Ankara removes police chief in Dink case

Ankara removes police chief in Dink case
By Vincent Boland in Ankara

FT
January 27 2007 02:00

The governor and police chief of Turkey’s Black Sea province of
Trabzon were fired yesterday as an investigation into the murder of a
prominent journalist highlighted possible lapses and failures by the
security forces.

Political commentators said their removal – officially the two men
were "recalled to Ankara" – was an attempt by the authorities to show
how seriously they were treating the killing of Hrant Dink, a
Turkish-Armenian newspaper editor shot dead in Istanbul on January 19.

His murder led to a clamour for a thorough and transparent
investigation. Six people have been charged in connection with the
crime. They all come from in or around Trabzon, a sprawling,
down-at-heel city (and province) on the Black Sea in north-eastern
Turkey.

At least one of the suspects, an extreme nationalist with a criminal
record, was known to the police before Dink’s murder. This may have
been a factor in removing the two officials, who are responsible for
security in the city and the province.

The interior ministry was investigating "whether there was any failure
or negligence of the local administration and the provincial security
department", according to the Anatolia news agency.

The suspects include Ogun Samast, a 17-year-old who confessed to
killing Dink and has been charged with murder. He is said to have told
interrogators that he killed Dink because of the journalist’s
pro-Armenian stance in the debate on the mass killing of Ottoman
Armenians during the first world war.

Trabzon, which has a population of about 500,000, has been pinpointed
by the media as the centre of a rising phenomenon in Turkey – a fusion
of ultra-nationalism and Islamic fundamentalism that seems to hold a
particular appeal for disaffected young men.

As well as producing Mr Samast and the criminal gang said to have
incited him to kill, the city last spring was the site of the murder
of Andrea Santoro, an Italian Roman Catholic priest.

The killer in that casewas of similar age and circumstance to Mr
Samast.

Television stations have held anxious panel discussions in recent days
on why Trabzon should have become a focal point of
nationalist/Islamist extremism.

Experts blame the city’s isolation from metropolitan Turkey and the
fact that it seems to be disproportionately represented in the armed
forces fighting separatist terrorism.

They also point to its relatively high unemployment and lack of
opportunities for youngsters, many of whom move to Istanbul in search
of a better life.

Critics’ Forum Article – 1.27.07

Critics’ Forum

Music
Mosaic: A Celebration of Sound
By Tamar Salibian

It was with great anticipation that over 1,000 audience members
braved the chilly weather on January 14 to experience Mosaic: a
Celebration of Sound at the Alex Theater in Glendale, California.
Presented by the Hamazkayin cultural organization, Mosaic highlighted
talent from around the country and was hosted by Voki Kalfayan and
Lory Tatoulian.

Dressed as an eccentric immigrant couple, Kalfayan and Tatoulian
opened the three-hour program by meandering through the audience,
animatedly chatting with people and posing for photographs on stage.
The over-the-top antics proved entertaining, if quite predictable.
As Kalfayan and Tatoulian told stories of their ventures in the "old
country," they managed no less a feat than exhibiting their break
dancing skills, while offering everyone sweets and pastries from
Tatoulian’s massive handbag, which she carried around all evening.
Tatoulian was engaging, asking the crowd for the jezveh she’d lent to
a fictional neighbor before utilizing the length of the stage for her
dance sequences, all with a deadpan facial expression. Kalfayan’s
earnestness proved a good match to Tatoulian’s larger-than-life
persona, helping the duo present their own take on the ups and downs
of immigrant life.

The highlight of the program was an impassioned set by a capella trio
Zulal. Paying tribute to the village life of an Armenia long gone,
Teni Apelian, Yeraz Markarian and Anaïs Tekerian proved the most
engaging act of the evening. The trio captivated the audience with
playful and informative explanations of the traditional Armenian folk
songs in their set. The performance itself was highlighted by
intricate, playful arrangements and perfectly choreographed dance
steps, all accompanied by the trio’s clear and lush voices. Most
enjoyable was Zulal’s performance of Ghapama, which the trio
performed with charm, wit and passion.

