ZNet: Hrant Dink’s Death

Hrant Dink’s Death
Ali Saysel
ZNet
Feb. 1, 2007
ectionID=3D74&ItemID=3D12009

Hrant Dink, the prominent Armenian intellectual of Turkey, co-founder
and the editor-in-chief of the Armenian weekly Agos was shot dead on
19th January at around 3 pm on one of the busiest streets of Istanbul,
just in front ofthe apartment block home to Agos’s small office. Hrant
Dink was known as a vocal and true defender of people’s fraternity,
equity and freedom of expression.

He was courageous enough to express in Turkey that "1915 was
genocide", even though he knew very well about the many articles in
Turkish Penal Code that can immediately criminalize anyone making such
a claim publicly. And he had held a true standard of freedom of
expression that urged him to express in France that "1915 was not
genocide", ridiculing French Parliament’s ruling against such contrary
claims.

Hrant Dink was born in 1954 in Malatya, one of the many eastern towns
of Turkey, all once home to a lively Armenian community before
1915. At the age of seven, with his family, he migrated to Istanbul
and had his primary education in Armenian orphanages and minority
schools. He studied zoology and philosophy in Istanbul University. He
had somehow been active in the leftist movement in the 70’s, managed a
large Armenian summer school in the 80’s, had his first journalism
experience in Patriarchate’s office and in 1996 co-found the weekly
Agos with the purpose of building a bridge between the Armenian and
Turkish communities, to be the voice of the Armenian community and to
fight against all sorts of injustices against those who are
underprivileged and in particular the Armenians. But Hrant Dink’s
impact and reach had been beyond Agos, with his speeches and columns
published in other dissident and sometimes in main-stream media and
press, and through his participation in many forums and democratic
platforms.

There have been many responses to his assassination. For the Armenian
community, perhaps it was a trauma recalling the sufferings that are
well written on their national folklore and common memory. Were their
elders right when they warned the young Armenians that Turks are not
dependable? Were Hrant and his friends over-optimistic in thinking
that Turks can actually change? His friends, the rather thin
democratic groups, leftists and some liberals hadan emotional turmoil
knowing that Hrant was not the first and probably would not be the
last. After all, since the Turkish state was established in 1923, 69
prominent journalists were killed, excluding the "less valuable" ones,
like the over 26 mostly Kurdish media workers that disappeared between
1992-1995.

For the state and its cogs in the elite-press, this murder was awful,
inhuman and would obviously harm Turkey’s foreign interests. The
perpetrators hadto be brought before justice, now it was time to
question the nationalist and jingoist atmosphere in the country, yet
without any specific reference to their own contribution in the
creation of this nationalist atmosphere. Finally, the extreme
nationalists and national-islamists adopted a rather pragmatic, hence
hypocritical stand saying that the murder was detrimental for the
national interests and therefore that could be a conspiracy of foreign
intelligence units like MOSSAD and CIA and their local collaborators,
or rather Armenian diaspora trying to break down the national unity
and the national identityof the country.

Who then killed Hrant Dink? It had been easy to catch the hoodlum, a
seventeen years old male, an easy recruit probably acting for his
bigger brother’s group which was possibly subcontracted by some more
experienced group that involves real professionals with considerable
counterinsurgency experiencein official service. Following the fate of
previous investigations for other assassins of prominent intellectuals
and activists, there is not much hopethat this inquiry will go deep
enough to discover the real criminal elements. For instance, Hrant
Dink’s lawyer says that he was receiving death treats froma retired
General, Veli Küçük who has been allegedly organizing and commanding
Special Forces in Gendarmerie before his retirement. General Küçük
stays active after his retirement conducting a group of lawyers
bringing lawsuits against the prominent intellectuals and thus
victimizing them by organized insulting demonstrations in front of the
courts while the sessions are being held.

Almost ten days after the assassination, none of these people are
questioned by the authorities yet.

