Old question revisited after journo’s murder

Independent Online, South Africa –
Feb 1 2007

Old question revisited after journo’s murder

February 01 2007 at 03:58PM

By Christopher Torchia

Have Turkish institutions been infiltrated by a shadowy "deep state"?

The slaying of a prominent ethnic Armenian journalist has renewed
debate about whether a network of renegade agents within the state,
driven by hardline nationalism, is targeting reformists and other
perceived enemies.

Skeptics say the claim fans conspiracy theories and only creates a
bogeyman for Turkey’s ills.

Whatever the truth, the investigation into the murder of Hrant Dink –
who was loathed by nationalists because he urged Turks to recognise
the mass killings of Armenians during World War I as genocide – is
under scrutiny despite its seeming success. Seven suspects, including
the teenager who allegedly pulled the trigger and the man accused of
supplying the gun, have been arrested since the killing two weeks
ago.

Uneasy questions are being raised about who holds the levers of power
in a nation where tensions between secularists and Islamists, and
liberals and rightists, have created deep faultlines in society.

The consensus among many government critics is that the plot to kill
Dink involved more than a few nationalists, and that a professional
group with considerable resources at its disposal may have played a
role. Police say they have uncovered no evidence suggesting a wider
conspiracy, and investigators have promised to follow all tips
despite scepticism about how aggressively they will do so.

The idea of "deep state," or "derin devlet" in Turkish, has been
around for decades. One definition says it is a clandestine group
within the security and intelligence services, as well as the state
bureaucracy, that resists change, sometimes violently.

Another theory says it is not a single group, but a set of beliefs
that espouses the centrality of the state in politics, and whose
protectors include the judiciary and the educational system. The
expression is so common that Turks often joke about it, blaming some
unforeseen development in the workplace or daily life on the "deep
state."

Little hard evidence has emerged that a "deep state" exists, but even
Turkey’s prime minister has given the idea credence.

"The ‘deep state’ has become a tradition. It is a term that has been
used since the Ottoman period," Erdogan told reporters on Sunday
aboard an airplane bound for an African Union summit in Ethiopia.

"We can describe it as gangs inside a state organisation, and this
kind of structure does exist. Our state and our nation have paid a
high price because we have not been able to crack down on such
networks," the daily Zaman newspaper quoted the prime minister as
saying.

The topic is so murky that Yeni Safak, an Islamist newspaper, once
addressed the cloak-and-dagger concept with a reference to the
signature introduction of fiction’s most famous spy, James Bond. "My
name is State, Deep State," read the title of a 2005 column.

The prominence of "deep state" in the Turkish imagination exposes
concerns about the accountability of the military and other
institutions in a nation that seeks to seal its modern status by
joining the European Union, a bid that is virtually on hold because
of a dispute over divided Cyprus.

The military has staged three coups in modern Turkey, and remained
influential after ceding control to civilian governments. Supporters
view it as a guardian of secular values, a vital tool in the fight
against separatist rebels in Kurdish-dominated areas, and the
champion of Turkish Cypriots whose government is unrecognised by any
other nation.

Dink, who was shot outside his Istanbul office on January 19, had
been prosecuted under a broadly defined law that bans the denigration
of Turkish identity, and he had suggested that judicial rulings
reflected behind-the-scenes allegiance to the state rather than the
rights of citizens.

"The great force, which was just there to bring me down and which let
its existence be felt at all stages of the case with methods unknown
to me, was again behind the curtain," Dink, 52, wrote obliquely in
one of his last columns in Agos, the weekly Turkish-Armenian
newspaper that he founded.

Dink said he received constant threats for his espousal of minority
Armenian rights, and he criticised top authorities for apparent
indifference.

"Other opponents of the bureaucracy have suffered a similar fate,"
said David L Phillips, a friend of Dink who served as chairman of the
Turkish-Armenian Reconciliation Commission and is now executive
director of The Elie Wiesel Foundation for Humanity, based in New
York City. "The ‘deep state’ has a history of eliminating its
opponents."

