ANKARA: `Armenian Claims’ tops Turkish FM talks with US Congressmen

Journal of Turkish Weekly, Turkey
Feb 9 2007

`Armenian Claims’ tops Turkish FM Gul’s talks with US Congressmen
Print

Friday , 09 February 2007

In Washington for talks with senior US officials, Turkish Foreign
Minister Abdullah Gul met with John Murtha, the chairman of the
defense sub-committee of the House of Representatives Appropriations
Committee, and House majority leader Congressman Steny Hoyer.

During both meetings Mr. Gul said a resolution proposed to the US
House of Representatives constitutes a threat to relations between
the two countries.

Gul later had talks with Congressman Robert Wexler, co-chairman of
the Turkish- American Friendship Group, Tom Lantos, the chairman of
the House Committee on Foreign Relations, and Congressman Roy Blunt.

Lantos had supported Turkey’s position on the "Armenian genocide
claims" issue in the past, but after the Turkish Parliament’s refusal
on March 1, 2003 to allow the deployment of 62,000 US troops in
Turkish territory to launch a northern front in the war with Iraq,
Lantos said he would shift his position and back the resolution.

Turkish Foreign Ministry spokesman Levent Balman said Gul’s meetings
at the US Congress have been positive.

US State Department spokesman Sean McCormack said, "We understand
very clearly that this is a sensitive issue not only for the Turkish
people but also for the Armenian people."

McCormack also said that the State Department is working with the
Congress to pass Turkey’s concerns regarding the issue. However, he
said, "I think Gul and the Turkish government understand how our
government system work, and that the Congress is a separate body."

US President George Bush will have to persuade the new
Democratic-controlled congress, which does not need presidential
approval to pass such a resolution. Members behind the proposed bill
have said they expect a push by the administration and lobbyists
working for the Turkish government to keep the resolution from a full
vote by the House.

House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, who will decide whether to offer the bill
for a full vote if, as expected, it is approved by the House Foreign
Affairs Committee, has already expressed support.

Gul said they do not plan to meet with Pelosi because she is "too
engaged" in the issue but he will meet with her close aides and
friends to make sure Turkey’s views are heard.

Turkey rejects the "genocide" accusations and argues that only
300,000 Armenians and at least as many Turks died in mutual civil
strife. The Ottoman Armenians rioted during the First World War and
the armed Armenian groups attacked the Turkish and Kurdish villages.
The Istanbul Government decided to re-settle about 800.000 Armenians
to Syria province of the State. The decision was similar to the
re-settlement campaign of the Japanese American people during the
Second World War.

`Our Glad’ painted in a new light

North Shore Times, Australia
Feb 9 2007

`Our Glad’ painted in a new light

08Feb07

GORDON artist Diana Cole wanted to paint a portrait of Gladys
Berejiklian for the exhibition Power in the House because she saw her
as someone totally commited to Parliament.

“I’ve painted two portraits and now I have to work out which one to
enter,” Cole said.

“I’d like to submit one for the Archibald Prize if the paint is dry
in time but my main objective is the Power in the House exhibition.”

Before she began painting, Cole spent some time on research.

“I like a portrait to include references which tell something about
the subject,” she said.

“Gladys has Armenian ancestry and Armenians are proud that their
country was the first totally Christian nation.

“Crosses on the border of the painting are a reference to
Christianity.”

As elected Member for Willoughby, Gladys represents an area including
Artarmon, Cammeray, Castle Cove, Chatswood, Naremburn, Northbridge
and Willoughby.

She also lives in Willoughby.

Cole’s home is in Gordon but she feels that Willoughby is almost her
second home because she has spent so much time with the Sketch Club
at the Workshop Art Centre in Laurel St.

“I like to paint portraits of people who interest me,” Cole said.

“I do not accept commissions because I am a figurative artist, not a
portrait painter.”

Member for Willoughby since 2003, Ms Berejiklian is the first person
of Armenian descent to be elected to NSW Parliament.

It was another “first” for Ms Berejiklian, who as president of the
NSW Young Liberal Party was one of only four female presidents in the
Party’s history.

Having her portrait painted was a also a “first”.

“I never thought I would have it done,” she said.

“I didn’t think I’d have the courage but from the moment I met Diana
I felt confident.

