Half-hearted Condolences

Monthly Review, VA
Jan 28 2007

Half-hearted Condolences

by Kenan Erçel

Hard to tell which is more upsetting: Hrant Dink’s "unsurprisingly
shocking" murder, or the hypocrisies uttered by government officials
in his wake.

Once words of condolences and condemnation are quickly dispensed with
— in a monotone reminiscent of a computerized voice telling a caller
that "the number you have dialed is not in service" — the topic
invariably turns toward the pending vote on the Armenian Genocide
resolution in the US Senate. As if the real tragedy is not the
murder of Dink, but its inopportune timing! Evidently, those who
couldn’t bring themselves to celebrate Orhan Pamuk’s Nobel prize
cannot bring themselves, for the very same reasons, to grieve Dink’s
death.

This is much like the evasiveness of the royal family in the days
following Lady Di’s passing. But even in her foot-dragging, Queen
Elizabeth was a good deal more sincere than our Turkish officials;
Her Majesty appeared before the cameras only after the mounting
protests of her "subjects," and even then, patently reluctant,
unwilling. She was more like Putin in that regard. It took Putin
three days and insistent questioning by the foreign press to make a
public statement about Anna Politkovskaya, who was shot dead on
October 7, 2006 in the elevator of her building, no doubt in
retaliation for her outspokenness on the atrocities committed by the
Kremlin in Chechnya. And yet, even in his chilling blankness toward
the demise of Hrant Dink’s Russian counterpart, Putin was more honest
than his Turkish counterpart.

On the Turkish front, in contrast, words of sympathies and sorrow
galore, but the only genuine sentiment is the deep concern that the
repercussions of the event will jeopardize national interests abroad.
These are crocodile tears — like the ones that welled up in
Türkeş’s eyes back in the day, while reciting Nazım
Hikmet.1

Government officials are not alone in their half-hearted condolences.
The media pundits, who have always echoed their master’s voice, are
whistling the same tune. On a radio broadcast of CNN-Turk, veteran
journalist Oktay Ekşi repeated almost verbatim his Prime
Minister’s comments, making a point of noting, of course, that the
murder of his "peer" might play into the hands of the Armenian lobby.
Beginning his column with the exclamatory outburst "No, this can’t
be happening," the columnist and sports commentator, Hıncal
Uluç, reveals a couple of sentences later what is really rending his
heart: "From those striving to stir trouble in Turkey to those
seeking support for their Armenian thesis, there are so many out
there hoping to benefit from this death."

"Condolences," only short of finding Dink himself at fault for
putting the Republic of Turkey on the spot! I wish this were
hyperbole, but it is not. Remember the accusations of "provocation"
levelled at Aziz Nesin in the aftermath of the Madımak inferno,
which he had barely survived.2

So nauseating is the hypocrisy oozing out of these half-hearted
condolences that the frankness of those who openly shout out "good
riddance!" is almost preferable in comparison. Which is worse,
really: the audacity of the gunman shouting out threats in the
courtroom against the human rights activist Akın Birdal, while
being tried for taking multiple rounds of point-blank shots at Birdal
in his office, or the two-facedness of the powers that be who
prosecute the monsters of their own making? Had he also survived the
attempt on his life, wouldn’t Dink have been seeking justice from the
very authorities who had sentenced him to 6 months in prison for
denigrating Turkishness? Such is the sorry state of affairs in
Turkey.

We know from his latest writings and interviews that this last
punishment he was meted out under the infamous article 301 of the
Turkish penal code had devastated Hrant Dink. Even as bottomless an
optimism as his seemed depleted. Dink was taken to court for using
the phrase "venomous Turkish blood," by which he meant, the long
held, almost visceral animosity the Armenians harbor against Turks —
a hatred, he believed, Armenians should get out of their systems for
the sake of dialogue and reconciliation. Dink was calling Turkish
blood venomous only in the same sense that I called his murder "good
riddance" above, i.e., he wasn’t. But the court insisted on taking
the metaphor literally and out of context and found him guilty all
the same, despite the expert opinion of a commission of three
professors to the contrary. And we are supposed to believe that
those who made his life a Kafkaesque nightmare are now grieving Hrant
Dink’s death?

That being said, it wouldn’t be fair to chalk up all the faults to
the government officials and their high-fidelity echoes in the media.
For the onus of the tragic end that Dink met is on all of us who
didn’t help outnumber Kerinçsiz and his gang in front of the court
houses when it really mattered. I wish we could muster our
organizational skills for something other than funeral processions,
our resourcefulnness for something other than commemoration. Had
only one person for every thousand reader of Pamuk in Turkey, had
only a fraction of the masses at Dink’s funeral, showed solidarity
with the prosecuted/persecuted during their trials, maybe today. . .
.

