Inside the First Amendment: In defense of the indefensible

The Desert Sun, CA
Jan 30 2007

Inside the First Amendment: In defense of the indefensible

Charles C. Haynes
Gannett News Service
January 30, 2007

———————————————— —————-
If any speech should be a crime, denying the Holocaust would be at
the top of my list.

That’s why it’s easy to understand the motivation behind Germany’s
announcement Jan. 8 that it will push for legislation that would
criminalize `Holocaust denial’ throughout the European Union.

Germany, France and eight other European nations already have laws
that make denying the Holocaust punishable by prison sentences. Last
year, British author David Irving was convicted in Austria under one
such law and sentenced to three years in jail. (He was released in
December and is now on two years’ probation.)

Germany’s move to expand the ban on Holocaust denial comes in wake of
Iran’s one-sided conference `debating the Holocaust’ in Tehran last
month. By giving credence to some of the most deluded and bigoted
Holocaust deniers in the world, Iran’s President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad
stirred outrage in Europe and elsewhere.

However well intentioned, Germany’s proposal is the wrong response to
this very ugly problem.

Criminalizing speech denying the Holocaust not only threatens free
speech – it gives power to the vile views it seeks to suppress.

Once Europe heads down the slippery slope of state censorship, where
will it stop?

Consider the French slide toward state censorship of speech. In 1990,
France passed a law punishing Holocaust denial with a year in prison
and a 45,000-euro fine. Last October, the lower house of the French
parliament added to the list of forbidden speech by passing a law
that would make it a crime to deny that Armenians suffered genocide
at the hands of Turks in 1915. The measure still needs Senate
approval.

While French Armenians celebrated the vote, Turkey reacted with
predictable anger – not in defense of free speech, but because Turkey
itself denies that any genocide against Armenians ever happened.

Turkey, which aspires to join the European Union, is already near the
bottom of the anti-speech slope. Not only can you go to jail for
calling the Armenian tragedy a genocide, but you also can be arrested
for any speech that insults the republic, parliament or any organs of
state.

In 2005, Turkish novelist Orhan Pamuk was put on trial for
questioning the official version of the mass killing of Armenians.
After intense international pressure, an Istanbul judge halted the
trial.

Meanwhile in Sweden, the Rev. Ake Green was convicted of `hate
speech’ for preaching a sermon against homosexuality. Although the
Swedish Supreme Court acquitted Green in 2005, his trial provoked
worldwide concern about the use of hate-speech laws to limit freedom
of speech and religion.

Although the United States prides itself on strong protection for
freedom of speech under the First Amendment, we are not immune from
the temptation to censor unpopular speech. This is especially true on
college campuses where speech codes and anti-harassment policies are
frequently invoked to punish student and faculty speech.

And in the land of the free, we have plenty of ugly, repulsive speech
that pushes the limits of public support for robust free speech.
Exhibit A is the Rev. Fred Phelps and his small band of followers who
have incensed Americans with their protests at funerals of soldiers
killed in Iraq. Carrying inflammatory signs with anti-gay messages,
Phelps and Co. declare that the soldiers’ deaths are God’s punishment
for the nation’s support of gay rights.

Thanks to Phelps, some 27 states and the Congress have passed
legislation limiting protests at funerals. Critics of these laws
argue that they go beyond constitutionally permissible limitations on
such things as noise level and disorderly conduct by imposing overly
broad and vague restrictions on free speech and assembly.

By giving the state the power to ban the offensive speech of a few,
we give the state the power to limit the fundamental rights of us
all.

Moreover, state censorship doesn’t work. Putting people like David
Irving in prison only makes them martyrs of the extreme right.
Attempting to silence people like Fred Phelps only makes them media
magnets and pushes them to more outrageous behavior.

After Irving’s conviction, historian Deborah Lipstadt, whom Irving
unsuccessfully sued for libel in 2000, put it this way: `I am not
happy when censorship wins, and I don’t believe in winning battles
via censorship. … The way of fighting Holocaust deniers is with
history and truth.’

It’s never easy (or pleasant) to defend the indefensible. But for
Europeans, Americans and people in any nation that would be free, the
familiar battle cry of free speech still applies: Fight bad speech
with good speech – not with state power.

Greek Roman Style wrestlers to participate in Grand Prix in Tashkent

Armenian Greek Roman Style wrestlers to participate in Grand Prix Tournament
in Tashkent

ArmRadio.am
30.01.2007 13:10

Eight Greek Roman Style wrestlers of Armenia will participate in the
Grand Prix Tournament to start February 27 in Tashkent, the capital of
Uzbekistan.

