BAKU: Azeri experts wary of possible adoption of resolution by Congr

Trend, Azerbaijan
Feb 1 2007

AZERI EXPERTS WARY ON POSSIBLE ADOPTION OF ARMENIAN RESOLUTION BY US
CONGRESS

Baku, 1 February: The adoption of the bill on the official
recognition of the Armenian "genocide" drawn up and submitted to
Congress by pro-Armenian congressmen is not realistic, political
expert Vafa Quluzada has told Trend news agency.

According to the expert, the United States is conducting a policy of
defeating regional states in the Middle East – Iraq has been
defeated, and the issue of Afghanistan lies ahead. Thus, Turkey
remains the only major Muslim state in the region, which is why the
USA is preparing the ground for a striking at Turkey in the future,
he said. It is impossible to give any other assessment to such a
hostile act towards a member of NATO – an ally of the USA, the
political expert thinks.

In Quluzada’s opinion, the so-called Armenian "genocide" is an issue
for scientists, not for the US Congress, and has nothing to do with
modern Turkey.

Political expert Rasim Musabayov thinks that given that the
administration does not have a majority in the House of
Representatives and Senate, the risk of the US Congress adopting a
bill on the official recognition of the so-called Armenian "genocide"
is fairly high right now. He did not rule out that this attempt might
be more successful for the pro-Armenian congressmen. At the same
time, the political expert thinks that the US administration has the
resources to carry out work and explain the consequences that this
situation might bring about.

Disposition to match weather: Yerevan & Baku

Agency WPS
DEFENSE and SECURITY (Russia)
January 31, 2007 Wednesday

DISPOSITION TO MATCH WEATHER
by Grigori Aleksandrjan

YEREVAN AND BAKU: INTERPRETATIONS OF THE VISIT OF OSCE MINSK GROUP
CHAIRMEN TO NAGORNO-KARABAKH DIFFER; Chairmen of the OSCE Minsk Group
visited Nagorno-Karabakh.

The president of Armenia met with chairmen of the OSCE Minsk Group
for Karabakh conflict resolution – Yuri Merzlyakov (Russia), Bernard
Fasie (France), and Matthew Bryza (USA), and with special
representative of the OSCE Chairman-in-Office Andrzei Kasprzyk. The
current phase of Karabakh talks was discussed. Chairmen of the OSCE
Minsk Group came to Yerevan from Stepanakert where they had met with
Karabakh President Arkady Gukasjan last Thursday.

Official reports on the meeting in Yerevan were scarce. Foreign
diplomats merely reiterated the necessity to solve the problem by
peaceful means.

Gukasjan had been more talkative when he admitted that negotiations
over certain issues (like the status of Nagorno-Karabakh, Azerbaijani
territories under Stepanakert’s control, and refugees) would be
lengthy and difficult yet. Stepanakert updated the foreign diplomats
on its stand on these and related matters and suggested what it
perceived as solutions. Judging by what the chairmen of the OSCE
Minsk Group said afterwards, they liked what they had been told.

Baku, in the meantime, is angered by the foreign diplomats’ visit to
Stepanakert. No wonder. The visit sends the following message: unlike
Azerbaijani authorities, chairmen of the OSCE Minsk Group do
recognize Nagorno-Karabakh as a warring side – however indirect this
recognition. This assumption is confirmed by the foreign diplomats’
words that they owed it to Gukasjan because they had been unable for
a long time to visit Stepanakert as a group and discuss matters with
he Nagorno-Karabakh leadership. This is what probably became the most
important nuance of the foreign diplomats’ visit to Stepanakert.

As for the prospects of conflict resolution, chairmen of the OSCE
Minsk Group and president Nagorno-Karabakh regard them as quite
murky. A breakthrough in the peace process is not about to
materialize in the foreseeable future. It follows that the visitors’
somewhat elated disposition was probably caused by an unexpected
spell of warm weather in Nagorno-Karabakh that coincided with their
visit – and not to diplomatic etiquette or any progress in the talks.

