Armenian and Azerbaijani leaders meet for the fifth time in Brussels

May 16 2023
Heydar Isayev May 16, 2023

The leaders of Armenia and Azerbaijan held their latest meeting in Brussels on May 14. The president of the European Council, who mediated, released a statement afterwards asserting that significant progress was made towards a peace agreement. 

But the parties, Prime Minister of Armenia Nikol Pashinyan and President of Azerbaijan Ilham Aliyev, gave no indication that a final accord was at hand.

Pashinyan, Aliyev, and President of the European Council Charles Michel met for the fifth time since the Second Karabakh War in 2020 in which Azerbaijan regained large swathes of territory in and around Nagorno-Karabakh from Armenian forces. (Azerbaijan-Armenia post-war talks have also been mediated by the U.S., which coordinates with the EU, and by Russia, which does not.)

“Together, we reviewed all issues on our agenda,” Michel said in his statement. “Following the recent positive talks held in the United States on the peace treaty, the momentum should be maintained to take decisive steps towards the signing of a comprehensive peace agreement between Armenia and Azerbaijan.”

Michel said that the sides agreed to resume bilateral talks on the demarcation of the mutual state border with a shared “unequivocal commitment to the 1991 Almaty Declaration and the respective territorial integrity of Armenia (29,800 km2) and Azerbaijan (86,600 km2).” 

The specific mention of the two countries’ areas means, effectively, that Armenia accepts Nagorno-Karabakh as part of Azerbaijan while Azerbaijan doesn’t claim any territory in the Republic of Armenia. 

Azerbaijan has made numerous incursions into Armenian territory since the 2020 war, justifying its moves by the lack of a demarcated border. The Armenian website Civilnet estimates that Azerbaijani troops are currently holding at least 215 square kilometers of land belonging to the Republic of Armenia. 

Michel also reported progress on the issue of connectivity between Azerbaijan and its Nakhchivan exclave through southern Armenia. “Positions on this topic have now come very close to each other in particular on the reopening of the railway connections to and via Nakhchivan. Their respective teams have been tasked to finalize an in-principle agreement on the modalities for the opening of the railway connections and the necessary construction works together with a concrete timetable. They also agreed to draw upon the support of the World Customs Organization in supporting this work,” the statement read.

Azerbaijan earlier pushed for a seamless corridor to Nakhchivan without any Armenian border or customs checks, but has lately seemed to back down from this demand. 

“The invitation to the World Customs Organization to support the discussions should mitigate concerns that this route will become a ‘corridor’ while still keeping preferential arrangements for Baku and its exclave – maybe similar to Kaliningrad?,” tweeted Olesya Vartanyan, a senior South Caucasus analyst at the International Crisis Group. 

Michel said that more military detainees would be freed “in the coming weeks”. “I also stressed the need to safeguard the mutual understanding that soldiers who have simply got lost and crossed to the other side would continue to be released through a speedy procedure,” Michel said. In one recent case, two Azerbaijani soldiers crossed into Armenia – by mistake, according to the Azerbaijani Defence Ministry – and one of them was sentenced to 11.5 years in prison on charges of illegal crossing and smuggling weapons, while the other awaits trial for the murder of a civilian. 

Michel again spoke of “the need for a transparent and constructive dialogue between Baku and the population” of Armenian-controlled Nagorno Karabakh, emphasizing “developing a positive agenda with the aim of guaranteeing the rights and security of this population, in close cooperation with the international community.”

Dialogue between Baku and representatives of the Armenian population of Nagorno-Karabakh seemed to have launched in earnest two months ago but faltered amid Azerbaijan’s continuing blockade of the region and regular flare-ups of violence.

Michel announced that the next meeting between the three in Brussels will be in July, and that Aliyev and Pashinyan will also meet with President Emmanuel Macron of France and Chancellor Olaf Scholz of Germany on the margins of the 2nd European Political Community Summit in Chisinau. 

