“There is no need to duplicate formats”: about Armenia-Azerbaijan negotiations

Sept 30 2022


  • JAMnews
  • Yerevan

Negotiation process between Armenia and Azerbaijan

Despite the ongoing tension after the hostilities of September 13-14, Armenian officials are not refusing negotiations with representatives of Azerbaijan. The next meeting of Foreign Ministers Ararat Mirzoyan and Jeyhun Bayramov is scheduled for October 2 in Geneva.

This information was confirmed by the press secretary of the Armenian Foreign Ministry Vahan Hunanyan: “Despite the provocations from Azerbaijan, Armenia will take part in the meeting. Thus, the statements of the Azerbaijani Foreign Ministry that Armenia is trying to disrupt the negotiations are groundless. Armenia, as before, is constructive, aimed at achieving a lasting peace in the South Caucasus, and expects the same of Azerbaijan.”

Earlier, on September 27, a meeting was held in the United States between Secretary of the Security Council of Armenia Armen Grigoryan and Advisor to the President of Azerbaijan Hikmet Hajiyev.

Azerbaijanologist Tatevik Hayrapetyan considers this format of meetings unnecessary, since the platform for negotiations between the foreign ministers of the two countries has long been used.

Details of the Grigoryan-Hajiyev meeting, topics of the Armenian-Azerbaijani talks, and xpert opinion on the expediency of their formats.


  • “Our ally isn’t fulfilling its obligation to supply weapons” – Prime Minister of Armenia
  • “The least painful solution” or “the path of struggle”? Choice of former presidents of Armenia
  • “Azerbaijan intends to occupy other territories of Armenia” – Pashinyan from UN rostrum

Armen Grigoryan and Hikmet Hajiyev met at the White House on the initiative of US National Security Adviser Jake Sullivan.

According to the Armenian Security Council, the parties recognized the importance of eliminating the consequences of hostilities, and discussed

  • the need for peace in the region,
  • the process of a long-term peaceful resolution of the Nagorno-Karabakh problem.

Intense hostilities on the Armenian-Azerbaijani border began at midnight on September 13. On the evening of September 14, Armenia announced that, thanks to the intervention of international partners, an agreement had been reached on a ceasefire. The officially announced total number of dead and missing Armenian soldiers is 207 men. At least 20 soldiers were captured.

On the evening of September 28 the Armenian Defense Ministry reported that Azerbaijan had resumed hostilities, as a result of which three more soldiers were killed.

Jake Sullivan described the Grigoryan-Gadzhiev meeting as “direct and constructive.”

“We discussed the importance of preventing further violence and holding timely and focused negotiations. We have also outlined clear steps to achieve a stable and lasting peace,” he wrote on his Twitter page.

Hikmet Hajiyev also commented on the meeting on Twitter. The adviser to the President of Azerbaijan expressed gratitude to America for “discussing and promoting the agenda of lasting peace and stability in the region.”

The Secretary of the Security Council of Armenia and the Advisor to the President of Azerbaijan met three times in 2022. The talks were held in Brussels with the participation of EU Special Representative Toivo Klaar.

The Prime Minister of Armenia and the Secretary of the Security Council are visiting Washington and Paris. What is the agenda?

On September 28 Armen Grigoryan, who is in Washington, gave an interview to the Armenian service of the Voice of America. He called the meeting with Hajiyev productive.

According to Grigoryan, Armenia and Azerbaijan are discussing four interrelated issues: humanitarian problems, unblocking roads, delimitation and demarcation of the border, and the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict.

“We have tried to be clear about how we will move forward in these areas. The peace agreement between Armenia and Azerbaijan is connected with all this,” he said.

Grigoryan recalled that there are other formats for Armenian-Azerbaijani talks: with the participation of foreign ministers, vice-premiers, as well as heads of national security services. According to him, “the meetings of the leaders of the countries are due to the progress made in these formats.”

The Secretary of the Security Council of Armenia emphasized the positive effect of US involvement in regional processes.

As an example, he cited recent hostilities on the Armenian-Azerbaijani border. He said it was possible to stop the fighting thanks to the retaliatory actions of the Armenian army and American intervention.

The Office of the Human Rights Defender published an extraordinary report on the consequences of hostilities on the Armenian border. The report presents cases of torture of Armenian prisoners of war, abuse of the bodies of the dead, destruction of civilian infrastructure, and shelling of hospitals, schools and kindergartens.

Azerbaijanologist Tatevik Hayrapetyan says the Grigoryan-Hajiyev format raises questions:

“To be honest the format is incomprehensible to me, because if there is a platform for negotiations between foreign ministers, then why launch duplicate formats. What are these issues that cannot be discussed by the Ministers of Foreign Affairs, but are discussed by the Secretary of the Security Council and Advisor to the President of Azerbaijan?”

She considers direct communication between the heads of security services and defense ministers more understandable. Hayrapetyan believes that the problem is that Armen Grigoryan is not meeting with his Azerbaijani counterpart, but with Aliyev’s adviser.

The Azerbaijanologist considers this format not only problematic, but even dangerous, “just like Grigoryan’s statements”:

“It should not be forgotten that his response to Aliyev about the illegitimacy of Azerbaijan’s demand to use another route connecting Artsakh with Armenia instead of the Lachin corridor was used by Azerbaijan to unleash aggression in the Berdzor [Lachin] region on August 3. After that the route connecting Armenia with Nagorno-Karabakh was quickly changed. I’m not talking about that anymore. Before the attack on September 12, Grigoryan and Hajiyev met in Brussels in August.”

