BAKU: Pashayeva offers to hold monitoring on Armenia’s weapons place

Today, Azerbaijan
Jan 24 2007

Ganira Pashayeva offers to hold monitoring on Armenia’s weapons
placed in occupied Azeri lands

24 January 2007 [21:22] – Today.Az

Member of the Azerbaijani delegation to the Parliamentary Assembly of
the Council of Europe (PACE), parliamentarian Ganira Pashayeva
presented written questionnaire to the Committee of Ministers on
"Armenia’s violating principles of European Convention on Firearms."

Parliamentarian told the APA that the determination of the number of
military equipment and weapons of the Post Soviet countries after
USSR downfall was noted in the questionnaire.

"The population, area, as well as military-political situation of the
countries was not taken into consideration while distribution. Though
Azerbaijan’s population and area is triple of Armenia, the number of
military equipment and weapons were equal. The number of personal
staff of the armed forces was determined 60 000 for Armenia with 3
million population and 70 000 for Azerbaijan with 8 million
population. According to the world practice, the number of armed
forces to ensure the security of the country makes up 1% of the whole
population. The main duty of armed forces of every country is to
ensure the territorial integrity. How can a state with triple area of
the other state ensure the security with the same number of military
equipment? So, it caused military disbalance in the region, and
resulted in Azerbaijan’s occupation by Armenia."

The document also notes that Russia gave Armenia illegal armament in
1995-1996 and a part of those armaments have been placed in occupied
Azerbaijani territories. All these happened after Armenia joined to
law on "common armed forces in Europe in the frame of OSCE" and
"Vienna document on strengthening of trust and safety."

The document notes that the Armenia’s information on traditional
annual military report of OSCE member states is not real. The
questionnaire stresses that Armenia continues to arm, violating the
rules of "Common Armed forces in Europe."

"Armenian became an arm passing center for international
organizations and regimes, and has created conditions for
international terrorist organizations to prepare terrorists.
Different illicit drugs and the components of weapons of mass
annihilation are passed from this point to different countries and it
menaces the stability and safety of region countries. OSCE monitoring
mission has confirmed the fact Armenians are placed in occupied
Azerbaijani territories which contradicts the international legal
norms."

Pashayeva asked the Cabinet of Ministers what measures can be taken
to estimate Armenian’s moves and about the possibility of holding
monitoring on armaments by CE in occupied Azerbaijani territories.

URL:

http://www.today.az/news/politics/35409.html

BAKU: Fiorenzo Stolfi: Resolutions on conflicts are not efficient

Fiorenzo Stolfi: Resolutions on conflicts are not efficient

Azeri Press Agency, Azerbaijan
Jan 24 2007

[ 24 Jan. 2007 20:51 ]

Fiorenzo Stolfi, San Marino Foreign Minster, chairing the CE Committee
of Ministers made a speech on the third day of the PACE winter session,
APA reports.

Member of the Azerbaijani delegation to PACE Ganira Pashayeva gave
two questions to him after his speech. She mentioned that Azerbaijan,
Georgia and Moldova whose territorial integrity was broken, are
members of the CE for 5 years and asked when the CE will use pressure
mechanisms against the countries preventing restoration of territorial
integrity. Fiorenzo Stolfi said that the country he represents respects
principles of international law, especially recognizes territorial
integrity and sovereignty of the countries.

"Our priorities are the peaceful solution of frozen and long-lasting
conflicts. If you mean Nagorno Karabakh conflict, OSCE Minsk Group
is engaged with the problem," he said.

Asked why Committee of Ministers does not take steps on Armenia
ignoring resolution 1416, the chairman said that some resolutions
were adopted on the mentioned conflicts, as well as Nagorno Karabakh
conflict. But we observe that the document is not efficient. Anyway, we
intend to discuss issues on conflicts in the meeting of the Committee
of Ministers next week. /APA/

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Armenian economy again ranked most liberal in CIS

ARMENIAN ECONOMY AGAIN RANKED MOST LIBERAL IN CIS
Emil Danielyan 1/24/07

EurasiaNet, NY
Jan 24 2007

Armenia has received plaudits for possessing the most liberal
and open economy in the Commonwealth of Independent States, as
the country ranked a highly respectable 32nd in a recent survey on
economic freedom. However, government critics and a few independent
economists contend that the study does not accurately represent the
country’s economic conditions.

