Regional leaders seal Kars-Akhalkalaki-Tbilisi-Baku railway deal

Eurasia Daily Monitor, DC
Jan 19 2007

REGIONAL LEADERS SEAL KARS-AKHALKALAKI-TBILISI-BAKU RAILWAY DEAL

By Fariz Ismailzade

Friday, January 19, 2007

Last Saturday, January 13, representatives from the governments of
Azerbaijan, Georgia, and Turkey took a significant step forward in
the realization of the Kars-Akhalkalaki-Tbilisi-Baku railway project,
which will link Asia and Europe through the Caucasus. Representatives
of three parties met in the Georgian capital, Tbilisi, to finalize
the negotiations over the project and sign a preliminary agreement.

Azerbaijan’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs issued a statement on
January 16 welcoming the agreement and calling it `an important event
in regional trade and economic cooperation’ (Press Release, January
16). Georgian Prime Minister Zurab Nogaideli also welcomed the
project by saying that the railway link will become `a bridge between
Europe and Asia’ (Day.az, January 19).

Under the terms of the negotiated agreement, Azerbaijan will issue a
loan to the Georgian government in the amount of $220 million for
construction of a vital segment of the railway. Georgian Minister of
Economic Development Georgy Arveladze, however, put this number at
$300 million (Day.az, January 18). The loan will be virtually
interest-free and is to be repaid within a period of 25 years using
the profits generated by the railway. The Turkish government, for its
part, will improve some portions of the railway in its own territory,
to bring it up to the required standards.

Azerbaijan’s minister of transportation, Ziya Mammadov, told ANS-TV
on January 18 that construction would start in the second half of
2007 and be completed within two or three years. `I have no doubt
that this project will be realized,’ Mammadov added.

The project comes amid protests from the Armenian lobby and a
prohibition put in place last year by the U.S. Congress on financing
the project from U.S. government funds. While two other major
Caucasus projects, the Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan oil pipeline and the
Baku-Tbilisi-Erzurum gas pipeline, were strongly supported in U.S.
political circles, the railway project received a cold shoulder,
despite the fact that it will further deepen regional cooperation and
expand the East-West trade corridor.

The reason for such a negative attitude is the Armenian lobby in the
United States and its influence on U.S. policymakers. The railway,
bypassing Armenia, further links Georgia and Azerbaijan to Western
markets and puts Armenia behind the regional trade and economic
cooperation. Last week, the Armenian Foreign Ministry expressed
interest in joining the railway project, yet the Azerbaijani side
responded by saying that Armenia must first liberate the occupied
territories of Azerbaijan.

Nevertheless, despite opposition from Armenia and the lack of
financial support from the United States, the Azerbaijani, Georgian,
and Turkish governments are eager to move forward with the project.
`The U.S. can issue any decisions it wants, but there will be no
problems with financing the project. There are other sources,’ said
Georgian Minister of Foreign Affairs Gela Bezhuashvilli (Trend News
Agency, January 10). The increasing revenues from Azerbaijan’s oil
contracts with Western oil companies have provide the government with
sufficient means to finance the project with its own funds.

Estimates set the cost of constructing the missing 98-kilometer
section link of the Kars-Akhalkalaki-Tbilisi-Baku railway will cost
around $400 million and raise the trade turnover by rail to 15-20
million tons per year. It will allow the direct shipment of goods and
people between Asia and Europe and vice versa and further develop the
regional infrastructure. It will be an essential part of the Silk
Road strategy, which envisions the development of trade ties between
the countries along the ancient Silk Road. China and Kazakhstan have
also expressed interest in the realization of the railway project.

Given the recent political changes in Turkmenistan following the
death of long-time President Saparmurat Niyazov, some analysts think
that bilateral Azerbaijani-Turkmen relations will warm and revive
regional trade and cooperation between these two Caspian states. If
this scenario occurs, it will provide additional significance to the
Kars-Akhalkalaki-Tbilisi-Baku railway.

Negotiations among Turkey, Azerbaijan, and Georgia are expected to
resume in the next few days regarding the concrete details of the
project. After this, the parliaments of these three countries will
ratify the agreement and construction work will start. When
completed, the project will be a major victory point for both
Azerbaijan and Georgia, because both countries will increase their
economic linkages and trade turnover, but even more importantly the
railway will also reduce their dependence on Russian railways to ship
goods to European markets.

Kars-Akhalkalaki-Tbilisi-Baku rail project soon to roll forward

Eurasia Daily Monitor, DC
Jan 19 2007

KARS-AKHALKALAKI-TBILISI-BAKU RAIL PROJECT SOON TO ROLL FORWARD

By Vladimir Socor

Friday, January 19, 2007

Thanks in large measure to Azerbaijan’s rapidly growing economic
strength, the Kars-Akhalkalaki-Tbilisi-Baku (KATB) railroad-building
project can soon become a reality. The project had stalled for more
than a decade, due to a lack of funding for the Georgian stretch of
the line. Now Azerbaijan is able to finance that part of the project.

On January 13 in Tbilisi, Georgian Economic Development Minister
Giorgi Arveladze and Azerbaijan’s Transport Minister Zia Mamedov
signed the relevant credit agreement on highly preferential terms.
Azerbaijan is providing a $220 million loan, repayable in 25 years,
with an annual interest rate of only 1%. This agreement will be
followed by an inter-bank agreement between the two countries and
then a tender to select the construction companies.

The line’s overall length is 258 kilometers (about 160 miles), of
which the Georgian section is the most challenging. There, 30
kilometers from the Turkish border to Akhalkalaki must be built from
scratch and another 120 kilometers of existing tracks need full
rehabilitation. Turkey will build a 68-kilometer line from Kars to
the Georgian border from scratch, at a cost of more than $200
million. KATB’s overall cost is estimated at up to $600 million.
Construction work in Georgia is expected to start in the third
quarter of 2007 and to require two-and-a-half years. The railroad’s
anticipated capacity is 10 to 15 million tons annually by the third
year of operation and up to 20 million tons annually afterward.

KATB has been conceived as a linchpin in the projected trans-Eurasian
railroad that would connect the European railroad network, via Turkey
and Georgia, to the Caspian Sea at Baku, continuing with ferryboat
lines to the eastern Caspian shore. There, the KATB line can connect
in the future with the proposed China-Kazakhstan-Europe railroad.

Even before the trans-Kazakhstan railroad from China becomes a
reality, the KATB itself with a trans-Caspian connection will be the
first major project that implements the European Union’s vision of a
Transport Corridor Europe-Caucasus-Central Asia (TRACECA), popularly
known as the `new Silk Road’ from Europe to China. The EU had
launched TRACECA in the South Caucasus in the mid-1990s amid great
expectations, but practically abandoned it afterward. The EU is not
investing in KATB, although it is aware of its potential benefits,
according to a statement issued by the German embassy in Baku on
behalf of the EU’s German presidency (Az.day, January 17).

Absent EU involvement, the United Nations Economic Commission for
Europe (UNECE) had considered supporting the KATB project in the
1990s, but eventually opted out as well. Ultimately, in May 2005
Presidents Ilham Aliyev of Azerbaijan, Mikheil Saakashvili of
Georgia, and Ahmed Necdet Sezer of Turkey signed a declaration of
intent to build the KATB railroad.

The United States is officially taking a bystander’s attitude toward
this project, `neither opposing it nor actively promoting it.’ In the
latter part of 2006, Armenian lobbying organizations succeeded in
amending the U.S. Export-Import Bank Reauthorization Act to prohibit
Eximbank funding to the KATB project, on the grounds that it
`isolates’ Armenia. In Moscow, empire-rebuilding advocate Andranik
Migranian applauded the Congressional vote: `This is a
well-thought-out step on the part of the American authorities’
(Rustavi-2 Television, December 8, 2006). President George W. Bush
signed the Act into law in December 2006 after both chambers of
Congress had passed it in that form.

Yerevan and its supporters call for reopening and overhauling the
existing railroad from Kars to Gyumri in Armenia and using it instead
of KATB. Turkey had closed the Kars-Gyumri line in response to
Armenia’s seizure of territories in Azerbaijan in 1994. The United
States and the EU are urging Turkey to reopen the border with
Armenia, including the Kars-Gyumri railroad, as part of efforts to
promote a settlement of the Armenia-Azerbaijan conflict.