Tatevik Hayrapetyan also believes that the Brussels format of the Armenian-Azerbaijani talks has exhausted itself, and mediation should go to the United States and France:

“In the Brussels format there is not even a mention of Nagorno-Karabakh, there have never been any normal formulations arising from the interests of Armenia. This format has already proven its worthlessness. The mediation of the United States and France is more useful for us, including from the point of view of containing Azerbaijan.”

https://jam-news.net/there-is-no-need-to-duplicate-formats-about-armenia-azerbaijan-negotiations/





“Turkey is not particularly interested”: On possible Pashinyan-Erdogan negotiations

Sept 30 2022


  • Armine Martirosyan
  • Yerevan

Pashinyan-Erdogan talks expected

The September war on the Armenian-Azerbaijani border again raised the question in Armenian society whether the hopes and intentions of Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan of establishing peace in the region are not illusory. Experts say that “Azerbaijan’s aggression has further complicated the solution of any issues through negotiations.” Although even under these conditions, foreign mediators organize meetings and negotiations between the conflicting parties. The latter took place in the United States with the participation of the Secretary of the Security Council of Armenia and an adviser to the President of Azerbaijan.

Another important meeting in early October in Prague has been announced. On the sidelines of the summit of the European Political Community, the Armenian Prime Minister is expected to meet with the President of Turkey, Azerbaijan’s main ally. In Armenia, they say that Ilham Aliyev will also be invisibly involved in these negotiations, since the head of Turkey openly announced the synchronization of his steps with the President of Azerbaijan.

Armenian experts below consider all bilateral negotiations important, though they doubt their effectiveness, and predict a possible agenda of Pashinyan-Erdogan talks expected in the near future.


  • Geopolitical project: How Armenia lost the war and wound up between world powers
  • “Armenia offers Azerbaijan three roads through its territory” – details from an expert
  • Regional processes without taking into account Armenian interests? Opinion

“Pashinyan and Erdogan can meet in Prague on the sidelines of the European Political Community summit. Their meeting could have taken place in New York during the last session of the UN General Assembly, but did not take place due to their busy schedules.

There are so many topics for conversation that it is difficult to say what will be given priority. Nevertheless, I suppose that the main topic for discussion at the meeting will be Armenian-Turkish relations, taking into account the interests of Azerbaijan. Ankara considers them parallel processes and constantly links them, which is justified in the case of the allies.

Yerevan must go to this meeting, but with its own very specific agenda. This meeting can minimize the risks of a possible new war.

Armenia should strive to sign agreements with Turkey and Azerbaijan – with minimal risks for itself. It is obvious that we are the losing side and we need this more than anything. And institutional peace is possible only after the signing of agreements.”

Pashinyan-Erdogan telephone conversation should not be overestimated or underestimated, experts believe, Instead, it should be regarded as a step forward in the Armenian-Turkish normalization process

“Of course, Armenia should have red lines. This is the territorial integrity of the country and its sovereignty. On all other issues we need to show great flexibility – in view of the fact that the army has been weakened, defense capability is low, and the diplomatic balance is not in our favor.

Armenia does not have an ally such as Turkey is for Azerbaijan. So, you need to choose the lesser of the evils.

“Turkey’s only real precondition for the normalization of Armenian-Turkish relations, both in the past before the war of 2020, and now, is the issue of Artsakh, the issue of the resolution of Armenian-Azerbaijani relations. Moreover, the formal side of this issue interests the Turks more than the content.

And any variant of resolving issues that suits Baku will also suit Ankara. This imperative comes from the Azerbaijani-Turkish allied relations.

There can be no other real preconditions.”

Pashinyan-Erdogan telephone conversation should not be overestimated or underestimated, experts believe, Instead, it should be regarded as a step forward in the Armenian-Turkish normalization process

“Except for Baku and Ankara, none of the players involved in the negotiations puts before Armenia the issue of providing an extraterritorial corridor through its territory. This demand is unrealizable unless Baku decides to solve it through war. It is impossible to achieve this in a negotiating format, since this would mean a violation of the territorial integrity and sovereignty of Armenia.

I believe the corridor connecting Azerbaijan with its exclave Nakhichevan will not be extraterritorial, but functional. That is, there will be no changes to the borders, but Azerbaijan will be provided with a road that will be controlled by the Russian FSB – as stated in the ninth paragraph of the November 2020 tripartite statement, which ceased hostilities in Karabakh.

Armenia will have control over the road, but very limited. I think Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan signed this. And it is unlikely that he will refuse it.

Azerbaijan is simply putting forward a maximalist agenda, but ultimately the issue will be resolved through a tripartite statement. In this case Armenia will not have territorial losses, but will lose in sovereignty.

And that’s the lesser of the evils. If a peace treaty is not signed, war could break out in Syunik [Armenia’s southern border with Azerbaijan]. Armenia does not have enough strength, defense capability to abandon this point of the tripartite statement.”

Pashinyan-Erdogan talks expected

Yerevanians discuss Armenian-Turkish negotiations and fears of the influx of Turkish goods forcing local producers out of the market

“The Pashinyan-Erdogan meeting is, of course, important from the point of view of the dialogue between the heads of the two countries, but it is not necessary to expect breakthroughs and pin great hopes on it, given Turkey’s tough position, which supports Azerbaijan’s demands of Armenia.

