ANKARA: Article 301 held responsible for Dink’s murder

Article 301 held responsible for Dink’s murder
by FATMA DISLI

Today’s Zaman, Turkey
Jan 23 2007

Turkish-Armenian journalist Hrant Dink, who was shot dead on Friday,
was laid to rest on Tuesday with the participation of thousands of
mourners. The prime suspect in Dink’s murder was captured in 24
hours. A 17-year-old secondary school graduate, unemployed Ogun
Samast confessed to the murder and said he killed Dink due to his
humiliating remarks about Turks. Dink had been previously tried for
"insulting Turkishness" in the scope of Article 301 of the Turkish
Penal Code. It is evident that nationalist feelings prompted the
killer and his masterminds, if there are any, to murder an Armenian
known for his public statements, particularly his labeling the 1915
incidents as genocide. There is a commonly held view that if Dink had
not appeared in court due to Article 301, he might still be alive
today, but according to another view, such explanations are simply
choosing the easy way out.

Vatan’s Okay Gonensin blames Article 301 for playing a major role in
Dink’s murder. He thinks some circles forced Dink’s trial under the
article and that they wanted to make him a victim of such an
assassination. Gonensin explains that it is necessary to consider the
chain of actors leading up to Dink’s murder such as the Justice and
Development Party (AK Party) government, which failed to save Turkey
from the calamity of Article 301, the Republican People’s Party (CHP)
opposition, the judiciary system that apparently forgot their purpose
and members of judiciary who are prone to act with the provocations
of street nationalists. He claims that all these people or
institutions owe an account to society due to Dink’s murder.

Posta’s Mehmet Ali Birand asserts that the killer of Dink is Article
301. He says that the police may have managed to capture the killer
who pulled the trigger, but the real killer would not be found.

"Because we are the real killers of Dink," urges Birand. "We have
nourished our murderers in a mindset and against a backdrop shaped by
Article 301. We have handed them guns," he claims. Just like
Gonensin, Birand criticizes defenders of Article 301, the members of
the judiciary and the public prosecutor who said," I would like to
get rid of the responsibility so I will file a lawsuit and let the
court decide." He also recalls the public reaction at the time of the
Armenian Conference. Birand admits that we have to change our
mindset. He thinks that urgently changing Article 301 is necessary if
we want to evolve as a society. "Only this way can we earn the
forgiveness of Dink," adds Birand.

Milliyet’s Fikret Bila’s views differ from other columnists about
holding Article 301 as the reason of Dink’s murder. He thinks
allegations such "defenders of Article 301 are responsible for this
tragic event" are cheap and simple. "If one of the defenders of
Article 301 is killed, who would be the killer then? Is it the
defenders of the abolishment of Article 301?" he asks. Bila also
directs criticism toward those who claim this murder was organized by
the "deep state." He calls such allegations conspiracy theories and
thinks that instead of making easy explanations by resorting to big
conspiracies, it is necessary to ponder the reasons and atmosphere
that resulted in murderers like Ogun Samast. Bila urges that it is
necessary to go beneath the surface and try to eradicate the problems
at its roots.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Taner Akcam: The real murderers are among the leading circles of Tur

Taner Akcam: The real murderers are among the leading circles of Turkey

ArmRadio.am
24.01.2007 15:13

"Hrant’s death was not accidental. He was chosen as a target for
this period of time. Moreover, Dink became a target, since he was
Armenian," Professor of the Minnesota University, Turkish historian
Taner Akcam said during the memorial service dedicated to Hrant Dink
in San Francisco.

The historian declared also that the real murderers are among the
leading circles of the country. Turning to the Turkish Prime Minister’s
condemning speech, Akcam said, "Let him not drop crocodile tears. This
was the culmination point of the continuous policy of Turkey.

"The press, the government, the military, everyone carries
responsibility for this assassination," the Turkish historian
declared. Taner Akcam told the participants that Dink was recently
warned by city authorities of Istanbul "to restrict his writings,
since there are a lot of mad young people in the streets." "The
detainee is very like the one they described," he said.

It’s worth mentioning that Taner Akcam was the first Turkish scientist
to write about the Armenian Genocide of 1915.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Mass protest at editor’s funeral

Mass protest at editor’s funeral

· Murder triggers debate on freedom of speech
· ‘We are all Armenians’ mourners chant

Benjamin Harvey, Associated Press
Wednesday January 24, 2007
The Guardian

More than 100,000 people marched in a funeral procession yesterday for the
murdered Turkish-Armenian journalist Hrant Dink. "We are all Armenians,"
chanted mourners in an extraordinary outpouring of affection for a journalist who
had made enemies by calling the mass killings of Armenians towards the end of
the Ottoman empire genocide.
Dink was shot dead outside his newspaper Agos on Friday. The murder touched
off debate about excessive nationalism, free expression and the ability of
Turks of different backgrounds to live together.

Throngs of mourners marched along the five-mile route from the Agos offices
to an Armenian Orthodox church, virtually shutting the city centre. Many
carried placards that read: "We are all Hrant Dinks." Thousands leaned out of
office windows to applaud and throw flowers.
Despite a request from his family not to turn the funeral into a protest,
many also raised their fists shouting: "Shoulder to shoulder against fascism"
and "Murderer 301" – a reference to the law that was used to prosecute Dink
and others on charges of "insulting Turkishness."

Sera, the 52-year-old journalist’s daughter, wept as she accompanied the
coffin.

Dink, the editor of Agos, a bilingual Armenian-Turkish newspaper, encouraged
reconciliation between Turkey and Armenia. But public statements about the
mass killings of Armenians by Turks in the early 20th century landed him in
court and prompted death threats. Among others taken to court was novelist
Orhan Pamuk, who last year won the Nobel literature prize. The prosecutions have
alarmed the EU, which is considering Turkey’s bid to join.