Irrespective of this political context, however, Kars-Gyumri is
essentially a local line, in no sense a substitute for the KATB
project of transcontinental relevance. From the standpoint of Turkey,
Georgia, and Azerbaijan, KATB provides their most direct as well as
politically safest link to the EU on one side and to Central Asia on
the other, as well as an inter-connector among the three
Western-oriented countries.

KATB has special significance to Georgia. The railroad can bring
economic development to the deeply impoverished, Armenian-inhabited
Javakheti region and ensure political stability there. It will also
provide Georgia with a reliable outlet to the outside world,
following Russia’s decision in 2006 to shut off transport
communications with Georgia.

With U.S. leadership faltering on this issue and EU leadership
absent, Azerbaijan is now demonstrating that it can take the
initiative in making the KATB railroad possible.

(Turan, Today.Az, Messenger, Civil Georgia, Turkish Daily News,
PanArmaniaNet, January 14-17; see EDM, November 9, 2006)

‘The Bastard of Istanbul’: Turks, Armenians and a troubled past

International Herald Tribune, France
Jan 19 2007

‘The Bastard of Istanbul’: Turks, Armenians and a troubled past

By Lorraine Adams
Published: January 19, 2007

The Bastard of Istanbul. By Elif Shafak. 360 pages. $24.95. Viking.

There is a moral putrescence peculiar to the denial of genocide. Yet
denial’s practitioners are all around us. The Sudanese government
calls the butchers of Darfur "self-defense militias." The Iranian
president, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, dismisses the Holocaust as "myth." In
an official government report, the Turkish Historical Society
describes the slaughter of more than a million Armenians between 1914
and 1918 as "relocations" with "some untoward incidents."

It seems obvious that the Turkish novelist Elif Shafak smells the rot
in her homeland. Indeed, "The Bastard of Istanbul," her sixth novel
and the second written in English, recently led to a suit by the
right- wing attorney Kemal Kerincsiz, who declared that Shafak’s
Armenian characters were "insulting Turkishness" by referring to the
"millions" of Armenians "massacred" by "Turkish butchers" who "then
contentedly denied it all." Earlier, Kerincsiz sued Turkey’s
best-known novelist, the Nobel Prize-winner Orhan Pamuk, for telling
a Swiss journalist that "30,000 Kurds and one million Armenians were
killed in these lands, and nobody but me dares to talk about it."

Pamuk’s isolation is less than complete and his stance not entirely
daring. Kerincsiz and others have brought about 60 similar cases, a
majority concerning the Armenian genocide, and not one has resulted
in prison time. Kerincsiz opposes Turkey’s bid for membership in the
European Union, and he acknowledges that these circus displays of his
country’s censorship laws aid his cause.

Although the international literary community has rallied behind
Pamuk and Shafak, both of whose cases were dismissed, there has been
decidedly less clamor about the suits brought against
Turkish-Armenian journalists, translators and political activists. At
the same time, Turkish nationalists have charged that Pamuk’s Nobel
and Shafak’s place in the spotlight have had more to do with their
persecution than with the merits of their work.

The critical consensus on Pamuk is undeniably strong, that on Shafak
far less substantial. Most of her novels have not been reviewed in
the West, and with the recent uproar she has become more discussed
than read. Here, she has taken on a subject of deep moral
consequence. But is the work worthy of its subject?

"The Bastard of Istanbul," set in the United States and Turkey,
concerns two families – one Turkish, living in Istanbul, and the
other Armenian, divided between Tucson, Arizona, and San Francisco.
(Shafak is currently an assistant professor of Near Eastern studies
at the University of Arizona.) An ardent feminist, Shafak populates
her novel with women. It’s no surprise, then, that Mustafa, the
Turkish man at the center of the plot, is more of an enigma than a
character. First seen in a Tucson supermarket as a college student,
he falls for and soon marries a young American who has recently
divorced her Armenian husband. Not only does his new wife enjoy
offending her Armenian in- laws with a Turkish spouse, she also
relishes the idea that her baby daughter will have a Turkish
stepfather.

That child, Armanoush, endures shuttle parenting, moving between her
mother in Arizona and her father and his relatives in San Francisco.
Shafak sketches these Armenians flatly and superficially, as
uniformly and fiercely anti-Turk – and as overprotectively fretful
about beautiful and bookish Armanoush. Instead of exploring her roots
with her own family, she makes contact with Armenian-Americans
online, joining a chat group dedicated to intellectual issues,
including combating Turkish denial of the massacres. At 21, Armanoush
somewhat illogically travels to Istanbul, where none of her Armenian
relatives remain. She stays with her stepfather’s Turkish family.

