Tales of tribal terror

The Japan Times, Japan
Feb 2 2007

Tales of tribal terror

By KAORI SHOJI

When Hitler got his collaborators together and proposed the genocide
of Jews, one of the things he said to justify the act was that before
long the world will forget the whole thing. He is famed for having
cited the example of the Armenian Genocide (1915-1917, in which
around a million people were estimated to have been killed) and said
that after all, no one remembered such a thing had happened, so how
different could it be this time around?

It seems that the same logic applied to the instigators of the
Rwandan genocide. Indeed, one remark by a soldier in "Shooting Dogs,"
just before he takes a machete to a victim’s head, says as much: "No
one will remember you existed."

The point of films like "Shooting Dogs" and the earlier "Hotel
Rwanda" is less about how well they’re made than the fact that
they’re there: that they get on the international film distribution
circuit, or that such films continue to be made, again and again. So
what if these movies aren’t hardcore documentaries? If entertainment
value is what it takes to get audiences to see them, then I cast my
vote to entertainment.

This especially goes for "Shooting Dogs," directed by entertainment
artisan Michael Caton-Jones, who has made works as diverse as "Basic
Instinct 2" and "Rob Roy." Caton-Jones takes a craftsman’s approach
to the story, and doesn’t let himself cave under the enormous weight
of this fact: In 1994, 800,000 Rwandans were murdered in the space of
100 days.

In many ways, "Shooting Dogs" displays a surreal insensitivity and a
typical Hollywood handling of real-life filth — the interior shots
are defined by a pristine orderliness, everyone looks as if they had
showered that morning and the Europeans depicted here are annoyingly
well-groomed. Still, it’s impossible not to come away with nerves in
tatters. Caton-Jones keeps an emotional distance. There was probably
no other way to go about it.

Based on true-life locations and the life of a Bosnian priest who had
been one of two white clergymen to remain in Rwanda after every other
Westerner had evacuated, "Shooting Dogs" opens with the news that the
president has been killed in a plane crash. There are rumors of a
coup, which quickly escalates to a mass wave of ethnic cleansing,
underscored by a feud that had continued between Rwandan Hutus and
Tutsis for centuries. Hutu extremists seize the upper hand by
installing road blocks, closing public facilities and taking to the
streets with machetes and lists containing the addresses and names of
Tutsis. Some 2,500 Tutsis take refuge in a local technical school run
by the idealistic Father Christopher (John Hurt) and the
well-intended young British teacher Joe Connor (Hugh Dancy). Both
strive to save their neighbors, their students and families, but
they’re ultimately helpless; the most chilling scene is when Father
Christopher finally leaves the school (he’s the last white man to go,
and the last vestige of hope for these people) in a truck. Even
before the dust from the wheels have cleared, Hutu extremists (who
had all been waiting at the gates with machetes and cleavers) are
given the command to "let the work begin!"

"Shooting Dogs" was partly written and produced by BBC news reporter
David Belton. In 1994, he had been in Rwanda to report on the
massacre and was helped by the Bosnian priest who inspired the story.
Eventually Belton got out of Rwanda when the atrocities threatened to
extend to the whites. He learned later that the priest was murdered.
What surfaces throughout the story is Belton’s sense of guilt at
having abandoned the country and its people and his deep frustration
at having been powerless to "make a difference," an oft-repeated
phrase in the dialogue.

Connor, however, is not Belton’s alter ego. Of all the characters
here, he seems to be the least substantial and is perhaps meant to be
so; an amalgam of all the Westerners who, with the best intentions,
fled Rwanda, not least of all the U.N. peacekeeping forces. In the
story, a Belgian unit based at the school is given orders to shoot
the dogs eating the corpses from genocide ("it’s a health risk!") but
they do nothing to stop the Hutu militia from producing corpses by
the score. Once seen, "Shooting Dogs" isn’t likely to be forgotten,
and that’s exactly what it aims for.

2a3.html

http://search.japantimes.co.jp/cgi-bin/ff2007020

Declining tolerance of dangerous words

The Japan Times, Japan
Feb 2 2007

Declining tolerance of dangerous words

By GEORGE P. FLETCHER

NEW YORK — Nowadays, words are often seen as a source of
instability. The violent reactions last year to the caricatures of
the Prophet Muhammad published in a Danish newspaper saw a confused
Western response, with governments tripping over their tongues trying
to explain what the media should and should not be allowed to do in
the name of political satire.

Then Iran trumped the West by sponsoring a conference of Holocaust
deniers, a form of speech punished as criminal almost everywhere in
Europe.

As Turks well know, it is dangerous to take a position on the
Armenian genocide of 1915. The most recent Nobel laureate in
literature, Orhan Pamuk, was prosecuted in Istanbul for denying
Turkey’s official history by saying that the Armenian genocide
actually occurred. Other Turks have faced prosecution in Western
Europe for saying that it did not.

So words are now clearly a battlefield in the cultural conflict
between Islam and the West. The West has learned that, simply as a
matter of self-censorship, not legal fiat, newspapers and other media
outlets will not disseminate critical pictures of Muhammad, and the
pope will no longer make critical comments about Islam. But these
gestures of cooperation with Muslim sensibilities have not been met
by reciprocal gestures.