The national team comprises 207 Champion of Armenia Ashot Khachatryan
(55 kg), Arsen Julfalakyan (74 kg), Tigran Sahakyan (84 kg), Khosrov
Melkonyan (60 kg), Arman Geghamyan (96 kg), Arman Adikyan (55 kg),
European Champion Roman Amoyan (55 kg) and Yuri Patrikeev (120 kg)
from Russia.

The chief coach of RA Greek Roman Style Wrestling team is Olympic
Champion Levon Julfalakyan.

Azeri sentenced to 14-year prison for `espionage for Armenia’

PanARMENIAN.Net

An Azeri sentenced to 14-year imprisonment for `espionage in favor of Armenia’
30.01.2007 13:57 GMT+04:00

/PanARMENIAN.Net/ A legal procedure finished in Baku on Azeri Ariz
Halilov case, who is Georgian citizen and `was cooperating with
Armenian Secret Services against Azerbaijan.’ On the decision of Heavy
Crimes Court Ariz Halilov was sentenced to 14-year imprisonment. The
Public Relations Office of the National Security Ministry of
Azerbaijan reports that `Halilov was convicted guilty on the Penal
Code articles of espionage and preparing terror acts in an armed gang
of plotters. During the investigation investigators have found out
that resident of Sadakhlo of Marneuol district of Georgia Ariz Djamal
ogly Halilov was transporting goods from Georgia to Armenia and
back. During one of his visits to Armenia he asked patronage from
police major Karen Antonyan who serves in Armenian Home Office and
cooperates with the Secret Services of the country.

Halilov was regularly visiting Armenia and meeting with workers of
Secret Services of that country. According to the investigation,
Antonyan ordered Halilov to commit terror acts in Azerbaijan. Oil and
gas infrastructure was chosen as target. He was ordered to examine the
possibility to attack some oil objects and wells. After arriving in
Baku with this goal Halilov carried out examination in some oil
objects. Having gathered the necessary information he returned to
Georgia and departed for Armenia. During his next visit Halilov was
ordered to examine the ways of committing terror acts in Underground
and to check out the level of security in `Gyandjlik’ metro station.

Making sure that metro was strongly protected and realizing that it
was impossible to realize the plan, Halilov informed it to his
patronage in Armenia. The next task was to blast one of Baku’s trade
centers. But Halilov refused to do that and said that it would be
better to pass explosives to him directly in Baku. He was detained on
May 11, 2006 in the result of special operation carried out by Azeri
National Security Minister," IA Regnum reports.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Tigran Torosian: Armenian Delegation to PACE Works Very Actively

TIGRAN TOROSIAN: ARMENIAN DELEGATION TO PACE WORKS VERY ACTIVELY

YEREVAN, JANUARY 30, NOYAN TAPAN. The plenary session of the
Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe held on January 22-26
in Strasbourg was, probably, the last for the Armenian delegation of
the National Assembly of the present convention. As Tigran Torosian,
the Armenian delegation head, NA Speaker stated at the January 29
press conference, most probably, the Armenian parliamentarians will
not take part in the next PACE session to take place in late
April. The reason is the RA NA elections to follow the session in few
days. In the NA Speaker’s words, "this is an understandable reasoning
for everybody, however, in Strasbourg."

Arising from the above-mentioned, T.Torosian considered purposeful to
sum up not only results of the session finished recently, but also the
3.5 year work of the delegation headed by him at the Assembly. In his
words, since 2001 the Assembly has adopted 5 resolutions concerning
the process of implementation of the obligations undertaken by
Armenia. The last one, resolution No1532 adopted on January 23 was an
unprecedented one for Armenia with its positive stresses compared with
the ones adopted before. "It does not mean that Armenia has no faults
and Armenia implemented all of its obligations. Just the opposite,
this resolution, fixing progress connected with fulfilling the
obligations, fixing a number of concretely successed steps, also fixes
a number of problems that Armenia must solve in future, at the same
time it fixes faults as well," the speaker said. In his words, the
faults, particularly, relate to the corruption, existing protests
connected with legal bodies’ attitude as well as to the Parliament’s
refusal of the draft on making amendments to the law on television and
radio. The Assembly also sees some deeds in the direction of
liquidating the faults existing in the law on alternative service.

