Azerbaijan fires mortars on Armenia’s eastern borders

Save

Share

 19:31,

YEREVAN, MAY 12, ARMENPRESS. On May 12, around 7:10 p.m., the units of the Azerbaijani armed forces violated the ceasefire in the direction of Kut, Gegharkunik Province, firing from mortars.

As ARMENPRESS was informed from the Ministry of Defense of the Republic of Armenia, the units of the Armed Forces of the Republic of Armenia have taken appropriate protective and preventive measures.

The Defense Ministry will make additional statement.

Armenpress: Azerbaijan continues shelling Armenia’s eastern borders in Gegharkunik

Share

 19:55,

YEREVAN, MAY 12, ARMENPRESS. As of May 12, at 7:40 p.m., the units of the Azerbaijani Armed Forces continue to fire at the Armenian positions located in the Kut sector, ARMENPRESS was informed from MoD Armenia.

“Azerbaijani armed forces are also using mortars in the direction of the Armenian positions located in the Sotk sector. The units of the Armed Forces of Armenia take appropriate protective and preventive measures.

The Ministry of Defense will issue an additional message,” the message stated.

Armenpress: One Armenian soldier killed, another wounded as a result of Azerbaijani provocation, situation calm at the moment

Save

Share

 21:51,

YEREVAN, MAY 12, ARMENPRESS. As a result of enemy fire on May 12 in the direction of Sotk and Kut, the Armenian side has 1 victim and 1 wounded, ARMENPRESS was informed from MoD Armenia.

“As of 9:40 p.m., the intensity of the fire continues to decrease.

The Ministry of Defense will issue an additional message,” the message reads.

CSWC [Cigar Smoking World Championship ] ARMENIA

As been common the last few years there are several new countries on the Cigar Smoking World Championship circuit and Armenia was the first one out. First time judge Emil Frangyan was in charge of the tournament and founder Marko Bilic was pleased with the debut.

“We’re overjoyed by the great expertise demonstrated by Armenian smokers,” he says. “The winning time was excellent and we can’t wait to see the Armenian champion in person at the grand finale.”

David Ter Gulanyan was the man of the hour when he managed to become the first ever Armenian champion. He finished at 1 hour 52 minutes and 24 seconds, way ahead of Bagrat Dilanyan and Edvard Baghdasaryan in second and third place.

  1. David Ter Gulanyan 01:52:24
  2. Bagrat Dilanyan 01:04:59
  3. Edvard Baghdasaryan 1:03:19

Winner1: Winner David Ter Gulanyan pushing the limits of his cigar.
Winner2: Host Aren Mykolyan with David Ter Gulanyan, Armenia’s first CSWC champion.

Eurovision 2023 semi-final 2 results: Who got through last night and the full list of song contest finalists

iNews, UK
By Jaymi McCann

Now that the semi-finals are over the grand finale of Eurovision is almost here – and we know who will be starring in it.

This year’s song contest is taking place in the UK instead of in last year’s winner Ukraine, due to the Russian invasion of Ukraine.

And Mae Muller, the British entry, will be hoping to emulate the success of Sam Ryder, whose second place in 2022 reversed a series of poor showings.

The remaining 10 finalists from the second semi-final on Thursday evening are:

  • Armenia | Brunette – Future Lover
  • Estonia | Alika – Bridges
  • Belgium | Gustaph – Because of You
  • Cyprus | Andrew Lambrou – Break A Broken Heart
  • Poland | Blanka – Solo
  • Slovenia | Joker Out – Carpe Diem
  • Austria | Teya & Salena – Who The Hell Is Edgar?
  • Albania | Albina & Familja Kelmendi – Duje
  • Lithuania | Monika Linkytė – Stay
  • Australia | Voyager – Promise

The final is on Saturday 13 May at 8pm, following semi-finals on Tuesday and Thursday.

As always, it will be broadcast live on BBC One and BBC iPlayer, with four hours of coverage coming to an end at midnight.

It will be hosted by singer and Britain’s Got Talent judge Alesha Dixon, Ted Lasso actress Hannah Waddingham, and Ukrainian singer Sanina, as well as returning favourite Graham Norton. This year, the BBC chat show host will alternate on commentary duties with the actress Mel Giedroyc.