Instead, Mahmoud Ahmedinejad, Iran’s president, has threatened to
wipe Israel off the map. The Israeli Foreign Ministry now seeks
prosecution of Ahmedinejad for incitement to commit genocide — a
violation of international law.

But the Israeli press is also bellicose. Israeli newspapers regularly
carry stories about why Israel may need to attack Iran to prevent it
from acquiring an arsenal of nuclear weapons. U.S. President George
W. Bush has made similarly ominous, if more vague, statements about
Iran. In Germany, preparing and calling for preemptive military
strikes from within the government are subject to criminal sanctions.

The world’s different legal systems have never been in much agreement
about the boundaries of free speech. Even between good neighbors like
Canada and the United States, there is little agreement about
punishing hate speech. Canadians punish racial insults, but Americans
do not, at least if the issue is simply one of protecting the dignity
of racial minorities.

But threatening violence is more serious. Many countries are united
in supporting the principle that if, say, Ahmedinejad does meet the
criteria for incitement of genocide, he should be punished in the
International Criminal Court. Indeed, the International Criminal
Tribunal for Rwanda punished radio station operators who made
aggressive public broadcasts urging Hutus to pick up their machetes
and murder Tutsis.

A decade ago there would have been a good argument in international
law that the Hutu-Tutsi example supports prosecution only after the
damage has been done. All the international precedents — from
Nuremberg to the present — concern international intervention after
mass atrocities. Domestic police may be able to intervene to prevent
crime before it occurs, but in the international arena there is no
police force that can do that.

It follows, therefore, that the crime of incitement should apply only
to cases like Rwanda, where the radio broadcasts actually contributed
to the occurrence of genocide. In cases where bellicose leaders make
public threats to "bury" another country (remember Khrushchev?) or to
wipe it off the map, the courts should wait, it was said, until some
harm occurs.

But the international community has become ever more intrusive in
using legal remedies against persons who engage in provocative and
dangerous speech. In September 2005, the United Nations Security
Council passed Resolution 1624 — paradoxically, with American
approval — calling upon all member states to enact criminal
sanctions against those who incite terrorism. The model of incitement
they had in mind is the same one that British Prime Minister Tony
Blair has publicly invoked: Muslim leaders standing up in their
mosques and urging their congregations to go out and kill infidels.

Americans have traditionally said that, absent a risk of immediate
unlawful violence, this form of speech should be protected under the
First Amendment. U.S. courts reasoned that it is better to allow the
release of hateful sentiments than to call attention to them by
showcasing them in court. But when it comes to terrorism in today’s
world, most countries, including the world’s democracies, are not as
tolerant as they used to be.

So the traditional liberal position in support of giving wide scope
to freedom of speech, even for extremists, is losing ground
everywhere. When it comes to fighting terrorism and the prospect of
genocide, the world is now becoming afraid of dangerous words.

George P. Fletcher, Cardozo professor of jurisprudence at Columbia
University, is author of "Romantics at War: Glory and Guilt in the
Age of Terrorism." Copyright 2007 Project Syndicate/Institute for
Human Sciences ()

2a1.html

http://search.japantimes.co.jp/cgi-bin/eo2007020
www.project-syndicate.org

Beautiful films

People’s Weekly World
Feb 2 2007

Beautiful films

Some of the world’s most beautiful humanist films have been made in a
country demonized by Western media. `Iran: A Cinematographic
Revolution’ is a penetrating study of the history of Iran, the
world’s first Islamic Republic, through the wondrous eye of the
camera.

Produced in France with succinct English narration and fascinating
interviews with prominent Iranian directors, the story begins with
the first Iranian film, made in 1933 by an Armenian, and it continues
through all the various Iranian regimes, some installed by the U.S.,
some not.

Certainly many of us are familiar with the historic revolution of
1979. That Islamic revolution attacked the decadent symbols of the
West, including the cinemas that had become known for screening
objectionable fare. Cinema suffered a major blow in Iran: 129
theaters were burned to the ground and for a few years the film
industry lay dormant.

Then one day the Ayatollah Khomeini happened to see an old film
called `The Cow’ on television. Somehow it didn’t contradict the
tenets of Islam as interpreted by the conservative regime. He said,
`We’re not against cinema, but what’s ungodly.’ With his blessing,
the new age of Iranian cinema was reborn.

And ironically it is this new cinema that has become the darling of
film festivals around the world. Names like Abbas Kiarostami and
Mohsen Makhmalbaf are recognized worldwide and their humanistic
films, which stress simplicity, children, Persian poetry, realism and
nonviolence, have won top honors.

Some 90,000 students have now graduated from the nascent Iranian Film
Institute, and they have created an art style unequalled in the world
today.

The all-consuming and destructive Iraq-Iran war of the 1980s did not
stop film production, but rather created films of immense urgency and
compassion, all within the new guidelines of society.

This documentary is an informative, entertaining tribute and
thoughtful examination of how positive cinema can develop in a
fundamentalist society. One director interviewed in the film refers
to the fact that after winning hundreds of awards worldwide, Iranian
filmmakers are acquiring a sort of `untouchable’ leverage over the
current government, which appears to be willing to gain the prestige
in exchange for a relaxation on censorship. In this sense Iranian
cinema is leading the regime to a more humanist approach.

