RFE/RL Armenian Report – 05/12/2023

                                        Friday, 
Armenian Journalist’s Assets Frozen After Corruption Report
        • Naira Bulghadarian
Armenia - Former Deputy Prime Minister Tigran Avinian attends a session of 
Yerevan's municipal assembly, September 23, 2022.
A court in Yerevan has frozen assets of an Armenian newspaper and one of its 
journalists who has accused a leading political ally of Prime Minister Nikol 
Pashinian of illicit enrichment.
In a video report posted on the 168 Zham newspaper’s website this month, the 
journalist, Davit Sargsian, described Yerevan’s Deputy Mayor Tigran Avinian as a 
“nouveau riche” whose family has been “steadily getting richer” ever since 
Pashinian came to power in 2018. It detailed the family’s allegedly extensive 
business interests developed in the last five years.
The reported claimed, in particular, that Avinian’s mother bought an expensive 
apartment in central Yerevan before becoming recently a co-owner of two firms 
and a 9-hectare plot of land in southern Armavir province.
Avinian, who will be the ruling Civil Contract’s candidate in upcoming mayoral 
elections in the Armenian capital, took the newspaper to court. He is seeking an 
unprecedentedly hefty compensation for the “slanderous” report which he claims 
damaged his “business reputation.”
Acting on Avinian’s demand, the court decided earlier this week to freeze 18 
million drams ($46,000) worth of assets belonging to 168 Zham and Sargsian 
personally pending its verdict in the case. The sum is huge by Armenian media 
standards.
Avinian, who also served as Armenia’s deputy prime minister from 2018-2021, 
defended the legal action when he spoke to reporters on Thursday.
“I can only advise media outlets to bear in mind before slandering anyone, lying 
about anyone that they can face such proceedings,” he said. “But I am otherwise 
not an enemy of the media.”
The 34-year-old politician did not specify which parts of the 5-minute video 
authored by Sargsian and posted on 168.am are untrue.
“Avinian’s real aim is to inflict significant material damage on me and thereby 
silence me,” Sargsian countered in a Facebook post.
The journalist, who is highly critical of the Armenian government, insisted that 
he simply shared with viewers credible information that was earlier reported by 
other media outlets and not refuted by Avinian.
Press freedom groups also criticized the lawsuit, saying that no Armenian media 
outlets or journalists have risked such heavy fines before.
“We are seeing a typical case of an official trying to muzzle and punish a media 
outlet,” said Shushan Doydoyan of the Yerevan-based Center for Freedom of 
Information. She noted that Avinian did not demand that the paper retract its 
corruption claims before he filed the lawsuit.
Armenia - A screenshot from an Aravot.am report on expensive property 
acquisitions by senior Armenian officials, March 15, 2023.
Pro-opposition and independent publications increasingly accuse members of 
Pashinian’s entourage of enriching themselves or their cronies and breaking 
their anti-corruption promises given during the 2018 “velvet revolution.”
Last month, hackers hijacked the YouTube channel of another newspaper, Aravot, 
as it was about to publish a video report detailing expensive property 
acquisitions by several senior government officials and pro-government lawmakers.
Earlier this year, Pashinian blamed such reports for a drop in Armenia’s 
position in an annual corruption survey conducted by Transparency International. 
He publicly urged senior officials to sue media outlets “falsely” accusing them 
of illicit enrichment.
In 2021, the Armenian parliament controlled by Pashinian’s party tripled maximum 
legal fines set for defamation.
Yerevan Vague On Azeri Control Of Karabakh
        • Astghik Bedevian
U.S. - U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken hosts talks between the Armenian 
and Azerbaijani foreign ministers, Arlington, May 1, 2023.
The Armenian government on Friday pointedly declined to clarify whether it is 
ready to explicitly recognize Azerbaijani sovereignty over Nagorno-Karabakh as a 
result of ongoing peace talks with Baku.
In April 2022, Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian signaled readiness to “lower the 
bar” on Karabakh’s status acceptable to Armenia and also stopped asserting the 
Karabakh Armenians’ right to self-determination in his public statements.