Turkey’s latest accusations against Armenia, which have nothing to do with reality, that it allegedly provoked Azerbaijani military operations on the border, is a confirmation of this. And this is not an isolated case, but a political approach. Therefore, Erdogan said on the sidelines of the UN General Assembly that all steps taken by Turkey in the region should be coordinated with Aliyev.”

“If the meeting does take place, Turkey will put the well-known “peace treaty” and the issue of a “corridor” through Armenia on the negotiating table. This means the unblocking of roads with the demand for a “corridor”, that is, the loss of Armenian sovereignty over this territory.

Yerevan officially opposes an extraterritorial corridor through its territory, although it is ready to provide a land road linking Azerbaijan with Nakhichevan.

Armenia also has red lines regarding the peace treaty. Azerbaijan presented five basic principles for the signing of a peace treaty. Armenia, in turn, put forward its six on providing mechanisms and guarantees for the security and rights of the Armenians of Nagorno-Karabakh. And if the Turkish-Azerbaijani tandem continues to ignore the proposals of Armenia, naturally, the disagreement will deepen.

At the same time, since it is important for Turkey to satisfy Baku’s demands for the signing of a peace treaty with the recognition of NK as part of it, that is, closure of the Artsakh issue, and for the provision of a “corridor”, the effectiveness of all possible meetings is automatically called into question.

In connection with the latest military aggression of Azerbaijan on the Armenian border, uncertainty arose about the meeting of special representatives on the normalization of relations between Armenia and Turkey, which was announced for September.

In general, the topic of purely Armenian-Turkish bilateral relations is secondary; other issues are important for Turkey.”

The latest IRI survey in Armenia shows that the majority regard Azerbaijan and Turkey as the main threat to the country’s security

“Azerbaijan raises the bar of its demands every time, exerting forceful military pressure.

Today it is customary to say that the Armenian army has few resources and its defense capability is insufficient. But on September 13-14 we saw tough resistance to Azerbaijani aggression, we saw what serious losses it inflicted on the enemy. It should be clearly stated here that it was through the efforts of the Armenian army and under the pressure of American diplomacy on Baku that another Azerbaijani aggression was halted through Turkey.

But here, too, Turkey is trying to give its Western partners the impression that it is in favor of a dialogue with Armenia. A possible meeting in Prague, most likely, is planned precisely for this purpose. Turkey needs to be shown that it is constructive. But if this meeting were important for Turkey, Erdogan would make efforts to have it take place in New York, where both Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan and Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan were.

And the statement about the “busy schedule” only says that Turkey is not particularly interested in this meeting. And if it takes place, Erdogan will once again present exclusively his position and make demands.”

https://jam-news.net/turkey-is-not-particularly-interested-on-possible-pashinyan-erdogan-negotiations/

La France en Cilicie et au Liban

Liban – 28 sep 2022

La realpolitik est très rentable à court terme. Cependant, pour le long terme, imaginons seulement aujourd’hui, si la Cilicie était toujours arménienne francophile, ce qu’elle aurait pu offrir comme possibilités au prestige de la culture française et donc de sa puissance politique et économique.

Le destin de la Cilicie était depuis toujours lié à celui du Liban. Déjà, dès l’époque séleucide, ils étaient réunis au sein d’une administration commune sous Antiochos X, entre 94 et 88 av. J.C. Au Moyen Âge, la Cilicie devenait un royaume arménien allié au Comté de Tripoli. En 1920, ce territoire montagneux situé au nord de l’île de Chypre, était, une fois de plus, joint au Liban sous un mandat français souhaité et obtenu par les Arméniens et les maronites qui se relevaient à peine du grand génocide perpétré à coups de massacres, de déportations et de famine.

L’abandon de la Cilicie

Les troupes françaises étaient intervenues en Cilicie dès novembre 1918, en coordination avec les contingents britanniques. Mais dès février 1920, les colonnes franco-arméniennes, qui subissaient de graves défaites, commençaient leur retrait de plusieurs villes, suivies de leurs populations chrétiennes. Pris de panique, les Arméniens entreprenaient des initiatives désespérées, proclamant le 5 août 1920, la République arménienne de Mésopotamie cilicienne, aussitôt réprimée par les autorités françaises.

Alors qu’à partir de Beyrouth, le général Gouraud préparait la reconquête d’Édesse, Paris signait le 20 octobre 1921 le traité d’Ankara. Elle y rétrocédait tous les territoires de Cilicie à la Turquie en échange du respect des populations chrétiennes, ainsi que la promesse d’hypothétiques avantages économiques. C’est le comble de la cruauté que de placer les survivants d’un génocide sous la protection de leurs bourreaux. Il en a résulté un exode général encouragé par l’Église arménienne elle-même qui ne se faisait pas la moindre illusion sur la suite des événements.

Le royaume de Cilicie et le comté de Tripoli en 1190. (Wikimedia)

L’abandon de Ninive et d’Alexandrette

La France a abandonné le peuple arménien de Cilicie pour se voir régler les dettes ottomanes par la jeune République turque, conformément au traité de Lausanne qui sera signé en 1923. Pour les Arméniens qui, comme les maronites, avaient attendu la protection française depuis des décennies et avaient combattu dans les légions loin de leurs foyers, ce fut la consternation. Toujours selon cette logique de raison d’État, à Ninive (Mossoul) en Haute-Mésopotamie, les assyro-chaldéens qui avaient combattu fidèlement auprès des Britanniques étaient à leur tour trahis par ces derniers, et abandonnés aux Arabes en 1933 pour subir les habituels massacres et exodes. En 1939, le Sandjak d’Alexandrette, avec la grande Antioche, était encore remis par la France à la Turquie. Tout ce qui avait miraculeusement survécu au génocide chrétien, succombait aux politiques franco-britanniques.