Summing up the Armenian delegation’s work at the Assembly, T.Torosian
expressed an opinion that the delegation, but not all of its members,
worked very actively. The result is both adopted resolutions and
positions they got at the Assembly committees. He especially reminded
that when the delegation started its work, it inherited resolution
No1304, where it was said that if some steps were not taken,
commissions of the Armenian delegation would stop. "The life showed
that not only it did not happen in future, but, I think, important
documents, resolutions were adopted for Armenia," T.Torosian said. In
his words, it relates both to implementation of the obligations and to
problem of refugees in the region as well as to Nagorno Karabakh
problem, "and even connected with the April, 2004, events we managed
to secure by a good work, in a very strained situation, adoption of a
resoltuion which had vital importance in future for weakening the
tension in Armenia."

ROA NSC has not coop’d with Halilov convicted in Baku for espionage

PanARMENIAN.Net

Armenian NSC has not cooperated with Halilov convicted in Baku for espionage
30.01.2007 14:12 GMT+04:00

/PanARMENIAN.Net/ The National Security Council of Armenia denies the
accusations on cooperating with Georgian citizen Ariz Halilov, who
just the other days was convicted for espionage in favor of Armenia
and planning terror acts, the NSC Press Office reports. According to
the report, Sadakhlo resident Halilov’s activity, who was trading in
border market, is artificially exaggerated by Baku, which ascribes to
him `exclusive abilities’ and intentions to organize blasts in oil and
gas infrastructure and other large objects in Baku.

`Most probably the Azeri authorities are seriously concerned about the
information, which was spread on last December 20, on detaining and
sentencing one more agent,’ the Armenian NSC reports.

The other days a legal procedure finished in Baku on Azeri Ariz
Halilov case, who is Georgian citizen and `was cooperating with
Armenian Secret Services against Azerbaijan.’ On the heavy crimes
court decision Ariz Halilov was sentenced to 14-year imprisonment.

V. Manukian Does Not Exclude That Opposition Will Go To Elections

VAZGEN MANUKIAN DOES NOT EXCLUDE THAT OPPOSITION WILL GO TO ELECTIONS
AS PART OF SEVERAL BLOCS

YEREVAN, JANUARY 30, NOYAN TAPAN. The year 2007 will be very important
"in the respect of the breakthrough" that will continue in 2008, too
and will lead Armenia to a normal situation." RA MP Vazgen Manukian,
Chairman of National-Democratic Union, declared this at the January 30
press conference.

He did not exclude that the opposition can go to the elections as part
of two or three blocs, which, nevertheless, will cooperate with one
another in the issue of holding fair elections. As regards the issue,
what can be the basis of dividing the opposition into several blocs,
V.Manukian said that these can be both certain principles conditioned
by foreign orientations and the principle of "compatibility,"
existence of normal contact between them.

The NDU Chairman pointed to expediency of creating a united Council by
all opposition parties for fighting falsifications at the elections.
In his words, in 1995 the opposition had a possibility to take part in
formation of electoral commissions, while now the situation is much
worse, as they wittingly include vulnerable people in commissions for
exerting pressure upon them in the future. "Today the goal is not only
to falsify the elections, but to commit these falsifications
imperceptibly," V.Manukian considered.

In response to the question about strong and weak points of opposition
the NDU leader said that the opposition is strong with support of
prevailing majority of population, as even many officials within the
power are not content with its current course. As V.Manukian
estimated, opposition’s weak points are great number of parties and
almost absolute lack of funds, even for implementing organization
activities.

Erdogan against canceling Article 301, but says possible to amend it

PanARMENIAN.Net

Erdogan against canceling 301 article, but says it’s possible to make
changes in it
30.01.2007 14:26 GMT+04:00

/PanARMENIAN.Net/ Turkish PM Recep Tayyip Erdogan
speaks against canceling the 301st article of the
Turkish Penal Code, but he says it is possible to make
some changes in it. In his words, the matter is not
about full cancellation of the article. Alongside he
added that the Turkish government is ready to discuss
offers from non-governmental organizations and other
interested parties on the issue. The well-known 301st
article, which foresees criminal punishment for
`insulting Turkishness’, has being criticized by
international structures, including the European
Union, since it limits freedom if speech in the
country. Armenian-Turkish bilingual `Agos’
editor-in-chief Hrant Dink was sentenced to 6-month
suspended imprisonment under this article. After his
assassination the claims to cancel that very law
strengthened both from international and Turkish
non-governmental organizations, Cihan News Agency
reports.