Source: Novoye Vremya (Yerevan), January 2, 2007, EV

Translated by A. Ignatkin

Turkey must loosen the grip of its founding myths

The Financial Times , UK
31 January 2007 Wednesday 10:18:04 PM GMT

Turkey must loosen the grip of its founding myths

by Mark Mazower

The banners read "We are all Armenians" at the funeral in Istanbul
last week for Hrant Dink, the Turkish-Armenian journalist shot in
January by a young nationalist assassin. "We are Turkish. We are all
Mustafa Kemal Ataturk," nationalist football fans chanted in reply
from terraces across the country, referring to modern Turkey’s
founder.

As Dink’s tragic death and the polarised reactions to it demonstrate
in the most graphic way, the ongoing reckoning with events now nearly
a century old remains a huge factor in Turkey itself. It is not
merely that, fairly or unfairly, its pursuit of European Union
membership is generating international pressure on the government to
recognise the Armenian genocide. The issue polarises the country
internally as well and raises more acutely than any other issue the
question of how tightly it remains within the ideological grip of its
founding fathers.

In many ways, the government of Tayyip Erdogan has moved further on
this issue than any of its predecessors. While still publicly
insisting the point has acquired an almost theological quality that
the mass murders of 1915-16 were not genocide, it has opened up the
Ottoman archives and even proposed to the Armenian government that
they jointly sponsor an international commission to settle the issue
once and for all. That the Armenians showed little interest may have
been just as well. States generally need to get out of the business
of adjudicating on history, not deeper into it.

Just as French parliamentarians would have done much better recently
to avoid laying down the law on a whole range of past (non-French)
crimes and (French) achievements, so the Turkish government should
not imagine that a bilateral commission of official appointees will
do anything more than continue politicking in another form.
Government committees, parliamentary resolutions and even
state-sponsored anniversaries often possess a powerful
headline-grabbing symbolic charge but, precisely for this reason,
they are a crude means of getting at truth.

The process of coming to historical understanding does not work
through officialdom. It is essentially uncontrollable, often
acrimonious and cannot be wrapped up fast to meet a ministerial
deadline. After 1945, Holocaust scholars enjoyed uniquely favourable
access to documents, survivors and perpetrators. Sixty years on, they
are still debating some fundamental matters of interpretation.
Serious discussion of the events of 1915-16 is at a much earlier
stage. Right now, it seems fairly clear that much of the killing was
centrally organised, and genocidal in scope; denial of this point
simply flies in the face of the evidence. Yet how the killing was
organised is poorly understood. Moreover, most Turkish nationalists
do not so much deny the killings themselves as claim they need to be
seen in the context of an all-out assault on what was left of the
Ottoman empire itself. It is certainly true though Europe still
ignores the unpalatable fact that the expansion of national states,
mostly Christian, was accompanied by the killing and expulsion of
Muslims from the Balkans and Russia. To explain is not to justify.
Yet the escalation of violence in Anatolia after 1914 was certainly
linked to the upheavals that had preceded it. Franker discussion of
the Armenian genocide thus has the potential to open up an entirely
different perspective on Europe’s modern history as a whole.

There are many ways the Turkish government can help this along. Its
key responsibility lies in fostering better conditions for such
discussions to flourish. Repealing the now infamous article 301 of
the penal code, under which Dink among many others was convicted,
would be an important step towards ending the legal intimidation of
writers: the government’s talk of reforming it is not really enough.
It could do more to support the dissemination of the exciting
research that is emerging from Turkey’s flourishing universities.

Above all, it should take a hard look at how the country’s history is
taught in schools. Right now, the Kemalist old guard still talks and
acts as though any discussion of the republic’s founding myths will
jeopardise the security of the state. This is absurd: Turkey is not
going to crumble if its leaders finally acknowledge the Armenian
genocide. The Turkish army is not suddenly going to be weakened by a
more critical look at what happened 90-odd years ago. The
alternatives right now look pretty stark. On the one hand, an opening
to Europe. On the other, continuing to live in a world where the work
of defining patriotism and historical truth is placed in the hands of
trigger-happy 17-year-olds.