The survey, prepared by The Wall Street Journal and the Heritage
Foundation and released January 16, covered 157 countries. It found
an "impressive amount of freedom" in the Armenian economy, which is
still recovering from the Soviet collapse and remains hamstrung by
the unresolved conflict over Nagorno-Karabakh.

The Index of Economic Freedom rated economies in 10 areas, including
the extent of government involvement in economic affairs, trade and
monetary policy, property rights and business regulations. Armenia
received high scores in most of these categories, surpassing all
other non-Baltic ex-Soviet states in recent years’ rankings.

WSJ/Heritage researchers went farther this year, putting it ahead of
economic powers like France, Italy and South Korea.

"Armenia is ranked 19th freest among the 41 countries in the
European region," concluded the study. "Armenia’s score puts it
above Europe’s average — an impressive feat for an impoverished
landlocked country." It cited, among other things, low tax rates,
modest government expenditures, a fully private banking sector,
and tight government monetary policies.

The WSJ/Heritage appraisal is largely in tune with the findings
of similar studies. Armenia, for example, was judged to have the
most investor-friendly business environment in the CIS in a 2005
World Bank survey that assessed "the ease of doing business" around
the world. Also in 2005 the European Bank for Reconstruction and
Development (EBRD) said in a report that it leads the way in the CIS
transition to a market economy.

Armenia launched its reform efforts amid adverse circumstances. The
conflicts in Karabakh and elsewhere in the South Caucasus effectively
cut off the country from the outside world, causing its Gross Domestic
Product to shrink by half from 1992-1993. The Armenian economy began
its slow but steady recovery after a Russian-mediated truce stopped
the Armenian-Azerbaijani war for Karabakh in 1994.

According to government statistics, it grew in 2006 at a double-digit
rate for a sixth consecutive year. Official figures also suggest that
the poverty rate in the country fell from 56 percent to 35 percent
between 1999 and 2005.

The World Bank and the International Monetary Fund say Armenians are
finally reaping the benefits of free-market economics. "Armenia’s
economic performance has been impressive in recent years," the IMF’s
managing director, Rodrigo de Rato, said during a June 2006 visit
to Yerevan.

The Armenian government is certain to seize upon the WSJ/Heritage
survey as vindication of its economic policies. Meanwhile, government
critics, along with some independent experts, say that economic
appearances are deceiving in Armenia’s case. The country’s economic
environment is not as liberal as it is portrayed, due to weak rule
of law, endemic corruption, and a lack of judicial independence,
they contend. Government connections are still essential for doing
business, and virtually all local millionaire businessmen operate
with the support and protection of various government factions and
pro-establishment parties. The richest of them are believed to have
close ties with the country’s two most powerful men, President Robert
Kocharian and Defense Minister Serge Sarkisian.

"Armenia is the most centralized state in the region," said Hrant
Bagratian, a liberal economist who served as prime minister in
1993-1996. "Forty or so families control 58 percent of our GDP."

A controversy surrounding the redevelopment of Yerevan underscores
the weak protections for private property. Hundreds of city residents
were forcibly evicted and their homes bulldozed so that expensive
residential and office buildings could be built. The process has been
regulated by a 2002 government directive, despite a constitutional
provision requiring that urban renewal be governed by parliamentary
approved legislation. Armenia’s Constitutional Court declared the
redevelopment process unconstitutional in April 2006, but stopped
short of ordering the state to pay additional compensation to the
evicted families.

Government corruption is another serious problem hampering economic
activity and competition in the country. Armenia ranked 93rd out of 163
countries in the Berlin-based Transparency International’s most recent
Corruption Perception Index. Fearing retribution, local entrepreneurs
rarely challenge bribe solicitations by government officials. One of
them who did, the owner of a coffee importing company, is currently
standing trial on tax evasion charges that were leveled after his
public allegations of high-level corruption in the Armenian customs
service.

The Index of Economic Freedom acknowledges these problems, putting
Armenia’s scores in the Property Rights and Freedom from Corruption
categories well below the world’s average. But its authors’ assertion
that the low level of Armenian public spending is a blessing will
be dismissed by many local and Western economists. The Armenian
government’s 2006 tax revenues accounted for less than 16 percent
of GDP, an extremely low proportion even by ex-Soviet standards that
highlights the scale of tax evasion among the local rich.

Consequently, the government’s 2007 budget, projected at a record-high
$1.5 billion, will still be insufficient for meeting the basic needs
of the country’s public sector.

