TBILISI: Increased EU involvement in conflict zones

The Messenger, Georgia
Jan 24 2007

Increased EU involvement in conflict zones
By Diana Dundua

German Ambassador Patricia Flor
and EU diplomats Per Eklund and
Peter Semneby say the EU wants to
help build confidence between the
conflicting sides in Georgia

European Union officials concluded a trip to Georgia on January 22
which included visits with separatist authorities in breakaway South
Ossetia and Abkhazia. The delegation was exploring ways to extend the
EU Neighbourhood Policy (ENP) Action Plan to help build bridges
between the sides in Georgia.

Head of the European Commission’s (EC) Delegation to Georgia and
Armenia HE Per Eklund, EU Special Representative for the South
Caucasus Peter Semneby and German Ambassador to Georgia HE (EU
presidency) Patricia Flor all participated in the visit headed by
Hugues Mingarelli, the European Commission Director for Eastern
Europe.

According to Eklund, one of the purposes of the mission’s visit was
to see what more the European Commission could do in the conflict
areas to assist conflict resolution and confidence-building measures.
The EU is one of the most active donors both in South Ossetia and
Abkhazia.

"We are already active in rehabilitation, the health and education
sectors, NGO support, and civil society support," Eklund stated at
the press conference on January 22.

During the mission’s visit, the participants met with OSCE and UNOMIG
representatives as well as government representatives in Tbilisi,
travelled to South Ossetia and Abkhazia and also met with the of the
de facto authorities and international NGOs in Abkhazia.

"The purpose was not to reinvent the wheel, because there are already
many EU instruments in place. The mission focused on developing and
building upon what the EU is already doing in Georgia. This includes
most importantly the European Neighbourhood Policy and the financial
instruments for supporting this policy. But it also includes for
example the border support team that has been in place in Georgia and
has been working here within the European Commission premises for
almost two years," stated Semneby adding, "The purpose is to extend
these programs, which are applying to Georgia, to Abkhazia and South
Ossetia in order to encourage contacts to increase confidence between
the parties."

The delegation only met with de facto Abkhazian officials of Sergey
Bagapsh’s government and breakaway South Ossetian officials of Eduard
Kokoity’s administration in South Ossetia. They did not meet with the
Dmitri Sanokoyev’s alternative government in South Ossetia, nor
travel to the seat of the Abkhaz government-in-exile in the Kodori
Gorge; however, Malkhaz Akishbaia, the head of the
government-in-exile was present at their Tbilisi meetings.

"None of the two alternatives [in South Ossetia] we consider
legitimate," Eklund said on January 22.

De facto Abkhazian foreign minister Sergey Shamba said after talks
with the EU delegation on January 18 that "despite disagreements in
political issues," the Abkhaz side considers EU-funded programs
"useful," Apsnypress news agency reported.

"The European Commission is financing several projects in Abkhazia.
But this does not mean that we reject our key interests and
independence," Shamba said, reports Civil Georgia.

He also said that Sokhumi wants to establish a dialogue and "direct
links with the European Union" without the mediation of Tbilisi.

"Abkhazia is a part of Europe and we have the right to integrate into
European society… I do not think that linking Abkhazia with Europe
will be effective through Georgia or through any other state. It is
necessary to establish direct ties," Shamba said.

German Ambassador HE Patricia Flor said at the press conference that
the EU supports Georgia’s territorial integrity within its
internationally recognized borders and at the same time it is
important to build bridges between the secessionist territories and
the rest of Georgia, stressing that it is vital to bring people
together.

Semneby explained that the mission’s findings would be discussed in
Brussels within the next few weeks and then concrete recommendations
would be worked out. The mission’s findings would include the areas
of civil society development, exchange programmes, economic
rehabilitation, infrastructure rehabilitation, issues related to
customs and trade as well as also confidence building measures.

BAKU: Perviz Shahbazov: Ilham Aliyev’s meeting with Angela Merkel is

Perviz Shahbazov: Ilham Aliyev’s meeting with Angela Merkel is of great importance

Azeri Press Agency, Azerbaijan
Jan 23 2007

[ 23 Jan. 2007 14:27 ]

Azerbaijani Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary Ambassador to Germany
interviewed by the APA

– How do you appreciate the activity of the Azerbaijani embassy in
Germany in 2006? What can you say about the plans of the embassy?