There are many assassinations in the recent history of Turkey that are
very well known by the public and have become a common memory of the
Turkish and Kurdish dissidents. When the voice of the opposition needs
to be suppressed, a prominent intellectual or human rights activist is
murdered, followed by others, until a terror atmosphere is created
where no one dares to speak out, so that some sections of the state
apparatus can implement their sinister hidden agenda.

It can be argued that, Dink had been the victim of Turkish
militarism. The military and the political parties deliberately sought
to create a jingoist-militarist cultural atmosphere; the mass-media,
mass-culture industry intentionally endorsed and exploited this
ascending culture and helped to create a "lynch culture" of so-called
self motivated hooligans. And under this atmosphere, the articles in
the new Turkish Penal Code of year 2005 and the new Anti-Terror Law of
year 2006 deliberately victimized the human rights activists and
intellectuals and labeled them betrayers.

What is then at stake at the moment? During US’s restructuring of the
Middle East, Turkey found its conventional Kurdish denial policy
obsolete. Seeing that it is impossible to avoid an emerging Kurdish
political structure in old Iraqi soils, the military establishment
panicked by projections that the country can be divided if the
millions of Kurds in Turkey pursue common ends with their Iraqi
fellows. The developments in Iraqi Kurdistan and the inability of the
Turkish military to manipulate the situation in Iraq and to suppress
the political demands of Kurds at home raised the atmosphere against
Kurds.

Human rights violations in Kurdish regions increased and approached
its 1990s levels at the time when there was a low-intensity
warfare. In the 2005 Newroz celebrations, after a child burned a
Turkish flag, the Chief Army Officer addressed many Kurds as not
proper citizens but "so-called" citizens. In Autumn 2005, in the
border Kurdish town of Semdinli in southeast Turkey, when the
perpetrators of the bombing of a bookstore were unveiled by the local
people they were found out to be army officials. Soon, the judicial
process also accusing the Chief Army Officer for organized conspiracy
was halted by the dismissal of the public prosecutor, to the
disappointment of many Kurds. In April 2006, during the funeral of a
Kurdish armed militant in his hometown, the largest Kurdish town of
Diyarbakir, people revolted against police and the succeeding events
were suppressed in days by force, killing tens of children and adults
on the street.

The political parties, without exception, laid their faith on this
ascending jingoist-militarist atmosphere. The red-white colors of
Turkish nationalism and the crescent-star on Turkish flag became
ordinary objects of propaganda.

A conference on "Ottoman Armenians" in Spring 2005, by three
relatively liberal universities in Istanbul had to be indefinitely
postponed becauseof the rivaling nationalist attitudes of both the
governing and opposition parties in the Parliament in Ankara. Again,
the participants of the conference were labeled as betrayers before
the public.

A TV series, covering illegal acts and crimes of a Turkish mafioso
character against so-called national enemies, his talents on how one
can evade being punished by law had become a cult for teenage males in
the country. Fictions and movies on Turkish forces fighting against
Americans and romantic and legendry versions of Turkish Liberation War
became best sellers in published media. Hitler’s Mein Kampf sold
thousands of copies, by far exceeding the circulation of any decent
book on the shelves in recent years.

Furthermore, thin activist groups and intellectuals were threatened by
law.

The year 2005 Turkish Penal Code, TPC 301 "insulting Turkishness", TPC
216 "inflicting hatred", the special law 5816 "insulting Kemal Ataturk
– the founder of the modern republic", and Anti-Terror Law article 6
"adopting the propaganda of terror organization", and many other
articles were designed to suppress the truths about suffering
underprivileged groups, harass the intellectuals and label them as
betrayers and disrupters before an extremely nationalistic
public. Even their trials were a drama. Jingoist groups weregathering
around the court, insulting and assaulting, and all this was being
watchedby the police officials.