If more Americans saw Iranian cinema, and appreciated its honesty and
simplicity, there would be a greater understanding of Iran today.

Two films shown at the Toronto International Film Festival were
chosen by their countries to contend for an Academy Award but did not
receive nominations. One of them, `Grbavica,’ named after a small
town in Bosnia, addresses the tragedy faced by women who were
tortured and raped in the recent war in that region.

Esma and her daughter Sara have an unusual relationship. Esma is
willing to overlook all the faults of her troubled 12-year-old child
while providing her with all the basic needs in life at great
personal expense. Esma walks hours to and from work just to make
enough money so her child can go on a school trip.

As the story develops, tragic secrets are revealed about how Sara
came into this world and the human drama gets more intense. Esma
attends gut-wrenching therapy sessions with real women who endured
the horrors of battle. Without revealing the powerful details of this
story, true for many women in Bosnia today, suffice it to say that
this film treats the issue with great respect and love. The acting is
intense and the direction convincing.

There are some films where the action and sets are so realistic that
you feel like you lived through the story. The people and places are
vivid and remain in your memory for a long time.

Paul Verhoeven (`Robocop,’ `Total Recall,’ `Basic Instinct’) returns
to his homeland to direct an action-packed suspenseful historical
drama about Jewish refugees in the Netherlands during World War II
called `Black Book.’

A young Jewish singer is constantly staying just one step ahead of
the advancing Germans. She eventually is recruited by the Resistance
and infiltrates the high offices of the German security police, the
same people who had her family slaughtered while they were trying to
leave.

The courage of the Resistance fighters and the townspeople who are
willing to hide the Jews are vividly portrayed, even as they deal
with betrayal, double agents and failed intelligence. A large and
remarkable cast, big budget and skilled direction make this a
thriller that is hard to forget.

57

http://www.pww.org/article/articleview/10515/1/3

Watertown mourns slain Armenian editor

Watertown TAB & Press, MA
Feb 2 2007

Watertown mourns slain Armenian editor

By Stephanie Karakozian, Correspondent
Thursday, February 01, 2007 – Updated: 04:17 PM EST

Hrant Dink was born in, and loved, a country that denied him, along
with millions of Armenians across the world, much of their ethnic
heritage.

It is a country that uprooted and savagely pruned too many family
trees – Turkey.

Dink was persecuted and killed in this country he loved too much to
leave. It was simply because he spoke out about the freedom of
expression regarding the Armenian Genocide that took place in 1915.

His supporters have spoken that his assassination on Jan. 19 is proof
that the genocide did not end nearly a century ago, but that it
continues today.

Dink, 52, was the editor of the bilingual Turkish-Armenian weekly,
Agos. He was shot outside his office on a busy Istanbul street. The
suspect, a teenage Turkish nationalist, was later apprehended and
arrested for the assassination.

On Friday, Jan. 26, a `Remembrance and Candlelight Vigil’ honoring
Dink was held at St. James Armenian Church. The event drew a
standing-room-only crowd, despite the frigid temperature and the lure
of other Friday night activities. Among those who gathered were
Armenian-Americans and human rights activists from throughout the
Boston area, including local government officials and clergy members.

Related content: Editorial "We are all Hrant"

Mourners filed in quietly as somber organ music played. Members of
the Armenian General Athletic Union Scouts bore both Armenian and
American flags. Students from St. Stephen’s Armenian Elementary
School and the Armenian Sisters Academy joined local clergy in
singing an Armenian tribute – `Mer Hayrenik’ and `God Bless America.’

Formal remarks, in memory of Dink, were made by Khatchig Mouradian,
editor of the Armenian Weekly, state representatives Rachel
Kaprielian and Peter Kotoujian, and the Very Reverend Father Krikor
Maksoudian, Diocese of the Armenian Church (East).

Following the indoor service, participants streamed into the bitterly
cold night air to light memorial candles and place them around a
wreathed portrait of Dink at the church’s cross stone on Mt. Auburn
Street.

Former Watertown resident Missak Barsoumian, now living in Belmont,
described the vigil as `somber and solemn.’

`This occasion showed that the whole Armenian community, and others,
are horrified at this atrocity. Hrant Dink used the democratic
process to speak his mind, and he paid with his life,’ he said after
the vigil.

Eric Ozcan, a Watertown businessman and close friend of Dink’s,
attended the vigil, and was one of many others who have expressed
their concern over Dink’s safety and security in recent years because
of his `outspokenness and courageous honesty’ in the face of a strict
Turkish policy against questioning the government’s line on the
deaths. Turkey has long maintained that while thousands of Armenians
died, it was a byproduct of the First World War, not a government
policy of genocide.

`I saw him last, six months ago [August 2006] in Istanbul,’ Ozcan
said. `I asked him to be very careful because he had become a greater
target.’

Ozcan said this was since his arrest in 2005 under Article 301 of the
Turkish Penal Code for `insulting Turkishness.’

Ozcan, also from Turkey, said he had developed a close bond with Dink
during their years at an ethnic Armenian boarding school, and
remained a friend with him throughout the years.

`Hrant always spoke his mind, even as a schoolboy,’ recalled Ozcan of
the time he spent in school with Dink. `He did not tolerate
unfairness of any kind, even against children in the schoolyard.’