Now the most poetic lines, the most poignant observations are of no
avail. And when he wrote "the pigeon-like timidity of my soul,"
Hrant Dink didn’t leave us much to say. And no, our sorrow, our pain
is not half-hearted, but most of us sound repentant these days.

1 The leader of the far-right, nationalistic party, MHP, and its
militant offshoot, "Grey Wolves," the late Alparslan Türkeş is
known to have quoted at a MHP congress from Nazım Hikmet, a
world-famous Turkish poet, who remained a committed communist all his
life and died in Russia in exile ("Hero or Traitor? Jon Gorvett
Reports from Istanbul on Celebrations to Mark the Birth of Nazim
Hikmet 100 Years Ago," 1 April 2002).

2 On July 2, 1993, a mob of furious fundamentalists laid siege to a
hotel (Madımak) in Sivas where the participants of the Pir
Sultan Abdal Culture Festival were staying, including Aziz Nesin, one
of the most published authors of Turkey. Nesin and his company were
targeted for Nesin’s Turkish translation of Salman Rushdie’s Satanic
Verses. As the security forces watched on, the mob set the hotel on
fire, as a result of which 37 people — mostly Allevite, leftist
poets, singers, performers — died ("Madimak Tragedy Commemorated on
13th Year," 14 September 2006).

Kenan Erçel, a Turkish citizen, is a graduate student in economics at
the University of Massachusetts, Amherst. He is also a member of the
editorial collective of the journal Rethinking Marxism.

http://mrzine.monthlyreview.org/ercel270107.html

A story for our times: Blessed Charles de Foucauld

Spero News
Jan 28 2007

Commentary:
A story for our times: Blessed Charles de Foucauld

It was at that time that he came to admire the exotic Islam of the
desert and, for a time, according to his early biographer, even
considered converting to that religion

by TCR

Many Catholics today have heard—at least in outline— the story of
the "Universal Brother," Charles de Foucauld (1858-1916), the
Frenchman who, after living the life of an aristocratic dandy as a
youth, with all that that entails, at age 28 encountered Jesus Christ
in a life-changing way and would eventually spend the rest of his
life in imitation of Jesus in service to Muslims of the Touareg tribe
in Tamanrasset, in the midst of the Sahara desert, southern Algeria.

Charles had previously been acquainted with the austere beauty and
mystery of the desert through French army life, and, after his first
unsuccessful tour, he won a measure of fame by mapping uncharted
territory in Morocco, being awarded a medal for the work by the
French Geographic Society. It was at that time that he came to admire
the exotic Islam of the desert and, for a time, according to his
early biographer, even considered converting to that religion; but
with more experience he was later glad he did not, even if his love
for the people—not a few of whose ancestors were Christians before
being conquered—- never wavered, but only increased in radically
new ways.

Dr.Marcellino D’Ambrosio in a brief sketch of Foucauld’s life, writes
at his website:

His insistence that his mistress Mimi accompany him to social events
for other officers and their wives earned him the contempt of his
colleagues, leading to his defiant resignation from the military.
While living among the Muslim population of North Africa, he had
developed a fascination with Islam and the Koran, but nevertheless
remained an agnostic.
Once back in his native France, he embarked on a religious quest that
led him frequently to stop in Catholic Churches to make this prayer:

"God, if you exist, let me know it."

Finally, in 1886, he experienced a profound conversion to Christ,
went to confession, and began discerning a vocation to some sort of
religious life. In 1888, he visited the Holy Land, and developed a
profound love of Nazareth and devotion to the hidden, ordinary life
of Mary, Joseph and Jesus. In 1890, he entered the French Trappist
Abbey of Our Lady of the Snows. Not long after, he was assigned to a
monastery in Syria where his work was to supervise a crew of Muslim
manual laborers who worked for the monastery. He realized at this
point that he was called not to be a boss, but a servant and laborer
himself, to be last as Jesus was, not first."

Missionary

Brother Charles, as mentioned, tried to live the Trappist monastic
life for some seven years but in time felt called to greater poverty
and identification with Christ’s poor. Like His Lord he wanted to
serve the poorest and, imitating Christ’s hidden years at Nazareth,
to manual labor and suffer with them, offering them the incomparable
Hope of One who was more than a mere prophet and Greater than Abraham
(Jn 1:1, 8:58; cf Exo 3:14, & more). With permission, then, he chose
a quasi-eremitical life (life as a hermit) amidst the Touareg in
Tamanrasset during the French colonial period.

Above all he wanted to be a witness to Jesus in serving the poor,
imitating the Word made flesh (Jn 1:1), the God-man who therefore was
the fulfillment of all the prophets; he wanted to ensure the
salvation of the Muslims, who he was convinced must accept Jesus
again in the biblical sense (Jn 1:12), and who had departed from the
way of the prophets and the teachings of Christ.

Brother Charles wanted this witness to be with his life more than
with his words. And to that end he spent decades opening his door to
the hungry, clothing the naked, giving drink to the thirsty, and,
being a proficient linguist, painstakingly assembling a
French-Touareg, Touareg-French dictionary.

