ANKARA: Foreign Ministry Condemns Assassination Of Dink

Turkish Press
Jan 20 2007

Foreign Ministry Condemns Assassination Of Dink
Published: 1/20/2007

ANKARA – The Turkish Foreign Ministry strongly condemned the
assassination of Turkish journalist of Armenian descent Hrant Dink,
editor-in-chief of bilingual Turkish-Armenian weekly Agos, on Friday.

The ministry expressed sorrow over death of Dink, and stated,
"security forces launched initiatives to arrest the assassin or
assassins."

The ministry offered condolences to family and relatives of Dink as
well as staff of Agos weekly and Turkish people of Armenian descent.

Turkish journalist murdered

Dominican Today, Dominican Republic
Jan 20 2007

Turkish journalist murdered

Istanbul.- An outspoken journalist who repeatedly clashed with
Turkish authorities over recognition of the early 20th Century
slaughter of Armenians was shot to death in broad daylight on a busy
Istanbul street on Friday.

Hrant Dink, who as editor of a Turkish-Armenian newspaper was the
leading voice for his ethnic community, died a week after he wrote
about threats from unknown forces who he said regarded him "an enemy
of the Turks."

Hundreds of people marched from the city’s central Taksim Square to
the offices of Dink’s Agos weekly newspaper on Friday evening near
the spot on a sidewalk where he was shot in the head. They held
candles and posters of him; a somber silence was interrupted
periodically with applause and chants for "the brotherhood of
peoples."

Istanbul Governor Muammer Guler said late Friday that three people
were detained in connection with the shooting, but no additional
details were released.

The slaying is likely to further darken Turkey’s reputation for
repressing critics of the government or of the country’s tight
control on how its turbulent past is portrayed.

Dink, 52, was part of an elite group of writers and thinkers,
including Nobel Literature laureate Orhan Pamuk and novelist Elif
Safak, who have been tried on charges of insulting their country’s
"Turkishness" under an ambiguous law promoted by hard-line
nationalists.

While most, including Pamuk, were cleared, Dink was convicted in 2005
for writing articles that criticized the law and explored questions
of Turkish and Armenian identity. He was sentenced to a six-month
term, which was suspended.

Last year, an Istanbul court opened a new case against him after he
told a foreign news agency that the World War I-era slaughter of
hundreds of thousands of Armenians by Ottoman Turks was genocide.

"Of course I say it was genocide," Dink had said. "With these events
you see the disappearance of a people who lived on these lands for
4,000 years."

Dink helped promote a conference of academics in 2005 who gathered
here to examine the era’s mass killings. The government attempted to
block the conference, and the justice minister accused participants
of "stabbing Turkey in the back."

On Friday, however, Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan was
among the first to condemn Dink’s "traitorous" and "disgraceful"
murder.

"Bullets have been fired at free thought and our democratic life,"
Erdogan said at a news conference. He urged calm.

ANKARA: Who killed the Turkish editor Hrant Dink?

Journal of Turkish Weekly
Jan 20 2007

Who killed the Turkish editor Hrant Dink?
Baris Sanli

Saturday , 20 January 2007

The bitterness diffused to everyone. For days, it has been cold and
dry in Ankara, yesterday the weather showed its mild face and rained
a bit. The rain, as if the clouds have cried, has added to this
bitterness.

Last night to this morning, whomever I talked, everyone expressed
his/her condemnations. From the mail list, there was this sense of
denial. The conspiracy machines were working at full speed. It is a
belief that most of the Turks think that this is completely an act
against Turkey and Turkey’s thesis. Even ultra-nationalists are
thinking this way.

What is the best time to expect such a horrible act like killing an
Armenian writer? I thought, in the 1980s, when ASALA was at large,
the attacks to the Armenian society was more likely. But that never
happened. This time, a Turkish Armenian editor, who is human, modest
and intellectual, has been shot dead.

I am personally very sorry, first of all another Turk has died.
Secondly, an adversary of mine has died. The readers of my column,
Turkish Chilli, will remember my sarcastic articles about Armenians.
I am quite successful irritating every Armenian.