Police are questioning seven suspects, including a teenager, Ogun Samast,
who authorities said has confessed to shooting Dink, and Yasin Hayal, a
nationalist convicted of a 2004 bomb attack at a McDonald’s restaurant. Hayal has
confessed to inciting the killing and providing a gun to the teenager,
according to police. The suspects also include a university student who allegedly
"inspired" the attack, Hurriyet newspaper reported. Police confirmed the report
but gave no details.

In a service attended by Armenians and Turks, including the deputy prime
minister, Mehmet Ali Sahin, and the interior minister, Abdulkadir Aksu, Armenian
Patriarch Mesrob II called for expanded freedom of speech and more dialogue
between Turks and Armenians. Although Turkey has no diplomatic ties with
Armenia, officials and religious leaders from Armenia also attended.

–Boundary_(ID_+HwKhSDjKG59SS6qCP8uHA)- –

Murdered journalist’s funeral is a silent rally of defiance

Murdered journalist’s funeral is a silent rally of defiance
By Suna Erdem in Istanbul

The Times/UK
January 24, 2007

A 100,000-strong crowd of Turks, ethnic Armenians and foreigners followed
Hrant Dink’s coffin (Reuters)

Turkish dissent law under spotlight
Big international presence at service

Tens of thousands of mourners marched in silence through Istanbul
yesterday behind the coffin of the Turkish Armenian journalist Hrant
Dink, who was shot dead by a teenager with suspected nationalist links.

Carrying black banners bearing the slogans "We are all Armenian"
and "We are all Hrant Dink", the 100,000-strong crowd of Turks,
ethnic Armenians and foreigners walked nearly five miles (8km),
expressing their anger without chanting but with their quiet presence,
as requested by Mr Dink’s widow, Rakel.

In an emotional speech outside the offices of Agos, the Turkish
Armenian newspaper, where Mr Dink, its editor, was shot, Rakel Dink
urged the mourners to work for an end to the hostile nationalistic
environment that still has many Turks in its grip despite recent
liberal reforms.

"Do not be satisfied with this much, do not be satisfied with today,"
she cried out to the crowd. "The killer was a baby once. We cannot
achieve anything if we do not question the darkness which creates a
murderer out of a baby."

Mr Dink, along with several other writers, including the Nobel laureate
Orhan Pamuk, had been prosecuted under the controversial Article 301
of the Turkish penal code for his views on the killing of Armenians by
Ottoman Turks in 1915. Turkey denies strongly that this amounted to
a genocide and treats any departure from the official line with deep
suspicion. Liberal Turks, including Mr Pamuk, say that they believe
that Article 301, which punishes "insults to Turkish identity",
is used to set people up as targets.

Seventeen-year-old Ogun Samast has confessed to the murder of Mr Dink
for " insulting Turks". Another man, Yasin Hayal, jailed recently
for bombing a McDonald’s restaurant, has admitted inciting him. A
university student is being held under suspicion of organising a
nationalist "cell" that included Hayal and commissioned the murder.

The killing of Mr Dink, 52, who had sought reconciliation between
Muslim Turks and Christian Armenians, harked back to the dark decades
at the end of the 20th century when dissenting journalists and other
activists were felled by militants with suspected links within the
state and intelligence apparatus.

The President and the Prime Minister were conspicuously absent at the
service in an Armenian church by the Golden Horn waterway, but the
public and international response has been overwhelming. Ambassadors,
Turkish ministers and MPs, members of the European Parliament and
leading Armenian clerics from across the world crowded into the church.

"He died defending his conscience and beliefs and the right to express
these beliefs," Patriarch Mesrob Mutafyan told the congregation.

Newspaper columnists have been railing against curbs on free speech
and nationalism in a way that would once have been considered
treacherous. "A giant awakened today," the commentator Mehmet Altan
said. "For the first time the Turkish people took a stand which
was distanced from the kind of propaganda by which it is usually
influenced. We gave him in death what we could not in life."

AWOL (Armenian Weekly On-Line), Volume 73, No. 3, January 20, 2007

The Armenian Weekly On-Line: AWOL
80 Bigelow Avenue
Watertown MA 02472 USA
(617) 926-3974
[email protected]

http://www.a rmenianweekly.com

* * *

AWOL (Armenian Weekly On-Line), Volume 73, No. 3, January 20, 2007

1. Hrant Dink (1954-1915)
By Khatchig Mouradian

2. The Armenian Genocide and Our Faith in God
By George Aghjayan

3. Could ‘Musa Dagh’ Ever Hit the Video Game Screen?
By Andy Turpin

4. The Spokesman Speaks of Genocide-Old and New
By K.M.

5. ‘Tis a Far Better Thing I Do.’
Book Details One Armenian-Canadian’s Fight Against Fascism in Civil War
Spain
By Andy Turpin

6. New English-Language Paper in Turkey Hosts Well-Attended Debut Ceremony

7. Your Weekly Fix Of Poetry
Muted Message
By Tatul Sonentz

8. Winding Down Toward Retirement
By Tom Vartabedian

————————————- —————————————
——-

1. Hrant Dink (1954-1915)
By Khatchig Mouradian

The above date, 1915, is not a typographical mistake.

On Saturday, April 24, 1915, Ottoman-Turkish soldiers arrested about 200
Armenian intellectuals-writers, journalists and community leaders-in
Istanbul, exiling them to the interior of the Ottoman Empire where they
would be killed. The plan was to behead the Armenian community by
annihilating its leadership and then to cleanse the entire population. The
day of the arrests marks the beginning of the Armenian Genocide.

On Friday, Jan. 19, 2007, also in Istanbul, another prominent Armenian
intellectual, Hrant Dink, was assassinated in front of the editorial offices
of his Armenian weekly newspaper Agos.

Hrant Dink is a victim of the Armenian Genocide.

And the Armenian Genocide continues.

Not only because denial is the last phase of Genocide.

But because the killing continues.

It was not an individual who killed Hrant Dink. So while Turkish authorities
are looking for a killer out loose in the streets, the real killer is the
Turkish state, which continues to foster a culture of violence,
assassinations, killings, oppression, and denial. The killer is the Turkish
state, which indoctrinates its citizens from an early age that the Armenian
Genocide is a myth, an agenda, pushed by the West to destroy Turkey.