The Colonial Project

While there is no question that Brother Charles was often critical of
French colonial rule—the proto-globalization of his day—he by no
means opposed it.

In Ali Merad’s book Christian Hermit in an Islamic World: A Muslim’s
View of Charles de Foucauld (Paulist Press, 1975) the translator, Zoe
Hersov, says of Foucauld, "His devotion to the army and to the ideal
of French supremacy never wavered". (P.82). That is because the
Universal Brother widely observed the Islamic civilization in his day
which he was acquainted with to be a brutal reality and came to
believe its desert forms were especially "babarous" compared to
Christianity at the roots. Some of his later followers, like Louis
Massignon, tried to sanitize this conviction of the holy hermit by
confusing their own changed politics with the spirituality of
Foucauld, but as, Merad suggests, it is unconvincing.

This is clear especially in the light of spiritual projects initiated
by Brother Charles himself precisely for the conversion of Muslims
which Massignon later suppressed. Projects like the Easter 1908
Confraternity dedicated to the Sacred Heart called the Catholic
Colonial Union (updated in 1914), which in its 9 planks explicitly
asked Catholics to dedicate themselves through prayer, good works,
and alms for the "conversion" of Muslim’s who he saw as lost souls,
strangers to the true God of biblical revevelation—people who had
departed from the Way or never known it— and who desperately needed
conversion back to Jesus. Those who quote a few later secondary or
Protestant sources to the contrary miss or are offended by the
essence of Charles de Foucauld. He was a missionary, but knew that,
especially with Muslims, education must come first.

"It is necessary," he told a friend, on June 4, 1908, "for the whole
continent to be covered with monks, nuns, and good Christians
remaining in the world to make contact with these poor Muslims, to
draw them in gently, to educate and civilize them, and finally, to
make them Christians. With Muslims you cannot make them Christians
first and then civilize them; the only possible way is the other,
very much slower one: to educate and civilize first, and then
covert…" (ECR. Spir. quoted by Merad, ibid P.61)
Merad says "Like other liberal and idealistic minds of his
generation, Charles de Foucauld identified the colonial enterprise
with a mission of human emancipation and civilization" (ibid). He
also writes, "…he had a preference for a "democratic" policy
conceived in the interest of the common people, the working classes,
rather than the privileged class of nobles and ajwad, that Muslim
chivalry who were more in love with glory than fortune, and for whom
the code of honor took the place of moral and political law" (P.62).

When Brother Charles looked around him he saw, besides deep piety,
warring tribes, "addicted to raiding and feuding, [who] were known to
the French for their cunning and treachery" (ibid. Translator’s
forward p. 5). All the more reason for these peoples to see Jesus in
the French and not corruption or sheer dominance. There was no end to
Charles de Foucauld’s urging that Christian virtues be seen in the
colonial forces in order to attract the Muslims he was patient to
convert, rather than to stir up their natural desert wrath. He was
often disappointed in this.

It was a burning love and desire for the salvation of souls which
supremely motivated Foucauld; the colonial project was useful as a
"civilizing influence" on desert dwelling peoples. But salvation came
through Jesus Christ, the Sacred Heart, His teachings and Church,
without which all would come to nothing. He was convinced Muslims
were steeped in grave errors which gave rise to barbarity too often.
It was the salvation of the people—and not just political peace—
for which he lived, prayed, suffered. He knew that the work of
conversion might take "centuries" but it would be necessary for
Christians to show Jesus Christ if it were ever to happen at all.

A Difficult Matter

Colonialism is a difficult matter today and charged with controversy,
however one looks at it. But whatever its faults, and even at times
crimes, it gave as much as it took. This is not acnowledged often
enough in our time, however wrongheaded colonialism may have been. It
was its "taming" influence that Merad says made it a valuable
preparation for the Gospel in Charles’ eyes. He saw Armenian
Christians massacred by the Turks, and in Beni Abbes he saw outright
slavery practiced by Muslims, according to Charles Lepeitt.

Yet Foucauld knew Christians must enter into the self-emptying love
of Jesus for sinners if Muslims were to see Him in them. To see, more
than hear. He wrote in a letter:

With goodness and kindness, brotherly affection, a virtuous example,
with humility and tenderness which are always impressive and
Christian…To some without ever saying to them a word about God or
religion, being patient as God is patient, being good as God is
good…speaking of God as much as they are able to take; Above all to
see in every human being a son of God, a person redeemed by the blood
of Jesus…We have to get rid of a domineering spirit…What a
difference there is between Jesus’ way of acting and talking and the
domineering attitude of those who are not Christians, or who are bad
Christians…" (ibid. Lepetit, 103)
This is what it meant to be Universal Brother. Adoration of the
Blessed Sacrament, Liturgy, prayer, the works of mercy, that was the
way men are converted, according to Charles de Foucauld, "without
books and without words".