L’abandon des Dardanelles

Rien n’a pu échapper à cette débâcle générale qui précipitait la mort de l’Orient chrétien. Les régions grecques ont fini par être rattrapées par les mouvements d’exode. Début janvier 1922, les troupes françaises évacuaient les villes arméniennes d’Adana et de Tarse en Cilicie et, dès septembre, elles livraient les territoires grecs d’Asie mineure jusqu’à leurs positions dans les Dardanelles. Un million trois cent mille Grecs se trouvaient arrachés à leur terre ancestrale. Tous les chrétiens, syriaques-orthodoxes, grecs-orthodoxes, assyro-chaldéens, maronites d’Alexandrette et Arméniens devenaient les victimes directes de la politique nationale turque de nettoyage ethnique.

La défaite des Grecs sur le front occidental avait rendu précaires les positions françaises. Pour le président du Conseil, Aristide Briand, l’entente avec les Kémalistes permettrait en revanche à la France de se maintenir en Syrie et de protéger le Liban, tout en s’assurant les bonnes grâces du monde musulman.

L’opposition de l’administrateur français

Les indignations étaient exprimées jusqu’au sein-même de l’armée française, témoin des événements sur le terrain. L’auteur Vahé Tachjian relève notamment dans les archives du Haut-Commissariat de Beyrouth, la figure du colonel Brémond, administrateur en chef de la Cilice, pour qui les Arméniens constituaient le “point d’appui unique” de la France en Cilicie. Ce militaire éclairé œuvrait pour l’établissement d’une forme d’autonomie cilicienne, ce qui lui avait valu une opposition ferme de sa diplomatie séduite par les Kémalistes.

Mustafa Kemal passait progressivement dans l’imaginaire français de vulgaire rebelle à héros national incarnant le progrès. Le colonel Brémond a été rappelé à Beyrouth dès l’automne 1920, contraint d’abandonner la Cilicie arménienne à son terrible sort. La France, elle, se félicitait des promesses de changement et de laïcité représentées par la personnalité de Mustafa Kemal. En effet, en 1922, le sultanat était aboli, en 1923 la République était proclamée et en 1924, le califat était supprimé. La laïcité n’a jamais cessé d’être un appât luisant pour les Occidentaux. Cependant, pour beaucoup d’observateurs plus perspicaces, cette vague incompatible avec la mentalité locale, ne pouvait être que passagère et finirait par être rejetée comme la greffe d’un corps étranger en Turquie et dans le reste de l’Orient.

La légion arménienne durant la Première Guerre mondiale, à Chypre. (Source: Légion arménienne, in: The Armenian Weekly)

L’opposition de parlementaires français

Après le rappel du colonel Brémond et la reddition de plusieurs contingents français, c’est au Parlement que, le 29 décembre 1921, Ernest Flandin (député du Calvados) et Gustave de Lamarzelle (sénateur du Morbihan) se sont insurgés contre le traité d’Ankara (dit d’Angora). Cet accord représentait l’abandon pur et simple de la Petite Arménie (la Cilicie) aux Turcs. Flandin a rappelé le martyre des Arméniens durant la Grande Guerre, les sacrifices héroïques offerts par la légion arménienne sous la bannière de la France, et enfin les promesses de protection faites par Raymond Poincaré, le 16 février 1919.

L’histoire se répète

Dans ses acrobaties de realpolitik, il arrive à la France de perdre le discernement. Après la Cilicie, la voilà qui retrouve au Liban, encore, d’hypothétiques avantages promis cette fois-ci par la République islamique. La diplomatie française contemporaine jongle avec des interprétations sur la milice terroriste du Hezbollah qui anéantit le Liban, lui inventant tantôt une aile politique supposée fréquentable, tantôt une représentativité légitimée par un choix prétendu démocratique.

Les échecs de l’histoire se répètent. Cependant, de nos jours, les transferts de populations se font d’une manière plus subtile. Si en 1922, le Haut-Commissaire débloquait ouvertement la somme de 50 millions de francs pour la délocalisation des Arméniens, aujourd’hui le processus est soigneusement délégué à des entreprises privées. C’est ainsi, par exemple, qu’à Jounié durant l’été 2021, 700 infirmières et infirmiers ont été transférés du Liban accompagnés de toutes leurs familles. La jeunesse et les cerveaux s’en vont vers ces pays d’Occident qui leur offrent toutes sortes d’avantages afin de les attirer en profitant de l’effondrement d’un Liban sous occupation, accablé et subissant un processus intentionnel d’appauvrissement.

