A Conference on Armenia and Azerbaijan at Columbia University Highlights Relations and Current Situation in the Region

Feb 22 2023

Dr. Michael Gunter Speaks as the Keynote Speaker on Wednesday, February 22nd, 2023 at Columbia University

NEW YORK CITY, NY, USA, February 22, 2023 /EINPresswire.com/ — Dr. Michael M. Gunter, a professor of political science at Tennessee Technological University in Cookeville, Tennessee will speak at “the Armenia and Azerbaijan through Peace and War” reception, today at Columbia University.

The registration and reception will start at 12:30 pm on Wednesday, February 22nd, 2023, with an opening speech by the organizers, and followed by a Khojaly video, a keynote speech by Dr. Gunter, and a brief speech by Dr. Ali Askerov. Audience will be able to ask questions following Dr. Askerov’s speech.

The location is Columbia University Faculty House, Garden Room-2, at 64 Morningside Drive. New York, NY, from 1 pm – 3:30 pm EST.
Please email [email protected] if you would like to participate in this event.

For more information on Dr. Michael M. Gunter: https://www.tntech.edu/directory/cas/sociology/mgunter.php

Dr. Gunter is also the Secretary-General of the EU Turkey Civic Commission (EUTCC) headquartered in Brussels. In the past he taught courses for many years during the summer at the International University in Vienna, as well as courses on Kurdish and Middle Eastern politics, among others, for the U.S. Government Areas Studies Program and U.S. Department of State Foreign Service Institute in Washington, D.C.

Dr. Gunter is the author of 10 critically praised scholarly books on the Kurdish question, and editor or co-editor of five more books on the Kurds, among others. He has also published numerous scholarly articles on the Kurds and many other issues in leading scholarly periodicals such as the Middle East Journal, Middle East Policy, Middle East Quarterly, Critique: Critical Middle Eastern Studies, Orient, Journal of Muslim Minority Affairs, Maghreb Review, American Journal of International Law, International Organization, World Affairs, Journal of International Affairs (Columbia University), Brown Journal of World Affairs, Columbia Journal of Transnational Law, Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law, Current History, Third World Quarterly, International Journal of Turkish Studies, Insight Turkey, Turkish Studies, Terrorism: An International Journal, and Arms Control, among numerous others. His most recent books are The Kurds: A Divided Nation in Search of a State, 3rd ed. (Princeton: Markus Wiener Publishers, 2019); Routledge Handbook on the Kurds (London & New York: Routledge, 2019); Historical Dictionary of the Kurds, 3rd ed. (Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield, 2018); Kurdish Issues: Essays in Honor of Robert W. Olson (Costa Mesa: Mazda Publishers, 2016); and Out of Nowhere: The Kurds of Syria in Peace and War, London: Hurst Publications, 2014.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Gunter

Melike Ayan
Mel Strategies
email us here

https://www.einnews.com/pr_news/618229794/a-conference-on-armenia-and-azerbaijan-at-columbia-university-highlights-relations-and-current-situation-in-the-region

Armenia: Another century, another Genocide?

Feb 22 2023
POLITICS
BY VICKEN CHETERIAN

35 years ago this week began the first Karabakh war: a devastating conflict between Armenia and Azerbaijan on the periphery of the old Soviet world. Though ending with an uneasy ceasefire in 1994, the conflict suddenly resumed in 2020, when Azerbaijan launched an offensive across the 1994 armistice line. Here, two scholars explain why it is vital for all to pay attention.


What happens when, a century after a genocide, the perpetrator returns to attack the victim? This is exactly what happened during the Second Karabakh War, when Azerbaijan attacked Armenia and Armenians in mountainous Karabakh in 2020. This is a unique event, with no parallels in history. It would be like if, in the year 2039, a neo-Nazi regime in Germany, allied with a neo-nationalist and Islamist regime in the Middle East, sent their most advanced aviation to attack and silence Israel for demanding justice for the Holocaust. Or if, in the year 2073, a neo-Khmer Rouge regime ordered the deportation of the population of Phnom Penh to the countryside for hard labor.

Of course, this is not the case of Israel or Cambodia. Germany has recognized its crime of genocide against European Jewry and pays yearly compensation to the State of Israel and Holocaust survivors. (And in fact, it is Israel that is arming Azerbaijan to attack Armenia—another nation that survived genocide—not to mention violating basic rights of Palestinians living under occupation.) In Cambodia, one can visit the infamous prison camp S-21 or Tuol Sleng turned into a memorial museum, and an international war crimes tribunal spent 16 years tracking down and prosecuting former Khmer Rouge officials.

In Turkey, on the contrary, the state and the population continue to celebrate the genocidaires Talaat, Enver, and Jemal, and others. The grandchildren of the Committee of Union and Progress are still in power. Indeed, it is not possible to believe that such an assault against the Armenians would have occurred without the direct participation of Turkey, or to imagine the emergence of today’s conflict between Armenia and Azerbaijan without the ongoing conflict between Armenia and Turkey. Most importantly, today’s war would have been impossible without the thick shadow of the first modern genocide a century ago, which remains unrecognized by the perpetrator state.


From the first day of Armenia’s independence in 1991, Turkey took a hostile position toward its erstwhile victim of genocide. As early as 1992, Turkey started a military collaboration with Azerbaijan, transforming its armed forces from an outdated post-Soviet military into a NATO-grade fighting machine. Over three decades, Turkey encouraged and supported the militaristic policy of Azerbaijan. Ultimately, it even participated directly in the Second Karabakh War on Azerbaijan’s behalf: in 2020, Turkey sent its generals and air force, US-made F-16s and Turkish-made Bayraktar TB2 attack drones, to actually assault Armenian positions.

Such a direct military intervention by a genocide perpetrator against a formerly victimized people is wholly unprecedented in modern international relations. The assault calls into question the legitimacy of our post-World War II international order, which did not even react when a perpetrator of genocide casually attacked its victims yet again. It also questions the legitimacy of our international news industry, which did not even notice—with dire consequences to all of us, not just Armenians.

Failing to see the legacy of the Armenia genocide—especially its continuous denial—today was not only the fault of the undefined “international community,” the influential media industry, or self-declared human rights organizations. The Turkish liberal intelligentsia was also to blame.

During the 2020 war and in its aftermath, Turkish intellectuals, dissidents, and oppositionists kept silent. This unbearable silence comes with a price: it casts doubt on the important progress made in Armenia-Turkey reconciliation since the mid-1990s. Turkish intellectuals had made slow, but regular progress in recognizing the importance of dealing with the past not only to bring justice to a wronged minority, the Armenians, but also as the cornerstone for the rule of law and democracy in Turkey itself. The struggle of Hrant Dink, the Turkish-Armenian journalist and editor of Agos, and his assassination in 2007 had awakened the conscience of the Turkish public, it seemed. Yet the silence of Turkish civil society during the Karabakh war in 2020 with the participation of the Turkish military has raised many questions about this normalization process, which will also radicalize Armenian positions. The struggle for recognition of the Armenian genocide, led by Armenian diaspora organizations, political parties, and grassroots movements, will continue. Yet the 2020 Karabakh War, direct Turkish military involvement, and the deafening silence about it within Turkey will eventually make the old struggle obsolete.

In 1965, for the first time after the 1915 genocide, Armenians around the world organized mass demonstrations directed toward Turkey and the “international community,” demanding genocide recognition and compensation. After 2020, it became evident that the Armenian struggle since 1965 was a pyrrhic victory. Clearly, that struggle, those partial recognitions, did not have any real effect when Turkey decided to turn its support for Azerbaijan into an open war. The struggle for the recognition of the 1915 genocide aimed to make “Never Again!” not merely a slogan—chanted during demonstrations on April 24, Armenian Genocide Remembrance Day—but a political reality that would shield the victim population from new threats, attacks, and “ethnic cleansing.” That, unfortunately, did not happen.

 

One might argue that today’s Karabakh conflict was caused by the Soviet system. This argument maintains that the administrative arrangements made by Joseph Stalin ensured that regions like Nagorno Karabakh would be impossible to manage after the hegemonic power of the Soviet center disintegrated. This is because the Soviets, despite their Marxist ideological references, attempted to solve the “national problem” by creating autonomous national territories. Unfortunately, the problem of Nagorno Karabakh simultaneously concerned both the Armenian and Azeri people. Since the region had an Armenian majority of 94 percent in the early 1920s, it was placed not within the Armenian Soviet Socialist Republic but within the Azerbaijani SSR. To underline its ethnic Armenian character, it was given a low level of autonomy. The Soviets imagined that with modernization, industrialization, urbanization, and mass education (in their terminology, advancing toward “socialism” and “communism”), Nagorno Karabakh’s ethnonational differences would lose importance.

But instead, the opposite happened. For decades, under the shroud of socialist friendship (the famous druzhba!), ethnic discrimination was the daily practice. Those systematic and routine acts of violence caused the mass mobilization of Karabakh Armenians in February 1988.

Until here, the developments of the Karabakh story remained within the context of the Soviet system and its contradictions. Yet, a week after the Karabakh Soviet passed a resolution demanding the unification of Nagorno Karabakh with neighboring Soviet Armenia, events took a turn. Karabakh began to echo another history, one outside the context of the Soviet Union.

On February 27, 1988—and for three days thereafter—anti-Armenian pogroms exploded in the Azerbaijani industrial town of Sumgait. The mass violence unleashed in Sumgait and the chain of anti-Armenian pogroms that continued in Kirovabad (now Ganja) and Baku strongly connected back to the Armenian-Azerbaijani conflict of 1918–1920, and the thick shadow of the unresolved history of the Armenian genocide.


For many decades, most journalists and scholars who researched and wrote about the Karabakh conflict made little or no reference at all to the impact of the 1915 genocide, and its denial, on the genesis of the Armenia-Azerbaijan conflict. Only a few understood how deep the connection was between the 1988 pogroms in Sumgait, Kirovabad, Baku, and elsewhere and the 1915 deportations and massacres executed by Turkey’s Committee of Union and Progress during World War I. This connection—going back to the formation of the Republic of Azerbaijan in 1918—was profound and ideological, but it was also mutating.

For long years I opposed those who argued that the contemporary Armenian-Azerbaijani conflict was rooted in the history of the Armenian genocide. The similarities were only on the level of symbols, I thought, while there were huge differences in context and institutional frameworks: the Armenian-Azerbaijani conflict emerged from contradictory Soviet policies, and within the context of the unexpected collapse of the Soviet state and the struggle to define political community (self-determination) and boundaries of the state (territorial integrity).

BROWSE
BY JULIA ELYACHAR

But even then, unlike my international colleagues writing about the conflict between Armenia and Azerbaijan, I had already documented how Azerbaijani nationalists had borrowed the most extreme form of denialism and the Unionist ideological baggage that came with it.1 I realized that the memory of past mass atrocities is kept not only by the victimized group but also, in a deformed way, by the perpetrators and hegemonic forces associated with them. Mass violence is an exchange between two groups: dominant and dominated. When dominated groups mobilize to fight for their liberation, hegemonic forces through symbolic acts of violence remind them of past massacres. The message is clear: If you dare to change the status quo, we will unleash mass violence against you once again! This was the symbolic message in Sumgait back in 1988, when pogroms were orchestrated in Azerbaijan merely a week after Karabakh Armenians voted on a motion demanding to be freed from Soviet Azerbaijan and united with neighboring Soviet Armenia.

Later, developments became more alarming. I started to see a closer overlap between the 1915 genocide and the Karabakh conflict. Surprisingly, it was not the Armenian political leadership that was insisting on continuities between those two events, but that of Azerbaijan. For Turkey, the link was always there, from day one of independent Armenia. The trend started in the late 1990s under Azerbaijani president Heydar Aliyev but took a very extreme form under his son and successor, Ilham Aliyev. A new ideology was taking shape where Armenians were the perfect others of the Azerbaijani nation, a national self-definition based on the negative other.2 Turkish sociologist Ceylan Tokluoglu writes: “Azerbaijanis (re)construct Armenian identity by defining the Armenians, not themselves, as a ‘unique community.’ In this context, they stereotype the Armenians. They also attribute a ‘special mission’ to them, which is to occupy the lands of other nations.”

In this new state-sponsored narrative of Azerbaijan, not only did the Armenian genocide not happen, but also the Armenians became guilty: the perpetrators of a series of anti-Azerbaijani genocides.

A second development was taking place, parallel to the Karabakh conflict. Since the early 1990s, Turkey had joined in, supporting Azerbaijan and antagonizing Armenia. Even before Armenian forces overran and occupied the Kelbajar district of Azerbaijan (a province situated between Karabakh and Armenia), Turkey refused to normalize its relations with Armenia, establish diplomatic relations, or open its border. Yet after the failure of “football diplomacy” and the “Zurich protocols” in 2009, Turkey became much more menacing.

By the centennial of the 1915 genocide, it was evident that Turkey wanted Armenia to abandon its international struggle for genocide recognition and give up any claims to compensation for the extermination of the Ottoman Armenians and plundering their properties. Turkey also wanted the Karabakh conflict to be resolved against Armenia and in favor of Azerbaijan. Such a geopolitical objective had been in Turkish policy starting in 1993. What was new (after the failure of Zurich protocols) was the emergence of an intense military collaboration between Turkey and Azerbaijan. This made the risk of a new war much higher.

Here, a second and quite surprising link between the 1915 genocide and the Armenia-Azerbaijan conflict came to light. The memory of genocide in a deformed manner was strongly present in Azerbaijani discourse. On the one hand, Azerbaijani officials became the most vehement deniers of the Armenian genocide. On the other hand, they made the memory of this genocide ever present in their propaganda. The victimhood of the Armenians was denied, and instead they became perpetrators of a series of genocidal events. Azerbaijan passed a presidential decree in 1998 that declared March 31 a “Day of Genocide of Azerbaijanis.” The text referred not to any event but to a long history of two centuries, from the Treaty of Gulistan (1813) between Tsarist Russia and Qajar Persia until the contemporary Karabakh conflict, in which Azeris were represented as victims of ahistoric and continuous Armenian mass violence. This was followed by official commemorations of the Khojaly massacre in 1992 as a “genocide” and the construction of several museums in Azerbaijan to create a tradition of Azerbaijani victimhood.3

Those evolutions in Azerbaijan and in Turkey led me to change my analysis.4 With Turkey supporting Azerbaijan, the militaristic positions in Baku moved to the extreme.

 

The Second Karabakh War was not possible without long-term Turkish participation: encouraging Azerbaijani militarism as well as threatening Armenia and pushing it into the corner. Turkey took direct part in the war by sending its generals, air force, and elite troops. At the end, when Ilham Aliyev organized his “Victory Parade” in Baku, he invited the Turkish president, Recep Tayyip Erdogan, to celebrate their shared victory against Armenia and Armenians. There, Erdogan openly referred to the legacy of the 1915 genocide by mentioning Enver and his brother Nuri, the leader of the “Army of Islam.”

Post-Soviet ethno-territorial conflicts are very complicated. Indeed, since these conflicts began erupting after the collapse of the Soviet Union, none has found a solution: not in Georgia (South Ossetia or Abkhazia) or in Moldova (the Transdniestria conflict).5 The same may be true of the Karabakh conflict, which is shadowed by the Soviet Union but also by another unresolved conflict, inherited from the period of the Ottoman Empire: the 1915 extermination of Armenians and the continuous denial of the crime. With such a history, the Karabakh conflict seems impossible to settle.

BROWSE
BY CHRISTINE PHILLIOU

But worse may still come. Today, there can be no more doubt that not only the Karabakh Armenians but indeed, all Armenians across the Caucasus are existentially threatened by the Azerbaijani-Turkish alliance. Moreover, today’s threat is rooted in the continuous legacy of a genocide that is not only denied but also celebrated.

 

This article was commissioned by Joanne Randa Nucho. 

  1. See Vicken Cheterian, War and Peace in the Caucasus, Russia’s Troubled Frontier (Hurst, 2009), chaps. 3 and 6. 
  2. Ceylan Tokluoglu, “The Political Discourse of the Azerbaijani Elite on Nagorno-Karabakh Conflict (1991-2009),” Europe-Asia Studies, vol. 63, no. 7 (2011), p. 1225. 
  3. Vicken Cheterian, “The Uses and Abuses of History: Genocide and the Making of the Karabakh Conflict,”  Europe-Asia Studies, vol. 70, no. 6 (2018), especially pp. 895–98. 
  4. See Vicken Cheterian, Open Wounds, Armenians, Turks, and a Century of Genocide (Hurst, 2015), chap. 12. 
  5. The conflict in Chechnya, which led to two bloody wars between Russian troops and Chechen fighters, is the only exception, achieved at the price of imposing a pro-Russian dictatorship led by the Kadyrov family in Chechnya. 
https://www.publicbooks.org/armenia-another-century-another-genocide/

Hotson’s Armenian church voted America’s most significant building of 2022

Feb 22 2023
Saint Sarkis Armenian Church in Texas, designed by New York architect David Hotson, has been selected as America’s building of last year in an online poll.

The survey was carried out among members of World-Architects, a network of US designers and building professionals. They were presented with a list of 40 projects and asked to choose which was the “most significant” building completed in the US last year.

The church in Carrollton, in the Dallas–Fort Worth conurbation, was chosen by 64% of the total votes cast. 

The church’s west façade appears to be covered in a design based on the Armenian cross

The design was based on the archetypal Church of Saint Hripsime close to the Armenian capital of Yerevan, which was completed in 618 AD, but updated with the help of modern digital design and production technologies.

Printed façade

One of the most striking details in Hotson’s design is the church’s west façade, which is covered by high-resolution printing carried out in Italy in collaboration with Fiandre Architectural Surfaces.

When the visitor is close enough, the image resolves to a design depicting natural objects …

At first sight this forms a traditional Armenian cross, which on closer inspection is composed of interwoven geometric patterns derived from the Armenian artistic tradition.

On still closer inspection, the pattern dissolves into a grid of tiny pixels, inspired by the Armenian symbol for infinity. Each unique pattern symbolises an individual who died in the genocide.

The church was consecrated on 23 April, and the first service was celebrated the following day, which is dedicated to the memory of the victims of the genocide.

No visible services

The interior of the church was stripped of lighting fixtures and has no visible mechanical services, which the architect says lends it an ethereal quality.

… which then resolves into individual unique pixels representing victims of the 1915 Armenian genocide

A remote plant room silently introduces conditioned air at low velocity through vents under the pews.

Hotson commented: “This award is shared with everyone involved in the design and construction of this building, including the members of the congregation and the international Armenian diaspora for whom this building has a special meaning.

“High on the list of invaluable collaborators was the team at Fiandre who have contributed an extraordinary level of innovation and an impeccable level of execution that is central to the aesthetic, emotional and experiential success of this special project.”

TIME: How Azerbaijan Weaponized Environmentalism to Justify Ethnic Cleansing

 TIME 
Feb 22 2023
IDEAS

 

FEBRUARY 22, 2023 12:07 PM EST
Maghakyan is a visiting scholar at Tufts University and a Ph.D. student in Heritage Crime at Cranfield University. He writes and speaks on post-Soviet memory politics and cultural erasure, and facilitates global conversations on protecting Armenian heritage

Blocking the only highway that connects 120,000 people of Nagorno-Karabakh with the outside world, a fur coat-wearing woman held a dove in one hand and a megaphone in the other as she yelled that the besieged region “belongs to Azerbaijan.” But instead of flying once released, the strangled dove dropped dead. This was meant to resemble an environmental demonstration.

Masqueraded as activists protesting the environmental impacts of ore mining operations, rotating affiliates of the authoritarian regime of Azerbaijan have blockaded the Armenian-populated mountainous region of Nagorno-Karabakh since December 12. This has left the disputed region, which is still recovering from the 2020 war launched by Azerbaijan, in the cold and on the brink of starvation.

The mining operations, along with much of Nagorno-Karabakh’s economy, have since halted, but the illegal blockade that violates the 2020 ceasefire has not. On Feb. 22 the International Court of Justice ordered Azerbaijan to end the blockade. But without an immediate enforcement mechanism, Azerbaijan may try to buy some extra time. Food and fuel are in such low supply in Nagorno-Karabakh that the local authorities now distribute coupons to ratio key groceries. Only vehicles belonging to Russian peacekeepers and the Red Cross have been allowed through, bringing in small quantities of vital supplies for the most vulnerable. But, according to Amnesty International, that’s not enough. On Feb. 9 the human rights watchdog reported that “access to healthcare has become the most pressing issue in the blockaded region”—a cardiologist sees only five or six patients per month, down from the typical 30 to 40, due to insufficient stent supply.

Ilham Aliyev, Azerbaijan’s dynastic president—whose 20-year recipe to remain in power has consisted of cultivating anti-Armenian hatred and weaponizing Azerbaijanis’ trauma of losing the first Nagorno-Karabakh war in the 1990s—makes no secret of the blockade’s ultimate goal. Armenians of Nagorno-Karabakh are free to leave: “the road [to Armenia] is open,” he says, suggesting ethnic cleansing as the resolution. It’s not the first time that his regime blends ethnic cleansing with environmentalism: Azerbaijan celebrated the 2020 war victory against Armenians with a stamp of a biohazard remediator fumigating Nagorno-Karabakh.

At the ICJ on January 30 Azerbaijan’s lawyers argued that there is no blockade and that the protesters are engaged in grassroots environmental demonstrations. Never mind that oil-rich Azerbaijan—one of the most repressive regimes according to Freedom House, and home to “the ecologically most devastated area in the world,” including a city dubbed “an ecological Armageddon”—doesn’t tolerate public protest. To science-wash the blockade, as a prominent academic exposed last month, Azerbaijan sought out professors abroad to rubber stamp the ongoing “eco-protest” in media outlets.

This weaponization of environmentalism sets a dangerous precedent for other dictatorships to hijack vital causes.

A man holds fruit in an empty market in Stepanakert, the capital of Nagorno-Karabakh, on December 23, 2022.

 

Davit Ghahramanyan—AFP/Getty Images

Scholars have diagnosed such bad-faith goodwill as “sharp power,” a term proposed in 2017 by the National Endowment for Democracy to describe authoritarian states’ efforts to influence the world’s perception of their actions through manipulation and distraction. While the term is new, the phenomenon is not. Exploiting fragile Western institutions and using popular causes is an ongoing authoritarian practice. In environmentalism, Azerbaijan has found a convenient, universal cause. Since losing the first Nagorno-Karabakh war to Armenians in the 1990s, it has long claimed “ecocide” in territories Armenians controlled until the second war in 2020.

But neither private nor public criticism has stopped Azerbaijan from weaponizing environmental movements. Even now, as international bodies and Western governments condemn the blockade, Azerbaijan doubles down on its messaging. It recently announced a “historic” environmental legal action against Armenia under the Bern convention over forest loss and other delinquency in the areas Armenians controlled until 2020. The announcement explicitly justified the blockade, stating that “these protests were not orchestrated by the Government of Azerbaijan.” Commenting on this move, a forest watchdog noted that satellites tell a different story: “between roughly 2000 and 2020, the region had gained more tree cover than it lost.”

More recent forest loss is connected with Azerbaijan’s activities, such as its use of white phosphorus against Armenian forces in 2020, as analyzed by the Atlantic Council’s Digital Forensic Research Lab, along with the ongoing “victory road” construction. The 63-mile highway follows the military attack route of Azerbaijan’s capture of a key city in late 2020, during which the entire south of Nagorno-Karabakh was ethnically cleansed of Armenians. As a U.N. environmental assessment report requested by Azerbaijan notes, this construction “is also having a significant impact on forest cover.” Satellites show oversized swaths of greenery gone for good.

And as Caucasus Heritage Watch’s satellite reports show, the “victory road” and another highway construction are often accompanied with the flattening of Armenian villages and sacred sites, despite the IJC’s December 2021 provisional order to the contrary. Most ironically, there is also ongoing deforestation caused by the blockade: Nagorno-Karabakh, whose gas supply, electricity, and imported fuel are under Azerbaijan’s siege, is utilizing firewood to survive the winter.

Before the ICJ’s Feb. 22 decision, President Aliyev bragged that nothing would stop his efforts in the Lachin corridor, and he had reason to believe so. The European Union is repeatedly courting him as a “reliable partner” in substituting Russian gas supplies, and the U.S. has continued to waive Section 907 sanctions, a U.S. law meant to stop Azerbaijan’s aggression against Armenians. “No one can influence us. There may be some phone calls and some statements, but we do not need to pay attention. We take those phone calls simply out of political courtesy,” he states, “but this will not change our position.”

The remarks primarily target the U.S. and France. During the U.N. Security Council hearing in December and in subsequent statements, both countries, among others, called on Azerbaijan to end the blockade. Russia—the third mediator of the Armenian-Azerbaijani conflict along with the U.S. and France—has been largely silent on the situation.

Read More: History Suggests This Winter Could Be Dangerous for Armenians

There is something brazenly cynical about a repressive petro-aggressor weaponizing environmentalism in 2023. Not only does it make a mockery of the existential crisis we face as a species, it serves to further corrode Azerbaijan’s civil society. By undermining the credibility of what is likely the most important cause in the world, Aliyev is setting an example for fellow dictators to pursue “sharp power.” He sends a message that there is no cause too sacred to exploit and no lie too absurd to pronounce if it allows the leader to stay in power.

When Aliyev’s activists transported doves to the blockade, the stunt was in line with a new tradition in Azerbaijan that reimagines the birds as victory symbols of war. But instead, the strangled dove symbolized the blockade’s methodology: choke the besieged people of Nagorno-Karabakh until they have no choice but to flee—an ethnic cleansing strategy of strangle-and-release, sugar-coated as environmentalism.

Saint Sarkis Armenian Church Named ‘Top American Architectural Work’ by International Group of Architects, Engineers

Christianity Daily
Feb 22 2023

An international committee of architects and engineers has selected an Armenian Orthodox church in Texas as the best building in the United States. The church was reportedly selected with its architectural design.

A report from the Christian Post stated that in 2022, World-Architects selected Saint Sarkis Armenian Church, located north of Dallas, as the best architectural work in the United States. World-Architects is an online publisher with national and regional platforms representing architects, architectural photographers, engineers, interior designers, landscape architects, lighting designers, and manufacturers from over 50 countries. 

The church grounds encompass more than 4.5 acres and are home to three distinct buildings: the main church building and sanctuary, a gymnasium and youth center, and a hall that houses offices, classes, and a kitchen.

The architecture of what is widely regarded as the world’s first Christian nation, Armenia, which converted to Christianity in the early third century, is reflected in the sanctuary building, designed by architect David Hotson and harkens back to that nation’s architecture.

According to World Architects, the Church of Saint Sarkis in Carrollton, Texas, is patterned after the ancient church of Saint Hripsime, which still stands 8,000 miles to the east near the old seat of the Armenian Apostolic Church in Etchmiadzin, within the modern Republic of Armenia.

The Armenian homeland, located in the South Caucasus, once encompassed Mount Ararat, the tallest mountain in the Middle East, where Noah’s ark is thought to have rested after the biblical flood. In 301 A.D., the Kingdom of Armenia became the world’s first nation to convert to Christianity, sixty years before Emperor Constantine made Christianity the Roman Empire’s official religion.

In this seismically active location, the Church of Saint Hripsime has sheltered Armenian congregations for fourteen centuries through the rise and fall of the Byzantine, Greek, Ottoman, Persian, Roman, Russian, and Soviet Empires. It symbolizes the resilience and continuation of the Armenian people’s language, religion, and traditions. Remembering the faraway Armenian homeland from which the ancestors of many congregation members were ruthlessly driven during the Armenian genocide in 1915, the Saint Sarkis church faces west and overlooks the expansive Texas horizon.

Also Read: Benedictines of Mary in Kansas City Build a Church Through Bitcoin Donations

As per St. Sarkis Armenian Orthodox Church, St. Sarkis is the church’s namesake and was a fourth-century Roman soldier persecuted for his Christian faith who sought safety in Armenia. He was from a settlement in the Cappadocian lowlands and was a courageous and devoted soldier in the army of the Christian Emperor Constantine.  When Julian the Apostate became emperor in the year 361 A.D. and began persecuting Christians, however, Sarkis and his son Mardiros sought shelter under the protection of King Tiran of Armenia. From there, he joined the Persian army, where he and his son converted many soldiers to Christianity.

However, Persia’s religious officials quickly learned about Sarkis and attempted to force him and his kid to worship their gods. Due to his refusal to worship pagan idols, the spiritual authority of Persia executed him and his wife. Fourteen of his loyal soldiers were resolved to bury the general’s remains, even at considerable risk. They were committed because of their religion. In addition, St. Sarkis, his son, and the faithful warriors are honored annually by the Armenian church on the third Saturday before the beginning of Lent.

The International Court of Justice rejects Azerbaijan’s claim against Armenia

Save

Share

 20:25, 22 February 2023

YEREVAN, FEBRUARY 22, ARMENPRESS. The International Court of Justice rejected Azerbaijan’s request to indicate provisional measures against Armenia, ARMENPRESS reports, the decision was published on February 22.

The decision notes that the Court does not consider that the Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination plausibly imposes any obligation on Armenia to take measures to enable Azerbaijan to undertake demining or to cease and desist from planting landmines. Azerbaijan has not placed before the Court evidence indicating that Armenia’s alleged conduct with respect to landmines has ‘the purpose or effect of nullifying or impairing the recognition, enjoyment or exercise, on an equal footing’, of rights of persons of Azerbaijani national or ethnic origin.”

The Court concludes from the foregoing that the conditions for the indication of provisional measures under Article 41 of the Statute are not met.

AW: Becoming a More Welcoming Church

Sts. Vartanantz Armenian Apostolic Church of New Jersey, April 17, 2022

While we struggle with the anxiety of our oppressed brethren in Artsakh, there are also a number of issues pertaining to the continued vibrancy of the diaspora. The “diaspora” is a singular convenient term for a scattered and diverse segment of the Armenian nation. Scattered in the sense that our communities populate all corners of the world and diverse in that each has taken on some elements of their host nation. Still, there are enough common denominators to sustain a universal identity regardless of where you reside. Diasporan communities are always under the threat of assimilation which occurs when the host country culture becomes a dominant influence, and ethnic/religious culture is subordinated. Assimilation has been impacting the Armenian community in the United States for decades. The sociological evidence is clear, but we have masked it with an influx of Armenian immigrants who are deeply committed to our culture. Professionals who study this will call it a natural phenomenon, but for the Armenian community, it is painful and worthy of resistance. This usually takes the form of identity building within a family starting in their home life and continuing in institutions such as the Armenian church. There are certainly other vehicles, but most observers would agree that the church, as a spiritual and cultural institution, is one of the most dominant and critical factors in preserving our national identity. The presence of the Republic of Armenia has also contributed to identity building for the diaspora as visitations and repatriation have occurred. The focus of this column will be on how the church can improve its role with a more welcoming approach to our scattered brethren.

I believe that the future of the diaspora is linked to a vibrant strong Armenian church. It is the only institution that brings together the two elements vital to our identity: our faith and our ethnicity. This sacred responsibility has remained clear in the eyes of the Armenian people for centuries and has continued in the post-genocide diaspora. It is because of this indispensable role that we must take decisive action to sustain a leadership position. For the first two generations in the American diaspora, the church was able to retain its traditional position with minimal change. The first generation straddled the line between historic Armenia and the establishment of the diaspora. They were obviously fluent in our native tongue, understood our customs, including the church, and for the most part, married other Armenians. This created an opportunity to essentially transfer the church to the new world and maintain its role with limited disruption. The first generation born in this country (my parents’ generation) continued and expanded this role. They were “Americanized” but had the language skills and cultural identity from their parents. Families were more intact, and life had fewer distractions. The church introduced some changes but was still able to maintain a leadership role without dramatic change. 

The first signs of distress occurred with my generation—the so-called baby boomers. The attrition of my peers in the church in my youth when considering today’s participation is significant. A 40- to 50-percent retention rate might be generous. One would think that the impact of this from the 1960s to the 1980s would have been motivation to understand cause and effect, but it wasn’t. Yes, there was change, of course, but not nearly enough to keep pace with the secularization advancing in our society and the intermarriage of the next generation. For example, a seminary in the United States began in the early sixties to supply American born and educated clergy to churches in America. This was the contribution of a man of unique vision, Archbishop Tiran Nersoyan. One of the main reasons for limited strategic action has to do with how we measure communal success. We usually view our communities and parishes by the numbers—membership or the level of participation in church organizations. During the critical period from the 70s to the 90s, our communities replenished the attrition of others with waves of immigration from the Middle East and the homeland. The demographic changes were evident, and in some cases, the decline of Sunday and Armenian school began. But as long as people were participating, the motivation for change was limited. In fact, the demographic changes reduced the need for change. Thousands simply walked away from the Mother Church. Well, the migrations have slowed, and our decline “by the numbers” has continued. The truth is there are fewer participants in Badarak attendance, schools and organizations across the board.

Thankfully, there are exceptions where leadership and unique demographics have carved out an oasis. Some of our leaders have rationalized this decline in population shifts in our traditional communities and the emergence of newer communities. There is some truth to this, but the assimilation impact in the larger communities is significant and the newer communities have a smaller resource base. An Armenian church will never close for financial causes. Parishes decline because of the absence of the faithful, yet we seem to worry more about money than participants. If we continue to deny the facts, then we are simply shortening the runway for recovery.

The urgent need for change has been thwarted by the superficial assessment of participants and the fear that change will result in the loss of our identity. Actually, the reverse is true. For a diaspora community to avoid aligning with succeeding generations is almost a guarantee for irrelevance and decline. Our approach to date has been essentially binary; either participants connect with what we offer, or they quietly fade into an assimilated state. The answer lies in the type of change proposed. Our theology and protocols are not the problem. Many Armenians and non-Armenians do not connect with our traditions and etiquettes and therefore find the church difficult to relate to. This goes beyond the language debate and how we greet people when we see new faces. 

I was in church this past week and read in the weekly bulletin that there were three family groups requesting hokehankist (requiem) prayers for departed family members. Increasingly in our church, large family groups for hokehankist are attended by members who are there out of respect but are not currently communicants of the church. They may have attended in their youth but have either drifted or intermarried and remain aloof from the church. This is an excellent example to illustrate my point. One of the families was sitting near me, and I noticed they were struggling with following along. I pointed out where in the Badarak book we were, careful not to embarrass them in any way. They didn’t understand standing and sitting, when to cross yourself, bowing to God at designated times or any of the communion protocol. I empathized with them as this must have been an awkward experience. The Kiss of Peace is a beautiful Christian exchange, but it can be intimidating if not understood. We all know people who will seat themselves between family members for fear that they will not know the response to the “Vokhchouyn” greeter. 

When we speak about being a welcoming church, it should be viewed not only in the warmth of our personalities, but rather in how participants can connect with the worship service and, for that matter, the history, protocols and functions of our church. We have no formal programs to ensure this type of integration. Of course, some churches have video page turners and Badarak video displays, but it is not universal or mandated. The problem runs along the deep lines of inherent knowledge and unintentional ignorance. How can we expect to engage succeeding generations when inherent knowledge is declining and unintentional ignorance is increasing? Rather than shun those who are on the periphery as “gorsehvatz” (lost), we must display our empathy by doing something formal and sustainable to replace discomfort with empowering knowledge. It starts with the worship experience and continues with having enough functional knowledge to become contributing members. I recall a respected member of the church speaking at a National Assembly warning about the increase of “functionally illiterate” participants. How can we expect to build a commitment to a church that does little to close the knowledge gap? Compounding the challenge are those who choose to walk away, which has become almost epidemic. This can be prevented.

It is a far different world than that of my grandparents or parents. As a people in the diaspora, we must always be mindful that the retention of one’s faith and heritage is a choice. We seek to influence that choice with organizations, programs and peer groups. It is a choice that individuals will make at some point in their life. The impact of secularism, material distraction and self-interest has dominated our society particularly in the last 50 years. The church can no longer wait for the people to come to that institution. We are competing with shallow but powerful forces which actually illustrate the importance of the church in our lives. In a world that tries to teach us that we alone can do anything, it is only the church that teaches us that all things are possible through Our Savior Jesus Christ. This message taught through the traditions of the Armenian church is powerful but limited if the church declines. The burden on the church has become more important as the family unit, the foundation of life, struggles. Our church in America need not worry about losing the beauty of our faith. We should focus on gathering the wandering sheep of the diaspora with mechanisms that enable the joy of our church with knowledge, comfort and identity. We must be willing to engage individuals with different methods so that they will experience the beauty of our church. From simple Badarak etiquette packages to formal educational programs for Armenian and non-Armenian participants, we must begin to assume the absence of knowledge. We must welcome all with the opportunity to function equally. It is natural but unfortunate that our offerings are geared toward those who participate and have identity. Those of us on the inside need to find the joy in reaching out to those on the outside. In this way, the church will prosper, and the Good News will reach new heights.

Columnist
Stepan was raised in the Armenian community of Indian Orchard, MA at the St. Gregory Parish. A former member of the AYF Central Executive and the Eastern Prelacy Executive Council, he also served many years as a delegate to the Eastern Diocesan Assembly. Currently , he serves as a member of the board and executive committee of the National Association for Armenian Studies and Research (NAASR). He also serves on the board of the Armenian Heritage Foundation. Stepan is a retired executive in the computer storage industry and resides in the Boston area with his wife Susan. He has spent many years as a volunteer teacher of Armenian history and contemporary issues to the young generation and adults at schools, camps and churches. His interests include the Armenian diaspora, Armenia, sports and reading.


Serena Williams’ Husband Alexis Ohanian Discloses Why He Got Three Armenian Carpets For Daughter Olympia

Feb 22 2023

Ohanian recently recalled the horrific incident and revealed how he’s getting the carpets to put them in his farmhouse in Jupiter, Florida.

The Naghash Ensemble announces New York debut

Naghash Ensemble

After years of successfully touring Europe, Armenia’s critically-acclaimed Naghash Ensemble will debut in New York at Zankel Hall at Carnegie Hall on March 11, 2023, as part of its North American tour. The performance, entitled “Songs of Exile,” is the 38th Musical Armenia concert presented by the Eastern Prelacy of the Armenian Apostolic Church. Based in Yerevan and led by Armenian-American composer John Hodian, the Naghash Ensemble combines the earthy spirituality of Armenian folk song, new classical music and contemporary post-minimalism with the energy of rock and jazz. Three brilliant female vocalists and some of Armenia’s finest instrumentalists on duduk, oud, dhol and piano play captivating new music based on sacred texts by Mkrtich Naghash, a medieval Armenian mystic poet and priest.

Sacred sounds inspire Armenia’s most intriguing new music

American-Armenian composer John Hodian, the creator and composer of the Naghash Ensemble, was raised in Philadelphia. “I grew up in a very Armenian household,” Hodian shared in a conversation with Weekly contributor Dalita Getzoyan. “Every recording my father owned was Armenian.” Although he plays piano, he noted that he identifies most as a composer. Hodian holds a master’s degree in both composition and conducting. His musical influences are highly varied, including Bach counterpoint, polyphonic medieval vocal music, contemporary classical music such as Steve Reich and Phillip Glass (who produced his first CD), Motown and funk, and of course, Armenian. Hodian said, “It’s got as much Prince as it does Komitas.” For 15 years, Hodian worked as a composer for film and television, eventually leaving to focus on his own goals and aspirations, though it took him some time to figure out exactly what those were.

In 2005, Hodian went to Yerevan with support from Nareg Hartounian, who had just created the Naregatsi Art Institute. He was able to work with many young Armenian composers, developed a recording studio, and taught classes in contemporary film scoring, electronic music and contemporary composition techniques. At the same time, he had just started exploring many of the ancient monasteries and sacred spaces in the country of his ancestors. He was alone at Garni temple when he suddenly heard something he describes as “the most beautiful sound I’ve ever heard.” It turned out to be soprano Hasmik Baghdasaryan, Armenia’s leading performer of medieval spiritual music.

“The sound of that voice in that temple was mesmerizing, and it remained in my mind for days after,” said Hodian. “As a composer, I wanted to steal it and make it my own. Stravinsky said ‘Bad composers borrow, good composers steal.’ I was determined to write something that would use this sound in a new way. When you borrow, it’s not really yours. But when you steal, it is yours. It becomes part of your own DNA, and you’re able to really do something with it that’s never been done. But you have to really encapsulate it.” Although Hodian is able to describe how he combines all the musical styles that have influenced his compositions, he noted that the incorporation of these styles is not conscious while he is creating. He intuitively trusts that he embodies all his musical influences. 

Though he knew what the music would sound like, Hodian spent several years looking for just the right text to set to music until he finally came across a short fragment of a poem by a little-known Armenian medieval priest named Mkrtich Naghash. The text described in terrifying detail the plight of people forced to live in exile. “Those words leapt off the page and into my soul,” Hodian said. “I knew I had found my text.” He had to track down the texts. The original manuscripts were lost, but there are versions by later copyists. With the help of several Armenian scholars and the Mekhitarists of San Lazzaro degli Armeni in Venice, Italy, Hodian was able to unearth all the remaining 16 poems. 

In setting these texts to music, Hodian followed his intuition. “The music is the natural product of someone who was raised listening to Armenian music in the home, studied European classical music in his youth, particularly medieval polyphonic vocal music and certain contemporary minimalist composers,” he said. “Plus, I was constantly surrounded by contemporary popular music in all its forms.” Subconsciously combining all these influences, the music he created has been described as “the sound of Ancient Armenia reinvented for the 21st century” by Armenia’s most renowned composer Tigran Mansurian.

To perform these works, Hodian gathered some of Armenia’s finest local musicians on oud, duduk and dhol, along with three highly-regarded Armenian female singers, including Baghdasaryan, his original inspiration. The group launched its first European tour in 2014 and has been touring internationally ever since. Typically, the ensemble’s audiences are not Armenian. They attract many classical and world musicians.

The Naghash Ensemble is Baghdasaryan (soprano), Tatevik Movsesyan (soprano), Arpine Ter-Petrosyan (alto), Harutyun Chkolyan (duduk), Aramayis Nikoghosyan (oud), Tigran  Hovhannisyan (dhol) and Hodian (piano/composer).

Praise for the Naghash Ensemble:

“The sounds of Ancient Armenia reimagined for the 21st century.” — Tigran Mansurian
“A moment of grace and meditation”— Rolling Stone
“An enchanting elixir of sounds based on new Armenian folk and centuries-old poetry” — KEXP
“A stunning discovery.”  — Bayerischer Rundfunk
“Part folk music, part classical, and profoundly moving. Unmistakably Armenian, but out of this world” – Armenisch-Deutsche Korrespondenz 

Tickets for the March 11 performance at Carnegie Hall are available online.

The ensemble’s other North American dates include:

3/02/23 • UCLA, Schoenberg Hall • Los Angeles, CA
3/03/23 • Mountain View Center for the Performing Arts • Mountain View, CA
3/04/23 • Lone Tree Arts Center • Lone Tree, CO
3/05/23 • The Lincoln Center • Fort Collins, CO
3/09/23 • University of Michigan • Ann Arbor, MI
3/10/23 • St. John Armenian Church • Southfield, MI
3/11/23 • Zankel Hall at Carnegie Hall • New York, NY
3/13/23 • Salle Bourgie • Montréal, Canada
3/15/23 • Kennedy Center, Millennium Stage • Washington, DC
3/17/23 • Chatter • Albuquerque, NM
3/18/23 • San Miguel Chapel • Santa Fe, NM




Rep. Grace Meng helps evacuate Akopyans from blockaded Artsakh

Lusine and Andranik reunite with Garegin at John F. Kennedy International Airport

Andranik Akopyan, a first-generation Armenian from Queens, New York, turned three years old under blockade in Artsakh. 

The toddler was happy to celebrate his birthday with relatives in Stepanakert. But his mother Lusine, with whom he had been in the capital of Artsakh for weeks, felt the severity of their reality. 

“The entire world was celebrating the New Year, and Artsakh was stuck in the cold,” Lusine shared in an exclusive interview with the Weekly. “It was terrible. We dressed warmly and sat at home, like everyone else.”  

Lusine and her son traveled to Artsakh on December 4, 2022 to see her father’s gravestone and visit their relatives for the holidays. Her husband Garegin planned to join them soon to celebrate their son’s birthday as a family. 

However, on December 12, Azerbaijani activists, with the support of their government, shut down the Lachin Corridor, the sole route connecting Artsakh with Armenia and the rest of the world. The Akopyans, along with the 120,000 residents of Artsakh, were trapped. They had little food or medicine, as the usual daily import of 400 tons of basic supplies from Armenia came to a halt. They also had no means of heating their home, due to repeated obstructions to the gas and electricity supply and internet connection, which Artsakh authorities blame on Azerbaijan. 

Lusine could not speak to her husband every day because of the disrupted internet access. Garegin would set alarms throughout the night and try to call them in case the internet connection was restored. 

“It is heroic to live in Artsakh under those conditions in the 21st century,” Lusine said. “The conditions the population lives in. It doesn’t make sense.”

Lusine was born in Stepanakert and moved to the United States when she married Garegin in 2005. The family lives in Rego Park, Queens but visits Artsakh often. Garegin says the family continued to visit Artsakh after the war between Armenia and Azerbaijan in 2020 in defiance of Azerbaijan and Turkey’s plan to “minimize the Armenian community all over the world to visit Artsakh.”

“These days, Artsakh needs Armenian community members to go more often and support,” Garegin said. “We want everyone who would love to cut the Armenian community off from Artsakh to know that it’s not going to happen. Armenians went, are and will visit Artsakh.” 

When Garegin received news of the blockade, he contacted his district’s representative in the New York State Assembly, Andrew Hevesi, whose office put him in touch with Congresswoman Grace Meng (D-NY). Meng’s office worked with the US State Department and the Armenian National Committee of America (ANCA) to evacuate the Akopyans from Artsakh.

“This family lives in Queens in Rego Park in the heart of my district. It’s our primary job to help constituents with these types of cases,” Congresswoman Meng told the Weekly in a recent interview. “This case was a bit more complicated than the usual, obviously having to deal with other organizations. We don’t have a presence on the ground in Artsakh, so my staff had to be the go-between working with these organizations.”

Congresswoman Meng, who represents New York’s 6th Congressional District in Queens, says she has been in regular contact with her constituents about the ongoing blockade of Artsakh.

“When we heard this is a local real-life family that has been affected by the blockade, we wanted to make sure we did whatever we could to make sure she and her son are safe and were able to come back home to New York,” Congresswoman Meng said. 

On January 26, Lusine got notice from the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) that she and her son would be transported to Armenia. 

The ICRC and the Russian peacekeeping mission in Artsakh are the only bodies that have been permitted to pass through the Lachin Corridor since its closure on December 12. The ICRC has transported 113 patients from Artsakh to Armenia, since all surgeries have been temporarily suspended in Artsakh due to the blockade. Lusine says the US Embassy sent a letter to the ICRC to hasten their evacuation. 

The next day, nearly two months after their arrival in Artsakh, Lusine and Andranik landed at John F. Kennedy International Airport in Queens. 

Congresswoman Meng is one of over 60 US representatives supporting a congressional resolution (H.Res.108) to condemn the blockade of Artsakh by Azerbaijan. The resolution calls for international investigations into Azerbaijani war crimes, suspension of US military assistance to Azerbaijan and sanctions against Azerbaijani officials, among other measures.  

“Symbolically, it’s important we have a resolution like that condemning the blockade,” Congresswoman Meng said. “This resolution, which is bipartisan, is important because not only does it confirm our stance as Congressmembers, but in a more public way, allows the rest of the world, who might not know what’s going on over there, to make sure that people understand what a dire circumstance this is for people.”

During the Weekly’s interview with the Akopyan family, Andranik interrupted his father with a laugh. Garegin, who had been warning that the Armenian Diaspora must take unified action to support Artsakh, paused to smile.

“I’m glad Armenia’s kids can still laugh, but I want them to laugh in their historical motherland as well,” Garegin said. 

Lillian Avedian is a staff writer for the Armenian Weekly. Her writing has also been published in the Los Angeles Review of Books, Hetq and the Daily Californian. She is pursuing master’s degrees in journalism and Near Eastern Studies at New York University. A human rights journalist and feminist poet, Lillian’s first poetry collection Journey to Tatev was released with Girls on Key Press in spring of 2021.