The two continued to stay touch with letters and frequent visits to
each other over the years.

`Hrant was very idealistic, but did not worry about the
consequences,’ said Ozcan. `He was a great human being who embodied
the ideals of freedom of speech and equality.’

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

The President Responds

Kommersant, Russia
Feb 2 2007

The President Responds
// Journalists in the Kremlin

Russian President Vladimir Putin appeared before journalists at his
annual press conference in the Kremlin. Kommersant special
correspondent Andrey Kolesnikov thinks that the reporters lost the
conference to the president.

The air was charged before the press conference, as always. It was
standing room only. The auditorium was cold because everyone came at
the same time – early to get the best seats. There was a traffic jam
in front of the 14th corpus. My colleagues only started to understand
how important the president’s press conference was at the fifth one.
For those present, the most important thing in the world was a single
seat, the one you could get a good view of him from and he could see
you, maybe even make out your nametag. It was the only way to better
your chance of getting to ask a question. For those people, the
question was more important than the answer.

Reporters milled about the parterre long after all the places were
taken, and resolutely ignored the balcony, although they would
attract more attention jumping up and down up there. I knew from
experience that the two people sitting behind the podium, Russian
President Vladimir Putin and his press secretary Alexey Gromov, had a
certain sympathetic inclination toward those in the balcony that
would make up for the inconvenience.

The president’s appearance is preceded by a ritual. First something
is placed on the table under the cover of a starched white napkin,
the kind that a magician might pull out of his sleeve. From afar
(from the balcony, for instance), it looks as though a white dove may
fly out from under it. I knew that there was a cup of green tea under
it, however. Last year and the year before, the audience applauded
the person who brought out the teacup, reflecting the good mood
prevailing. Yesterday, one person began to clap and quickly stopped
when no one joined him.

After the tea, the president’s press secretary appears. He is a man
of few words. (Journalists have not heard a single word of commentary
on the president’s activities out of him in six years.) He looks a
little worried and shuffles the papers lying on the table.

You might think that his harried appearance is because the president
is hot on his heels. Nothing of the kind. First of all, in reality,
he has nerves of steel. (You have to have to keep your lips that
tightly closed.) Second, he knows exactly where the president is. He
has already cracked open the door and is peeking through, counting
the seconds before he steps into the light. He will follow Gromov by
exactly one minute, no more and no less.

The president began the press conference with a roundup of last
year’s events. That was routine. According to the president, was
stably good, the numbers even, and there was no reason to get upset
or overly happy.

The president praised the Central Bank (as if in response to Alexey
Frenkel’s letter) and noted that the government still owes `a debt
for shipbuilding.’ As he returned to the government several times, it
became clear that it was one of the few things in today’s Russia that
he is not impressed with.

The first question concerned the sad fate of Alexander Ponosov, the
director of the village school in Perm Region on trial for buying
computers with unlicensed software inside.

The president replied that he was unaware of the case, which is hard
to believe. It would mean that he never watches TV news and does not
read newspapers. He had a comment ready any way: a folksy `nonsense.’
In our complex times, that is the same as being found innocent for
lack of a crime. In my opinion, the cost of the whole event was paid
back right there.

An American radio reporter named Feifer asked Putin to explain what
he meant when he said that `superpower is an outdated notion from the
Cold War era.’ `And you said that it is other countries that seek to
portray Russia as the enemy, Feifer continued. Could you please name
these countries? Does this include Washington and London? If not, who
is it specifically that is trying to damage Russia’s image?’

The president answered exhaustively. `We see a dishonest attitude to
the interpretation of events taking place, he said, glaring at the
brave journalist. `This is, of course, the work of Russia’s
ill-wishers. I am not suggesting that this is something going on at
state level, but there are people out there who do not wish Russia
well. The people who write these kinds of things, it’s them who are
our ill-wishers. So, if you write these kinds of things, then you are
among their number.’

I was sure that he was going to suggest that the journalist be
circumcised.

`But if you give an accurate and objective portrayal of events, then
you are not counted in this category,’ he concluded, seemingly using
all of his strength to hold fast to a peaceful foreign policy.

Soon the president began getting questions about his successor. He
did not like them and made no secret of it. When NTV correspondent
Vladimir Kondratyev asked a question, the president replied that he
does not rule, as Kondratyev had put it, but simply does his job and
the people, not he, will decide who the future president will be, as
he should know.

`There will be no successors,’ he continued. `There will be
candidates for the post of president of the Russian Federation.’

That pronouncement was unexpected. It might mean that both Defense
Minister and Deputy Prime Minister Sergey Ivanov and First Deputy
Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev, who are considered to have the best
chances of being called Successor of the Russian Federation by the
President of Russia, will be candidates. But, according to my
information, one of them is still having doubts that he needs any of
it.

The Reuter’s correspondent repeated the NTV reporter’s question about
the successor.

`Everyone who should be is already working as high state officials,’
the president answered. `We should not be running round in a fuss
over the upcoming elections.’

Did he mean himself? Or was he hinting that neither Ivanov nor
Medvedev would be the successor?

`I am also a citizen of this country,’ the president concluded, `a
fact of which I am very proud, and I reserve the right to express my
preferences, but I will do this only once the election campaign
begins.’