La realpolitik est en effet très rentable à court terme. Cependant, pour le long terme, imaginons seulement aujourd’hui, si la Cilicie était toujours arménienne francophile, ce qu’elle aurait pu offrir comme possibilités au prestige de la culture française et donc de sa puissance politique et économique. Imaginons aussi demain, lorsque la majorité des Libanais aura été transférée en France, Hollande, Danemark, Canada, Australie et ailleurs, ce que la France aura perdu comme assise politico-culturelle sur cette côte du Levant. Il ne fait aucun doute que l’abandon de ses alliés de cœur consiste, pour les grandes nations, en un suicide lent, mais désespérément inéluctable.

https://icibeyrouth.com/liban/130397?gclid=CjwKCAjwp9qZBhBkEiwAsYFsbxs6AXUQTFvCyPbsSIZ__nQ8tw4fgDpruOIe1H7gxNB0SWPOvpC-mBoCPC0QAvD_BwE

EBRD raises growth forecast for Armenia’s economy for 2022

Save

Share

 14:14,

YEREVAN, SEPTEMBER 28, ARMENPRESS. The European Bank for Reconstruction and Development (EBRD) has revised its growth forecast for the economy of Armenia. The Bank is now forecasting 8% economic growth for Armenia in 2022.

In its latest Regional Economic Prospects (REP), the EBRD said that the economies of Armenia, Azerbaijan and Georgia are enjoying some of their highest growth rates in years.

The EBRD said Armenia and Georgia are benefiting from an inflow of Russian businesses and information and communication technology (ICT) professionals, boosting the service sectors of these small economies.

However, the robust growth recorded for the region in 2022 will taper off in 2023, highlighting concerns about its medium-term sustainability. The report warns that current growth in the Caucasus is mainly driven by temporary factors that could easily be reversed.

“In Armenia, the solid recovery seen in 2021 carried strong growth momentum into 2022, with economic growth reaching 13.1 per cent in the period from January to July. As in Georgia, the arrival of many people and firms from Russia led to an increase of 113 per cent in foreign inflows and boosted demand for services.

This has helped Armenia to finance its widening trade deficit. Foreign reserves have also increased by 20 per cent and the exchange rate by 18 per cent. The report forecasts robust growth of 8 per cent in 2022, up from a previous estimate of 4.5 per cent. The slowdown is expected to be less gentle, with a drop to 4 per cent likely in 2023. However, the latest growth estimate for 2023 remains above the earlier projection of 2.5 per cent”, the Bank said.

Three killed by Azeri shelling: Armenia

Perth Now, Australia
Sept 28 2022
Staff WritersReuters
9:02PM

Armenia says three soldiers have been killed by shelling from Azerbaijan, Tass agency reports, as the two neighbours accused each other of violating a ceasefire that ended two days of warfare.

Tass cited an Armenian defence ministry statement but did not give details.

Last Friday, both sides accused each other of breaching the truce by firing across the border.

After border clashes two weeks ago that killed almost 200 soldiers, the worst bout of fighting since a six-week war between the two ex-Soviet countries in late 2020, the two sides agreed to a ceasefire deal brokered by Russia.

The fighting is linked to decades-old hostilities over control of the mountainous Nagorno-Karabakh region, internationally recognised as part of Azerbaijan but until 2020 largely controlled by the majority ethnic Armenian population.

Azerbaijan’s defence ministry said that at 6pm, Armenian units had started firing at Azerbaijani positions in the Kalbajar region, wounding one serviceman, and that Azerbaijani forces had taken “retaliatory measures”.

The Armenian defence ministry gave an opposite account, tweeting that Azerbaijani forces had fired towards Armenian positions near the common border using mortars and large-calibre weapons, and that the Armenian side had retaliated.

Armenia said then that Azerbaijan had attacked its territory and seized settlements inside its borders; Azerbaijan said it was responding to “provocations” from the Armenian side.

Armenian Students Organization Promotes Peace

Villanova University, PA
Sept 28 2022

Students tabled for Armenia.

Arden West, Staff Writer

This past Thursday, the Armenian Students Organization (ASO) called on Villanovans to take action in response to the Armenia-Azerbaijan conflict that flared up on Sept. 12, when Azerbaijan attacked Armenian air defense and artillery. Armenian spokespeople report that 135 of their service members were killed and six civilians were wounded. Azerbaijan claims its actions were “retaliatory measures” and that 77 of its service members were killed. The United Nations brokered a cease-fire that started at 8 p.m. local time last Wednesday night. However, the situation remains extremely tense, especially at the border. 

 

“The intention of our event was to inform the greater community about what’s happening in Armenia and to provide them with ways to contribute to peace efforts,” said ASO Secretary, sophomore Isabella Bailain. “As a part of the Armenian Students Organization, we believe it’s imperative that Villanova students take interest in international crises and human rights violations, and that when possible, we can educate ourselves on ways to uphold our Augustinian values of truth, unity and love, and the way that those values have an important place in our activism.”

 

The table at Connelly Center’s main feature was a flier that contained a QR code to a petition form on the March to Justice website. It allowed students to call on their representatives to “restrict military aid to Azerbaijan in light of new unprovoked strikes against Armenia.”

 

Connecting to the national level, the organization hopes to get House Resolution 1351, titled: “Condemning Azerbaijan’s unprovoked military attack on Armenia” passed. The bill was introduced by the House Foreign Affairs Committee on Sept. 14, and it is sponsored by California representative Adam Schiff. 

 

“Our event’s purpose was not only to invigorate support for Armenia, a religious minority in the Middle East, who is being attacked by a close ally of a nation—who to this day— denies committing genocide against our people, but to also educate them and provide resources for their continued interest in the often ignored region of the world,” explained ASO Vice President, junior Taleen Postian.

 

Postian added that “of the 70 fliers [they] handed out on Thursday, each included resources for students to learn more about Armenian issues and starting points for them to conduct their own research on the conflict. Our message is a call to empathy and a call to action. We do not want your pity without effort, we do not want prayers without concrete change.”

