Europe Won’t Stay In Shade Of US And Europe

EUROPE WON’T STAY IN SHADE OF US AND EUROPE
By Gayane Movsisian
Yerkir.am
March 24, 2006
Karabakh settlement process has been paused. On March 20, the OSCE
Minsk Group co-chairs met in Istanbul to discuss the settlement but
there us news from them so far.
One more report by the International Crisis Group released recently
says the South Caucasus countries are currently engaged in a
no-war-no-peace situation which could transform into military
operations, and Europe will not be prepared for an adequate reaction.
The report says to ensure its own security Europe should engage in
the conflict settlement more actively to avoid wars near Europe’s
borders. “Only recently did Brussels react strongly to those
challenges. Several promising steps were taken but there is still a
long way to go,” said Sabina Fraizer, ICG’s Caucasus Program director.
With a reputation of fair mediator and having both soft and tough
leverage methods, the European Union is in a position to play a greater
role and add to the efforts of the United Nations and the OSCE, the
ICG believes, which suggests that settling the sides should presume
the obligations to settle the conflict through peaceful means only.
Besides, the ICG suggests that a special observer’s status be given
to EU special representative in the talks for Abkhaz, South Ossetian
and Karabakh conflicts.
“The EU has contributed greatly in the work to restore Abkhazia and
South Osetia. It should evaluate what it could do in Karabakh and
adjacent regions,” the report says.
Judging from the statements EU Special chairman Peter Semnebi mad
in Baku during his recent visit the European Union is preparing for
a new role. “My mandate is extended to include large authority to
settle the ‘frozen conflicts.’ I will be carefully watching all the
aspects of conflict situations and then submit recommendations for
the leadership,” said Semnebi, adding also that the EU’s contribution
could be in sending observing missions, peacekeepers or rehabilitation
of the territories. Besides, beginning March 1, 2006, the office of
the OSCE South Caucasus office moved from Finland to Brussels which
is due to growing interest in the region.
Peter Semnebi is set to visit Armenia in April. It is likely that
the EU would assume more active role in the region by then.

‘The Return Of The Poet’: The New Victory Of Armenian Cinema

‘THE RETURN OF THE POET’: THE NEW VICTORY OF ARMENIAN CINEMA
By Ruzan Zakarian, Media-7 Cultural Center
Yerkir.am
March 24, 2006
Before the screening in Yerevan, Harutyun Khachatrian’s film “The
Return of the Poet” first appeared on the screen at the International
Film Festival in Rotterdam. It was then presented at the film
festival in Tehran. The film attracted the attention of critics and
art workers alike.
The film received positive comments in European press and internet
publications. It was announced one of the best three films screened
at the Rotterdam Festival.
The author of the film, Harutyun Khachatrian has already received
invitations to present his film and lecture at a number of
international festivals. The cinema centers in the Netherlands and
Japan have organized a retrospective screening of the works of four
Armenian film directors – S. Parajanov, A. Peleshian, A. Egoyan and
H. Khachatrian.
In the third millennium when the intolerance towards cultural monuments
leads to violence, when destruction of cultural monuments leads to
wars, when inter-religion cultural relations are becoming war fronts,
the success of Harutyun Khachatrian’s film means a victory in this
conflict.
“The Return of the Poet” is about someone who carries the wisdom of
the nation, who is a poet, a philosopher, a gussan. This film tells
about Jivani. It’s a film that asks questions so relevant for our
times, and the author tries to find answers traveling with Jivani.
The director of the film simply watches how Jivani’s statue created
in Yerevan is transported to Javakhq, the poet’s place of birth. And
the travel from Yerevan to Javakhq is not merely travel. It is a
saga about Armenia. It reveals to what extent Jivani’s songs have
been preserved and how up-to-date they sound.
The film shows that the people have kept in their hearts Jivani’s
simple melodic songs that came from his heart. Jivani’s songs flow
as the life itself. And this is why people have always listened to
his songs and continue listening to them.
Khachatrian takes up another line in his film: the road that takes
from Yerevan to Javakhq, the road by which Jivani’s statue is
transported, passes through Armenian cities, town and villages. The
director manages to tell about the hard lives people live in these
places. He draws parallels between the past and present making you
think about the constant and temporary values, about the national
identity thus creating a portrait of Armenia, a collective portrait
of the Armenian nation.