The writer teaches history at Columbia University

Armenia is not going to join NATO – defence ministry

ITAR-TASS News Agency, Russia
February 1, 2007 Thursday

Armenia is not going to join NATO – defence ministry

The Armenian Defence Ministry said on Thursday that the republic is
not going to join NATO.

“The task of the membership in NATO is not set in Armenia’s foreign
policy agenda,” the ministry’s press service said on Thursday.

The George C. Marshall European Center for Security Studies will hold
a seminar in Armenia on February 5-7.

Some of mass media said, citing the center, that Armenia’s joining
NATO is to be discussed at the meeting.

“This does not correspond to reality and does not ensue from the
spirit of Armenia’s individual partnership with NATO and from the
interests of the republic’s relations with the Marshall center,” the
Defence Ministry said.

Turks revisit an old question after murder of journalist

Associated Press Worldstream
February 1, 2007 Thursday 12:39 PM GMT

Turks revisit an old question after murder of journalist: is there a
"deep state"?

By CHRISTOPHER TORCHIA, Associated Press Writer

Have Turkish institutions been infiltrated by a shadowy "deep state"?

The slaying of a prominent ethnic Armenian journalist has renewed
debate about whether a network of renegade agents within the state,
driven by hardline nationalism, is targeting reformists and other
perceived enemies.

Skeptics say the claim fans conspiracy theories and only creates a
bogeyman for Turkey’s ills.

Whatever the truth, the investigation into the murder of Hrant Dink
who was loathed by nationalists because he urged Turks to recognize
the mass killings of Armenians during World War I as genocide is
under scrutiny despite its seeming success. Seven suspects, including
the teenager who allegedly pulled the trigger and the man accused of
supplying the gun, have been arrested since the killing two weeks
ago.

Uneasy questions are being raised about who holds the levers of power
in a nation where tensions between secularists and Islamists, and
liberals and rightists, have created deep faultlines in society.

The consensus among many government critics is that the plot to kill
Dink involved more than a few nationalists, and that a professional
group with considerable resources at its disposal may have played a
role. Police say they have uncovered no evidence suggesting a wider
conspiracy, and investigators have promised to follow all tips
despite skepticism about how aggressively they will do so.

The idea of "deep state," or "derin devlet" in Turkish, has been
around for decades. One definition says it is a clandestine group
within the security and intelligence services, as well as the state
bureaucracy, that resists change, sometimes violently.

Another theory says it is not a single group, but a set of beliefs
that espouses the centrality of the state in politics, and whose
protectors include the judiciary and the educational system. The
expression is so common that Turks often joke about it, blaming some
unforeseen development in the workplace or daily life on the "deep
state."

Little hard evidence has emerged that a "deep state" exists, but even
Turkey’s prime minister has given the idea credence.

"The ‘deep state’ has become a tradition. It is a term that has been
used since the Ottoman period," Erdogan told reporters on Sunday
aboard an airplane bound for an African Union summit in Ethiopia.

"We can describe it as gangs inside a state organization, and this
kind of structure does exist. Our state and our nation have paid a
high price because we have not been able to crack down on such
networks," the daily Zaman newspaper quoted the prime minister as
saying.

The topic is so murky that Yeni Safak, an Islamist newspaper, once
addressed the cloak-and-dagger concept with a reference to the
signature introduction of fiction’s most famous spy, James Bond. "My
name is State, Deep State," read the title of a 2005 column.

The prominence of "deep state" in the Turkish imagination exposes
concerns about the accountability of the military and other
institutions in a nation that seeks to seal its modern status by
joining the European Union, a bid that is virtually on hold because
of a dispute over divided Cyprus.