“I have enjoyed seeing how she works and I like the way she paints
real people.”

ANKARA: It was all about Iraq… sort of

Today’s Zaman, Turkey
Feb 9 2007

It was all about Iraq… sort of

by Ali Aslan

In a capital that sleeps and wakes up with Iraq, what else could be
the main topic of discussion with a distinguished visitor from the
immediate neighborhood of Iraq?
The US and Turkey cooperate and consult one another on a wide range
of issues listed in the Strategic Partnership Document. But Turkish
Foreign Minister Abdullah Gul’s Washington visit was mainly about
Iraq.
Turkey’s fight against the PKK was a subset of the Iraq discussion.
Even the prospects of an Armenian genocide resolution, another
primary Turkish concern, is linked to Iraq because both
administrations know that US-Turkish collaboration in Iraq would
suffer a severe blow if the US Congress approved it.
It is hard to think of a country in the region that the US cooperates
more with on so many topics, ranging from the Balkans to Central
Asia. But Gul was not shy when he linked Turkey’s continued
contribution — particularly in Iraq and Afghanistan — to the
rejection of the genocide resolution. It sounded more like a
prediction than a threat.
Cognizant of the strategic significance of Turkey, the Bush
administration has treated their Turkish guests with the utmost care.
Gul was granted a meeting with Vice President Dick Cheney, and a rare
half hour one-on-one session was held with Secretary of State
Condoleeza Rice. High*profile think tank members, prominent
journalists like New York Times correspondent Thomas Friedman and
many international policy experts joined the occasions at Gul’s
hotel.
Perhaps the only place that lacked hospitality were the chambers of
the US Congressö poisoned by Armenian genocide lobbyists.
Unfortunately, as Democrats are challenging the Bush administration’s
Iraq policy and trying to prove themselves a more constructive force
in foreign affairs, some of their most influential members, like
House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, are preparing to intimidate a crucial
ally.
Republicans made a grave mistake when they tried bringing democracy
and self-criticism to the Islamic world by military force. Democrats
are near to committing a similar mistake by trying to mature Turkey’s
self-criticism of its history via legislative force. As was the case
of Iraq, any push in the absence of a prerequisite social,
intellectual and economic infrastructure would not yield a desired
change in Turkey.
The natural consequence of any foreign military intervention and
pressure in a country is increasing nationalism. Please see figure A
in Iraq. The effects of foreign legislative intervention and pressure
could be similar. Since there was suppressed ethnic and religious
identity in Iraq, sectarian uprisings provoked the by the US
occupation have now brought the country to the verge of fracture.
In the case of Turkey, which is also a relatively mixed and diverse
country, one can see increased nationalism might break up the
country’s culture of living together. In addition, crazy people under
the influence of nationalism could attack minorities, as has already
happened with Hrant Dink. As if domestic factors for ultranationalist
tendencies weren’t enough, irresponsible actions on the part of
foreign elements give extremists extra ammunition.
Americans are right when they say Dink’s assassination didn’t really
help "Turkishness," but hurt it. Similarly, a political assassination
against Turkey by semi-official recognition of a historically
disputed genocide would not help "Armenian-ness" at all. That is
certainly the case with "American-ness," too.
When Gul was arguing against the resolution in Washington, he said
this was not an American matter. Indeed, neither Americans nor
Armenians nor Turks would benefit from increased nationalism. How can
the US and Armenia expect a meaningful outreach from Turkey if they
follow the path of provocation? I believe it this resolution passes,
it will be politically impossible for any government in Turkey to
strike a reconciliation deal with Armenia in the foreseeable future.
Fortunately, America’s executive branch was smart enough to realize
that. The indications so far are that they are going to push hard
against it. We only hope the US Congress does not trade vital
American national interests with some misguided convictions and soft
money.

Concerns grow over Turkey rights

Religious Intelligence Ltd, UK
Feb 9 2007

Concerns grow over Turkey rights
Friday, 9th February 2007. 3:06pm

By: Matthew Cresswell.

TWO TURKISH Christians are facing trial in Istanbul for `insulting’
their nationality and reviling Islam.

Meanwhile heightened security surrounds Silivri where the trial is
unfolding in light of the recent assination of Turkish Christian
journalist Hrant Dink – murdered in Istanbul by a teenage
nationalist.

The two men, Hakan Tastan and Turan Topal, are facing criminal
charges for insulting their Turkish identity under the nation’s
Article 301. Heading up the team of opposition lawyers was
ultranationalist attornet Kemal Kerincsiz – known for hounding Dink
who spoke against the government’s silencing of the 1915 Armenian
genocide.

Both converts from Islam, Tastan and Topal are also being accused of
reviling Islam, under Article 216, and for compiling private data on
Turkish citizens for a correspondence course, Article 135.

One accuser was Fatih Kose, aged 23, who gave an account of when he
had allegedly heard `illegal’ statements from the two defendants. But
defence lawyer Haydar Polat told Compass News his testimony was very
`contradictory’, which angered the judge hearing the case.

It was also unclear as to why the other two accusers, two teenage
boys, were unable to testify.

The court was told that they had not received permission from school,
but this was questionable as Turkey’s schools were currently on
vacation. The next hearing will be on April 18.

BAKU: Lennmarker said it was important to learn both parties’ stance

Today, Azerbaijan
Feb 10 2007

Lennmarker said it was important to learn both parties’ stances on
conflict

10 February 2007 [01:11] – Today.Az

President of the OSCE Parliamentary Assembly Goran Lennmarker met
with a group of NGO representatives in Azerbaijan.

Head of the Society for Woman Rights Defense Novella Jafaroglu told
reporters that the issues concerning human rights defense,
improvement of electoral law and the Nagorno Karabakh conflict
between Armenia and Azerbaijan were discussed at the meeting. NGO
representatives expressed their will to join negotiations between
Azerbaijan and European organizations on the amendments to the
Election Code.

Lennmarker called his visit to Baku very effective stressing that he
has learned the positions of both parties to the Nagorno Karabakh
conflict.

Answering the question on why he didn’t meet with President Robert
Kocharian in Yerevan, he said he had been told that the president was
abroad.

URL:

http://www.today.az/news/politics/36222.html

ANKARA: `Nationalism race’

Today’s Zaman, Turkey
Feb 10 2007

`Nationalism race’

by
MÜMTAZ’ER TÜRKÖNE

`They shall digest Turkishness!’ says Republican People’s Party (CHP)
Leader Deniz Baykal, speaking about the controversial Article 301 of
the Turkish Penal Code.