Scott Mills and Rylan will be providing additional commentary on BBC Radio 2.

Sam Ryder, last year’s Eurovision hero, will performing during the final. Other who will sing include Eurovision 2022 winner Kalush Orchestra, who will perform their powerful new track “Voices of a New Generation”, followed by their winning song “Stefania”.

Afterwards, several Ukrainian performers will sing during a Flag Parade:

  • Go_A (Ukraine 2020 and 2021)
  • Jamala (Ukraine 2016)
  • Verka Serduchka (Ukraine 2007)
  • Tina Karol (Ukraine 2006)

According to the official Eurovision website, fans can expect “a new twist on their Eurovision entries weaved with British classics”.

The BBC has also brought together six iconic past Eurovision acts: Italy’s Mahmood, Israel’s Netta, Iceland’s Daði Freyr, Sweden’s Cornelia Jakobs, Duncan Laurence from the Netherland – and Liverpool’s very own Sonia, celebrating 30 years since she came second at Eurovision in 1993.

In total, 26 countries will take part, out of a total of 37 entrants.

The UK, along with France, Germany, Italy and Spain – the “Big Five” – automatically qualify for the Grand Final due to making the biggest financial contribution towards the organisation of the event. Ukraine, last year’s winner, also qualifies automatically, and there are 20 countries from the two semi-finals.

The running order is:

  • 1. 🇦🇹 Austria | Teya & Salena – Who The Hell Is Edgar?
  • 2. 🇵🇹 Portugal | Mimicat – Ai Coração
  • 3. 🇨🇭 Switzerland | Remo Forrer – Watergun
  • 4. 🇵🇱 Poland | Blanka – Solo
  • 5. 🇷🇸 Serbia | Luke Black – Samo Mi Se Spava
  • 6. 🇫🇷 France: La Zarra – Évidemment
  • 7. 🇨🇾 Cyprus | Andrew Lambrou – Break A Broken Heart
  • 8. 🇪🇸 Spain: Blanca Paloma – Eaea
  • 9. 🇸🇪 Sweden | Loreen – Tattoo
  • 10. 🇦🇱 Albania | Albina & Familja Kelmendi – Duje
  • 11. 🇮🇹 Italy: Marco Mengoni – Due Vite
  • 12. 🇪🇪 Estonia | Alika – Bridges
  • 13. 🇫🇮 Finland | Käärijä – Cha Cha Cha
  • 14. 🇨🇿 Czechia | Vesna – My Sister’s Crown
  • 15. 🇦🇺 Australia | Voyager – Promise
  • 16. 🇧🇪 Belgium | Gustaph – Because Of You
  • 17.  🇦🇲 Armenia | Brunette – Future Lover
  • 18. 🇲🇩 Moldova | Pasha Parfeni – Soarele şi Luna
  • 19. 🇺🇦 Ukraine: TVORCHI – Heart of Steel
  • 20. 🇳🇴 Norway | Alessandra – Queen of Kings
  • 21. 🇩🇪 Germany: Lord of the Lost – Blood & Glitter
  • 22. 🇱🇹 Lithuania | Monika Linkytė – Stay
  • 23. 🇮🇱 Israel | Noa Kirel – Unicorn
  • 24. 🇸🇮 Slovenia | Joker Out – Carpe Diem
  • 25. 🇭🇷 Croatia | Let 3 – Mama ŠČ!
  • 26. 🇬🇧 United Kingdom: Mae Muller – I Wrote A Song

Armenia-Azerbaijan clashes threaten to derail peace talks

Armenia and Azerbaijan on Thursday (11 May) blamed each other for a deadly exchange of fire along their border, which threatened to derail momentum to resolve a long-running dispute days ahead of EU-led peace talks.

The United States and rival Russia both urged restraint between the Caucasus neighbours after the clash that left one person dead and injured four, the latest flare-up in a decades-long dispute over the Nagorno-Karabakh region.

Armenia initially said four of its soldiers had been wounded by incoming fire in an eastern region of the ex-Soviet country.

“Azerbaijani forces are shooting artillery and mortars at Armenian positions in the Sotk region,” Armenia’s defence ministry said.

The Sotk region in Eastern Armenia is known for its gold mines.