“Will it resolve all the past concerns in Yerevan and Stepanakert toward Brussels? Certainly not. There are and will be many who will question different parts of this statement and why certain issues did not get into the text,” Vartanyan tweeted. “What’s important is that after more than eight months Brussels is finally back to hosting such meetings – this will not resolve all the problems overnight, but should hopefully prevent emergence of new issues.”

Heydar Isayev is a journalist from Baku.

https://eurasianet.org/armenian-and-azerbaijani-leaders-meet-for-the-fifth-time-in-brussels

An interview with the Secretary of the Security Council of Armenia on relations with Russia

May 16 2023
  • JAMnews

Armenia’s independence and relations with Russia

Novaya Gazeta Europe published the opinion of the Secretary of the Security Council of Armenia, Armen Grigoryan, on issues of concern to the country’s society.Journalist Jan Shenkman asked Grigoryan questions about the problems between Armenia and Russia, the presence of the Russian military in Karabakh, “which is no longer a factor of stability”, why the Pashinyan government is “so indecisive and cannot choose between Russia and the West”, and how the confrontation in Karabakh will end.


  • Is ban on export of dairy products from Armenia to Russian Federation a political decision?
  • Criticism of Russia and the CSTO by the Armenian authorities
  • Ratification of the Rome Statute: will the Armenian authorities go against Russia?

– There is nothing strange here. In recent years the security architecture in the world and in our region has changed dramatically. Before, everything was clear and understandable. We thought that it would be possible to call on the phone and say: “I have a problem.” In response, they would say: “Okay, my friend, we will help.” We have tried and seen that this mechanism does not work. Contractual obligations are not respected. Our whole security concept was built on this, but there is no new one yet.

The mechanisms that were supposed to ensure the security of Armenia have collapsed, new ones have not been created. This is the crisis.

We need to look for new mechanisms and arms supplies, because objectively we do not get what we ordered and paid Russia for. The 2021 contract for hundreds of millions of dollars, which is still not closed, is not the only one. There are several such contracts. And we also expected from the CSTO that it would work in September last year during the direct aggression of Azerbaijan on Armenian territory. It didn’t work and so on.

On a recent message from the Russian Foreign Ministry on the upcoming EU civilian mission to the Armenian border

– You are right in some ways, not in others. Shelling and provocations occur not only when we are negotiating with the West.

In 2018, when the revolution took place in Armenia, we said that this is an internal democratic process, it will not influence foreign policy. And we continued to work with Russia, but this did not guarantee us security: we got the war of 2020.

Another example. In 2013, President Serzh Sargsyan decided to join the Customs Union, which later became known as the EAEU. He was given to understand that if he did not do this, there would be problems in Nagorno-Karabakh. The main argument for joining the Union for Sargsyan was the security of Karabakh. After that we got two wars. April 2016 and September 2020.

Human rights activist on Putin’s extradition – “Facilitating the arrest of Putin is in the interests of Armenia.”

– Yes, there is such a danger. In fact, there are many vulnerabilities. We need to diversify the economy, but we cannot do it overnight.

So far, there is only one way to preserve sovereignty and prevent interference in the internal affairs of Armenia – these are the democratic institutions that we have managed to build.

– A complete reform of the security structures is needed to curb any intelligence activity. We must ensure that our institutions serve only Armenia.

Right now we cannot interfere, but in the future we can and will do it. By the way, everyone remembers that until recently Russian border guards were sitting at the Zvartnots airport, and now Armenian border guards are also sitting. So, there is progress. But sovereignty is a long way to go. You can’t wake up one day and be completely independent.

Even if you are in a hurry, it is impossible to change the sequence of actions. It has to e step by step.

We honestly admit that we do not yet have a solution, but we are looking for it. We have a chance, an opportunity. But there are no guarantees.