– 2006 was very successful from the point of view of expansion of
relations in political, economic, cultural and other spheres between
Germany and Azerbaijan. Azerbaijani President visited Germany in
September last year and participated in International Bertelsmann
Forum. Besides, we can mention Foreign Minister’s visit to Germany,
political and security consultations of the Deputy Foreign Ministers
from the point of view of development of bilateral political
dialogue. A number of events were realized last year for the
development of economic relations. Among them we can mention
Azerbaijani Economic Development Minister’s visit to Germany, the
visit of the delegation composed of German businessmen to Azerbaijan,
Azerbaijan’s participation in the International Tourism Exhibition
held in Berlin and international exhibition on new technologies held
in Hanover etc. The embassy carried on propaganda for establishing
direct relations between Azerbaijani and German companies to
strengthen German investments in Azerbaijan. As to the cultural
cooperation, I would like to note that Azerbaijani Culture Ten-day
was held in Berlin, Mainz, Stuttgart and Frankfurt am Main in October
last year. Azerbaijani art figures gave concert, exhibition of young
Azerbaijani artists was held, Azerbaijani books for the first time
were demonstrated in famous Frankfurt Book Fair. As a result of
negotiations 2008 is declared "Azerbaijani Culture Year" in Germany
and various events are planned to be held.

– What is the level of the relations between Azerbaijan and Germany,
and are you satisfied with it?

– The relations between the two countries are improving dynamically.

There is exists active political dialogue between the countries,
economic and cultural relations are developing. There is a great
potential for further development of our relations. Azerbaijan pays
great attention to the broadening of relations with Germany, one of
the leading states of the European Union and world. Therefore the
embassy pays special attention to the recognition of Azerbaijan in
Germany, informing the society of the Azerbaijan’s truths.

– What meetings will be held and what documents are planned to be
signed within President Ilham Aliyev’s visit to Germany in February?

According to the information the president will be accompanied by the
delegation representing economic organizations. Is business forum
expected within the visit?

– As is known, President Ilham Aliyev will visit Germany in February
this year. Some official meetings are expected in the frame of his
visit. The meeting with German Chancellor Angela Merkel has great
importance for us. As we know, Germany will chair EU during the first
term of 2007 and G8 within the year. Germany has declared that it
will try to activate New Neighbourhood Policy. That is why it is very
important for Azerbaijan to cooperate with Germany, because
Azerbaijan has aims at integrating to the structures that newly
joined to New Neighbourhood Policy and close cooperation with
Euro-Atlantic structures. Azerbaijan-Germany business forum is
expected to be held in the frame of the visit. Generally, German
businessmen are mostly interested in non-oil sector of Azerbaijan. It
includes infrastructure, tourism, engineering industry, product
industry and some others.

– What do Azerbaijanis mostly do in Germany?

– Most of Azeris living in Germany are engaged in construction,
product industry, tourism, public catering and so on.

– Does the embassy keep in touch with Azerbaijani Diaspora and what
problems do our people have? Do Azerbaijanis, that introduced
themselves as the representatives of other nations but did not
achieve their goals, appeal to our embassy and what about their
number?

– There is great Azerbaijani community in Germany. There are
Azerbaijanis that moved from Turkey and Iran a long time ago and also
Azerbaijani citizens. The embassy has close relations with
Azerbaijanis living in this country and in case that they face any
problem; we take necessary measures in this sphere. European
Azerbaijanis Congress which acts in Berlin cooperates with the
embassy. The embassy implements joint cultural projects with
Azerbaijani societies. Recently we held a big ceremony dedicated to
World Azerbaijanis solidarity day where over 350 Azerbaijanis and our
German friends took part in. Azerbaijani Diaspora organizations are
expected to participate in the Azerbaijani culture years to be
celebrated in Germany. Department working with the foreigners
sometimes appeal to our embassy, and ask to define the citizenship of
the people that are supposed to be Azerbaijani citizens. The embassy
sends the questionnaire to relevant bodies of Azerbaijani and informs
German side about the results. Sometimes Armenian-born people
introduce themselves as Azerbaijani for getting permanent asylum. The
embassy immediately informs the relevant bodies after getting needed
information about the person. /APA/

