Turkish Journalist Mourned Monday

All Headline News
Jan 24 2007

Turkish Journalist Mourned Monday

January 24, 2007 6:36 a.m. EST

Megan Shannon – All Headline News Staff Writer
(AHN) – The streets of Istanbul were flooded Monday with mourners of
Turkish-Armenian Journalist Hrant Dink, who was murdered last Friday.

The 53-year-old news editor was close to his office when he was
gunned down. He was known for his controversial writings on the
genocide of Armenians by Ottoman Turks during World War I.

Tens of thousands of people followed Dink’s coffin for five miles,
pausing at the spot where he was shot to applaud. They stopped at the
Armenian Orthodox church where Dink was buried.

During the funeral Dink’s widow said, "We are seeing off our brother
with a silent walk, without slogans and without asking how a baby
became a murderer."

Teenage suspect Ogun Samast confessed to the murder. Police have six
other suspects they are questioning at this time.

In defense of the indefensible

Statesman Journal, OR
Salem Statesman Journal, OR
Jan 24 2007

In defense of the indefensible

Inside the First Amendment

By CHARLES C. HAYNES
Gannett News Service

January 24, 2007

If any speech should be a crime, denying the Holocaust would be at
the top of my list.

That’s why it’s easy to understand the motivation behind Germany’s
announcement Jan. 8 that it will push for legislation that would
criminalize "Holocaust denial" throughout the European Union.

Germany, France and eight other European nations already have laws
that make denying the Holocaust punishable by prison sentences. Last
year, British author David Irving was convicted in Austria under one
such law and sentenced to three years in jail. (He was released in
December and is now on two years’ probation.)

Germany’s move to expand the ban on Holocaust denial comes in wake of
Iran’s one-sided conference "debating the Holocaust" in Tehran last
month. By giving credence to some of the most deluded and bigoted
Holocaust deniers in the world, Iran’s President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad
stirred outrage in Europe and elsewhere.

However well intentioned, Germany’s proposal is the wrong response to
this very ugly problem.

Criminalizing speech denying the Holocaust not only threatens free
speech – it gives power to the vile views it seeks to suppress.

Once Europe heads down the slippery slope of state censorship, where
will it stop?

Consider the French slide toward state censorship of speech. In 1990,
France passed a law punishing Holocaust denial with a year in prison
and a 45,000-euro fine. Last October, the lower house of the French
parliament added to the list of forbidden speech by passing a law
that would make it a crime to deny that Armenians suffered genocide
at the hands of Turks in 1915. The measure still needs Senate
approval.

While French Armenians celebrated the vote, Turkey reacted with
predictable anger – not in defense of free speech, but because Turkey
itself denies that any genocide against Armenians ever happened.

Turkey, which aspires to join the European Union, is already near the
bottom of the anti-speech slope. Not only can you go to jail for
calling the Armenian tragedy a genocide, but you also can be arrested
for any speech that insults the republic, parliament or any organs of
state.

In 2005, Turkish novelist Orhan Pamuk was put on trial for
questioning the official version of the mass killing of Armenians.
After intense international pressure, an Istanbul judge halted the
trial.

Meanwhile in Sweden, the Rev. Ake Green was convicted of "hate
speech" for preaching a sermon against homosexuality. Although the
Swedish Supreme Court acquitted Green in 2005, his trial provoked
worldwide concern about the use of hate-speech laws to limit freedom
of speech and religion.

Although the United States prides itself on strong protection for
freedom of speech under the First Amendment, we are not immune from
the temptation to censor unpopular speech. This is especially true on
college campuses where speech codes and anti-harassment policies are
frequently invoked to punish student and faculty speech.

And in the land of the free, we have plenty of ugly, repulsive speech
that pushes the limits of public support for robust free speech.
Exhibit A is the Rev. Fred Phelps and his small band of followers who
have incensed Americans with their protests at funerals of soldiers
killed in Iraq. Carrying inflammatory signs with anti-gay messages,
Phelps and Co. declare that the soldiers’ deaths are God’s punishment
for the nation’s support of gay rights.