Are Human Rights Of Armed Forces Personnel In Armenia Honored?

ARE HUMAN RIGHTS OF ARMED FORCES PERSONNEL IN ARMENIA HONORED?
Lragir.am
27 March 06
Two reports on Armenia will be heard at the PACE Spring Session on
April 11-13 in Strasbourg, which will be in the focus of attention of
the Armenian delegation. Two question directly connected with Armenia
will be discussed, said Tigran Torosyan, Deputy Speaker, the head of
the Armenian delegation in the PACE, to the Armenian news reporters
before the session. The first is the report on the refugees and the
displaced persons in the South Caucasus, which had been introduced in
December, but was moved to the agenda of the spring session because
the winter agenda was tough.
The second is the draft report on human rights of the military
personnel in Europe, which does not directly concern Armenia, but some
points of it regard Armenia. Tigran Torosyan says the draft report
includes the assessment of the human rights of the Armenian military
personnel in 2001-2003. The deputy speaker of the National Assembly
said this document had been extended to the Ministry of Defense to
get acquainted with the assessment of the European reporter.

Fifth Forum Of World Alliance Of Cities Against Poverty

FIFTH FORUM OF WORLD ALLIANCE OF CITIES AGAINST POVERTY
Lragir.am
27 March 06
>From March 29 to April 1 Arthur Baghdasaryan, Speaker of the National
Assembly of Armenia, will be in Spain on a working visit. During the
visit the speaker will meet with the President of the Spanish Senate
Xavier Rojo and the president of the Congress of Deputies of Spain
Manuel Marin Gonzalez, informed the Public Relations Office of the
National Assembly of Armenia.
On March 29 Speaker Arthur Baghdasaryan and the president of the Senate
of the Kingdom of Belgium Ann Marie Lysine will open the fifth forum
of WACAP in Valencia, during which four Armenian cities will become
members of the alliance.
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Republicans Admit Accusations

REPUBLICANS ADMIT ACCUSATIONS
Lragir.am
27 March 06
The Republican Deputy Speaker Tigran Torosyan announced on March 27
that he agreed with the Orinats Yerkir MP Samvel Balasanyan, who had
observed that the activity of the Orinats Yerkir Party gets more
coverage during the Parliamentary Hour on TV, because the Orinats
Yerkir Party is more deeply engaged in legislative activity. “I agree
with Samvel Balasanyan that the Parliamentary Hour should cover
the activity that is performed, the speeches that are made in the
parliament,” says Tigran Torosyan, admitting that his address during
the plenary meeting of the Republican Party calling for more activity
as a parliamentary force has not been fulfilled. Tigran Torosyan states
that steps to fulfill his call were not sufficient, but he reassures
that the spring session of the National Assembly has just opened,
and in the course of time the Republicans will take greater initiative.

Revolution Is Not An Aim, Revolution Is A Means

REVOLUTION IS NOT AN AIM, REVOLUTION IS A MEANS
Lragir.am
27 March 06
The parliamentary election in Ukraine reveals one important thing:
the orange enthusiasm has yielded. Thus the deputy speaker of the
National Assembly of Armenia Tigran Torosyan evaluated the March 26
election to the Supreme Rada on March 27. He thinks that after the
election in Ukraine and generally after the enthusiasm of revolution
it must be stated that the revolution should be a means, not an aim.
Tigran Torosyan thinks that the parliamentary election in Ukraine
will definitely sooth the surge of predictions of fruit and flower
revolutions in the CIS; moreover, he is convinced that there were no
preconditions for the spreading of such revolutions. The deputy speaker
of Armenia says those were mere predictions which have nothing to do
with a revolution. “A revolution is a subject of serious political
analysis. It is necessary to analyze seriously the situation, moods,
preconditions in a country and only then predict if a revolution is
likely to happen or not. A revolution may occur when it is needed,
when it is not, it is unlikely to occur.”
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