"A bullet has been fired at democracy and freedom of expression," said
Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan. Yes, the bullet was Article 301
of the Turkish Penal Code, under which Dink was prosecuted.

The person who pulled the trigger was executing the will of the Turkish
state. Like his Prime Minister, government, army and the so-called
"Deep-State," he wanted to make the world believe that there was no Armenian
Genocide. Like Talaat Pasha, he believed that the Armenian question could be
solved by killing those who made demands.

We shall remember you, Hrant, together with Varoujan and Siamanto and all
the victims of the Armenian Genocide.
—————————————- ————————————
—-

2. The Armenian Genocide and Our Faith in God
By George Aghjayan

"In my young mind I kept asking myself why we had been born Armenians, and
why our God and Jesus Christ were apparently unprotective and less powerful
than the so-almighty Allah and Prophet Mohammed of the Turks." (Rebirth: The
Story of an Armenian girl who survived the Genocide and found Rebirth in
America by Elise Hagopian Taft.)

"Only God in heaven, who looked down upon that pitiful death march, and
permitted it, we are sure, for some good purpose, knows how far we walked."
(Exiled: Story of an Armenian Girl by Serpohi Tavoukdjian.)

"Yeran had learned now the hard lesson that life without faith and hope is
meaningless, and that courage is one of the most important virtues of
mankind." (Destined to Survive by Negdar K. Tabibian.)

Faith in God is a frequent theme contained in the accounts of Armenian
Genocide survivors. However, I find very little written on the subject of
the existence of an all-powerful, benevolent God and evil of the magnitude
manifested in the Armenian Genocide. This is particularly surprising given
the strong adherence of the Armenian people to Christianity.

Theodicy, as defined in Wikipedia [The biggest multilingual encyclopedia on
the Internet], is a specific branch of theology and philosophy that attempts
to reconcile the existence of evil in the world with the assumption of a
benevolent God, i.e. the problem of evil. It is not my aim here to recount
the enormous literature on the subject of theodicy, but instead to discuss
some points of interest from the perspective of Armenians.

On the surface, it might seem amazing that Armenians would retain any faith
in an all-powerful, benevolent God after witnessing the horrors of the
Genocide. Many did lose their faith, but one can also understand how
surviving would lead to a renewal or strengthening of faith. Those being
subjected daily to the horrors of the Genocide continually prayed to God for
deliverance-thus, the ultimate deliverance would serve as justification for
not having lost faith.

Given how miraculous it was that any survived, one could also reason that it
was the intervention of God that led to their survival. It follows that God
must have had a purpose for them in life that was for others in death. I am
sure this view weighed heavily on the minds of survivors. The dedication of
many in the Armenian community to this day, whether in the religious,
political or cultural sphere, can probably be traced to a sense of
responsibility to God and those that perished.

While my own commitment probably stems in large part to the responsibility I
feel towards those in my family that suffered and survived, I still reject
the notion that those who suffered unspeakable horrors did so for some
higher purpose. More specifically, that such a plan would be so detailed as
to pick one person over another.

Some survivors attributed survival to their purity of heart and actions. I,
personally, have trouble accepting this line of reasoning which sniffs of a
"holier than thou" attitude. Those that survived were not somehow more
worthy than those that perished.

Perhaps a more honest assessment is given by those survivors that believed
they would have perished if not for the hope that faith supplied. Once all
hope was lost, the will to survive and ultimately the person would die.

Mental strength, physical strength, luck, hope and faith were all needed to
survive the Armenian Genocide. But none of this really addresses the
question of how evil can exist. How can those who profess a Christian belief
suffer while those who denounce Jesus Christ be rewarded?

I have read many unsatisfactory answers to this question and maybe there
cannot be a truly fulfilling one in this age of reasoning. For me, the only
perspective I can draw upon is the view of God as a parent who must allow
his children to make mistakes in the process of maturing. Mankind is still
in its infancy. Hopefully, as we mature, we will outgrow the evil of our
childhood.

To do so will require a strong faith in God and a commitment to live good
lives.
————————————– ————————————–
—-
3. Could ‘Musa Dagh’ Ever Hit the Video Game Screen?
By Andy Turpin

Video games are not what they used to be.

That statement is both nostalgic and loaded. It may seem infantile to ponder
the future of video games when there are so many crucial real-world issues
today to worry about that haven’t upped American tension levels this much
since the Cuban Missile Crisis. But for the teenager beside you, all the
would-be Orwellian fates in the world aren’t as important as the video game
title releases on their calendar.

In no way are these sentiments a blessing to any parent or adult, but one
should be abreast of where video games are headed-not to stop the train per
se, but to have some control and say in the content.

Video games are more realistic and cinematic than ever before; their
die-hard creators are now highly educated and well-read individuals with
just as much eye for detail and accuracy as lust for gore.

And the people, not just the children, are riveted. Video games are becoming
celluloid reality. Note last year’s film release of "Crank," an obvious
staging of the "Grand Theft Auto" video game series, and the film version of
the classic video game "Doom," which surprised many with its didactic plot,
related in its deconstruction of evil to Christopher R. Browning’s 1992 book
Ordinary Men.

In an age where journalism and publishing industry jobs have become ivory
tower ranks, more young writers are turning in their pens and keyboards, and
scripting video games instead.

History and cult audiences are big business in this industry when you look
at the success of games like the "Call of Duty" series, which lets people
fight the Battle of Stalingrad as a Communist soldier, or the much
anticipated release this year of the game "Civil War: A Nation Divided" by
the History Channel and Activision.

Now, whether parents will admit it or not, there is a trend of apathy among
Armenian youth when it comes to political issues. Perhaps not quite at the
gut wrenching level that exists among American youth, but it’s alarming
enough for a people that have always made their voice heard. I’m not
advocating for teens to play video games instead of being involved in
activism or writing their Congressmen, but if they’re going to spend their
time at the game console, why not "hit them where they live" with politics,
as well.

