War is going on for the soul of Turkey

Hamilton Spectator, Canada
Jan 27 2007

War is going on for the soul of Turkey

>From their powerful positions in the army, the judiciary and the
bureaucracy, ‘republican elite’ work to undermine the reforms and to
wreck Turkey’s chances of joining the EU.

By Gwynne Dyer
Independent

When they buried Hrant Dink in Istanbul last Tuesday, more than
100,000 Turks came to his funeral, filling the streets and chanting
"We are all Armenians." There is a war going on for the soul of
Turkey, but at least a lot of Turks are on the right side.

Dink, who called himself "an Armenian from Turkey and a good Turkish
citizen," was murdered because he insisted on talking about the great
crime that happened in the country 92 years ago: the mass murder of
most of Turkey’s Armenian population in eastern Anatolia. The
newspaper he founded and edited, a bilingual Turkish-Armenian weekly
called Agos, had only a small circulation, but his outspoken
editorials had made him one of Turkey’s most famous journalists —
and a target for assassination.

His killer, 17-year-old Ogun Samast, was a semi-educated young thug
from Trabzon in the far north-east of Anatolia. He was given the gun
by a group of older ultra-nationalists including Yusuf Hayal, who was
convicted of bombing a McDonald’s restaurant in Trabzon in 2004. But
these marginal characters are just pawns in the larger war between
those who want a more democratic, more tolerant Turkey and those who
are desperately defending the power and privileges of the old
"republican" elite.

Samast shot Dink from behind in the street in front of his newspaper
office. "I feel no remorse," the killer allegedly told investigators.
"He said that Turkish blood was dirty blood." Of course, Dink never
said any such thing. What he actually said, in a newspaper article
addressed to his fellow Armenians, was that their obsession with the
massacres of 1915-17 was having "a poisonous effect on your blood."

But it’s east to see how a useful idiot like Samast could have
believed that Hrant Dink was an enemy of the Turks, because just over
a year ago a Turkish court took that phrase out of context, found
Dink guilty of "insulting Turkishness", and gave him a six-month
suspended sentence under Article 301 of the Criminal Code. A number
of other Turkish citizens including Nobel Prize-winning author Orhan
Pamuk have been prosecuted under the same law for daring to discuss
what happened to the Armenians, and most of them have received death
threats too.

It really is a kind of war, and the villains of the piece are
precisely the army officers, judges and senior civil servants who
were once seen as the guardians of the "republican" tradition, the
people who were going to modernize and democratize Turkey.
Unfortunately, "republican" doesn’t really mean the same as
"democratic."

The forms of the Turkish republic were democratic from the start, but
for a very long time the reality was a mass of illiterate peasants
under the harsh tutelage of a narrow educated elite who were
determined to Westernize the country. The "republican" elite rewrote
history (including the denial of the Armenian massacres) in order to
mould a new Turkish national consciousness, and saw religion as a
retrograde force that must be banned from politics.

The decades passed, and much of the elite’s dream came to pass.
Turkey today has a per-capita income higher than Romania or Bulgaria,
the most recent countries to join the European Union. Democracy is a
reality, and the current prime minister, Recep Tayyib Erdogan, leads
a party whose members openly refer to themselves as "Muslim
Democrats." Under Erdogan, there has been a wave of legal and
administrative reforms designed to qualify Turkey for EU membership.
But all this threatens both the rigidly secular ideology and the
autocratic privileges of the old republican elite.

>From their powerful positions in the army, the judiciary and the
bureaucracy, they work to undermine the reforms and to wreck Turkey’s
chances of joining the EU. In de facto alliance with
ultra-nationalist right-wing parties that also oppose EU membership,
they incite hatred of minorities, bring false prosecutions against
the advocates of a more open and democratic Turkish society, and
pursue the long-term goal of destabilizing the democratic order.

It was they who smuggled the notorious Article 301 into the Criminal
Code when it was being reformed to align Turkish law with EU
standards, they who brought false prosecutions for "insulting
Turkishness" against Hrant Dink, Orhan Pamuk, and other well-known
writers, journalists and scholars, they who spread the lies about
what Dink had actually said. It is they, not some ignorant, angry
teenager, who are really responsible for his death.