Armenia and Russia have completely stopped mutual Armenia and Russia have completely stopped mutual settlements in dollars and euros. settlements in dollars and euros. Economist Armen Ktoyan’s opinion on the situation as a whole, the risks that have arisen and how to overcome them

– Since the beginning of December 2022, Armenia has been saying on all international platforms that Azerbaijan has plans for ethnic cleansing in Karabakh. Let’s see who has the ability to prevent them. First, the peacekeeping forces of the Russian Federation, which are located in Nagorno-Karabakh. Moreover, under the 2020 agreements, they are obliged to do so. But they don’t.

You understand the tragedy of the situation: Russian peacekeepers are in Karabakh, and people are talking about the threat of ethnic cleansing. They have no hope of being rescued.

The second chance is the international community. Armenia has long been lobbying to send an international observation mission to Karabakh. At least observant.

– Unrecognized, but the international community is committed to preventing genocide wherever it happens.

More and more experts advise the Armenian authorities to take a decisive stance and abandon pseudo-allied relations with Russia while it is still possible to change something

– It was until recently. Now the mood has changed under the influence of circumstances. This is a very interesting topic. Russia began to treat Armenia worse because after the revolution a pro-Western party came to power.

Can such a huge country like Russia change its geopolitical plans and rebuild its strategy because of the changes in the leadership of Armenia?

There are no pro-Western sentiments in Nagorno-Karabakh. No Soros. Instead of NATO – the Russian peacekeeping contingent. And yet there are anti-Russian sentiments. Why do you think? Because of Russia itself, not because of the West. Russia shapes the attitude towards itself.

– But this is already happening, gas is already flowing within the framework of the existing infrastructures. I don’t think that’s the issue, or at least not only that.

In any case, Armenia will never agree to an extraterritorial corridor through its territory. For us, this is a red line.

– What if there is a war?

– Then there is a war.

https://jam-news.net/armenias-independence-and-relations-with-russia/

Hematologist Trains at Moffitt, Hoping to Benefit Armenians

May 15 2023

By Steve Blanchard – May 15, 2023

Navigating the intricacies of allogeneic transplants is a specialty of Dr. Nelli Bejanyan. The program leader of Blood and Marrow Transplant and the head of the Leukemia/Myeloid Section of the Department of Blood and Marrow Transplant and Cellular Immunotherapy at Moffitt Cancer Center is renowned for her expertise in transplanting healthy donor (allogeneic) stem cells into patients with blood cancers such as acute leukemia.

It’s a skill and an expertise that isn’t available everywhere around the globe. But with the specialized BMT training program at Moffitt, Bejanyan hopes to change that. She wants to start with her home country of Armenia.

This year, Bejanyan invited hematologist Dr. Nerses Ghahramanyan from Yeolyan Hematology Center in Yerevan, Armenia, to learn as much as he can about allogenic transplantation at Moffitt. The goal is to take that knowledge and experience back to Armenia, where adult patients have no access to curative allogeneic bone marrow transplants.

“In my country I treat blood cancers like leukemia, lymphoma and myeloma,” Ghahramanyan said. “I am here to gain expertise in BMT, specifically allogeneic transplants. In Armenia, there are challenges also with research and clinical trials. It’s part of my dream to establish a strong allogeneic BMT program and develop research in that field in my country.”

“It’s part of my dream to establish a strong allogeneic BMT program and develop research in that field in my country,” says Dr. Nerses Ghahramanyan, who will bring his knowledge back to Armenia later this summer.

Gaining Guidance and Education

Access to clinical trials in allogeneic BMT and broad exposure to transplant cases are big advantages for Ghahramanyan while visiting Moffitt. The guidance provided by Bejanyan is also crucial to his education and his ability to relay what he learns to fellow doctors in Armenia when he returns home later this summer.

Bejanyan and Ghahramanyan met in 2019 at the 5th International Medical Congress of Armenia. In 2021, Bejanyan spoke with Moffitt leadership about offering a training program to Armenia, and since then every week, she has been mentoring Ghahramanyan online.