INTERVIEW – Pope To Use Turkey Trip To Help West-Islam Dialogue

INTERVIEW – POPE TO USE TURKEY TRIP TO HELP WEST-ISLAM DIALOGUE
By Philip Pullella and Tom Heneghan
Reuters, UK
March 27 2006
VATICAN CITY (Reuters) – Pope Benedict will use his trip to
predominantly Muslim Turkey later this year to promote greater dialogue
between Islam and the West, a senior Vatican cardinal said on Monday.
Cardinal Walter Kasper, a German like the Pope, also said in an
interview with Reuters that he believed that a controversy over remarks
made by Benedict before his election about Turkey’s credentials to
join the European Union had now been overcome.
The Pope is scheduled to visit Turkey Nov. 28-30 for what will
predominantly be a trip aimed at improving ties with Orthodox
Christians, whose symbolic head, Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew,
is based in Istanbul.
“This is one of the main problems today, to come to a relationship
with Islam which will not be a clash of civilisations but a dialogue
between civilisations,” Kasper, head of the Council for Christian
Unity, said in a wide-ranging interview on the Catholic Church’s
ecumenical activities.
“Of course, nobody wants a clash of cultures. It would be disastrous
for the whole world,” Kasper said adding that he expected the Pope
to speak on relations with Islam at meetings with Turkey’s government
in Ankara before going to Istanbul.
“There, I think, the problem is unavoidable,” Kasper said.
Since his election in April, the Pope has condemned cartoons lampooning
the prophet Mohammad but has also called for charges to be dropped
against an Afghan man who faces possible capital punishment because
he converted from Islam to Christianity.
His aides have been stressing the Vatican’s view that the rights of
minority Christians in Islamic countries had to be respected as part
of reciprocity for the religious freedoms available to Muslims in
Christian countries.
Relations with Islam were also a top item on the agenda of closed-door
discussions last week among over 150 cardinals meeting at the Vatican
to admit 15 new members into what Benedict calls his “senate.”
POSITIVE INFLUENCE
“There are many difficult and deep questions we have to solve with
Islam but we also must remember times of good relations. There
have been many positive influences of Islam, also on Christianity,”
Kasper said.
“We must try to deepen our dialogue with Islam, especially with
moderate forces in Islam and to try to come to a positive and friendly
relationship,” he said.
When he was Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, the future pope gave a
controversial interview arguing that Europe’s roots are Christian
and that a Muslim country would not fit in.
Some 99 percent of Turks are Muslims, the majority of them in
the mainstream Sunni tradition. Most of Turkey’s ancient Christian
population — chiefly Greeks and Armenians — fled, perished or were
exchanged with Greek Muslims in the 1920s.
The trip was delayed by a year because of Turkey’s lingering suspicions
about the comments but Kasper said he believed the problem was now
in the past and that the Pope would not bring it up during the visit.
“That was a private opinion by Cardinal Ratzinger … I don’t think the
Pope, when he goes as Pope to Turkey, will speak of this,” Kasper said.
Turkey began European Union membership talks last October, but is
not expected to join the bloc before 2015 at the earliest.
Many in the EU are wary about admitting Turkey, a large, mainly Muslim
and relatively poor country of 72 million people.
The Pope’s visit to Istanbul will be seen as a major step forward
in relations between the Western Church and world Orthodoxy, which
split >From each other in the schism of 1054.
As Constantinople, the city later served as the centre of eastern
Christianity for centuries until it fell to the Turks in 1453,
becoming in turn the capital of the Muslim Ottoman empire.