Also noteworthy was opening act Tallulah Sound Experiment, an
ensemble of self-proclaimed "scientists" who cite a wide variety of
musicians, from Radiohead to The Red Hot Chili Peppers, as sources of
inspiration. Lead singer Soseh Keshishyan’s near-perfect pitch,
accompanied by the band’s eclectic and fiery sound, generated an
infectious energy most evident in the group’s final piece, LaDaDa.

K’noup, the lead singer of Visa, also managed to impress the audience
with the distinct intonation and texture of his voice, going so far
as to pepper his lyrics with chants of "I love Glendale!" The
energetic performances of percussionist Danny Shamoun and drummer
Hiram Rosario helped lend a unity and coherence to the performance of
the 8-member group.

Touted as the "concert of the year" in numerous invitations and
advertisements, Mosaic promised a night to remember for both
Armenians and non-Armenians alike. The evening generally managed to
live up to its billing, creating a veritable "mosaic," a tapestry of
sorts with a number of standout performances. And yet, while each
musical act brought an eclectic element to the stage, the thread that
tied the various acts together – apart from the fact that they were
performed largely by Armenian individuals – was difficult to see.
Finding an underlying theme or unifying force for the evening,
therefore, proved somewhat elusive. The end-result was an uneven
program that failed to provide much insight into its acts or engage
the audience beyond the performances’ immediate entertainment value.
It would have been wonderful, for instance, to have incorporated more
commentary on the different performances, as the members of Zulal
did. It would also be interesting to find out how many non-Armenians
heard about the event and, more importantly, whether any were
actually there on the 14th.

All Rights Reserved: Critics Forum, 2007

Tamar Salibian is a filmmaker and writer living in Los Angeles. She
has written for AIM magazine. Her latest film, "Beautiful Armenians,"
was released in 2006.

You can reach her or any of the other contributors to Critics’ Forum
at [email protected]. This and all other articles published
in this series are available online at To sign
up for a weekly electronic version of new articles, go to
Critics’ Forum is a group created to
discuss issues relating to Armenian art and culture in the Diaspora.

http://www.criticsforum.org/
www.criticsforum.org.
www.criticsforum.org/join.

Armenian community mounts global effort for "Hrant Dink Foundation"

Yevrobatsi
Saturday, Jan. 27, 2007
Armenian community mounts global effort to create the "Hrant Dink Fondation"
php?r=10&id=2563

As Armenians throughout the world mourn the senseless murder of
journalist Hrant Dink, community leaders have vowed to keep his name
and ideals alive with the establishment of the "Hrant Dink Foundation."
The primary purpose of the foundation will be to disseminate the
message and vision of Mr. Dink and support the continued efforts of
Agos newspaper, of which Dink was the founder and editor-in-chief.

A coalition of Armenian community organizations spearheaded by the
Organizations of Istanbul Armenians gathered at the Western Diocese of
the Armenian Church to launch the Foundation. They are in the process
of collecting donations to fund it. Those interested in contributing
to the Hrant Dink Foundation can call 818-641-1059 or visit the
Foundation’s web site at: .

"We feel it is our duty to continue the struggle of Hrant Dink, who
died fighting for the right of free speech," said Hovsep Tokat, Chair
of the Committee establishing the Foundation. "His only crime was that
he was an Armenian living in Turkey . The response of hundreds of
thousands of people throughout the world is a testament to the support
of his ideals," he said.

Dink was a champion of the right of free speech. He was a fearless
leader and proponent of free expression and democracy. This stand was
particularly difficult for the native of Turkey , due to Turkey ‘s
policy of suppressing and punishing those who engage in free speech
with ideas contrary to government opinion. Dink’s dream was to achieve
better understanding between Armenians and Turks. He believed he could
succeed if he could reach the average Turkish citizen. This is why he
chose to stay in Turkey even when he knew that his life was in danger.