Hrant Dink was one of those defendants. He was tried and convicted by
TPC 301. Against all expert opinion before the court, claiming that
Hrant did not insult Turkishness, he was convicted to 6 months
imprisonment by the Supreme Court in Ankara. He was sure of himself
that he did not insult but the verdict was a big disappointment. It
was very difficult for him to be understood and perceived as someone
insulting his Turkish fellows, he would not insult anyone, and under
such circumstances it could even become impossible for him to live
with Turks, with a group of people he had supposedly insulted. Other
fellow defendants of similar trials, like the Nobel Laureate Orhan
Pamuk,Elif Safak and some others were acquitted. Hrant was not,
although he was quiteas salient as Pamuk and Safak for the world
public opinion and international community.

He was not acquitted, because he was Armenian. He did something wrong,
something that cannot be tolerated: for the first time since 1915, an
Armenian in Turkey stood up and openly claimed that "1915 is genocide"
and at the same time said "I am an Armenian and this is my
country". And he said all this without inflicting any hatred on
Turkish and Kurdish people. He sought equitable means to live
together. That was too much, that was something to be punished.

Eventually, on 19th January, he was assassinated by a seventeen year
old hoodlum. His funeral on 23rd January was quite unanticipated in
many respects.

For the first time in Istanbul, over 100.000 people marched and
mourned during a funeral. For the first time in Turkey, over 100.000
people chanted "We are all Armenians". This obviously shows an
emerging democratic culture against ascending racism and jingoism in
the country. Moreover, for the first time in the country, the citizens
had the chance to see the true human face of a dissident and the
mourning of his friends and relatives on live broadcast through elite
media channels. It proved that, when people are given the chance to
see the truth, they have the ability to understand and build empathy
with the victims. That is, if they can generalize this feeling onto
hundreds of other victims in this country whose names are unknown to
many, a decent public opinion can emerge and can help building a more
democratic society.

Hrant Dink’s life, and unfortunately his funeral taught something. On
the other hand malicious forces are still much larger, much stronger
and much more vocal. The future in Turkey will be one of struggle
between thriving democratic opinion and Turkish militarism, covering
itself as lay people’s nationalism, racism and jingoism.

Ali Saysel is a scholar in Bogazici University, Istanbul and he can be
reached at [email protected]

http://www.zmag.org/content/showarticle.cfm?S

BAKU: No one can deprive Azerbaijan of right to restore terr. integ.

Today, Azerbaijan
Jan 31 2007

Tahir Tagizade: "No one can deprive Azerbaijan of right to restore
territorial integrity"

31 January 2007 [17:01] – Today.Az

"Azerbaijan has the right to restore its territorial integrity, and
no one can deprive us of it. We won’t give up this right either,"
Foreign Affairs Ministry press and information policy department
chief Tahir Tagizade told while commenting on Armenian Foreign
Minister Vardan Oskanian’s statement during his visit in Netherlands
that Azerbaijan will never dare to attack Armenia.

Tahir Tagizade stated that Azerbaijan has never been against the
territorial integrity of any country and attacked sovereignty of any
country, APA reports.

Vardan Oskanian had regarded had co-chairs’ proposals as logical,
saying "If these propositions are considered in the settlement, the
conflict will find a solution not contradicting Armenia’s national
interests, and ensuring the principles of security and
self-determination of Nagorno Karabakh people and their continual
contacts to Armenia.

Tahir Tagizade said he has to correct Armenian FM’s statement.

"Matter is not Nagorno Karabakh people, but Azerbaijani and Armenian
communities living in the region. These people have the right of
self-determination, but only within Azerbaijan’s territorial
integrity. This may be the highest authority within Azerbaijan. As
for Armeni’s relations with Nagorno Karabakh, Armenian Diaspora in
Nagorno Karabakh has the right to make relations with Armenia as
Azerbaijan has the same right with Nakhchivan Autonomous Republic. We
have declared not once about the infrastructural projects considering
both of these issues. As for the security, Azerbaijani officials have
stated that the first phrase of the settlement includes the security
of Nagorno Karabakh people and strengthening of mutual confidence,"
he said.