The World Bank and the IMF regard tax evasion as a key economic
challenge facing Armenia, pressing the authorities in Yerevan to
tackle the problem in earnest. Kocharian admitted its gravity at an
extraordinary meeting on January 10 with top government officials. "I
don’t see in the [tax collection] services sufficient energy to fight
against the shadow economy," he told them. "There is improvement,
but it can not be considered satisfactory in the existing situation."

Editor’s Note: Emil Danielyan is a Yerevan-based journalist and
political analyst.

Choose Your Words Carefully

Brown Alumni Magazine, RI
Jan 24 2007

Choose Your Words Carefully

Writing would be much easier, says Salmon Rushdie, if its purpose
were merely to entertain.

By Lawrence Goodman

[CENSORSHIP]

The writers up on the Salomon Center stage may have come from different
countries, but they all had one thing in common-they’ve been persecuted
for speaking their minds.

"We are gambling with our lives when we choose a word," said Iranian
novelist Shahriar Mandanipour about the lack of free expression in his
native land. Mandanipour spoke at a panel on freedom of expression
that was part of a weeklong program titled "Strange Times, My Dear:
A Freedom-to-Write Literary Festival." Speaking alongside Mandanipour
was 2006 Nobel Prize winner Orhan Pamuk, who was threatened with
imprisonment in his native Turkey after he spoke openly about the
early twentieth-century mass murder of Armenians there.

At the forum Pamuk said he preferred not to speak about his battle with
the Turkish government. "I don’t want to go into it," he responded
when a student asked about his experience, which ended in late 2005
after the government dropped all charges.

Instead, Pamuk said, he worried about censorship in the West. As
immigrants from the East enter Europe, he said, they are "very roughly
treated." As a result, when they perceive insults against their culture
they call for less free speech or the banning of certain books. Then,
he said, Western governments ignore the underlying issues of racism
and cheap labor and instead "choose to ban books, plays, and films
just to please these immigrants."

The festival featured a one-on-one conversation with Salman Rushdie,
who in 1989 famously became the target of a fatwa offering a reward for
his murder. In an interview with conference organizer Robert Coover,
the T.B. Stowell Adjunct Professor of Literary Arts, Rushdie said
that writers have an obligation to be more than entertainers.

"It would give us [writers] a much better life if we were
entertaining," he said, "if all we were doing was to put things out
there to give people a pleasing evening."

Rushdie said the writer should be less a political activist than
an excavator of the memories and experiences a society wishes to
suppress. "It’s not a question of seeking out a political conflict,"
he explained, "but simply remembering the way it was."

Rushdie noted he will be starring as a gynecologist in an upcoming
movie directed by Helen Hunt. "Helen said that when she wrote the
part she was thinking of Salman," Rushdie said. "I have been thinking
what it means that when Helen Hunt thinks of me, she thinks of her
gynecologist."

Armenia doesn’t want new dividing lines in Caucasus – Kocharyan

Armenia doesn’t want new dividing lines in Caucasus – Kocharyan

ITAR-TASS, Russia
Jan 24 2007

24.01.2007, 17.42

SOCHI, January 24 (Itar-Tass) – Armenian President Robert
Kocharyan warned about the danger of creating new dividing lines
in Transcaucasia.

"Armenia does not want processes in Transcaucasia to lead to the
appearance of new dividing lines," Kocharyan told a news conference
in Sochi.

"We have problems with Azerbaijan; we conduct talks, there’s been
little optimism so far, but the main thing is that the ceasefire
established in the region with Russia’s help has been in effect since
1992," he said.

Kocharyan thanked Russia for its peacemaking efforts in the region.

ANKARA: Putin hails strong growth in trade with Armenia

Putin hails strong growth in trade with Armenia
17:24 | 24/ 01/ 2007

RIA Novosti, Russia
Jan 24 2007

SOCHI, January 24 (RIA Novosti) – At a meeting with the president
of Armenia in a southern Russian city Wednesday, the Russian leader
praised the strong upward trend in bilateral trade, which gained 70%
in January-November 2006.

At talks in a Russian Black Sea resort of Sochi, Vladimir Putin and
Robert Kocharyan discussed trade and the implementation of agreements
between the former Soviet allies.

"On the whole, we are satisfied with the steady growth in trade over
the past few years," Putin said. "It increased 40% in 2005, and 70%
in the first eleven months of 2006."

"The final figure for the whole last year may reach about $500
million," the president told a news conference following the
negotiations.

Kocharyan said he hoped Russia would reclaim its leading positions
among Armenia’s foreign investors by March.

"Trade is on the increase, and Russian investment in the Armenian
economy has also grown substantially," Kocharyan said.