BAKU: Co-chairs to release joint statement after Yerevan negotiation

Co-chairs to release joint statement after Yerevan negotiations

Azeri Press Agency, Azerbaijan
Jan 24 2007

[ 24 Jan. 2007 15:16 ]

The co-chairs of OSCE Minsk Group Yuri Merzlyakov (Russia), Bernard
Fasie (France), Metyu Bryza (USA) and personal representative of
OSCE Chairman-in-Office Andrzey Kasprzyk will visit Yerevan today,
Russian co-chair Yuri Merzlyakov told the APA.

He said that during their meeting with President Ilham Aliyev they
discussed the present stage of negotiations on Nagorno Karabakh, but
he did not bring up any details. He also added that the co-chairs will
release joint statement after their meeting with Armenian President
Robert Kocharyan.

It should be noted that after the meeting with Azerbaijani President,
the co-chairs had business dinner with Foreign Minister Elmar
Mammadyarov and held informal negotiations. /APA/

Sydney: Armenian protest over murder

Armenian protest over murder
January 25, 2007 12:00am

Melbourne Herald Sun, Australia
Jan 24 2007

MORE than 500 members of Sydney’s Armenian community rallied outside
the city’s Turkish consulate yesterday in protest at the murder of
outspoken journalist Hrant Dink.

Mr Dink, 52, was shot outside his newspaper office in Istanbul on
Friday.

Many believe he was a target because of his criticism of the Turkish
Government over its continued refusal to acknowledge the Armenian
genocide at the end of World War I.

Up to 600 Sydney-based Armenians gathered outside the Turkish
consulate to express their anger at Mr Dink’s death, said Armenian
National Committee of Australia president Tro Kortian.

Protesters called on the Turkish Government to punish the teenager
who confessed to Mr Dink’s murder, and also urged it to acknowledge
the Armenian genocide.

Dr Kortian said it had been a peaceful rally.

"The purpose was to convey the community’s collective indignation as
well as to add the community’s voice to the international
condemnation regarding the assassination of Hrant Dink," he said.

Dr Kortian said the Turkish Government’s continuing denial of the
genocide was feeding an atmosphere of intolerance and racial hatred.

Consular officials refused to accept a letter from a delegation of
protesters, but Dr Kortian said he was confident the message had been
heard.

Speeches in Armenian and English, and a tribute to Mr Dink’s life and
work featured in the one-hour protest.

Between 25,000 and 30,000 Armenians live in Sydney.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Silent salute to editor killed for ‘insulting Turks’

The Australian, Australia
Jan 24 2007

Silent salute to editor killed for ‘insulting Turks’
Suna Erdem, Istanbul
January 25, 2007

TENS of thousands of mourners marched in silence yesterday through
Istanbul behind the coffin of the Turkish-Armenian journalist Hrant
Dink, who was shot dead by a teenager with suspected nationalist links.

Carrying black banners bearing the slogans "We are all Armenian" and
"We are all Hrant Dink", the 100,000- strong crowd of Turks, ethnic
Armenians and foreigners walked nearly 8km expressing their anger,
not with chanting but with their quiet presence, asrequested by Dink’s
widow, Rakel.

Marchers took time off from work and school to join the procession,
and thousands leaned out of their office windows to applaud, weep
and throw flowers as the hearse carrying Dink’s body passed.

The 52-year-old journalist’s daughter, Sera, carrying a framed portrait
of her father, wept as she walked in front of the coffin.

In a speech outside the offices of Agos, the Turkish-Armenian newspaper
where Dink, its editor, was shot on Friday, Rakel Dink urged the
mourners to work for an end to the hostile nationalistic environment
that still has many Turks in its grip despite recent liberal reforms.

"Do not be satisfied with this much; do not be satisfied with today,"
she cried out to the crowd. "The killer was a baby once. We cannot
achieve anything if we do not question the darkness that creates a
murderer out of a baby."