Pashinian made clear last month that his administration unequivocally recognizes 
Azerbaijan’s territorial integrity and is ready to sign an Armenian-Azerbaijani 
peace treaty that would commit the two South Caucasus states to recognizing each 
other’s Soviet-era borders.
Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev demanded, meanwhile, that Armenia go farther 
and officially declare that “Karabakh is Azerbaijan.”
Pashinian said last week that Baku is now not ready to even grant Karabakh an 
autonomous status.
Responding to questions sent by RFE/RL’s Armenian Service, Armenia’s Foreign 
Ministry did not say whether this means Yerevan has already agreed to the 
restoration of Azerbaijani control over Karabakh. It said only that Yerevan 
continues to insist on “discussion between Baku and Stepanakert on the rights 
and security guarantees of Nagorno-Karabakh’s population.”
Nagorno-Karabakh - Protesters hold a giant Armenian flag as they attend a rally 
in Stepanakert, December 25, 2022.
“Addressing the issues of the Nagorno-Karabakh people’s rights and security is 
very important for establishing a lasting peace and stability in the region,” 
the ministry said in a written reply. It did not specify whether Pashinian’s 
government believes this can be done under Azerbaijani rule.
Pashinian has publicly encouraged Karabakh’s leaders to negotiate with 
Azerbaijan while accusing Baku of planning to commit genocide in the 
Armenian-populated region.
The authorities in Stepanakert as well as the Armenian opposition have 
repeatedly denounced Pashinian’s public pronouncements on the conflict with 
Azerbaijan. In a joint statement issued on April 19, the five political groups 
represented in the Karabakh parliament again accused him of undermining the 
Karabakh Armenians’ right to self-determination which was for decades supported 
by international mediators.
The Armenian and Azerbaijani foreign ministers made what the U.S. State 
Department described as “tangible progress” towards the bilateral peace deal 
during marathon talks held outside Washington last week. Aliyev and Pashinian 
are expected to try to build on that progress when they meet in Brussels this 
Sunday.
U.S. Calls For Armenian-Azeri Troop Disengagement
U.S. -- State Department spokesman Vedant Patel speaks during a daily press 
briefing in Washington, September 6, 2022.
The United States has called on Armenia and Azerbaijan to withdraw their troops 
from the Armenian-Azerbaijani border after fresh fighting between them.
A U.S. State Department spokesman, Vedant Patel, said late on Thursday that the 
violence “undermines the progress made” by the two sides during recent peace 
talks, notably last week’s meetings between their foreign ministers held outside 
Washington.
Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian and Azerbaijan President Ilham Aliyev 
are scheduled meet to Brussels this Sunday in a bid to build on that progress.
“We call on the leaders of both of these countries that when they convene in 
Brussels on [May] 14th to a – that these two parties agree to distance their 
forces along the border, as discussed by Secretary [of State Antony] Blinken 
during their participation of these negotiations that we hosted here in 
Washington, D.C., at the beginning of May,” Patel told a news briefing.
Pashinian accused Baku of trying to derail the peace process shortly after the 
fighting involving artillery fire erupted near the Armenian border village of 
Sotk on Thursday morning, leaving one Azerbaijani soldier dead and four Armenian 
servicemen wounded.
Each side accused the other of shelling its military positions in the 
mountainous area. The intensity of the clashes decreased in the following hours, 
and no major truce violations were reported on the night from Thursday to Friday.
The Defense Ministry in Yerevan said that two more Armenian soldiers were 
wounded on Friday morning in an Azerbaijani drone attack on their position 
outside Sotk. It said that the situation at that section of the volatile border 
was “relatively stable” in the immediate aftermath of the incident.
The Armenian government has consistently advocated the idea of troop 
disengagement, also backed by the European Union, for the last two years. Baku 
does not support it.
Reposted on ANN/Armenian News with permission from RFE/RL
Copyright (c) 2023 Radio Free Europe / Radio Liberty, Inc.
1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.
 