The Armenian leader said ambitious energy projects had already been
launched, and that the sides were considering Russian participation
in Armenia’s mining industry.

Russian president warns potential for conflict in South Caucasus sti

Russian president warns potential for conflict in South Caucasus still high
The Associated PressPublished: January 24, 2007

International Herald Tribune, France
Jan 24 2007

SOCHI, Russia: President Vladimir Putin on Wednesday warned that
the potential for a new outbreak of fighting in the strategic South
Caucasus remained high and pledged that Moscow would work to resolve
the region’s most dangerous, outstanding conflicts – including the
dispute over Nagorno-Karabakh.

Putin and his Armenian counterpart, Robert Kocharian, met one day
after Armenia’s foreign minister and his Azerbaijani counterpart held
inconclusive talks in Moscow on the status of the mountainous territory
inside Azerbaijan that is controlled by ethnic Armenian forces.

"The potential for conflict is still very high," Putin said at a
joint news conference with Kocharian in the Black Sea port of Sochi.

A shaky cease-fire in 1994 ended six years of fighting that left
30,000 people killed and about 1 million driven from their homes and
left Karabakh and Armenian forces in control of the territory.

Gunfire breaks out regularly along the border between the two ex-Soviet
countries and in the regions near Nagorno-Karabakh.

Repeated efforts by international mediators, including Russia, France,
the United States and the Organization for Security and Cooperation in
Europe, to resolve the dispute have failed, and the lack of resolution
has tied up development in the energy-rich South Caucasus.

"We have problems with Azerbaijan on the Nagorno-Karabakh settlement.

We are conducting active negotiations," Kocharian said. "The most
important factor is that the cease-fire introduced in the region in
1994 remains effective until now. This proves the intentions of the
parties to adhere to the peaceful process within the framework of
the OSCE."

Armenia is Russia’s closest ally in the South Caucasus, and Yerevan
in recent years has turned over a substantial part of its energy
infrastructure and network to Russia companies.

Among the other South Caucasus nations, Azerbaijan is increasingly
asserting its substantial energy reserves and its independence from
Russia while Georgia is actively seeking tighter ties with NATO,
the European Union and the West.

Azerbaijan, flush with oil and gas revenues, has also markedly
increased its defense spending and warned that it has the potential
to retake Nagorno-Karabakh from ethnic Armenian forces – raising
fears of a new outbreak of fighting if no final resolution for the
territory is found.

In Baku, U.S. diplomat Matthew J. Bryza, who is helping OSCE efforts
to resolve the conflict, suggested that an agreement could be reached
this year.

"There is a possibility to reach an agreement. I don’t know when.

It’s possible this year. Everything depends on the presidents,"
Bryza told reporters at Baku airport after meeting with Azerbaijani
President Ilham Aliev and other officials.

"The meetings were constructive. I have the impression that your
president and foreign minister are demonstrating a constructive
position, said Bryza, a U.S. deputy assistant secretary of state.

In Sochi, Putin and Kocharian praised bilateral relations.

"We’ve tackled everything in energy and now focus on transport and
industry," Putin was quoted by ITAR-TASS as saying. "Our bilateral
trade is growing and direct contacts between our people are on the
ascent."

"Last year was very successful in bilateral relations. We reached
agreements on very serious projects in economics and I very much
hope that this year will be that of their practical realization,"
Kocharian told Putin in televised comments.

___

Associated Press writer Aida Sultanova contributed to this report
from Baku, Azerbaijan.

All Members Of Azerbaijani Delegation Also Beforehand Subscribed To

ALL MEMBERS OF AZERBAIJANI DELEGATION ALSO BEGOREHAND SUBSCRIBED TO
DISCUSSION OF ISSUE RELATING TO ARMENIA AT PACE SESSION

STRASBOURG, JANUARY 24, NOYAN TAPAN. Discussion of the process of
implementation of the obligations of Armenia was envisaged at the
January 23 last sitting of the winter session of the Parliamentary
Assembly of the Council of Europe. The discussion started at 21:30
Yerevan time. As Tigran Torosian, the Armenian delegation head, NA
Speaker informed Radio Liberty on the previous day, all the members of
the Armenian as well as Azerbaijani delegations being in Strasbourg
were subscribed for speeches concerning the issue. In T.Torosian’s
words, subscribtion of the Azerbaijani delegation members is strange
as there is no line in the resolution relating to Azerbaijan.