But the war is not over yet, and the good guys have not lost. Foreign
Minister Abdullah Gul vowed last November to change or abolish
Article 301, and last week 100,000 Turks thronged streets of Istanbul
to mourn the country’s best-known Armenian and condemn his murderers.

Gwynne Dyer is a London-based independent journalist whose articles
are published in 45 countries.

‘Screamers’ remembers genocide

amNewYork, New York
Jan 27 2007

‘Screamers’ remembers genocide
By Jay Carr

January 26, 2007

Before there was Hitler’s Holocaust, there was Turkey’s, where 1.5
million Armenians were exterminated between 1915 and 1923. Who, asked
Hitler on the eve of his genocide, remembers the Armenians?

"Screamers," Carla Garapedian’s documentary driven by the abrasive
metal uproar of the band System of a Down, does. And she wants us to,
as well. When she and the band, comprised of descendants of Armenian
genocide victims, aren’t busy taking Turkey to task, they raise other
inconvenient questions, lapped up by young audiences receptive to
anti-establishment edge.

If the Armenian genocide had been protested, or even questioned, one
band member asks, who’s to say that Cambodia, Bosnia, Rwanda, Darfur
and the Holocaust might not have been mitigated? As even Turkish
writers (Orhan Pamuk, Taner Ackam) boldly question the long silence,
the band’s outcry keeps the pressure on countries (including the
U.S.) to put geopolitcal expediency aside and lean on Turkey, where
the issue is met with denial and repression. As the concert footage
bumps heads with the archival footage, "Screamers" keeps the issue
alive like a hot coal.

SCREAMERS. Documentary by Carla Garapedian

eamers,0,6861007.story?coll=am-entertainment-utili ty

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

http://www.amny.com/entertainment/movies/am-scr

Legislators honor murdered journalist

Burbank Leader, CA
Jan 27 2007

Legislators honor murdered journalist

Rep. Adam Schiff, state Sen. Jack Scott and Assemblyman Paul
Krekorian mourned the loss of Turkey’s most outspoken Armenian
journalist, Hrant Dink, who was shot to death on Jan. 19 outside of
his newspaper’s office in Istanbul.

Both houses of the California State Legislature adjourned in memory
of the journalist Thursday. The Glendale City Council adjourned its
Tuesday meeting in honor of Dink.

Schiff, who met Dink in 2003 during a trip to Turkey to discuss
Armenian genocide recognition and free-press issues there, said
Dink’s passing is a great loss for those who cherish free speech.

"The silencing of such a prominent and outspoken voice is not only a
personal tragedy," Schiff said in a statement. "It is also a tragedy
for those who believe in a free and unfettered press, and for those
who are committed to a thoughtful examination of the past."

Dink had the courage to challenge his government’s suppression of
dissent, women and ethnic rights, Krekorian said.

"Mr. Dink was a courageous and outspoken champion of these values who
fearlessly spoke truth to power and challenged those who would revise
history," Krekorian said. "He was a clarion voice of dissent who
demanded freedom and gave hope to all people struggling under the
yoke of tyranny and oppression in Turkey and throughout the world."

State Sen. Jack Scott also mourned the journalist’s death.

"In the historic struggle of all nations for freedom of speech, this
man died for his ideas and his ideals," Scott said. "His death has
led to an outcry from around the world by those who believe in the
freedom to speak the truth."

Dink was the editor in chief of the bilingual Armenian and Turkish
newspaper Agos. He was given a shortened six-week sentence in October
2005 in Turkey after being convicted for inciting racial tension and
denouncing a Turkish historical figure in one of his articles. He was
awaiting another trial, which was scheduled for March.

ANKARA: Ankara slams Armenian proposal to open ties wo preconditions

The New Anatolian, Turkey
Jan 27 2007

Ankara slams Armenian proposal to open ties without preconditions

The New Anatolian / Ankara
27 January 2007

Both the Turkish Foreign Ministry and Premier Recep Tayyip Erdogan
late Thursday slammed Armenian Deputy Foreign Minister Arman
Karakosian’s proposal to begin relations with Turkey without
preconditions.

