
attitudes is on the increase throughout Europe?
The Pamuk trial was so hot, the political and criminal establishment
postponed the case until February 7. Turkey’s trajectory into the
EU is at risk. If Pamuk is found not guilty in February the penal
code is invalidated. If he is guilty, more ammunition is given to
those opposing Turkey in the EU, a slap in the face of the Bush-Blair
regimes promoting. Turkey’s accession talks for geopolitical reasons,
to control the Middle East and Central Asia for their oil and natural
resources.
Turkey’s trajectory into the EU will be very bumpy. The Pamuk case
involves admission by the Ankara regime for the crimes committed
against Armenians and Kurds, which is common knowledge throughout
the world. The worse scenario would be demands for reparations by
the descendants of the Armenians massacred. The Turkish state seems
to be good at taking, not giving or paying its dues, even offering an
apology for crimes committed 90 years ago. Money is the real problem,
but there is more to it. Pandora’s box will be opened. A flood will be
cascading into the faces of those Turks hiding behind the fig leaf of
“honor” to deny the barbarism within the Turkish civilization.
If official Ankara cannot admit to the massacre of Armenians and
Greeks at the turn of the last century, how can it admit to the crimes
committed against the 15 million Kurds, persecuted since the days of
Ataturk. Ataturk’s policy was, those who could be Turkified could stay
in Turkey, those who could not, be eliminated. The fate of millions
of Greeks, Armenians, and Jews in Asia Minor is well-known to Turks
in the street, but not to the all the regimes in Ankara since WWI.
This Turkish barbarism is not just the legacy of the past. The war
on the Kurds continued throughout the 20th Century. It continues
today in Eastern Anatolia and Ankara’s current policy towards the
Kurds in northern Iraq. It continues in Cyprus as well. The invasion
and ethnic cleansing in 1974 has been in place for 31 years. 200,000
Cypriots were forced to leave the northern part of Cyprus, to make
room for 130,000 settlers from Anatolia. This is the Turkish method of
settling disputes, settlers to change the demographics and an army of
occupation to guarantee that the facts on the ground created by the
invasion are irreversible. There could be a settlement of the Cyprus
problem between the Greeks and Turks of Cyprus within 24 hours if
the settlers and the Turkish army were to go back to Turkey.
Ankara is not alone in this crime. Washington and London are its
co-conspirators.
The Turkish dilemma is real. If Ankara cannot admit the massacre of
the Armenians and is prosecuting one of Turkey¹s best known novelist,
Orhan Pamuk, how can it deal with the Kurdish and Cyprus problems
if it is serious and wants to be in the EU? Nicosia, Athens, and
other European capitals may have the last word: a veto over Turkey¹s
membership in the European Union.
*** George Gregoriou Professor, Critical Theory and Geopolitics
Department of Political Science The William Paterson University Wayne,
New Jersey 07470 e-mail: [email protected] om/modules.php?name=News&file=article&sid= 4248&mode=thread&order=0&thold=0
–Bo undary_(ID_LKYnrIq3TAjI2VLZJ/I9dA)–
Turks In Germany, France Protest Armenian Claims
TURKS IN GERMANY, FRANCE PROTEST ARMENIAN CLAIMS
Journal of Turkish Weekly
March 20 2006
Some 5,000 Turks rallied under the slogan “Take your flag and come
to Berlin” over the weekend in Berlin to urge the German Parliament
to reverse its decision to acknowledge Armenian genocide claims.
The Talat Pasha movement, responsible for the rally, was initiated by
Workers’ Party (IP) leader Dogu Perincek and former Turkish Republic
of Northern Cyprus (TRNC) President Rauf Denktas. Many representatives
from Turkish political parties and non-governmental organizations
(NGOs) participated.
The participants in the rally marched from Berlin’s An der Urania
Street to Ernst Reuter Square chanting “Long live Turkish-German
friendship,” “We didn’t commit genocide, we defended the country,” and
“The genocide lie is a U.S. game.” While they carried signs showing
photos of Turkish diplomats killed by Armenian terrorists, they also
called on the German Parliament to denounce the genocide claims.