Thus Putin made it known how long he would not say anything about it.
Thos wishing to know will have to wait for the next press conference,
in the winter of 2007-2008.

The president was given a little rest at this point. A woman
journalist of a certain age dressed in a sailor’s suit called the
president `incomparable’ and got what she wanted. The president
admitted that she was embarrassing him. They bantered a while longer,
but the respite was not to last.

I asked if Putin would return to big politics after all he has seen
and done. I meant in 2012, of course, not 2008. `I understand,’ I
added, `that there is probably some temptation to say immediately
that you aren’t going anywhere, and that will be true, put mildly.
But it seems to me that you can permit yourself to be candid.’

Unfortunately, the president did what in judo is called using your
opponent’s weight against him.

`I can permit myself to be candid,’ he answered. `Therefore, I will
say that I am not going anywhere yet. First, presidential elections
are to be held, if my memory serves, sometime in the beginning of
March of 2008, and then there will be some time after that, two or
three months, for the transfer of power and so on. That is, it will
be sometime in May 2008. What do you want to get rid of me early for?
I’ll go by myself. Don’t hurry.’

The information agencies paid no attention to what the president
added to that. `The organs of authority in this country should be
formed in the appropriate manner at the end of 2007 and beginning of
2008. I an thinking about it, of course.’

So the president is thinking not just about who will be president. He
is already thinking about who will be prime minister and members of
his government.

The president’s best joke, I thought, was when he answered a question
about whether he agreed with Moscow Mayor Yury Luzhkov that `a gay
parade is the business of Satanists.’

`My attitude toward gay parades and sexual minorities in general is
simple,’ he answered. `It is related to fulfillment of my official
duties and is that one of the main problems of the country is
demographic.’

The press conference had been in progress at least an hour and a half
and, answering the next question, the president practically started
dictating flashes for agency news wires. The Russian company
Transneft `has practically begun work on a plan to expand the
terminals in Primorsk by an additional 50 million tons of oil.’ That
was a fraternal hello to Belarusian President Alexander Lukashenko.

For the sake of international information agencies, the president
told who really poisoned Alexander Litvinenko. `Alexander Litvinenko
was dismissed from the security organs. Before that, he served in the
escort forces. He was never in possession of any secrets. He was
charged with abuse of office in the Russian Federation, specifically
for beating citizens in custody while he was a security officer, and
for the theft of explosives. But they gave him, I think, three years’
probation. There was no need for him to flee, he was not the bearer
of any secrets at all… As for those people who are trying to cause
damage to the Russian Federation,… they are the so-called fugitive
oligarchs who are hiding in Western Europe or the Middle East. I
don’t believe in the conspiracy theory very much, and frankly it
doesn’t worry me very much. The stability of the Russian government
today allows us to look down on that.’

The next big news was about new proposals by Ukraine concerning
natural gas.

`Our Ukrainian partners would like not only to form a gas
transportation consortium, they would also like to have the
opportunity to acquire production assets on the territory of the
Russian Federation,’ the president announced. `And if we did it while
establishing relations with our European partners, say the German
company BASF, now I think we will come to an agreement with EON, we
have in principle reached an agreement with the Italian company ENI,
why shouldn’t we do it with the Ukrainians?’

Without pause, he moved on to another piece of news: he thinks that
`a natural gas OPEC is an interesting idea.’ He had not thought so
before.

`We don’t plan to form any kind of cartel,’ he said, `but I think it
would be correct to coordinate our activities, keeping a solution to
the main task in view: an unconditional and dependable guarantee of
energy sources for our main consumers.’

That was probably all the news flashes. They were all oil-and-gas
related. It is interesting that there is as much more oil-and-gas
news every year as there are calls by the president for the
diversification of the economy. A meeting between the president and
the best (in his and their opinions) Russian businessmen scheduled
for February 6 will be devoted to that topic as well.

By now, Putin had probably relaxed, thinking that he had satisfied
everyone with his answers about his successor. And here he received a
question about how he sees himself after 2008.

`You’re really pressing me! How I see myself? I see myself as a
person most of all.’

He became a little more sullen after that. Maybe he stopped liking
journalists completely. He immediately looked tired. The press
conference had been going on for three hours.

And that was when the best question of the press conference, in my
opinion, was asked. It (unlike the answer) is worth reproducing
almost in full. Greek journalist Tsiolias Athanasios asked, `Vladimir
Vladimirovich, you haven’t mentioned our little pipeline from Burgas
to Alexandroupolis. You know, we have been hearing about that
pipeline for 15 years. We would like to hear your opinion. Will it
finally be built? Or will someone interfere endlessly? I understood
that you do not intend to leave before the end of your term but… No,
you will understand. You will understand. I read the opinion that you
were sitting on your suitcases ready to run away.’ The president
frowned at the Greek. `That was the opinion of the chess player
Kasparov, I think,’ Athanasios continued. `Is that so? Will the
pipeline be built while you are in Russia?’

The Russian saying that simplicity is worse than thievery is untrue.
I understood here that sometimes the opposite is true. The best thing
about the Greek journalist’s question was that the only reason he
cared whether Putin would stay to the end of his term was to find out
if that small but proud pipeline would be built.