The family this young woman encounters is a confusing swirl of four
generations of women that includes a great-grandmother suffering from
Alzheimer’s disease; a disapproving, distant and angry grandmother;
her four daughters; and one great-granddaughter. The eldest daughter
is a self- styled Muslim mystic; another is a high school teacher,
and yet another a schizophrenic. The youngest runs a tattoo parlor
and has an illegitimate daughter, the bastard of the novel’s title.

Keeping all these women straight isn’t crucial since they function
chiefly as adornments of Shafak’s magic realism. We learn, for
example, that the men of the family for "generations after
generations … had died young and unexpectedly," a contrivance that
explains why Mustafa is living in Arizona and has never returned to
Istanbul to see his sisters.

Armanoush’s visit, which begins as an impulsive spurt of tourism,
unexpectedly leads to a far darker explanation of her stepfather’s
exile. (Those who wish to read the novel and not have the ending
spoiled should stop here.)

Armanoush inadvertently helps reveal Mustafa’s secret – that he raped
his youngest sister, that this sister covered up for him and that her
child is a product of incest. It takes the mystic sister, with the
help of an evil djinni, to bring about both her brother’s death and
his daughter’s discovery of her origins.

Mustafa’s crime is meant, presumably, to symbolize Turkey’s
long-denied history of genocide. But the fate of the Armenians is by
no means obscure: Scholars around the world have documented it with
precision. Unlike the members of the Armenian diaspora, Mustafa’s
sister willfully hides the circumstances of her rape – although it’s
difficult to believe that this miniskirted, high-heeled, radically
irreverent woman would have engaged in such subterfuge.

When the novel’s skeleton finally dances out of its flimsy closet,
it’s clear that although Shafak may be a writer of moral compunction
she has yet to become – in English, at any rate – a good novelist.
But Shafak, still in her 30s, has more than enough time to grow into
a writer whose artistry matches her ambition.

Lorraine Adams is a writer in residence at the New School in New York
and author of the novel, "Harbor."

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Turkey Responsible for Dink’s Murder

PanARMENIAN.Net

Turkey Responsible for Dink’s Murder
20.01.2007 12:59 GMT+04:00

/PanARMENIAN.Net/ The Federation of Armenian Organizations in the
Netherlands (FAON) is shocked to hear of the assassination of Armenian
journalist Hrant Dink living in Turkey. Just last month Dink visited
the Netherlands to receive the Oxfam pen Award. Dink was a brave man,
who was future oriented. In many ways Turkey carries responsibility
for the death of Dink.

By educating generations with the superiority of the Turks and with
the denial of the Armenian Genocide for decades the Turks in fact have
been stirring up Turks against Armenians. Also Turkey didn’t give
protection to Hrant Dink, he was in fact outlawed,’ says the FAON
statement.

The Hornet’s Nest

The hornet’s nest Stallone is planning to put his foot to

Saturday, 20 January 2007 Written by Alexander G. Rubio

er_stallone1_large.jpg

I think it’s safe to say a man of Sylvester Stallone’s means can
afford to globetrot with the best of them. But prudence should perhaps
dictate that he scratch Turkey off his shortlist of potential vacation
spots. As the whole pre-Nobel Prize saga of Orhan Pamuk, and related
cases, show, there are certain historical topics that are prone to
stir up a bit of… bad blood… in that part of the world – One of
them is, of course, the question of the status of the Kurdish
population. But chief among them is perhaps the festering sore that is
the Armenian genocide ()
.

As recent events have shown, it is a question that still provokes
deadly conflict. The murder of the Armenian journalist and editor
Hrant Dink, who had been the victim of even official persecution
( ison/honorarymembers/turkey/hrantdink/)
, is a glaring example of just how inflamed this topic really is.

And this is the hornet’s nest Stallone is planning to put his foot to.

( ink_large.jpg) The
star of such movies as, "Rocky", its recent sequel "Rocky Balboa", and
the decidedly non-pacifist "Rambo" is planning to shoot a movie based
on the book "The Forty Days of Musa Dagh"
( _Days_of_Musa_Dagh) about the
Armenian Genocide by the Austrian author Franz Werfel, according to
The Denver Post, via Filmstalker
( /2007/01/stallone_may_direct_armenian_g.ht
ml) .