Sotk is in Armenia proper, and is at some distance from the disputed Nagorno-Karabakh. Armenia is member of the Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO), a Russia-led lose defense pact, according to which Moscow should come to the rescue of a member whose territory is under attack.

Baku accused Armenia of a “provocation” that had left one of its soldiers dead.

It said Armenian troops had “once again violated the ceasefire agreement” with “large-calibre weapons”, referring to an accord from November 2020 that ended six weeks of hostilities.

Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan and Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev have been scheduled to meet Sunday in Brussels for talks led by European Council President Charles Michel.

The leaders of Armenia and Azerbaijan will hold talks in Brussels on Sunday (14 May), the European Union said, amid efforts to reach a peace deal over their three-decade territorial dispute.

The rival leaders had also agreed to jointly meet the leaders of France and Germany on the sidelines of a European summit in Moldova on 1 June, according to the EU.

Pashinyan on Thursday accused Azerbaijan of looking to “undermine the talks” in Brussels.

“I have not changed my mind about going to Brussels,” he said in a statement, but warned there was “very little” chance of signing a peace deal with Azerbaijan at the meeting.

A draft agreement “is still at a very preliminary stage and it is too early to speak of an eventual signature”, Pashinyan said.

The EU-led diplomacy comes after US Secretary of State Antony Blinken brought the Azerbaijani and Armenian foreign ministers to Washington for negotiations in early May.

State Department spokesman Vedant Patel said the two countries should embrace in Brussels a proposal by Blinken that would distance forces along the border.

“This kind of violence, we believe — it undermines the progress made by Armenia and Azerbaijan toward a durable and dignified peace,” Patel told reporters in Washington.

“We believe that there continues to be a durable path forward. We believe that there is a peaceful solution to this,” Patel said.

The West has stepped up mediation as the clout of Russia, historically the major powerbroker between the former Soviet republics, wanes due to its invasion of Ukraine.

In Moscow, Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said: “We expect a restrained approach from the parties and urge them not to take any actions that could lead to an increase in tensions.”

Armenia has traditionally relied on Russia as its ally and security guarantor, but Yerevan has grown increasingly frustrated with Moscow.

It has accused Russia of failing to fulfill its peacekeeping role when Azerbaijani activists blocked the Lachin corridor, the only land link to Armenia.

The two countries have gone to war twice over disputed territories, mainly Nagorno-Karabakh, a majority-Armenian region inside Azerbaijan, which has close ties with Turkey.

Tens of thousands of people have been killed in the two wars over the region.

The first war lasted six years, until 1994. The second, fought in 2020, ended in a Russia-negotiated ceasefire.

Under that ceasefire, Azerbaijan is required to guarantee safe passage on the Lachin corridor, which is patrolled by Russian peacekeepers.

Azerbaijan said on Sunday (23 April) it had established a checkpoint on the only land route to the contested region of Nagorno-Karabakh, a step that was followed by claims of border shootings by both Azeri and Armenian forces.

In a new escalation at the end of end April, Azerbaijan said it had built a checkpoint on the corridor following “threats and provocations” from Armenia.

Armenia denounced the move as a ceasefire violation and said the claims were a “far-fetched and baseless pretext”.

(Edited by Georgi Gotev)

https://www.euractiv.com/section/global-europe/news/armenia-azerbaijan-clashes-threaten-to-derail-peace-talks/

Applying International Environmental Law Conventions in Occupied Territory: The Azerbaijan v. Armenia Case under the Bern Convention

Introduction 

On 18 January 2023, Azerbaijan announced that it had launched against Armenia an inter-state case under the dispute settlement provision in the 1979 Convention on the Conservation of European Wildlife and Natural Habitats (Bern Convention).  Azerbaijan notified the Bern Convention Secretariat of the dispute by letter on 27 March 2023, stating that negotiations would have failed to resolve it and that the dispute had been submitted to arbitration. This is another episode in a fiery exchanges of legal proceedings between the two states, in particular in relation to the contested area of Nagorno-Karabakh. At the time this post is written, there is a pending case brought by Azerbaijan against Armenia before the International Court of Justice (ICJ), a pending case brought by Armenia against Azerbaijan before the same Court,  a number of inter-state proceedings before the European Court of Human Rights, and, most recently, an arbitration initiated by Azerbaijan under the Energy Charter Treaty.