A large budget film version of Franz Werfel’s "The Forty Days at Musa Dagh"
is currently in the works by producer Sylvester Stallone. It’s much needed;
but to play devil’s advocate, how much more would a historically accurate
and interactive game version of the battle resonate with people?

Of course, the rub would be to create the game in such a manner that it
detailed the form of the resistance and didn’t trivialize the Genocide
itself. But didactic games have been created successfully about the French
resisting the German Vichy government in Steven Spielberg’s "Medal of Honor"
series, and they’ve even cornered the market on a yet unfought future war to
liberate North Korea in Lucasart’s "Mercenaries." In both games, the
dynamics between war and genocide are either touched upon just enough to be
valuable learning tools, or skirted around just enough to be politically
correct-depending on which side of the parental fence you stand on.

It isn’t possible to de-program the nature of evil from humanity. But it may
be a question of "when" and not "if’ you’ll get to create a 3D working image
of your fedayi great-grandfather on screen.
—————————————— ———————————-
–

4. The Spokesman Speaks of Genocide-Old and New
By K.M.

WATERTOWN, Mass. (A.W.)-Issue number 93 of the Spokesman, a publication of
the Bertrand Russell Peace Foundation based in England, deals with the theme
of genocides-old and new. Among the featured articles are "Genocide" by
Raphael Lemkin, first published in 1946, and "The First Holocaust," the
chapter on the Armenian Genocide from Robert Fisk’s recent book The Great
War for Civilization. (For a complete list of the articles or for more
information on the Bertrand Russell Foundation, visit
and )

In "Genocide," Lemkin, the Polish-Jew who coined the term "genocide," talks
about the "mass obliteration of nationhoods" throughout Nazi occupied
Europe, noting that although the Nazi experience is "the most striking,"
there are other examples: "The destruction of Carthage; that of religious
groups in the wars of Islam and the Crusades; the massacres of Albigenses
and Waldenses; and more recently, the massacre of the Armenians." Arguing
that mass murder is not an adequate name for such phenomena, Lemkin says he
felt the need to coin a new term: genocide. "This word is made from the
ancient Greek word genos (race clan) and the latin suffix cide (killing),"
he explains. The rest, as they say, is history.

"But why have we chosen a chapter on the Armenian genocide to represent this
great book here, when it is also alive with reports of contemporary traumas,
in Afghanistan or Lebanon, Iraq, Iran, or Algeria?" asks Spokesman editor
Ken Coates in his editorial, referring to Fisk’s book.

"There have been, in short, innumerable cruelties in the conquest of the
Middle East, but in one sense the most shocking thing about these often
criminal acts is that the screams of their victims have so frequently gone
unheard. The great warriors who have sought to impose their own mean
civilization on peoples whose culture is as old as time, have also imposed
selective hearing, discriminate memory. A celebration of happy
indifference," Coates continues.

"Fisk has unerringly homed in on the Armenian massacres as a classic symbol
of these responses. with his help, we can try to count the dead. But far
more significantly, we can begin to understand the vital necessity of memory
in defending the humanity of its victims," concludes Coates.

During his 30 years as news correspondent in the Middle East, Fisk
interviewed many survivors of the Armenian Genocide and visited death sites
like Der Zor and Margada. He also acquired many British private papers
discussing the Genocide. In "The First Holocaust," Fisk masterfully narrates
the horrors of the first genocide of the 20th century through survivor
accounts, reports of foreign diplomats, documents unearthed by historians,
and the press. Serpouhi Papazian is one of the survivors he interviews.
"Ten years after the Armenian Holocaust, Serpouhi returned to the hill at
Margada to try to find the remains of her father and sister. ‘All I found in
1925 were heaps of bones and skulls she said. They had been eaten by wild
animals and dogs. I don’t even know why you bother to come here with your
notebook and take down what I say.’"

Because the truth must be told, and justice must be served.
—————————————— ———————————-
—–
5. ‘Tis a Far Better Thing I Do.’
Book Details One Armenian-Canadian’s Fight Against Fascism in Civil War
Spain
By Andy Turpin

Now is a time of reckoning in world politics. Genocide recognition is
gaining international momentum, nuclear ambition tides are rising, and
hybrid indigenous Catholic-Communism is taking hold in South America-all in
the shadow of the U.S.-Iraq quagmire and a powder keg of death and
displacement in Africa.

Thus perhaps more than ever, the veterans who fought against the Fascist
forces in the Spanish Civil War need to be remembered, for their heroism and
foresight into the monster that would soon become World War II.

Coupled with a sizeable number of vigilant Jews, some of the resistance
fighters were Armenian. The story of one such Armenian, Pat Stephens, is
recounted in the book A Memoir of the Spanish Civil War: An
Armenian-Canadian in the Lincoln Battalion, published by the Canadian
Committee on Labor History in 2000, 13 years after Stephens’ death. The book
details his military career as a Republican-Communist soldier in Spain from
1936 to 1939, with Franco’s defeat of the resistance. Richard Rennie,
professor of history at the Memorial University of Newfoundland, wrote the
introduction, detailing Stephens’ family background. "Stephens was born in
Armenia on 22 November 1910. His given name was Badrig der Stepanian, and he
was the fourth of five boys born to Esther Bedrossian and Solomon der
Stephanian. .Stephen’s father and his uncle, Mugerditch, were active in
local politics, and early in the war [WWI] Mugerditch was taken away and
executed. Stephen’s father narrowly escaped the same fate, but died shortly
after."

In 1921, Stephens and his family left Armenia and moved to Syria and then to
Windsor, Ontario. Prior to the outbreak of the war in Spain, Stephens
foraged his way through the Depression by working any job, no matter how
minute. Just before the stock market crash of 1929, he started working as an
accountant with General Motors, and was able to bring his mother to Detroit,
though she died the same year. Stephens lost his job soon after to massive
layoffs and was forced to return to Canada. In Toronto, he picked up jobs
selling refrigerators and electric signs, or working in restaurants. It was
at this point that he joined the Canadian Communist party-which is
noteworthy, because many of the volunteer fighters who went to Spain did so
assuaging their reservations against Communism to work towards the greater
good of combating Fascism.