Thanks to Phelps, some 27 states and the Congress have passed
legislation limiting protests at funerals. Critics of these laws
argue that they go beyond constitutionally permissible limitations on
such things as noise level and disorderly conduct by imposing overly
broad and vague restrictions on free speech and assembly.

By giving the state the power to ban the offensive speech of a few,
we give the state the power to limit the fundamental rights of us
all.

Moreover, state censorship doesn’t work. Putting people like David
Irving in prison only makes them martyrs of the extreme right.
Attempting to silence people like Fred Phelps only makes them media
magnets and pushes them to more outrageous behavior.

After Irving’s conviction, historian Deborah Lipstadt, whom Irving
unsuccessfully sued for libel in 2000, put it this way: "I am not
happy when censorship wins, and I don’t believe in winning battles
via censorship. … The way of fighting Holocaust deniers is with
history and truth."

It’s never easy (or pleasant) to defend the indefensible. But for
Europeans, Americans and people in any nation that would be free, the
familiar battle cry of free speech still applies: Fight bad speech
with good speech – not with state power.

Charles Haynes is a senior scholar for the Freedom Forum First
Amendment Center, 1101 Wilson Blvd., Arlington, VA 22209. Send e-mail
to [email protected].

ANKARA: Trabzon circle of suspects widens; Ogun Samast says "I am so

Trabzon circle of suspects widens; Ogun Samast says "I am sorry I killed him"

Hurriyet, Turkey
Jan 24 2007

17 year old Trabzon resident Ogun Samast, who has admitted to shooting
and killing journalist Hrant Dink in the Istanbul district of Sisli,
ended his 8 pages of testimony to prosecutors yesterday with the words
"I am very sorry that I killed Hrant Dink." Samast, who was first
observed by psychologists, went before the prosecutors to give his
version of the events surrounding the Friday afternoon murder.

Samast is not the only person in custody for the murder of Hrant Dink
at this point; Trabzon resident Yasin Hayal, who is thought to have
given Samast the gun and the orders to kill the Armenian journalist,
is also in police custody currently, as is Black Sea Technical
University student Erhan Tuncel, who is thought to be one of the
possible masterminds behind the plans. There are also several other
young men being questioned by the police, several of whom appear to
be linked with Tuncel, Hayal, and Samast.

While investigating the murder of Hrant Dink, the police have also
apparently stumbled upon important clues to last year’s murder of
the Italian priest, Andrea Santoro, which took place in Trabzon. Some
of the suspects in Dink’s murder have admitted to links to Santoro’s
killer.

ANKARA: ARTICLE: 1915-2007

24 Jan 07

ARTICLE: 1915-2007
by Ahmet Altan
gazetem.net
in English and Turkish original

"1915-2007" by Ahmet Altan

Nothing much has changed it seems.

They were murdered in 1915 as well…

They are being murdered in 2007 too…

What was being said about that massacre at the beginning of last
century.

"They killed us, and we killed them back."

What are we going to say about the murder of Hrant then?

That "Hrant killed us, and we killed Hrant back?"

Now that is not what we say, is it?

We say "traitors killed Hrant."

We do not see the murderers of Hrant as one of "us."

Why is it that "we" are the ones who ninety years ago killed
hundreds of thousands of people, without forsaking children, women,
elderly and babies, who decimated the Armenians, but we are not the
ones who killed Hrant?

What is the difference between the two?

The difference is that this time we saw the murder, that we have an
idea about the intentions of the murderer.

This time they did not "tell us" how the murder was
committed, we personally witnessed it ourselves.

If those who in this country "write" the history of 1915 had
also written the murder of Hrant, the children in this country
would have said fifty years later that "Hrant had killed us, and
we killed Hrant back."

The truth would have changed shape in the hands of the liars.

We did not kill Hrant.

Most probably some people who have ferreted their way into the state
had Hrant killed.

Their intention was for the world to react negatively to Turkey,
which would have escalated nationalism within the country in
response, leading to a break off from Europe.

In 1915 as well, "we" did not kill the Armenians.

Those poor people were not killed by "the ones ferreted inside the
state," but directly by the state itself.

A great massacre that was organized by the Unionists in government
was actualized.

The Armenians who were killed were Ottoman subjects.

They were a part of the Ottoman nation.

A part of the nation was utterly destroyed by the state.