While the Foreign Ministry dismissed the offer as "including nothing
new," Erdogan urged Yerevan to act in a "genuine" manner.

The ministry said that Armenia has been making various statements
from time to time and that the latest doesn’t lead to any new
opening.

Stressing that Turkey maintains its willingness to develop ties based
on mutual trust and respect with all neighbors, the ministry added
however that the development and strengthening of bilateral and
regional cooperation can’t only depend on Turkey’s steps, but can
only be realized through the will and positive steps of all concerned
sides. "In relation to our country’s will to further develop dialogue
with Armenia, Turkey has taken constructive and concrete steps," the
statement continued. "The Turkish suggestion to set up a joint
commission of Armenian and Turkish historians to study the events of
1915 (Armenian genocide claims) is an example of the country’s will."

Similarly Premier Erdogan, in his response to the Armenian deputy
foreign minister’s proposal to establish relations without
preconditions, stated that Armenia should first give a response to
the Turkish suggestion to set up a joint commission to study the
disputed events. "They haven’t responded to my suggestion. These
statements don’t show good will. Therefore I don’t find their manner
genuine," Erdogan added.

Erdogan made the remarks during his meeting with European Union
members states’ ambassadors in Ankara late Thursday, in response to
German Ambassador Eckart Cuntz saying, "History might open some
windows of opportunity. Could (Hrant) Dink’s murder lead to positive
events in Turkish-Armenian relations and in Article 301 (of the
Turkish Penal Code)?"

In the closed-door session of the meeting, sources quoted Erdogan as
replying to Ambassador Cuntz’ remarks as saying, "There is no
relation between Article 301 and Dink’s murder. The murder is a
criminal act committed by a young man."

Ankara has urged Yerevan to abandon the Armenian genocide claims, to
give up claims of domination over Turkish territory (which were
stated in Armenia’s independence manifesto in 1991), to withdraw from
the Nagorno-Karabakh region without preconditions and to give
permission for the opening of a corridor between Azerbaijan and
Nakhchivan in order to establish diplomatic relations with the
country.

ANKARA: Top Trabzon officials suspended after Dink killing

The New Anatolian, Turkey
Jan 27 2007

Top Trabzon officials suspended after Dink killing

The New Anatolian / Ankara
27 January 2007

The governor and police chief of the northern province of Trabzon
have been recalled to the capital, a week after the shocking murder
of Armenian origin Turkish journalist Hrant Dink.

The city has now been shaken by two murder cases, with Italian
Catholic Priest Andrea Santoro killed by a reportedly mentally
unbalanced teenager last year, and journalist Dink slain in Istanbul
by yet another Trabzon teen.

Hours after the Interior Ministry launched an investigation into the
administrative and security personnel of the city, following claims
of a security lapses following Dink’s murder, Police Chief Resat
Altay and Governor Huseyin Yavuzdemir were called back to Ankara for
reassignment.

The ministry said in a written statement that two chief inspectors
were assigned to investigate the recent developments in the city
following the killing. It also added that the primary mission of the
inspectors is to find out whether the city’s security and
administrative heads neglected their duty in incidents and
demonstrations in the aftermath of the murder.

On Thursday it was reported that the gendarmerie asked the public not
to talk to people introducing themselves as secret service personnel
while questioning passers-by about the killer Ogun Samast and other
suspects.

A recently revealed intelligence report also said that certain
foreign circles had tried to establish youth gangs in the city that
resembled the gang allegedly founded by Yasin Hayal, reportedly the
second man behind the journalist’s murder.

A photo of Samast published by several dailies along with claims that
it was made available by the Trabzon gendarmerie has also fueled
concerns, as both the gendarmerie and police say they haven’t taken
photos of Samast since his detention.