Overstating Jewish Power

OVERSTATING JEWISH POWER
By Christopher Hitchens
Slate
March 27 2006
Mearsheimer and Walt give too much credit to the Israeli lobby.
It’s slightly hard to understand the fuss generated by the article
on the Israeli lobby produced by the joint labors of John Mearsheimer
and Stephen Walt that was published in the London Review of Books. My
guess is that the Harvard logo has something to do with it, but then
I don’t understand why the doings of that campus get so much media
attention, either.
The essay itself, mostly a very average “realist” and centrist critique
of the influence of Israel, contains much that is true and a little
that is original. But what is original is not true and what is true
is not original.
Everybody knows that the American Israel Public Affairs Committee and
other Jewish organizations exert a vast influence over Middle East
policy, especially on Capitol Hill. The influence is not as total,
perhaps, as that exerted by Cuban exiles over Cuba policy, but it is
an impressive demonstration of strength by an ethnic minority. Almost
everybody also concedes that the Israeli occupation has been a moral
and political catastrophe and has implicated the United States in a
sordid and costly morass. I would have gone further than Mearsheimer
and Walt and pointed up the role of Israel in supporting apartheid
in South Africa, in providing arms and training for dictators in
Congo and Guatemala, and helping reactionary circles in America do
their dirty work-most notably during the Iran-Contra assault on the
Constitution and in the emergence of the alliance between Likud and
the Christian right. Counterarguments concerning Israel’s help in
the Cold War and in the region do not really outweigh these points.
However, Mearsheimer and Walt present the situation as one where the
Jewish tail wags the American dog, and where the United States has
gone to war in Iraq to gratify Ariel Sharon, and where the alliance
between the two countries has brought down on us the wrath of Osama
Bin Laden. This is partly misleading and partly creepy. If the Jewish
stranglehold on policy has been so absolute since the days of Harry
Truman, then what was Gen. Eisenhower thinking when, on the eve of an
election 50 years ago, he peremptorily ordered Ben Gurion out of Sinai
and Gaza on pain of canceling the sale of Israeli bonds? On the next
occasion when Israel went to war with its neighbors, 11 years later,
President Lyndon Johnson was much more lenient, but a strong motive
of his policy (undetermined by Israel) was to win Jewish support for
the war the “realists” were then waging in Vietnam. (He didn’t get
the support, except from Rabbi Meir Kahane.)
If it is Israel that decides on the deployment of American force,
it seems odd that the first President Bush had to order them to
stay out of the coalition to free Kuwait, and it is even more odd
that the first order of neocon business has not been an attack on
Iran, as Israeli hawks have been urging. Mearsheimer and Walt are
especially weak on this point: They speak darkly about neocon and
Israeli maneuvers in respect to Tehran today, but they entirely fail
to explain why the main initiative against the mullahs has come from
the European Union and the International Atomic Energy Authority,
two organizations where the voice of the Jewish lobby is, to say the
least, distinctly muted. Their theory does nothing to explain why it
was French President Jacques Chirac who took the lead in isolating
the death-squad regime of Assad’s Syria (a government that Mearsheimer
and Walt regard, for reasons of their own, as a force for stability).
As for the idea that Israel is the root cause of the emergence of
al-Qaida: Where have these two gentlemen been? Bin Laden’s gang
emerged from a whole series of tough and reactionary battles in
Central and Eastern Asia, from the war for a separate Muslim state in
the Philippines to the fighting in Kashmir, the Uighur territories in
China, and of course Afghanistan. There are hardly any Palestinians
in its ranks, and its communiques have been notable for how little
they say about the Palestinian struggle. Bin Laden does not favor a
Palestinian state; he simply regards the whole area of the former
British Mandate as a part of the future caliphate. The right of
the Palestinians to a state is a just demand in its own right, but
anyone who imagines that its emergence would appease-or would have
appeased-the forces of jihad is quite simply a fool. Is al-Qaida
fomenting civil war in Nigeria or demanding the return of East Timor
to Indonesia because its heart bleeds for the West Bank?
For purposes of contrast, let us look at two other regional allies
of the United States. Both Turkey and Pakistan have been joined to
the Pentagon hip since approximately the time of the emergence of the
state of Israel, which coincided with the Truman Doctrine. Pakistan
was, like Israel, cleaved from a former British territory. Since that
time, both states have carried out appalling internal repression
and even more appalling external aggression. Pakistan attempted a
genocide in Bangladesh, with the support of Nixon and Kissinger, in
1971. It imposed the Taliban as its client in a quasi-occupation of
Afghanistan. It continues to arm and train Bin Ladenists to infiltrate
Indian-held Kashmir, and its promiscuity with nuclear materials
exceeds anything Israel has tried with its stockpile at Dimona. Turkey
invaded Cyprus in 1974 and continues in illegal occupation of the
northern third of the island, which has been forcibly cleansed of
its Greek inhabitants. It continues to lie about its massacre of the
Armenians. U.N. resolutions have had no impact on these instances
of state terror and illegality in which the United States is also
partially implicated.
But here’s the thing: There is no Turkish or Pakistani ethnic
“lobby” in America. And here’s the other thing: There is no call for
“disinvestment” in Turkey or Pakistan. We are not incessantly told
that with these two friends we are partners in crime. Perhaps the
Greek Cypriots and Indians are in error in refusing to fly civilian
aircraft into skyscrapers. That might get the attention of the
“realists.” Or perhaps the affairs of two states, one secular Muslim
and one created specifically in the name of Islam, do not possess
the eternal fascination that attaches to the Jewish question.
There has been some disquiet expressed about Mearsheimer and Walt’s
over-fondness for Jewish name-dropping: their reiteration of the
names Wolfowitz, Perle, Feith, etc., as the neocon inner circle.
Well, it would be stupid not to notice that a group of high-energy Jews
has been playing a role in our foreign-policy debate for some time. The
first occasion on which it had any significant influence (because,
despite its tentacular influence, it lost the argument over removing
Saddam Hussein in 1991) was in pressing the Clinton administration to
intervene in Bosnia and Kosovo. These are the territories of Europe’s
oldest and largest Muslim minorities; they are oil-free and they
do not in the least involve the state interest of Israel. Indeed,
Sharon publicly opposed the intervention. One could not explain any
of this from Mearsheimer and Walt’s rhetoric about “the lobby.”
Mearsheimer and Walt belong to that vapid school that essentially
wishes that the war with jihadism had never started. Their wish is
father to the thought that there must be some way, short of a fight,
to get around this confrontation. Wishfulness has led them to seriously
mischaracterize the origins of the problem and to produce an article
that is redeemed from complete dullness and mediocrity only by being
slightly but unmistakably smelly.
Related in Slate Michael Kinsley explored why some people believe that,
as Hitchens put it, the “Jewish tail wags the American dog.” Anne
Kornblut explained why, unlike past Republican presidents, President
Bush is tight with Jewish voters. With a track record like this, maybe
Turkish-Americans should think about setting up an ethnic lobby. On
the other hand, the Cuban-American lobby may be pretty powerful,
but Jacob Weisberg suggested it has helped keep the island isolated
from democracy.
Christopher Hitchens is a columnist for Vanity Fair. His most recent
book is Thomas Jefferson: Author of America. His most recent collection
of essays is titled Love, Poverty, and War.