URL:

http://www.today.az/news/politics/35711.html

BAKU: Electronic war likely to harm Armenia more, ICT Minister says

Today, Azerbaijan
Jan 31 2007

Electronic war likely to harm Armenia more, ICT Minister says

31 January 2007 [16:43] – Today.Az

"The electronic war between Azerbaijan and Armenia appears
undesirable. Azerbaijan enjoys much more technical and financial
potential (levers), so this hostility is likely to harm Armenia
more," Azerbaijan’s Information and Technologies Minister, Ali
Abbasov, stated.

He said that the only solution to the problem is that Azerbaijan and
Armenia should join Convention on cyber-crime and honor this
agreement.

Recommending both Armenian and Azerbaijani hackers to avoid attacking
websites, the Minister said Azerbaijan has a legal base to ensure
security of its websites.

As per the Information Law, Internet providers are responsible for
defense of websites, APA reports.

URL:

http://www.today.az/news/business/35710.html

Armenian genocide resolution renewed

Fresno Bee, CA
Jan 31 2007

Armenian genocide resolution renewed

Supporters hope reshaped Congress can vault over White House
opposition.By Michael Doyle / Bee Washington Bureau01/31/07 04:41:20

WASHINGTON – Armenian-Americans are putting their hopes in a new
Democratic Congress.

So are some Republicans.

On Tuesday, lawmakers and their politically active Armenian-American
allies introduced the latest version of an Armenian genocide
resolution. After years of trying, they now think they can prevail
over the Bush administration’s strong opposition.

"I’m very hopeful that this time we’ll be able to do this," said Rep.
George Radanovich, R-Mariposa.

Under the aged and watchful eyes of two genocide survivors – one of
them said to be 100 years old – Radanovich helped reintroduce a
resolution that will incite controversy even though it lacks the
force of law.

Joined by three other House members, one Republican and two
Democrats, Radanovich is sponsoring what’s being called the
"affirmation of the United States record on the Armenian Genocide."
Essentially, the 10-page resolution puts the House on the side of
Armenians and many historians who have studied the period between
1915 and 1923.

Some 1.5 million Armenians were killed as part of a policy of
extermination conducted during the final days of the Ottoman Empire,
the resolution asserts. The nonbinding resolution further calls upon
President Bush to use the word "genocide" in his annual April message
commemorating the horrific events.

Bush and preceding presidents, attentive to the concerns of Turkey
and the State Department, have delicately avoided using the term
genocide when referring to Armenia. Diplomatically, it’s a sensitive
issue. The last U.S. ambassador to Armenia, John Evans, appears to
have been forced from his post after he gave a public speech
affirming there was a genocide.

"Armenian Americans have attempted to extricate and isolate their
history from the complex circumstances in which their ancestors were
embroiled," the Turkish Embassy declared in a statement. "In so
doing, they describe a world populated only by white-hatted heroes
and black-hatted villains."

Turkey dismisses as "grossly erroneous" the claim that 1.5million
Armenians were killed. A member of NATO now hoping to join the
European Union, Turkey enjoys its own Capitol Hill clout with the
assistance of well-placed lobbyists, including one-time Congress
member Bob Livingston.

Rep. Adam Schiff, D-Pasadena, is the Armenian genocide resolution’s
chief sponsor since his party took control of the House.

"I do think we have the best opportunity in a decade to succeed,"
Schiff said, "but no one should be under the illusion that this will
be easy."

Radanovich was the chief sponsor under Republican control, but had
the rug pulled out from underneath him by GOP leaders. Former House
Speaker Dennis Hastert first promised to let Radanovich bring an
earlier Armenian genocide resolution to the House floor, then
reversed himself at the last minute after receiving a call from the
White House.

Current House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, as a rank-and-file member in
previous years, was a supporter of the genocide resolution.

"We’ve got a speaker now who we think is receptive," said Paul
Jamushian, an activist who splits his time between Fresno and the
East Coast. "We’ve always had the votes."

Lawmakers acknowledged Tuesday that they had not yet received a
commitment from Pelosi, although they predicted she will face White
House pressure before April.

"Make no mistake," Radanovich said. "The speaker will get a call from
the president."

Resolution authors say they expect to rally at least 140 House
co-sponsors.