Kremlin urges restraint over Armenia-Azerbaijan clashes

DIPLOMACY

“We expect a restrained approach from the parties and urge them not to take any actions that could lead to an increase in tensions,” Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov told reporters

The Kremlin on Thursday urged Armenia and Azerbaijan to ease tensions along their restive border after an exchange of fire left at least one dead.

“We expect a restrained approach from the parties and urge them not to take any actions that could lead to an increase in tensions. We will continue contacts with Baku and Yerevan,” Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov told reporters during a briefing.

Armenia, Azerbaijan accuse each other of fresh crossborder attacks, days ahead of EU talks

Armenia and Azerbaijan on Thursday blamed each other for an exchange of fire along their restive border, which killed one person and wounded four, days ahead of EU-hosted peace talks.

The leaders of the two countries are due to hold talks in Brussels on Saturday as part of a push to resolve the three-decade territorial dispute between the two neighbours in the Caucasus. 

The European Union-hosted meeting comes after the United States said “tangible progress” had been made at talks between foreign ministers in Washington last week aimed at ending the dispute over the enclave of Nagorno-Karabakh. But on Thursday, both sides accused each other of shooting along their border.

“A soldier from the Azerbaijani army was killed after a provocation from the Armenian forces,” Azerbaijan’s defence ministry said, accusing Armenia of having “once again violated the ceasefire agreement” with “large-calibre weapons”. Armenia said four of its soldiers were wounded in the clashes, which it blamed on Azerbaijan.

“Azerbaijani forces are shooting artillery and mortars at Armenian position in the Sotk region” in the east, Armenia’s defence ministry said.

The incident comes just days before European Council President Charles Michel is to host Armenia’s Nikol Pashinyan and Azerbaijan’s Ilham Aliyev for talks in Brussels.

The two leaders had also agreed to jointly meet the leaders of France and Germany on the sidelines of a European summit in Moldova on June 1, according to the EU.

Pashinyan on Thursday accused Azerbaijan of looking to “undermine the talks” in Brussels but added that he was still willing to attend. “I have not changed my mind about going to Brussels,” the Armenia premier told his government.

He added however that there was “very little” chance of signing a peace deal with Azerbaijan at the meeting. The draft agreement “is still at a very preliminary stage and it is too early to speak of an eventual signature”, Pashinyan said.

Majority-Christian Armenia and Azerbaijan, whose population is mostly Muslim, were both republics of the Soviet Union that gained independence in 1991, when the USSR broke up.

They have gone to war twice over disputed territories, mainly Nagorno-Karabakh, a majority-Armenian region inside Azerbaijan.

Tens of thousands of people have been killed in the two wars over the region, one lasting six years and ending in 1994, and the second in 2020, which ended in a Russia-negotiated ceasefire deal.

But clashes have broken out regularly since then. The Western mediation efforts to resolve the conflict come as major regional power Russia has struggled to maintain its decisive influence, due to the fallout from its war on Ukraine. 

(AFP)

https://www.france24.com/en/europe/20230511-armenia-azerbaijan-accuse-each-other-of-fresh-crossborder-attacks-days-ahead-of-eu-talks

On Armenia’s hot border with Azerbaijan: the ghost of an invasion and the resistance of a wounded people

by Mary Ortiz 

Noravank Monastery blends into the red rocks on the heights of Armenia. Azerbaijan is nearby, lurking. The priest of one of the temples in the complex turns his back to the altar and stands in front of a group of visitors, some of whom are faithful. One of them brings a message of peace in the face of growing conflict over the territory of Nagorno Karabagh. The priest stands still, raises his arm and replies vehemently: “We will not let them take our land away from us. Fight. We are not kneeling.”

– Advertisement –

Noravank is located on the road that connects the capital Yerevan with one of the hottest spots in the South Caucasus: the corridor that connects Armenia with Nagorno Karabakh, a territory inhabited by about 120,000 Armenians that has remained within the borders of Azerbaijan since Josef Stalin decided to cede the territory to the Azeris.

sinuous. at a distance. hidden. The border is trapped between mountains that seem to drown out the noise of war So hot That can be activated at any time.

– Advertisement –

On Thursday, both countries accused each other of initiating a firefight at the border that left at least one Azerbaijani soldier dead and four Armenians wounded.

In 2020, countries clashed in arms for 44 days. Azerbaijani military superiority made itself felt. Armenia lost around 5,000 troops and over 70% of the Artsakh region. Currently, Prime Minister Nikol Pashinián denounces before the international community that Baku is violating one of the points of the peace agreement signed between the two countries after that war: the obligation to ensure free movement along the road that connects Armenia with Nagorno.


On the way to the Lachin corridor, they begin to see each other austere trenches alternated with Armenian checkpoints. They report that Azerbaijani soldiers entered their territory in April. The clashes resulted in eight deaths: four on each side. Between trenches and trenches, small altars of dead soldiers appear by the side of the road with their photo in uniform and the Armenian flag.

clarion traveled to the point closer to the corridor. The checkpoint that Azerbaijan set up on April 3 to block the border is no longer accessible. Armenian military forces say they cannot guarantee the safety of people attempting to cross it. Only a few Red Cross ambulances and United Nations vans are allowed to circulate.

even along the way Russian patent parade military trucks. The soldiers stop to rest along the way. They smoke and speak little.

“The situation is very complicated,” admits one of them, the youngest of the group. And he goes further: “The responsibility lies with the three presidents”. Indicates the presidents of Armenia, Pashinián, and of Azerbaijan, Ilham Aliyev. But also to the Putin government, which should guarantee compliance with the peace agreement signed in 2020. None of that happens. Russia looks to Ukraine in war mode.

in conversation with clarion and other international media, the Deputy Foreign Minister of Armenia, Paruyr Hovhannisyan, complains that Russia is too “cautious” and “is not fulfilling its obligations”. “For them, relations with Turkey are more important, as well as with Azerbaijan, and this is also related to the gas and oil they export through Azerbaijan,” she complains.

Even in this border area the labor monitors of the European Union. They observe, take pictures, talk to people. They move between Yerevan and Stepanakert. They assure that “for now” the situation is calm. None of them will stay too long in the place.

On the other side of the mountains, more than two thousand meters high, they report it the population of Nagorno Karabakh is experiencing a situation of siege. They must have access to vouchers for increasingly scarce food rations; medicines are no longer enough and basic services are cut.

Azat Gevorkyan and his wife Anaik are pictured before leaving their home in Lachin, Nagorno-Karabakh, the last district to return to Azerbaijani control after the war. Photo: Valery Melnikov:/ World Press

The harsh Caucasus winter went through it without gas replenishment. This territory, which has its own Parliament, officials and uses the same currency as Armenia, it is not recognized as autonomous from any country in the world and today is surrounded by them.

“The possibility of an escalation of violence is very high”, warns the vice-rector. But the fear runs deeper: “Azerbaijan intends to go as far as possible. Aliyev always claims that the territory of present Armenia is West Azerbaijan. In accordance with this aggressive program, It is not only Nagorno-Karabakh, it is also the territory of Armenia”.

He Supreme Patriarch of Armenians, Karekin IIalso spoke to clarion and other media about the delicate situation at the border. “Periodically the Azrebaijan army penetrates our territory and tries to conquer more towns and cities. The euphoria that gave him the victory in 2020 he encouraged them”, he assures.

This is the border area where the blocked Lachin corridor crosses.

“I think the purpose is very clear: leave Artsakh without Armenians, provoke a new genocide”warns Karekin II and alludes to the great ghost that hovers in the history of this nation: the massacre of a million Armenians between 1915 and 1923 at the hands of the young Turks.

The silence of the people takes possession of this city in southeast Armenia. Goris is only 30 kilometers away from the Lachin Corridor and is the closest city to the border. There is a military base at the entrance to the city. Contemplative or vigilant, everyone is waiting for something to happen.

Southern Armenians live mainly from agriculture. Here they say that in this region the inhabitants are tough and that’s why they live longer. There has not been a mass exodus since the last war broke out in 2020. They stayed to protect their homes.

Zuren is 69 years old. He is retired but still works. This morning she left the taxi and is resting in the shade of a tree.

“Before living well, it was a dream. Now the situation is bad. We can no longer visit our family in Nagorno. We have them here, very close, behind the mountain, and we don’t see them. The world must understand that we are a nation with a lot of history. This is our land and they are denying us as a people.”the Mint.

Amidst this swarm of modest buildings with little trace of Soviet heritage is the city’s main square. Seated on a bench is Natalí, a 22-year-old teacher. She smiles a lot and stands out. Armenians laugh little. “What we live is very sad, people don’t know what’s really going on. We don’t live a normal life. – he underlines – People are worried about their children, about their future, but nobody wants to leave here”.

“We are not well we are in a war situation. We tell them we’re not moving from here. We believe they can advance, but we are not afraid,” challenges Vazgen, a 36-year-old opening maker.

to the cities of Goris and Khachardzan are separated by an undulating journey of 300 kilometersbut they are united by the Azerbaijani border fence.

Of the 420 people who live in this docile town in northwestern Armenia, 80% of the men have participated in the war. In the school where they study 65 students stands a kind of altar with photos of two men who died in the last clash. They are your heroes.

The mayor of the city, Gagik Shahnazaryan, is to be reckoned with for his deep blue eyes. He says Khachardzan has soldiers and volunteers at the border, which is only 40 kilometers from this wet and green village. He assures that although “the threat is always there”, they remain “ready to defend” the people.

“In our history We have always been in danger, but we have always overcome it and we will overcome this too.”says the mayor of a city that named its main street Argentina in recognition of the infrastructure contribution of the Armenian diaspora.

The mayor of the village of Khachardzan, Gagik Shahnazaryan.

Khachardzan and Goris are keeping their guard up that this Sunday, when the President of Azerbaijan and the Prime Minister of Armenia finally meet in Brussels, a sign of agreement that makes them -finally- sleep peacefully.

Goris, Armenia. special Correspondent

ap

Source: Clarin

https://newsrebeat.com/world-news/166876.html

Russia Acts As Mediator On Nagorno-Karabakh, Expects Restraint From Parties – Kremlin

Russia acts as a mediator on Nagorno-Karabakh and expects restraint from Armenia and Azerbaijan, Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said on Thursday

MOSCOW (UrduPoint News / Sputnik – 11th May, 2023) Russia acts as a mediator on Nagorno-Karabakh and expects restraint from Armenia and Azerbaijan, Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said on Thursday.

Moscow’s contacts with Yerevan and Baku continue, the official said, recalling that Russian President Vladimir Putin held talks with the leaders of Armenia and Azerbaijan earlier this week.

“Russia will continue to fulfill its functions (as a mediator), which are provided for in accordance with the tripartite documents. We, of course, expect a restrained approach from the parties and urge not to take any action that could lead to an increase in tension,” Peskov told reporters.

https://www.urdupoint.com/en/world/russia-acts-as-mediator-on-nagorno-karabakh-1690063.html

Stand Tall to Hate: Glendale town hall discusses anti-Armenian racism

PASADENA WEEKLY

One hundred and eight years ago, the Ottoman Empire began a campaign of violence that killed or displaced 1.5 million Armenians. The genocide left a scar on Armenia and its people around the world, still felt in the Armenian communities throughout Los Angeles today.

In a recent town hall meeting at Glendale Central Library, the Truth and Accountability League (TAAL) and LA County Commission on Human Relations brought elected officials and community leaders together to discuss a string of recent racist fliers seen in Beverly Hills and Glendale that reportedly called for the extermination of Armenians.

“It’s unfathomable that, on the heels of the Armenian genocide anniversary, Armenians are terrorized by fliers around schools and churches,” said TAAL founder Vic Gerami, who moderated the event dedicated to raising awareness and discussing solutions to combat increasing anti-Armenian racism and propaganda.

“This is really painful because we have kids; we have to explain this to our kids,” Commissioner Sam Kbushyan said during the town hall. “They go to public schools; they engage with all kinds of people. … And this is on social media saying that Armenians should have been erased and the next phase of genocide will be concluded. It really hurts because growing up, we Armenians are victims of the genocide. … We’ve been educated with the non-Armenians and the world of all these atrocities that ‘Never again,’ and we have this issue.”

Glendale Mayor Daniel Brotman spoke of the city’s “checkered past” and summarized a brief history of anti-Armenian rhetoric in the community as more Armenians began to hold political positions and build cultural influence in Glendale, now one of the largest Armenian diaspora communities in the world. 

“There was a lot of pushback,” he said. “There was a lot of the old Glendale that didn’t appreciate having others come in and kind of change the fabric of the community. … But when we look at today’s Glendale, I mean, can you imagine Glendale today without the Armenian community? The Armenian American population is incredibly active politically, in civic organizations, contributes so much to this city. … I don’t want to downplay the tensions that still exist, but despite all that, we are really a highly functional, integrated community.”

Brotman said that the city is “in a good place,” that he didn’t know where the fliers came from and doubted that they came from members of the Glendale community. Gerami responded by saying that where they originated from is “irrelevant,” that anti-Armenian racism still exists in Glendale, and that there is no task force or budget dedicated to combating hate incidents in the city. 

“There are many ways to go at this,” Brotman replied. “We have our Armenian genocide commemorative event every year. … We obviously speak out regularly on these issues, and we pass resolutions. We have sister cities in Artsakh, and we do many, many things to show that we have the backs of our Armenian community here and Armenians around the world.”

The Glendale Police Department has not yet made an arrest regarding the fliers, but the investigation remains ongoing. Glendale Police Chief Manuel Cid said the department is looking to enlist the help of community members who may have information regarding the incident.

“It’s concerning, and it follows a trend of ongoing hate speech and rhetoric that we see in several different communities, in this instance targeting the Armenian community here in Glendale … (with) fliers found, I think, more than a dozen of them, scattered in front of a church and throughout other areas in the city,” Cid said. “Any threat to any group or individual in our community really is a threat to our way of life and our entire community. I think as a police department and as a community, we need to take it as such. 

“We’re going to bring all our resources to bear in investigating any of those sorts of incidents, trying to identify who’s responsible for them, working in collaboration with our partners … to try to identify these individuals that are responsible, establish if we have a crime and, if we do, actively look to prosecute it.”

Joseph F. Iniguez, chief of staff from the LA County District Attorney’s Office, explained that many cases of racism cannot be pursued as a crime, as the First Amendment can protect instances of hate speech from prosecution. When a hate incident motivates property damage, physical harm or death, it can then be classed as a hate crime. Despite this distinction, Iniguez said that both events cause immense harm to the victims and wider community.

“When there’s a hate incident, there’s a tremendous impact in the community and on individuals that are impacted by that hate incident, the same way that a hate crime where there may be property damage or physical injury or even death can also have an impact on the community,” he said. “Our relationships with law enforcement are very strong, and we’re confident that when they bring us these cases, we’re going to give them a fair analysis. But more importantly, we’re going to provide victims with services because that’s the biggest component to start the survivor’s healing journey, even if we can’t prosecute a case.”

The need for collaboration was also raised by Robin S. Toma, executive director of the LA County Commission on Human Relations, who stressed the importance of connecting victims with available resources like LA vs. Hate, an online reporting tool.

“I’m sure all of you have seen (anti-racist) statements for a long time,” Toma said. “Just putting a message out there perhaps is not going to change the way we’ve been operating. It’s important, but it’s not enough.

“There’re so many different acts of hate that happen that are completely unknown and unreported, except for people experiencing them. … There are things that we can’t turn to the police and the prosecutors to take action on because it’s just simply not a crime, and that’s where their ability really ends.”

Systems like LA vs. Hate were created so that people can report incidents of hate and not only receive resources like trauma counseling but also take action.

“This is something where you can pursue your civil rights under our state laws, under our federal laws,” Toma said. “Say it happens at a school and you don’t know whether the school’s really taking it seriously. … We’re going to help you work with the school to make sure that they are taking the strongest action as possible, that they know the options they have and the resources they have to take it seriously.”

Cid added that education can be crucial to preventing hate incidents from occurring in the future while also making people aware of resources like LA vs. Hate if they are a victim of racism.

“There’re so many parts of our communities, particularly our immigrant communities, that don’t understand the resources that are available to them,” he said. “The collaboration with our school district can’t be understated. And to be able to educate our youth, let them know and their families know the resources that are available to them is something that this police department takes great lengths in doing. (We) pride ourselves on it, and we’ll keep working at it because by no means have we attained where we’re trying to be, but there’s a great deal of effort that’s being put forth from this organization and this community.”

Nearly 40% of Glendale’s population belongs to the Armenian community. The city has become an important home for Armenian people and their cultural heritage, and both elected leaders and community members alike have expressed their commitment to ending Armenian hate in Glendale.

“It’s not just caring about your own group that’s targeted, but recognizing that we stand for one another when it happens” Toma said. “This won’t change unless we realize that it matters.”

https://www.pasadenaweekly.com/news/stand-tall-to-hate-glendale-town-hall-discusses-anti-armenian-racism/article_b86d93ec-ef61-11ed-9c71-0fdfc94eef56.html 

Next Pashinyan-Aliyev meeting in Brussels: experts do not expect a breakthrough

  • JAMnews
  • Yerevan

Pashinyan-Aliyev meeting in Brussels

Brussels officially confirmed that on May 14 the leaders of Armenia and Azerbaijan will meet through the mediation of the head of the European Council, Charles Michel. Although negotiations between Nikol Pashinyan and Ilham Aliyev have not yet taken place, Western mediators have already announced the possibility of their continuation in Chisinau on June 1, and then, in October, in Granada with the participation of the French and German presidents.

Russia is also stepping up mediation efforts. Talks between the Foreign Ministers of Armenia and Azerbaijan are expected in Moscow on May 19.

On the other hand, the Armenian authorities have recently been increasingly saying that “there is no progress on the key issues.”

Armenian political scientists also believe that it is not worth expecting resolution of differences between the parties in the near future. They consider “Azerbaijan’s maximalism” to be the main obstacle to progress in the negotiation process.

Pashinyan and Aliyev last met in February in Munich. The meeting was mediated by the US Secretary of State. The latest talks between the Foreign Ministers of Armenia and Azerbaijan took place on May 1-4 in Washington. As a result of four days of discussions, Ararat Mirzoyan and Jeyhun Bayramov did not sign a joint statement. However, in the United States, the talks were considered constructive and announced that the delegations participating in them had made significant progress in solving complex problems. Yerevan and Baku believe that “positions on key issues still diverge.”


  • Foreign Ministers of Armenia and Azerbaijan disagree in Washington, but US Secretary of State optimistic
  • Madrid Principles: Interpretation of Pashinyan, Former Armenian Foreign Minister and Expert
  • “The language of threats and terror does not work with Azerbaijan” – Ilham Aliyev

Armen Grigoryan, Secretary of the Security Council of Armenia, told journalists that the discussion that began in Washington will continue in Brussels.

“I think that all meetings, negotiations around the peace treaty are a continuation of each other, because it is known what issues will be discussed,” Grigoryan stated.

He said that during the Washington meeting it was not possible to agree on the most important issues:

“This is the fixation of 29,800 square kilometers of the sovereign territory of the Republic of Armenia, and the creation of the Stepanakert-Baku international mechanism, and the creation of international guarantees [of the implementation of the agreements reached]. Pay attention to the current situation: the elements of the November 9 [2020] tripartite declaration on the cessation of hostilities in Karabakh, signed with the mediation of Russia, cannot be achieved. For example, in the Lachin corridor, according to the trilateral statement, Azerbaijan should not be there, but it is there at the moment.”

As for the forthcoming Armenian-Azerbaijani talks in Brussels, Grigoryan believes that Armenia intends to “bring approaches as close as possible and move forward.”

The Prime Minister of Armenia also talked about disagreements with Azerbaijan. According to Pashinyan, the positions of the parties do not fundamentally coincide regarding ensuring the rights of the Armenians of Nagorno-Karabakh and creating an international mechanism that guarantees the fulfillment of the points of the peace treaty.

“Of course, there is some progress. If earlier there was 1 km between the positions of the parties, now it is 990 meters. This is progress, but the discrepancy is still huge.”

Pashinyan-Aliyev meeting in Brussels

Negotiations continue in the US between the foreign ministers of Armenia and Azerbaijan, but what next?

Political scientist Tigran Grigoryan believes that there will be an attempt in Brussels to continue the discussion on key issues and bring the positions of the parties as close as possible, but he does not share the mediators’ optimism:

“There will be an attempt to have in the near future some kind of ready-made text [of a peace treaty] that can be signed. But there are some serious disagreements. I do not think that the parties will be able to come to any compromise or any acceptable agreement, especially on the creation of an international mechanism for direct negotiations on the Nagorno-Karabakh issue.”

Grigoryan also considers it unlikely that “Baku will agree to withdraw its troops from the territories of Armenia occupied since May 2021.”

He notes that on this issue “the differences between the parties are deeper”, so it is difficult to imagine how a compromise can be reached.

Grigoryan recalls that the positions of Yerevan and Baku also differ greatly on the issue of maps that can be used to delimit the border.

“Armenia talks about the recognition of state administrative borders and refers to the maps of the last years of the existence of the USSR. Azerbaijan talks about the so-called “historical maps” and “implementation of delimitation on Azerbaijani terms.” Perhaps, as a result of the intervention of mediators, it will be possible to slightly soften Azerbaijan’s position, but I consider this unlikely, ”he said.

According to Grigoryan, during the meeting in Brussels, special attention will be paid to the topic of unblocking regional roads.

Pashinyan-Aliyev meeting in Brussels

Political scientist Areg Kochinyan believes that the biggest obstacle to progress in the negotiation process is “Azerbaijani maximalism”:

“Baku is intoxicated with victory in the war and is trying to get everything at once. Destructive behavior and maximalist expectations of Azerbaijan cause great damage when discussing unresolved issues. In particular, the issue of the status of Artsakh and guarantees of security and rights of Artsakh Armenians. Moreover, unlike the issue of status, on the issue of guarantees of ensuring rights in the international community there is a certain understanding of what it should be and it is important that it be.”

According to Kochinyan, the problems lie in the details – what this mechanism should be:

“Will this mechanism be a contingent with a certain right to protect people, some kind of observation mission or some kind of technical and legal complex? So far, there is no concrete answer as to what the international mechanism that should ensure the security and rights of Artsakh Armenians will be.”

https://jam-news.net/pashinyan-aliyev-meeting-in-brussels/

Armenian Diaspora Survey: Local Community Research Results Announced

By MARTIN HARRIS 
The Armenian Diaspora Survey has published the results of the research conducted in 2019, 2021 and 2022. Over 12,000 Armenians in more than 50 diaspora communities in 10 countries share their views on issues such as identity, language, culture, political engagement, and relations with Armenia.

The latest research into today’s Armenian diaspora was funded by the Calouste Gulbenkian Foundation and carried out by the Armenian Institute in London. It was led by a group of international scholars and researchers who studied Armenian communities in different countries.

More details can be found at http://www.armeniandiaspora.com

According to the director of the Armenian Diaspora Survey, Dr. Hratch Tchilingirian, University of Oxford, the newly published survey highlights the multifaceted and complex experiences in diasporic life. In particular, the study found that despite the geographical differences, the defining elements of “Armenia identity” are common among the diaspora communities.

“One generalization we could make based on our research is that Armenian identity is largely self-defined, fluid, and personalized,” explained Dr. Tchilingirian. “Armenians living in the same country or in the same state or city could have different perceptions and understanding of ‘Armenianness’, depending on multiple variables, such as family upbringing, community, personal preferences, and so on.”

The 2021 research was carried out in Belgium, Paris, the United Kingdom, and Rostov-on-Don, and the 2022 survey features the views and opinions of Armenians living in the United States and Ontario, Canada. The results from both surveys are publicly available and can be downloaded at no cost.

The annual survey, whose previous round was completed in 2019 in Argentina, Lebanon, Montreal, and Romania, is intended to fill a critical gap in the evidence-based understanding of the Armenian diaspora. The researchers hope the results will be useful for the public, scholars, policymakers, and community leaders to raise their awareness of the attitudes and views defining the Armenian world in the 21st century.

“We are pleased that this systematic survey that covers a vast geography of the Armenian Diaspora has been successfully completed and the results are published,” said Dr. Razmik Panossian, Director of the Calouste Gulbenkian Foundation’s Armenian Communities Department. “We look forward to building on this research and enhancing its impact on policy development.”

Interested parties can find more information by visiting http://www.armeniandiaspora.com

Source: http://newswire.net/newsroom/pr/00000000-https-www-armeniandiasporasurvey-com.html

1 soldier killed, several others wounded in clashes between Armenia, Azerbaijan

– Associated Press – Thursday,

YEREVAN, Armenia (AP) — Armenian and Azerbaijani troops exchanged artillery fire Thursday along their tense border, leaving at least one soldier dead and several others wounded in the latest bout of escalation between the longtime adversaries that threatened to derail their latest attempts at peace talks.

The two countries’ authorities traded blame for triggering the clashes and accused each other of trying to undermine negotiations on a prospective peace deal.

The Armenian Defense Ministry said that Azerbaijani forces opened artillery fire on Armenian positions near the town of Sotk in the eastern Gegharkunik province, leaving four Armenian soldiers wounded.

Azerbaijan’s Defense Ministry said that one Azerbaijani soldier was killed and another one was wounded by Armenian fire.

The exchange of fire follows U.S.-hosted peace talks earlier this month between the Armenian and Azerbaijani foreign minister, which U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken said had achieved “tangible progress.” Blinken said that he believed a peace deal could be “within sight, within reach” and praised the two sides for coming together to try to find common ground.