Azerbaijan’s Bern Convention initiative has reached mainstream media not only because it is a new chapter in the legal battle on the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict (which has sparked several international law commentaries over the years), but because it pertains to environmental damage in armed conflict. According to its January 2023 press release, Azerbaijan seeks an order that Armenia cease all ongoing violations of the Bern Convention, and pay full reparation for environmental destruction in the formerly occupied territories. This is the first time that the inter-state dispute settlement provision under the Bern Convention has been invoked.  This blog post analyses the relevance of this case in relation to the applicability of multilateral environmental agreements in occupied territory. Using the lack of explicit rules on the protection of the environment in occupied territory as a starting point, we will explore whether environmental treaties such as the Bern Convention are applicable to occupied territory, and their potential to enhance the protection of the environment in occupied areas. We will also discuss under which conditions the specific inter-state mechanisms under the Bern Convention can be activated.

The Law of Occupation and the Environment 

The area of Nagorno-Karabakh has been under Armenian occupation between 1994 and 2020 (see e.g. RULAC). The rules governing occupied territory (so-called law of occupation) are customary in nature and are mainly codified by the 1907 Hague Regulations (HR), the 1949 Fourth Geneva Convention (GCIV), and the 1977 First Additional Protocol (API). In contrast to the law on the conduct of the hostilities, which offers some protection to the environment (see e.g. Articles 35(3) and 55 API), the law of occupation contains no explicit reference to the protection of the environment.

The limited protection offered by the law of occupation to the environment is limited and indirect. For instance, under Article 43 HR, the occupying power must take ‘all the measures in his power to restore, and ensure, as far as possible, public order and civil life, while respecting, unless absolutely prevented, the laws in force in the country.’ There is a mutual relationship between the occupant’s responsibility under the first part of Article 43 to maintain public order and civil life on the one hand, and the protection of the environment in the occupied territory. The more the environment is protected, the more civil life of the local population is guaranteed. Moreover, the duty to respect ‘unless absolutely prevented, the laws in force in the country’ prior to the occupation encompasses the duty to respect the local environmental legislation.

Moreover, indirect protection of the environment under the law of occupation can be provided through the rules on property and objects indispensable to the survival of civilians. The rules on both public and private property in the law of occupation focus on the illegality of aspects of the occupying power’s conduct such as unjustified destruction and pillage of property in the occupied territory, as recently affirmed by the 2023 French Military Manual (section 4.4.2.5). For example, Articles 46(2) and 55 HR, Article 53 GCIV, and Article 54 API can be applied to those elements of the environment that are private or public property. For instance, in 2005, the ICJ has recognised the responsibility of Uganda for the illegal exploitation of some components of the natural environment in occupied DRC in light of the applicable rules of the law of occupation on property (paras 219 and 245); later in 2022, the Court awarded to DRC reparations for damage to flora and fauna caused by Uganda in the occupied region of Ituri (paras 328-363).

However, not all the components of the environment are either public or private property. In part to adopt a more comprehensive approach to the protection of the environment in armed conflict, since 2013, the ILC has been working on codifying the rules on the protection of the environment in relation to armed conflicts, with significant attention devoted to occupied territories.

The Applicability of the Bern Convention in Occupied Territory

Although scholars have debated for decades whether international environmental treaties apply to armed conflict and occupied territories (see e.g. Bothe et als; Dam-de Jong; Sjostedt; Longobardo; Dienelt), no international court or tribunal has provided an answer to whether these conventions apply to occupied territory (Abegón Novella, section IV.III). Accordingly, if the proceedings launched by Azerbaijan against Armenia result in an arbitral award on the merits, this would be an important precedent with potentially significant repercussions in this field.

Although in the Nuclear Weapons opinion, the ICJ avoided the question affirming that ‘the issue is not whether the treaties relating to the protection of the environment are or are not applicable during an armed conflict, but rather whether the obligations stemming from these treaties were intended to be obligations of total restraint during military conflict’ (para 30), the International Law Commission (ILC) has confirmed that the existence of an armed conflict does not suspend or terminate the application of a treaty (Article 3 2011 Draft articles on the effects of armed conflicts on treaties). Rather, the ILC considered that ‘treaties relating to the international protection of the environment’ are among those treaties whose ‘subject-matter … involves an implication that they continue in operation’ (ibid, Article 7 and Annex, g).