The new chairman of the House International Relations Committee, Rep.
Tom Lantos, D-San Mateo, voted for a genocide resolution the last
time it appeared, although in previous years he opposed it.

Hypothec crediting program adopted in NKR

DeFacto Agency, Armenia
Jan 31 2007

HYPOTHEC CREDITING PROGRAM ADOPTED IN NKR

In the course of a sitting held last Tuesday the Nagorno-Karabakh
Republic government adopted a hypothec crediting program.
According to the information DE FACTO got at the NKR government’s
press service today, it is the first long-term program aimed at
improving the citizens’ housing conditions and stimulating housing
construction in the Republic.
According to the program, the amount of the hypothec credit will make
up to 15 millions drams; however, it must not surpass 80 % of the
cost of the flat or that of an individual housing’s construction. The
credit will be granted for a term up to 20 years at a year’s rate of
6 %.

ANKARA: Ertugrul Ozkok: Those Armenians will never be men

Hürriyet, Turkey
Jan 31 2007

Ertugrul Ozkok:Those Armenians will never be men

I grew up with the following phrase, which my now-dead father used to
whisper often into my ear when I was a child: "My son, these
Armenians are incapable of being true men…."

Even when I protested, he would insist "You just don’t know these
things." In France, when I was student, many of my friends held the
same views as my father. When I would say "Armenians have been
changed by the Armenian diaspora," my friends would reply "No my
friend, these people can never change. An Armenian is an Armenian."

I was naive. Very naive. Even when the father of one of my best
friends was killed by an Armenian terrorist in Madrid, I still held
onto my beliefs. Even when I saw that not a single Armenian tear was
shed for one of our many diplomats killed in Western capitals, I
still didn’t sway from my naive beliefs.

When I learned that one of these Armenian killers wasn’t even a full
adult yet, one of these same friends of mine said "You see, that’s
it. Is the Armenian society as a full even adult?" He then went on to
add:

"The Armenians live in a society that has been prevented from
maturing. The time has come to ask this question: I wonder if the
Armenian society, which turns its own character problems into violent
acts against others, is a society which remains immature in order to
carry out these acts?"

I was always told this by those around me: "Of course some Armenians
can change, but the other Armenians? Never."

Yes, my whole life has passed hearing these things about Armenians.

******

OK, let’s leave this idiocy behind and return to reality. My own
now-dead father in his whole entire life never said anything about
Armenians to me. And not just Armenians; he also never said a bad
word about the Bulgarians, despite the fact that he had escaped from
Bulgaria to Turkey with just his life. I never heard anything like
"Those Bulgarians will never be men. They are killers who will never
change" from him. This, despite the fact that we lost many many
relatives in the Balkan Wars. Also, my friend whose father was killed
by ASALA terrorists in Madrid actually never said anything bad about
Armenians either. To the contrary, he put extra effort into
strengthening the bonds between Turks and Armenians living in Turkey.
And we, as a society, when putting our murdered diplomats to rest
after their deaths, spoke only of "ASALA terror," not of the
Armenians.

******

But then where did I come up with the disgusting first part of this
column today? Well, I did not make it up. I read it in a column by
Zaman newspaper’s Etyen Mahcupyan. In other words, in a column by the
new general editor of the Agos newspaper. Not only this, I read it
only days after one of the biggest funeral ceremonies this country
has ever participated in. After the most sincere songs ever sung for
someone for whom we mourned were sung. What I wrote above, in the
first part of this column, was exactly what Etyen Mahcupyan wrote in
his column, with one difference: instead of writing about Armenians,
he was writing about Turks. The main point of his article was that
"Turks can never change…." And so, I decided to write my today’s
column just to show how incorrect this perspective is. I also
apologize to all the Armenian citizens of this country who I know
love this country as much as I do. I am sure they were made
uncomfortable by the tone of the start of this column. And for that
reason, I think it’s necessary that the Armenian intellectuals in
this country use a more careful style from now on in their writings.