Danger

In Tamanrasset Brother Charles lived amidst many dangers always. He
was considered an "infidel" and "savage" by many of the Muslims
there, except for those he directly helped and who experienced his
Christic way, and they were not a few. Moreover he was loyal to the
French army and to the colonial project which to many Muslims meant
he was a spy. That, of course, could mean death—even a horrible
death—at any minute. Charles Lepitetit said Brother Charles knew
well those Muslims whose idea of glory "was to die with one’s weapons
in one’s hand against the enemies of God," those "who wanted no mercy
for infidels". Some of these cases were extreme, even for the
Universal Brother who was used to the desert. There were those whom
he considered outright pirates and demanded the French army summarily
shoot upon locating, "without any kind of trial," and not take
prisoner. Charles was a peacemaker but not a pacifist. (ibid,
Lepetit, p.93).

Ever since his conversion he prayed for the grace of martyrdom for
the sake of the people he loved. In the end he seems to have been
killed by a Muslim bandit’s gun. That would have been good enough for
Charles de Foucauld who, like His Lord, prayed to offer His blood for
those souls who opposed him.

48

http://www.speroforum.com/site/article.asp?id=76

This Armenian Offers a Potato in Every Pot

The Moscow Times, Russia
Jan 29 2007

This Armenian Offers a Potato in Every Pot
By Matthew Collin

These are high times for the man they call Dodi Gago. He’s rumored to
be the richest person in Armenia, his political party is riding high
in the opinion polls ahead of parliamentary elections later this
year, and he’s been voted the most popular man in Armenia in two
separate opinion polls.

His real name is Gagik Tsarukyan, although many Armenians know him
better by his nickname. He’s a former arm-wrestling champion, the
winner of the world title in 1998; a hunk of beef and muscle who,
despite the fact that he’s now over 50, can still get away with
flaunting it in a skin-tight T-shirt. He got his start in what’s
known as animal husbandry, then set up a string of businesses in
Armenia that have brought him fabulous wealth and the kind of
palatial hilltop villa that are the dream of wannabe post-Soviet
oligarchs.

His business empire has continued to expand rapidly, and it probably
seemed logical to set up a political party to consolidate his
position. Prosperous Armenia, it’s called, although its main support
comes from those who are far from prosperous. Tsarukyan came up with
a winning strategy to get the public on his side: hand out free
potatoes in poor rural villages.

OK, so it’s not exactly high-level political discourse, but it seemed
to work, if the party’s own claims are to be believed. Although it
was only founded last year, Prosperous Armenia says it now has more
members than any other political group in the country. A recent poll
asked people which prominent Armenian, current or historical, would
be the most suitable national hero or leader today. A dead man topped
the poll, but Tsurukyan led the pack of the living.

Uncharitable critics, of course, have denigrated Dodi Gago’s
philanthropic benevolence, saying that the millions he’s spent on
potatoes, wheat and free medical care for the poor amount to nothing
more than vote buying on a massive scale — even describing it as
"potato democracy." As Tsurukyan himself put it: "They are just
condemning a person who is getting things done." There have also been
accusations that his pro-government party is just a lightly disguised
vehicle to boost the power of his ally, President Robert Kocharyan,
and to help Kocharyan maintain his influence after he leaves office
in 2008.

Others have suggested that the fact that Armenians can’t seem to
resist the charm of a super-rich strongman carrying a sack full of
free potatoes says something about the state of Armenian democracy.
How many of them would dare say it to the musclebound tycoon’s face,
however, is a different matter.

Matthew Collin is a journalist in Tbilisi.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Shining the spotlight on interfaith cinema

DePaulina, IL
Jan 28 2007

Shining the spotlight on interfaith cinema

by Alexandra Klimczak
Staff Writer

The interfaith scholars present a new program that aims to attract
the film enthusiast, faith scholar, student and faculty member alike
with their carefully-chosen cinematic gems.

The DePaul Student Interfaith Council and student interfaith scholars
based in University Ministry introduced film screenings this quarter.
The Interfaith Film Society is part of the University Ministry’s
intefaith ministry program, which aims to "foster opportunites for
religious understanding, dialogue, and celebration among the
different faith communities on campus, and seeks to build a strong
intercollegiate network of interfaith leaders.
Taking place once each week, the film screenings provide an
opportunity for students to experience different cultures and eras
from multiple perspectives.

Meetings are held at 7 p.m. on Wednesdays. The films are screened on
the Lincoln Park campus in the Schmitt Academic Center, Room 254. The
next film screening and discussion will be held Jan. 31 and is on
Sergei Parajanov’s "Color of Pomegranates."

Sofiko Chiaureli stars in this production made in 1969 based on the
life of Armenian poet, Sayat Nova.