 

Members of ASO also mentioned how most people at the University do not even know that an Armenian Students Organization exists on campus, and they might not even know that Armenia exists, let alone what’s happening in Artsakh and the prolonged humanitarian crisis that has taken place. To combat this unawareness, ASO hosts countless activities and events around the year ranging from member dinners with Armenian mezzeh, khorovats, Armenian barbecue, lemejoon, Armenian pizza sales, genocide recognition events and various petitions. 

 

“We also believe it’s important to pay attention to America’s contribution to international crises, as we do play a larger role than what is visible to citizens on the surface,” Bailan said.

 

Her point could not be further proven by this situation. Recently, Speaker Nancy Pelosi sparked intense controversy when she visited Armenia to demonstrate support for the country and to say that the violence “was initiated by the Azeris.” While some argue that Speaker Pelosi traveled to Armenia solely to model the diplomatic strength of the United States House, the issue is even more complex since Armenians have historically been backed by Russia, and Azerbaijan has received support from Turkey—a country in NATO.

 

To many Villanovans, this conflict, along with many other complicated ones in the East, seem non-existent because of physical distance and lack of connection to the region. However, to many of our peers here, Armenia is home. 

 

“It is very difficult spending hours talking at your fellow students to no avail,” Postian said. “Saying, ‘would you like to take action to prevent genocide?’ And hearing a mumbled ‘no’ in response is not only depressing, it’s aggravating. We are meant to be immersed in the teachings of Augustinian tradition and values at Villanova. We as Armenians are yelling the truth, and apathetic responses are not demonstrative of the traits we have had ingrained in us since freshman year. We as Armenians ask you to do better. All we want is that you start by listening and opening up your mind to learning.”

https://villanovan.com/21292/news/armenian-students-organization-promotes-peace/

Armenia says three soldiers killed by Azeri shelling -Tass

Reuters
Sept 28 2022
Reuters

LONDON, Sept 28 (Reuters) – Armenia said three soldiers were killed by shelling from Azerbaijan on Wednesday, Tass agency reported, as the two neighbours accused each other of violating a ceasefire that ended two days of warfare.

Tass cited an Armenian defence ministry statement but did not give details. Last Friday, both sides accused each other of breaching the truce by firing across the border.

After border clashes two weeks ago that killed almost 200 soldiers, the worst bout of fighting since a six-week war between the two ex-Soviet countries in late 2020, the two sides agreed to a ceasefire deal brokered by Russia.

The fighting is linked to decades-old hostilities over control of the mountainous Nagorno-Karabakh region, internationally recognised as part of Azerbaijan but until 2020 largely controlled by the majority ethnic Armenian population.

Azerbaijan’s defence ministry said that at about 6 p.m. (1400 GMT), Armenian units had started firing at Azerbaijani positions in the Kalbajar region, wounding one serviceman, and that Azerbaijani forces had taken “retaliatory measures”.

The Armenian defence ministry gave an opposite account, tweeting that Azerbaijani forces had fired towards Armenian positions near the common border using mortars and large-calibre weapons, and that the Armenian side had retaliated.

Armenia said then that Azerbaijan had attacked its territory and seized settlements inside its borders; Azerbaijan said it was responding to “provocations” from the Armenian side.

Arming Armenia: India to export missiles, rockets and ammunition

India Times – Sept 28 2022
DefenceIndia has signed a significant export order for missiles, rockets and ammunition to Armenia as the Asian nation is engaged in a prolonged border conflict with neighbour Azerbaijan. The government to government route was used to sign a number of contracts for the supply of arms and ammunition to Armenia earlier this month.

While the value of the contracts has not been revealed, it is estimated that weapons worth over Rs 2,000 crore will be supplied to the country over the coming months. India has been making significant efforts to increase weapons exports, with policy reforms and active support of the government to secure overseas orders.

Sources told ET that the order includes the first-ever export of the indigenous Pinaka multi-barrel rocket launchers that are already in service with the Indian Army. The potent weapon has been designed by the Defence Research and Development Organisation (DRDO) and is manufactured by private sector companies in India. The Army has recently placed orders for six additional Pinaka regiments and is testing extended range rockets as well.

India will also supply anti-tank rockets as well as a range of ammunition to Armenia under the bundled deal. This is not the first time that weapon systems have been exported to Armenia. In 2020, India beat competitors from the region to supply four Swathi radars to the nation for an estimated Rs 350 crore.

Designed to the specifications of the Indian Army, these radars are used to track incoming artillery shells, mortars and rockets and give a pinpoint location of enemy launchers and positions. The radars have been successfully employed on both Pakistan and China borders.

India has been making focused efforts to increase defence exports, with a target of Rs 35,000 crore worth of equipment to be sold abroad by 2025. Last year, annual defence exports were close to Rs 13,000 crore, driven primarily by the private sector.


Remembering War in Stepanakert

Stepanakert, September 27, 2020.
A view from the author’s window.

Stepanakert, the capital of Artsakh, once again celebrated its eponymous day without festivities. Two years ago, the city woke up to strong explosions the morning after these annual celebrations. Still sleepy, residents did not understand what was going on. The screams of women and children running down the stairs to the basement in panic could be heard from the entrance to our five-story Soviet-era building. A cluster bomb had exploded in our yard. Cars were on fire. It was around seven in the morning on September 27, 2020. It is terrible to imagine if the shelling had started two hours later, and the children were already in the yard. A black cat had been lying near the burning cars. Its intestines were laid bare, the fragments crushed and its dark blood spilled on the ground. It was the only living creature outside out at that hour. 