BAKU: Henick: Kosovo model shouldn’t be taken as an example for NK

Azeri Press Agency, Azerbaijan
Jan 31 2007

Jonathan Henick: `The Kosovo model shouldn’t be taken as an example
for Nagorno-Karabakh conflict resolution’

[ 31 Jan. 2007 15:59 ]

The Head of Public Affairs Department of US embassy in Baku Jonathan
Henick interviewed by the APA

– How will develop the relations between Azerbaijan and USA during
this year?
– Our relations continue to be very strong and continue to develop.
To give you an example, next week we will have an Economic
Partnership Commission meeting here in Baku. We believe that it is
time to take our cooperation and dialogue on economic issues to a
higher level. This new commission will be chaired by Finance Minister
Samir Sharifov and on US side by Assistant Secretary of State on
Economic, Energy, and Business affairs Dan Sullivan. Participants
will include senior officials from a number of different agencies.
The commission meeting will take place next week on February 7th. We
continue working very closely on energy, military and security
issues. There should be some discussions on energy issues as part of
the commission. In coming several weeks we will also have discussions
on military and security issues. And, of course, the US continues to
be very active in working with the Minsk Group of OSCE to find the
resolution to the conflict.
– Is it possible that section 907 will be annuled?
– It is difficult to comment on this issue. The US administration
believes that section 907 is an obstacle to cooperation and bilateral
relations between our countries. And we favor the complete
elimination of section 907. At the same time this is part of US
legislation and so only the US congress can make a decision on
whether to completely repeal 907. I have no information about the new
Congress’ intentions on this issue. However, the administration
remains committed to continue to waive the provisions of 907 each
year.
– USA doesn’t approve the construction of
Baku-Tbilisi-Axalkalaki-Kars because Armenia is not participating in
it. Did USA offer Armenia that if the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict is
solved with Azerbaijan’s territory unity condition Armenia could join
the project?
– There are no such discussions that I am aware of. I will repeat
what Deputy Assistant Secretary Bryza said the last time he was here
– that the US doesn’t oppose the construction of this railroad. In
fact we are taking no measures of any kind to slow down this project.
There was a misunderstanding created by a legislative measure. This
measure was adopted by the Congress and signed by the President as
part of the Export-Import Bank Reauthorization Act. What that measure
did was to prohibit any official assistance that the US government
could provide, but this does not mean that the US opposes the
project. Projects like this, for example the Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan
pipeline, are financed by private companies, these are not projects
financed by governments. So if this project is commercially viable
then I see no obstacles to the successful implementation of the
project. But US government will not provide official assistance.
– The co-chairs valued 2006 as a year of solving the Nagrno-Karabakh.
How are the hopes of 2007 valued?
– One of the reasons why there was so much optimism in 2006 is
because this was one of the few years when there were no elections in
either country. Obviously it is now 2007 and there is still no
agreement or visible progress on ground. The responsibility for this
is shared not only by the MG, but by the parties as well. A lot of
progress was made and there is every reason to be optimistic that a
solution is not far away. When such an agreement will be reached is
difficult to say – this is an election year for Armenia – but if both
parties show political will there is no reason not to expect a
resolution in the near future.
– The co-chairs called on the leaders to prepare their population for
compromises…
– This is not the first time that the co-chairs have called the
parties to begin to prepare for compromises. Any solution that can be
reached at a negotiating table will involve difficult compromises on
both sides. It is important that the leaders explain their position
to their populations, so that when the time comes – they will have
the necessary public support. Last June the co-chairs released some
of the basic principles that were being discussed during the
negotiations. That led to a healthy dialogue on general issues. It
would be useful to continue such a dialogue in both countries to
prepare both countries for peace. What specific compromises will be
required depends on the negotiations. It is up to the two presidents
to know what their key interests are and where they can make
compromises. Those are not decisions that the MG Co-Chairs can make.
– But both Azerbaijan and Armenia presidents promised not to change
their oppinions…
– It is very easy to look at public statements and decide there is no
room for compromise. But the two presidents have invested a lot of
time and energy in these negotiations, and that demonstrates that
they believe there is room for compromise. I hope that both the
compromises and the achievements of such negotiations will soon be
presented to the publics.
– Russian co-chair stated that the Kosovo model could be possible for
Karabakh conflict. What does USA think about that?
– I spent two years working on these issues as an adviser to the U.S.
Co-Chair. During that time we looked all over the world at examples
and models that might give us useful ideas for helping to resolve the
Nagorno Karabakh issue. At the same time, we also recognize that
every conflict – whether it is in Palestine or Kosovo or somewhere
else – has unique circumstances. So while you might be able to borrow
specific ideas, it is impossible to take one model and apply it to
another conflict. The Kosovo model might be of some interest, but we
shouldn’t assume that it can be used in Nagorno-Karabakh or any other
conflict situation. /APA/