The closing film for the quarter will showcase an American director
that challenged many social norms of the early 1900s.
T.J. Bigbee, a senior religious studies student and an interfaith
scholar explained that the nature of meetings is to "bring together
people as a catalyst for dialogue." He refers to a fellow organizer
as being the passion

behind the project.

This coordinator, Hunter Seamons, a 2004 DePaul alumnus with
concentrations in acting and religious studies planned the
screenings. Seamons is now a graduate student at DePaul. The group
was started as a way to combine his passion for film and the
interfaith mission.
The new program introduces an expanded approach alongside the recent
initiative to promote interfaith discourse. After researching other
ministry activities, Seamons wanted to create a group that could
introduce art as a medium of faith discussion.

According to Seamons, "The films have been chosen to be powerful
experiences."
He explains that the screenings provide two opportunities for active
intercultural thought. This experience is not solely for the
religious, but rather can help anyone "explore through the eyes of
the other."
Although the current meetings have seen modest turnouts, the group
has the potential for consistent growth. The screenings utilize both
the filmmaker and the viewpoints of the present veiwers to build
knowledge and understanding of both differences and similarities.
The group’s mission to bring together people of diverse backgrounds
carries on through their work with other interfaith organizations,
including the interfaith ministries on campus.

These groups include the Niagara Foundation, which works to spread
diversity throughout the city and the Interfaith Youth Core.
The Interfaith Youth Core is an organization that "seeks to build a
movement that encourages religious young people to strengthen their
religious identites, foster inter-religious understanding and
cooperate to serve the common good," according to a link on the
Interfaith Film Society’s Web site.

The Interfaith Film Society’s future film screenings include "The
Wild Blue Yonder," which will be shown Feb. 7 in the Student Center,
2250 N. Sheffield Ave. Room 316; "The Gospel According to St.
Matthew," will be shown on Feb. 14. "Ikiru" will be shown on Feb. 21.
Charlie Chaplin’s 1920’s black and white silent classic "The Kid"
will cap the screenings for this quarter.

Events are open to all people. Discussion of the films presented is
open to students, faculty members, and anyone who wishes to pose new
perspectives to the group.
The Student Interfaith Scholars encourage open discussion and
questions concerning many of their programs.
The student interfaith scholars welcome any inquiry into the
interfaith initiative or questions concerning details of the
Interfaith Film Society.

More information about the Interfaith Film Society can be found on
the University Ministry Web site,
The Interfaith Film Society
also has a Facebook group.

25&sectid=2

http://www.thedepaulia.com/story.asp?artid
www.studentaffairs.depaul.edu/ministry.

Damascus: Syria and Armenia to boost economic ties

SANA – Syrian Arab News Agency, Syria
Jan 28 2007

Syria and Armenia to boost economic ties

Sunday, January 28, 2007 – 10:10 PM

DAMASCUS, (SANA) – Minister of Economy and Trade Dr. Amer Hosni lutfi
discussed with Armenian Deputy Foreign Minister Gegham Gharibjanian
on Sunday the economic, trade and investment relations connecting the
two countries and ways of developing them.

Minister Lutfi stressed that Syria’s openness to world
economy is part of the economic reforms the country has recently
been witnessing, stressing the necessity of enhancing the bilateral
ties between Syria and Armenia in all economic and trade fields.
"Both countries have great possibilities for improving their joint
cooperation," he added.

The Syrian Minister clarified that the Syrian-Armenian
Joint Committee scheduled to be held next March will touch upon
several topics that contribute in increasing the trade exchange
between the two countries.

"Several agreements are to be signed in order to
facilitate cooperation between businessmen from both countries and
create an appropriate investment environment between the two
countries," Lutfi said.

He pointed out to the main and important role that
businessmen and private sectors in both countries can play to enhance
the joint cooperation between them, expressing his Ministry’s
readiness to push this cooperation forward.

For his part, Mr. Gharibjanian expressed his country’s
desire to develop the economic cooperation ties with Syria, stressing
the necessity of making the joint economic committee’s meeting during
its forthcoming session a success.

A.Zeitoun / Zahra

Baby steps for democracy

The Calgary Herald (Alberta)
January 28, 2007 Sunday
Final Edition

Baby steps for democracy

The Turkish response to the assassination of writer Hrant Dink has
been encouraging.

"We are all Hrant Dink," said the protesters’ signs. It looks as if
the people of Turkey are ready to defend their freedom.

There is little doubt Hrant Dink was killed because of his opinions.

He was shot to death on Jan. 19 in Istanbul. He was the editor of a
Turkish-Armenian newspaper, who spoke his mind about the 1915
massacres of Armenians.

The Turkish authorities have arrested a 17-year-old and say they
suspect the teenager was incited by nationalist militants.

Turkey has yet to come to terms with its history, and there is
tension between ethnic Armenians and ethnic Turks. In such a climate,
one might have expected the assassination of a prominent advocate to
inflame sectarian divisions.