Third man detained

Also on Friday, Erhan Tuncel, allegedly the third man behind the
killing, who in his initial testimony to police confessed to ordering
Hayal to found a gang and provide firearms training as well as
ideological indoctrination, was charged by the 11th Istanbul Heavy
Criminal Court. Tuncel reportedly exercised his right to remain
silent.

The total number of suspects reached six with the latest arrest.

Tuncel was seen behind Muhsin Yazicioglu, the leader of the
ultranationalist Grand Unity Party (BBP), in a newly released photo,
reinforcing speculation that the three suspects and unknown others
had been used by ultranationalist circles.

However Yazicioglu denied allegations of links to the suspect, saying
that he cannot know who is standing behind him everywhere. Reports
have claimed that all suspects were once members of an extremist
youth organization affiliated with the party.

Hayal, who was convicted for a bombing outside a McDonald’s
restaurant in Trabzon in 2004, told police that he was given bomb
training by Chechen militants in Azerbaijan, a country where a
notorious ex-army officer allegedly founded anti-Armenian assassin
groups.

The ex-general, Veli Kucuk, was also alleged to have threatened Dink
and sent his men to the journalist’s hearings. Dink’s prosecutor,
ultranationalist lawyer Kemal Kerincsiz, is also said to be a close
figure to the former army member.

Bomb outside Parliament walls raises fears

Acting on a tip-off, police defused a bomb in a package found near
the outer walls of the grounds behind Parliament on Friday.

The package also contained a letter, signed by Turkish Revenge
Brigade, calling for Hayal and Samast be released.

"Set free our brothers Yasin and Ogun," said the letter, which also
protested demonstrations during Dink’s funeral ceremony.

The note resembled many others including those from political parties
that protested the banners, "We’re all Armenians, we’re all Hrant."
Even an unrelated civil group, the Association for Protection and
Evaluation of Natural Resources (EVDK) said, "We’re all Mehmed, tens
of thousands marched for an Armenian, we lose thousands of soldiers
each year; who marched to protest the losses?"

The threatening messages were also posted on the message board of a
website belonging to a local football club where both Hayal and
Samast was players for days after Samast was detained by police.

Those who posted the messages, apparently members of the football
club, called Hayal "the bomber," and expressed their hatred for Dink
while praising what Samast did.

The brigade became a high-profile yet mysterious illegal group when
it tried in 1998 to assassinate former Human Rights Association (IHD)
head Akin Birdal. The group last year claimed responsibility for a
number of bombings in southeastern Diyarbakir. A note on its website
read that they will kill 100 Kurds for every Turk killed.

Bomb causes minor damage in Samsun

Also on Friday, a bomb explosion at the entrance of a business center
in the northern province of Samsun, although it caused minor damage,
alerted police for further investigation.

Dink’s killer was apprehended at a bus terminal in Samsun, which
neighbors his hometown Trabzon, over the weekend.

The bomb was placed outside the Sengun Business Center where several
shops and non-governmental organizations are located.

The bomb went off around 2:15 a.m., shattering windows of the
building and damaging parked cars.

Police said a pipe bomb was responsible for the explosion.

ANKARA: Extreme parties point finger at foreign circles for murder

The New Anatolian, Turkey
Jan 27 2007

Extreme parties point finger at foreign circles for Dink murder

The New Anatolian / Ankara
27 January 2007

Two extreme parties of opposite poles on Friday reiterated a
much-uttered claim over the murder of journalist Hrant Dink, which
blames the assassination on international circles.

Ultranationalist Grand Unity Party (BBP) deputy leader Edip Ozbas
claimed that Westerners encouraged the killing, while the Labor Party
(IP), a socialist party which has recently begun to employ an
ultranationalist approach, blamed the U.S. and NATO for the murder.

Ozbas said Dink’s murder enabled certain circles to reveal the poison
they had amassed against Turkey. "We believe that the independent
judiciary will shed light onto the incident, but we know that the
primary power behind the Dink murder and all others are Westerners
who put pressure on Turkey to adopt European Union acquis."