Stephens volunteered to fight alongside the International Brigades in Dec.
1936 and arrived in Spain in Feb. 1937. "As such, he was one of those
approximately 500 Canadians who went to Spain before the promulgation of the
Foreign Enlistment Act in July 1937," writes Rennie. Stephens was first a
machine gunner, then Chief of Intendencia and later a military investigator.
He was older and more literate than many of his counterparts, and advanced
quickly through the rank and file troops.

To take his account at face value, one would gauge that part of this
advancement was due to the amount of nurturing care and competence he showed
the men under his command. One example is when he notes, "I noticed someone
I knew," wrote Stevens in his accounts. "An Armenian-American from
Worcester, Mass. This man was one of the worst bitchers in the Battalion. I
was always trying to cheer him up and bolster his morale whenever we got
together. I told him as soon as we got to Alvarez, I would buy a lamb and
prepare a nice meal for some of our boys."

The fact that he was Armenian most likely played a part in the internal
politics and relations of his unit. Every organization has its own system of
advancement, favoritism and nepotism. Within the International Brigades, it
was an asset to be Armenian, Jewish, Italian, Basque or Greek, as these were
all tightly knit cultures that had a vested interest in defeating Fascist
and genocidal enemies. Thus, degrees of ethnic solidarity existed next to
genuine fraternal and Communal values.

Stephens notes that being Armenian helped him secure his machine gunner
position. "I put in a request to be transferred to the machine gun company,
which was regarded as the elite of the Battalion," he wrote. "I asked
Comrade Sahagian, who was in charge of the ammunition detail, and he said he
would speak to Comrade Davidian, who was in charge of the machine gun
company. Davidian was also an Armenian, like myself and Sahagian. .He told
me to get my gear together. Then he took me to Number One machine gun
section and I became a member of that group. Soon I was taught how to take
the machine gun apart, clean it, and put it together again. I was also shown
how to shoot it. Our guns were all World War I relics, but they worked."

Those in the International Brigades, like those in the French Foreign
Legion, joined for any number of political reasons, which created an even
more diverse and resourceful body of men and indeed women, as well. Jews
joined to fight German influence in Spain and anti-Semitism; Basques fought
to preserve their communities, which were under smaller attacks, such as
that on Guerica by Nazis forces assisting Franco in 1937); and many Irish
volunteered to flee terrorist arrest warrants issued by the British
authorities.

Stephens mentions one such man who later became a turncoat both to the
Communist party, the British Empire, and the Spanish Republicans he fought
beside. "Another top IRA man was Frank Ryan. He had played a leading role in
the Irish uprisings [Easter, 1916]. . Frank Ryan was eventually captured.
Because of his connections to the IRA, he was not executed. He was shifted
from Spain to Berlin and placed at the disposal of the Germans. Even then
the Germans had plans to use Ryan for their purposes against Britain. I
don’t know what happened to him in Berlin, but he’s buried there."

Such acute memories of the various personalities he encountered in Spain are
historically important, as they illustrate that seeds of distrust and
duplicity existed alongside palates of patriotic and ideological loyalty.
Similar to many accounts of the First World War, Stephens writes that the
Spanish Civil War was in many ways a trench war; as such, soldiers endured
many of the same hardships their brethren faced on the earlier fronts of
Gallipoli and the Somme. Stephens had a front row seat to history while in
Spain, and an unabashed preview of the carnage that would follow on its
heels when the Wiermacht marched across Europe.

He wrote of the "lousy" conditions of everyday life, including how he and
his men coped with outbreaks of dysentery throughout the camp. "The more
serious cases were sent to hospitals in the rear. It was strange that the
native Spaniards were not affected at all. One day I asked the commander of
the Spanish contingent why the Spanish comrades were not affected by these
outbreaks. He took me to his dugout and showed me the strings of garlic
hanging on the walls. He said they ate some every day and never got sick.
Soon our entire battalion was eating raw garlic."

Stephens had the ability to speak plainly about those he met, including
Ernest Hemingway, who is often romanticized, to say the least. Stephens met
Hemingway and spoke of their encounter, saying, "We went to Madrid in a
truck and arrived there before noon. Our group was to stay at the Florida
Hotel, where a kitchen had been arranged for the American boys. A few tables
away from us sat Ernest Hemingway, and Herbert Matthews of the New York
Times. . These reporters never lacked the comforts of life. The discussion
took the form of a press conference. They wanted to know if we had
experienced hand-to-hand combat with the enemy, how the food was at the
front, whether we regretted volunteering, and so on. None of these men
really impressed me, not even Hemingway. They were cold and impersonal, and
seemed not to care much what happened in Spain, or for that matter in the
world."

At one point Stephens mildly probes Hemingway to gauge his genuine combat
experience. "I asked Hemingway how our war compared with his experience in
Italy during the war [WWI]. He replied that he couldn’t really answer that
because he really hadn’t been away from Madrid long enough to formulate an
opinion. He said, however, that from what he had seen in Madrid and his
visits with Spanish units at the front, the Spanish war seemed to be a more
cruel war."

The culmination of Stephens’ Spanish Civil War experience, like the
correlating experiences of other International Brigade volunteers, is
bittersweet. Similar to the Hungarian anti-Soviet uprising that would occur
in 1956, much of the world had their eye on Spain, but officially their
hands stayed at their sides and erred on the side of caution when it came to
intervention.

After the defeat of the International Brigades and the solidification of the
Franco government, volunteers were sent home. What added insult to injury
for these brave men and women was the fact that their own governments
treated them with suspicion and distain because they had directly
collaborated with the regime of Stalin, who footed the armament’s bill to
the International Brigades during their campaign.