In the words of Stepan Demirchian, a member of the Armenian
delegation, head of the opposing "Ardarutiun" (Justice) faction,
the report is balanced. It fixes that after joining the Council
of Europe, no election in Armenia was free and just, it attaches
importance to the coming parliamentary and president’s elections. It
is at the same time mentioned in the report that Armenia fixed
progress in the sense of implementation of the obligations undertaken
by it. The constitutional amendments are attached importance to
among the latters. But the report authors also mentioned that the
referendum on the constitutional amendments was a lost possibility
for the authorities of Armenia in the sense of organizing free and
just elections.

S.Demirchian mentioned that he intended to speak in his speech
particularly about the issue that the authorities of Armenia did not
take step till now in the direction of subjecting to responsibility
those falsifying the elections what had been presented as a demand
by the Council of Europe continuously for years, in the direction of
giving TV broadcast to "A1+", securing balanced staff of electoral
commissions.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Terry Davis: The Country Who Will First Apply Force To Resolve Karab

TERRY DAVIS: THE COUNTRY WHO WILL FIRST APPLY FORCE TO RESOLVE KARABAKH
CONFLICT WILL BE EXPELLED FROM COUNCIL OF EUROPE

Strasbourg, January 24. ArmInfo. When Armenia and Azerbaijan were
joining the Council of Europe they committed themselves to resolve
the Karabakh conflict by peace, CE Secretary General Terry Davis
said during a press-launch when answering the question of ArmInfo’s
correspondent.

The failure to meet this commitment will lead to very serious
consequences, up to the expulsion of the defaulter-country from the
CE, Davis said and noted that he will be very much sorry if Armenia
or Azerbaijan break their promises.

Davis thanked the Armenian and Azeri FMs for constantly informing
him of the peace process. He reminded the journalists that he was
rapporteur on the Karabakh conflict and is always keen to know about
the developments in the South Caucasus. Davis stressed the importance
of the early resolution of the conflict for the fates of the people
living in the conflict zone. Many people have died in this conflict
and the sides should do their best to find an early solution to it –
a solution that would serve the interests of the nations of Armenia,
Azerbaijan and Nagorno-Karabakh.

Funeral of Hrant Dink, Istanbul, 23/01/07

Funeral of Hrant Dink, Istanbul, 23/01/07

Words: Jerome Taylor,

The Independent – United Kingdom
Published: Jan 24, 2007

The crowd

In an extraordinary outpouring of public grief and spontaneous protest
against militant Turkish nationalism, more than 100,000 mourners march
through Istanbul in a funeral procession for the slain Turkish-Armenian
writer and editor Hrant Dink, who was gunned down last week outside
his office.

The media

The assassination of Hrant Dink has caused a media sensation in Turkey.
Just four weeks ago, media buses like these were placed across the
country’s capital to record Turkey’s notoriously buoyant New Year
celebrations. Now they capture a very different national mood: anger
and defiance.

The mourned writer

One of Turkey’s best known Armenian writers, Dink paid the ultimate
price for encouraging reconciliation between his country’s Turkish
and Armenian populations. His insistence on recognising the Armenian
genocide not only landed him in court, but also, it appears, infuriated
ultranationalists enough to want
him dead.

The family

Dink’s immediate family follow directly behind the hearse as it winds
its way through the streets of Istanbul. His daughter Sera marches in
front of the coffin carrying a portrait of her father, as the former
editor’s close friends
and colleagues link arms to f lank the hearse.

The flowers

Crammed on to every overpass and bridge lining the funeral route,
thousands more people clap as the procession goes by and throw
blood-red roses on to the
hearse. Roses have come to symbolise Dink’s assassination, and shrines
bearing his portrait bedecked with the f lowers have sprung up across
the city.

The flagless protest

In a country where Turks are taught from a young age to revere their
country, its f lag and their secular, nationalist founder Kamal
Ataturk, the procession’s anti-nationalist stance is noticeable for
its lack of Turkish f lags, a symbol found f luttering on f lagpoles
across the country.

The placards

Mourners hold placards and wear T-shirts with provocative slogans
(including "We are all Armenians" and "Shoulder to shoulder against
fascism") in Armenian, Turkish and Kurdish. Such condemnation of Dink’s
murderers is astonishing in a country where the use of non-Turkish
languages is controversial.

The route

The procession travels through five miles of unusually traffic-free
Istanbul. It began at the bilingual Turkish-Armenian newspaper where
Dink was editor, winding through Taksim Square and over the Golden
Horn to a small Armenian church, passing some of the city’s most
iconic tourist spots along the way.