Dink, along with several other writers, including the Nobel laureate
Orhan Pamuk, had been prosecuted under the controversial Article 301
of the Turkish penal code for his views on the killing of Armenians by
Ottoman Turks in 1915. Turkey denies that this amounted to a genocide
and treats any departure from the official line with suspicion.

Liberal Turks, including Pamuk, say Article 301, which punishes
"insults to Turkish identity", is used to set people up as targets.

Authorities say Ogun Samast, 17, has confessed to the murder of Dink
for "insulting Turks".

Another man, Yasin Hayal, jailed recently for bombing a McDonald’s
restaurant, has admitted inciting him. A university student is being
held under suspicion of organising a cell that included Hayal and
commissioned the murder.

The killing of Dink, who had sought reconciliation between Muslim
Turks and Christian Armenians, harked back to the end of the 20th
century when dissenting journalists and other activists were felled
by militants with suspected links in the state intelligence apparatus.

Turkish President Ahmet Necdet Sezer and Prime Minister Recep Tayyip
Erdogan were conspicuously absent at the service in an Armenian church
by the Golden Horn waterway, but the public and international response
was overwhelming.

Ambassadors, Turkish ministers and MPs, members of the European
parliament and Armenian clerics from across the world crowded into
the church.

Armenian Patriarch Mesrob II called for expanded freedoms of speech
and more dialogue between Turks and Armenians.

BAKU: Protests against "We are all Armenians" slogan increase in Tur

Protests against "We are all Armenians" slogan increase in Turkey

Azeri Press Agency, Azerbaijan
Jan 24 2007

[ 24 Jan. 2007 17:20 ]

The leader of Turkey Nationalist Movement Party Dovlet Bakhchali
protested against slogan chanted in the funeral ceremony of
editor-in-chief of Agos newspaper Hrant Dink, APA Turkey bureau
reports.

Condemning the assassination of Armenia-born journalist, Dovlet
Bakhchali asked to find and punish the perpetrator. The party leader
said it is not right to blame Turkey after each event. The leader
of Turkey nationalists criticized the slogans "We are all Armenians"
chanted in the funeral ceremony of the journalist and noted that that
script is played after the journalist’s death too.

"Some forces try to use this situation for their own goals and compete
with each other to form guilty Turkish society. It is interesting that,
they all are joined under the slogan "We are all Armenians". Turkey
has great amount of martyrs as the result of struggle with PFF terror
since 1984," he said.

He said that it is shameless to call sincere nationalists potential
culprits and stressed that some Turkish intelligentsia began crusade
against Turkish nationalism. /APA/

Nationalists threaten to kill Orhan Pamuk

Nationalists threaten to kill Orhan Pamuk

ArmRadio.am
24.01.2007 16:02

Yasin Hayal, suspected of organizing the murder of the editor-in-chief
of the Agos daily Hrant Dink, has threatened to kill writer, Nobel
Prize winner Orhan Pamuk.

CNN Turk TV Channel reported that connected with the increase of
threats to Pamuk immediately following the assassination of Hrant
Dink, Turkish authorities have taken the decision to provide a group
of bodyguards to him.

Ogyun Samast suspected of murdering Hrant Dink has completely
confessed his guilt, Turkish media report referring to sources of
the Prosecutor’s Office of Istanbul. In his four-day confession
Samast wrote he decided to kill Hrant Dink for the journalist’s
public statements.

TDN: No, let’s talk 301 today

Cicek is wrong. It’s high time to talk about amending Article 301
By Yusuf KANLI

Turkish Daily News
Wed. Jan. 24, 2007
php?ed=yusuf_kanli

It was at the height of a debate on the persecution of intellectuals
in our society, under Article 301 of the Turkish Penal Code (TCK),
when the TDN asked Justice Minister Cemil Cicek during a Sept. 20
reception in Ankara hosted by Sabancı Holding Chairwoman Guler
Sabancı, whether the government would consider making amendments to
the article or totally scrap it.

The minister was very irritated and tried to avoid giving an answer
when I asked why he was so opposed to an amendment – which would
include a detailed clarification as to exactly what constitutes a
crime – to Article 301. However, with a large smile on his face,
he replied, "How willing are you to let people curse at Turkey,
insult Turkishness and get away with it?"

That night, within a few minutes and without giving the minister enough
time to fully answer one question before moving on to the next, I threw
a set of questions at him: But don’t you think this article seriously
infringes on the concept of free thought? Don’t you see that this
article is being used by some people to disseminate hatred? Can’t
we have a new law that complies with the modern understanding of
freedom of expression and opinion, negative or otherwise? Don’t you
think it will be in the best interest of Turkey to draw a line between
criticism and insult? Can there be progress in any area if criticism
is barred? Why are you against the amendment of this article?

He was very irritated. "Parliament is in session to legislate the
reform package, I must go," he responded at first, but seeing that
I had no intention of giving up, he said: "Where were you when the
TCK amendment was being debated? Did you not read the draft at that
time? Were you not aware of this article? Why did you, and others,
not raise your voices at that time? The TCK was legislated only
a short time ago. We need time to see problems that may arise in
practice. This is a serious issue. We cannot make a law and start
talking of amending it the next day, we need to see the application,
let the courts develop an interpretation. There have been different
court verdicts under the same article. Let’s wait and see how it
is implemented and if there is a need, at a later stage we may make
amendments and correct all the problems arising from that and perhaps
other articles. Why are you acting in such haste?"

I don’t want to repeat here how successfully the government had
distracted our attention from the adultery debate and how big a
mistake the intellectuals and progressive personalities of this nation
committed by not focusing well enough on each and every article of
the TCK…

"We were unfortunately debating adultery at that time," I said and
noticed a large smile on the face of Cicek. "You should have been
more attentive. … You should not have let yourself get carried away
with a discussion about one article only to forget about the rest,
including an important package like the TCK," he said.

He was damn right! But we were right as well in demanding immediate
action on Article 301, which we believed was not only devastating
Turkey’s international reputation, but at the same time had become a
tool for a witch-hunt by hard-core nationalists, a major contributor to
the widening polarization in the country and escalation of nationalism
with racist tones.

I should have asked the minister that night as well why the hell
the prosecutors were not taking punitive action against those hordes
attacking not only outside court rooms, but in the courts as well,
against people being prosecuted under the contentious article on
grounds that they insulted "Turkishness."

But, as we were laying to rest our friend and colleague Hrant Dink,
it must be clear to everyone concerned for the future of democracy,
freedom of thought, freedom of press and of minority rights in this
country why we were demanding from the government in such "haste"
to either totally scrap or make radical amendments to Article 301.

Still, it was sad to see the justice minister declaring even on such a
sorrowful day that the last thing Turkey needed was to begin another
debate on Article 301, arguing that the matter should be discussed
in a more suitable atmosphere.

Sorry Cicek. … We are sorry to say but you are totally out of
tune with our people – some of whom turned out in thousands at the
funeral of Dink yesterday while others were glued to their TV sets
watching live coverage of the procession on all news channels –
who are shouting out loud their demand for wider freedom of thought.

Can’t you, Cicek, understand the message in the statement of Rachel
Dink yesterday when she underlined: "He parted from his loved ones;
from his children; from his grandchildren. … even from his life,
but did not part from his homeland." She was speaking after her
husband was made a target by Article 301. Do we have the luxury to
wait longer so that the contentious article produces other targets
for the death squads?

–Boundary_(ID_hZx8coU14WvY9dedNPO4Xg)–

http://www.turkishdailynews.com.tr/editorial.

Suspect in Journalist Death Makes Threat

Suspect in Journalist Death Makes Threat
By BENJAMIN HARVEY

Wednesday January 24, 2007 2:46 PM
Associated Press Writer

ISTANBUL, Turkey (AP) – A man who confessed to inciting the murder
of a prominent journalist shouted what appeared to be a threat
against another leading Turkish intellectual on Wednesday, the Nobel
Prize-winning novelist Orhan Pamuk.

"Orhan Pamuk, be smart! Be smart!" Yasin Hayal shouted as he was
being brought to an Istanbul courtroom with his hands cuffed behind
his back. Police quickly pressed Hayal’s head down to silence him
and led him away.

Hayal, a militant nationalist who served time in prison for a 2004 bomb
attack, confessed to inciting last week’s slaying of the influential
ethnic Armenian journalist Hrant Dink and to providing a gun and
money to the alleged killer, police said.

Hayal allegedly told the killer that Dink, who angered nationalists
by calling the mass killing of Armenians in the early 20th century
genocide, was "a traitor to his country who insults Turks."

The suspected triggerman, a teenager named Ogun Samast, confessed to
shooting Dink in a four-page statement given to prosecutors Wednesday,
and was formally charged with the murder, the state-run Anatolia news
agency reported.

Samast told police Hayal gave him money and a picture of the journalist
that he carried with him for several months, the news agency reported.

Dink, editor of the bilingual Turkish-Armenian newspaper Agos, had been
brought to trial numerous times for allegedly "insulting Turkishness,"
a crime under the notorious Article 301 of Turkey’s penal code.

Like Dink, Pamuk also faced trial in Turkey for commenting on the
killings of Armenians and had been accused of treason for doing so.
And like Dink, he said he received death threats and considered
leaving the country because of them.

Pamuk’s case was thrown out on a technicality, and he went on to win
the Nobel Prize in literature last year. He was the first Turk to
do so.

Dink’s murder inspired an outpouring of support for liberal values,
including freedom of expression, tolerance and reconciliation between
Armenians and Turks, with more than 100,000 people marching in his
funeral procession on Tuesday.

But Hayal’s comments raised fears that Turkey may continue to be a
dangerous place for intellectuals who openly express their ideas.

Most Turks suspect that the killer – who as a teenager will likely
receive a lessened prison sentence if convicted – may have ties to
ultra-nationalist groups.

Dink himself had said that he was being threatened by elements of the
"deep state," a term for a shadowy network inside the Turkish military,
intelligence and political circles that is believed to use clandestine
methods to defend the state against perceived threats.

Amid a period of national introspection, Dink’s family has called on
Turks to look at how they have permitted the creation of an atmosphere
that led to his killing.

Interior Minister Abdulkadir Aksu said the crime was carried out by
"circles who do not want Turkey to develop and reach the level of
prosperous and modern countries." Aksu condemned the attack, saying
it had no justification and was being "investigated in great detail."

TDN: Meet the Monster, Turkish Fascism

Meet the Monster: Turkish Fascism
Turkish Daily News
Wednesday, January 24, 2007
php?ed=mustafa_akyol

It is simply tragic and repulsive to see some prominent figures
in Turkey who insist on putting the blame on imagined ‘external
enemies.’ Alas, enough is enough, and it is time to be honest. What
we are facing is an internal enemy. And it deserves being called
‘Turkish fascism’

MUSTAFA AKYOL

Hrant Dink, a beacon of conscience and liberty, was shot dead on
Jan. 19. Since that black Friday, many Turks have shown the virtue
to condemn this heinous murder and cry out for the memory of this
noble man. Yet some of our "opinion leaders" have also invented
concealed plots against "the Turkish nation" behind this public
killing. This is, they rushed to conclude, a maneuver by "foreign
powers" and their intelligence services directed at putting Turkey
in a difficult situation in the international scene.

But lo and behold! The Turkish police caught the killer and he turned
out to be no agent of the CIA. Nor of Mossad, MI6, Mukhabarat, or some
People’s Army for The Liberation of The Turkish-Occupied Wherever. He
is neither Armenian nor Kurdish. He is, as his family proudly noted,
"of pure Turkish stock." Moreover, as he himself proudly noted, he
is a die-hard Turkish nationalist who killed Dink out of his zeal
for the "Turkish blood." It also turned out that the 17-year-old
apparatchik was directed by his elder "brothers" in Trabzon who
have an ugly history of nationalist violence. The city, after all,
is the citadel of ultra-nationalism: Catholic priest Father Andrea
Santoro was also shot there a year ago by a 16-year-old militant,
who had a profile very similar to his comrade who killed Dink.

In the face of all that, it is simply tragic and repulsive to see
some prominent figures in Turkey who insist on putting the blame on
imagined "external enemies." Alas, enough is enough, and it is time
be honest. What we are facing is an internal enemy. And it deserves
to be called "Turkish fascism."

Measuring the Turkish skull:

The term does not imply an organic link between Turks and the fascist
ideology. The latter is a modern disease that has influenced many
nations throughout the 20th century. Germans and Italians are the two
most obvious cases, of course, but there are countless others. Even
the quintessentially liberal Anglo-Saxons had their experience with the
monster. (Remember the Ku Klux Klan and the British Union of Fascists.)

In Turkey, the story of fascism is most ironic, because although our
contemporary fascists are fanatically anti-Western, the ideology is
an import from the West into the traditionally multicultural lands
of the great Ottoman Empire. It all began with the Social Darwinism
that some Young Turk intellectuals, such as Yusuf Akcura, acquired in
European capitals in the turn of the century. Their vision of a fully
Turkified state came true in the 1920’s, with the creation of the
Turkish Republic. Ataturk’s vision for this new state was not racist,
he instead defined Turkishness in terms culture and citizenship, but
things started to change in the ’30s. Fascist Italy and Nazi Germany
were admired by some of the Republican elite, such as Recep Peker,
the long-time general secretary of the CHP (the party, which is now
chaired by his intellectual descendant, Deniz Baykal.) The Turkey
of the ’30s also imitated corporatism, the economic model of fascist
Italy, and internalized Mussolini’s motto, "Everything for the State;
nothing outside the State; nothing against the State."

In the same period, "Turkishness" also acquired an ethnic meaning. An
officially sanctioned "scientific" congress was held in Ankara in 1932,
in which the "advanced" features of the "Turkish skull" was praised
and Turks were proudly declared to be "Aryans." During the same period,
public calls for applicants to government offices demanded them to be
"of the Turkish stock." Tevfik RuÅ~_tu Aras, the foreign minister,
affirmed, "Kurds will be beaten by Turks in the struggle for life." And
Mahmut Esat Bozkurt, the minister of justice, notoriously announced,
"In Turkey, non-Turks are the servants and slaves of Turks."

During the war years, Turkey also initiated the infamous Wealth Tax,
which was designed to confiscate the properties of its Christian
and Jewish citizens. 1942, the first and only Jewish labor camp was
established in AÅ~_kale, a district in Erzurum. Had the Third Reich
won the war, Turkey apparently would not have had much trouble fitting
into its "new order."

The hysteria on ‘internal enemies’:

Of course, Turkey never became fully fascist, but there is plenty of
evidence to argue that it was deeply influenced by that monstrous
ideology. But, alas, since Turkey never became fully fascist, it
never had the chance to fully liberate itself from it. Post-war
Germany, Italy and Japan started as tabula rasas, but Turkey had
only a partial transition to democracy. In 1950, the Democrat Party
(DP) came to power in the first free and fair elections since the
beginning of the republic, with the motto, "Enough, the nation has
the word!" But with a military coup in 1960, the DP was crushed by
despots in uniform, who did not hesitate to execute Prime Minister
Adnan Menderes and two of his ministers after a show trial.

Since then, fascism, not as a system but a spirit, has survived in
Turkey. The depiction of all other nations as "the enemies of Turks,"
the cult of personality built around the country’s founder, and the
deification of the state are all elements of that spirit. In recent
years, as a reaction to the EU-inspired push for more democracy and
freedom, the fascist rhetoric has ascended. Some elements of the media,
along with some pundits, bureaucrats and politicians, systematically
spread the fear that Turkey is facing existential threats. Kurds,
Armenians, Jews, Greeks, missionaries, non-nationalist Muslims —
anybody who falls outside the narrow definition of a "good Turk" —
are all seen as "internal enemies," who are in bed with the external
ones — the Europeans, the Americans, Iraqi Kurds, and, actually,
the whole world.

The militant who killed Dink is the product of this popular
hysteria. Unless we accept this bitter fact and start to think
seriously about our internal fascism, it is quite likely that Turkey
will produce more of them. "Nationalism is the last refuge of the
scoundrel," said Samuel Johnson. We should not tolerate becoming a
nation of scoundrels.

–Boundary_(ID_M0vwBQI3XmIEP68VaaQJZQ )–

http://www.turkishdailynews.com.tr/editorial.