Stephens’ ends his memoir disheartened and disillusioned by the apathy of
the world. He tells of his journey home to Canada. "We traveled in locked
cars to the Port of Dieppe, and there we were met at the station by a
contingent of the French Guard Mobile, to make sure that none of us escaped
into France itself. . We had to wait a few hours until the tide came in, and
then we started for England. In a few hours, we docked at Newhaven, and were
on English soil again. We read the giant headlines on the local newspapers,
‘Barcelona Fallen to Franco.’ That was the end of my romantic attempt to
make the world safe for democracy."

A Memoir of the Spanish Civil War stands today as a testament to a bygone
era in democratic history, and a milestone-perhaps under researched-chapter
in Diasporan Armenian history. It represents yet another window into the
minds of the younger Genocide survivors and of the immediate offspring of
the older ones.

Stephens’ memories may hold fast today as a standard to combat political
apathy among the present generation of young Armenians, even if at times it
reveals itself as evidence of the Sicilian proverb, "No good deed goes
unpunished."

I prefer to see it as a manifestation of kith and kin to the words uttered
both by Socrates and Thomas Paine: "I am neither an Athenian, nor a Greek,
but a Citizen of the World."
————————————- —————————————
—

6. New English-Language Paper in Turkey Hosts Well-Attended Debut Ceremony

WATERTOWN, Mass. (A.W.)-On Jan. 15, the Turkish government stars were out in
the sky to roll out the welcome kilim for the debut ceremony honoring the
establishment of Turkey’s third English-language daily newspaper, Today’s
Zaman.

In attendance at the ceremony, held at the Ankara Sheraton, were Turkish
Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan, foreign minister Abdullah Gul, state
minister and chief EU negotiator Ali Babacan, education minister Huseyin
Celik, energy and natural resources minister Hilmi Guler, and state minister
Kurshad Tuzmen.

In its coverage of the event, Today’s Zaman noted that Gul’s "excitement
could be seen in his eyes"-so much so that the paper recorded it twice.

Expectations for the new paper ran high as Erdogan expressed that "Plurality
in the media is of great importance in a democratic society." He continued
by saying, "Today’s Zaman will increase the richness and diversity of the
Turkish media. Such a strong publication, with a substantial content, will
add strength to the attempts carried out to promote Turkey in the world. It
will be a window for diplomats who closely follow Turkey as well as foreign
public opinion. I see this in Today’s Zaman. Turkey has experienced a
dramatic image revolution in the last four years. Yet, it is evident that we
have a problem concerning effective promotion of our country in the world.
We better understand it from the prejudices of other nations towards Turkey.
Despite the efforts, we will ask, ‘Are we still there?’ With its principled
and constructive publication, Today’s Zaman will contribute to the promotion
of Turkey, the Turkish nation and to overcoming the biases and cliches about
Turkey."

Gul spoke before Erdogan took the stage and praised the paper’s release. "We
will do our best to support this endeavor," he said. "I see the rise in the
number of papers published in English in Turkey to three as a signal of
Turkey’s importance and greatness. Foreign politicians and economic circles
are following what is going on in Turkey. Our country became worthy of being
followed. Rest assured that you will achieve a high volume of circulation.
You will be followed with interest, and sometimes you will be quoted by
others."

Ekrem Dumanli, and editor-in-chief of the Zaman Daily, the Turkish-language
counterpart of Today’s Zaman, gave special thanks to Erdogan for his support
of Turkish journalism, particularly on the occasion of the Daily’s 15th
anniversary on Nov. 3, 2001. Dumanli was heavily involved in attempting to
gain journalistic respectability for Turkish papers. "We invited a number of
guests to our anniversary six years ago," he recalled. "Some did not show up
despite our insistence. We felt resentment back then because we did not
expect special favors from anybody. All we wanted was emotional support for
the paper. I would like to offer a special thank you to a very special
person who attended that meeting and gave an eloquent address. That day he
was excited about the founding of a new political party; today, he
administers this beautiful country. I would like to thank our Prime Minister
Recep Tayyip Erdogan, who is honored this evening."

Today’s Zaman own editor-in-chief, Bulent Kenes, set community-oriented
goals for the fledgling paper, stating that "Today’s Zaman, determined to
convey Turkey’s realities to the international stage, was designed to
reflect all colors of life, and not as a publication only with columns and a
diplomatic content."

Saudi Arabia’s ambassador to Turkey, Muhammad R Al-Hussaini, lauded the
paper similarly. when he commented, "Now we will have three papers, each
with a different perspective. I believe Today’s Zaman will be more
successful than the others. What will distinguish it is its transparency and
integrity. Hopefully its news will meet the demands of the individuals as
well as the envoys. First thing first, I will buy the paper. I will be a
regular reader." Turkey’s other two English-language papers are The Turkish
Daily News and The New Anatolian.

Various new agencies expressed interest in the paper’s launch, including the
Chinese news agency Xinhua, the Lebanese communication group Al-Manhar TV,
and the IRNA official Iranian news network. European or American news
agencies did not attend the ceremony.

Today’s Zaman can be accessed online by visiting www.todays zaman.com.
————————————— ————————————-
———— —–

7. Your Weekly Fix Of Poetry
MUTED MESSAGE

First snow of the year
life is muffled like the sounds
made by a string ensemble
playing to frozen eardrums
out of sight out of reach to those
stranded in the lone recesses
of a receding lifeline.
Nothing can speak louder
or freeze colder than silence.
no curse emoted or whispered
can cause the pain that silence can
without emitting a word without
being here – where once a song
of a shared passion steamed
the windowpanes of this place
where I now reside alone
dismissed sheltered
yet. homeless
With the meandering flakes
silence descends like a shroud
on the love that was my home
for what seemed like eternity
uninterrupted – it seemed –
from lullaby to taps.
First snow of the year
desires are muted now like
murmured prayers to gods
long departed.

Tatul Sonentz
Dec. 2001
——————————————— —————–

8. Winding Down Toward Retirement
By Tom Vartabedian

Had I known my retirement from the newspaper industry would create this much
of a stir, I probably would have been more discreet about it.

I’ve always shyed away from such attention, preferring a more secluded
lifestyle. Of course, that didn’t prevent me from attending other people’s
retirements and wishing them well.

Actually, if you want to know the truth, I’ve been retired ever since I
started with the Gazette 40 years ago. I’ve never considered my work a job
but more of an enjoyable recreation that quenched my thirst for writing and
introduced me to many fine friends both inside and outside the media.

I remember one time sitting in the dugout of a high school baseball game
with a scorebook in my hand, puffing away on my pipe with my feet extended
on the bench. The weather was warm and I was soaking in the sun.

"That’s my kind of a job," a player remarked. "You actually get paid for
doing this?"

"Tough work, but somebody’s got to do it," I joked.

What the boy didn’t realize was that the real work was yet to come. That

meant figuring out the box score and writing a story that was positive, even
if the score was lopsided.

So when does a man with a lifetime profession retire? Well, it’s time. Four
decades of deadlines was actually the easy part. I was never one to buckle
under pressure, even if it meant being six feet under water without a
snorkel. The creative part was just as much fun. The challenge came in
finding the good stories. For that, you have to play detective.

The big concern toward retirement is how to spend a lot of time doing what
you might enjoy without spending a lot of cash.

"You could always volunteer," a working colleague told me. "Or you can spend
your days at the senior center playing pool and going on trips."

What I don’t want to be is "chairman of the bored." Since word got out about
my retirement, I’ve been invited to join four service clubs in the
community, three bank boards, two planning committees and an offer to hike
the Appalachian Trail.

The hiking part is out of the question, unless I want to spend six months
trudging across 2,100 miles of rough terrain.

Truthfully, I wanted to cash in before it was too late. I’ve seen too many
who were besieged by medical problems and couldn’t enjoy their golden years.
My father died at 66-the year he was thinking about leaving the restaurant
business. My brother succumbed at 54 while still employed. He never got the
benefit of a happy retirement.

A good time to retire is before it’s too late to enjoy the rewards.

I see the friendly folks at my local YMCA fitness center and they’ve

struck up a worthwhile routine. They spend their mornings exercising for
themselves and the afternoons exercising for their wives.

"She gives me a honey-do list," said one chap. "Honey do this. Honey do
that. After awhile, you may want to become re-employed."

Others agree that once I’m retired and get into the flow, I’ll begin to
wonder how I ever found the time to hold down a job. The fact I was able to
survive this long at one job was another miracle, considering the changes
and the takeovers over my tenure. Just an educated guess, I’ve worked for
more than 100 editors over that span and none are around today to bid me
farewell.

People are asking me what my last story will be. I remember the first. It
turned out to be an obituary after I was hired as a sportswriter. I took
offense to that.

"Son," my editor said. "When you work for a community paper, you do it
all-sports, obits, politics, police, school and society. Nobody
specializes around here."

If anything, it’s taught me to be a better craftsman at

my art, certainly more versatile and all the more oriented to my profession.

My wife retired from the teaching profession two years ago. At the time, she
encouraged me to continue doing what I loved. I owe this retirement to her,
my children and a 95-year-old mom inside a nursing home that welcomes the
attention.

Most of all, I owe it to myself. We are often the architects of our own
destiny and selfish as it may sound, we should often put ourselves first. No
one else can dictate your pleasure.

With two weeks remaining, the last story has yet to be written, much less
determined. But I’ll tell you this much. I hope it’s a story that will do
some good for somebody because that’s what newspapers should be all about.
I’ve always tried to be a good news type, even when I was called upon to be
a critic.

As the days wind down to a precious few, I have one last thought about my
imminent retirement-and that’s a disadvantage. Now I’ll be forced to drink
coffee on my own time.

***
(c) 2006 Armenian Weekly On-Line. All Rights Reserved.

www.spokesmanbooks.com
www.russfound.org.

Armenia, Azerbaijan FM reach no results at Moscow talks

Armenia, Azerbaijan FM reach no results at Moscow talks

ITAR-TASS News Agency, Russia
January 23, 2007 Tuesday

The Armenian and Azerbaijani foreign ministers have not reached results
at the talks in Moscow on settlement of the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict.

The chief of Armenian National Assembly’s international department,
Vooruzhan Nersesyan, said that "we have not come to concrete results,
but a solid basis has been prepared the continuation of the talks
during the upcoming visits of an OSCE group to Baku, Yerevan and
Stepanakert".

The Armenian side "considers the talks in Moscow as a positive
extension of the Prague process," Nersesyan said.

He said that the foreign ministers discussed in detail OSCE-proposed
projects of settling the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict.

"The visit of the OSCE Minsk Group to Baku begins on Wednesday, and
we pin great hopes on results of this trip. The Armenian delegation
leaves for Yerevan content with results of the Moscow meeting,"
Nersesyan said.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Mourning march to Tsitsernakaberd

Mourning march to Tsitsernakaberd

ArmRadio.am
24.01.2007 10:38

At 13:30 today mourning march in honor of the editor-in-chief of the
Agos newspaper Hrat Dink will be organized from Shahumyan square to
Tsitsernakaberd. The event has been organized jointly by the Yerevan
Municipality and the Writers’ Union of Armenia.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Azerbaijan to create powerful defense industry in 2007 – Aliyev

Azerbaijan to create powerful defense industry in 2007 – Aliyev

ITAR-TASS News Agency, Russia
January 23, 2007 Tuesday

Azerbaijan will create "a powerful defense industry" this year.
"This year’s budget envisions considerable funds to strengthen
the material-technological basis of the industry, which have to be
used effectively," Azerbaijani President Ilkham Aliyev said at a
behind-closed-dollars Cabinet meeting on Monday.

The text of the president’s speech was carried by official Baku
sources.

"It’s no secret that we buy equipment and armaments to strengthen
the army; and we’ll continue to do so," he said.

But Azerbaijan has to launch its own production of military
equipment. "One has to invest money in it. We must develop the
defense sector to support ourselves; and we’ll score a success in
this direction," the head of state underlined.

Azerbaijan’s defense spending in 2007 will reach one billion dollars;
and the figure will increase in the future, according to him.