During the rally, the crowd stopped at Steinplatz where Talat Pasha
was assassinated in 1921 and sang the Turkish national anthem.
Delivering a speech to the crowd, Perincek said, “Nobody can bring
us to our knees by accusing our nation of massacre.” He also lashed
out at the decision of the German Parliament making Turks out to be
“butchers,” saying, “The German Parliament has stabbed Turkish-German
friendship in the back with this decision.” He also urged the
Parliament to annul the earlier recognition.
Stressing that an erroneous decision by Germany should not be included
in German textbooks, Perincek said, “Don’t put hatred and antagonism
in textbooks. Don’t make Turks and Germans enemies.”
Perincek also lambasted German Chancellor Angela Merkel’s undertakings
to ban the rally, saying, “Merkel should speak in German, not in
American.” The IP leader also claimed that the Armenian genocide
claims serve the U.S.’ Greater Middle East Initiative (GME), adding
that the recognition of the claims is not for the benefit of Germany.
At the head of the rally, Denktas laid flowers where Talat Pasha
was assassinated. Sunday, a general assembly to commemorate Talat
Pasha was held in Berlin. Last year, the same group held another
demonstration to mark the 82nd anniversary of the Treaty of Lausanne.
During that rally, Perincek lashed out at a decision by Switzerland
to punish those who deny the Armenian genocide claims, saying,
“The Armenian ‘genocide’ is an international lie,” after which the
prosecutor from Winterthur opened an investigation into Perincek
and the incident turned into a diplomatic crisis between Turkey
and Switzerland.
Turks in Lyon protest inauguration of Armenian monument
Turkish associations in Lyon, France organized a rally over the
weekend to protest the Lyon Municipality’s decision to dedicate a
monument commemorating the so-called Armenian genocide.
The rally began at Place Bellcour with the members of various Turkish
associations participating while carrying Turkish and French flags.
Some 1,500 Turks participated in the rally and chanted slogans
against the inauguration of the monument. The rally ended at the Lyon
Municipality Building, where protestors laid a black wreath at the
front door.
French police used teargas to disperse a number of Armenians who were
trying to provoke protesters as a means of preventing a dangerous
escalation of tension between Turks and Armenians.
The Lyon Municipality made its decision in 2004 to dedicate a monument
to commemorating the alleged Armenian genocide. They also decided
to make a 45,000 euro contribution towards the total cost of 130,000
euros for the monument and ceremony.
Certain French NGOs together with UNESCO opened a lawsuit against
the construction of the monument, claiming that it will violate the
district’s aesthetics. Some 150,000 Armenians live in Lyon.
In 2001, the French Parliament recognized the Armenian genocide claims,
a move which created a diplomatic row between Ankara and Paris.
Pope: “Terrible Persecution” Of Armenians Lingers In History
POPE: “TERRIBLE PERSECUTION” OF ARMENIANS LINGERS IN HISTORY
AsiaNews.it, Italy
March 20 2006
Receiving members of the Patriarchate of Cilicia, Benedict XVI
praised the loyalty of the Armenians to Christianity and expressed
the hope that continued division between the different Churches will
be overcome.
Vatican City (AsiaNews) – “Metz yeghèrn, the great evil”: this
is what Armenians still call the genocide they suffered in the
years of the First World War, at the hands of the then Ottoman
Empire. The phrase was repeated by Benedict XVI when he received
Nerses Bedros XIX Tarmouni, Patriarch of Cilicia for Armenians, who
was accompanied by members of the Patriarchal Synod. He talked about
the “great persecution” at the roots of the diaspora of that people,
and also about the division which persists among Armenian Christians,
expressing the hope that it will soon be overcome.
“The Armenian Church that refers to the Patriarchate of Cilicia (in
Lebanon n.d.r.), is certainly a full participant of historical events
lived by the Armenian people throughout the centuries and, especially,
of the suffering they bore in the name of the Christian faith in the
years of the terrible persecution which remains known in history by
the sadly significant name of metz yeghèrn, the great evil. How can
one not remember, in this regard, the many invitations sent by Leo
XIII to Catholics, to go to the rescue of the poverty and suffering
of the Armenian peoples?”