One thing everyone has to ask himself is what the murderers have
aimed? A greater Turkey? To rotten Armenian allegations through the
blood of an editor who supports dialog? Greater nationalist aims?
Punishing?

At the end, from Military to hard core nationalists, everyone
condemned the incident, and acted as if it was a bullet to the heart
of Turkey. First of all a Turkish citizen has been killed, secondly a
sui generis Turkish citizen has been killed who defended Turkey in
France. In this sense he was more Turk than opposing
ultra-nationalists.

The post-Ottoman Turkish identity in general is defined by Ataturk’s
famous proverb: `How happy is the one who says I am a Turk’. He
doesn’t say `How happy is the one who is a Turk’. So, anyone who
identifies himself as a Turk, may not be an ethnic Turk. If someone
says I am a Turk, then he/she is a Turk, according to Ataturk.

The nationalist idea does not make you a Turk, but how you define
yourself, what you did for your country counts. With this logic and
his efforts in France against Armenian aims and his love for this
land, makes him a Turkish nationalist which the protesters against
him can only dream of. We will remember his name, but not his
protestors.

So who killed him? The popular rumours in Ankara are those: First
suspect is a foreign intelligence service, who is against Turkey’s EU
accession. This service has been accused of carrying out killings in
Turkey like Necip Hablemitoglu’s murder and provoking inter-ethnic
clashes. Also this intelligence organization’s name is related to
Sivas incident.

Second is, this may be an incident stemming from disputes among
Armenian groups. Mr. Dink’s ideas were not in parallel with other
Armenian groups, especially with those living in Diaspora.

Ask yourself calmly as if he was alive. Who will benefit most from
his death? Turkey? Armenian Diaspora? Anti-Turkish EU camp? Or idiot
ultra-nationalist?

At the end, we will probably face Agca dilemma. The killer may be an
ordinary guy, who has nationalist links but not complete connection,
who doesn’t ask lots of question and claiming his motives as `to
serve Turkish nation’. He will not be rich, probably he will have
debts. He has probably been in different ideological circles but he
will lack any leadership skills or charisma. He will also show signs
of psychological disorders.

These are my ideas and may not be true. But if these are correct, he
will probably be a perfect candidate for `Dark hands’

BAKU: Hrant Dink, editor-in-chief of `Aqos’ in Turkey, was killed

Azeri Press Agency, Azerbaijan
Jan 19 2007

Hrant Dink, the editor-in-chief of `Aqos’ newspaper published in
Turkey in Armenian language, was killed

[ 19 Jan. 2007 18:00 ]

Hrant Dink, the editor-in-chief of `Aqos’ newspaper published in
Turkey in Armenian language, was killed, APA Turkey bureau reports.

The incident happened today in front of the editorial office. Unknown
persons fired on editor-in-chief for four times. Dink died in the
site. Though Hrant Dink was known as the defender of Armenians, he
criticized the approval of the law that demanded the punishment of
those who deny false `Armenian genocide’. /APA/

Dink’s Murder is a Proof for Turkish Intolerance, for over 90 years

PanARMENIAN.Net

Dink’s Murder is a Proof for Turkish Intolerance,
which Continues More than 90 Years
20.01.2007 13:42 GMT+04:00

/PanARMENIAN.Net/ The Armenian National Committee of America (ANCA)
mourns the loss of Hrant Dink, a leading Istanbul-based Armenian
journalist murdered outside the offices of his Agos newspaper amid a
growing tide of official Turkish government prosecutions and
nationalist pressure to silence his writings on the Armenian Genocide,
says the ANCA statement. `Hrant Dink’s murder is tragic proof that the
Turkish government through its campaign of denial, threats and
intimidation against the recognition of the Armenian Genocide
continues to fuel the same hatred and intolerance that initially led
to this crime against humanity more than 90 years ago," said ANCA
Executive Director Aram Hamparian.

He also added the Turkish government can continue denying the Armenian
Genocide in great measure due to the complicity of the U.S.
Administration, which, at Turkey’s urging, works against Congressional
legislation commemorating this crime and has even nominated an
Ambassador to Armenia, Richard Hoagland, who is on record denying that
it was a genocide. "Today’s brutal murder serves as a wake up call to
the United States and the entire international community to unite
together in ending forever the Turkish government’s denial of the
Armenian Genocide," Hamparian said.

