Movie Review: A noble attempt to understand genocide

Boston Globe, MA
Feb 9 2007

MOVIE REVIEW
A noble attempt to understand genocide

By Wesley Morris, Globe Staff | February 9, 2007

In 90 minutes, Carla Garapedian’s documentary "Screamers" tries to
get a lot done — too much, in fact. The movie’s principal goals are
to decry the Armenian genocide in 1915 at the hands of the Turks and
to wrestle with the enduring controversy over whether the slaughter
constitutes genocide. Garapedian also holes up with the intelligent
hard-rock outfit System of a Down , four affable and earnest
Armenian-American guys who, along with millions of other people, want
the 1915 massacre, in which a million and a half Armenians died,
ruled genocide once and for all.

But "Screamers" doesn’t stop there. Randomly inserted amid chunks of
time on the System of a Down tour bus and footage of the band onstage
are interviews with Armenian survivors. Garapedian talks to Hrant
Dink , the Armenian-Turkish journalist who was slain last month and
whose assassination, as awful as it was, might have begun a healing
process between Turkey and Armenians. There is footage from a
congressional hearing last year that produced a resolution to
recognize the events of 1915 as genocide. President Bush hasn’t
recognized the resolution, the prevailing hypothesis being that the
United States doesn’t want to anger Turkey. We need the air bases.

This film has provocations to spare; it just hasn’t been made
provocatively. It’s a mess, actually. Most of the content is
inarguable, but Garapedian’s handling of it leaves much to be
desired. Several subjects compete for our attention, and since the
filmmaker can’t seem to decide how best to arrange them, the parsing
is left to us. Garapedian, an Armenian-American from Los Angeles, has
an extensive international broadcast journalism background, but she
has a hard time clearly situating the Armenian genocide within the
larger political-moral problem of genocide itself.

Concert footage of System of a Down performing, say, its
half-melodic, half-infuriated, and dangerously good anti war song,
"B.Y.O.B.," aren’t easily wed with impassioned park-bench
explanations of genocide from journalist Samantha Power. Atom
Egoyan’s 2002 historical drama about the genocide, "Ararat," was a
similarly noble blur.

The way "Screamers" is staged, a lot of the film’s material feels
like padding, rather than a collection of scenes gathering toward a
climactic conclusion. The sheer importance and personal urgency of
the material seems to have gotten the better of the filmmaking. Or
maybe "Screamers" is intended to serve a purely tutorial end. That
might meet an obvious, urgent political need, but it doesn’t do the
film’s many fascinating strands any lasting favors.

Kurds say Armenians head towards a bright future in the Region

Kurdish Aspect, CO
Feb 9 2007

Kurds say Armenians head towards a bright future in the Region

The Kurdish Globe – by Khidhr Domle

"The most important case here (in Kurdistan) is the rule of law,"
says Dr. Lewis, an Armenian university-professor.

"Kurdistan Region has become part of the Western world and
civilization, which people look at with respect ? and the majority
push towards this direction; it is a civilized trait."

"Turkey should be punished," Nasik Minas Abraham, an Armenian who
fled Baghdad 8 years ago and came to live in Kurdistan, says. "Turks
killed the Armenian journalist because he was trying to uncover the
truth, which must be revealed."

She says despite the fact she was not reading his articles before he
was assassinated and did not know much about him; she has since then
learnt of his activities, including his attempts to unveil the truth
that would have convicted Turkey of the Armenian genocide. "He was a
great journalist who had a goal and struggled for it; and Turkey
eleminated him," Nasik says, angrily.

Fleeing Baghdad and settling in Kurdistan Region has resulted in a
sharp increase in the number of Armenians in the region. Armenians do
not face any kind of discrimination against them, regional
authorities say. "Being a minority in Kurdistan, our rights have
never been violated," Artin Khalatiyan, the Pastor of the Armenian
Orthodox Church in Zakho, says. "The most important issue for us is
to lay the foundation of brotherhood and the spread of love, which
are things we pray for, for everyone and not just the Armenians," he
says. "Similar to all other minorities, we hope that our rights will
be granted in the Constitution of Kurdistan."