Benedict XVI continued: “The Armenians, who have always sought to
integrate themselves with their industriousness and dignity in the
societies where they found themselves, continue to bear witness to
their faithfulness to the Gospel still today.” This is a fidelity that
is also a “strong attachment, sometimes even to the point of martyrdom,
which your Community has always shown towards the See of Peter,
in a reciprocal and fertile relationship of faith and affection”.
A relationship that the Pope would like to see extended to other
Christian communities of Armenia, which are still divided, although
they recognize St Gregory the Illuminator as their common father
founder and even if “in recent decades all have resumed a cordial and
fruitful dialogue to the end of rediscovering their common roots. I
encourage this rediscovered fraternity and collaboration, with the
hope that new initiatives for a shared path towards full unity will
spring from this. And if historical events have seen the fragmentation
of the Armenian Church, may Divine Providence allow that one day it
will return to being united, with its hierarchy in brotherly internal
harmony and in full communion with the Bishop of Rome.”
–Boundary_(ID_KRsltsoTMXQBn5Pcd83C6Q)–
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress
Revenues To The NKR State Budget Increased Compared With The SamePer
REVENUES TO THE NKR STATE BUDGET INCREASED COMPARED WITH THE SAME PERIOD LAST YEAR
DeFacto Agency, Armenia
March 20 2006
January – February 2006 the Nagorno Karabakh Republic (NKR) state
budget own revenue made 1 milliard 464,4 million drams, which surpasses
the level of the same period last year by 39,1 %.
According to the information De Facto Information-Analytics Agency
got at the NKR Ministry of Finance and Economy, the budget revenues
have been guaranteed at the expense of the tax receipts, state duty
and operations with capital.
The state budget expenses for the same period made 2 milliard 114,2
million drams.
The budget revenues from the operations with capital made 125,6 million
drams, 62,6 million drams of the sum has been received from the state
property and 63 million from expropriation of the principal funds,
which are considered to be state property.
For current January – February incomings to the NKR Social Insurance
Fund increased by 14,7%, having made 254,4 million drams.
Legislative Initiative On Giving Armenian Language Status Of SecondS
LEGISLATIVE INITIATIVE ON GIVING ARMENIAN LANGUAGE STATUS OF SECOND STATE LANGUAGE IN REGIONS COMPACTLY POPULATED WITH ARMENIANS TO BE PRESENTED TO GEORGIAN PARLIAMENT
Noyan Tapan
Armenians Today
Mar 21 2006
AKHALKALAK, MARCH 21, NOYAN TAPAN – ARMENIANS TODAY. At the regular
sitting of the Samtskhe-Javakhk Armenian Public Organizations’ Council
which was held on March 16 in Akhalkalak, it’s decided to make a
statement on a legislative initiative on giving the state status to
the Armenian language parallel with Georgian in Samtskhe-Javakhk
and its neighboring region of Tsalka. Representatives of public
organizations intend to present their legislative initiative to
the Parliament with the help of all the 4 Armenian deputies of the
Parliament. If the issue doesn’t enter the Parliament with the help of
the Armenian deputies, then the Council will make a statement about
the legislative initiative according to the order envisaged by the
Constitution of the country. According to the “A-Info” agency, the
issue of giving the Armenian language the state status was touched
upon at previous sittings of the Council as well, and after a long
discussion the Council made the above-mentioned decision.
During its discussions the Council also took into account the
fact that Georgia signed and certified the Framework Convention
for the Protection of National Minorities (Strasbourg, February
1995), according to Article 10.2 of which, “in places, populated
traditionally or with considerable quantity of people belonging
to the ethnic minorities, if those people ask and this request
corresponds to real needs, the sides, as much as it’s possible, must
strive for providing such conditions which will give possibility to
use the language of the minority in relations among those people and
administrative authorities.” The Council also took into account that
when joining the Council of Europe, Georgia undertook obligation
to sing and certify the European Charter for Regional and Minority
Languages where in this sense the rights of minorities are defined more
detailed. According to the Council representatives, in the region,
giving the state status to the Armenian language in parallel to the
Goergian one will create guarantees for the language-cultural safety
of the Armenian inhabitation as well as will decrease the interracial
tension in the region incomparably.