It’s worth mentioning Congressman Adam Schiff has called on his House
colleagues to join with him in praising Hrant Dink’s courage in
confronting the facts of the Armenian Genocide, and urging the Prime
Minister of Turkey to repeal the law under which Dink was prosecuted.

Protests To Condemn Killing of Dink In Istanbul And Ankara

PanARMENIAN.Net

Protests To Condemn Killing of Dink In Istanbul And Ankara
20.01.2007 13:50 GMT+04:00

/PanARMENIAN.Net/ A group has organized a sit-in protest to condemn
assassination of Hrant Dink, editor-in-chief of bilingual
Turkish-Armenian weekly Agos in Istanbul. Protestors carried banners
reading "All We Are Hrant Dink" and "We Condemn Those Who Murdered
Hrant Dink". On the other hand, nearly 700 people from several
non-governmental organizations held a demonstration to protest killing
of Dink in Kizilay Square in Ankara. Ismail Hakki Tombul, chairman of
the Confederation of Public Sector Labor Unions, said that Dink was
murdered in a disgraceful attack, noting that the bullet fired at Dink
was also fired at those who wanted to live free in Turkey.

Meanwhile, a group of people gathered in front of Human Rights
Monument in Yuksel Street in Ankara and chanted slogans denouncing
assassination of Dink.
From: Baghdasarian

Chief of General Staff of Turkish Army Condemns `Hateful Attack’

PanARMENIAN.Net

Chief of General Staff of Turkish Army Condemns `Hateful Attack’
Against Hrant Dink
20.01.2007 14:08 GMT+04:00

/PanARMENIAN.Net/ `We strongly condemn hateful attack against Hrant
Dink,’ stated Chief of General Staff Gen. Yasar Buyukanit. The Turkish
Press reports Gen. Buyukanit released a statement noting that he
hopes those who staged the attack will be found as soon as
possible. He also repeated that bullets fired at Dink were also fired
at Turkey.

Dink was shot in front of his office building in Sisli district of
Istanbul yesterday, and died instantly at the scene.

OSCE Called Hrant Dink’s Assassination a `Cowardly Act’

PanARMENIAN.Net

OSCE Called Hrant Dink’s Assassination a `Cowardly Act’
20.01.2007 14:19 GMT+04:00

/PanARMENIAN.Net/ OSCE representative on Media freedom Miklós
Haraszti released a statement, which condemns Armenian journalist
Hrant Dink’s assassination in Istanbul. Particularly, the statement
says violence against journalists must not remain unpunished. `We call
upon Turkish authorities to find the murderers as soon as possible,’
says Haraszti.

`Hrant Dink was one of the most famous representatives of the Armenian
Diaspora in Turkey, who was speaking on its problems publicly. His
assassination is a cowardly act,’ Haraszti underlines, `Yerkir Media’
reports.

Is it a crime or just idiocy?

International Herald Tribune, France
Jan 19 2007

Is it a crime or just idiocy?
Ronald Sokol Published: January 19, 2007

PUYRICARD, France: Last week, Germany proposed that all European
Union members adopt a uniform law to make Holocaust denial a criminal
offense. Denial of the Holocaust is already a crime in Austria,
Belgium, the Czech Republic, France, Germany, Lithuania, Poland,
Romania, Slovakia, Spain and Switzerland.

The proposal has prompted a sharp debate on whether denial of an
historical event should ever be criminalized.

The dominant theme in American law is that of Supreme Court Justices
Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr. and Louis Brandeis, who believed that
"unless the incidence of the evil is so imminent that it may befall
before there is opportunity for full discussion the remedy to be
applied is more speech, not enforced silence."

The lineage of that theme traces back to John Milton, who wrote that
if Truth and Falsehood were to grapple in a free and open encounter,
Truth would always win.

There is no doubt that freedom to advocate one’s thoughts and ideas
is a vital ingredient in any healthy society. It is the principal
means by which change can occur and a society can correct the errors
of its leadership.