Leadership at Moffitt was supportive of a hands-on training program, and Ghahramanyan was on the short list of physicians considered for the opportunity. He accepted immediately.

Bejanyan has personal experience with the importance of having access to lifesaving allogeneic transplants. It was the lack of that option that led to the passing of her cousin in the early 1990s and inspired her to pursue a career in blood and marrow transplant, Bejanyan said.

“My cousin was 28 and had acute myeloid leukemia,” Bejanyan said. “She had two kids, one of those children was only 40 days old when she died.”

Her cousin did not have access to the appropriate care such as leukemia chemotherapy and allogeneic transplant.

“This was in the early 1990s and I always thought, ‘Maybe I should learn this,’” she said. “I would hear heartbreaking stories like hers and it was just too expensive to move patients elsewhere for transplants.”

Since moving to and pursuing post-graduate education in the United States more than 20 years ago, Bejanyan has worked to hone her expertise, as well as teach other physicians the techniques that can save the lives of leukemia patients.

Learning All He Can

Ghahramanyan, 28, has already established himself in the blood and marrow transplant community of Armenia. He spends 90% of his time in the clinic, he said, because there are not many opportunities to conduct research.

“So, I really haven’t done much research in my home country,” Ghahramanyan said. “I am really surprised and impressed with the number of clinical trials going on here in the United States. Part of my dream is to develop research in hematology and BMT in my country. It’s an essential part of developing successful treatment.”

Bejanyan is not only giving Ghahramanyan a chance to see how research is conducted at Moffitt, she’s also giving him an opportunity to see all aspects of patient care, from the clinicians, nurses and pharmacists on the floor to the researchers in the lab.

According to Bejanyan, Moffitt performs 450 transplants a year on average, and she is working to expand the cancer center’s program.

“We provide excellent care, and we have the experience,” she said. “Our one-year survival exceeds the expected national requirements.”

“We provide excellent care, and we have the experience. Our one-year survival exceeds the expected national requirements.”

– Dr. Nelli Bejanyan, Department of Blood and Marrow Transplant and Cellular Immunotherapy

Moffitt’s one-year survival rate for patients who undergo allogeneic transplant is at 78%, she said.

“If we look at the entire patient population receiving allogeneic transplant, we can cure 50 to 60%,” she said. “There is still a risk of recurrence for disease and a risk for mortality from the transplant. But in many cases, if you don’t do the transplant, you won’t survive.”

And that is exactly why Ghahramanyan wants to take what he is learning at Moffitt and make it available in Armenia. Providing an option that is unavailable will save countless lives.

“For Armenia, my team there is well-equipped,” Ghahramanyan said. “I hope to get back to my team, start performing allogeneic transplants for blood cancers and transfer the knowledge I’ve gained here to my colleagues.”

Ghahramanyan said he doesn’t know of any other cancer treatment plan that is more complex than allogeneic transplants.

“My hope is that my experience will change lives — change patient care — for my whole country,” he said.

https://moffitt.org/endeavor/archive/hematologist-trains-at-moffitt-hoping-to-benefit-armenians/

Armenia’s Possible Withdrawal From CSTO Not On Agenda – Foreign Ministry

May 16 2023

 

The possibility of Armenia withdrawing from the Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO) is not currently on the agenda, but it appears to have been after the escalation at the border with Azerbaijan last fall, Armenian Deputy Foreign Minister Mnatsakan Safaryan said on Tuesday

YEREVAN (UrduPoint News / Sputnik – 16th May, 2023) The possibility of Armenia withdrawing from the Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO) is not currently on the agenda, but it appears to have been after the escalation at the border with Azerbaijan last fall, Armenian Deputy Foreign Minister Mnatsakan Safaryan said on Tuesday.

On Monday, Armenian Security Council Secretary Armen Grigoryan said that the Armenian government mulled leaving the CSTO, adding that the organization’s mechanism did not work properly and the member states failed to fulfill their commitments.