One case that fuelled speculation about the "deep state" was the 1996
Susurluk scandal, named after the town where a car crash revealed
alliances between state officials and mobsters. Passengers who died
in the wrecked Mercedes included Istanbul’s No. 2 police officer and
a fugitive hit man.

A probe confirmed suspicions that officials were using radical
nationalists and criminals to intimidate or kill perceived enemies. A
1997 government report accused some police and politicians of hiring
hit men to target journalists, Kurdish rebels and Armenian activists
since the 1980s.

Erdogan pledged an investigation "at full speed" into Dink’s killing
and his government removed the governor and police chief of Trabzon,
the city on the Black Sea coast that is home to suspects in the
murder.

A year ago, a Turkish teenager shot dead a Roman Catholic priest in
Trabzon; investigators believed that attack was linked to Islamic
anger over the publication in European newspapers of caricatures of
the Prophet Mohammed.

Erdogan, a moderate whose Islamic-rooted Justice and Development
Party is distasteful to some in the secular military, has indicated
that authorities need to tackle more than just youthful triggermen
likely to get relatively lenient sentences if prosecuted as minors.

But Justice Minister Cemil Cicek was ambivalent in an address to the
Ankara Chamber of Commerce on Wednesday.

"It is not a legal definition, but a political one," Cicek said.
"Whether there is a ‘deep state’ or not depends on where you stand in
politics."

Nationalists have speculated that reformists targeted Dink to create
a liberal backlash. The killing has stirred the debate on possible
amendments to Article 301 and, according to the conspiracy theory,
could make it easier for U.S. lawmakers to pass a resolution urging
the U.S. government to recognise the deaths of 1.5 million Armenians
in the last years of the Ottoman empire as genocide. – South Africa
Press Agency SAPA

Turkish novelist Orhan Pamuk heads to U.S.

International Herald Tribune, France
Feb 1 2007

Turkish novelist Orhan Pamuk heads to U.S.
The Associated Press
Published: February 1, 2007

ANKARA, Turkey: Nobel Prize-winning Turkish novelist Orhan Pamuk
boarded a plane for New York on Thursday to give a series of talks in
the United States, a day after he called off a visit to Germany.

"I will give talks at Columbia University and other universities,"
Pamuk told reporters at Istanbul’s Ataturk airport, but refused to
answer questions on news reports that he had canceled his trip to
Germany over security concerns.

The German daily Koelner Stadt-Anzeiger had reported, without
specifying sources, that security concerns were behind the decision
not to go to Germany after a suspect in the killing in Turkey of
prominent journalist Hrant Dink last week shouted what appeared to be
a threat against Pamuk.

Germany has a population of at least 2.6 million people of Turkish
origin.

Pamuk, like Dink, spoke about the mass killings of Armenians in the
early 20th century – and like him has been accused of the crime of
"insulting Turkishness."

Prosecutors on Thursday arrested an eighth suspect in Dink’s
assassination, while police sent two inspectors to Istanbul to
determine if there had been flaws in the police investigation, the
state-owned Anatolia news agency reported.

BAKU: Putin: Azerbaijan, Armenia can together produce popular wine

Azeri Press Agency, Azerbaijan
Feb 1 2007

Vladimir Putin: Azerbaijan and Armenia can together produce cheap
`Aghdam’ wine popular in USSR

[ 01 Feb. 2007 17:50 ]

Russian president Vladimir Putin at the press conference held in
Kremlin answered the question about the settlement of Nagorno
Karabakh conflict, APA Russian bureau reports.