Aliyev Renews Calls on Armenia ‘to End its Aggressive Policy’

Armenpress

AZERI PRESIDENT RENEWS CALLS ON ARMENIA ‘TO END ITS
AGGRESSIVE POLICY’

PARIS, JANUARY 30, ARMENPRESS: President of
Azerbaijan Ilham Aliyev renewed his calls on Armenia
‘to end its aggressive policy towards Azerbaijan’
during a face-to-face meeting with French president
Jacques Chirac Monday, saying it was key to bringing
stability to the South Caucasian region and fostering
its economic development.
Azerbaijani state television said ways to settle
the ongoing Armenian-Azerbaijani conflict over
Nagorno-Karabakh was high on Chirac-Aliyev meeting.
Aliyev was said also to describe last week meetings of
Armenian and Azerbaijani leaderships with the OSCE
Minsk Group cochairmen as ‘useful."
Jacques Chirac for his part said France, as a
member country of the Minsk Group, ‘is exercising its
influence and possibilities for establishment of a
soonest peace in the region.’ According to Azerbaijani
state television, the two presidents also exchanged
ideas about energy projects and the overall situation
in the South Caucasus. Chirac was said to evaluate
highly the French-Azeri cooperation saying that France
will host the Year of Azerbaijan in 2007.
In an interview with French newspaper Le Monde on
Monday Aliyev said he prefers a peaceful solution to a
dispute with Armenia, but is not ruling out military
means. "It’s clear that our political weight will give
us one day the means to liberate our lands," Aliyev
was quoted as saying. "We’d prefer to do it
peacefully, without going to war. But if there are no
other means … we’ll see."
Diplomats from Russia, France and the United
States, who make the OSCE Minsk Group, said in a
statement Monday they were encouraged by what they
called the "constructive" approach of the leaders of
Armenia and Azerbaijan as they work toward resolving
the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict.

Armenian Church Participates in Week of Prayer for Christian Unity

PRESS RELEASE
Mother See of Holy Etchmiadzin, Information Services
Address:  Vagharshapat, Republic of Armenia
Contact:  Rev. Fr. Ktrij Devejian
Tel:  +374-10-517163
Fax:  +374-10-517301
E-Mail:  [email protected]
Website: 
January 30, 2007

Armenian Church Participates in Week of Prayer for Christian Unity in the
Vatican

ROME:  The Roman Catholic Church has organized and hosted the "Week of
Prayer for Christian Unity" for the past number of years.  This year, on
January 25, His Holiness Pope Benedict XVI presided during an ecumenical
service at St. Peter’s Basilica in Vatican City, which was the closing event
of the Week of Prayer.

The Armenian Church was a participant in the service alongside many clergy
and laymen from the Roman Catholic, Eastern Orthodox, Ancient Orthodox and
Anglican Churches.  Representing the Armenian Church this year was Very Rev.
Fr. Aren Shahinian, pastor of the Italian-Armenian community and member of
the Brotherhood of Holy Etchmiadzin.  He was accompanied by Rev. Fr. Geghard
Vahuni, Rev. Fr. Moushegh Babayan and Rev. Fr. Ruben Zargarian, all
currently continuing their theological educations in institutions of higher
learning in Rome.

At the conclusion of the service, Fr. Shahinian extended the warm fraternal
greetings and best wishes of His Holiness Karekin II, Catholicos of All
Armenians, to His Holiness Pope Benedict XVI.

Also on January 25, an ecumenical service took place in Milan with the
participation of members of the Armenian community of Milan and the
"Norahrash" choir and deacons of the Armenian Church of the Forty Martyrs. 
During the ecumenical service, all present observed a moment of silence in
memory of Hrant Dink, the recently assassinated human rights activist and
editor of the "Agos" Weekly newspaper of Istanbul.

www.armenianchurch.org

Armenian Taxman Attributes Growth to Improved Administration

Armenpress

ARMENIAN TAXMAN ATTRIBUTES GROWTH TO IMPROVED
ADMINISTRATION

YEREVAN, JANUARY 30, ARMENPRESS; Armenia’s state
taxation services attributed a 27 percent rise in the
volume of collected taxes last year against the
previous 2005 to improved administration. Overall
229.7 billion drams in taxes were collected in 2006.
Robert Kocharian, a deputy head of the state
taxation service, said progress was reported also in
the structure of collected taxes. Particularly, the
share of direct taxes-income and profit taxes, grew.
Robert Kocharian said the state taxation service
has designed a plan of actions to continue the
crackdown on shadow sector. ‘Economic growth and
improved tax administration are the best evidence of
our work,’ he said