During World War I, as the Ottoman Turkish empire fought Russian
forces, some of the Armenian minority in eastern Anatolia sided with
the Russians.

Turkey took reprisals. On 24 April 1915 it rounded up and killed
hundreds of Armenian community leaders.

In May 1915, the Armenian minority, two or three million strong, was
forcefully deported and marched from the Anatolian borders towards
Syria and Mesopotamia (now Iraq). Many died en route.

The issue has long been a contentious topic in Turkey, which claims
the 1915 events () were not
genocide, something that has become a bit of a problem in Turkish
relations to the European Union, which it hopes to join as a member,
due to the European Parliament’s decision
( tion.152/current_category.7/affirmation_detail.htm l)
to recognise as genocide the extermination of around 1.5 million
civilian Armenians in Turkey (the Ottoman Empire at the time) in 1915.

Late last year, French MPs also passed a bill making it a crime to
deny that the Ottoman Turkish empire committed genocide against
Armenians, a decision that delighted Armenians and infuriated the
Turks.

For years Stallone’s wanted to create an epic, and the book that
intrigues him is Franz Werfel’s "The Forty Days of Musa Dagh,"
detailing the Turkish genocide of its Armenian community in
1915. (After futile attempts to turn the novel into a movie,
filmmakers finally succeeded in 1982, but it was a low-profile
production.)

French ships eventually rescued some Armenians, and Stallone has his
favorite scene memorized: "The French ships come, and they’ve dropped
the ladders and everybody has climbed up the side. The ships sail. The
hero, the one who set up the rescue, has fallen asleep, exhausted,
behind a rock on the slope above. The camera pulls back, and the ships
and the sea are on one side, and there’s one lonely figure at the top
of the mountain, and the Turks are coming up the mountain by the
thousands on the far side."

A pretty great shot.

The movie would be "an epic about the complete destruction of a
civilization," Stallone said. Then he laughed at the ambition. "Talk
about a political hot potato. The Turks have been killing that subject
for 85 years."

And the blow-back has not been slow in coming. UK daily The
Independent
( ple/pandora/article2162835.ece)
reports that the plans have attracted the wrath of the Turkish
community in Hollywood.

( an_genocide_turkey_large.JPG)
A group calling themselves the Association on Struggle Against
Armenian Genocide Acknowledgement is targeting Stallone with an angry
letters campaign urging him not to make the film.

"The book is full of lies, since the author got his information from
nationalist and radical Armenians," says the association’s chairman,
Savas Egilmez.

"We have already sent necessary documents about the mentioned days to
the producer of the film. Our allies will urge the producer not to
produce this film."

On the eve of the orchestration of his own genocide against the Jews,
Hitler took comfort from the fact that such an atrocity could
seemingly pass all but unnoticed to the outside world. "Who remembers
the Armenians?", he asked. Well, quite few, and more each day, seems
to be the answer.

http://www.bitsofnews.com/images/graphics/sylvest
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Armenian_Genocide
http://www.englishpen.org/writersinpr
http://www.bitsofnews.com/images/graphics/hrant_d
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Forty
http://www.filmstalker.co.uk/archives
http://www.theforgotten.org/intro.html
http://www.armenian-genocide.org/Affirma
http://news.independent.co.uk/peo
http://www.bitsofnews.com/images/graphics/armeni

His Holiness Karekin II Condemns Assassination of Hrant Dink

PRESS RELEASE
Mother See of Holy Etchmiadzin, Information Services
Address:  Vagharshapat, Republic of Armenia
Contact:  Rev. Fr. Ktrij Devejian
Tel:  (374 10) 517 163
Fax:  (374 10) 517 301
E-Mail:  [email protected]
Website: 
January 20, 2007

His Holiness Karekin II Condemns Assassination of Hrant Dink
Requiem Service to be offered in all Armenian Churches

His Holiness Karekin II, Supreme Patriarch and Catholicos of All Armenians,
sent a letter today to His Beatitude Archbishop Mesrob Mutafian, Armenian
Patriarch of Constantinople, on the tragic assassination in Istanbul
yesterday of journalist Hrant Dink, editor of the Agos weekly newspaper.  On
behalf of the Brotherhood of Holy Etchmiadzin and the Supreme Spiritual
Council of the Armenian Church, His Holiness expressed his sympathies to
Patriarch Mesrob, the family and friends of Hrant Dink, the editorial staff
of Agos weekly and all Armenians living in Turkey.