The analysis of whether the Bern Convention applies to occupied territory can be performed taking into account the twofold test devised to assess whether international human rights law conventions are applicable to occupied territory (see e.g. Ben-Naftali and Shany; Vité; Lubell; Gutiérrez Castillo): first, it is necessary to explore whether a certain convention is applicable to situations of armed conflict given that occupations are situations of armed conflict; and second, one has to explore if the convention applies extraterritorially, the occupied territory being located outside the sovereign territory of the occupying power. The analogy with the applicability of international human rights law conventions is logical: the legal issues at hand are similar (i.e., the applicability of peacetime conventions in armed conflict outside the territory of a state). Moreover, international human rights law is relevant per se to the protection of the environment in occupied territory e.g. in the field of the right to health (see Hulme).

The Bern Convention does not include any provision regarding its application to situations of armed conflict and occupation, nor does it address its extraterritorial scope of application. However, that does not mean the Convention is not applicable to situations of occupation. The applicability of the Bern Convention to occupied territory can be compared to the applicability of the 1966 International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR), which, similarly, does not contain any clause on its application in armed conflict and on its extraterritorial scope. In 2004, the ICJ affirmed in its Wall opinion that the ICESCR is applicable to occupied territory (para 112). There is no reason why such an approach should not be employed by the arbitral tribunal created under the Bern Convention in relation to the application of the Bern Convention to Nagorno-Karabakh: nothing in the Bern Convention excludes its applicability during armed conflict and denying its applicability to situations of extraterritorial jurisdiction (i.e., occupations) would frustrate the object and purpose of the Convention itself. In this vein, in relation to the 1971 Ramsar Convention, the Conference of the Contracting Parties in 2022 confirmed that its obligations are applicable to Ukrainian territory under Russia occupation.

In light of the above, we consider that the Bern Convention is applicable to the occupation of the Nagorno-Karabakh, along with international humanitarian law. Accordingly, there is no reason that the arbitral tribunal should decline to hear the case because of the inapplicability of the Bern Convention.

Procedural Issues under the Bern Convention

The arbitral proceedings have been commenced by Azerbaijan under Article 18 of the Bern Convention. This provision refers first to the role of the Convention’s Standing Committee in facilitating a friendly settlement of any difficulty to which the execution of the convention may give rise. Where a dispute between contracting parties cannot be settled through the endeavours of the Standing Committee or by negotiation, then Article 18 provides for arbitration at the request of one of the parties to the dispute.  It is not uncommon for multilateral environmental agreements to provide for arbitration of disputes concerning the interpretation or application of their provisions, either at the request of one party to the dispute or with the agreement of both parties. In such instances, the agreement often incorporates  a set of arbitration provisions, while providing for the tribunal to determine its own rules of procedure (see for example, Convention on Biological Diversity, Annex II; OSPAR Convention, Article 32). Article 18 of the Bern Convention does not contain a full set of arbitration rules. It sets out the rules governing the appointment of arbitrators, and the tribunal is then to draw up its own rules of procedure. Each party to the dispute should designate one arbitrator, and the two party-appointed arbitrators should appoint a third.

Article 18 contains a default appointment procedure, so that the arbitral tribunal can be constituted even if one of the parties does not designate an arbitrator. This could be a time-consuming process. If a party fails to designate an arbitrator within three months of the request for arbitration, the other party may request the President of the European Court of Human Rights to designate an arbitrator within the next three months. The same procedure applies if, within three months of their designation, the two designated arbitrators cannot agree on the choice of the third arbitrator.  If Armenia rejects Azerbaijan’s complaints and objects to them being formulated in the terms of compliance with the Bern Convention, one might anticipate a lengthy process for the constitution of the arbitral tribunal, and, in due course, objections to jurisdiction and admissibility.

Besides the applicability of the Convention to the dispute, a further jurisdictional hurdle might be whether prior recourse to negotiation or to the friendly settlement role of the Convention’s Standing Committee constitutes a prerequisite to commencement of arbitral proceedings under Article 18 (in ICJ, see Georgia v Russian Federation and Ukraine v Russian Federation, and see Nakajima).