The military has staged three coups in modern Turkey, and remained
influential after ceding control to civilian governments. Supporters
view it as a guardian of secular values, a vital tool in the fight
against separatist rebels in Kurdish-dominated areas, and the
champion of Turkish Cypriots whose government is unrecognized by any
other nation.

Dink, who was shot outside his Istanbul office on Jan. 19, had been
prosecuted under a broadly defined law that bans the denigration of
Turkish identity, and he had suggested that judicial rulings
reflected behind-the-scenes allegiance to the state rather than the
rights of citizens.

"The great force, which was just there to bring me down and which let
its existence be felt at all stages of the case with methods unknown
to me, was again behind the curtain," Dink, 52, wrote obliquely in
one of his last columns in Agos, the weekly Turkish-Armenian
newspaper that he founded.

Dink said he received constant threats for his espousal of minority
Armenian rights, and he criticized top authorities for apparent
indifference.

"Other opponents of the bureaucracy have suffered a similar fate,"
said David L. Phillips, a friend of Dink who served as chairman of
the Turkish-Armenian Reconciliation Commission and is now executive
director of The Elie Wiesel Foundation for Humanity, based in New
York City. "The ‘deep state’ has a history of eliminating its
opponents."

One case that fueled speculation about the "deep state" was the 1996
Susurluk scandal, named after the town where a car crash revealed
alliances between state officials and mobsters. Passengers who died
in the wrecked Mercedes included Istanbul’s No. 2 police officer and
a fugitive hit man.

A probe confirmed suspicions that officials were using radical
nationalists and criminals to intimidate or kill perceived enemies. A
1997 government report accused some police and politicians of hiring
hit men to target journalists, Kurdish rebels and Armenian activists
since the 1980s.

Erdogan pledged an investigation "at full speed" into Dink’s killing
and his government removed the governor and police chief of Trabzon,
the city on the Black Sea coast that is home to suspects in the
murder.

A year ago, a Turkish teenager shot dead a Roman Catholic priest in
Trabzon; investigators believed that attack was linked to Islamic
anger over the publication in European newspapers of caricatures of
the Prophet Muhammad.

Erdogan, a moderate whose Islamic-rooted Justice and Development
Party is distasteful to some in the secular military, has indicated
that authorities need to tackle more than just youthful triggermen
likely to get relatively lenient sentences if prosecuted as minors.

But Justice Minister Cemil Cicek was ambivalent in an address to the
Ankara Chamber of Commerce on Wednesday.

"It is not a legal definition, but a political one," Cicek said.
"Whether there is a ‘deep state’ or not depends on where you stand in
politics."

Nationalists have speculated that reformists targeted Dink to create
a liberal backlash. The killing has stirred the debate on possible
amendments to Article 301 and, according to the conspiracy theory,
could make it easier for U.S. lawmakers to pass a resolution urging
the U.S. government to recognize the deaths of 1.5 million Armenians
in the last years of the Ottoman empire as genocide.

AP correspondent Selcan Hacaoglu contributed to this report from
Ankara.

Baku hails Moscow’s position on Nagorno-Karabakh

Interfax News Agency
Russia & CIS General Newswire
February 1, 2007 Thursday 6:16 PM MSK

Baku hails Moscow’s position on Nagorno-Karabakh

The Azeri Foreign Ministry has welcomed Russian President Vladimir
Putin’s statement that Moscow had been trying to help Baku and
Yerevan find a solution to the Nagorno-Karabakh problem

"Putin’s words are in unison with Azerbaijan’s approval of more
active efforts on the part the OSCE Minsk Group’s co-chairmen,
including the Russian side," the Azeri Foreign Ministry’s official
spokesman Tair Tagizade told Interfax on Thursday.

"The co-chairmen’s role is not to impose a solution on anyone – this
is out of the question, and here we agree with the Russian president
– but to promote the search for a solution, just what they have been
doing," the spokesman said.