“There is not such an issue on the agenda at the moment,” Safaryan told reporters, when asked whether the country was considering withdrawal from the CSTO.

Commenting on Grigoryan’s remarks, Safaryan admitted that such a possibility could have been discussed during the session of the Armenian Security Council after the escalation at the border with Azerbaijan in September 2022.

“I cannot give you the exact date (when the discussions took place), because apparently it was discussed during the session of the Security Council.

I think it was at the time of the September events. Please check (with the Security Council),” the Armenian senior diplomat told reporters.

Safaryan stressed that a decision had finally been made not to withdraw, but to continue the work within the organization, with Yerevan hoping for certain results.

The developments come after in March, Armenia refused to send a representative to serve as Deputy Secretary General of the CSTO. Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan has repeatedly said that Yerevan had witnessed the organization’s inaction in 2021-2022.

In September 2022, an outbreak of hostilities between Yerevan and Baku was reported in an area unrelated to the breakaway Nagorno-Karabakh region (also known as the self-proclaimed Republic of Artsakh) � the most serious escalation since the 2020 events. Armenia and Azerbaijan accused each other of shelling and reported losses in their ranks.

https://www.urdupoint.com/en/world/armenias-possible-withdrawal-from-csto-not-o-1692629.html

Armenian Security Council in 2022 discussed withdrawal from CSTO, says senior diplomat

 TASS 
Russia – May 16 2023
“At the moment, the withdrawal from the CSTO is out of the question, the rest will be discussed additionally,” Armenian Deputy Foreign Minister Mnatsakan Safaryan said

YEREVAN, May 16. /TASS/. The Armenian Security Council discussed in September 2022 the possibility of the country’s withdrawal from the CSTO (Collective Security Treaty Organization), but decided to remain a member of the organization, a Foreign Ministry representative said.

“Apparently, I think it (Armenia’s withdrawal from the CSTO – TASS) has been discussed at a Security Council meeting in September 2022. It was decided not to take such a step, to remain in the organization. At the moment, the withdrawal from the CSTO is out of the question, the rest will be discussed additionally,” Armenian Deputy Foreign Minister Mnatsakan Safaryan told the briefing.

According to the senior diplomat, Armenia, as a CSTO member state, continues to hope that the work carried out will yield positive results. “We’ve repeatedly stated that there must be a political assessment of Azerbaijan’s aggression by the CSTO. At some point, the discussion about [CSTO] observers may be resumed,” he added.

https://tass.com/world/1618111

Expert: It’s naive to think Baku recognizes Armenia’s territorial integrity

Panorama
Armenia – May 15 2023

Iran specialist Vardan Voskanyan has dismissed claims about Azerbaijan’s recognition of Armenia’s territorial integrity and a “bright future” it could lead to.

President of the European Council Charles Michel said after Sunday’s talks with Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan and Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev that the two leaders “confirmed their unequivocal commitment to the 1991 Almaty Declaration and the respective territorial integrity of Armenia (29,800 km2) and Azerbaijan (86,600 km2).”

“It’s naive to believe that the leader of Baku’s barbarian regime allegedly recognizes or will recognize the Republic of Armenia within an area of 29,800 square kilometers and that it will lead to a ‘bright future’,” Voskanyan wrote on Facebook on Monday.

He expert recalled Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev’s claims to modern-day Armenia, including Kond, one of the oldest districts in Yerevan which houses the government villas.

“It’s the same as if someone were to believe that I was supposedly convinced the artificial entity of Azerbaijan had a legitimate claim to the territory or culture of any indigenous peoples,” Voskanyan said.

https://www.panorama.am/en/news/2023/05/15/expert-Armenia-territorial-integrity/2836290

Envoy: Reports of EU observers not shared with Armenia or Azerbaijan

Panorama
Armenia – May 15 2023

The EU observers deployed to Armenia’s border with Azerbaijan do not share their reports either with the Armenian or the Azerbaijani authorities, Andrea Wiktorin, head of the EU Delegation in Yerevan, said on Monday, adding the civilian mission reports back to Brussels.