That hasn’t happened. There have been large and peaceful protests.
Non-Armenians carried signs that read, "We are all Armenian." Crowd
estimates from Dink’s funeral procession have been 100,000 mourners.

This is an encouraging sign that the people of Turkey want to live in
a secular, pluralist and free society. As for the Turkish government,
the signs are not as clear. Despite the official display of mourning,
it must not be forgotten that Turkish law makes it a crime to
"insult" Turkey and its national character.

This law has led to charges against several writers, including Dink.
It may have been a misguided teenager who shot him, but it is the
government that is willing to send writers to jail for using the word
"genocide" in the context of the Armenian massacres.

When Turkish police brought a nationalist into a courtroom to face
charges in the Dink case, he yelled that Orhan Pamuk had better watch
out. Pamuk is the Turkish writer who won the 2006 Nobel literary
prize. He, too, has been charged with insulting Turkishness, although
his case was thrown out on a technicality. The state is sending mixed
signals to nationalist zealots.

Turkey’s policy of harassing its best writers is an embarrassment to
a country that wants to be seen as worthy of inclusion in the
European Union.

Most writers, and especially journalists, work to keep governments
accountable. In return, citizens will pressure their governments to
respect the press. In China, outcry over a journalist beaten to death
at a coal mine has caused President Hu Jintao to become personally
involved in the investigation.

Canadian Journalists for Free Expression puts the number of
journalists killed last year at 82 and calls 2006 the most deadly
year on record for journalists.

Freedom of expression is the first freedom; without it, Turkey cannot
reach its potential.

The martyrdom of Hrant Dink

The Halifax Daily News (Nova Scotia)
January 28, 2007 Sunday

The martyrdom of Hrant Dink

by Gwynne dyer

When they buried Hrant Dink in Istanbul last Tuesday, more than
100,000 Turks came to his funeral, filling the streets and chanting
"We are all Armenians." There is a war going on for the soul of
Turkey, but at least a lot of Turks are on the right side.

Dink, who called himself "an Armenian from Turkey and a good Turkish
citizen," was murdered because he insisted on talking about the great
crime that happened in the country 92 years ago: the mass murder of
most of Turkey’s Armenian population in eastern Anatolia. The
newspaper he founded and edited, a bilingual Turkish-Armenian weekly
called Agos, had only a small circulation, but his outspoken
editorials had made him one of Turkey’s most famous journalists – and
a target for assassination.

His killer, 17-year-old Ogun Samast, was a semi-educated thug from
Trabzon in the far north-east of Anatolia. He was given the gun by
older ultra-nationalists including Yusuf Hayal, who was convicted of
bombing a McDonald’s restaurant in Trabzon in 2004. But these
marginal characters are just pawns in the larger war between those
who want a more democratic, tolerant Turkey and those who are
desperately defending the power and privileges of the old
"republican" elite.

‘Dirty blood’

Samast shot Dink from behind in the street in front of his newspaper
office. "I feel no remorse," the killer allegedly told investigators.
"He said that Turkish blood was dirty blood."

Of course, Dink never said any such thing. What he said, in a
newspaper article addressed to his fellow Armenians, was that their
obsession with the massacres of 1915 to ’17 was having "a poisonous
effect on your blood."

But it’s easy to see how a useful idiot like Samast could have
believed that Hrant Dink was an enemy of the Turks, because just over
a year ago a Turkish court took that phrase out of context, found
Dink guilty of "insulting Turkishness," and gave him a six- month
suspended sentence under Article 301 of the Criminal Code. A number
of other Turkish citizens, including Nobel Prize-winning author Orhan
Pamuk, have been prosecuted under the same law for daring to discuss
what happened to the Armenians, and most of them have received death
threats, too.

It really is a kind of war, and the villains of the piece are
precisely the army officers, judges and senior civil servants who
were once seen as the guardians of the "republican" tradition, the
people who were going to modernize and democratize Turkey.
Unfortunately, "republican" doesn’t really mean the same as
"democratic."

The forms of the Turkish republic were democratic from the start, but
for a very long time the reality was a mass of illiterate peasants
under the harsh tutelage of a narrow educated elite who were
determined to Westernize the country.

The "republican" elite rewrote history (including the denial of the
Armenian massacres) in order to mould a new Turkish national
consciousness, and saw religion as a retrograde force that must be
banned from politics.

The decades passed, and much of the elite’s dream came to pass.
Turkey today has a per capita income higher than Romania or Bulgaria,
the most recent countries to join the European Union. Democracy is a
reality, and the current prime minister, Recep Tayyib Erdogan, leads
a party whose members openly refer to themselves as "Muslim
Democrats." Under Erdogan, there has been a wave of legal and
administrative reforms designed to qualify Turkey for EU membership.
But all this threatens both the rigidly secular ideology and the
autocratic privileges of the old republican elite.