Putin said that it is a complicated problem and Russia tries to help
Azerbaijan and Armenia for finding way of solution favorable for both
parties.
`But we can not exert pressure on the parties. Otherwise we will
damage our relations either with Armenian or with Azerbaijani people.
Therefore the parties should themselves find the way out. For
example, Azerbaijan and Armenia can together produce cheap `Aghdam’
wine popular in the USSR,’ he said.
Asked why Russia keeps military bases in Armenia Vladimir Putin said
that Russian military bases abroad left since Soviet period.
`It does not concern only Armenia, but Tajikistan as well. Russian
base in Armenia is not against the interests of any country of the
region, as well as Azerbaijan,’ he said. /APA/

Zabelle Goorabian leaves Fresno with a legacy of giving

Fresno Bee , CA
Feb 1 2007

Zabelle Goorabian leaves Fresno with a legacy of giving

By Jim Steinberg / The Fresno Bee02/01/07 05:10:32

A family graveside service for longtime Fresno benefactor Zabelle
Karahadian Goorabian will be held Friday, followed at 11 a.m. by a
memorial service and luncheon at Pilgrim Armenian Congregational
Church.

Mrs. Goorabian gave her energies and financial support for decades to
Fresno religious, cultural and athletic projects. She died Friday, at
90, from effects of a stroke she suffered last year.

She and her late husband, Harry, supported the Fresno Philharmonic,
the Fresno Metropolitan Museum and Fresno Art Museum. They
established the Goorabian Family Life Center at Pilgrim Armenian
Congregational Church.

Harry "Har" Goorabian died in 1997. The couple founded Mid Valley
Distributors in Fresno, which became a dominant Central California
wholesaler of nuts, bolts and fasteners.

After her husband’s death, Mrs. Goorabian saw to it that the city of
Fresno, Riverpark Little League and young Fresnans in general could
enjoy Harry Goorabian Park in north Fresno.

Mrs. Goorabian was born in Fresno. She graduated from Roosevelt High
School and Fresno State College. She joined the business office of
the Karahadian family’s raisin packing company.

Mrs. Goorabian became an active supporter of the California Armenian
Home.

The Rev. Roger Minassian, former pastor of Pilgrim Armenian
Congregational Church, worked with Mrs. Goorabian, who had no
children, to establish the Goorabian Family Life Center there.

"She was a person of giving," Minassian said. "She had compassion for
the young."

Nephew Dr. Edward Karahadian III, a Fresno dentist, called his aunt
"a very dignified, modern woman for someone born to an ethnic family
in 1916. She and my uncle had an epic love affair, a wonderful life
together. She became my second mother and the matriarch of our clan."

Landscape architect Robert Boro worked with Mrs. Goorabian at the
California Armenian Home and the Goorabian ballpark.

"She was fun-loving," Boro said. "She enjoyed all those projects, and
took a personal interest."

Niece Allison Karahadian called her aunt a great listener who was
"easy to love." She taught by example at holiday and Sunday night
dinners, and around the kitchen sink afterward, that "this is
family," Karahadian said.

The family requests that any remembrance be sent to the California
Armenian Home, Children’s Hospital Central California or Hope Now for
Youth.

Hrant Dink’s Death

ZNet, MA
Feb 1 2007

Hrant Dink’s Death

by Ali Saysel
February 01, 2007

Hrant Dink, the prominent Armenian intellectual of Turkey, co-founder
and the editor-in-chief of the Armenian weekly Agos was shot dead on
19th January at around 3 pm on one of the busiest streets of
Istanbul, just in front of the apartment block home to Agos’s small
office. Hrant Dink was known as a vocal and true defender of people’s
fraternity, equity and freedom of expression. He was courageous
enough to express in Turkey that "1915 was genocide", even though he
knew very well about the many articles in Turkish Penal Code that can
immediately criminalize anyone making such a claim publicly. And he
had held a true standard of freedom of expression that urged him to
express in France that "1915 was not genocide", ridiculing French
Parliament’s ruling against such contrary claims.

Hrant Dink was born in 1954 in Malatya, one of the many eastern towns
of Turkey, all once home to a lively Armenian community before 1915.
At the age of seven, with his family, he migrated to Istanbul and had
his primary education in Armenian orphanages and minority schools. He
studied zoology and philosophy in Istanbul University. He had somehow
been active in the leftist movement in the 70’s, managed a large
Armenian summer school in the 80’s, had his first journalism
experience in Patriarchate’s office and in 1996 co-found the weekly
Agos with the purpose of building a bridge between the Armenian and
Turkish communities, to be the voice of the Armenian community and to
fight against all sorts of injustices against those who are
underprivileged and in particular the Armenians. But Hrant Dink’s
impact and reach had been beyond Agos, with his speeches and columns
published in other dissident and sometimes in main-stream media and
press, and through his participation in many forums and democratic
platforms.

There have been many responses to his assassination. For the Armenian
community, perhaps it was a trauma recalling the sufferings that are
well written on their national folklore and common memory. Were their
elders right when they warned the young Armenians that Turks are not
dependable? Were Hrant and his friends over-optimistic in thinking
that Turks can actually change? His friends, the rather thin
democratic groups, leftists and some liberals had an emotional
turmoil knowing that Hrant was not the first and probably would not
be the last. After all, since the Turkish state was established in
1923, 69 prominent journalists were killed, excluding the "less
valuable" ones, like the over 26 mostly Kurdish media workers that
disappeared between 1992-1995. For the state and its cogs in the
elite-press, this murder was awful, inhuman and would obviously harm
Turkey’s foreign interests. The perpetrators had to be brought before
justice, now it was time to question the nationalist and jingoist
atmosphere in the country, yet without any specific reference to
their own contribution in the creation of this nationalist
atmosphere. Finally, the extreme nationalists and national-islamists
adopted a rather pragmatic, hence hypocritical stand saying that the
murder was detrimental for the national interests and therefore that
could be a conspiracy of foreign intelligence units like MOSSAD and
CIA and their local collaborators, or rather Armenian diaspora trying
to break down the national unity and the national identity of the
country.

Who then killed Hrant Dink? It had been easy to catch the hoodlum, a
seventeen years old male, an easy recruit probably acting for his
bigger brother’s group which was possibly subcontracted by some more
experienced group that involves real professionals with considerable
counterinsurgency experience in official service. Following the fate
of previous investigations for other assassins of prominent
intellectuals and activists, there is not much hope that this inquiry
will go deep enough to discover the real criminal elements. For
instance, Hrant Dink’s lawyer says that he was receiving death treats
from a retired General, Veli Küçük who has been allegedly organizing
and commanding Special Forces in Gendarmerie before his retirement.
General Küçük stays active after his retirement conducting a group of
lawyers bringing lawsuits against the prominent intellectuals and
thus victimizing them by organized insulting demonstrations in front
of the courts while the sessions are being held. Almost ten days
after the assassination, none of these people are questioned by the
authorities yet.

There are many assassinations in the recent history of Turkey that
are very well known by the public and have become a common memory of
the Turkish and Kurdish dissidents. When the voice of the opposition
needs to be suppressed, a prominent intellectual or human rights
activist is murdered, followed by others, until a terror atmosphere
is created where no one dares to speak out, so that some sections of
the state apparatus can implement their sinister hidden agenda.

It can be argued that, Dink had been the victim of Turkish
militarism. The military and the political parties deliberately
sought to create a jingoist-militarist cultural atmosphere; the
mass-media, mass-culture industry intentionally endorsed and
exploited this ascending culture and helped to create a "lynch
culture" of so-called self motivated hooligans. And under this
atmosphere, the articles in the new Turkish Penal Code of year 2005
and the new Anti-Terror Law of year 2006 deliberately victimized the
human rights activists and intellectuals and labeled them betrayers.

What is then at stake at the moment? During US’s restructuring of the
Middle East, Turkey found its conventional Kurdish denial policy
obsolete. Seeing that it is impossible to avoid an emerging Kurdish
political structure in old Iraqi soils, the military establishment
panicked by projections that the country can be divided if the
millions of Kurds in Turkey pursue common ends with their Iraqi
fellows. The developments in Iraqi Kurdistan and the inability of the
Turkish military to manipulate the situation in Iraq and to suppress
the political demands of Kurds at home raised the atmosphere against
Kurds. Human rights violations in Kurdish regions increased and
approached its 1990s levels at the time when there was a
low-intensity warfare. In the 2005 Newroz celebrations, after a child
burned a Turkish flag, the Chief Army Officer addressed many Kurds as
not proper citizens but "so-called" citizens. In Autumn 2005, in the
border Kurdish town of Semdinli in southeast Turkey, when the
perpetrators of the bombing of a bookstore were unveiled by the local
people they were found out to be army officials. Soon, the judicial
process also accusing the Chief Army Officer for organized conspiracy
was halted by the dismissal of the public prosecutor, to the
disappointment of many Kurds. In April 2006, during the funeral of a
Kurdish armed militant in his hometown, the largest Kurdish town of
Diyarbakir, people revolted against police and the succeeding events
were suppressed in days by force, killing tens of children and adults
on the street.

The political parties, without exception, laid their faith on this
ascending jingoist-militarist atmosphere. The red-white colors of
Turkish nationalism and the crescent-star on Turkish flag became
ordinary objects of propaganda. A conference on "Ottoman Armenians"
in Spring 2005, by three relatively liberal universities in Istanbul
had to be indefinitely postponed because of the rivaling nationalist
attitudes of both the governing and opposition parties in the
Parliament in Ankara. Again, the participants of the conference were
labeled as betrayers before the public.

A TV series, covering illegal acts and crimes of a Turkish mafioso
character against so-called national enemies, his talents on how one
can evade being punished by law had become a cult for teenage males
in the country. Fictions and movies on Turkish forces fighting
against Americans and romantic and legendry versions of Turkish
Liberation War became best sellers in published media. Hitler’s Mein
Kampf sold thousands of copies, by far exceeding the circulation of
any decent book on the shelves in recent years.

Furthermore, thin activist groups and intellectuals were threatened
by law. The year 2005 Turkish Penal Code, TPC 301 "insulting
Turkishness", TPC 216 "inflicting hatred", the special law 5816
"insulting Kemal Ataturk – the founder of the modern republic", and
Anti-Terror Law article 6 "adopting the propaganda of terror
organization", and many other articles were designed to suppress the
truths about suffering underprivileged groups, harass the
intellectuals and label them as betrayers and disrupters before an
extremely nationalistic public. Even their trials were a drama.
Jingoist groups were gathering around the court, insulting and
assaulting, and all this was being watched by the police officials.

Hrant Dink was one of those defendants. He was tried and convicted by
TPC 301. Against all expert opinion before the court, claiming that
Hrant did not insult Turkishness, he was convicted to 6 months
imprisonment by the Supreme Court in Ankara. He was sure of himself
that he did not insult but the verdict was a big disappointment. It
was very difficult for him to be understood and perceived as someone
insulting his Turkish fellows, he would not insult anyone, and under
such circumstances it could even become impossible for him to live
with Turks, with a group of people he had supposedly insulted. Other
fellow defendants of similar trials, like the Nobel Laureate Orhan
Pamuk, Elif Safak and some others were acquitted. Hrant was not,
although he was quite as salient as Pamuk and Safak for the world
public opinion and international community.

He was not acquitted, because he was Armenian. He did something
wrong, something that cannot be tolerated: for the first time since
1915, an Armenian in Turkey stood up and openly claimed that "1915 is
genocide" and at the same time said "I am an Armenian and this is my
country". And he said all this without inflicting any hatred on
Turkish and Kurdish people. He sought equitable means to live
together. That was too much, that was something to be punished.

Eventually, on 19th January, he was assassinated by a seventeen year
old hoodlum. His funeral on 23rd January was quite unanticipated in
many respects. For the first time in Istanbul, over 100.000 people
marched and mourned during a funeral. For the first time in Turkey,
over 100.000 people chanted "We are all Armenians". This obviously
shows an emerging democratic culture against ascending racism and
jingoism in the country. Moreover, for the first time in the country,
the citizens had the chance to see the true human face of a dissident
and the mourning of his friends and relatives on live broadcast
through elite media channels. It proved that, when people are given
the chance to see the truth, they have the ability to understand and
build empathy with the victims. That is, if they can generalize this
feeling onto hundreds of other victims in this country whose names
are unknown to many, a decent public opinion can emerge and can help
building a more democratic society.

Hrant Dink’s life, and unfortunately his funeral taught something. On
the other hand malicious forces are still much larger, much stronger
and much more vocal. The future in Turkey will be one of struggle
between thriving democratic opinion and Turkish militarism, covering
itself as lay people’s nationalism, racism and jingoism.

Ali Saysel is a scholar in Bogazici University, Istanbul and he can
be reached at [email protected]

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

ANKARA: Genocide Bill Refers to Adolf Hitler in Context of Turkey

Hürriyet, Turkey
Feb 1 2007

Armenian genocide bill refers to Adolf Hitler in context of Turkey

The bill proposing official recognition of the Armenians’ claims of
genocide which has been presented to the floor of the US House of
Representatives reportedly references Nazi leader Adolf Hitler in
context of the allegations against Turkey.

The bill, which received signatures from more than 150 members of the
435 member House, requests that the US president refer to the
"Armenian genocide" in his annual April 24 message, and that the
Armenian claims become an accepted part of US foreign policy.
Noteable, one section of the bill even asserts that Nazi leader Adolf
Hitler was "imitating the Turks" in his actions. The bill notes that
Hitler, prior to invading Poland, queried "Who even remembers that
the Armenians were wiped out?"

Sources in the US capital note that, at this point, it looks very
likely that the Armenian bill will in fact pass through the US
Congress.

Microsoft to implement investing, educational, innovation programs

Arka News Agency, Armenia
Feb 1 2007

MICROSOFT TO IMPLEMENT INVESTING, EDUCATIONAL, INNOVATION PROGRAMS IN
ARMENIA

YEREVAN, January 31. /ARKA/. Armenia’s Government and the Microsoft
Corporation signed an agreement on cooperation in Edinburgh last
night.
The Press Service of Armenia’s Ministry of Trade and Economic
Development reported that the agreement was signed by Karen
Chshmarityan, Armenia’s Minister of Trade and Economic Development,
and Bill Gates, the President of Microsoft Corporation.
According to the agreement, Microsoft will implement a number of
investing, educational and innovation programs, the press-service
said. In particular, it envisages setting up of a Microsoft
Innovation Center in Armenia.
In its turn, Armenia’s Government will continue making efforts in
protecting the copyright of the company under the country’s
legislation and will take measures to apply licensed packages of
Microsoft programs in the state system.
"As far back as in September 2006, under the IT Month held in
Yerevan, Armenia’s Prime-Minister and the European Regional
Vice-President of Microsoft reached an understanding to start the
Microsoft-Armenia’s Government strategic cooperation," the press
release says.
The subsequent long and intensive negotiations resulted in a text of
agreement and an understanding to sign the agreement on cooperation
in Edinburgh in the course of the Government Leaders Forum – Europe.
The Armenian delegation headed by the Minister of Trade and Economic
Development Karen Chshmarityan left for Scotland on January 29, at
the invitation of the Microsoft Corporation.
The Ambassador to the United Kingdom Vahe Gabrielyan, the Advisor to
the Prime-Minister Ara Hakobyan and the Director of Enterprise
Incubator Fund Bagrat Engibaryan were in the Armenian delegation.
The signing of the agreement with Microsoft is the logical
continuation of the strategic cooperation with such leading companies
as Alcatel SUN – Mycrosystems, Hewlett&Packard, to develop IT sphere,
which has been declared a priority by the Government, the
press-release says. N.V. -0–

Azeri party failed to lead OSCE observers to its frontline

DeFacto Agency, Armenia
Feb 1 2007

AZERI PARTY FAILED TO LEAD OSCE OBSERVERS TO ITS FRONTLINE

January 31, according to an agreement achieved with the
Nagorno-Karabakh Republic leadership, the OSCE Mission held a planned
monitoring of the Nagorno-Karabakh and Azeri Armed Forces’ contact
line in the east direction of the Talysh populated locality of the
Nagorno-Karabakh Republic Martakert region.
According to the information DE FACTO got at the NKR MFA, from the
positions of the NKR Defense Army the monitoring had been held by the
OSCE Office Coordinator Imre Palatinus (Hungary), Field Assistants of
the OSCE Chair-in-Office’s Personal Representative Gunter Folk
(Germany) and Miroslav Vymetal (Czechia).
The monitoring passed according to the schedule. However, the Azeri
party again failed to lead the OSCE observers to its frontline. No
cease-fire violations were fixed in the course of the monitoring.
>From the Karabakh party the observation mission was accompanied by
the NKR MFA and MOD officials.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

BAKU: Mammadov: Azerbaijan should participate in all PACE programs

Azeri Press Agency, Azerbaijan
Feb 1 2007

Ambassador Arif Mammadov: Azerbaijan should participate in all
programs of the PACE

[ 01 Feb. 2007 16:21 ]

The head of Permanent Office of Azerbaijan to Parliamentary Assembly
of the Council of Europe, Ambassador Arif Mammadov interviewed by the
APA European bureau

– What are the differences and similarities in the working principles
of European Union (EU) and Council of Europe (CE)?
– The main difference between the EU and CE for Azerbaijan is that we
are the member of the CE, but not the EU. Of course, the EU is a
unity of mighty states both from economic and political points of
view. EUR100bn budget organization has great financial potential and
its opportunities are broad. The EU is not an international
organization but a union of states assumed any national authorities
entrusted to the EU. The CE is an international organization and the
problems on human rights and democracy are attached special
importance. We always express our opinion as a member of this
organization. The EU Neighborhood Policy program includes, for
example, packet of finances, projects and programs of economic
character. Azerbaijani president during his visit to Belgium and the
EU said that compared with previous 10 years, Azerbaijan does not
need financial aid and humanitarian programs. We are a mighty state
from economic point of view, and our need is mainly connected with
democratic development of our society. I think that the CE’s role in
this field is very important. Even if a country is strong and rich
from economic point of view, it will be weak in case democratic civil
society is not established. Therefore the CE’s activity, role and our
work is very important in this sphere. Besides, EU-CE partnership in
this field is very important for us.
– As a diplomat working in Europe for a long time, do you think it is
possible to coordinate European values and values of Azerbaijan?
– I was in contact with the EU for a long time, and it made influence
on my outlook and other matters. For example, Armenian ambassador has
again exaggerated the problem of Armenian genocide recently. I said
we should look forward. The nation that quotes to the past, remains
in the past, the nation that sees the future, looks forward to the
future will always move forward. I told them that they touch upon the
problems happened at the beginning of the XX century, and who will
speak about the happenings of the end of XX century. To know
literature and quote to history is good, but to live with obscure
past, will do no good to a man, or to the state. We should think only
about the future. Europe suggests it. Europe suggests that we should
establish strong, mighty, democratic society by peace. We should
develop and think about strengthening our societies and countries. I
think that the society where democratic principles develop more will
be powerful from economic point of view. The stronger our democracy
and economy are, the more important Azerbaijan nation will be.
Azerbaijani president always says that we are ready to give authority
to ethnic Armenians and create conditions for their economic
development as Azerbaijani citizens. Azerbaijan is ready to
contribute more-than-its-budget to the development of Nagorno
Karabakh. Our citizens living there should know that to live within
Azerbaijani borders and government, to be Azerbaijani citizen, to
develop in democratic Azerbaijani society means the development of
their future generation.
– What kind of innovations do you expect from Azerbaijan and CE
relations?
– I think we should join discussions covering all issues. If we
pursue this policy the interest to our country will increase in
European countries. That is, it is important not to waste our
opportunity, our active participation in the discussions of issues on
international problems, energy, human rights is very important not
only for Azerbaijan but also for Caucasus region. The role of member
countries strengthen in CE and it consider that EU is not satisfied
with it in some points. The weight of Russia, as well as other
countries in CE increase, pressure mechanisms expands; strong
politicians and diplomats are involved to this issue. You know that
EU has passed decision on establishment of Fundamental Laws Agency.
It is stated that this agency will not hamper the activity of EC and
European court of human rights. But this is only statements; I think
that EU wants to establish the agency to discuss its issues only by
means of this institution. If we take into consideration the work of
the EC in various counties, it is possible to say that the goal of
this agency is to limit all of these. The weekly budget of EU equals
in annual budget of CE, and then it is doubtless that these problems
will appear. Against the background of these processes, we should
show positive sides of Azerbaijan, represent ourselves as close
country to European values, and every-one should see that Azerbaijan
made proposals that can be understood and admitted in European level.
The economy and establishment of civil society should develop in
parallel. We should actively partake in all programs of EC. It is
important to implement it not only in Baku, but also in all regions.
Europe has a great experience in the above mentioned fields and we
have no alternative. Everything begins with mentality; we should
accelerate adaptation to European mentality. It should not be only
state policy; generally, different programs should be implemented in
the society. These programs are pushes for the development of the
society. For example let’s take the education of our students in
foreign countries. Azerbaijani president’s decree on education of
students abroad is one of the great steps in this sphere. From this
point of view I consider that we should not be satisfied with
36%-economic growth, should step forward for the adaptation to
European standards. As you get acquainted with the documents signed
with CE, you understand that these documents bear great importance
for Azerbaijan. We should look for the ways how to implement these
documents. /APA/

BAKU: Statement of OSCE Co-chairs Made Public

Ïðàî ûáîðà, Azerbaijan
Democratic Azerbaijan
Feb 1 2007

Statement of OSCE Co-chairs Made Public
01.02.2007

OSCE Minsk Group co-chairs, Yuriy Merzlyakov (Russia), Bernard
Fassier (France) and Matthew Bryza (USA) dealing with regulation of
Armenian-Azerbaijani, Nagorni Garabagh conflict made statement.
Statement, received by Azer-Tac from US Embassy to Baku, says that
co-chairs are satisfied with constructive approach demonstrated by
leaders of Azerbaijan and Armenia in the course of recent talks held
to regulate the conflict.
Co-chairs underline that they are inspired by constructiveness
demonstrated by leaders of both states while defining combined
principles to regulate Nagorni Garabagh conflict.
Statement touches upon meeting of Ministers of Foreign Affairs of
Azerbaijan and Armenia, Elmar Mamadyarov, Vardan Oskanyan with Minsk
Group co-chairs held January 23 in Moscow, and meeting of co-chairs
with President of Azerbaijan, Ilham Aliyev, January 23, and leader of
separatist regime in Nagorni Garabagh, Arkadiy Gukasyan, January 25,
and President of Armenia, Robert Kocharyan, in Yerevan.
Evaluating efforts of all parties they met co-chairs stress that
searching for ways for stable and peaceful regulation of
Nagorni-Garabagh conflict is referred to Presidents of Azerbaijan and
Armenia. Co-chairs will assist them in this respect.
Statement reads that both presidents actively defend their national
interests the way that provides opportunity to continue peace
process. Co-chairs call on parties to prepare societies of their
countries to compromise and to the search for measures for trust and
mutual understanding and maintenance of cease-fire regime at the same
time maintaining achieved results.