Robert Kocharyan Still Abstains From Ascertaining Lukashenko’s Victo

ROBERT KOCHARYAN STILL ABSTAINS FROM ASCERTAINING LUKASHENKO’S VICTORY
Regnum, Russia
March 27 2006
President of Armenia Robert Kocharyan still has not congratulated his
Byelorussian counterpart with victory at his third presidential race,
informs a REGNUM correspondent.
According to information of the Byelorussian Central Electoral
committee on presidential elections on March 19, Alexander Lukashenko
received 83% of votes. Main opponents, Milinkevich and Kozulin received
6.1% and 2.2% votes correspondingly.
Presidents of Russia, Iran, Cuba, Abkhazia, South Ossetia and several
other countries already congratulated Alexander Lukashenko with
his victory.
The US declines to recognize the results of Byelorussian elections,
because they took place “in the atmosphere of fear.” “The US does
not recognize the results of elections. We support the appeal for
the new elections,” stated on March 20 spokesman of the White House
Scott McClellan.

BAKU: Azerbaijan’s FM: “We Should Continue Talks Within Prague Proce

AZERBAIJAN’S FM: “WE SHOULD CONTINUE TALKS WITHIN PRAGUE PROCESS”
Azeri Press Agency, Azerbaijan
March 27 2006
“We think we should continue the negotiations within the Prague
process. We have always said and will say that our stance remains
unchanged. If we really want to solve the Nagorno Garabagh conflict
once and for all, we should apply international juridical norms.
The world community recognizes Nagorno Garabagh as the territory of
Azerbaijan,” Azerbaijan’s Foreign Minister Elmar Mammadyarov told
journalists (APA).
The Minister also said that the conflict can possibly be settled only
in the framework of Azerbaijan’s Constitution.
Mr.Mammadyarov objected to tendencies to compare the Garabagh conflict
with the Kosovo conflict as if they are similar. The Minister noted
that each conflict has its own specific features.