"Those who now unleash allegations against the BBP and its leader
Yazicioglu for his stance will have to account for their claims
soon," said the party official also expressing their willingness to
fight for Turkish Penal Code (TCK) Article 301 in the face of
Westerners who want to see it annulled.

Another BBP member, Okkes Sendiller, condemned people who reopened
the Article 301 debate, in a written statement that also criticized
Cabinet ministers and Nobel Prize-winning Turkish author Orhan Pamuk
for comments criticizing the article.

"This nation has the right to curse at those who are trying to
realize a regulation to enable cursing at Turkish national values,"
he said. He added that Pamuk overstepped the line once more with
calls to lift Article 301.

Sendiller also criticized Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan’s visit
to offer condolences to Turkish Armenian Patriarch Mesrob II
Mutafyan.

IP: Culprit is US, NATO

IP leader Dogu Perincek’s target was more distant compared to that of
the BBP; he claimed that the U.S. and NATO — branding it a crony of
the U.S. — engineered Dink’s murder.

Perincek, in a letter to Mutafyan, claimed that the assassination was
part of a bigger plan to spark turmoil and chaos in the country.

He also linked the killing to an Armenian genocide bill about to be
debated in the U.S. House of Representatives.

He also criticized the funeral ceremony for the journalist, which he
claimed was turned into a demonstration against Turkey, and asked
Mutafyan why he failed to prevent this.

"We expect you, the leaders of the Turkey’s Armenian community, not
to guide the bullets targeting Turkey but to sweat along with all
members of this country to prevent foreign powers from dissolving
Turkey," the IP leader said.

ANKARA: Gul reproves Douste-Blazy on French passage of Armenian bill

The New Anatolian, Turkey
Jan 27 2007

Gul reproves Douste-Blazy on French passage of Armenian bill

The New Anatolian / Paris
27 January 2007

Meeting with his French counterpart in Paris on Thursday, Foreign
Minister Abdullah Gul expressed criticisms and concerns about the
French Parliament’s passage of a bill last October to penalize people
who question the Armenian genocide claims.

"France is following the wrong path in relations with Turkey," Gul
told French Foreign Minister Douste-Blazy on the sidelines of the
International Donors Conference held in Paris. "The French
Parliament’s passage of the Armenian bill was in nobody’ interest."

Underlining the damage done to relations between Ankara and Paris by
the passage of the Armenian bill, Gul said, "Relations with France
could have been better."

The French Parliament voted last October in favor of an Armenian bill
that introduces prison terms of up to one year and fines of up to
45,000 euros to those who question the genocide claims. The bill must
be approved by both the other house of the French legislature and the
president in order to become a law.

Foreign Minister Gul also met with U.S. Secretary of State
Condoleezza Rice and German Foreign Minister Frank-Walter Steinmeier
on the sidelines of the conference. While the latest developments in
Iraq and Lebanon and the fight against terrorism dominated Gul’s
talks with Rice, reconstruction efforts and further contributions by
Turkey and Germany to the development of Lebanon dominated Gul’s
talks with Steinmeier.

ANKARA: Turkish General: Dink Murder was Part of a Greater Operation

Journal of Turkish Weekly, Turkey
Jan 27 2007

Turkish General: Dink Murder was Part of a Greater Operation

Saturday , 27 January 2007

Tuncer Kilinc, retired General and Former National Security Council
General Secretary, argues that the Dink Murder is a part of a greater
operation against Turkey. Mr. Kilinc told the Aksam paper that `the
real target is stability in Turkey’. Kilinc said `they try to make
enemy Turkish and Armenian citizens of Turkey. Dink was son of this
motherland and there is no difference between Dink and any other
journalist’. Mr. Kilincs also added that the operation against Turkey
will be continued in near future.

Book on Ethiopia inspired by dream

Inspire Magazine, UK
Jan 27 2007

Book on Ethiopia inspired by dream

A Buckinghamshire author whose first non-fiction book was inspired by
a dream, is using it to help raise funds for clean water and
sanitation projects in Ethiopia.