Comparing the situation of Armenianas in Kurdistan to their patriots
living in Turkey, he says, "It is very unfortunate that he (Hrant
Dink) was assassinated ? this proves that the Turkish authorities
were afraid of him because he was an active journalist to whom the
Armenian rights mattered."

The Pastor also touched the case of Armenians fleeing Mosul following
the explosion of their church on January 5, 2006. "Around a hundred
(Armenian) families have fled to Duhok (in Kurdistan), with many to
Karakush, in the north of Mosul as well as Ainkawa in Erbil."

According to Artin, eleven hundred Armenians live in Zakho. He said,
"Armenians paid dearly during the 1915 Massacre in Turkey." He added
that the Ottoman Empire slaughtered 70% of the rest of the Armenian
people. "(But) we feel safe here, the Kurdish government is assisting
all the Armenians who have fled." He added that "30 families in Zakho
are receiving monthly aid and there are attempts to rebuild the
Armenian villages."

"The campaign to rebuild Armenian villages has started at Hawresk
Village, for the Armenians," he said. "It is on the highway between
Zakho and Duhok."

Living in peace and brotherhood is the objective. "Our goal is to
live in peace and to spread love and forgiveness, which we lost," he
said. "We, in our prayers, ask for promotion of these principles for
the rest of the people of Kurdistan, not only for Armenians."

Kurdistan is the place where followers of different religions live
together in harmony. "Kurdistan has started inculcating the culture
of religious forgiveness and brotherhood," Dr. Lewis of the Faculty
of Basic Education at the University of Duhok said. "Kurdish
leadership has been respecting these principles and working hard to
emphasize them," he confirmed. "It is not the Armenians alone who
feel safe, but every one in Kurdistan feels safe and sound, and hopes
for a prosperous future."

According to Dr. Lewis, "Sectarian conflict has changed the social
structure of Iraq; but Kurdistan Region has promoted its racial and
ethnic diversity, and worked in accordance with the Constitution so
that all groups can assure their rights – cultural and political."

Ms. Polis, another Armenian, believes that "it is not the Armenians
alone who want to live in peace and prosperity, but everyone else in
Kurdistan, too."

"Our neighbors are all of different cultures, but they all respect
us," she says, referring to neighborhood where she lives. "There is
friendship among Muslims, Christians, Armenians and Ezidis, and I
believe the future is going to improve."

Tranick Hartean, 46, believes that Kurdistan is becoming home to
co-existence and religious tolerance. He hopes that everyone will
continue to work towards understanding among Muslims, Christians,
Chaldo-Assyrians and Armenians and all other religious sects for
"every society to enjoy their rights."

In Kurdistan, most Armenians feel they have their rights guaranteed.
"The services provided by the Kurdistan Regional Government make us,
Armenians, feel that we have our rights granted to us," says
Khalatiyan. "That is in spite of the fact that we know we have our
own country – Armenia." He added, "What we receive here is
indisputable evidence – we are all equal here."

The rule of law must prevail, Dr. Lewis believes. "The most important
case here is the rule of law," he says. "Kurdistan Region has become
part the Western world and civilization at which people view with
respect ? the majority push towards this direction; it is a civilized
trait."

It is worth mentioning that most Armenians fled Turkey during the
massacres committed against them during WWI. They resettled, mostly,
in Shingal, Zakho, Mosul and Duhok. The Church Virgin Marry for
Armenians was built in 1923. Today, there are many pictures hanged on
the walls; telling the stories of the Armenian Genocide.

html

http://www.kurdishaspect.com/doc0209KD.

ANKARA: The U.S. Might Discuss A Cross-border Op With Turkey

Anatolian Times, Turkey
Feb 9 2007

The U.S. Might Discuss A Cross-border Op With Turkey
BY ASLI AYDINBAS
SABAH- The US administration, which is preparing to receive Chief of
General Staff Gen. Yasar Buyukanit close on the heels of Foreign
Minister Abdullah Gul, has given signals that it’s ready to discuss a
cross-border operation in northern Iraq against the terrorist PKK. A
high-ranking official from the Bush administration, which has put the
brakes on cross-border ops in recent years, told Sabah that everybody
understood Turkey’s concerns and that now certain figures in the
administration see this request favorably. The official said that the
Bush people might discuss the request for an operation on the
condition that it’s `limited and definite.’ He said that some in the
administration were open to discussing it, but they should firstly
consider all other alternatives. He added that the territory was very
rough and it wasn’t clear what would be found across the border.
American sources are ready to discuss a limited and definite
operation against PKK leaders using civilian and military officials
from Turkey, instead of a military operation using a large number of
soldiers. However, the sources who spoke to Sabah said that US
Special Envoy for countering terrorism Joseph Ralston’s recent visit
and the contacts held by the chief of General Staff had both been
successful. `Firstly, let’s talk about other alternatives,’ one
added. `There’s sympathy for Turkey’s position, but there are also
certain efforts to find a scapegoat in the PKK issue. Yes, the PKK is
a large problem for Turkey, but the issue doesn’t end with it.’

The US administration says that the civilian and military sectors in
Turkey neglected to try non-military methods against the PKK and also
stresses that terrorism is a multidimensional problem with military,
economic and social aspects. Officials also emphasize that the recent
rise of nationalism in Turkey and the election-year atmosphere
brought the military alternative to the forefront and that there have
been no concrete steps to solve the Kurdish issue since Prime
Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan’s landmark 2005 speech in Diyarbakir
and that the issue has been stuck between civilian and military
leaders.

But the US administration, now welcoming a cross-border op against
PKK leaders more than in recent years, is only concerned with
conventions. Washington is concerned that if the Turkish Armed Forces
(TSK) enters northern Iraq during hot pursuit or under an air
operation, neighboring countries such as Iran and Syria will assert
their own right to hot pursuit. The high-ranking official asked Sabah
how neighboring countries can be prevented from crossing the border
if Turkey enters Iraq. Also, the US government believes passage of
the Armenian resolution would make a cross-border op more likely. The
strong support received by the US Congress for the resolution spurred
the State Department, White House and Pentagon to prepare efforts to
head it off. US officials say that even a debate of the resolution on
the US House of Representatives floor would damage Turkish-American
relations and end Washington’s power to deter a cross-border
operation.

ANKARA: Washington’s Concerns About Turkey

Anatolian Times, Turkey
Feb 9 2007

Washington’s Concerns About Turkey

BY TUFAN TURENC

HURRIYET- Foreign Minister Abdullah Gul is holding interesting
meetings in Washington this week. According to Gul’s impressions,
important developments will soon occur concerning the terrorist PKK.
Are Americans again distracting Ankara, as they have done up to now,
or will they really take effective steps against the terrorist group?
Gul seems to believe the promises made by American officials.
According to the journalists accompanying him, he has a smile on his
face. If America keeps the promises it made to Gul and takes the
steps expected by Turkey, relations between the two countries, which
recently have been a `dialogue of the deaf,’ can be fixed. Washington
is concerned that the anti-American and anti-European atmosphere in
Turkey could worsen, because they have already reached a dangerous
level. Washington is also concerned by the racist and nationalist
wave rising in Turkey. I think they realize that European countries
played an important role in this atmosphere. If they still haven’t
understood this, we should be seriously concerned.

According to experts in Washington, jingoistic elements in Turkey are
forcing the limits of our positive nationalism which has embraced
Islam and democracy. Not only the US and Europe, but also trends
which despise the country’s values played a role in this negative
development. These kinds of actions provoke illiterate people living
in areas on the outskirts of cities. Washington believes that the
basic traditions of the Turkish nation are Islam and democracy.
According to these Americans, the only party which embraces these
traditions is the Justice and Development Party (AKP). So even though
it was disappointed by the AKP after it rejected the March 1, 2003
motion on US troops in Turkey before the Iraq invasion, Washington
supports this party. Because there is no other party that Washington
can trust. Washington particularly doesn’t care for the main
opposition Republican People’s Party (CHP). It knows that the CHP was
the driving force against the March 1, 2003 motion. It doesn’t
consider the other parties as strong.

So Gul’s expectations that the US will take effective steps
concerning the terrorist PKK might have a basis. For example, they
could arrest and send a few PKK leaders to Turkey as a gesture to the
AKP before this year’s elections. This might strengthen the AKP.
However, no matter what the US does, certain facts won’t change. If
the PKK issue isn’t resolved, and if Iraq falls apart, a Kurdish
state is established in northern Iraq, Kirkuk is given to the Kurds
and a so-called Armenian genocide resolution is passed, hatred of the
US in Turkey will rise. Even if it comes to power again, the AKP can
do nothing to prevent this. If the US still can’t understand this, it
means that their diplomats and intelligence officials in Turkey may
as well have stayed at home.

ANKARA: Gul presses against ‘genocide’ resolution

New Anatolian, Turkey
Feb 9 2007

Gul presses against ‘genocide’ resolution

The New Anatolian / Washington
09 February 2007

In Washington on Wednesday, Turkish Foreign Minister Abdullah Gul
continued working against the Armenian genocide resolution set to be
debated in the U.S. House of Representatives.

Foreign Minister Gul met several members of the U.S. Congress in
order to discuss recent developments in Turkish-American relations.

He essentially underlined the threat posed by the resolution on the
so-called Armenian genocide towards relations between the two
countries.

After meeting with John Murtha, chairman of the Defense Subcommittee
of the U.S. House of Representatives Appropriations Committee, Gul
had talks with House Majority Leader Steny Hoyer, both Democrats.

After participating in the luncheon given in his honor at Congress by
members of the U.S.-Turkey Congress Working Group, Gul met with
Robert Wexler, co-chairman of the Turkish-American Friendship Group
and Democratic Party congressman from Florida.

Gul also spoke with Democrat Tom Lantos, a Jewish congressman from
California and chairman of the House Foreign Relations Committee, as
well as Congressman Roy Blunt of Missouri, from the minority
Republican Party.

Ankara: FM got positive impression

Turkish Foreign Ministry spokesperson Levent Bilman said on Wednesday
that Gul left the U.S. Congress with positive impressions.

Expressing Ankara’s uneasiness on the so-called Armenian genocide
resolution, he stated that Gul had answered questions posed by
congressmen on the Armenian allegations and clarified the issue.

The Turkish foreign minister also late Tuesday warned the U.S.
Congress that passing the resolution on the so-called Armenian
genocide would harm relations with his country.

"Passage of even a nonbinding resolution in either chamber would
seriously harm our bilateral relations," he stated.

Gul described the possible resolution as an irritant to otherwise
close cooperation with the United States on vital issues including
bringing political stability to Iraq, preventing nuclear
proliferation and connecting Asian energy supplies with European
markets. Even as the Bush administration says it will work with
members of Congress to head off the genocide resolution, Gul warned
that the U.S. government should not get involved in the sensitive
dispute.

"I believe that Turkish-American relations should not be taken
hostage by this issue," he said. "I see this as a real threat to our
relationship."

The administration also sees the issue as a threat to relations with
Turkey, a key strategic ally. The administration has opposed previous
attempts by members of Congress to pass resolutions

However, the speaker of the House of Representatives, Nancy Pelosi,
avoided meeting with Abdullah Gul, even when the two leaders were in
the same hotel.

Pelosi, who supports the so-called genocide resolution, rejected a
request from the Turkish Foreign Ministry for a meeting with Gul.
Pelosi’s office said her schedule during Gul’s visit to the U.S.
would be too busy to fit him in.

ANKARA: ‘Turkey has to consider cross-border op’s consequences’

New Anatolian, Turkey
Feb 9 2007

‘Turkey has to consider cross-border op’s consequences’

The New Anatolian / Ankara
09 February 2007

While Turkish Foreign Ministry Abdullah Gul continued his meetings in
Washington expressing Ankara’s uneasiness at the continuing Kurdistan
Workers’ Party (PKK) terrorist presence in northern Iraq, a top U.S.
official cautioned yesterday about a possible military action, "The
responsibility for the consequences is something that Turkey has to
think about."

Assistant Secretary of State for European and Eurasian Affairs Daniel
Fried, in a teleconference with Turkish journalists in Ankara, stated
that the presence of the terrorists in northern Iraq is a problem,
adding that they are discussing the problem to eliminate them.
Calling Turkey’s frustration understandable, he said the
responsibility for the consequences of possible military action is
something Turkey has to think about.

He added that Washington believes Turkey should cooperate with the
central Iraqi and Kurdish regional government.

Fried also talked about Turkish Foreign Minister Gul’s current visit
to the U.S., characterizing it as successful. He added that U.S. and
Turkish officials talked about the Middle East, Lebanon, Israel,
Iraq, Afghanistan, Central Asian, Afghanistan, the Caucasus,
diversification of energy projects, the terrorist PKK, and the
so-called Armenian genocide resolution.

He described relations between Turkey and the U.S. as very deep and
broad, stating both countries share common interests. Recalling
previous disagreements in Iraq before the 2003 invasion of Iraq,
which Turkey refused to join, he stressed, "We put any disagreements
behind us."

He said that so-called Armenian genocide resolution could damage
Turkish-U.S. relations, adding that the U.S. administration opposes
the measure and continues to work to block it.

"Turkey needs to look honestly at its own history," he added. "It is
a process of deep democracy. We need to encourage Turkey, but not
through pressure from outside"

Civic Groups Seek to Amend Law on Insults to Turkish State

New York Times, NY
Feb 9 2007

Civic Groups Seek to Amend Law on Insults to Turkish State

By SEBNEM ARSU
Published: February 9, 2007

ISTANBUL, Feb. 8 – A group of civic organizations on Thursday
submitted suggestions for rewording a section of the Turkish penal
code under which noted intellectuals and writers had been charged
with the crime of insulting the Turkish identity and the state.

But some critics of the law say it should be revoked, not amended.

After the killing last month of an Armenian-Turkish journalist, Hrant
Dink, some critics said the law, known as Article 301, was partly
responsible. According to this argument, Mr. Dink’s conviction under
the article for comments he made about the genocide in which more
than a million Armenians were killed by the Ottoman Turk government
from 1915 to 1918 made him a traitor in the eyes of many Turks and
put his life in jeopardy.

For Turkey, the Armenian issue is among the thorniest issues of free
speech. The courts have interpreted the use of the word genocide in
reference to the killings as an `insult against the Turkish state’
under Article 301.

Last year, after harsh criticism by the European Union, the
government said it was receptive to changing the law but not
abolishing it.

The proposal submitted on Thursday, signed by 10 civic organizations,
tried to make a distinction between illegal language and legal
criticism. Instead of outlawing `insulting Turkishness’ it proposed
new wording that would outlaw `openly abasing and deriding’ the
Turkish identity.

That was not enough for one civic group, the Turkish Chamber of
Doctors, which broke with the umbrella group and accused the
government of trying to evade responsibility for the law for fear of
losing voters in November’s general elections. `Changes are only a
facade and can never prevent bitter consequences, as we’ve witnessed
with Mr. Dink’s murder,’ said Gencay Gursoy, the group’s general
secretary.

Perihan Magden, a journalist who is one of a number of people given
security protection by the government after Mr. Dink’s death, said
the suggested changes were too mild to make a difference.

`The fact that I have to live in my own country under police
protection is a government acknowledgment that something is wrong,’
she said.

ANKARA: In Washington DC, FM Gul pushes against Armenian claims

Hürriyet, Turkey
Feb 9 2007

In Washington DC, FM Gul pushes against Armenian claims

With Foreign Minister Abdullah Gul on an official visit to the US
capital Washington, DC, the Armenian claims of genocide have shaped
the course of diplomacy efforts over the past days for the Turkish
delegation.

Speaking to the Hurriyet, a Turkish Foreign Ministry source said "We
have explained to everyone here how much sensitivity this matter
holds for the Turkish people. The US administration understands the
importance of the situation. We had done our best in the Congress."
The same source reasserted assurances which have emerged over the
past weeks that, as the Armenian Genocide bill proceeds further in
the Congress, it is expected that US President George W. Bush will
intercede to try and stop it. It has also been reported that US State
Department officials have prepared a letter to be given to Congress
members, and that an additional section of the letter addresses the
matter "Why Turkey is important."

The same source said to the Hurriyet: "We will continue to speak
about this at every level. We have not behaved as though this bill is
a threat. However, it is a truth that on many levels, Turkey has
helped the US. We have underlined this. Our dual relations are too
important to be toyed with by the narrow elections calculations of a
few Congress members…."

ANKARA: Mutafyan: I’ve been threatened since Dink killing

New Anatolian, Turkey
Feb 9 2007

Mutafyan: I’ve been threatened since Dink killing

The New Anatolian / Ankara
09 February 2007

Turkish-Armenian community head Patriarch Mesrob II Mutafyan
yesterday expressed growing concerns after last month’s killing of
Armenian origin Turkish journalist Hrant Dink.

Mutafyan revealed that he has been receiving threats, which,
according to the police, are from the same sources who threatened
Dink, adding that the state appointed guards for him after last
year’s murder of Catholic Priest Andrea Santoro in the northern
province of Trabzon.

Mesrob underlined that the killing of Dink seems to continue to
occupy a significant place in both domestic and world politics.

"It would certainly be a very optimistic view to deny the security
concerns of the Armenian community in Turkey, but until the Dink
assassination, no Armenian had been subjected to a serious attack for
years," Mesrob said.

On his concerns following the latest developments, he said that
Turkish Armenians fear being seen as potential domestic enemies in
the European Union process, which has swelled extremist nationalist
feelings.

He also added that he is opposed to attempts to cut dialogue between
the Turkish and Armenian people.

Regarding the developments following Dink’s murder, he said that the
members of the public, both Turkish or Armenian, expect to see the
perpetrators of the killing and those who incited the murder behind
bars.

"We are deeply concerned about the confrontation between different
sectors of society after the killing," said the patriarch.

"The slogans at the funeral saying ‘We’re all Hrant, we’re all
Armenians,’ should not be linked to the Armenian community," he said,
but added that he views criticism of the slogans as unhelpful, given
that these were a manifestation of sentiments after the killing, not
attempts to spark a clash regarding ethnic identities.

He declined to comment on the investigation process, but reiterated
his wish to learn who or which circles incited the murder. Mesrob
also called on state authorities to take necessary measures to put an
end to unwanted social developments greatly upsetting the community.

Dink’s autopsy completed

In related news, the murdered journalist’s autopsy report had been
completed and sent to the Sisli Public Prosecutor’s Office.

The reports said that Dink was shot twice in the head at short range
by one person.

It was also reported yesterday that Yasin Hayal, the alleged second
man behind the Dink murder who provided the murder weapon and money
to gunman Ogun Samast, claimed he learned that Erhan Tuncel, the
third man alleged to have engineered the attack, was a police
informant, from the press.

Hayal, commenting on reports of Tuncel being an informant, during his
testimony given at an F-type prison in the western city of Tekirdag,
said, "If I knew that, I would have killed him."

Ex-convict Hayal on Wednesday claimed that Tuncel gave him the bomb
for a McDonald’s attack in Trabzon in 2004.

The prison administration also said that Hayal regularly follows
newspaper reports and that he has reclaimed a Koran seized by police
when he was detained.

Another suspect, Tuncay Uzundal, also a housemate of Tuncel, was
quoted as saying in his testimony that he has doubts as to whether
Tuncel incited the murder.

ANKARA: Gul gives a lecture in history

Sabah, Turkey
Feb 9 2007

Gül gives a lecture in history
There was an Armenian minister

Minister Gül spoke about the Armenian bill in the USA: "the Ottoman
Empire had an Armenian minister during the years of genocide."

Minister of Foreign Affairs Gül told the chairman of the US Congress
Defense Sub Committee Hoyer: "the Ottoman Empire had an Armenian
foreign affairs minister and an Armenian ambassador of London in the
years during the so-called genocide."

Gül gives a lecture in history

Minister of Foreign Affairs Gül met with the top level authorities of
the US congress. Gül met with 15 congress members and around 40
politicians and made a striking request: "Talk to me about the claim
of an Armenian genocide, for which you have signed on in three
sentences. Tell me when did it happen?" Gül was not replied to and he
then asked: "then why did you sign this?"

Minister of Foreign Affairs Gül met with the top level authorities of
the US congress. Gül met with 15 congress members and around 40
politicians, including those signing the Armenian bill, at lunch. Gül
gave some critical messages in his speech at the lunch attended by
both Republicans and Democrats. Addressing those who are signing the
bill, Gül made a striking request: "tell me about the claims
regarding the Armenian genocide for which you have signed in three
sentences. Tell me when did it happen?" Gül was not replied to and he
then asked: "then why did you sign this?"