BAKU: Simmons: We will discuss protection of energy infrastructure

Azeri Press Agency, Azerbaijan
Jan 31 2007

Robert Simmons: We will discuss the protection of energy
infrastructure with Partners in the Caspian Sea region

[ 31 Jan. 2007 15:53 ]

Interview with the NATO Special Representative for the Caucasus and
Central Asia, Ambassador Robert Simmons

– How do you estimate the IPAP between Azerbaijan and NATO? Will
there be any changes in the framework of this plan? What has already
been done according to the plan now?
– NATO and Azerbaijan agreed the IPAP in May 2005 and there was a
first review of implementation in the spring of 2006. Generally the
review was positive and Azerbaijan has implemented many of the goals
in the Plan. However, NATO Allies indicated that there could be
greater progress in the area of defence reform and I welcome the fact
that at my last meeting with the Minister of Defence, he indicated a
number of positive additional steps which had been decided. NATO will
look forward to effective implementation of those steps. The IPAP is
a living document and NATO and Azerbaijan agreed a small number of
changes in the IPAP last autumn. This revised document will be the
basis of the next annual review in spring, 2007. After that review
NATO and Azerbaijan will revise the document completely, including
setting new goals in all areas of NATO-Azerbaijan cooperation for the
years ahead.
– Will there be created any new military structures in Azerbaijan in
the future in framework of IPAP?
– As part of the IPAP process, Azerbaijan has agreed to identify a
unit which will be interoperable with NATO and other Partner forces
and thus potentially be available for a NATO peace support operation.
Through training and participation in exercises, this unit will
develop the capabilities to operate with NATO and other partner
forces. This is not a new military structure, but an existing
structure, developed specifically to be interoperable with the
Alliance. In addition, the Ministry of Defence has indicated its
interest in adapting Azerbaijan’s military education structures so
they too are NATO compatible.
– When will intensive dialog between Azerbaijan and NATO start? Is
there a stimulus for that?
– There is already an extensive political dialogue between NATO and
Azerbaijan as shown by the successful visit of President Aliyev to
NATO in November 2006, when he met with the Secretary General and the
North Atlantic Council. Over the past year there were a number of
such meetings with senior officials of the Government of Azerbaijan
and NATO.
Intensified Dialogue as a technical term is the first stage in a
country’s process of seeking to join the Alliance. All of the recent
new members went through Intensified Dialogue and recently NATO
decided to begin the process with Ukraine and Georgia. At the present
time, while making clear its eventual ambitions to join Euro-Atlantic
institutions, Azerbaijan has not decided to request an intensified
dialogue but rather making the best use of Partnership for Peace
activities and the Individual Partnership Action Plan (IPAP). As we
continue to develop a closer Partnership with Azerbaijan through
IPAP, NATO is not pressing Azerbaijan to move to another stage before
it is ready.
– Russia took away its military forces from Georgia and put them in
Armenia. So it creates a military misbalance in the region.
– Russia has long had forces in Armenia with the agreement of the
Government of Armenia. This fulfils the conditions of the OSCE, that
foreign forces be stationed in other countries only with the
agreement of the host country. NATO has welcomed the withdrawal of
Russia forces from Georgia as consistent with Russia’s Istanbul
commitments. All countries with forces in the region should avoid
steps which go against the efforts to achieve a peaceful negotiated
settlement to conflicts in the region.
– How do you see the solution of the conflicts in South Caucasus
region and especially Nagorno-Karabakh conflict? Some analytics think
that only NATO can solve them instead of OSCE.
– NATO supports peaceful, negotiated solutions to conflicts in the
South Caucasus region. We believe that the countries of the region
themselves should find solutions to these conflicts using the
existing structures. In that context, NATO strongly supports the OSCE
Minsk Group and particularly the efforts of its Co-Chairman to seek a
peaceful solution to Nagorno Karabakh. We welcome the progress that
has been made in recent meetings between the Presidents and Foreign
Ministers of Azerbaijan and Armenia. But we have always made clear
that NATO does not want to play a more direct role in any way which
would undercut the direct negotiations between the parties or the
efforts of the Minsk Group Co-chairman to facilitate those
discussions.
– In what way does NATO want to take part in the project of
protecting energy resources which is being carried out in South
Caucasus? Will there be placed any mobile militaries on the
territory?
– At the recent NATO summit in Riga, Allied Heads of State and
Government agreed that NATO would look at ways in which it can make
its own contribution as part of a coordinated, international effort
to secure energy resources and identify the most likely threats to
it. Obviously, the protection of energy infrastructure is one area
which the Alliance will be looking at, and we will have this
discussion also with our Partners including Partners in the Caspian
Sea region. In fact, this will be a theme of the next EAPC Security
Forum to be held this year. NATO is willing to discuss these issues
with our Partners and I have done so when I visited the region. In
any case, NATO is not considering deploying any military forces to
the South Caucasus to protect energy infrastructure. /APA/