In 2005, Dink was prosecuted in Turkey for violating article 301 of
Turkey ‘s penal code, which states that open reference to the Armenian
Genocide equals "insulting Turkishness" and is punishable as a
crime. While Dink was convicted under this article, he was given a
6-month suspended sentence. In September, 2006, a prosecutor in
Istanbul opened a new case against Dink for the same crime, due to his
statement to a foreign news agency that the mass killings of Armenians
in Turkey was Genocide. His trial was still pending when he was
assassinated in front of his newspaper office on January 19, 2007
. Despite numerous death threats, Turkish authorities did not provide
any protection or investigate the threats.

"Of course I say it was Genocide. With these events, you see the
disappearance of people who lived on these lands for 4,000 years,"
Dink said. Despite the new charges, Dink remained determined, and
vowed to continue to speak the truth regardless of the consequences.

Other Turkish journalists have come under fire by the Turkish
government and have been prosecuted under Article 301, including Orhan
Pamuk. Despite heavy criticism none were convicted. Pamuk went on to
receive the Nobel prize in literature, becoming the first Turk in
history to be so honored.

Turkey denies that the Ottoman regime committed Genocide during World
War I despite voluminous evidence to the contrary.

"In addition to his principled stand on free speech, Dink was an
advocate of educating the Turkish population of its own history," said
Tokat. "He did not blame the general population for denial of the
Genocide, rather he criticized the government for not educating its
citizens about the truth of its past. His progressive thoughts and
opinions are what the foundation hopes to keep alive," he said.

http://www.yevrobatsi.org/st/item.
www.HrantDinkFoundation.com

ANKARA: Slogans During Dink’s Funeral Become Matters of Controversy

Journal of Turkish Weekly
Slogans During Dink’s Funeral Become Matters of Controversy
Jan, 27, 2007
328

View: Fatma DISLI

It has been a week since Hrant Dink was murdered in İstanbul, but the
debates on this tragic event have not ceased. One particularly telling
debate focuses on slogans chanted during Hrant’s funeral. "We are all
Hrant, we are all Armenians," the approximately 100,000 people
attending the funeral procession chanted, the slogan echoed on the
placards they carried. The slogan was a reaction to the
ultranationalist motives behind the killing and an affirmation of
ethnic and religious tolerance and solidarity. This has not been
without consequence. Already, Nationalist Movement Party (MHP) leader
Devlet Bahçeli has voiced his annoyance with these slogans, thinking
that it is not appropriate for a Turk to say "I am an Armenian" no
matter what the reason.

Yeni Å=9Eafak’s Fehmi Koru directs harsh criticism toward those who
are disturbed by these slogans. Koru asserts that one has to be either
blind ordeaf in order not to see that those slogans did not contain a
religious or national message. He explains that everyone’s religion or
ethnic background is special to him or her and that people cannot
change such things all of a sudden. Such slogans do not imply a desire
for such a change or transformation. Such slogans imply a message for
another change, one for an understanding the "other."

Koru asserts that it is really absurd to look for an ulterior motive
behind these slogans at a time when we should be ashamed of
ourselves. "Those who chanted slogans or carried banners reading ‘We
are all Hrant, we are all Armenians’ did not turn into Armenians or
Christians. Some people are evenable to infer discrimination from
gestures that were made for solidarity," concludes Koru.

Another columnist from Yeni Å=9Eafak, Ali Bayramoglu, is also very
critical of those who were disturbed by these slogans. He comments
that Turkey has not cried this much for any of its Armenians, it has
never been so shaken overthe death of an Armenian. Bayramoglu calls
this a "turning point" for Turkey. He claims many Turks harbor a
feeling of shame and embarrassment, or at leasta feeling of pity, in
their hearts. The turning point, he says, is the soul-searching here,
but the most important thing is the social reaction toa man’s unjust
killing and the radical nationalism and racism behind it.
Bayramoglu urges that these slogans should be considered in this
respect. He harshly criticizes those who derided the reactions to
Dink’s death as "Hrantmania." "This is completely immoral. This is a
mentality that values a human being not because he is a human being
but according to his ethnic or religious identity," he asserts.