A living, bustling city became desolate in one day. For 44 days, the silence was periodically interrupted by air raid sirens, which still blare in our ears.

The wave of the blast shattered windows. The men stood stunned, and one of them uttered, “The war has begun.” The women, for some reason, started sweeping broken glass.

A Stepanakert classroom destroyed during the Artsakh War, October 1, 2020

The man was right. The war lasted 44 days. Thousands were killed, tens of thousands of Artsakh citizens were displaced, and hundreds of villages and cities came under the control of Azerbaijan. The reality in Artsakh changed in one morning. Two years later, the city is an open wound. The war has yet to end in Artsakh. Today, we see that it has even been transferred to the sovereign territory of the Republic of Armenia (RA).

Azeri shelling in Stepanakert (Photo: Marut Vanyan)

It seemed that the entry of Russian peacekeepers would bring peace to the region, at least temporarily for five years, but many concerning events have taken place, which continue to worry all Armenians, especially Armenians living in Artsakh.

December 14, 2020: Azerbaijan occupies the still remaining villages of Hin Tagher and Khtsaberd of the Hadrut region of Artsakh and captures Armenian servicemen.

May 12, 2021: Azerbaijan launches attacks in Gegharkunik (Upper Shorzha) and Syunik (Black Lake, Khoznavar), capturing more than 40 kilometers of RA territory.

August 26, 2021: Azerbaijan demands and receives from Armenia sections of the Goris-Kapan road, paralyzing the Armenia-Iran interstate land connection. 

November 16, 2021: Azerbaijan launches an attack in the direction of Ishkhanasar mountain in the Syunik region. The Armenian side had seven victims, ten captured.

March 2022: Azerbaijan attacks in the direction of Parukh village in the Askeran region of Artsakh and captures the nearby strategic Karaglukh heights. Three Armenian soldiers are killed in the battles. The populations of Parukh and Khramort villages are evacuated.

March 2022: Azerbaijan interrupts the gas supply from Armenia to Artsakh twice during an unprecedented, unbearably cold month, creating a humanitarian crisis.

August 1-3, 2022: Azerbaijan launches attacks in the direction of Armenian positions in the western parts of the Martakert region in Artsakh and the Berdzor corridor. Armenia has at least two victims and 19 wounded. Azerbaijan demands the town of Berdzor and the villages of  Aghavno and Nerkin Sus and receives them as of September 1.

September 13-14, 2022: Azerbaijan launches the largest offensive since the 2020 war, from Gegharkunik to the Armenian-Iranian border. Azerbaijani forces shell RA cities and villages, occupying at least 10 square kilometers of RA territory. As of September 19, the Armenian side has at least 207 dead and missing.

During this entire period, Azerbaijan’s Armed Forces have regularly shot at the border villages of Artsakh, particularly in the direction of the villages of Taghavard and Karmir Shuka.

Along with non-stop fighting, the socio-psychological situation in Artsakh remains very difficult. The government of Artsakh has only been able to provide housing for 1,200 displaced persons. To this day, people live in hotels, garages and shops, hoping that one day they will receive housing from the government. This issue is considered one of the most urgent in Artsakh. Every day, people are looking for a house for rent in Stepanakert, but there are none.

Gurgen papik and his granddaughter (Photo: Marut Vanyan)

Grandpa Gurgen lives in a former shop with his 12 family members. “I worked as a builder for 40 years,” he says. “I built two houses in Stepanakert, but during the first Artsakh war, when they were shelled from Shushi, my house was razed to the ground. The product of my whole life’s work became zero in just a minute. We moved to Shushi after it was liberated. Now we have been evacuated and live in this shop with 12 people. The owner of this area says that we have to vacate it on the first of October. We don’t know what we will do. We will end up on the street like dogs. I can’t fight anymore. I can’t build another house. I am too old now. My grandson is a participant in the war. His friend, who is also from Shushi, lost his leg as a result of war and still hasn’t received a house from the government. If an injured person didn’t get a home, we just should stay silent and wait. But for how long? We have relatives in Russia, but we didn’t want to go to them. We want to live here, on our land. It’s hard. I don’t know.”

A shop where Gurgen papik lives

There are many stories like this in Artsakh. In addition to social problems, there is always fear of war. 

“The Republic of Artsakh and the Republic of Armenia both face short-term and long-term security issues, which are the pivotal challenges of the present day,” Artsakh President Arayik Harutyunyan said in his address on September 19, 2022. “We must honestly admit that the Armenian state is standing on the threshold of a new and catastrophic war, which could have no less serious consequences than the 44-day war.” 

[RELATED | Remembering and Honoring the Heroes of the 2020 Artsakh War]

Despite this imminent danger, the people of Artsakh continue to be optimistic. We have lived here for one-thousand years, and we will live here for another thousand, people say. There is no better place in the world than here. We just want peace.

A cemetery in Stepanakert (Photo: Marut Vanyan)

Marut Vanyan is a freelance journalist based in Stepanakert.