Should the arbitral tribunal be established, there are plenty of examples of inter-state arbitration rules upon which the tribunal might draw, including those established by other MEAs, and the optional rules published by the Permanent Court of Arbitration, which include specific rules for arbitrating disputes between states, and rules for arbitrating disputes relating to natural resources and the environment. Any use and adaptation of such rules would generally be made in consultation with the parties to the dispute.  Given the nature of Azerbaijan’s claims, rules relating to scientific evidence and the possible appointment of experts in respect of the identification, attribution and assessment of environmental damage are likely be of particular importance. Such issues have proved challenging for international courts in recent cases involving compensation for damage to the environment, including in the context of armed conflict (on assessment of compensation, see for example, Certain Activities (Costa Rica v Nicaragua) and Armed Activities (DRC v Uganda), and see Desierto, Bendel). Further, arbitration rules relating to the failure of a party to appear or make submissions in the proceedings may also be of significance.

Under Article 18 of the Bern Convention, decisions of the tribunal may be taken by majority vote, and the arbitral award is final and binding. Parties are to bear the expenses of their designated arbitrator, and share the expenses of the third arbitrator and other costs entailed by the arbitration. The designation of the registry and provisions for the administration for the arbitration are also not addressed in Article 18. The Permanent Court of Arbitration has been selected as the registry for most inter-state arbitral proceedings in recent years, but it may also be that this role could be fulfilled within the Council of Europe institutions.

Conclusions

This post has explored the potential for the pending arbitral proceedings between Azerbaijan and Armenia under the Bern Convention to offer an authoritative clarification on whether multilateral environmental treaties conventions apply in occupied territory. We argued that this is possible. Accordingly, the outcomes of these proceedings should be closely monitored since they offer the possibility to finally conclude that international environmental law complements the law of occupation in relation to the protection of the environment in occupied territory.

The dispute also has implications for the evolution of the Council of Europe’s approach to environmental protection in armed conflict. In early 2023, the Parliamentary Assembly adopted a resolution and a recommendation, which  propose, among others, consideration of further measures under the Bern Convention and/or under a separate regional legal instrument on the protection of the environmentally during armed conflicts.

Armenia reports new border clashes with Azerbaijan forces

At least two Armenian forces have been wounded after Baku used drones in the direction of Sotk, according to Yerevan.

Renewed border clashes have erupted between Armenian and Azerbaijani forces, according to Yerevan, a day after deadly fighting threatened to derail European Union-led weekend peace talks between the Caucasus arch-foes.

Baku and Yerevan are locked in a decades-long territorial dispute over Azerbaijan’s Armenian-populated region of Nagorno-Karabakh, over which they have fought two wars.

On Friday morning, “Azerbaijani Armed Forces violated the ceasefire in the direction of Sotk (eastern part of the state border) using UAVs”, the defence ministry in Yerevan said in a statement.

It said “two servicemen of the Armenian armed forces were wounded”, and one of them is in a critical condition.

Border clashes on Thursday left an Azerbaijani serviceman dead and four Armenian troops injured.

Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan and Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev are scheduled to meet on Sunday in Brussels for talks led by European Council President Charles Michel.

The rival leaders had also agreed to jointly meet the leaders of France and Germany on the sidelines of a European summit in Moldova on June 1, according to the EU.

Pashinyan on Thursday accused Azerbaijan of looking to “undermine the talks” in Brussels.

He warned there was “very little” chance of signing a peace deal with Azerbaijan at the meeting.

A draft agreement “is still at a very preliminary stage and it is too early to speak of an eventual signature”, Pashinyan said.

The EU-led diplomacy comes after US Secretary of State Antony Blinken brought the Azerbaijani and Armenian foreign ministers to Washington for negotiations in early May.

The West has stepped up mediation as the clout of Russia, historically the key powerbroker between the former Soviet republics, wanes due to its invasion of Ukraine.

Armenia, which has traditionally relied on Russia as its security guarantor, has grown increasingly frustrated with Moscow.

It has accused Russia of having failed to fulfil its peacekeeping role when Azerbaijani activists blocked Karabakh’s only land link to Armenia.

The two countries went to war in 2020 and in the 1990s over disputed territories, mainly Nagorno-Karabakh.

Tens of thousands of people have been killed in the two wars over the region.

https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2023/5/12/armenia-reports-fresh-border-clashes-with-azerbaijan-forces