Vatan’s Okay Gönensin shares the same view in that some people just
reacted to these slogans instead of pondering the messages they
contain. He accuses such people of lacking confidence. "Only those who
are suspicious of their Turkishness, who are suspicious of the honor
of being a Turkish citizen, could be disturbed by these slogans. As a
matter of fact, the champions of street nationalism were disturbed,"
he explains.

Milli Gazete’s Zeki Ceyhan is at odds with the other columnists and
feels that the reactions expressed during Dink’s funeral were
exaggerated. He suggests that the people chanting these slogans did
not consider the possible outcome of their remarks and characterizes
such slogans as "foolish." Ceyhan thinks Dink’s funeral was a good
opportunity to get to know some people better. "Who is who was
revealed," he says.

[email protected]

Today’s Zaman
27 January 2007

http://www.turkishweekly.net/news.php?id=3D42

Greco-Roman Wrestling Championship Begins

Armenpress

GRECO-ROMAN WRESTLING CHAMPIONSHIP BEGINS

YEREVAN, JANUARY 26, ARMENPRESS: Over 100 athletes
will be competing for medals of Armenia’s Greco-Roman
Wrestling championship, which kicked off today.
Levon Vardanian, the secretary of the Armenian
Wrestling Federation, said to Armenpress the
competition will allow coaches to outline the national
team for 2008 Olympic Games.

Independent Economist Says Elections Will Not Affect Economic Growth

Armenpress

INDEPENDENT ECONOMIST SAYS ELECTIONS WILL NOT AFFECT
ECONOMIC GROWTH

YEREVAN, JANUARY 26, ARMENPRESS: An independent
economist downplayed today fears that next
parliamentary elections, slated tentatively for May
12, may have a negative impact on the country’s
economy.
Eduard Aghajanov, a vocal critic of the
government’s economic policies, cited the official
numbers of 2003, when Armenia had successful
presidential and parliamentary elections in less than
three months, according to which the economy grew
almost 14 percent.
But he predicted a wider gap between exports and
imports, saying this will be concomitant to ongoing
economic growth. "The gross domestic product is
supposed to amount this year to $82 billion, which is
not a barrier to a country like Armenia, but this may
be achieved given a real and effective crackdown on
shadow economy," Aghajanov stressed, adding that even
a 10 percent cut would be a success.
Aghajanov said also money remittances from
Armenians working abroad, which spur up consumption
here, account for about 40 percent of GDP growth.

Levon Aronyan beats Karyakin in the Corus Chess Tournament

Levon Aronyan beats Karyakin in the Corus Chess Tournament

ArmRadio.am
27.01.2007 13:36

In the 11th round of the Corus Chess Tournament held in the Dutch city
of Wijk aan Zee Grand Master of Armenia Levon Aronyan beat Grand
Master Sergey Karyakin, thus gaining 7 points and equaling to Teymur
Rajebov, who played a draw with Russian Grand Master Vladimir Kramnik.

Currently Levon Aronyan, Teymur Rajebov and Pyotor Svidler share the
2nd-4th places. The leader of the tournament is Vesselin Topalov with
7.5 points.

Grand Master Gabriel Sargsyan, representing Armenian in Group B, has
6.5 points and shares the second place with a number of chess
players. Pavel Elyanov is leading with 7 points, Armenpress reports.