The vexatious issue is where to draw the line. Even under the
expansive American view there are limits to free speech. In Justice
Holmes’s famous phrase, "The most stringent protection of free speech
would not protect a man in falsely shouting fire in a theater and
causing a panic."

In an inversion of Germany’s criminalization of Holocaust denial,
Turkish prosecutors have sought to punish those who affirm the truth
of the Armenian genocide. If denial of an event can be made a crime,
then logic compels that affirming an event can also be punished.

Yet when governments begin to legislate what is true and what is
false, they embark upon what has historically been a very slippery
slope.

Even on major historical events men and women rarely agree upon a
single truth. Was Napoleon a hero or a tyrant? Each generation must
interpret history anew and discover its own truths, and competing
versions can coexist. The Holocaust itself was not named and
categorized until almost a full generation after the event.

Today only a person in a state of appalling ignorance or advanced
dementia can deny the facts of the Holocaust. Yet if the facts are
true, then why is legislation needed to make the denial a crime?

The American view is that government has no right to forbid speech
unless it will incite imminent lawless action. If that test is
applied to those who deny the Holocaust, there would appear to be no
need for a law. While Holocaust deniers do attract followers, they
are largely ignored by the general public and, at least to date, have
not incited or produced imminent lawless action.

Yet there are also valid arguments for punishing Holocaust denial.
The Holocaust was a methodical effort to exterminate an entire
people; it plunged far deeper into the maelstrom of human depravity
than anything before it.

Holocaust denial is not really about denying a historically
established event. Human language is not limited to conveying verbal
information. It also conveys emotional information and can influence
and incite by the unspoken message it contains. It can be a powerful
message.

The recent Holocaust-denial conference hosted by the Iranian
president is a good example. The emotive message was both anti-Israel
and anti-Semitic. That was in fact its whole purpose.

Holocaust denial can thus be seen as a way to incite hatred against
Jews and the Jewish state. And inciting hatred, whether religious,
ethnic or racial, is generally deemed to be unprotected speech. Just
as there is no right to shout fire in a crowded theater, so there can
be no free- speech right to incite racial or religious hatred.

Of course there are ways of discouraging speech intended to stir
hatred other than by prohibiting it. Laws can be passed enabling
those who are targeted to sue the speaker and to recover substantial
damages.

As ministers of justice throughout the European Union begin to
consider a uniform Holocaust-denial law, they ought to ask whether
this might have a chilling effect on other speech. If a uniform law
is adopted, will it tempt legislators to descend the slippery slope
and begin to legislate about other historical events perhaps not so
clearly documented and to impose by law what can and cannot be said?

They might ask what precisely a Holocaust-denial law intends to
accomplish. Is it to silence the quacks who deny the fact or to
prevent false information from influencing others?

They can then reflect on whether the law will accomplish either of
those ends and whether it will further or hinder the goal of an open
society.

Ronald Sokol, former lecturer in law at the University of Virginia,
practices law in Aix-en-Provence, France.
From: Baghdasarian

Armenia can become major geopolitical player in region

Arka News Agency, Armenia
Jan 19 2007

ARMENIA CAN BECOME MAJOR GEOPOLITICAL PLAYER IN REGION THROUGH
COOPERATION WITH RUSSIA, IRAN

YEREVAN, January 19. /ARKA/. Armenia can become a major geopolitical
player in the region through cooperation with Russia and Iran, said
Hayk Babukhanyan, the chairman of the "Union of Constitutional Right"
(UCR) Party.
According to Barkhudaryan, Armenia found itself in a complete
isolation from the regional projects, in particular from the
Baku-Tbilisi-Jeykhan oil pipeline. "We need an alternative to oppose
it to the Baku-Tbilisi-Jeykhan," Babukhanyan said.
According to him, the alternative is extension of the Iran-Armenia
gas pipeline to Russia and further establishment of a trilateral
consortium on its management.
"We should not pin all our hopes on the road through Georgia: we do
have a real opportunity to arrange communication with Russia
otherwise," Babukhanyan said. According to him, the
Astrakhan-Iran-Armenia direction can become one of the options. N.V.
-0–