His Holiness’ letter states in part:  "We learned of Hrant Dink’s
assassination yesterday with deep sorrow.  His untimely and tragic death has
shocked us all.  We and all our people grieve the loss of yet another
intellectual who has become an innocent victim.  In the strongest of terms,
we condemn this clandestine assassination which took from our people a
graceful and courageous son, who faithfully brought his service with his pen
for the love of a just, free and peaceful life and better world.  We also
expect that the authorities of Turkey will uncover and punish the
individuals responsible for this crime to the fullest extent of the law."

By order of the Pontiff of All Armenians, following the Divine Liturgy on
Sunday, January 21, a special Repose of Souls service will be offered in the
Mother Cathedral of Holy Etchmiadzin and all Armenian Church dioceses
throughout the world, asking for rest for the soul of Hrant Dink of blessed
memory.

Blessed be the memory of the righteous.

www.armenianchurch.org

Reporters w/o Borders: Deep shock re Turkish-Armenian Editor Murder

Reporters without borders (press release), France
Jan 19 2007

Deep shock over Turkish-Armenian editor’s murder today in Istanbul

Reporters Without Borders said it was deeply shocked by the murder of
Hrant Dink, editor and columnist of the bilingual Turkish-Armenian
weekly Agos, who was gunned down by an unidentified man today outside
his newspaper in Istanbul.

`This murder will distress and disturb all those who defend the
freedom of thought and expression in Turkey and elsewhere,’ the press
freedom organisation said. `The Turkish government must weigh the
extreme gravity of this crime and ensure that a thorough
investigation identifies those responsible as quickly as possible.’

Reporters Without Borders added: `This will be a key test for a
country that hopes to join the European Union. No one would
understand if Turkey failed to do everything possible to shed light
on this tragedy.’

Aged 53, Dink was killed by several shots fired at him shortly after
midday as he was outside the premises of his privately-owned
newspaper in Sisli, a district on the European side of Istanbul. The
police said they were looking for a youth aged about 18 or 19 wearing
a jean-jacket and a white beret.

A well-known journalist and one who was respected by his colleagues,
Dink was the target of several prosecutions over his views on the
massacre of Armenians under the Ottoman empire. In 2005, he received
six-month suspended sentence for `humiliating Turkish identity.’ He
was prosecuted against in September 2006 over an interview he gave to
Reuters in which he referred to the massacres in Anatolia during the
First World War as `genocide.’ He had been facing a possible
three-year prison sentence.

Reporters Without Borders is supporting the call issued by the
Coordinating Council of Armenian Organisations in France (CCAF) for a
demonstration at noon tomorrow outside the Turkish embassy on Rue
Ankara in Paris’ 16th district.

Armenian journalist assassinated in Turkey

Financial Mirror, Cyprus
Jan 19 2007

Armenian journalist assassinated in Turkey

19/01/2007

Hrant Dink, the editor of Turkey’s main Armenian-language newspaper
Agos who had questioned Turkey’s denial of the Armenian genocide, was
shot dead in Istanbul Friday.

Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan called the assassination an
attack against `Turkey’s stability.’

Turkish stocks fell after the shooting was reported by as much as 1%
in Istanbul following the attack after rising 1.4% earlier, Bloomberg
reported, fearing new civil strife from nationalist elements.

Dink, one of the most prominent ethnic Armenians in Turkey, received
a sixth-month suspended jail term from a Turkish court in July for
`insulting Turkishness’ in a 2004 article he wrote about the killing
of hundreds of thousands of Armenians by Ottoman Turks at the time of
World War I. Turkey denies that a genocide took place.

`This attack against Hrant Dink is against the Turkish nation’s
togetherness and peace,’ Erdogan said. `A bullet was fired at freedom
of thought and democratic life.’