The growing economic potential of the country, and the strengthening of
its army, together with diplomatic activity and Azerbaijan’s growing
role in the sphere of ensuring energy security "strengthens the
country’s positions, creating excellent opportunities for resolving
the Karabakh conflict," the president said.

Aliyev urged Armenia to unconditionally withdraw from the occupied
territories of Azerbaijan, underlining that in this case it would be
possible to resolve the Karabakh conflict.

In his opinion, the year 2006 yielded no practical results in the
settlement of the problem."

At the same time, Aliyev underlined that "the Azerbaijani side is
committed to the process of negotiations" and that "the Prague process
is an acceptable format for them."

He is convinced that this format is capable of ensuring Azerbaijan’s
interests and the restoration of justice.

"The territorial integrity of Azerbaijan has never been and never
will be a subject of discussions," Aliyev stated.

Gegham Gharibjanyan: Until nationalism is endorsed, no one is secure

Gegham Gharibjanyan: Until nationalism is endorsed, no one is secure from such crimes

ArmRadio.am
23.01.2007 15:52

Armenia is shocked with the assassination of the editor-in-chief of the
Agos daily Hrant Dink and condemns the crime committed in Istanbul,
RA Deputy Foreign Minister Gegham Gharibjanyan told ArmInfo during
the mourning ceremony in the Liberty Square of Yerevan.

In Gegham Gharibjanyan’s words, until nationalism is endorsed, no
one can be secure from such crimes. He did not agree that the time
has come for Armenia to undertake similar harsh steps. "We have our
foreign policy, which we are implementing," Gegham Gharibjanyan noted.

Let us remind that last night the delegation headed by RA Deputy
Foreign Minister Arman Kirakosyan left for Istanbul to participate
in the funeral of Hrant Dink. Several thousands of people gathered
in the Liberty Square today.

The gathering was attended by representatives of the clergy, political
and public figures, foreign media representatives.

Jihad Watch: Fitzgerald: The murder of Hrant Dink

Jihad Watch,
Jan 21 2007

Fitzgerald: The murder of Hrant Dink

When awards are handed out, they often go to the wrong people. It is
not the hapless Mohammed El Baradei, nor that apologist-for-Islam
("the mistreatment of women does not come from Islam") Shirin Ebadi,
who deserve that Nobel for Peace, but rather Ayaan Hirsi Ali and
other brave apostates. And the same is true for those prizes awarded
to journalists.

Who has given a prize to Flemming Rose? Or to Hrant Dink?

Hrant (pronounced "Ervant") Dink was a non-Muslim victim of Muslim
hatred of non-Muslims. He was shot because he was an Armenian citizen
of Turkey, who thought that the government and people of Turkey
should own up to the mass-murder (genocide) of the Armenians. He was
not, and could not be, a true "Turk" according to the definition
supplied by Turkish nationalists.

The particular variant on Islam operative in the murder of Hrant Dink
was the Kemalist cult of "the Turk" — Kemalism, in constraining
Islam, offered a replacement cult, the cult of Ataturk and of The
Turk. But in this case it can be seen to have adopted to a new age
essentially the same attitudes. The violence and aggression of Islam,
the inability to conceive of non-Muslims as fully equal legally and
socially to Muslims, have carried over into the Kemalist substitute
for Islam — the cult of "the Turk" by which the past civilizations
of Anatolia, its entire history, back to the Hittites, is ascribed to
"the Turks." This is another variant on the Muslim desire to ignore
everything that happened before Islam arrived as merely the time of
"Jahiliyya." That cannot be done in the case of Turkey: too many
impressive remnants of classical antiquity, as well as of Byzantium,
remain and must remain — if only for the Western tourists. The
solution of the Kemalist-nationalists was to take that pre-Islamic
past and enroll it in a counter-myth: the myth of the Turk to whom
all this somehow belongs, and for which he, the glorious Turk, is
somehow responsible. The educated elite realize that this is absurd,
but as in any country, and especially in such a country as Turkey,
how few must be those members of the educated elite who are immune to
both Islam and to the Myth of the Turk.

The re-emergence of Islam has led some Turks, including the one who
waited to kill Hrant Dink, to be possessed by a syncretistic mix. The
non-Turk means the non-Muslim citizen of Turkey — Armenian, Greek,
or Jew. No offense must be given by these inferior citizens to the
cult of the Turk, or to "the Turkish Nation." There is the same
readiness to be offended, the same division of the universe between
Us and Them (in the case of Islam it is Believer and Infidel, and in
the case of Muslim Turks who have embraced Kemalism it can be, for
the primitive, the true Turk and the non-Turk), the same recourse to
violence.

Hrant Dink should be remembered, and that memory honored, and not
only in Sausalito or Watertown, but everywhere. And the reasons for
his killing should be understood, including the reflection of the
persistence of Islamic attitudes in Turks, even those who are
"defending the Turkish nation from slander" rather than "defending
Muhammad from blasphemy." In the minds of Turkish Muslims, these
attitudes are mutually reinforcing.

One more thing.

This should be it, as far as entry into the EU is concerned. Call off
the farce. And this should also be the time when the Bush
Administration reads Turkey the riot act about Kurdistan, and starts
to make plans for that independent state, and tells the Turkish
government that it had better accept the American-extorted guarantees
that there will be no territorial claim made on Turkey by the new and
independent Kurdistan, but that Syria and Iran are fair game. And if
it doesn’t accept that? Then Turkey, whose military is entirely
dependent on American re-quipping, American spare parts, American
training, can see that American connection go up in smoke from the
top of Mount Ararat. No more nonsense about being afraid of "the
Turkish reaction." The Turkish government can get with the new
program, with those guarantees given by the Kurds to the Americans
(and without American diplomatic and military support an independent
Kurdistan could never exist) or face abandonment by its main, and
only sure ally. And if the Turkish government thinks that the Arabs
would or could ever be an ally of Turkey, rather than mischief-makers
intent on reversing 80 years of Kemalism, it should be disabused of
that thought quickly.

01/014922print.html

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

http://www.jihadwatch.org/archives/2007/