The Last Time

The last time,
I will ever go there.
The streets vibrant with people,
Children, parents, soldiers, tourists.
This was the last time I would go.
The family whose father was disabled after the 1994 war,
The suitcases full of clothes that we had given them,
The crisp 100 dollar bill that was a shock to them,
The tears of joy,
This was the last time we would go,
This was the last time we would see them.
The sky filled with lights,
Fireworks?
No—bombs! drones! missiles!
These are what the people of Artsakh, native Armenians on their native land, saw, endured.
These were their last sights,
This was the last time I saw them,
Dead or alive—
They were gone.

The land we all loved—gone! The people we all loved—gone! The restaurants we went to—gone! Everything I had seen was gone. How could a place change so drastically within a year? I wonder now, even years later, if that dear family I met in Shushi was able to escape with their lives, died defending their land or lived as subjugated citizens of a hostile neighboring country.

A year before the calamity, our plane landed in Yerevan, and we were greeted by a family friend, a well-known physician. “Parev! Parev!” After exchanging hellos in Armenian, we began a 30 minute journey from the small airport to our hotel. The sky was dark, but the streets were lit by shop signs and street lights. There was a positive and exciting vibe that I don’t recall the last time I was in Armenia. I wonder if it was because I was much younger then?

Arriving at the hotel was a relief. The hotel looked small from the outside, but it was massive on the inside. We had ambitious plans ahead of us, so a good night’s rest was crucial. But we were so anxious that we could barely sleep, given that we had heard and read so much about Artsakh, a disputed region which has been inhabited by Armenians for centuries and our destination the following day. The multi-hour car ride in the back of a black Mercedes sprinter was lengthy, but enjoyable. Oblivious to any danger, as an uneasy peace had persisted in the region for the last 25 years, we drove into what seemed like a giant divot. It actually was a normal road with sandbags built up high so that Azeri snipers would be unable to get a clean shot off, a danger we didn’t really consider as Armenia maintained control of the region and surrounding areas. 

After driving through mountain after mountain and past military post after military post, we finally arrived in Stepanakert, the capital of Artsakh. The excitement on the streets was something I had never seen before. It was shocking considering the city was being rebuilt after Azeri forces damaged it during a terrible six year conflict that ended in 1994, with the Armenian population winning control over the land they had inhabited for so long. 

The next day, we visited the heart of Artsakh—Shushi. After traveling up the mountain on a winding gravel road, we met a family who lived on top of the mountain. They had owned a vineyard for many years. “Tsavut danem” (Let me take your pain), they greeted us. It’s a common Armenian phrase of humbleness, affection and warmth. After talking to the family, we were saddened to hear that the father had experienced extreme physical and mental damage during the first Nagorno-Karabakh war. They were poor and couldn’t make much money as the head of the household was unable to get a job. My father asked if they needed anything. The mother explained in Armenian that they needed clothes for their daughter who was starting school. We took our two suitcases full of clothes that we had brought to give away and handed them to the family. They thanked us with tears rolling down their eyes. Knowing that they were struggling, my father had handed them a pair of crisp 100 dollar bills, something they’d never seen before. Tears streamed down their cheeks as they repeatedly expressed their gratitude, “Shnorhakalutyun.” We spent some time talking with them, and then we went on to tour the rest of the area. We hoped we could take their pain away in some small way. 

The author pictured third from the left with members of his family and Armenians from Shushi

I will never forget these moments. They opened my eyes to the struggles of people living in developing countries. These Armenian families have endured so much in a region where oppression has been constant since the time of the Ottoman Empire and before. Armenians have had to deal with corrupt political leaders influenced by historical Soviet policies. A country where 18 year old boys (some even younger) defend a border to protect their families from death or, in luckier circumstances, deportation. 

I also won’t forget the fate of those people, for it all changed only a year after our visit in August 2019. In September 2020, Azerbaijan attacked Artsakh, gaining control of Shushi (Artsakh’s strategically high location) and possibly planning to destroy it for good. Much of the capital and surrounding villages were bombed, children were killed in the shelling and families died not only by Azeri attacks but also from COVID-19, which raged through the community. Within six weeks, a generation of 18 to 20 year old boys, only a few years older than me, died on the battlefield, as Turkish suicide drones targeted them. And the world was silent.

The people I met and the sites we visited during my trip are now gone. The beauty and the villages are all gone. They have fallen into the hands of Azerbaijan—a country where killing Armenians is glorified and considered nothing more than a sport. A country where murdering an Armenian is celebrated and rewarded with national fame. A country where joining hands with Turkey to wipe out the Armenian race has been fantasized for ages. 

That one family in the mountains is gone—likely dead. My time on the mountain in Shushi is one of many moments that I should cherish more, for life is not guaranteed to anyone. I appreciate the life I enjoy in the US, where fear of invasion, deportation, loss of life, property and land is almost unimaginable. I have realized I live a life of luxury, where I don’t need to worry about death, losing my house or my next meal, and take so much for granted, such as my family, home, school, and even church (our ancient Armenian churches have been desecrated and, in many cases, destroyed by Azeris and Turks). That family in Shushi, on the other hand, appreciated every moment, as they knew that their happiness could be fleeting and their lives could be taken momentarily. In many ways, their example is one that I should embrace, as we all need to cherish moments, for you never know if you will ever get to experience them again.

Aram Dombalagian is a junior in high school and the grandson of Weekly contributor Knarik Meneshian, who along with her late husband Murad Meneshian, taught Aram the importance of being Armenian. He attends Armenian school and enjoys playing baseball and soccer. Aram was the 2021 16U soccer champion for the state of Illinois. He is a member of the AYF Chicago “Ararat” Chapter.