According to Sabah, Erdogan said `the chief editor of Agos newspaper
Hrant Dink has become an innocent victim of an obnoxious murder.
Shady forces have once more chosen our country to reach their ill
desires. The bullets that shot Hrant Dink today are in fact bullets
fired for the unity of our nation. I have already commissioned the
minister of justice as well as the minister of internal affairs to
capture the assassin.
We have lived on these lands together for many centuries. No ill plot
can ruin Turley’s unity. I believe Turkish and Armenian citizens have
the common sense to recover from such treachery."

The European Union has called on Turkey to halt the prosecution of
writers and journalists for expressing their opinion or face a halt
to its membership bid.

Dink was killed by an unidentified gunman outside his office in
Istanbul’s Sisli district, a spokeswoman for Agos said in a telephone
interview with Bloomberg.

`Whatever the motive, this is a despicable act,’ said Ilter Turkmen,
a former Turkish foreign minister, in a telephone interview. `The
government needs to find the assailant immediately.’

Just before his assassination, Dink had complained of death threats
he was receiving from nationalists.

`My computer is laden with lines filled with angry threats,’ Dink
wrote in a January 10 article for Agos. He said he found one letter
`extremely worrying’ and said police took no action after he
complained.

Police have arrested two people in connection with the murder, NTV
television reported. Police believe a male aged 18 or 19 may have
killed Dink, CNN Turk television reported citing unidentified police
officials.

Akin Birdal, the former head of Turkey’s Human Rights Association who
was shot six times in 1998 in his office by a suspected nationalist,
called the shooting `an organized attempt by those who want to
destroy Turkey’s European Union aspirations to cast Turkey into
darkness.’

Police in riot gear surrounded Dink’s office in downtown Istanbul.
Forensic teams were combing the pavement outside for clues to the
murder.

Dink, born in Malatya, southeast Turkey in 1954, was a member of
Turkey’s small ethnic Armenian community, and a Turkish citizen. He
was editor-in-chief of the bilingual Turkish and Armenian weekly Agos
().
Dink had been convicted of insulting Turkishness — under the
controversial article 301 of Turkey’s penal code — and handed a
six-month suspended sentence in 2005. The case was prompted by an
article he wrote in which he referred to an Armenian nationalist idea
of ethnic purity.

The European Union has repeatedly called on Ankara to change the law
and the government has promised to revise it.
Of his conviction, Dink had told Reuters: "I may be paying the price
for this, but Turkish democracy will gain from it, I hope."
Armenians have long campaigned for recognition of the genocide by
Ottoman Turks during World War One, but Dink opposed the French
parliament’s passing of a law banning denial of the Armenian
genocide. He said he would even be ready to go to prison in France in
defence of free speech.

www.agos.com.tr

Turkey: journalist of Armenian descent murdered

editorsweblog.org
Jan 19 2007

Turkey: journalist of Armenian descent murdered

Hrant Dink, a Turkish journalist of Armenian origins, editor of the
weekly Agos, was shot to death today in Istanbul. He had been sued by
Turkish courts and was the target of nationalist groups.
He was shot in front of his newspaper’s office. He had been sued
several times for saying that the massive killing of Armenians during
the Ottoman Empire was a genocide.

`Of course I say it’s a genocide. Because the result makes it what it
was. You can see that a people who had lived on these grounds for
4000 years has disappeared.’

Dink had been sued under the infamous penal code on ‘insulting
Turkishness," which has been used to persecute dozens of
intellectuals and speakers, usually because of their ‘genocidal’ view
of the Armenian massacre.

Armenians claim that 1.5 million of them were slaughtered between
1915 and 1918. According to Turkey, 300,000 Armenians were killed,
and just as many Turks when Armenians sided with Russian troops in
Anatolia, revolting against the Ottoman Empire.

Source: Le Monde (link in French)

Journalist, Prominent member of Turkish Armenian community slain

Brandon Sun, Canada
Jan 19 2007

Journalist, prominent member of Turkish Armenian community slain in
Istanbul
Canadian Press

ISTANBUL, Turkey (AP) – Hrant Dink, the most prominent voice of
Turkey’s shrinking Armenian community who stood trial for speaking
out against the mass killings of Armenians by Turks, was shot and
killed in broad daylight Friday at the entrance to his newspaper’s
offices.

Just hours after a gunman pumped two bullets into the journalist’s
head, thousands marched down the bustling street where he was slain.
They blocked traffic, carried posters of Dink and shouted slogans in
favour of free expression.

Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan twice addressed the country to
condemn the killing and vow to capture those responsible. Late
Friday, Istanbul’s governor announced that three people were
arrested, CNN-Turk television reported without giving further
details.

Most Turks assumed the shooting was politically motivated, a reaction
to Dink’s public statements that the mass killings of Armenians
around the time of the First World War constituted genocide.
Nationalists see such statements as insults to the honour of Turks
and as threats to national unity.

Regardless of the motive for Dink’s killing, Turkey remains a place
where people speak freely at their own peril despite generations of
Western-looking liberal reformers. The New York-based Committee to
Protect Journalists said that in the past 15 years, "18 Turkish
journalists have been killed for their work, many of them murdered,
making it the eighth deadliest country in the world for journalists."

Dink, 52, was one of dozens of journalists, writers and academics who
have gone on trial for expressing their opinions here, most under the
infamous article 301 of the penal code, which makes it a crime to
insult Turkey, its government or the national character.

In the most famous case, Nobel Prize-winning novelist Orhan Pamuk
faced jail time last year for insulting Turkey by saying Turks had
killed a million Armenians. His case was dropped on a technicality.

Dink, a Turkish citizen of Armenian descent who edited the bilingual
Turkish-Armenian newspaper Agos, clearly sensed his life was in
danger.

"My computer’s memory is loaded with sentences full of anger and
threats," Dink wrote Jan. 10 in his last newspaper column.

He complained that authorities had not responded to his letters about
threats against him – and his death less than two weeks later will
raise yet more questions about Turkey’s commitment to democracy as it
strives to join the European Union.

"I have become famous as an enemy of Turkey," he wrote.

Dink, who is survived by his wife, Rakel, and their three children,
was charming, soft-spoken and eloquent, even debonair. He was
respected and beloved by many Turks who disagreed with his views but
admired his courage in stating them.

He was hated by just as many.

The last that many Turks saw of Dink was the shocking image of his
body, face down and covered with a white sheet, his dress shoes
awkwardly splayed, lying in a small pool of blood on the middle of an
Istanbul sidewalk.

Witnesses said four bullet shells could be seen near his body. Family
members and co-workers cried and consoled one another as police
cordoned off the area and the crowd of onlookers, some of them with
sadness and shock etched onto their faces, grew larger.

In the past few years, Turks had come to know Dink well, most often
because of the high-profile freedom of expression cases opened
against him, in which he faced jail time for talking of genocide.

Turkey’s relationship with its Armenian community has long been
fraught with tension, controversy and painful memories of a brutal
past. Much of Turkey’s once-sizeable Armenian population was killed
or driven out beginning around 1915 in what an increasing number of
countries are recognizing as the first genocide of the 20th century.

Turks vehemently deny that their ancestors committed genocide,
however, and saying so is tantamount here to treason. In the 1970s
and 1980s, tensions were further inflamed as dozens of Turkish
diplomats were killed by Armenian assassins seeking revenge.

Turkey, which is 99 per cent Muslim, and Armenia, which claims to be
the first country to officially adopt Christianity, share a border.
But the border is closed, and the two countries have no formal
diplomatic relations.

But it’s not only the Armenian issue that draws fire here. Kurds have
suffered for years with oppressive laws limiting their ability to
speak their own language or speak up for equal rights. The country’s
dwindling Greek Orthodox community is the target of frequent protests
against its leader, the Istanbul-based Patriarch Bartholomew I.

A Catholic priest was murdered last year as he prayed in his church,
apparently by a teenage Turk incensed by the publication across
Europe of cartoons lampooning Islam’s Prophet Muhammad. Other priests
were also attacked and threatened.

Reporters Without Borders, a press freedom organization, urged
Turkey’s government to do everything possible to catch Dink’s
killers, and to recognize the "extreme gravity" of the crime.

"This murder will distress and disturb all those who defend the
freedom of thought and expression in Turkey and elsewhere," the group
said in a statement. "This will be a key test for a country that
hopes to join the European Union."

Dink’s killing will likely come to many as a final warning of the
consequences of failure, and his last column suggested he wasn’t
optimistic.

"For me, 2007 is likely to be a hard year," Dink wrote. "The trials
will continue, new ones will be started. Who knows what other
injustices I will be up against."