In her dream Annette Allen was back in the foothills of Addis Ababa
where she went to school and had bent down to feel the dry topsoil.
As she did so she knew she was there to help provide water for
Ethiopia’s poor. Two years later, Annette was made redundant from her
job as a corporate communications manager and vowed to make her dream
come true.

The result is An Ethiopian Odysssey about her journey to find nine
classmates from Nazareth School for Girls in Addis Ababa and to
discover what had happened to them since she last saw them in July
1964. The book includes interviews with four school friends,
including the granddaughter of Emperor Haile Selassie. It also
recounts stories about the Queen, Princess Anne, the Armenian
genocide, Ethiopia’s first big famine in 1973, wars and more recent
events such as the 9/11 World Trade Centre attacks in New York and
the Commission for Africa.

Half of the royalties from each book will go to three charities:
WaterAid, who have worked in Ethiopia since 1983, AGOHELD, a charity
run by Abebech Gobena, the `Mother Theresa of Africa and Christian
Aid’s Middle East crisis appeal.

`This has been a truly wonderful journey, with amazing connections
and synchronicity,’ says Annette, a committed Christian. `I’ve
experienced the kindness and hospitality of many strangers in
different countries who wanted to help me make my dream come true.

`In Ethiopia, I saw for myself how permanent clean water has a major
impact on the quality of people’s lives: especially for women and
girls, along with the family’s health, income and self-esteem. Having
clean water on tap means an end to water-borne diseases, and the
long, daily walks to bring water to their family. Water is, indeed,
life.’

on=view&id=780

http://www.inspiremagazine.org.uk/news.aspx?acti

ANKARA: Erdogan noncommittal on changes to Article 301

Today’s Zaman, Turkey –
Jan 27 2007

Erdogan noncommittal on changes to Article 301

Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan has declined to give
assurance to the EU over changing Article 301 of the Turkish Penal
Code (TCK) but reaffirmed that his government was open to idea of
amending the article.
The EU has bitterly criticized Article 301, saying it restricts
freedom of expression, but Turkey has so far avoided taking steps to
directly amend it. Pressure on the government to change the
controversial article, under which numerous writers, intellectuals
and journalists have landed in court, has been increasing since the
murder of a Turkish-Armenian newspaper editor.
Hrant Dink, editor-in-chief of the bilingual Agos newspaper, was shot
dead by a 17-year-old assailant outside his office on Friday. He had
been tried under Article 301 for "insulting Turkishness" and
sentenced to a six-month suspended imprisonment for an article he
wrote about an alleged genocide of Armenians at the hands of the
Ottoman Empire.
Turkey’s top business group, the Turkish Industrialists and
Businessmen’s Association (TÜSİAD), and the Parliamentary
Assembly of the Council of Europe have raised concerns over the
article.
Ambassadors of EU countries, meeting with Erdogan at a dinner on
Wednesday evening in Ankara, clearly expressed the bloc’s
expectations for changes to Article 301, according to the private
ANKA news agency.
Erdogan made no reference to Article 301 in his speech to the
ambassadors but touched on the issue in a question-and-answer
session. Responding to the diplomats’ questions, Erdogan
repeated the line of his government and said most of the problems
stemmed from the way the law was implemented.
He also complained that the EU had not expressed any concern over
Article 301 in its preparatory stage and added that some EU member
countries also had similar laws in their national codes.
The EU continues to have firm expectations that Article 301 be
amended, but some ambassadors showed "understanding" toward the
Turkish government’s position, given that two critical elections lay
ahead, according to ANKA.
Presidential elections are scheduled for May and parliamentary
elections will take place in November. But in his speech,
Erdogan said the upcoming elections would not affect the
government’s determination for reforms.
In comments on Dink’s killing, Erdogan said the attack was
against Turkey. During Dink’s funeral, up to 100,000 people gathered
in Istanbul to attend and carried banners reading "We are all
Armenians" and "We are all Hrant Dink."
"Turkey is the inheritor of a great civilization that embraced people
of different races and faiths for centuries," Erdogan told the
ambassadors.

27.01.2007

Ankara Today’s Zaman with wires

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress