The delegation led by the Minister of Culture of Italy visits Armenian Genocide Memorial

Save

Share

 18:25, 22 February 2023

YEREVAN, FEBRUARY 22, ARMENPRESS. On February 22, the delegation led by the Minister of Culture of Italy, Gennaro Sangiuliano, visited the Armenian Genocide Memorial accompanied by the Deputy Minister of Education, Science, Culture and Sports of the Republic of Armenia Alfred Kocharyan, the Head of the Department of Foreign Relations and Diaspora Arkadi Papoyan, the Ambassador of the Republic of Armenia to Italy Tsovinar Hambardzumyan and the Ambassador of Italy to Armenia Alfonso di Riso.

As ARMENPRESS was informed from the Armenian Genocide Museum-Institute, Harutyun Marutyan, director of the AGMI, welcomed the guests and presented the history of the creation of the memorial complex. He also referred to the three khachkars (cross-stones) placed in the Tsitsernakaberd area in memory of the Armenians who fell victim to the massacres organized by the Azerbaijani government in the cities of Sumgait, Kirovabad (Gandzak), Baku at the end of the last century, and the stories of the five freedom fighters buried in the area of the memorial complex during the Artsakh war, stressing the connection between what happened and the Armenian Genocide.

Mr. Gennaro Sangiuliano laid a wreath at the memorial to the victims of the Armenian Genocide, then the guests placed flowers near the eternal fire and observed a minute of silence in memory of the innocent victims of the Armenian Genocide.

The guests also toured the Armenian Genocide Museum Institute, where they got acquainted with the permanent and temporary exhibitions accompanied by the senior tour guide of AGMI, Angel Tevekelyan.

At the end of the visit, Shushan Khachatryan, a senior researcher at the Armenian Genocide Museum Institute, presented the guests from Italy with the exclusive documents about Father Salvatore Lilli (1853-1895), in which Salvatore Lilli, as an eyewitness, also describes the Ottoman Empire’s repressions against the Armenian population.

URGENT. International Court of Justice obliges Azerbaijan to ensure uninterrupted movement through the Lachin Corridor

Save

Share

 19:53, 22 February 2023

YEREVAN, FEBRUARY 22, ARMENPRESS. The International Court of Justice obliged Azerbaijan to ensure the uninterrupted movement of transport and people through the Lachin Corridor in both directions, as provided by the obligations it has assumed, reads the decision of the International Court of Justice on Armenia’s petition on the issue of unblocking the Lachin Corridor.

Azerbaijan is obliged to ensure uninterrupted movement through the Lachin Corridor in both directions. The Hague Court

Save

Share

 20:06, 22 February 2023

YEREVAN, FEBRUARY 22, ARMENPRESS. The International Court of Justice published the decision on Armenia’s request to apply provisional measures regarding the unblocking of the Lachin Corridor. Thus, the court concludes that Azerbaijan is obliged, in accordance with its obligations under the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination, to take all measures at its disposal to ensure unimpeded movement of persons, vehicles and cargo along the Lachin Corridor in both directions, ARMENPRESS reports, the decision was published on February 22.

The Court reminded that by the December 7, 2021 decision, the following provisional measures were applied,

The Republic of Azerbaijan shall, in accordance with its obligations under the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination,

(a) Protect from violence and bodily harm all persons captured in relation to the 2020 Conflict who remain in detention, and ensure their security and equality before the law;

(b) Take all necessary measures to prevent the incitement and promotion of racial hatred and discrimination, including by its officials and public institutions, targeted at persons of Armenian national or ethnic origin;

(c) Take all necessary measures to prevent and punish acts of vandalism and desecration affecting Armenian cultural heritage, including but not limited to churches and other places of worship, monuments, landmarks, cemeteries and artefacts.

The Court further recalls that by a letter dated 16 September 2022, Armenia, referring to Article 76 of the Rules of Court, requested the modification of the Court’s Order of 7 December 2021 (the “second Request”).

By an Order dated 12 October 2022, the Court found that “the circumstances, as they [then] present[ed] themselves to the Court, [were] not such as to require the exercise of its power to modify the measures indicated in the Order of 7 December 2021”. In addition, the Court reaffirmed the provisional measures indicated in its Order of 7 December 2021, in particular the requirement that both Parties refrain from any action which might aggravate or extend the dispute before the Court or make it more difficult to resolve.

Finally, the Court recalls that, on 28 December 2022, Armenia, referring to Article 41 of the Statute and Article 73 of the Rules of Court, filed a new Request for the indication of provisional measures (the “third Request”). In that Request, Armenia states that, on 12 December 2022, Azerbaijan “orchestrated a blockade of the only road connecting the 120,000 ethnic Armenians in Nagorno-Karabakh with the outside world” and asks the Court to indicate the following two provisional measures: “Azerbaijan shall cease its orchestration and support of the alleged ‘protests’ blocking uninterrupted free movement along the Lachin Corridor in both directions [; and] Azerbaijan shall ensure uninterrupted free movement of all persons, vehicles, and cargo along the Lachin Corridor in both directions.” By a letter dated 26 January 2023, the Agent of Armenia communicated to the Court the text of a further provisional measure sought by his Government, as follows: “Azerbaijan shall immediately fully restore and refrain from disrupting or impeding the provision of natural gas and other public utilities to Nagorno-Karabakh.”

The judge noted that the court notices that since December 12, 2022, the connection between Nagorno-Karabakh and Armenia through the Lachin Corridor has been disrupted. The Court notes that a number of consequences have arisen as a result of this situation, and that those who bear the consequences continue to suffer these effects to this day. According to the information, the import of vital goods to Nagorno-Karabakh was also hindered, as a result of which there is a shortage of food, medicine and other life-saving supplies. The Court considers that the damage can be considered irreparable when the relevant persons find themselves in life- and health-threatening circumstances.

The Court recalled that at the open session held on January 30, 2023, the representative of Azerbaijan confirmed that his government has committed and remains committed to taking all the steps within its power to guarantee the free movement of people, vehicles and cargo through the Lachin Corridor, including continuously working with the ICRC.

The court takes note of that statement. However, this does not eliminate the imminent risk of irreparable damage due to the disruption of movement through the Lachin Corridor. In light of the above circumstances, the Court concludes that the alleged impairment of the rights recognized by the Court as enforceable may cause irreparable damage to the rights and there is urgency. That is, there is a real or imminent and immediate risk that irreparable harm will occur before the Court makes a final decision on the case. Therefore, the Court concludes that the conditions for applying provisional measures are present and grounded, so it is necessary for the Court to apply some provisional measures before the final decision in order to protect the rights mentioned by the Court requested by Armenia. The Court mentions that it has the right under the statute to apply such measures that are completely or partially different from the requested measures.

“The Court notes that the Statement by the President of the Republic of Azerbaijan, Prime Minister of the Republic of Armenia and President of the Russian Federation of 9 November 2020 provides, inter alia, that the Lachin Corridor, “which will provide a connection between Nagorno Karabakh and Armenia . . . shall remain under the control of the Russian Federation peacemaking forces”. The Statement further states that “Azerbaijan shall guarantee the security of persons, vehicles and cargo moving along the Lachin Corridor in both directions”.

In the present case, having considered the terms of the provisional measures requested by Armenia and the circumstances of the case, the Court finds that the measures to be indicated need not be identical to those requested. The Court concludes that Azerbaijan shall, pending the final decision in the case and in accordance with its obligations under the Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination, take all measures at its disposal to ensure unimpeded movement of persons, vehicles and cargo along the Lachin Corridor in both directions”, reads the decision of the Court.

The government of Azerbaijan supports the "activists" who blocked Lachin corridor. Human Rights Watch

Save

Share

 21:04, 22 February 2023

YEREVAN, FEBRUARY 22, ARMENPRESS. The international human rights organization Human Rights Watch has published an article depicting the humanitarian crisis created in Nagorno-Karabakh as a result of the blocking of the Lachin Corridor by Azerbaijan.

ARMENPRESS reports, the publication reminds that from December 12, 2022, Azerbaijan blocked the Lachin Corridor, the only road connecting Nagorno Karabakh to Armenia and the outside world, as a result of which the Armenian people of Nagorno Karabakh found themselves in a difficult situation.

40-year-old Armine, who lives with her family in Nagorno-Karabakh, told Human Rights Watch that her husband lost his job as a taxi driver due to lack of fuel, and now she is the sole breadwinner of the family. And the 12- and 14-year-old children only recently returned to school when the school was heated with wood stoves. However, some schools remain closed due to lack of heating. Food is becoming scarcer, not affordable as prices have skyrocketed. Armine said that she waited two hours even in cold weather to buy eggs.

Armine plans her day around power outages. During the few hours when there is electricity, she has to cook and do housework, heat the children’s room and help them with their homework.

Human Rights Watch emphasized that Armine’s story is not an exception. The blockade of the Lachin Corridor has disrupted access to essential goods and services for thousands of Armenians living in Nagorno-Karabakh. Many remained in Armenia and cannot return to their homes.

It is noted that the authorities of Azerbaijan deny that they are responsible for the closure of the road, but support the rallies.

The disruption of the Lachin Corridor is creating a humanitarian crisis as many needs remain unmet. The publication of Human Rights Watch presents the difficult situation with a concrete example. Armine’s father is sick with cancer and has to travel regularly from the village to Stepanakert, but due to lack of fuel and transport, he missed his last medical visits.

