BAKU: Turkey Is Always Ready To Conclude Security Agreement With Aze

TURKEY IS ALWAYS READY TO CONCLUDE SECURITY AGREEMENT WITH AZERBAIJAN

Today, Azerbaijan
Feb 26 2007

"The United Nations and the world countries should feel ashamed
for the Khojaly genocide. The world does ignore the occupation of
Azerbaijan’s lands, its one million refugees and Khojaly genocide."

"I condemn the occupation of our lands and those who do not want to see
it," former secretary-general of Turkey’s National Security Council,
resigned Army General Tuncer Kilinc stated, according to APA.

He said it is impossible to open the borders with Armenia, which does
not recognize Turkey’s territorial integrity showing Agri Mountain
in the 13th article of the Constitution as its territory.

"First of all, they should admit Khojaly genocide, leave the occupied
territories," he said.

As to the question whether the Karabakh problem is in the Turkish
national security conception, the Army General said in its policy,
Ankara has always attached great attention to this problem.

"Be sure that Turkey will always defend its brothers’ rights.

National security’s documents confirm this. Turkish foreign policy
attaches great importance to the Karabakh problem," he said.

Commenting on the importance of conclusion of an agreement on security
between Turkey and Azerbaijan, Mr. Kilinc said that this document
can be signed at any time.

"We always support our brothers. Turkish government will never ignore
Azerbaijan’s request," he said.

URL:

http://www.today.az/news/politics/37038.html

UCLA: Journalist Gets A Fond, Emotional Memorial

JOURNALIST GETS A FOND, EMOTIONAL MEMORIAL

The UCLA Daily Bruin, CA
Feb 26 2007

Tears flowed from the eyes of both Turkish and Armenian audience
members at a crowded commemoration held at UCLA Sunday afternoon to
remember the death of journalist Hrant Dink.

Dink, the editor in chief of Turkish-Armenian newspaper Agos, was
murdered in front of his office on Jan. 19 by teenager Ogun Samsast.

Samsast’s motives for the murder remain unclear, but according to
Hurriyet, a daily Turkish newspaper, Samsast was ordered to kill Dink
by militant nationalist Yasin Hayal.

In the last two years of Dink’s life, he received numerous death
threats for speaking about the Armenian genocide. The Turkish
government denies the deaths constitute genocide because it maintains
they resulted from the effects of World War I and not an extermination
of the Armenians.

Dink was convicted for denigrating the Turkish government under article
301 of the Turkish Penal Code. The article allows journalists to be
prosecuted for any perceived criticism of the Turkish government,
according to the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe.

Many speakers at the event shared fond memories of Dink. One speaker
was Zeynep Turkyilmaz, a UCLA doctoral student in history and a
member of the informal student group Initiative of Turkish Students
to Commemorate "Our Hrant."

Turkyilmaz said she met Dink 11 years ago in Turkey. She said as a
Turkish undergraduate student doing a project on Armenian literature,
she was met by opposition in the course of her research, but Dink
encouraged the Armenian-Turkish relationship and supported the project.

"He was very excited … and he sent a reporter from Agos to cover
(the presentation on Armenian literature). I was in one of the first
issues (of the newspaper)," recalled Turkyilmaz.

Turkyilmaz urged the audience to remember the challenges Dink went
through in his lifetime and to help Dink’s newspaper Agos endure.

"My last memories of Hrant Dink is at Agos. Agos is his legacy. Its
survival is now on our shoulders," Turkyilmaz said.

Speaker Ayse Gul Altinay, a friend of Dink’s, spoke on her feelings
about his death.

"I still find myself waking up (and hoping) it is a terrible dream,"
Altinay said.

Altinay, a professor from Sabanci University in Istanbul, Turkey,
last met Dink for dinner, where Dink mentioned the threats he had
been receiving but said he was only worried about the threats to his
family, she said.

This concern for other people and disregard for himself made him
popular, Altinay said.

"It is amazing how many friends Hrant had. He touched many lives,"
she said.

Altinay also discussed the effect of article 301 and the prosecution
of Dink.

"This decision was used as a mechanism to silence Hrant, and yet we
all know Hrant was not silenced," Altinay said.

David Myers, director of the UCLA Center for Jewish Studies, did not
know Dink but said he could relate to and admired the late journalist.

"(Dink) sought to wage the battle for his people and his culture –
a battle in the name of dialogue and understanding. It is a struggle
that many of us are familiar with," said Myers.

Myers also applauded Dink for acknowledging the Armenian genocide
in 1915.

"I think of him less as a victim and more as a inspiration, a role
model, a teacher," Myers said.

Other speakers included Richard Hovannisian, chairman of modern
Armenian history and host of the event, and Ruben Centinyan, a UCLA
alumnus who spoke about Dink’s beliefs about the government.

The event also had Armenian music: A duduk, a traditional woodwind
instrument, was played.

"Let us cry together, mourn together, so that we can soon laugh
together, love together," Altinay said.

b/26/journalist_gets_fond_emotional_memorial/

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

http://www.dailybruin.ucla.edu/news/2007/fe

ANKARA: Gul: Turkey To Reform Further Despite Negative EU ‘Climate’

GUL: TURKEY TO REFORM FURTHER DESPITE NEGATIVE EU ‘CLIMATE’

The New Anatolian, Turkey
Feb 26 2007

Foreign Minister Abdullah Gul said on Saturday that the EU has
some problems and those problems should not be seen as permanent,
stating that commitment of Turkey to the full membership process is
not just rhetorical.

Gul, in an interview with "Euobserver.com," stated that Ankara will
continue reforms even if the "climate" in the EU towards Ankara’s
membership bid is currently not optimal.

"We made an assessment: The EU has some problems and these are not
permanent. There will be a better climate, and by that time, we will
already be in a different situation. We will use this time and make
progress. Our commitment to the full process is not just rhetorical,"
Gul said.

Underlining that Ankara will nevertheless continue to work to meet EU
standards, Gul said, "Negotiations are still going on, even if some
chapters have been frozen. The German presidency has asked for our
negotiating position on three other chapters without any benchmarks:
economy and market policy, statistics and financial control. We have
not slowed down our speed."

Gul also stated that EU shuold not underestimate the strategic clout
Turkey could offer to the bloc in the Middle East and Central Asia
in terms of security and energy supplies.

"The question is this: is the EU paying enough attention to its
future? Who is planning where the EU will be 30, 50 years from now?

Is the EU going to play an important role in world affairs? Is the EU
going to have a say in security issues or energy transport?" Gul said.

Last December 2006, EU leaders decided to temporarily suspend eight of
Turkey’s 35 accession negotiation chapters due to Ankara’s decision
not to open up its ports to trade from Greek Cyprus – seen by Gul as
an attempt by some EU member countries to "slow down" the speed of
accession negotiations with Ankara.

Meanwhile, Gul criticized French deputies as well as American
politicians who want to pass a bill condemning the Armenian genocide
in the US Congress.

Defining the events in 1915 as tragedy, Gul said, "Our offer is this:
if you are really so interested in this issue, why don’t we have a
committee composed of historians, we asked them – we open our archives
and let them study. But the Armenians are not forthcoming.

The same offer is valid for the American congressmen and the French."

Moscow Chamber Orchestra Leaves Audience Ecstatic

MOSCOW CHAMBER ORCHESTRA LEAVES AUDIENCE ECSTATIC
By Laura Stewart

Daytona Beach News-Journal, FL
Feb 26 2007

DAYTONA BEACH — Constantine Orbellian and the Moscow Chamber Orchestra
did many things at Sunday’s Central Florida Cultural Endeavors concert,
but by their third encore one stood out: They made virtuosity fun.

When Orbellian led Alexander Mayorov, the Russian ensemble’s
concertmaster, in a spectacular riff on "Yankee Doodle Dandy," he
rewarded the audience that had jumped to its feet in appreciation
several times already. During the News-Journal Center performance,
as the 17 string players from Moscow moved nimbly from one work
to another, it was easy to understand the audience’s enthusiasm;
conveying its causes is trickier.

>>From beginning to end, the concert performance was absolutely
masterful, and unusually invigorating. It wasn’t just the musicians —
especially Mayorov and the three cellists, led by principal Alexander
Zagorinsky. Neither was it simply Orbellian’s way of communicating
with the musicians, who responded to his every eloquent gesture,
nor was it the subtle pulse established in a program that alternated
between relatively gentle and absolutely, rivetingly dramatic.

It was all of those, along with a surprising dash of humor and the
artists’ sheer, entertaining enjoyment of their music. The program
opened with Edvard Grieg’s elegiac neo-classical "From Holberg’s Time,
Suite for String Orchestra, Op. 40," then moved into the impassioned
"Three Armenian Dances," written before the 1915 genocide by Komitas,
to preserve Armenia’s folk music. The mood shifted back to classical
after the gleaming grand piano arrived onstage, and Alexander Kobrin
matched his brilliant style to the polished perfection of the Moscow
musicians in Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart’s Piano Concerto No. 14 in E flat.

Stately, always elegantly cogent, even majestic at times, the Mozart
Concerto outdid all of the performances dedicated to the composer last
year, the 250th anniversary of his birth. Yet, when Vladislav Lavrik
and his trumpet joined Kobrin and the orchestra after intermission,
the Mozart seemed languid. Dmitri Shostakovich’s 1933 Concerto No. 1
in C minor for Piano, and Trumpet, Op. 35 was the evening’s highlight,
a dazzling display of everything from sonic abstraction to sudden,
vivid nods to pop culture, from cerebral phrases to jazzy, witty
musical references.

Almost incomprehensibly complex and demanding, the concerto brought
the orchestra to new heights but put the spotlight directly on Kobrin,
Lavrik and their witty, wonderful dialogue. The final notes had barely
faded before the audience seemed to rise as one, cheering.

It would seem that the Moscow musicians couldn’t top the Shostakovich;
they didn’t even try. They merely shifted gears again and gave an
atmospheric, memorable performance of Antonio Vivaldi’s Concerto
Grosso in D minor for Two Violins, Cello and Orchestra. As rich as the
rest of the stellar performance, the Vivaldi rounded out Orbellian’s
fine balance of loud and soft, vivid and reflective that balanced
the program.

Until he introduced his "first encore," the sweet Russian lament that
led to the next encore, a sizzling tarantella that swaggered. Any one
of the evening’s works would have been enough; the encores were icing
on a luscious layer cake. But then Orbellian, in a last, virtuosic
burst that underlined the fun, played up his own expressive style in
the hot, happy, utterly exquisite "Yankee Doodle Dandy," and brought
the house down.

BAKU: "Kosovo Model Not Suitable For Solving Nagorni Garabagh Proble

"KOSOVO MODEL NOT SUITABLE FOR SOLVING NAGORNI GARABAGH PROBLEM"

Ïðaâî Âûaîða, Azerbaijan
Democratic Azerbaijan
Feb 26 2007

President, Ilham Aliyev, stated so during interview for German TV radio
channel "Deutsche Welle" In the course of recent official visit to
Federal Republic of Germany, President of the Republic of Azerbaijan,
Ilham Aliyev, gave interview for respectable TV and radio channel of
the country "Deutsche Welle" in Berlin.

Answering question concerning OSCE Minsk Group co-chairs’ support of
"Kosovo model" application for regulation Nagorni Garabgh conflict,
I. Aliyev stressed that this model can not be acceptable for our
state. "Every conflict has its history and ways of regulation. Today
there are different conflicts in the world, the part of which
was broken out by separatist regimes. For example, we know that
separatists do exist in Abkhazia, South Osetia, Nagorni Garabagh
and the Trans-Dniester Region. There is no international control,
monitoring or international participation on these territories. For
this very reason illegal drug trafficking, money-laundering, harboring
of terrorists occur there. Unlike mentioned regions international
control is established in Kosovo with international peacemaking
forces. We can’t say that Kosovo like other separatist regimes in
Nagorni Garabagh and post-soviet area is sore of Europe.

At the same time while regulating such conflicts territorial integrity
should be accepted as the basic principle. If this principle is
violated chain reaction will be inevitable", President stressed.

At the same time head of state underlined that Azerbaijan will never
consent to grant independence to Nagorni Garabagh. Accordingly to
him it is impossible to allow national minorities living on the
territory of any country to create their own state at the cost of
its territories.

I. Aliyev reminded that currently Azerbaijan’s economy surpasses
Armenian’s by factor of 7, thus it will be more reasonable if opponent
party, taking courage, will withdraw occupation forces from Nagorni
Garabagh. At the same time President emphasized that Azerbaijan is
ready to present very constructive way out. He proposed to grant
maximal autonomy within the frames of territorial integrity of
Azerbaijan to Armenians living in occupied Azerbaijani territories,
providing security for all people living there.

Moreover, President focused on the issue of return of all people
displaced from native territories.

Asked if Azerbaijan is taking interests in being NATO member, I.

Aliyev informed that our country has been cooperating with NATO for
many years. "We are participating in different programs of this
structure and we hope that our partnership and cooperation will
go on. However participation of any international organization in
this structure should be mutually agreed. Both NATO and Azerbaijan
understand that our country is not ready for it today. That is why
we should continue mutual activity as partners and time will show
results of this partnership and cooperation", – I. Aliyev said.

–Boundary_(ID_mPeYOA+amqSB52WOlopQaA)–

A Turkish Novelist Acquits Herself Nicely

A TURKISH NOVELIST ACQUITS HERSELF NICELY
By John Freeman

Newsday, NY
Feb 26 2007

Salman Rushdie once noted that societies that emerged from colonial
rule in the ’50s, ’60s and ’70s became hotbeds for literary invention.

"The Empire Writes Back," he called the phenomenon, punning on George
Lucas’ "Star Wars" film.

That phrase is gaining new currency in Turkey, where, according to
35-year-old writer Elif Shafak, a young generation of Turks is using
the novel, a form that came to them from the West, to reimagine their
society from within.

"Novelists have played a very, very critical role as the engineers of
social and cultural transformation in Turkey," Shafak says, sitting
in an empty hotel ballroom in New York City. "Maybe in that regard
we are closer to the Russian tradition than the Western tradition."

The debate over what these novels say about Turkish society, and
how they say it, lurched to the forefront of life in Istanbul in
recent years, as the Turkish government began prosecuting writers for
"offending Turkishness."

Nobel laureate Orhan Pamuk and several dozen other writers were
tried under this code of Turkish law. In September, Shafak, too,
was put on trial because of passages from her new novel, "The Bastard

of Istanbul" (Viking, $24.95), which referenced the long fallout of
what many call the Armenian Genocide, when up to 1 million Armenians
were forcibly removed from Turkey and killed.

The book has become a bestseller in Turkey, selling more than 60,000
copies, but not without repercussions for Shafak. Writing in The
Washington Post, Shafak explained how critics within Turkey claimed
she "had taken the Armenians’ side by having an Armenian character
call the Turks ‘butchers’ in a reference to the Ottoman Empire’s
deportation and massacre of Armenians during World War I."

Although Shafak was acquitted, others have not been so lucky. On Jan.

19, her "dear friend," journalist Hrant Dink, the Armenian
editor-in-chief of a Turkish newspaper, was murdered on a street
in Istanbul, allegedly by an ultra-nationalist teenager. The
reverberations of this event are still etched on Shafak’s face.

"The debate on literature and art is very much politicized," she
says, her voice revealing palpable anguish, "sometimes very much
polarized. I think my work attracted it because I combined elements
people like to see separate."

Shafak is referring to sex and religion, faith and skepticism, and
all these elements come together in "The Bastard of Istanbul." The
novel tells the story of two families – one Turkish Muslim, the other
Armenian – who discover they are united by a shared secret.

Set mostly in Istanbul, it is a lively book, populated by powerful,
talkative women who are full of superstitions, folk tales and vengeful
schemes.

"Turkey is incomparable with any other Muslim country with regard to
the freedoms women exercise," Shafak says. "But we have a tradition
of state feminism. To this day, when we talk about women’s rights, we
say Ataturk gave us our rights," she says, referring to the republic
of Turkey’s first president. "And that tells us a lot. What we need
is an independent women’s movement."

In some people’s eyes, Shafak is a walking contradiction: a radical
feminist Muslim Turk who writes about sex and slang; a leftist on
some issues who believes in the power of religion. Every point of
her identity is politicized, even the types of words she uses.

"Turkish as we speak today is very centralized. We took out words
coming from Arabic origin, Persian origin and Sufi heritage. And I
think in doing so we lost the nuances of the language."

Born in France, Shafak spent her childhood shuttling between Germany,
Jordan and Spain, with stops in between in Turkey. She earned a
graduate degree in international relations and titled her PhD thesis
"An Analysis of Turkish Modernity Through Discourses in Masculinities."

Since 2003, she has lived in Turkey and traveled to the United States
to teach. She calls herself a commuter, not an immigrant. "There is
a metaphor I like very much in the Quran, in the Holy Book, and it’s
about a tree that has its roots up in the air. When my nationalist
critics say you have no roots, you are a so-called Turk, I say no,
I do have roots, they’re just not rooted in the ground. They are up
in the air."

In popular conception, Istanbul is the great meeting bazaar
between East and West, but Shafak says the city remains somewhat
uncomfortable with that role. "One thing that worries me is that
there is no … mobility between classes. There’s not that kind of
geographical mobility – east and west, north and south – that you
have in the States."

And yet, Istanbul remains a source of endless inspiration for Shafak,
and it also remains her home. "For anyone," she says, "especially
after 9/11, who is asking herself how western democracy and Islam
can co-exist side by side, how seemingly opposite forces can be
juxtaposed, for anyone asking these sorts of questions, Istanbul is
a very important case study."

As for how she is going to manage, given the controversy and the real
security issues, she’s up for the challenge.

"My relationship with the city has been like a pendulum. I am deeply
attracted to it, but sometimes suffocated by it.

"So I need to take a step outside of it and then come back."

ANKARA: Mr. Kocharian Talks Nonsense Again

MR. KOCHARIAN TALKS NONSENSE AGAIN

Hurriyet (Liberal)
Turkish Press
Feb 26 2007

Armenian President Robert Kocharian does not realize what he is
saying. Kocharian spoke nonsense in Paris while rendering thanks to
Armenian lobby.

"As in 1915, we have the same neighbor who does not admit the crime
it committed. There is a risk of repetition," he said.

ANKARA: Historian Halacoglu: Let’s Excavate Disputed Site Together

HISTORIAN HALACOGLU: LET’S EXCAVATE DISPUTED SITE TOGETHER

New Anatolian, Turkey
Feb 26 2007

Yusuf Halacoglu, head of the Turkish Historical Society (TTK), is
urging a leading Armenian historian to officially declare his intent
to work alongside Turkish historians at an alleged mass grave site
near Harput.

Speaking to the Anatolia news agency, Halacoglu said that Armenian
historian Ara Sarafian claimed Leslie Davis, who was on the Harput
Council in 1915, said 12,000 Armenian were killed and thrown into a
valley near Lake Hazar.

"Upon his allegations I told Sarafian we should open this so-called
mass grave together," said Halacoglu. "The allegations are so
groundless that it wasn’t possible to find a grave to put 12,000
people in those days. Moreover, it was impossible to cover up 12,000
people by working with shovels."

Halacoglu said that when the Armenian historian went there to do
research he didn’t find anything. "So I told him that he can’t claim
what he didn’t find as real by citing some reports as evidence,"
he continued. "Basing allegations on rumors of missionaries without
researching the Ottoman archives or other archives isn’t suitable for
a scholar or historian. I proposed to Sarafian that we investigate
together what had happened to the Armenians all over Anatolia in those
days, and what had happened to Muslims; in other words what happened
generally in 1915. Upon my offer I think they came with a suggestion
to work together regarding the alleged mass grave in Nusaybin."

Claiming that both Ottoman and Armenian archives should be researched
thoroughly regarding the issue, Halacoglu said that working alone
doesn’t work out.

The historian added that Sarafian didn’t write to him directly. "He
should have make contact directly with us," said Halacoglu. "Now
if he didn’t write to us officially his intention won’t be seen as
sincere. They should have sent us their offer officially. We can’t
solve a problem by just saying, ‘Let’s deal with an event in Harput.’
It may only be a beginning. The reason behind my accepting his
suggestion immediately was to show that we don’t have anything to
hide. We can work wherever they want."

Halacoglu said that they are ready to confront everything with every
kind of method. "If they want to open a grave, then let’s do it;
if the want to do research, let’s do it," he said.

Stating that the atrocities Armenian committees committed on Turks
and Muslims should also be dealt with, Halacoglu said that the
Armenian Dashnak organization’s atrocities were recorded in archives
in Yerevan and Boston. He added that opening these archives will shed
light on history.

Halacoglu also said that forming a tribunal to deal with the 1915
events is not possible. "If such a court is formed, then it should
deal with the deeds of many countries," he claimed. "What Armenians
or Russians or Greeks did to Turks should be investigated by the
tribunal as well. In other words, 5.5 million people were deported
in the Balkans, which can be called ethnic cleansing. This should
also be investigated."

Halacoglu said that some world parliaments say Turks should
confront their past. "But which Turks? Turks in the Middle East,
in the Caucasus, the Balkans? Turks today?" he asked. "How can they
accuse me of committing the worst crime of humanity before giving me
a chance to defend myself? If I make an application at the European
Court of Human Rights I can get compensation. Accusing them of hurting
me and humiliating me with their accusations, I can get a huge amount
of compensation. We can do it together."

Halacoglu said that rather than officials, ordinary people and
non-governmental groups should do this against the 19 countries
which have taken decisions regarding the so-called Armenian genocide,
including Italy, Germany, Belgium, Poland and France.

Armenians claim that large numbers of Armenians — with figures
ranging between 600,000 and 1.5 million — were massacred by Turks
during World War I, which they say amounts to genocide. The Turkish
side says that there were many deaths on both sides, fiercely denying
any systematic massacres.

Book Review: Whitewashing Western Intervention

BOOK REVIEW: WHITEWASHING WESTERN INTERVENTION
by Dimitri Oram

Swans, CA
Feb 26 2007

Samantha Power’s A Problem from Hell

(Swans – February 26, 2007) Samantha Power, an advocacy journalist,
professor at Harvard’s Carr Center for Human Rights, and leading figure
in the Save Darfur movement, is one of the best examples of a crusader
against genocide who has been involved in denying, condoning, or
trivializing US war crimes. Right out of college, Samantha Power began
her career as an intern with the Carnegie Endowment for Peace under
then President Morton Abramowitz, who had quit the State Department
in order to lobby for military intervention in Bosnia. Having been
told that the situation in Bosnia was "genocide," Power went off to
the former Yugoslavia in 1993 where she worked for several years as
a reporter serving up the familiar (if oversimplified and factually
inaccurate) tale of "genocidal" Serbian aggression against Bosnia. As
she tells it, she and her colleagues questioned "how the United
States and its allies might have responded if the same crimes had
been committed in a different place…against different victims…at a
different time" (p. xv) This prompted her to undertake an investigation
of US responses to previous cases of genocide and write her 2002 book,
A Problem from Hell: America and the Age of Genocide, a book that
has been widely read and often respectfully reviewed.

The book’s premise is essentially as follows: "We have all been
bystanders to genocide" (xvii), the US government time and again has
failed to exercise its power in order to stop genocide. Power tries
to show over the course of more than 500 pages the US reaction (or
failure to react) to different cases of genocide over the twentieth
century. She begins with the Turkish genocide against the Armenians
during World War I, then moves on to the Holocaust in World War II,
Cambodia under the Khmer Rouge, Iraq’s attacks on the northern Kurds,
Serb atrocities in Bosnia, the Hutu massacres of Tutsi in Rwanda
in 1994, Kosovo and NATO’s "humanitarian" bombing campaign. With
the exception of the Armenian genocide, all the genocides (real and
alleged) to which Power devotes serious attention involve enemies of
the U.S. The genocides in which the U.S. and its client states are
directly implicated (including Vietnam, Iraq after Saddam Hussein
became an enemy, Guatemala, Indonesia, East Timor, El Salvador)
receive only passing mention when discussed at all.

Power’s book has a few good points: She presents an interesting and
sympathetic portrait of Raphael Lemkin, the Polish Jew who coined
the word genocide and played a leading role in getting the Genocide
Convention passed. (To her credit, she does also reproduce the actual
text of the 1948 Genocide Convention on p. 62-63) She notes that the
US government was late to ratify the Genocide Convention, doing so
only in the late 1980s in order to counter domestic criticism stemming
from the President Reagan’s 1985 visit to the Bitburg cemetery in West
Germany, which included the graves of SS soldiers, and his appalling
equation of SS soldiers with concentration camp victims. Even so,
the ratification only passed with added resolutions that made it
essentially inapplicable to the U.S. Power allows enough challenging
of the official line to appear critical of the U.S. government: She
criticizes US failure to help or save the various victims as well as
US support for the Khmer Rouge, Saddam Hussein’s government during the
1980s, and the US role in pushing for withdrawal of UN peacekeepers in
Rwanda. And, of course, she is critical of the U.S. for its failure
to state that "genocide" was occurring in Bosnia and intervene
even sooner.

This may sound like harsh criticism but, in fact, her complaints only
serve to underscore the evil of our current enemies. The true villains
always lie elsewhere and the real trouble is, as she said about the
alleged failure to confront Yugoslav President Milosevic, that "Western
officials … [were/are] engaged in a wishful thinking, failing to
imagine evil and presuming rational actors." The U.S. and the other
First World countries may have done some not so very nice things
in the past but the basic moral supremacy of the West is presumed;
only its refusal to do more about the crimes of others is questioned.

Our Crimes Don’t Count

In order to make her case that the U.S. is derelict in its duty
to stop genocide Ms. Power presents a warped and decontextualized
version of events, relying largely on the say-so of of various
interventionists and hawkish US officials, omitting key facts and
distorting others. Events are reduced to simple tales of bad leaders
who do bad things and need to be stopped or countered by the U.S. and
its allies. As a result of this the reader is left with a wildly flawed
but typically American view of the designated enemy as "irrational" or
"evil," with war or US intervention as a positive thing or at least
the lesser evil. Most disturbing is Power’s refusal to deal honestly
with the crimes of the United States and hold her government to an
equal level of accountability as the various enemy states she decries.

On those occasions when she does mention US crimes it is usually to
downplay them or use them in background to emphasize the greater crimes
of the enemy. She is critical of US conduct during the war on Vietnam,
which she mentions briefly — "American lives were being lost, American
honor was being soiled AND North Vietnam was winning the war." (p. 91,
Power’s emphasis) — and particularly of the bombing of Cambodia, which
she notes killed tens of thousands of people, destroyed Cambodia’s
economy and "did great damage in its own right." (Curiously she never
mentions Laos.) But she never calls US atrocities in Southeast Asia
genocide, or spends much time on them.

Primarily, she writes about the crimes of the Khmer Rouge and US
inaction.

As with the Western media in general she pays far less attention
to the comparable crime of a Western client state occurring at the
same time as the KR rule over Cambodia. She devotes one misleading
sentence to the US-backed Indonesian invasion of East Timor: "In 1975,
when its ally, the oil-producing, anti-communist Indonesia, invaded
East Timor, killing between 100,000 and 200,000 civilians, the United
States looked away." (pp.146-147) But the U.S. did not simply look
away, it supported Indonesia with large amounts of military aid,
blocked UN action and denied atrocities while the "Free Press" put
East Timor in virtual media blackout. (1)

Similarly, Power manages to give the U.S. a war-crimes-free version
of the 1991 Gulf War: "The U.S. bombing of Baghdad began in January
17, 1991. U.S. ground troops routed Iraqi republican guards soon
thereafter." (p. 237) There are no cluster bombs or depleted uranium
or highways of death in this account. The enormous suffering,
death, and damage caused by UN sanctions pushed through, enforced,
and maintained by the U.S. and Britain for over 12 years is not a
subject of discussion anywhere in Power’s book. For Power, like the
neoconservatives, only the US betrayal of Iraq’s Kurds and Shia is
a problem worth dwelling on. Indeed, Ms. Power even does her bit to
present the deeply suffering Iraq as a post-September 11 threat to
the United States:

States that murder and torment their own citizens target citizens
elsewhere. Their appetites become insatiable. Hitler began by
persecuting his own people and then waged war on the rest of Europe
and, in time, the United States. Saddam Hussein wiped out rural Kurdish
life and then turned on Kuwait, sending his genocidal henchman Ali
Hassan al Majid to govern the newly occupied country.

The United States now has reason to fear that the poisonous potions
Hussein tried out on the Kurds will be used next on Americans. (p.
513) If there is any difference between this passage and the rhetoric
of the Bush administration, one is hard pressed to find it. Indeed,
Power and her favored sources mix liberal human rights appeals with
the cold language of US "interests," both of which are supposedly
served by intervening in other countries one way or another, a road
that leads eventually to "bomb[ing] the fuckers" (Richard Holbrooke)
allegedly to prevent atrocities. Naturally, the bad guys are so bad
they deserve it.

Benevolent Atrocities

Certainly this is the way she portrays the wars in Bosnia and Kosovo,
which take up the greatest part of her book. Following the standard
script, which collapses under any serious scrutiny as Diana Johnstone
has shown in her book Fools’ Crusade, (2) she takes all allegations
against the Serbs at face value: Serbs are always the victimizers,
never the victims. Power does reluctantly acknowledge the post-bombing
ethnic cleansing of Kosovo by Albanian extremists (although she ignores
earlier KLA crimes) but attributes it to "revenge" and ignores NATO’s
obligation under international law to protect Kosovo’s Serb, Roma, and
other minority groups. Power actually looks favorably on the largest
ethnic cleansing operation of the Balkan wars, Operation Storm, in
which the Croatian armed forces drove over 200,000 Serbs from the UN
protected areas of Krajina on the eve of a peace agreement: "Croatia’s
success showed that the so-called Serb juggernaut was more of a paper
tiger, a vital piece of news for those who had deferred for years to
alarmist Pentagon warnings of steep US casualties." (p. 438) Ms. Power
does not mention the US support for this operation including training
given to Croatian forces by US private military contractor MPRI or
the US role in blocking a UN resolution condemning the atrocities
then being committed. She hails NATO’s large-scale bombing of the
Bosnian Serbs in 1995 and wholeheartedly supports NATO’s 1999 bombing
campaign against Yugoslavia.

Anyone who was alive at that time and had any access to mainstream
Western media will recognize the cliched, overwrought rhetoric and the
gross apologetics for NATO war crimes: "From his time at the Dayton
peace talks, [NATO general Wesley] Clark was well-acquainted with the
spuriousness of Milosevic’s charm, the prevalence of his lies and
the hardness of his heart" (p. 453); "Given the choice, virtually
every Albanian in Kosovo would have preferred to take his or her
chances with the NATO bombing then business as usual under Milosevic"
(p. 454); "NATO planners were especially sensitive about violations
of international humanitarian law"(p. 457) even though there were
"mistakes" and a number of the targets (i.e., Yugoslavia’s civilian
infrastructure), were "controversial" etc. Walter J. Rockler, a former
Prosecutor at the Nuremburg War crimes trials, whom Samantha Power,
despite her numerous references to the Holocaust and the Nuremburg
Tribunal, never cites, demolishes the NATO PR line:

The attack on Yugoslavia constitutes the most brazen act of
international aggression since the Nazis attacked Poland to prevent
"Polish atrocities" against Germans. The United States has discarded
pretensions to international legality and decency. And embarked
on a course of raw imperialism run amok… In reality, when we the
self-appointed rulers of the planet, issue an ultimatum to another
country it is "surrender or die." To maintain our "credibility" we
must crush any resemblance of resistance to our dictate, to that
country." (3) >>From the US government’s recruitment of leading
Nazi war criminals, to Wesley Clark’s attempt to force a military
showdown with Russian troops, there is a great deal Samantha Power
is not telling us. (4) Given the extensive amount of information
available to those who wish to look, it is not believable that
Ms. Power is unaware of these realities. Her allegedly damning look
at US policy provides cover for a much grimmer reality. Namely, that
the U.S. is itself guilty of acts of genocide and numerous other
horrendous crimes and that US intervention abroad (not US inaction)
has been the cause of enormous suffering and devastation for much
of the world’s population. While numerous writers, researchers, and
activists (including William Blum in his excellent book Killing Hope)
(5) have documented the terrible consequences of US intervention,
Ms. Power is not interested in a similarly full and honest look at
the record. She wants to make a case for further US intervention in
the affairs of other countries and limit examination of the past.

Those interested in a serious reform of US policy and a critical
look at the past would spend time examining the crimes that were
and are undertaken or supported by the U.S. They would not engage in
egregious evasions, accepting all allegations of the enemy’s evil at
face value. A Problem from Hell: America and the Age of Genocide is an
attempt to obscure the real problem from hell: Western intervention,
undertaken by the U.S. and its various imperial partners and rivals
along with the current global economic system that have led to
destruction, war, genocide, the continual globalization of poverty
combined with ever widening disparities in wealth and an increase in
nationalism, racism, and religious fundamentalism worldwide.

[I will address Power’s work on Rwanda, which serves primarily to mask
the crimes of the Rwandan Patriotic Front and its Western backers,
in a separate article.]

If you find our work valuable, please consider helping us financially.

Notes

1. On East Timor see among other sources Noam Chomsky and Edward
Herman, The Washington Connection and Third World Fascism, South End
Press, 1979, pp. 129-204. (back)

2. Diana Johnstone, Fools’ Crusade, Pluto Press, 2002. See
reviews here:
her e and here:
(back)

3. The Chicago Tribune, May 10, 1999
erg.html (back)

4. Among other sources see Christopher Simpson, The Splendid Blond
Beast (Grove Press, 1993) and Blowback: America’s Recruitment of
Nazis and Its Effects on the Cold War (Weidenfeld & Nicholson, 1988).

On Wesley Clark’s attempt to provoke a confrontation with
Russian troops at Pristina airport, an action vetoed by NATO
General Sir Michael Jackson who stated, "I’m not going to start
World War III for your sake," see The Guardian, August 2, 1999:
,,20 8120,00.html

Clark earned the disapproval of the Pentagon and his dismissal for
this kind of hawkishness rather than Power’s claim that "favoring
humanitarian intervention had never been a great career move." (p.
473) (back)

5. William Blum, Killing Hope, Common Courage Press, 1995. (back)

Internal Resources

Book Reviews

The Balkans and Yugoslavia

About the Author

Dimitri Oram is a writer and researcher based in Western
Massachusetts. He was born and raised in Northampton and graduated from
the University of Massachusetts in 2000. He woke up to the realities
of the US Global Empire back in 1999 during the NATO bombing campaign
against Serbia.

2.html

http://www.swans.com/library/art9/lproy04.html
http://www.swans.com/library/art9/herman10.html
http://www.swans.com/library/art9/ga156.html
http://members.tripod.com/~sarant_2/ks21nurnb
http://www.guardian.co.uk/Kosovo/Story/0
http://www.swans.com/library/art13/doram0

ANKARA: Turkish Parliamentarians Send Messages Of Warning To Their U

TURKISH PARLIAMENTARIANS SEND MESSAGES OF WARNING TO THEIR US COUNTERPARTS

Turkish Press
Feb 26 2007

BRUSSELS – Turkish parliamentary delegation that is currently in
Brussels to attend NATO Parliamentary Assembly meetings sent messages
of warning to their U.S. counterparts on the draft resolution about
so-called Armenian genocide.

Vahit Erdem, head of the delegation, said in his letter to John
Tanner, head of the U.S. parliamentary delegation, "we attribute
great importance to friendly relations between Turkey and the United
States. Any attempt that may harm those relations in a complicated
period following the Cold War era, should be avoided."

"Approval of the draft resolution by the U.S. Congress will disrupt
the bilateral relations. In that case, Turkey-the United States
relations will seriously damaged. By making such a political judgment,
the U.S. Congress will make a big mistake," he said.

Erdem stressed that Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan had
earlier proposed Armenia to form a committee of historians and open
all archives, but Armenian party did not give a response.

Meanwhile, Turkey-the United States Inter-parliamentary
Friendship Group Chairman Egemen Bagis held a series of talks with
U.S. congressmen on the same issue.

Bagis said that the congressmen understood the importance of the
matter, and pledged to explain it to their colleagues when they return
to Washington D.C.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress