Jane’s: Turkish Military Seeks Armenia Detente

TURKISH MILITARY SEEKS ARMENIA DETENTE

Jane’s International Security, UK
Feb 12 2007

The assassination of a prominent Turkish-Armenian journalist, Hrant
Dink, on 19 January 2007 in Istanbul renewed attention on Turkey’s
troubled relations with its small neighbour, Armenia.

The record of Turkish-Armenian relations has been blighted by both
Ankara’s refusal to extend normal diplomatic relations to Yerevan
and a trade embargo and transport blockade, imposed on Armenia in
1993 in support of Azerbaijan in the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict.

A group of Western-trained young officers brought into senior posts
within the Turkish military’s General Staff authored a preliminary,
semi-official internal study in late 2006 that presented several
new strategic initiatives, including a reconsideration of Turkey’s
long-standing hesitance toward addressing the stalemate with Armenia.

Such recognition has to date been limited to a rather narrow circle
of Turkish elite, defined by a generally progressive, pro-Western
orientation. In the wake of Dink’s murder, however, there has been
a surprising public outpouring of sympathy for Armenians that has,
at least temporarily, bridged the historic enmity between the two
neighbours. This has also triggered a political shift, with public
opinion presently driving and defending a reassessment of Turkey’s
policies regarding Armenia.

For the Turkish government, the Armenian issue offers a new sense of
political advantage, whereby any improvement in its relations with
Armenia can offer a welcome respite to the recent round of vocal
European opposition to Turkish EU membership aspirations.

It is, however, the economic consideration of a possible
Turkish-Armenian rapprochement that is key for decision makers in
Ankara. In fact, less than a week before Dink’s killing, a conference
was held in Yerevan to examine the economic and social implications of
the possible reopening of the Turkish-Armenian border. The conference
brought together leading economists from the US and Europe, as well
as academics and business leaders from Armenia and Turkey.

al_security/news/jiaa/jiaa070212_1_n.shtml

http://www.janes.com/security/internation

Armenia Ranks 8th In Rating Of Former USSR Countries’ Economic Statu

ARMENIA RANKS 8TH IN RATING OF FORMER USSR COUNTRIES’ ECONOMIC STATUS

Arka News Agency, Armenia
Feb 12 2007

YEREVAN. February 12. /ARKA/. Armenia ranks 8th in the rating
of former USSR countries’ economic status. The research of the
Russian Renaissance Capital Company titled "Former USSR Countries:
Profitability of Changes".

The research demonstrates the rating of indicators of political and
economic reforms, carried out in former USSR countries over the last
15 years.

According to the rating, Armenia ranks 3rd after Turkmenistan and
Azerbaijan for the indicator of economic growth in 2000-2006. At the
same time, Armenia shifted to the 10th position for the GDP indicator
based on the parity of purchasing capacity of Armenia. Baltic countries
occupy 1-3 positions.

Armenia ranks 4th for the inflation rate after Lithuania, Estonia,
and Kyrgyzstan. After Azerbaijan and Estonia, Armenia has the
third indicator of investment rate, based on the ratio of foreign
investments and GDP Armenia. The country ranks 13th for unemployment
rate. Azerbaijan, Belarus, and Russia lead the rating.

Armenia occupies the 11th position for the poverty rate. The lowest
indicator of poverty is in Estonia, Kazakhstan, and Belarus.

At the same time, inequality rate is the highest in Armenia.

The lowest inequality rate is observed in Uzbekistan, Belarus,
and Latvia.

The report authors point out that the economic welfare of Russia,
Kazakhstan, and Azerbaijan is connected with plenty of oil and gas
resources, that of Belarus – with low prices for these resources.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Armenian Parliament Rejects Government Formation Bill In First Readi

ARMENIAN PARLIAMENT REJECTS GOVERNMENT FORMATION BILL IN FIRST READING

Arka News Agency, Armenia
Feb 12 2007

YEREVAN, February 12. /ARKA/. The Armenian parliament rejected
the bill on the formation of the Armenian Government in the first
reading. Fifty Parliament members voted for the bill, with three
abstentions, the necessary quorum being 66 parliament members.

Before the voting, Speaker Tigran Torosyan reported that the Government
renamed the bill "On formation and resignation of Government"
"Government formation standards". One point, according to which,
"the Government is considered to be formed if all the Government
members have been appointed" has been incorporated into the new bill.

However, the parliamentarians did not approve the new version and
demanded a new discussion because the new bill is seriously different
from its predecessor and does not set any mechanisms of forming the
executive power.

As a result, the parliamentary faction of the United Worker’s Party,
as well as the "Justice" and "National Unity" factions did not
participate in the voting.

Commenting on the situation, Speaker Torosyan said that the Government
will have to convene a special parliamentary session to re-submit the
bill to Parliament. Since the parliamentary elections are scheduled
for May 12, and a new Government is to be formed too little time is
left for the adoption of the bill. According to the initial wording,
if the Government resigns, a new cabinet must be formed by the RA
President within 20 days after the appointment of the RA Premier. The
bill also allowed a person with dual citizenship to be appointed a
Government member.

The current Law "On formation and resignation of Government" was
adopted in 1998. Constitutional reforms necessitated the adoption of
a new one.

ANKARA: Cutting The Gordions Knot – Are The Questions Since 1915 Goi

CUTTING THE GORDIONS KNOT – ARE THE QUESTIONS SINCE 1915 GOING TO BE ANSWERED?
By Irem Guney, JTW

Journal of Turkish Weekly, Turkey
Feb 12 2007

The assassination of the Turkish-Armenian journalist Hrant Dink has
stimulated the debates about the minority rights in Turkey as well
as the questions about facing the history regarding the year 1915.

The recent news about the mass grave in Nusaybin, a town in the
southeast region of Turkey, deepened the discussions not only between
Armenians and Turks but also between the international community
whose majority asks for the recognition of the "genocide" and the
Turkish people who mostly perceive the happenings as a tragedy for
both nations during the First World War and refer to the incidences
as the displacement of Armenians.

The genocide researcher Prof. David Gaunt from Sodertorns University
argued that these graves in Nusaybin town belong to Armenians and
Suryanis and took up the topic to the Swedish Parlament. Following
this, Prof. Yusuf Halacoðlu, the head of the Turkish Historical Society
addressed to Mr. Gaunt and other academics who are researching in this
field, in that he suggested cooperated field work on the graveyards and
to open up them together. Mr. Gaunt responded to this affirmatively
whereas his conditions such as absolute freedom in his work, the
allowance to interview those who have a knowledge about the graves,
and the entrance to other mass graves around Mardin were also accepted
by the Turkish Historical Society that is also willing to cover the
expenses and needs of the researchers who will start their work in
March. This project is going to be the first of his kind regarding
the international cooperation, says Mr. Halacoðlu.

Prof. Yusuf Halacoðlu also commented on the assassination of the
Armenian Journalist Hrant Dink and referred to it as an important
loss for Turkish society. Currently, the Turkish Historical Society
expects the final reply from Mr. Gaunt and his colleagues who, in
Halacoðlu’s view, should apologise if the outcomes would show that
the graves belong to neither Armenians nor Suryanis but Turkish
people. Halacoðlu finally stated that they would apologise if the
researches support the hypothesis of Prof. Gaunt.

The importance of this cooperation does not only lie in its
international character but also in its possible outcomes. The lack
of a mass grave is one of the mostly claimed points of the Turkish
side against the Armenian arguments. In this view, there must be a
mass grave for Armenians in the Eastern Turkey or in former Ottoman
Syria’s territories who were displaced in 1915 if one is talking about
genocide. In Turkish point of view, the hypothesis that most of the
Armenians were killed on their way is also not very plausible since
nevertheless there would have been a mass grave for so many people.

In the last 20 years, there had been some field work on the graveyards
led by the Turkish Historical Society and some universities like
Erzurum Ataturk University. However, in these projects there was no
Armenian researchers who refused the appeal of the Turkish Historical
Society regarding the cooperation.

Another crucial point in the research for the possible Armenian graves
is with respect to the route of the displacement. The significant
amount of Armenians who were directed to Syria-a province of the
Ottoman Empire at that time- should, in Turkish point of view, indicate
to the possibility of mass graves in Syria if there had been the
genocide against Armenian people. Yet despite its possibility there
has not been any opening up works in this region which, in Turkish
perspective, strengthens the position that Armenians want to reach
conclusions that are based on subjectivity.

The expected cooperation in Mardin would probably reveal important
results for both of the parties. On the other hand, one should not
expect a quick resolution after the research on the mass grave. As the
experience until today has demonstrated, no matter what the current
debates are, there is one certain point in the whole debate about
what happened in 1915. That it will continue for a long time.

–Boundary_(ID_QMK0CmwVxnds7euEWaUuNA)–

ANKARA: Turkey’s Top General In The US

TURKEY’S TOP GENERAL IN THE US

NTV MSNBC, Turkey
Feb 12 2007

Buyukanit is expected to warn US officials that passing the resolution
on the so-called Armenian genocide would harm military ties between
Ankara and Washington.

Guncelleme: 14:48 TSÝ 12 Þubat 2007 Pazartesi- Turkey’s senior armed
forces commander is going to caution US officials that Turkish-US
military ties will be harmed if the US Congress adopts a resolution
formally acknowledging the alleged massacre of Armenians by the
Ottoman Empire.

The visit of General Yasar Buyukanit, the Chief of the Turkish General
Staff Chief to Washington comes only days after Foreign Minister
Abdullah Gul was in the US capital to push for the resolution before
Congress to be dropped.

During his visit, General Buyukanit is scheduled to meet US Vice
President Dick Cheney, Joint Chiefs of Staff Chairman General Peter
Pace, Under Secretary of Defence for Policy Eric Edelman, and US Army
Chief of Staff General Peter Schoomaker.

Apart from the Armenian issue and military relations between Turkey
and the US, Buyukanit will also be discussing issues such as Iraq,
the fight against terrorism, and recent developments in the Middle
East in his meetings with US officials.

–Boundary_(ID_m6Gft8Zys+8AYJZH5YtoEA) —

BAKU: Bahar Muradova: "The Cooperation With Armenia Is Unrealizable"

BAHAR MURADOVA: "THE COOPERATION WITH ARMENIA IS UNREALIZABLE"

Ïðaâî Âûaîða, Azerbaijan
Democratic Azerbaijan
Feb 12 2007

Lord Russell Johnston, a chairman of the Sub-Committee for the
Nagorno-Karabakh conflict of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council
of Europe (PACE) appraised positively the meeting with Azerbaijan and
Armenian delegation. He expressed his desire to hold such meetings
at the level of different structures of both countries.

Deputy MM Chairman and head of Azerbaijan delegation to the PA OSCE
Bahar Muradova informed that if they fail to reach a settlement
concerning the conflict, any cooperation between Azerbaijan and
Armenia will be impossible: "Azerbaijan repeatedly stated about its
position in this issue. Today a specific part of Azerbaijan’s lands
are occupied by Armenia. Armenian’s occupation policy resulted in
deprivation of over million of our citizens of their native homes and
properties. In this case, it is useless to speak of any cooperation
between Azerbaijan and Armenia."

In addition, B. Muradova thinks that any arrangements hosted
by international organizations are not harmful for our State:
"Azerbaijan is represented in powerful states worldwide. Such meetings
are also organized by their structures and we should attend their
arrangements. For instance, LINKS, a UK organization carries out a
joint project, which covers MPs of three Caucasus countries.

Thus, whether we want it or not, we have to maintain contact with
Armenians in the Parliamentary Assembly of OSCE."

According to vice-speaker, if any meeting can influence on the conflict
settlement, Azerbaijan is interested to attend them.

B. Muradova also touched upon the issue concerning the putting the
report of the PA OSCE Chairman and Rapporteur Goran Lenmarker on the
agenda: "As you know, Armenia always tries to distract international
organizations’ attention from the discussion of such issues. This
time they abide by their own principles. One of the reasons that
the report was not put to the agenda is due to both party’s attitude
towards the document. Azerbaijan as well as Armenia has also their
own position to this point. To date these positions did not change
at all. The OSCE leadership that was witness of such situation is
likely not to discuss the report yet."

–Boundary_(ID_rXWpkYB7Bv0Pho/wvnI/2g) —

TBILISI: Georgian Secondary School To Close In The Village Of Sameba

GEORGIAN SECONDARY SCHOOL TO CLOSE IN THE VILLAGE OF SAMEBA

The Messenger, Georgia
Feb 12 2007

According to the newspaper Akhali Taoba, a Georgian secondary
school located in the village of Sameba, in Ninotsminda district of
Samtskhe-Javakheti, is on the verge of closing. Several days ago the
school’s head teacher was dismissed from his post due to conflicts
with the rest of the staff.

The school’s teachers state that they have not received the salary for
last six months, but nevertheless are not going to cancel lessons. They
add that they are afraid the school may be forced to close, leaving
them without jobs. A lack of heating in the school means they are
obliged to conduct lessons in the freezing rooms.

According to the director of Ninotsminda Educational Resource Centre,
Marina Zalalian, they were not able to provide Sameba school with
wood because of lack of finances. She says only a very small number
of children are studying in that school, and it may merge with an
Armenian school located in the neighbouring village. Sameba residents
object to this strongly.

Sameba is located on the Georgian-Armenian border, in winter it is
virtually cut off from other local towns.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Adviser To RA President: Armenia Will Not Surrender To Intimidation

ADVISER TO RA PRESIDENT: ARMENIA WILL NOT SURRENDER TO INTIMIDATION IN ISSUE OF KARABAKH CONFLICT SETTLEMENT

DeFacto Agency, Armenia
Feb 12 2007

Preconditions to Yerevan to normalize its relations with Turkey and
Azerbaijan are unacceptable for Armenia, Adviser to the RA President
on National Security Garnik Isagulian stated at a press conference
held in Yerevan.

In his words, Armenia will not surrender to any intimidation in the
issue of the Nagorno- Karabakh conflict settlement. As to fact that
Armenia does not participate in the Kars-Akhalkalaki-Baku railway
project, Isagulian does not believe the above-mentioned stance
will significantly harm the country’s economy in such extent that
Azerbaijan and Turkey account for. "Armenia is a bit concerned by
Georgia, but its stand in the construction of Kars-Akhalkalaki-Baku
railway is the Georgian authorities’ inner business," Isagulian noted.

At the same time the RA President’s Adviser reminded such concerns
used to arouse during construction of Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan oil pipeline
as well. "But as you all see, little has changed after launching the
pipeline. In any case, the situation in the region remains an object
of our rapt attention," Isagulian underscored, PanARMENIAN.Net reports.

Denial Of Current Misleading Information Disseminated By Azeri Mass

DENIAL OF CURRENT MISLEADING INFORMATION DISSEMINATED BY AZERI MASS MEDIA

DeFacto Agency, Armenia
Feb 12 2007

The Nagorno-Karabakh MOD officials have categorically denied the
information disseminated by the Azeri mass media concerning the fact
that the day before the Karabakh party allegedly violated cease-fire
and concentrated military equipment on the sector of the contact line
in the Jebrail region.

"The information pursues purely propaganda goals and does not
correspond to reality", the NKR MOD Spokesman Sub Colonel Senor
Asratian told Novosti-Armenia Agency on Monday.

Turkey’s Foreign Minister Backs Amendment To Law Curbing Free Speech

TURKEY’S FOREIGN MINISTER BACKS AMENDMENT TO LAW CURBING FREE SPEECH

The Associated Press
International Herald Tribune, France
Feb 12 2007

ANKARA, Turkey: Foreign Minister Abdullah Gul on Monday backed the
amendment of Turkey’s controversial article 301, used to prosecute
intellectuals including Nobel Prize-winning novelist Orhan Pamuk and
an ethnic Armenian journalist who was later shot dead.

"I want this article amended because it puts a shadow on Turkey’s
reform process," Gul said at a joint news conference with visiting
Australian Foreign Minister Alexander Downer.

"It is damaging Turkey’s image. It is portraying Turkey as a country
where hundreds of journalists and intellectuals are jailed for their
speeches. This is wrong."

Gul’s remarks came days after a group of trade unions and other
non-governmental organizations proposed a new wording to the article,
which makes insults to the Turkish state or its people a crime. The
groups said the new wording would set clearer limits to what
constitutes insult and what is legitimate criticism.

Some non-governmental organizations were demanding scrapping the law
completely, but Gul made clear the government favored amending it.

"We want everyone to freely express their thoughts as long they
don’t incite violence or amount to insult," Gul said. "These cannot
be allowed. They are not allowed anywhere else."

Nobel Prize-winning novelist Orhan Pamuk and murdered journalist
Hrant Dink were both prosecuted under the broad law criminalizing
the denigration of "Turkishness." Both had spoken out about the
mass killings of Armenians in the early 20th century. Numerous other
writers, journalists and academics have also been prosecuted.

Dink, the editor of the minority Agos newspaper, was shot dead outside
his Istanbul office on Jan. 19 and his murder revived a debate about
the law. Many said his prosecution under article 301 had made him a
target for ultranationalist groups.

The proposal by trade unions and non-governmental organizations would
replace the crime of "insulting Turkishness" with wording that would
translate as "openly abasing and deriding" Turkishness.

Newspapers, however, have criticized the proposed amendment, saying
it would not stop prosecutions because the interpretation of the law
is often left to prosecutors, most of whom are nationalists.