“Azerbaijani authorities and Russian peacekeeping forces must ensure that the protests do not deprive Armine and other residents of Nagorno-Karabakh of their rights, including access to healthcare, basic services and goods, as well as the right to free movement,” the publication emphasizes.

Armenpress: We are happy to see the truth prevail. Armenian FM welcomes the decision of the Hague Court

Save

Share

 21:13, 22 February 2023

YEREVAN, FEBRUARY 22, ARMENPRESS. Armenia welcomes the International Court of Justice’s decision on Armenia’s request to indicate a provisional measure to unblock the Lachin Corridor, ARMENPRESS reports the Minister of Foreign Affairs of Armenia Ararat Mirzoyan wrote in his Twitter microblog.

“We welcome CIJ’s ruling today that Azerbaijan must take all measures to end its blockade and ensure unimpeded movement of persons, vehicles and cargo along the Lachin Corridor.

We are also pleased to see truth prevail as the Court rejected in full Azerbaijan’s counter request”, Mirzoyan wrote.

Armenian National Committee of America Endorses Portantino For Congress

PASADENA NOW
Feb 21 2023

The Armenian National Committee of America – Western Region (ANCA-WR) today announced its endorsement of Senator Anthony Portantino for the 30th Congressional District of California.

California’s 30th Congressional District is home to the largest concentration of Armenian-American constituents anywhere in the United State. The district includes part of Pasadena and the communities of Glendale, Burbank, the Foothills, and Little Armenia.

“Senator Portantino’s commitment to the Armenian-American Community is manifest in his unrelenting advocacy for Armenian issues,” said ANCA-WR Board Chair Nora Hovsepian, Esq.

“Senator Portantino has worked closely with the ANCA-WR for many years both as a State Assemblymember and then as State Senator, and we look forward to continuing our close partnership with him in Congress. We are confident that he will be the leading voice for Armenian-Americans in the United States Congress as he follows in the footsteps and example set by Congressman Adam Schiff. While we typically do not issue endorsements this early in a campaign, we make exceptions for candidates who have proven themselves to be champions of our Cause and leaders on our issues, as Senator Portantino most certainly has over a period of many years. We are therefore proud to stand with him from this early stage of the campaign.”

The ANCA – Western Region is the largest and most influential Armenian-American grassroots advocacy organization in the Western United States. Working in coordination with a network of offices, chapters, and supporters throughout the Western United States and affiliated organizations around the country, the ANCA-WR advances the concerns of the Armenian-American community on a broad range of issues.

In 2018, Portantino and other state and local leaders visited Armenia as part of an ANCA-WR-led delegation focused on deepening economic ties between California and Armenia.

As the chair of the senate appropriations committee, Portantino has supported various Armenian-American institutions like the Armenian Relief Society and the Armenian-American Museum, which was allocated $10 million in Governor Newsom’s budget.

During his time as chair of the senate budget subcommittee on Education from 2018-2019, Senator Portantino successfully allocated $500,000 to California’s state budget to fund curricula on the Armenian Genocide.

In 2021, the Senator introduced legislation ensuring that California taxpayers no longer fund the Turkish Government and its continued denial of the Armenian Genocide.

Senate Bill 457, introduced by Senators Anthony Portantino and Scott Wilk, allowed local agencies to divest from Turkey. The bill passed in the California Senate with overwhelming support.

More recently, Portantino and 21 other legislators from California’s Senate and Assembly authored a letter to President Biden regarding Azerbaijan’s ongoing blockade of Artsakh. The letter calls upon the Biden Administration:
• To condemn and call for the unconditional lifting of the blockade by Azerbaijan;
• To allocate humanitarian assistance to Artsakh;
• To halt all U.S. military aid to Azerbaijan under Section 907 of the Freedom Support Act;
• To sanction the Aliyev regime under the Global Magnitsky Act for violating International Humanitarian Law; and
• To introduce a resolution in the United Nations to establish a mission in Artsakh to ensure regional peace and security.

“I am extremely honored to receive the endorsement of the Armenian National Committee of America – Western Region. I have many long-standing friendships with ANCA members and grassroots activists, and I have been proud to stand shoulder to shoulder with my friends for human rights, Genocide recognition, condemning the violent Azeri attacks on Arstakh and supporting increased trade and cooperation between California and Armenia. I can think of no better way to begin my campaign to succeed Adam Schiff than with the support of the ANCA.

From my youth, I remember my mother speaking about Armenian orphans in the wake of the Genocide, and I was pleased to have developed friendships in California where I can utilize my mother’s lessons to make a positive difference for a vibrant community. I have been to Armenia and Artsakh four times, and I look forward to my continued support of Armenian American causes and greater community in Congress,” said Portantino.

City Council Supports Burbank Armenian Association With Resolution


Feb 21 2023

Burbank Armenian Association applauds City Council for standing with the Armenian community in a historic moment for justice!

On February 14th, amidst the ongoing Artsakh blockade, ANCA Burbank and Burbank Armenian Association united to craft a powerful resolution that will raise awareness and inspire action, bringing hope and justice to the forefront of the Burbank City Council’s agenda.

The resolution passed unanimously by the Burbank City Council, reflecting the city’s commitment to supporting the Armenian-American community and advocating for a peaceful resolution to the ongoing Artsakh conflict.

What is happening in Artsakh?

The Artsakh blockade is an ongoing issue that has affected the lives of thousands of people, and the situation remains highly volatile. Despite several attempts at ceasefires and peace negotiations, violence and conflict continue to plague the region. To address this, it is essential to raise awareness and advocate for solutions that address the root causes of the conflict, including issues of territory, human rights, and economic inequality. By working together and promoting meaningful change, organizations like ANCA Burbank and Burbank Armenian Association are playing a crucial role in advocating for peace and justice in the region.

https://myburbank.com/city-council-supports-burbank-armenian-association-with-resolution/

What Does the Armenian Genocide Have to Do With Florida?

Sapiens.org
Feb 22 2023


OP-ED / VIEWPOINT
Archaeologists have increasingly ignored evidence for the 1915 Armenian genocide that has long been denied by Turkey. The consequences have lessons for the U.S. as Florida seeks to prevent educators from teaching about injustices in the country’s history.

IN JANUARY, THE Florida Department of Education rejected an Advanced Placement high school course on African American studies. The decision has been widely seen as part of Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis’ “anti-woke” efforts to ban schools from covering issues of race, racism, and injustice in U.S. history. Since the uproar, the College Board, the organization that develops AP courses, has issued a revised plan for the course, which omits some of the allegedly controversial content.

This right-wing crusade to censor history is not unprecedented in the United States—the last half-century has seen book burnings and public library battles aplenty. But Americans have not seen a concerted legislative effort to restrict teaching about injustices in the country’s past since the Red Scare of the 1950s. At the university level, DeSantis wants to mandate courses about Western civilization, eliminate faculty tenure, and defund diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) programs.

To understand the long-term consequences of this path of repressing a nation’s inglorious past, we can look to another country with collective violence at its origins: Turkey.

For over a century, Turkish leaders have denied the Armenian genocide, the systematic program of ethnic cleansing carried out by the Ottoman Empire that resulted in the deaths of as many as 1.5 million Armenians in Anatolia between 1915 and 1921. This period of staggering violence financed the emergence of the Turkish Republic out of the ashes, bones, and estates of the victims.

Today in Turkey, one regularly encounters expressions of anger from the political class over accusations of genocide. Turkish schools are mandated to teach the denial of the Armenian genocide, and in 2017, the Turkish parliament banned its lawmakers from using the term “Armenian genocide,” along with “Kurdistan” and “Kurdish regions.” And, as my recent analysis has shown, foreign archaeologists have been complicit in sanitizing Turkey’s history.

As an archaeologist who has excavated in Armenia and the wider South Caucasus for three decades, I have become increasingly interested in how colleagues who work in Turkey handle the lingering traces of Armenian heritage and its destruction. Archaeologists conducting research in Anatolia work amid ruins, artifacts, and skeletal remains that testify both to centuries of Armenian communities and their violent end.

As research into archaeology’s role in nationalist projects has clearly demonstrated, knowing the past is vital to understanding the present. Typically, nations valorize portions of the past, allowing less savory episodes to recede from popular imagination. As a discipline of memory and memorialization, archaeology can aid this process, providing material evidence for nationalistic narratives. But archaeology can also bear witness to past injustices, uncovering remains that disprove or complicate such narratives.

The Armenian genocide’s 100th anniversary was in 2015. Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan had already begun taking an increasingly authoritarian turn. At the same time, Turkey had become more active in UNESCO’s World Heritage Committee, hosting their annual meeting in 2016. World Heritage has provided a platform that allows Turkey to disseminate state-sponsored narratives about the region’s past—narratives that place considerable pressure on foreign archaeologists.

As I observed these events, I began to wonder how foreign archaeologists working in Turkey were dealing with evidence of the Armenian genocide. My findings, recently published in Current Anthropology, document how over the last four decades, researchers have faced real or perceived state intimidation. Fearing retribution that would end their research programs, archaeologists have deliberately ignored Armenian place names, monuments, and human remains. And as a result, they’ve been coopted as accessories in Turkey’s century-old policy of genocide denial.

✽

I BEGAN MY STUDY by delving through reports written by foreign archaeologists working in Turkey over the last half century. In these publications, I noticed several tactics scholars used to sidestep Armenian heritage. First, the archaeologists conspicuously avoided materials and eras that would raise the question of Armenian presence and force the follow-up question: “Where did they go?”

Next, they emphasized that a handful of undeniable Armenian remnants, such as the Church of the Redeemer at Ani and the Cathedral of the Holy Cross at Aghtamar, were used during the ninth to 11th centuries—a safe remove from the communities destroyed by the Ottoman Empire in the early 20th century. Finally, other enduring Armenian remains were de-ethnicized: referred to not as Armenian but as generically Christian or Byzantine, categories that are treated quite differently in official Turkish discourse.

Given my reading of the published archive, I sought to better understand the interests and experiences of the international archaeologists who created it. Many colleagues politely declined my interview requests; some refused to even answer my initial overtures. Ultimately, I was able to conduct formal interviews with eight anonymous scholars.

                                                                                       A 1966 photograph features the Armenian St. Hovhannes Church of Bagrevand.

In 2000, only traces of the church’s foundation remained.

Raffi Kortoshian/Research on Armenian Architecture

What I found was a pervasive climate of fear—fear of retribution, fear of expulsion, fear of permits revoked. This climate led projects to actively discourage any discussion of Armenians, even when researchers encountered remains of murdered individuals or the quiet witness of their living descendants.

This was the case for the most chilling testimony I encountered. An archaeologist recounted excavations in eastern Turkey amid the remnants of an Armenian village whose residents had been massacred and their land and homes expropriated during the genocide. One day, during the dig, a man started praying at the ruins of the Armenian church. It turned out he was the sole Armenian survivor of the village.

“He said he came every year to pay his respect for his ancestors. The bones of whom we excavated up on the top of the site, [each one] with a tiny hole on the back of the head,” the archaeologist explained. The bullet holes observed by the archaeologist clearly marked the skeletal remains as victims of the Armenian genocide.

The archaeologist continued, “Turkish authorities didn’t want to know. [We] didn’t report it. And the bones got chucked.”

This was not a singular occurrence. The archaeologist continued: “The next village where we worked was also an Armenian village. [The bones we found there] got chucked into the Euphrates.”

✽

IN MY ANALYSIS, I concluded that state intimidation has nearly eliminated Armenian heritage from the archaeology of Anatolia. I called this blinkered vision “unseeing” after novelist China Miéville’s dystopian thriller The City and The City, a novel that seems set somewhere along Turkey’s troubled borderlands. By unseeing, I don’t simply mean ignoring parts of the past that are less grand or out of current academic fashion. Unseeing is skilled and deliberate inattention, which occurs when those in power want undesirable facts to disappear.

Like Turkey’s state policy of genocide denial, Gov. Ron DeSantis and the anti-woke right-wing are demanding that people in the U.S. unsee the collective violence and exploitation that lie at the founding of the nation. In Turkey, the goal of unseeing is a sanitized history that legitimates a monoethnic, monotheistic Turkish Republic—not dissimilar from the historical fairy tales that support white supremacy in the U.S.

But as Turkey shows, ignoring the violence of the past ensures that communities can never move beyond it to establish a free and equal future. Fatma Müge Göçek, a Turkish sociologist at the University of Michigan, draws a clear line from Turkey’s denial of the Armenian genocide to state violence and oppression throughout the following century. That violence extended first to other non-Muslims (that is, Greeks in the 1955 Istanbul Pogrom) and then to non-Turks (including Kurdish communities under attack since 1984).

In the United States, a refusal to acknowledge the suffering of slavery and colonial dispossession not only delays our collective search for a just society, it also opens the possibility of accepting injustice and cruelty as vital to the survival of the nation. Indeed, in Turkey, perpetrators of violence toward religious or ethnic minorities have been hailed as heroes.

Yet, unseeing is a weak form of repression. The archaeologists I interviewed all knew of the collective violence in Turkey’s past, and most were deeply resentful of the censorship required of them. Far from burnishing the nation’s image, unseeing has left archaeologists in Turkey not only ethically compromised, but also aimless. As Lafayette College historian Rachel Goshgarian noted in her response to my article, “What is [archaeologists’] work, really, if they are so fearful of seeing and writing about the past?”

The lesson from Turkey should commit archaeologists worldwide to resist demands that they unsee the past, documenting only a sanitized record purged of struggle, exploitation, violence, and victims. But more broadly, the Turkish case should serve as a caution for the U.S. and its continuing battle over the teaching of American history. A commitment to understanding America’s past demands that we not become complicit in DeSantis’ program of unseeing.

A citizenry fully informed of prior wrongs and able to commit to shared values of decency is prepared to look to the future. A deluded citizenry that believes in a nationalist fairy tale is perpetually worried about defending the past, lest the truth be seen. We must confront the past in its totality and brutality, with an eye to a more just and equitable future. Archaeologists can play a critical role in this process, if only we resist demands to unsee.


Azerbaijan steps back on demands for “Zangezur Corridor”

Feb 22 2023
Joshua Kucera Feb 22, 2023

Azerbaijan has offered a new proposal to Armenia in the ongoing peace negotiations between the two countries: to allow Armenian checks of Azerbaijani traffic along what Baku calls the “Zangezur Corridor,” in exchange for the establishment of Azerbaijani checkpoints on the road connecting Armenia to Nagorno-Karabakh.

The move would effectively give up on the larger geopolitical vision of the Zangezur Corridor: a seamless transportation route connecting Azerbaijan to Turkey and beyond. At its most fanciful, it was envisaged as a road to “unite the entire Turkic world.” Azerbaijan President Ilham Aliyev has even repeatedly threatened to use force if Armenia doesn’t allow the corridor to be built.

Now, though, Aliyev says that Baku would accept Armenian checkpoints on the road when it enters and leaves Armenian territory. “It would be good if Armenia and Azerbaijan established checkpoints on the Armenia-Azerbaijan border bilaterally,” he told reporters on February 18. “Checkpoints should be established at both ends of the Zangezur corridor and the border between the Lachin district [of Azerbaijan] and Armenia.”

Aliyev said that he made that proposal formally to the Armenian side on the same day, when he met with Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan and United States Secretary of State Anthony Blinken. “We will wait for a response from Armenia,” he said. 

In a sense, the proposal is not strictly new. Azerbaijan has long argued that the statuses of the two roads should be equal: either checkpoints on both or on neither. 

“Today, there are no customs [posts] in the Lachin corridor,” the road connecting Armenia to Karabakh, Aliyev said in December 2021. “Therefore, there should be no customs [posts] in the Zangezur corridor. If Armenia would insist on using customs facilities to control cargo and people, then we will insist on the same in the Lachin corridor. This is logical.” 

But the accent has always been on the no-checkpoint version. Just a month ago, an Azerbaijani official told Eurasianet that Azerbaijan’s demand was not only no Armenian checkpoints, but no Armenian security officers at all in a 2.5-kilometer buffer zone on the road as it passed through Armenian territory.

The would-be Zangezur Corridor would connect the mainland of Azerbaijan with its exclave of Nakhchivan through Armenian territory. It was borne out of the ceasefire agreement that ended the 2020 war between Armenia and Azerbaijan, the ninth point of which stipulated that Armenia would “guarantee the security of transport connections” to Nakhchivan “in order to arrange unobstructed movement of persons, vehicles and cargo in both directions.” Russian border guards would be responsible for “overseeing” the route.

The most disputed word in that provision was “unobstructed.” Armenians argued that passport and customs controls as the route entered and left Armenian territory did not amount to obstruction; Azerbaijanis argued that it did.

“How will this unobstructed movement be ensured? Will Armenians just sit and watch us? Let them watch. But the movement should be unobstructed. If there is a checkpoint there, it won’t be unobstructed,” said Farid Shafiyev, the head of a state-run think tank, in a November 2021 interview with RFE/RL.

“What Azerbaijan wants is no checkpoints, not to have to stop at the border,” Anar Valiyev, the dean of ADA University, told analyst Tom de Waal the same month. “We are in a situation where we have leverage, we have time and we can dictate terms.”

Armenians, for their part, consistently offered to open a road connecting mainland Azerbaijan to Nakhchivan, but that it couldn’t be an “extraterritorial corridor” over which it had no control.

As negotiations over a comprehensive peace agreement between the two sides have dragged on, with the nature of the Zangezur Corridor apparently the biggest sticking point, Azerbaijan launched a blockade of the Lachin Corridor. That blockade has continued now for more than two months; Azerbaijan claims that Armenians had been using the road to smuggle weapons in and valuable resources out of Nagorno-Karabakh, and that they need some sort of checkpoint to make sure that doesn’t happen.

Meanwhile, Baku was proposing a variant of the Zangezur Corridor in which checks could be carried out by Russian, but not Armenian, security officers. (While Aliyev wasn’t entirely explicit on who would operate the checkpoints on the Armenian side of the border under his proposal, a senior Azerbaijan Foreign Ministry official confirmed to Eurasianet, on condition of anonymity, that it would be Armenians.)

It is not clear whether Aliyev’s “new” proposal was inspired by changing circumstances or was the strategy all along – that is, the maximalist vision of the Zangezur Corridor was always a bargaining chip to gain control over Karabakh. In any event, the new Azerbaijani proposal amounts to a retreat from that public grand geopolitical strategy for the sake of a more local strategic aim: cementing its control over Karabakh.

And it could pave the way for Armenia to sign a comprehensive agreement more quickly. While allowing Azerbaijan customs and passport control is unacceptable to the Armenian population of Karabakh, that will not be a dealbreaker. Armenia and the American and European mediators who have been working on a peace agreement have been increasingly focusing on arranging some kind of direct relationship between the Karabakh Armenians and the Azerbaijani government, without involvement from Yerevan. Disputes over the Zangezur Corridor appear to have been the biggest impediment for Armenia, and now they may have been resolved.

The new proposal appears to have caught the Armenian side flat-footed. There has been little official response, and the Ministry of Foreign Affairs did not respond to requests for comment.

The head of the ruling party faction in the Armenian parliament was asked about the proposal in an interview with RFE/RL, and repeated the talking points that Armenia would never accept an extraterritorial corridor. When the interviewer persisted, pointing out that the question was no longer about an extraterritorial corridor, the MP, Hayk Konjoryan, replied: “At the moment I don’t think the question deserves discussion.”

On February 22, Armenian Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan addressed the proposal, saying that Yerevan rejected the proposal of setting up the checkpoint on the Lachin Corridor. On the Zangezur Corridor proposal, he said only that it was “not new.”

Azerbaijani commentary, meanwhile, has tended to crow over Aliyev’s outmaneuvering of Armenia and its repeated objections to the notion of a “corridor,” while sidestepping the fact that that was precisely what Baku had been publicly demanding for so long.

An analysis on Caliber.az, a site associated with Azerbaijan’s Defense Ministry, suggested that perhaps it was Russia who might want an extraterritorial corridor. (Russia has pushed the idea of the transportation routes being opened, all the more now that its options are constrained as a result of Ukraine war sanctions, but Moscow also has consistently opposed the idea of extraterritoriality.)

“Is the idea of an extraterritorial Zangezur Corridor no longer on Azerbaijan’s agenda? It’s possible that extraterritoriality is just as important to us as before, but Azerbaijan has decided to avoid involvement in this toxic-for-us issue,” Caliber wrote. “If Russia needs an extraterritorial corridor, then it should resolve that issue with the Armenians directly, but not at Azerbaijan’s expense.”

This post has been edited to add comments from Armenia’s foreign minister.

Joshua Kucera, a senior correspondent, is Eurasianet’s former Turkey/Caucasus editor and has written for the site since 2007.

Lachin Corridor standoff between Azerbaijan and Armenia enters third month

Feb 22 2023

This article was first published on OC Media. An edited version is republished here under a content partnership agreement. 

The blockade of Lachin Corridor, which started on December 12, 2022, continues with residents saying food and energy are depleting quickly while no solution is in sight. In December 2022, Azerbaijani citizens claiming to be environmental activists began blocking the Lachin Corridor, the sole land route connecting Armenia to the Karabakh region. The protestors are demanding that Armenia stop mining gold and copper-molybdenum deposits in Karabakh, which official Baku claims Armenians are exporting illegally.

Since the blockade began, Karabakh Armenians have faced cuts in goods supplies, services, fuel, as well as, internet access and gas supplies. The government of Azerbaijani has denied any involvement in the blockade. And although lorries from the Red Cross and the Russian peacekeeping mission in Nagorno-Karabakh began transporting humanitarian aid to the region, local authorities in Stepanakert (Khankendi in Azerbaijani) say the aid is insufficient for the city of 120,000 people.

In January, Nagorno-Karabakh began rationing buckwheat, rice, sugar, and cooking oil. The list expanded to cover eggs, fruits, and vegetables in February. Marut Vanyan, a Stepanakert-based journalist, told OC Media that there are queues for food and that the region is struggling with the food rationing system.

Since the blockade started, Nagorno-Karabakh’s gas supply from Armenia has been cut off seven times. Officials from Yerevan and Stepanakert have accused Azerbaijan, as all gas pipes pass through Azerbaijan-controlled territories. “There is almost no traffic in the city. The city looks like a village: silence and smoke from stoves,” Vanyan told OC Media. “In the evenings, the city is shrouded in complete darkness.”

People have resorted to burning wood for heating and cooking, relying on wood stoves, Vanyan explained. Shortages in energy supply have also disrupted education as some educational institutions have partly closed, while others adjusted to using wood stoves for heating. An electricity supply shortage has forced the residents into temporary blackouts, with hour-long power cuts six times daily. Local authorities say the cuts are due to damage to electricity cables in territories controlled by Azerbaijan. According to the news outlet EVN report, on February 19, Artsakh authorities said, “public classes will resume in gas-heated public schools on February 20.”

On Monday, Nagorno-Karabakh’s local power distribution firm, Artsakhenergo, reported supply chain breakdowns in several parts of Stepanakert as a result of overloads in the system. Residents of the city were instructed to save electricity to avoid further damage.

Hospitals in the region have also reported shortages of medical supplies and equipment, putting a hold on around 600 non-essential surgeries so they could tend to more urgent cases in operating rooms.

The Red Cross has also transferred several patients requiring urgent medical assistance to hospitals in Armenia.

Lachin Corridor is supposedly under the protection of Russian peacekeepers who have been deployed in the territory since November 2020, following the Russia-brokered agreement signed between Russia, Armenia, and Azerbaijan. They are also in charge of providing security for entry and exit points of the corridor. In a broader context, however, the role of some 2,000 Russian peacekeepers remains vague. The lack of clearly defined roles, responsibilities, and activities in the 2020 agreement is now becoming an issue. The blockade is a testament to that.

On February 9, human rights watchdog Amnesty International issued a statement warning that the ongoing blockade was endangering thousands of lives, calling on “Azerbaijan’s authorities and Russian peacekeepers to immediately unblock the route and bring an end to the unfolding humanitarian crisis.” In addition, Marie Struthers, Amnesty International’s Director for Eastern Europe and Central Asia, said:

The Azerbaijani authorities have internationally recognized sovereignty over these territories and exercise control over the territory from which the blockade is being carried out. It is Azerbaijan’s obligation to undertake to ensure that the population in Nagorno-Karabakh is not denied access to food and other essential goods and medications. For its part, the Russian peacekeeping mission is mandated to ensure the safety of the Lachin corridor. However, both parties are manifestly failing to fulfill their obligations.

In January, UK and US Ambassadors to the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) urged Azerbaijan’s government to “restore access” and “allow for the unhindered movement of humanitarian goods and civilians.” On February 7, German Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbock joined the calls, saying that in light of the escalating situation on the ground, it was “essential that the blockade ends immediately.”

On February 10, the French Foreign Ministry also demanded an “immediate” reopening of the corridor. In an interview with Armenpress, former French Prime Minister Édouard Philippe said, “Azerbaijan was creating a humanitarian crisis for no reason with its ‘illegal and illegitimate’ blockade of the Lachin corridor.” On February 14, Josep Borrell, the EU’s High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy, said in a statement that the “EU remained seriously concerned about the distress the ongoing restrictions to freedom of movement and to the supply of vital goods were causing for the local population.”

On February 18, during the Munich Security Conference, leaders of Armenia and Azerbaijan met for the first time since October 2022. The October meeting was hailed as a landmark breakthrough as leaders from Armenia and Azerbaijan pledged to mutually recognize each other’s territorial integrity and sovereignty at the European Political Community summit held in Prague on October 6. The Prague meeting was mediated by the President of the European Council, Charles Michel, and French president, Emanuel Macron. The trilateral talks in Munich were with US Secretary of State Antony Blinken.

Ahead of the meeting in Munich, Armenia’s Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan announced that a peace plan was offered to Azerbaijan on February 16. Speaking to journalists in Munich, Azerbaijan’s President Ilham Aliyev said although there was progress based on the wording of the peace treaty, “it was not enough.” According to OC Media reporting, “three key issues remain undecided in Azerbaijan and Armenia’s peace agreement process: the demarcation of borders between the two countries, the opening of transport links, and the rights and security of Nagorno-Karabakh’s Armenian population.” Last year, official Baku proposed its own five-point plan.

Meanwhile, the International Crisis Group (ICG) released a new report in January 2023, warning of a possibility of another war in the South Caucasus less the risks are mitigated with the involvement of mediators such as the European Union (EU), which dispatched a civilian monitoring mission to the border between Armenia and Azerbaijan in January 2023.  In its report the ICG wrote:

While much remains to be fleshed out on the new mission, it aims (in the EU’s own words) to ‘contribute to stability in the border areas,’ ‘build confidence’ and ‘ensure an environment conducive’ to peace talks. These goals are ambitious but appropriate. Providing the EU deeper and more immediate knowledge of the situation on the ground may alert it to building tensions, helping position it for timely diplomatic engagement, and would also enhance its mediation efforts.

Olesya Vartanyan, Senior South Caucasus analyst with the ICG, shared a Twitter thread on the significance of the EU mission and the stakes. “In theory, this deployment should significantly shorten the time it takes the EU or member states to react if any new fighting flares up at the Armenian-Azerbaijani border,” wrote Vartanyan.