`I was a judoist once, but I was never a sprinter. I don’t plan on
running anywhere,’ Putin grumbled. `As for the Burgas-Alexandroupolis
pipeline, I really didn’t say anything about it because it doesn’t
exist. There are only conversations about the project.’

The president had been decided for himself what questions to take.
Earlier, Gromov had been doing it. The journalists, seeing their
chance to call out to the president directly, began to do so. That
had never happened at the press conferences before.

Gromov tried to calm them down.

`Where are the Armenian journalists? Because the Azeris asked a
question. It would be politically incorrect to skip the Armenians,’
the president asked. His enthusiasm was picking up again, but it was
still clear that the press conference was winding down.

The president announced all the news he wanted to make known. He kept
to himself what he did not want known. The journalists did not get
anything out of him that he did not want to say.

In that sense, we lost the press conference.

Andrey Kolesnikov

Statistics on President Putin’s Press Conferences

Russian President Vladimir Putin’s first big press conference was
held in the Kremlin on July 18, 2001. There were 400 journalists
present, who asked 22 questions in 1 hour and 22 minutes. Since then,
those indicators have risen steadily. On June 24, 2002, 500
journalists came to the Kremlin. The president answered 37 of their
questions in 2 hours and 7 minutes. On June 20, 2003, Putin spent 2
hours and 45 minutes at a press conference with 700 journalists, who
asked 53 questions. In 2005, there was no big press conference. On
January 31, 2006, the president met with 1030 journalists for 3 hours
and 26 minutes and 76 questions. Social issues (21 questions),
domestic policy (19 questions) and foreign policy (16 times) were the
most popular topics, in that order. He was asked about the economy
ten times, his personal life nine times and the army once.

Yesterday’s press conference set new records: 1132 journalists, 3
hours and 32 minutes, 79 questions. Nineteen of the questions
concerned domestic policy. Economics, international relations and
social problems were the subjects of 16 questions each. The president
was asked about his private life 11 times, and about the army once.

The press’s attitude toward the president can be judged from the way
journalists address him. In 2001, Putin was addressed as `respected’
twice. In 2002 and 2003, four times. In 2004, his respectedness fell
to a single appellation. In 2006, the record was set with six times.
In 2007, it returned to the average four. But yesterday Putin was
called `incomparable,’ which had never happened before.

Alexander Kukolevsky

ANKARA: Revisiting old Q after murder of Dink: Is there a deep state

Today’s Zaman, Turkey
Feb 2 2007

Revisiting an old question after murder of Dink: Is there a `deep state’?

Have Turkish institutions been infiltrated by a shadowy deep state»?
The slaying of a prominent ethnic Armenian journalist has renewed
debate about whether a network of renegade agents within the state,
driven by hardline nationalism, is targeting reformists and other
perceived enemies.

Turkish teenager Ogün Samast, suspected of killing journalist Hrant
Dink, center, is escorted by plainclothes policemen as he arrives at
a courthouse in Ýstanbul
Skeptics say the claim fans conspiracy theories and only creates a
bogeyman for Turkey’s ills. Whatever the truth, the investigation
into the murder of Hrant Dink _ who was loathed by nationalists
because he urged Turks to recognize the mass killings of Armenians
during World War I as genocide – is under scrutiny despite its
seeming success. Seven suspects, including the teenager who allegedly
pulled the trigger and the man accused of supplying the gun, have
been arrested since the killing two weeks ago.
Uneasy questions are being raised about who holds the levers of power
in a nation where tensions between secularists and Islamists, and
liberals and rightists, have created deep faultlines in society.
The consensus among many government critics is that the plot to kill
Dink involved more than a few nationalists, and that a professional
group with considerable resources at its disposal may have played a
role. Police say they have uncovered no evidence suggesting a wider
conspiracy, and investigators have promised to follow all tips
despite skepticism about how aggressively they will do so.
The idea of `deep state,’ or `derin devlet’ in Turkish, has been
around for decades. One definition says it is a clandestine group
within the security and intelligence services, as well as the state
bureaucracy, that resists change, sometimes violently.
Another theory says it is not a single group, but a set of beliefs
that espouses the centrality of the state in politics, and whose
protectors include the judiciary and the educational system. The
expression is so common that Turks often joke about it, blaming some
unforeseen development in the workplace or daily life on the `deep
state.’
Little hard evidence has emerged that a `deep state’exists, but even
Turkey’s prime minister has given the idea credence.
`The `deep state’ has become a tradition. It is a term that has been
used since the Ottoman period,’ Erdogan told reporters on Sunday
aboard an airplane bound for an African Union summit in Ethiopia.
`We can describe it as gangs inside a state organization, and this
kind of structure does exist. Our state and our nation have paid a
high price because we have not been able to crack down on such
networks,’ the daily Zaman newspaper quoted the prime minister as
saying. The topic is so murky that Yeni Safak, an Islamist newspaper,
once addressed the cloak-and-dagger concept with a reference to the
signature introduction of fiction’s most famous spy, James Bond. `My
name is State, Deep State,’ read the title of a 2005 column. The
prominence of `deep state’ in the Turkish imagination exposes
concerns about the accountability of the military and other
institutions in a nation that seeks to seal its modern status by
joining the European Union, a bid that is virtually on hold because
of a dispute over divided Cyprus.
The military has staged three coups in modern Turkey, and remained
influential after ceding control to civilian governments. Supporters
view it as a guardian of secular values, a vital tool in the fight
against separatist rebels in Kurdish-dominated areas, and the
champion of Turkish Cypriots whose government is unrecognized by any
other nation. Dink, who was shot outside his Istanbul office on Jan.
19, had been prosecuted under a broadly defined law that bans the
denigration of Turkish identity, and he had suggested that judicial
rulings reflected behind-the-scenes allegiance to the state rather
than the rights of citizens.
`The great force, which was just there to bring me down and which let
its existence be felt at all stages of the case with methods unknown
to me, was again behind the curtain,’ Dink, 52, wrote obliquely in
one of his last columns in Agos, the weekly Turkish-Armenian
newspaper that he founded.
Dink said he received constant threats for his espousal of minority
Armenian rights, and he criticized top authorities for apparent
indifference. `Other opponents of the bureaucracy have suffered a
similar fate,’ said David L. Phillips, a friend of Dink who served as
chairman of the Turkish-Armenian Reconciliation Commission and is now
executive director of The Elie Wiesel Foundation for Humanity, based
in New York City. `The `deep state’ has a history of eliminating its
opponents.’
One case that fueled speculation about the `deep state’ was the 1996
Susurluk scandal, named after the town where a car crash revealed
alliances between state officials and mobsters. Passengers who died
in the wrecked Mercedes included Istanbul’s No. 2 police officer and
a fugitive hit man.
A probe confirmed suspicions that officials were using radical
nationalists and criminals to intimidate or kill perceived enemies. A
1997 government report accused some police and politicians of hiring
hit men to target journalists, Kurdish rebels and Armenian activists
since the 1980s. Erdogan pledged an investigation `at full speed’
into Dink’s killing and his government removed the governor and
police chief of Trabzon, the city on the Black Sea coast that is home
to suspects in the murder.
A year ago, a Turkish teenager shot dead a Roman Catholic priest in
Trabzon; investigators believed that attack was linked to Islamic
anger over the publication in European newspapers of caricatures of
the Prophet Muhammad.
Erdogan, a moderate whose Islamic-rooted Justice and Development
Party is distasteful to some in the secular military, has indicated
that authorities need to tackle more than just youthful triggermen
likely to get relatively lenient sentences if prosecuted as minors.
But Justice Minister Cemil Cicek was ambivalent in an address to the
Ankara Chamber of Commerce on Wednesday.