The said article defines the crime of `insulting Turkishness,’ whose
commission entails an imprisonment of up to three years. With the
murder of Turkish-Armenian journalist Hrant Dink, the long-debated
article became the focal point of political discussions. Political
identities and attitudes were divided along the support/opposition
line to the article. Most importantly, some discussions referred to
the provocative climate created by the article as the primary reason
for Dink’s murder. He was prosecuted under the article on the grounds
that he insulted Turkishness.
The crime of `insulting Turkishness’ as outlined in Article 301 may
have different meanings because of speculation as to what
`Turkishness’ connotes. The majority of Turkish citizens are of
ethnic Turkish origin. The Constitution transforms this ethnic
identity to an expression of citizenship bonds. By providing that
`Everyone bound to the Turkish state through the bond of citizenship
is a Turk,’ Article 66 of Turkish Constitution transforms the term
`Turk’ from an ethnic reference to a legal description. For this
reason, skeptics argue that the `Turkishness’ invoked in Article 301
reconstructs the ethnic references and thus contradicts with the
Constitution.
Last November, Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoðan called on civil
society organizations to work on possible amendments to Article 301.
While initial attempts failed, after Dink’s murder, the amendment
process was revitalized. Last week, another meeting attended by civil
society organizations was held to address the issue, but once again,
the attempt was unsuccessful. Just recently, the organizations
announced they reached an agreement on an amended text. The statement
provides that because of the vagueness of the present text, different
meanings could be inferred; hence `Turkishness’ should be replaced by
`Turkish nation.’ The newly invented formula will apparently not work
out. Because the notion `Turkishness’ is preserved intact, the
accompanying term `Turkish nation’ will unlikely eliminate the
different interpretations and change the definition of the existing
crime. Those who put forward this proposal, while using the notion
`Turkishness’ in the ethnical sense, think they use `Turkish nation’
as the match of modern `nation.’ But the problem is not in the
description of the `Turkishness’ notion but in the description of
`Turkish nation’ so as to embrace all Turkish citizens. As such,
those who interpret this article may demand the interpretation of the
`Turkish nation’ in parallel with the ethnic content of
`Turkishness.’
Because they did not agree with the proposal, the leftist Turkish
Physicians Association and labor union DÝSK left the meeting. In its
present form, the amendment proposal lags even behind the already
controversial existing article text.
The entire discussion process shows that supporting the full
preservation of the article in its present form is cited as the
benign manifestation of an extreme nationalist and even chauvinist
stance. Baykal’s remark, `They shall digest Turkishness,’ represents
this extreme nationalist view. CHP asserts Article 301 should be kept
as it is. The only leftist party of Turkish political landscape
aligns itself with the extreme nationalist circles. Let us recall CHP
is a member of Socialist International.
Citing Matt Bryza from the US State Department, Yasemin Çongar noted
that nationalism was viewed by the US administration as the only
common concept of Turkish politics. Bryza asserted the rise of
nationalism was not at an alarming level. He is not so wrong.
Nationalism has already created the discussion ground on which the
upcoming elections would be based. The primary actors of the
political landscape question the nationalist stance of their
opponents. Prime Minister and AK Party leader Recep Tayyip Erdoðan,
while openly accusing the MHP, the party that managed to transform
the nationalist ideology into a political movement, of racism,
asserts that his party adopts a positive nationalist approach. In
order not to lag behind in the race, the only leftist party CHP, as
already noted, adopts an ethno-centric nationalist paradigm as a
political discourse.
Apparently, the secularism-reactionary movement debate that has long
dominated the realm of political discussions is being replaced by the
conflicting views on nationalism. The message President Ahmet Necdet
Sezer gave last week on the occasion of 70th anniversary of the
inclusion of secularism principle in the constitution harbored some
elements that certainly need further discussion. Quite unusually, the
president barred the judiciary from making comments on secularism.
The lack of attention to this message, which did not trigger new
debates, demonstrates how busy the political environment is with the
nationalism discussions.
How does the domination of competition by all political actors along
nationalist lines affect Turkey’s future?
The answer to this question should be sought in the sociological base
that feeds nationalism. Society — particularly the younger
generations — are experiencing a state of common anomie in
connection with the crash of the tradition under modernity’s impacts.
Unemployment, poverty and the huge income disparities as reflected
through the TV screens lead the youth to hatred and anger. They seek
a scapegoat to blame for all mistakes. Nationalism serves as a
channel to embrace this anger. Every challenge in foreign or domestic
policy is transformed into a concrete enemy. The already growing
anti-Americanism is further fostered by nationalism. The developments
in northern Iraq since the US occupation and the likely division of
Iraq in three separate states rise serious concerns. The Kirkuk issue
has become the most important foreign policy issue of the Turkish
state. The EU is accused of double standards and hypocrisy vis-à-vis
Turkey. The Cyprus issue has become the most favorite discussion of
nationalist politics.
The nationalist race among political parties will inevitably deepen
the already existing nationalist concerns. A race that will take
place between the different tones of nationalism will most probably
create a much more serious breakdown than secularism debates did in
the near past. The race that took place along the secularism debate
was easy to control because of its state-oriented character. When the
generals became reluctant to express their concerns over secularism,
the tension was eased in its natural course. Conversely, nationalism
has the potential to politicize the social issues and create distinct
sides by partitioning the entire society into opposing poles. It is
already evident that nationalism embodies strong feelings. A
political discourse seized by sentiments and emotions will only
promote hatred and enmity.
To resolve a political equation with multiple unknown variables, we
must be able to provide a satisfactory answer to this question: Will
the tension that politics creates be reflected in the society in its
entirety? Or will the competition that fosters nationalism remain a
political fantasy detached from the public?It seems that society’s
anticipation of political stability is strong enough to suppress the
herein reviewed nationalist race.

ANKARA: US envoy says USA committed to fighting terrorism

Milliyet, Turkey
Feb 8 2007

Turkey: US envoy says USA committed to fighting terrorism

Text of a report by Sami Kohen: "Are we not on the same page as the
United States?" published by Turkish newspaper Milliyet website on 8
February

Talks between Turkey and the United States, especially with respect
to overcoming the different points of view regarding northern Iraq,
the PKK [Kurdistan Workers’ Party] and the Armenian problems, are
intensifying.

Foreign Minister Abdullah Gul’s current visit to the United States is
one link in this chain of meetings. Just recently Defence Minister
Vecdi Gonul was in Washington. A delegation of Turkish lawmakers has
just returned from the United States and Chief of Staff Gen Yasar
Buyukanit is off to Washington next week.

Meanwhile, there are people who regard these talks as "actors not
being on the same page". Really, as far as the public has been made
aware to date these meetings have failed to produce anything visible,
at least nothing in the way of meeting Turkey’s expectations. The
Turkish side is telling its American counterparts what it wants, what
it expects and what its complaints are. Similarly, the American side
is telling its Turkish counterparts where they stand and what the
problems are.

Can it go any further than this?

Foreign Minister Gul says: "I saw an attentiveness in Washington I
had not seen last year. They feel compelled to do something. I will
not talk much about this but there is some commitment."

When?

What we heard US Ambassador Ross Wilson say when he spoke with a
group of columnists in Istanbul yesterday was along those lines.

We spoke with him about two "critical issues" in particular. One was
about the situation in northern Iraq, the PKK presence there and the
future of Kirkuk.

When we reminded him that the Turkish-US talks that have been going
on regarding this topic for some time had turned into a "dialogue
between deaf people" Wilson objected to this. "Speaking as somebody
who has attended most of these meetings I can say that this is not a
‘dialogue of the deaf’." But he did state that he was aware of
Turkey’s expectation and disappointments. He emphasized that despite
this their efforts were still continuing and that "visible" results
would soon be achieved.

When and like what, for example? Echoing Foreign Minister Gul,
Ambassador Wilson said he would "not divulge much more" and added,
"You cannot announce in advance what your counter-terrorism plans
are."

Despite this, Wilson stated that some results were being achieved
right now as a result of the counter-terrorism envoy’s efforts. He
linked the raids against the PKK in France and Belgium and the
arrests made to these efforts.

We also asked this of the ambassador: What will the United States do
if Turkey mounts a cross-border operation? We know that certain
official voices in Washington have noted their opposition to this
eventuality. Wilson preferred to leave this question unanswered.

In fact, Turkey has always expected the United States to make an
effort to put an end to the PKK presence in northern Iraq. Is this a
case of "not putting in the right cc’s?" Should Baghdad and northern
Iraq also be cc’d? Ankara is trying to resolve this business
"exclusively" through Washington.

What if it gets passed?

The second important topic of our interview with the US ambassador
concerned the "Armenian genocide bill" being submitted to the House
of Representatives.

Wilson emphasized that this was not a "law" only a "ruling" and that
it was not binding on President Bush or his administration.

Frankly, the American officials and diplomats are afraid that this
ruling will get passed this time. In fact, Wilson is planning to go
to Washington next month to do some "lobbying".

He is aware that if this ruling is passed it will have a very adverse
impact on Turkish-US relations. But despite this he says: "But there
are so many other issues out there: Iraq, the PKK, Cyprus, the EU,
Iran, the Middle East etc, we need to work on these together. Any
breakdown in relations will be harmful for both sides. We need each
other more than ever before."

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Recognition of genocide a political issue in Turkey

Guelph Mercury (Ontario, Canada)
February 9, 2007 Friday
Final Edition

Recognition of genocide a political issue in Turkey

by VARTAN OSKANIAN

Ankara has let a rare moment pass. Three weeks after the
assassination of acclaimed Turkish Armenian journalist Hrant Dink, it
appears the Turkish authorities have grasped neither the message of
Hrant’s life nor the significance of his death.

In the days immediately following Dink’s shocking death, allegedly at
the hands of a fanatic Turkish nationalist, we in Armenia and others
around the world wanted to believe that the outpouring of public
grief would create a crack in the Turkish wall of denial and
rejection, and that efforts would be made to chip away at the
conditions that made the assassination possible. We all hoped that
the gravity of this slaying and the breadth of the reaction would
have compelled Turkey’s leaders to seize the moment and make a
radical shift in the policies that sustain today’s dead-end
situation.

However, after those initial hints at conciliation, the message out
of Ankara has already changed. Last week, according to the Turkish
media, Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan said there can be
no rapprochement with Armenians because Armenians still insist on
talking about the genocide, mass killings of Armenians during the
First World War.

The prime minister is right. Armenians do insist on talking about the
genocide. It’s a history-changing event that ought not, indeed
cannot, be forgotten. However, we also advocate a rapprochement. And
one is not a precondition for the other.

Dink was an advocate of many things. Chief among them, he believed
that individuals have the right to think, to talk, to explore, to
debate. Dink knew that if the authorities would just allow people to
reflect and reason aloud, share questions and search for answers,
everything would fall into place. Eventually, through public and
private discourse, Turks would arrive at genocide recognition
themselves.

Equally, he also believed that there must be dialogue between
peoples, between nations — especially between his two peoples, the
Armenians and the Turks. He himself was a one-man dialogue, carrying
on both sides of the conversation, trying to make one side’s needs
and fears audible to the other.

Unfortunately, Turkey’s policy of keeping the Armenian-Turkish border
closed has resulted in a reinforcement of animosities. Dink was one
of many Armenian and Turkish intellectuals who understood that there
needs to be free movement of people and ideas in order to achieve
reconciliation among neighbours. But Turkey insists on maintaining
the last closed border in Europe as a tool to exert pressure on
Armenia, to make its foreign policy more pliant, to punish Armenians
for defending their rights and not renouncing their past. Armenia, on
the other hand, has no preconditions to normalizing relations.

This hermetically closed border combined with a law that prevents
Turkey from exploring its own history and memory — by criminalizing
truth-seekers such as Dink — have created a world in which Turks
can’t know their past and can’t forge their future.

Three weeks ago, our grief was mixed with hope. Today, Turkish
authorities continue to defend Article 301, the notorious "insulting
Turkishness" statute used to prosecute even novelists who depict
characters questioning Ankara’s official line on the genocide. And
there is no mention at all of the continuing damage caused by a
closed border.

If Turkey can’t seize the moment, it should not be surprised when
others do. Last week, a resolution was introduced in the U.S.
Congress to affirm the U.S. record on the Armenian genocide.

The Turks will say such a resolution is not needed. They will say
that they’ve called for a joint Armenian-Turkish historical
commission to discuss the genocide, and they don’t need third
parties. But recognition of the Armenian genocide is no longer a
historical issue in Turkey, it’s a political one. Dink would wonder
how "on the one hand, they call for dialogue with Armenia and
Armenians, on the other hand they want to condemn or neutralize their
own citizen who is working for dialogue."

Dink was courageous but not naive. Still, he could not have predicted
this kind of "neutralization." The brutality of his killing serves
several political ends. First, it makes Turkey less interesting for
Europe, which is exactly what some in the Turkish establishment want.
Second, it may scare away Armenians and other minorities in Turkey
from pursuing their civil and human rights. Third, it can frighten
into silence those bold Turks who are beginning to explore these
complicated, sensitive subjects in earnest.

I prefer to think that more noble political ideals will be served.
Hrant Dink will remain an inspiration for Armenians who share his
vision of understanding and harmony among peoples and for Turks who
share his dream of living in peace with neighbours and with history.

Vartan Oskanian is minister of foreign affairs of the Republic of
Armenia. This column appeared in the Los Angeles Times.

RUSSIA: Armenia is prepared to betray us

Agency WPS
What the Papers Say Part B (Russia)
February 9, 2007 Friday

ARMENIA IS PREPARED TO BETRAY US;
Yerevan dreams of the Trans-Caspian Gas Pipeline

by Sergei Sklyarov, Mikhail Sergeyev

Armenian foreign minister’s reckless statement may offend Moscow;
Armenian Foreign Minister Vardan Oskanian has said that Yerevan is
considering joining the upcoming Trans-Caspian Gas Pipeline project,
in an effort to make Central Asian gas producers less dependent on
transit via Russia.

Addressing the parliament on February 7, Armenian Foreign Minister
Vardan Oskanian said Yerevan is considering joining the upcoming
Trans-Caspian Gas Pipeline project, in an effort to make Central
Asian gas producers less dependent on transit via Russia.

"We are importing gas from Russia nowadays. Imports of gas from Iran
will begin soon. We intend to apply for some gas from Central Asia as
well," Oskanian said. "Diversifying import routes is undeniably
important for Armenia. This is a problem we will be tackling from all
angles." This is not the first statement to the effect that Yerevan
would like to participate in construction of the gas pipeline.
Oskanian made his previous statement on the issue a month ago, give
or take a few days.

At this point, builders of the gas pipeline want it running from
Tenghiz (Kazakhstan) to Turkmenbashi (Turkmenistan) to Baku
(Azerbaijan) to Tbilisi (Georgia) to Erzerum (Turkey). No branches to
Armenia are planned because Azerbaijan backed by Turkey refuses to
consider Yerevan’s economic interests or need pending
Nagorno-Karabakh conflict settlement. Aware of the political futility
of counting on Azeri gas, the Armenian diplomat emphasized that what
he was talking about concerned gas import from Central Asian
countries and not from Azerbaijan as such. Oskanian added that
Armenia did not intend to make concessions to Azerbaijan in the
matter of Nagorno-Karabakh for the sake of gas.

Baku promptly responded. Azeri Foreign Ministry spokesman Tair
Tagizade told the Turan news agency that no bilateral or multilateral
relations with Armenia are possible until the Nagorno-Karabakh
conflict is resolved.

Even experts are fairly skeptical about Armenia’s chances of becoming
involved. "The whole project of the Trans-Caspian Gas Pipeline looks
ill-planned and economically inexpedient, and Armenia’s participation
will make it even more risky," Valery Nesterov from Troika Dialog
told us. "After all, the Azeri-Armenian confrontation over
Nagorno-Karabakh is not going to be over in the foreseeable future."

All things considered, Oskanian’s statement doesn’t look particularly
far-sighted or even tactful. Armenia’s chances of receiving Central
Asian gas are negligible, but relations with its ally, Russia, may
sour over what was essentially an anti-Russian statement.

Source: Nezavisimaya Gazeta, February 9, 2007, p. 4

Translated by A. Ignatkin

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

ANKARA: US official says genocide res. could damage ties with Turkey

Anatolia News Agency, Turkey
Feb 8 2007

US official says Armenian genocide resolution could damage ties with
Turkey

Ankara, 8 February: Adoption of the resolution on so-called Armenian
genocide by the US House of Representatives would damage Turkish-US
relations and it would not serve Turkish-Armenian dialogue, said the
US assistant secretary of state for European and Eurasian affairs,
Dan Fried.

Answering questions of Turkish journalists at a video conference
organized by the US embassy in Turkish capital of Ankara, Fried said
that several matters concerning both the US and Turkey were discussed
during Turkish Foreign Minister Abdullah Gul’s talks in the USA,
stating that Turkish and US authorities exchanged views on Iraq,
Afghanistan, Israel-Palestine conflict, Lebanon, Caucasus and Central
Asia.

Stressing that the United States considered PKK [Kurdistan Workers’
Party] a terrorist organization, Fried said that they welcomed
operations against terrorist organization in some European countries.
Noting that Turkey and the USA had cooperation with their European
friends on this matter, Fried indicated that they would continue to
fight against terrorist organization PKK not only in Europe but also
in the north of Iraq.

Replying to a question on referendum in Kirkuk, Fried said Turkey was
free to explain its views on this matter but Iraqi people should make
a decision on it by themselves.

Fried summarized the US administration’s policy about the resolution
on the so-called Armenian genocide presented to the US House of
Representatives as the "administration does not support it".

Answering a question on possible outcomes of adoption of the
resolution, Fried said that its adoption would damage Turkish-US
relations and would not serve Turkish-Armenian dialogue. Turkish-US
relations are important than any particular issue, Fried underlined
and stated that Turkey and the USA had common interests in several
regions.

Fried noted that democratic countries should look at their dark sides
in their histories, stating that the USA also had some dark sides in
its history.

Stating that he felt deep sad over killing of journalist Hrant Dink,
Fried said the reaction that was shown during the funeral of Dink was
a strong and sound one.

Asked whether Turkey made some advices to the United States, Fried
noted that they welcomed Turkey’s advices, stating that Foreign
Minister Gul made some suggestions on several issues, including the
Middle East, Iraq, Lebanon and Afghanistan.