Earlier on Thursday, Putin told reporters in the Kremlin that it was
up to Armenia and Azerbaijan to find a solution on the issue of
Nagorno-Karabakh.

"Don’t shift this problem onto our shoulders. You must find a
mutually acceptable way out yourselves," the Russian leader said.

Armenian budget deficit at 0.6% of GDP in 2006

Interfax News Agency
Russia & CIS Business and Financial Newswire
February 1, 2007 Thursday 4:59 PM MSK

Armenian budget deficit at 0.6% of GDP in 2006

The Armenian budget deficit was 15.358 billion dram, or 0.6% of GDP,
in 2006, a source in the National Statistics Service told Interfax.

Revenue and official budget transfers totaled 439.62 billion dram, or
16.5% of GDP in 2006, which was a growth of 17.9% from 2005. Tax
revenue grew 18.2% to 359.71 billion dram, or 13.5% of GDP.

Budget spending rose 15.1% to 454.978 billion dram, or 17.1% of GDP,
in 2006. Official transfers were 89.532 billion dram, capital
spending was 89.228 billion dram and government loans were 15.974
billion dram.

Military spending was 2.9% of GDP. Spending on education and science
was 2.7% of GDP and spending on social insurance and social support
was 2% of GDP.

The official exchange rate on February 1 was 358.8 dram/$1.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Baku, Yerevan need to work to find solution to NK problem – Putin

Interfax News Agency
Russia & CIS Military Newswire
February 1, 2007 Thursday 4:14 PM MSK

Baku, Yerevan need to work to find solution to Karabakh problem –
Putin

Armenia and Azerbaijan should find a solution to the Nagorno-Karabakh
problem themselves without shifting responsibility to Russia, Russian
President Vladimir Putin said.

"The burden of the problem should not be placed on us. You should
find an acceptable way to settle the situation yourself," the
president said at a news conference in the Kremlin on Thursday.

Moscow tries to assist Baku and Yerevan to find the solution to the
problem wherever possible, he said.

"However, you should make decisions yourselves. We cannot impose any
ways out from the current situation on anyone, because should we try
to do this, we will spoil relations with either the Armenians or the
Azeris for centuries," the president said.

Russian base in Armenia not a threat to region, Baku – Putin

Interfax News Agency
Russia & CIS Military Newswire
February 1, 2007 Thursday 3:56 PM MSK

Russian base in Armenia not a threat to region, Baku – Putin

Russia’s military base in Armenia is not directed against any state,
including Azerbaijan, Russian President Vladimir Putin said at a news
conference in the Kremlin on Thursday.

"I would like to highlight the fact that the Russian military base in
Armenia is not directed any other countries in the region’s
interests, and this includes Azerbaijan," the president said.

During a spell of high tensions in Ajaria, Georgia, Georgian
President Mikheil Saakashvili once said that "he was afraid that our
military would be conducting backstage activities," Putin said.

"I answered him that no such thing would happen and later he thanked
me for this, saying that they saw that the Russian military stood
aside from the development of the situation. The same thing is true
regarding the Russian base in Armenia," Putin said.

Armenian telecom companies boost revenue in 2006

Interfax News Agency
Russia & CIS Business and Financial Newswire
February 1, 2007 Thursday 1:48 PM MSK

Armenian telecom companies boost revenue in 2006

Telecommunication companies in Armenia posted revenue of 126.16
billion dram in 2006, up 36.9%, the National Statistics Service told
Interfax.

Revenue from the sale of telecom services to the population surged
52.4% to 538.5 million dram.

Revenue increased 7% to 36.07 billion dram for fixed-line services
and 89.5% to 63 billion for mobile phone services. Revenue from
postal and delivery services amounted to 2.52 billion, data transfer
revenue totaled 3.76 billion and TV and radio broadcasting revenue
was 2.93 billion dram.

The official exchange rate on January 31 stood at 360.07 dram/$1.