Georgia: Political storm clouds still surround new rail link

Railway Market Magazine, Poland
Feb 2 2007

Georgia: Political storm clouds still surround new rail link

Although the financing, engineering and logistical issues surrounding
the construction of the Kars-Akhalkalaki railway have been largely
solved, the political concerns surrounding the project remain.

Armenian President Robert Kocharian’s Press Secretary Victor
Sogomonian recently reiterated Yerevan’s opposition to the project,
saying Armenia would use "political methods" to hamper the project’s
implementation.

"The fact that the US refused to sponsor the building of the railway
was the result of appropriate steps taken by Yerevan," explained
Sogomonian, as quoted by the newspaper Rezonansi.

Russia, a staunch Armenian ally, is also against the railway’s
construction. This would be unlikely to deter Georgia, were it not
for the fact that their main patron and strategic partner, the United
States, has also voiced its opposition to the project. The US
recently passed a bill forbidding American financing of the railway’s
construction, out of fear that the railway will further isolate
Armenia, whose borders with both Azerbaijan and Turkey have been
closed since the early 90s.

According to the chair of the parliamentary Committee on European
Integration, David Bakradze, Georgia will not ignore its own
interests because of American opposition. However, Bakradze also
mentions that the US is not "totally" against the railway.

Some Georgian analysts agree with Bakradze on this.

"As a rule, if the US is against something, it does its best to make
sure it doesn’t happen. In this case the situation is different,"
explains analyst Mamuka Areshidze in the newspaper Kvela Siakhle.

The analyst says the US’s position regarding the railway is
ill-defined. US diplomat Matt Bryza has said that despite being
against any regional project that bypasses Armenia, America will not
disturb its implementation.

Deputy US Ambassador to Armenia Anthony Godfrey made a similar
statement several days ago, reports the newspaper Rezonansi.

The US and Armenia both fear the railway will add to Armenia’s
isolation, but this itself is questionable. Georgia is trying to show
the potential benefits the railway could bring Armenia, which already
conducts a large amount of trade with Turkey via Georgia.

"Georgia cannot change the relationship that exists between Armenia
and Azerbaijan and Armenia and Turkey. But Armenia will still profit
from this project because the railway will allow Armenia improved
access to European products," explains Bakradze in the newspaper
Kvela Siakhle.

ANKARA; Babacan: Turkey is more ‘open’ with EU process

The New ANatolian, Turkey
Feb 2 2007

Babacan: Turkey is more ‘open’ with EU process

Turkey’s chief European Union talks negotiator Ali Babacan yesterday
touted Turkey’s rapid transformation toward openness, saying, "Turkey
has become very open, very fast."

Babacan, in an interview with Business Week magazine, stated that the
assassination of Turkish Armenian journalist Hrant Dink last month
"looks like an anachronism." It’s not compatible with the open
society we are looking for, he said.