Arts, Briefly: A Novelist Under Threat

The New York Times

Arts, Briefly

Compiled by PETER EDIDIN
Published: January 27, 2007

[other stuff removed from compilation]

A Novelist Under Threat

The Turkish novelist Elif Shafak has sharply curtailed her book tour
in the United States because of fears for her safety, her publisher
said yesterday. Ms. Shafak was scheduled to promote her new novel,
"The Bastard of Istanbul," in six cities, including Chicago, Los
Angeles and Seattle, but has canceled everything but a visit to New
York on Feb. 5. Ms. Shafak has been sued by a right-wing Turkish
attorney, Kemal Kerincsiz, who said her new novel’s characters were
guilty of "insulting Turkishness" by referring to the "millions" of
Armenians "massacred" by Turks. Ms. Shafak was placed under police
protection in Turkey, where she lives part time, after the murder of
Hrant Dink, a newspaper editor who was prosecuted for challenging the
official Turkish version of the 1915 Armenian genocide. Paul Slovak,
the publisher of Viking, said that while Ms. Shafak had received no
specific threats in the United States, she had been attacked as an
"enemy of the state" on ultra-nationalist Web sites. "It’s a situation
where you want to be as careful as you can and not take any chances,"
he said. JULIE BOSMAN

TBILISI: Bleak Prospects for Armenia’s Involvement in KAB Rail Proj.

The Georgian Times, Georgia
Jan 27 2007

Bleak Prospects for Armenia’s Involvement in Karsi-Akhalkalaki-Baku
Railway Project

As Georgia and Azerbaijan are pushing ahead with
Karsi-Akhalkalaki-Baku railway, Armenia has raised its voice for its
involvement in already third big regional project.

Armenian Deputy Foreign Minister said Thursday Armenia is ready to
open the border with Turkey and give a kick to
Kars-Guimri-Akhalkalaki railway which has been idle since 1992.

Although Armenia’s inclusion in the railway project would be a real
bonanza to the regional cooperation in South Caucasus, it seems too
implausible with the presence of the Nagorno-Karabgah conflict.

On January 15, Minister of Economic Development of Georgia Giorgi
Arveladze and Azerbaijan’s Transport Minister Zia Mamedov signed an
agreement in Tbilisi to provide much-needed funding for
Kars-Akhalkalaki-Tbilisi-Baku railway. Georgia will receive 220m USD
loan from Azerbaijan for a maturity of 25 years at a 1-percent annual
interest rate.

The Kars-Akhalkalaki-Tbilisi-Baku railway will run for 258kms
crossing the three countries. Georgia needs 200 M USD to rebuild
Marabda-Akhalkalaki and Kartsakhi-Akhalkalaki railway link and
construct running gears shop in Akhalkalaki.

The signing comes less than a week after Matthew Bryza reiterated the
US support to Armenia’s involvement in the project.

PanARMENIAN.Net quoted him as saying: `We would like the railway,
which connects Turkey with Baku, to pass through Armenia, since it
reflects our policy. Second, from economic point of view it is more
expedient to connect Turkey and Georgia through Armenian territory.
But we cannot make decisions on that issue. Investors themselves push
forward investment plans, which are more profitable for them. If
Azerbaijan, Turkey and Georgia want to construct a railway, of
course, we cannot object. But we do not particularly support that
project. We hope that in near future we will see such a
transportation scheme, which includes all the countries of the
region,’ said Bryza.

The Armenian-American lobbies successfully lobbied the US Senate last
year to ban funding Turkey-Georgia-Azerbaijan rail link which would
bypass Armenia. The amendments approved by the Senate Banking,
Housing and Urban Affairs Committee to the Export-Import Bank
Reauthorization Act, states that `The Bank shall not guarantee,
ensure or extend (or participate in the extension of) of credit in
connection with the export of any good or service relating to the
development or promotion any railway connection that does not
traverse or connect with Armenia and does not traverse or connect
with Baku, Azerbaijan, Tbilisi, Georgia and Kars, Turkey.’

Turkey thus fur has snubbed calls by the US and Europe to reopen the
border with Armenia, including Kars-Gyumri railway which was
predominantly used for passenger transportation in the Soviet times
and was the only railway immediately connecting the USSR with Turkey.

Although Turkey was one of the first countries to recognize Armenia’s
independence from the USSR, it has seen its relations with Yerevan
marred by 1915 genocide allegations. Yerevan asserts that some 1.5m
Armenians were killed in 1915 in Turkey and seeks international
recognition of the genocide.

Yet another motivation for Turkey to keep the border closed is its
solidarity with Azerbaijan, which came to war with Armenia over
Nagorno-Karabagh region. Turkey imposed a blockade on Armenia in 1993
during the armed conflict between Azerbaijan and Armenia.

The Nagorno-Karabagh conflict remains the main glitch not only in the
relations between Ankara and Yerevan but more importantly in the
regional cooperation between the three South Caucasus countries and
the reason for increasing isolation of Armenia.

The world politics has witnessed a resurgence of regionalism since
the late 1980s and there are calls for strengthened regionalist
arrangements. The South Caucasus emerged as a single region in 1990s
with the collapse of the USSR, as it detached itself from the
dominant power Russia in the north, and from Turkey and Iran in the
south. There is certain cultural proximity between the three
countries, the presence of the common Soviet legacy; geographical
settings bind Georgia, Azerbaijan and Armenia in a single region. The
international community would like to see a tighter regional
association and the EU’s decision to include Azerbaijan and Armenia
into the European Neighbourhood Policy due to Georgia’s Rose
Revolution can be cited as an example.

No wonder there is a strong desire from the West to see enhanced
cooperation, trade and prosperity in the region. The World Bank even
commissioned a research to identify the `peace dividends’, examine
the likely- short-term impacts of the lifting of blockades. The
report called `Changing Trade Patterns after Conflict Resolution in
South Caucasus’ says: `Potential peace benefits are highest for
Armenia, the country that suffers most from the blockades. Armenia
would annually save 6-8m dollars on the transport costs of non-energy
imports and 45m dollars on switching the flows of natural gas and
petroleum to new sources. The increase in experts may lead to up to
30-38 percent of GDP growth. Azerbaijan could increase its exports
by 100m dollars, or 11 percent of current level, slashing the trade
deficit by a quarter. As a result GDP would increase up to five
percent… Georgia might face a reduction of transit through its
territory. Nevertheless, it is unlikely to exceed a quarter of the
freight service surplus in the bop, or 1.5 percent of trade deficit.’

By Keti Khachidze,

The Turkish State Continues Disseminating Hatred Against Non-Muslims

AINA, CA
Assyrian International News Agency
Jan 27 2007

The Turkish State Continues Disseminating Hatred Against Non-Muslims

The Assyrian-Chaldean-Syriac Association has recently written about
the religiously based threats being continuously spread from the
Turkish state ministry responsible for religious affairs, the Diyanet
Isleri Baskanligi.

The European Parliament has demanded that Turkey stop these threats,
but the situation remains. On the contrary, the threats have
intensified.

As the whole world condemns the murder and mourns the death of
Armenian journalist Hrant Dink, and as tens of thousands of Muslims
participated in the mourning of Hrant Dink, the Turkish state
ministry mentioned above has published a statement on its home page.

The statement on the home page says that, from a religious point of
view, it’s unacceptable for a Muslim to participate in religious
ceremonies of non-Muslims. It further states that Muslims are not
allowed to pray for blessing or salvation for the soul of a
non-Muslim.

The Mullah of Istanbul, who recently received the Pope and asked him
to turn to Mecca, "in the name of tolerance", did obviously not
bother himself to attend the funeral of Hrant Dink and show the same
kind of tolerance he asked from the Pope.

Turkey, an EU-candidate, continuous to spread hate propaganda against
non-Muslims, from highest authority, its own ministry of religious
issues, even after the murder of Hrant Dink.

Ahmed Hakan, a Turkish writer, recently turned against the Turkish
state in the leading news paper Hurriet, questioning the
discriminating message of the ministry of religious affairs.

This state sponsored, Turkish, religious hate propaganda against
non-Muslims must stop.

For how long will the EU and its member states turn a blind eye to
these barbaric acts?

Sweden, Södertälje 24 January 2007

ACSA Assyrian-Chaldean-Syriac Association
Özcan Kaldoyo
Jakob Rohyo
Olle Wiberg

EasternStar News Agency