"We" are the nation.

The ones who were killed were a part of "us."

Since each Turk who lives in this country see themselves not as a
"part of the nation" but rather a "part of the
state," however, they also own this massacre executed by the
state.

"They killed us, we killed them," they say.

Now that is a lie.

The Ottoman state, under the government of the Unionists killed, in
an organized manner, with the planning of the intelligence unit
entitled Special Organization (TeÅ~_kilat-ı Mahsusa), a "part
of us."

The murdered Armenians are a part of "us."

It is actually our duty to ask them to account for that murdered part
of us.

"We" ought to face this state and ask them "are you a
continuation of the Ottoman state," ask them "why do you own
up to the murder committed by a state you destroyed," ask them
"why don’t you yourself seek accountability for this
destruction by the state of a part of its nation and instead leave
this task to others."

Because "we" did not ask this, one of "us," Hrant
Dink, has now been murdered.

On top of it all, he, while still mourning for his ancestors, wanted
Turkey not to be trapped solely within the term "genocide,"
not to have the entire debate forced into a single word; he wanted
Turkey to be permiited to become democratized through uniting with
the world .

He was declared "an enemy of the Turks."

Hrant was no one’s enemy, he was not someone who could have been
a foe.

He was a friend.

And he was a friend to everyone.

Why is it that in this country those who are "for murders and
massacres" are accepted as a Turk while "those for
friendship, peace, justice and humanity" are regarded as foe.

Why is it that those who strive to equate the word "Turk"
with "death" are regarded as a "Turk"?

Are those who try to have an entire tribe declared as
"murderers" truly the friends of the Turks?

The Turkish populace owns up to the crimes of the old and new
"state" because it cannot grasp that it is the
"nation."

As it cannot grasp that it itself is the nation, it identifies
itself with the murderers instead and says "us."

My heart could never bear to have the sorrowful deaths of those
hundreds of thousands of people, the bloody tragedy that was
experienced to be lost within the vortex created by the term
"genocide."

Yet because we have not been able to move beyond that word, people
like Hrant are still being killed.

I think that now, in order to prevent new murders, iin order to stop
this country from being dragged to a dead end, it is up to us to move
beyond that word.

The Ottoman state killed hundreds of thousands of people solely
because they were "Armenians."

And today a hidden force kills Hrant for "being an
Armenian."

What are we going to call it if a person is being killed solely
because of their race or their religion?

It is up to "us," to this nation to ask for an accounting of
those who were killed.

Hrant’s death hurt you all deeply.

If you had witnessed what had happened in 1915, you would have been
likewise deeply hurt.

And you would not have said "they killed us, we kiled them."

You would have been ashamed.

Just as you wanted Hrant’s murderers to be found, you would have
wanted the murderers of those Armenians found as well.

With his death, Hrant made us remember that we are a nation, that we
should not identify ourselves with the murderers.

Then let us do what befits being a nation.

Who killed Hrant?

Who killed the Armenians in 1915?

They do not have to account for their actions to "others,"
they have to account to "us."

For we are the ones who have died.

The ones who died are a part of us.

–Boundary_(ID_IFR7XrGOICprnWTtz+sTdw)–

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

http://www.gazetem.net/ahmetaltan.asp

ANKARA: MHP(Nationalist Movement Party) leader Bahceli talks harsh

MHP(Nationalist Movement Party) leader Bahceli talks harsh

Sabah, Turkey
Jan 24 2007

MHP leader Devlet Bahceli said it has become a seriously dangerous
habit to declare the state guilty after every single incident occur
in Turkey.

In a press conference he organized in his party building on Wednesday,
Bahceli told press that Turkey is being left with no defense against
domestic or foreign provocations by other countries who want it to
become a weak and problematic society.

Bahceli said he believes that the Dink murder was one of the scenarios
that aim political chaos.

Stating that lies have mixed up with truths in Turkey Bahceli said:
"This psychological pressure environment which is full of provocations
and accusations is being used for political marketing.

Emotional and humanly reactions are being exploited in order to
slander the national values and sensitivity of the Turkish nation.

Turkey is going through a dark period. Killing of an Armenian citizen
of this country has appalled Turkey. We have to admit that Turkey
must take necessary lessons from this vile murder.

ANKARA: Three more detained over Dink murder

Three more detained over Dink murder

NTV MSNBC, Turkey
Jan 24 2007

Dink was laid to rest Tuesday, his funeral bringing tens of thousands
out onto the streets of Istanbul.

Guncelleme: 12:45 TSİ 24 Ocak 2007 CarşambaTRABZON/BURSA –
Three more people have been detained by Turkish police in connection
with the murder of Turkish-Armenian journalist Hrant Dink.

Two persons were taken into custody in the Black Sea city of Trabzon,
on the orders of the Istanbul Chief Prosecutor’s office, which is
conducting the investigation into Dink’s slaying last Friday.

A third person, identified by authorities as Muharrem K, aged 19,
was detained in the western city of Bursa before being transferred
to Istanbul for questioning, officials said.

At least ten people have been taken into custody over the killing of
Dink outside the offices of the Argos newspaper, including Ogun Samast,
a 17 year old from Trabzon who has admitted carrying out the murder.

Massive crowds, estimated by some officials as being 100,000, attended
a commemorative service for Dink in Istanbul Tuesday, before following
the hearse carrying his coffin to the Church of the Virgin Mary in
Kumkampi, where his funeral was held. Dink was later buried at the
Balikli Armenian Cemetery in the Istanbul district of Zeytinburnu.

Turkey: Thousands mourn slain editor

SomaliNet, Somalia
Jan 24 2007

Turkey: Thousands mourn slain editor
Wed. January 24, 2007 08:23 am.

by Bonny Apunyu

(SomaliNet) Sprits were low among thousands of Turks who gathered on
Tuesday in Istanbul to pay tribute to slain Turkish Armenian editor
Hrant Dink, whose murder has caused a lot of debate in Turkey.

On Tuesday morning, several mourners, many holding identical
black-and-white signs reading "We are all Hrant Dink" and "We are all
Armenians", gathered outside the Agos newspaper office where Dink was
shot three times in broad daylight last Friday.

Much of Istanbul was closed to traffic.

Ogun Samast, 17, has confessed to killing Mr Dink for "insulting"
Turks. A source said a nationalist militant friend of Samast has
admitted to police that he incited Samast to kill Dink.

"We are seeing off our brother with a silent walk, without slogans
and without asking how a baby became a murderer," Dink’s widow Rakel
told thousands of mourners.

The killing was viewed with concern abroad, where there is a large
and politically influential Armenian diaspora.

A more liberal attitude to national minorities is also one of the
demands of the European Union Turkey seeks to join.

Mr Dink, like dozens of other intellectuals, had been prosecuted for
his views on the massacres of Armenians by Ottoman Turks in 1915 a
very sensitive issue in Turkey.

An ominous slaying of a Turkish journalist

An ominous slaying of a Turkish journalist

Allentown Morning Call, PA
Jan 24 2007

Last year was the worst on record for news media casualties, according
to the International News Safety Institute: 167 journalists and 30
other news-gathering personnel died while trying to do their jobs
in 37 countries. The most recent, prominent example of a journalist
deliberately attacked for exercising freedom of the press occurred on
Friday in Istanbul, when Hrant Dink was shot dead outside the office
of his bilingual Turkish-Armenian weekly newspaper, Agos.

Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan condemned the shooting:
"A bullet was fired at freedom of thought and democratic life in
Turkey." Several thousand people marched from Mr. Dink’s newspaper
office to Taksim Square on Friday to protest. By Sunday, Turkish
news agencies reported the arrest of a teenage Turkish gunman who
reportedly gave prosecutors an extensive confession. However, the
teen might have been just a part of a conspiracy; at least 10 other
suspects were arrested in connection with the killing.

Lehigh Valley Local Links

Mobile News | Subscribe Online | Order Reprints There are several
complicated layers to this story, in addition to the loss of a
journalist with the courage to speak his mind on controversial
topics. Turkey has long refused to use the term "genocide" to describe
the deaths of Armenians beginning in 1915. Mr. Dink counted himself
among a growing number of Turks who want the government to admit that
leaders of the Ottoman Empire had directed the slaughter of Armenians,
and who want Turkey to become a full democracy.

The death of Mr. Dink might mobilize his supporters, who seek the
repeal of Article 301 of the Turkish penal code. Article 301 places
restrictions on a free press. Mr. Dink was convicted in 2005 of
insulting the Turkish identity in some of his articles and he received
a six-month suspended prison sentence.

Turkey must agree to a series of democratic reforms if it is to be
allowed to join the European Union. European resistance to Turkish
membership is growing, and the death of Mr. Dink will only fuel that
fire. Ironically, Mr. Dink viewed entry into the European Union as
the best way to strengthen democracy in Turkey.

"Orhan Pamuk, be smart, be smart!" he shouted.

Times Online, UK
Jan 24 2007

"Orhan Pamuk, be smart, be smart!" he shouted.

Murder suspect threatens Turkey’s Nobel laureate
Times Online and AP in Istanbul

A man suspected of directing the murder of the prominent Turkish
Armenian journalist, Hrant Dink, today appeared to threaten the life
of Orhan Pamuk, a Nobel laureate and Turkey’s best-known novelist.

The Anatolia news agency reported that Yasin Hayal, a nationalist
militant jailed for bombing a McDonald’s restaurant in 2004, called
out the threat as he was led handcuffed into a courtroom in Istanbul.

"Orhan Pamuk, be smart, be smart!" he shouted.

Turkish police have said that Mr Hayal has confessed to recommending
the murder of Dink, who was shot several times outside the offices of
Agos, the leading Turkish-Armenian newspaper he edited last week. Mr
Hayal is also accused of providing a gun and money to Ogun Samast, a
17-year-old who has confessed to the shooting.

Dink’s murder prompted an enormous silent procession in Istanbul
yesterday. Around 100,000 people filed through the city, holding
photographs and placards reading: "We are all Hrant Dink" and "We are
all Armenian" in recognition of the journalist’s commitment to
writing about the mass killing of Armenians by Turks at the end of
the First World War.

Both Mr Hayal and Mr Samast were in court this morning. The private
news station, NTV, reported that Mr Hayal called Dink a traitor to
his country.

Mr Pamuk, whose books are sold all over the world, became the first
Turk to win the Nobel prize for literature last year for a career of
writing in which he has tackled Turkey’s tense ambivalence towards
the West and its own competing nationalist and Islamic identities.

Although he is Turkish, rather than ethnically Armenian, Mr Pamuk has
much in common with Dink, and like the murdered journalist is a
leading liberal intellectual who has been prosecuted under Article
301 of Turkey’s penal code, which forbids writers from "insulting
Turkish identity".

Like Dink, who received dozens of death threats before his eventual
murder, Mr Pamuk has also written about the 1915-1917 massacre of the
Armenians and been threatened as a result.

Dink’s family has asked Turkey to use the journalist’s death to
prompt a national moment of reflection about how such violent
feelings could arise. The country’s Interior Minister, Abdulkadir
Aksu, said the killing was ordered by "circles who do not want Turkey
to develop and reach the level of prosperous and modern countries".

The Turkish Prime Minister, Recep Tayyip Erdogan, is expected to
visit Dink’s relatives later today.

[iso-8859-1] Robert Kocharian Receives Orthodox People’s Unity Inter

Robert Kocharian Receives Orthodox People’s Unity International Foundation Award

PanARMENIAN.Net
22.01.2007 17:00 GMT+04:00

/PanARMENIAN.Net/ January 21 a solemn awarding ceremony of the Orthodox
People’s Unity International Foundation for "Outstanding activities
for consolidation of unity of orthodox nations" took place in Moscow,
reports the Moscow Patriarchy press office.

The awarding ceremony was lead by Patriarch of Moscow and All Russia
Alexi II. This year the awards were handed to

-Armenian President Robert Kocharian for the contribution to the
development of the church-state relations;

-UN 6th Secretary General Butros-Butros-Gali for prominent personal
contribution to the promotion of Christian spiritual values;

-Gazprom Russian company for assistance in renaissance of the Russian
Orthodox Church and other churches throughout the globe.

The Armenian President is awarded as a consistent and active adherent
to extension of Christian influence within the modern society.