>From their powerful positions in the army, the judiciary and the
bureaucracy, they work to undermine the reforms and to wreck Turkey’s
chances of joining the EU. In de facto alliance with ultra-
nationalist right-wing parties that also oppose EU membership, they
incite hatred of minorities, bring false prosecutions against the
advocates of a more open and democratic Turkish society, and pursue
the long-term goal of destabilizing the democratic order.

But the war is not over yet, and the good guys have not lost. Foreign
Minister Abdullah Gul vowed last November to change or abolish
Article 301, and last week 100,000 Turks thronged streets of Istanbul
to mourn the country’s best-known Armenian and condemn his murderers.

Gwynne Dyer is a London-based independent journalist whose articles
are published in 45 countries.

The death of a hero

Ottawa Citizen
January 28, 2007 Sunday
Final Edition

The death of a hero

by David Warren, The Ottawa Citizen

Hrant Dink, a Christian Turk of Armenian extraction, was the editor
of Agos, a prominent weekly in Istanbul. He campaigned fearlessly for
recognition in Turkey of historical facts surrounding the forced
expulsions and massacres of Armenians in 1915-17, when the "Young
Turks" governed the collapsing Ottoman Empire. He also campaigned for
Turkish-Armenian reconciliation, thus earning the enmity of radicals
on both sides. And he campaigned for open democracy.

Last year, he was tried and convicted under Article 301 of the
Turkish penal code, for "insulting Turkishness." That is an article
that has been used repeatedly to silence discussion of the Armenian
holocaust. He wrote in his newspaper of the pain he felt, at being
taken as an enemy of his own country. Also of the pain of receiving
constant death threats and having to behave like a pigeon, "always
alert, looking right, left, in front, behind."

Hrant was gunned down on Jan. 19. Ogun Samast, a 17-year-old high
school dropout, has confessed the murder, declaring that Hrant had
"dirtied Turkish blood." Turkish police have made several further
arrests, for the boy was obviously not acting entirely on his own.

>From an account of the funeral, by an eyewitness in Istanbul:

"It started with a memorial service in the street in front of the
Agos offices. His widow gave a passionate speech, written in the form
of a letter to her husband. Speaking of the killer, she wrote, ‘We
know he was once a baby. Without questioning the darkness that can
turn a baby into a killer, nothing will change.’ She also quoted John
15:13: ‘No one can have greater love than to lay down his life for
his friends.’

"In spite of being surrounded by tens of thousands of people, during
much of the service a white dove stayed on top of the black vehicle
that held Hrant’s coffin."

This last is the sort of detail journalists instinctively delete from
copy, since it will be disputed no matter how many witnesses there
were. (The dove was one of many released at the funeral.) But the
fact that, according to Turkish press, as many as 100,000 walked the
eight-kilometre route of the procession is itself remarkable. And the
fact that many chanted, "We are all Armenians!" in Turkish, when they
were mostly Turks, must serve to remind my reader that no country can
be painted in one colour.

The Columbia Journalism Review has described Turkish penal code 301
as "a law that stinks of suppression of speech." For once I agree
with the CJR. And yet before we think, smugly, that we do not have
such laws in the West, we must look at the whole tendency of
"political correctness," which is to stink in like manner.

Everywhere I can see, we are losing the finest achievement of
liberalism. Not of "gliberalism," as I call it — the degenerate
child of liberalism, which embraces its forms and denies its content
— but of the fine tradition itself, of opening rat’s nests of state
and clerical privilege, and exposing human claims to free enquiry.

True liberalism originated in the impulse to tell the truth, and in
so doing, "vindicate the ways of God to man."

Free speech in all its forms, including freedom of the press,
airwaves, and web, is something beyond law that goes into the dye and
fabric of a society. It is not licence, and it dies when it becomes
licentious. It exists, while it survives, for a purpose — "that we
may know the truth, and the truth will set us free." Free speech
exists so that the truth may be defended, and so that ugly lies,
dressed up as pretty platitudes and plausibilities, can be exposed
and destroyed.

Hrant was a true hero of journalism — though few of his licentious
colleagues around the world will ever remember his name or care for
his mission. The massacre of around 1.5 million Armenians is not
something that will ever stay swept under a Turkish carpet.

Its denial by Turkish nationalists and Muslim chauvinists can serve
no honest cause. Lies serve only lies.

Yet freedom is indivisible. Hrant had last made news in October, when
he attacked a French parliamentary bill that would have made denial
of the Armenian holocaust a criminal offence. He called this the flip
side of the coin, and said: "Those who restrict freedom of expression
in Turkey and those who try to restrict it in France are of the same
mentality."