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Time limit for housing’s privatization extended for a year in NKR

DeFacto Agency, Armenia
Jan 31 2007

TIME LIMIT FOR HOUSING’S PRIVATIZATION EXTENDED FOR A YEAR IN NKR

The Nagorno-Karabakh Republic President Anoushavan Danielian
expressed dissatisfaction with the rates of the state and public
housing fund’s privatization.
According to the information DE FACTO got at the NKR government’s
press service, the Cabinet of Ministers had to render a decision to
extend the time limit for the housing’s privatization for a year.
539 flats have not been privatized in the Republic yet. The PM
charged the heads of the corresponding departments and city councils
to carefully study the reasons of the slow rates and elaborate the
specific mechanisms of accelerating the process of the housing’s
privatization.

RA NSS: Azeri leadership’s actions resemble boulevard detective

DeFacto Agency, Armenia
Jan 31 2007

RA NSS: AZERI LEADERSHIP’S ACTIONS RESEMBLE BOULEVARD DETECTIVE

`’The Azerbaijani authorities seem to be seriously anxious about a
statement made December 20, 2006, according to which a current
Azerbaijani agent was detected and convicted, so they have decided to
take a retaliatory move, which resembles a boulevard detective”, RA
National Security Service’s statement runs. The document refers to
the arrest of Jamal Khalilov, who, according to the Azeri special
services, cooperated with the Armenian party.
`’According to the information provided by the Azerbaijani propaganda
machine, Ariz Jamal Ogli Khalilov, a dweller of the Sadakhlo village
situated in Georgia’s Marneuli region, who was allegedly cooperating
with RA special services, was arrested and convicted `’for espionage
and preparation of the terrorist acts within a conspiratorial
group”. The sphere of Jamal Ogli’s activity has been presented
widely, maybe, taking into consideration his `’exclusive
capabilities”: beginning with carrying out `’small missions” up to
wide-scale terrorism. Trying to make their hero all-mighty, the
scenario’s authors impute to him the preparation of explosion in a
huge oil infrastructure, then in the Baku Metro, and in the end, for
some reason, they confine themselves to a trade centre. The
fabrications of the kind are aimed at making illusion of the
efficient work being carried out by the Azerbaijani special
services”, RA NSS statement reads.