Dink was shot dead on Jan. 19, outside the offices of his Agos weekly
in Istanbul.

Babacan also underlined that a "reform in mentality" was still needed
in Turkey and that certain things "were not changing overnight."

Business Week commented that Turkey has striven to come up to EU
standards of openness to prepare its bid to join the Union.

"A whole new media web has sprung up in the Eurasian nation of 75
million people, where almost none existed before," the magazine said.

"From a single state-owned TV station, more than 300 channels have
emerged," said the magazine. "Eleven hundred radio stations crowd the
airwaves. Every private school is now linked to the Internet, and the
the government is distributing 400,000 PCs to pupils."

Courier: TIME magazine Distributes Doc., Adopts Policy on Genocide

California Courier
February 2, 2007

TIME Magazine Distributes Documentary;
Adopts Policy on the Armenian Genocide

The Feb. 12, 2007 issue of the European edition of TIME magazine

— available in newsstands throughout Europe as of Feb. 2nd — carries
na full-page factual announcement on the Armenian Genocide, along with
a complimentary DVD, in English and French, which contains a
compelling 52-minute documentary on the Armenian Genocide by French
director Laurence Jourdan. The DVD also includes a 46-minute interview
with Dr. Yves Ternon, a leading expert on the Armenian Genocide.

Both the DVD and the full-page ad were provided free of charge by TIME
Europe (circulation 550,000) after realizing that its staff, without
proper review, had inserted in the June 6, 2005 issue of TIME Europe a
Turkish DVD as a paid advertisement under the guise of promoting
tourism to Turkey. The Turkish DVD, paid for by the Ankara Chamber of
Commerce, was a deceitful attempt to spread malicious lies and
denialist propaganda on the Armenian Genocide.

To correct this error, TIME (Europe) published, in its October 17,
2005 issue, a critical page-long letter to the editor jointly signed
by the following five French organizations: Memoire 2000, the
Coordinating Council of Armenian Organizations of France (CCAF),
Comité de Defense de la Cause Armenienne (CDCA) — ANC France,
J’Accuse, and the Movement Against Racism and for Friendship Among
Peoples (MRAP). In an Editor’s note appended to the letter, TIME
apologized for disseminating the Turkish DVD.

In December 2005, these five organizations along with the
Switzerland-Armenia Association (SAA), the French Association of
Armenian Lawyers and Jurists (AFAJA), the EUROPEAN – ARMENIAN
FEDERATION for Justice and Democracy (EAFJD), and The California
Courier newspaper reached an amicable agreement with TIME executives
ensuring that the facts of the Armenian Genocide are not distorted
again in the pages of the magazine.

Subsequently, Michael Elliott, the Editor of TIME International,
issued the following public statement: "Please be advised that, in
common with other leading news organizations, it is TIME’s policy and
practice to refer to the Armenian genocide as a historical fact.
Accordingly, I will be informing our correspondents and editors that
the term ‘Armenian genocide’ should be used without qualification."

The above mentioned organizations are fully satisfied with the
corrective steps taken by TIME magazine. They are also pleased that
the Turkish attempt to distort the facts of the Armenian Genocide,
supported by considerable financial resources, was properly countered
as a result of these organizations’ close cooperation with TIME which
placed journalistic ethics above all other considerations.

— 30 —

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Senator Biden introduces resolution condemning Hrant Dink’s murder

Senator Biden introduces resolution condemning Hrant Dink’s murder

ArmRadio.am
02.02.2007 10:08

Senate Foreign Relations Committee Chairman Joseph R. Biden,
Jr. (D-DE) introduced legislation condemning the assassination of
Hrant Dink and honoring his legacy of tolerance and peaceful change.

"We commend Senator Biden for spearheading this important
legislation," said Executive Director Bryan Ardouny. "The atmosphere
that led to this killing must be changed, starting with the repeal of
Article 301 of the Turkish Penal Code. As a moral leader, America must
ensure that minority populations in Turkey are afforded every
protection."

Dink, who worked hard to foster dialogue and understanding between
Armenians and Turks, was gunned down outside his newspaper office on
January 19 in Istanbul, Turkey. An outspoken advocate for democratic
reform, Dink stood trial several times for his public comments on the
genocide and was convicted in October 2005 for "insulting Turkishness"
under Article 301 of the Turkish Penal Code. He received a six-month
suspended sentence and was set to appear in court again in March 2007
for affirming the Armenian Genocide. "Hrant Dink was a leading voice
in Turkey’s Armenian community and an eloquent advocate for human
rights, press freedom, and democracy," Senator Biden told the
Assembly. "His assassination was an outrage and a tragedy. Hrant’s
legacy deserves the Senate’s respect. His murder demands our action."

The Senate bill is similar to H. Res. 102, which was introduced by
Congressman Joseph Crowley (D-NY) on January 29 with the support of
the Armenian Assembly. The Biden resolution condemns Dink’s
assassination and supports Turkey’s pledge to conduct an exhaustive
investigation into his killing. Furthermore, the legislation urges
Turkey to take appropriate action to protect freedom of speech in
Turkey by repealing Article 301 of the Turkish Penal Code, which
criminalizes public discussion on the Armenian Genocide. The
resolution also calls on Turkey to reestablish full diplomatic,
political and economic relations with Armenia.