David Warren’s column appears Sunday, Wednesday and Saturday.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Soapbox: Holocaust day

Bristol Evening Post, UK
January 27, 2007 Saturday

Soapbox: Holocaust day

This is a polite reminder that today is Holocaust Day, which in my
opinion ought to be renamed Genocide Day, especially when one
considers the situations in Iraq, Afghanistan, Chechnya, Palestine
and, lest we forget, Africa (Rwanda, The Congo and Darfur spring to
mind).

Genocide is defined in the dictionary in unambiguous terms as "the
deliberate extermination of a racial, religious or ethnic group". A
more expanded definition comes with the following quote from the
Peace Pledge Union website: "It is mass murder deliberately planned
and carried out by individuals, all of whom are responsible whether
they made the plan, gave the order or carried out the killings.

"Whatever its scale, genocide is made up of individual acts and
individual choices to perform them. So human individuals need to make
the commitment, as early in life as possible, that they will have no
truck with it."

Almost without question, the Holocaust – to sacrifice by fire – (or
Shoa) was the worst example of this kind of barbarism and organised
mass murder. The fact that it was so organised and meticulously
carried out makes it so. Sadly, it is not unique in history.

Millions of Congolese were murdered by the Belgian imperialists under
the stewardship of King Leopold the second.

The British incarcerated and starved hundreds of thousands of Boers
during the Boer War, the British army effectively invented the
concentration camp.

In 1915, the Young Turks organised the extermination of at least
million Christian Armenians.

By 1900, the Native American Indians were practically eradicated from
a population of at least three million.

In 1904, the German imperialists murdered 65,000 members of the
Namibian Herero tribe from an initial population of 80,000.

In 1932, enforced collectivisation of the Ukrainian farmers resulted
in the deaths of at least seven million people and another 10 million
were deported to Siberia as slave labour.

At least 100,000 Cambodians were killed as a direct result of US B52
bombing – this catastrophe helped Pol Pot take control. The Khmer
Rouge (which the US backed in its war with Vietnam) systematically
slaughtered, tortured and starved at least three million people.

This is by no means an exhaustive list, and I have tried to convey
balance – no one country or geographic block is guilt-free.

This leads me to believe that it is a system of deliberate policies
that allow it all to happen.

The great US historian Howard Sinn hits the nail on the head, saying:
"The memory of the Jewish holocaust should not be kept isolated from
other atrocities in history. To remember what happened to the six
million Jews serves no important purpose unless it arouses
indignation, anger and action against all atrocities anywhere in the
world."

So, dear reader, if you are anything like me, you are appalled about
the general state of our beautiful world today, sick of seeing
killing versus helping. You think that it is a crime that recent
Pentagon disclosures show the US military alone is spending 320
million a day solely on Iraq and Afghanistan, with no discernable
improvements for those we are supposed to be helping. In fact, by any
benchmark, things are worse than they were before "liberation". You
think it is an obscenity that our UK establishment is even
considering spending £25 to £75 billion on the Trident replacement,
yet is shutting hospitals and selling off services that could be run
for decades if not centuries for the same money.

In short, you are appalled by our reality and disgusted by the lack
of progress in terms of "sorting things out".

Look at the solutions put forward by the establishment to deal with
climate change, world hunger, Aids, and poverty across the world – do
you think they are going to work?

I believe that in a global context these sorts of issues taken as a
whole constitute a crime against humanity, as it is all so
unnecessary and tragic.

Today is about giving some time to reflect on our situation. More
importantly, it is about taking action and saying words to the effect
of "I’m not standing for this any more."

Mark Plummer, Knowle.

We won’t forget Holocaust victims

Bristol Evening Post, UK
January 27, 2007 Saturday

We won’t forget Holocaust victims

This small pile of polished rocks was the centrepiece of a ceremony
to remember victims of the Holocaust.

At some Jewish funerals, it is practice to bring rocks instead of
flowers and build a cairn to remember the dead.

But at yesterday’s memorial event at the Victoria Rooms in Queens
Road, the pile of rocks was built in advance – and each person
attending took one of a rock away with them to symbolise the
continuing toll of genocide across the globe.

Yesterday’s event was attended by almost 100 religious and community
leaders, one day before International Holocaust Memorial Day.

The day marks the liberation of Auschwitz – the Nazis’ most notorious
death camp – by the Soviet Army in 1945.

The service was organised by Bristol University’s multi-faith
university chaplaincy. It included music, poems, prayers and readings
from survivors of the Holocaust.

It also remembered the genocides of Bosnia, Rwanda, Sudan and
Armenians in Turkey.

The Lord Mayor of Bristol, Councillor Peter Abraham, attended and lit
a candle as a symbol of hope.

Rabbi Natan Levy, the university’s orthodox Jewish chaplain, said:
"The theme of this year’s commemoration is the dignity of difference.
Genocide has and will exist as long as we fear that which is
different.

"When we can embrace our differences, only then will hope emerge."

Today there was to be a remembrance service at St Mary-on-the-Quay
Church in the city centre after the 12.15pm Mass.