“But as the mission is accompanied by officers of the Ministry of Defense, the Armenian side is well aware of what they see,” she told a news conference.

Wiktorin said the EU observers were not in the border village of Sotk during the latest Azerbaijani attacks which left one Armenian soldier killed and several others wounded. They visited the area after the tensions eased, she added.

“So far with the latest incursion and hostilities they were not present on the ground… when the incursion happened. You have quite a long border and there is a schedule of the patrols. It is also not an intention that they had to be there while something happens. They are monitoring the border and they see what they see around the border, but it does not mean that they are actually on the spot when something happens,” Wiktorin said.

EU leadership continues to ignore Artsakh people’s legitimate rights – Foreign Ministry

Panorama
Armenia – May 16 2023

The Artsakh Foreign Ministry issued a statement on European Council President Charles Michel’s remarks made after Sunday’s Armenian-Azerbaijani summit in Brussels. The full text of the statement is provided below.

“On 14 May, President of the European Council Charles Michel made a press statement following a trilateral meeting with Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan and Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev. The content of the statement as a whole, as well as a number of points contained there indicate that the EU leadership continues to ignore the legitimate rights and interests of the people of Artsakh and is guided solely by their own geopolitical and short-term interests in the region to the detriment of the values of democracy and human rights declared by the European Union.

This is evidenced in particular by the absence in the statement of any mention of more than 5-months blockade of the Lachin Corridor, the establishment of an illegal Azerbaijani checkpoint at the entrance to the corridor and the factual siege of the 120,000 population of Artsakh with all the ensuing humanitarian consequences. This is an indication of the fact that the President of the European Council not only does not prevent, but in fact indulges Azerbaijan in using the suffering of the people of Artsakh as a political tool.

However, if the intentions and visible actions of Azerbaijan to provoke a humanitarian catastrophe and carry out ethnic cleansing in Artsakh are not a matter of concern for the President of the European Council, we still had the right to expect that the organisation he represents would show direct interest in Azerbaijan’s strict compliance with the decisions of the European Court of Human Rights and the International Court of Justice, as one of the pillars of contemporary international legal order. In this regard, the European Council President’s  defiant disregard for Azerbaijan’s consistent non-compliance with the legally binding Order of the principal judicial organ of the UN and its systematic violations of international law, in particular the non-use or threat of force and the peaceful settlement of disputes, is puzzling.

It is only the effective measures on the part of the international community aimed at forcing Azerbaijan to immediately and unconditionally implement its obligations under the Trilateral Statement of 9 November 2020 and the Order of the International Court of Justice of 22 February 2023, that may testify that those acting as mediators are sincerely interested in lasting peace and stability in the region. We believe that those international actors who either by their action or inaction are encouraging Baku in their aggressive, expansionist policies and internationally wrongful acts, not only bear responsibility for their grave consequences, but also justify the recurrence of such policies and violations in other parts of the world.

We recall once again that in 1991, the people of Artsakh, in full compliance with international law and domestic legislation in force at that time, exercised their inalienable right to self-determination and established their statehood on the same basis as Azerbaijan and Armenia. The authorities of the Republic of Artsakh have consistently defended and will continue to defend the legitimate choice and _expression_ of the free will of their people.

Representatives of individual countries and international organisations have no right to decide the fate of the people of Artsakh. Moreover, any attempt to impose on the people of Artsakh an agenda based on the legitimisation of the illegal use of force and ongoing terror is tantamount to complicity in the implementation of Azerbaijan’s criminal plans of ethnic cleansing of Artsakh and maintaining a permanent source of tension in the region, as well as encouraging Baku’s territorial ambitions and aggressive policies.

In this connection, we reiterate the determination of the people and authorities of the Republic of Artsakh to continue the struggle for their inalienable rights in accordance with the norms and principles of international law. We are convinced that only the recognition of the right to self-determination exercised by the people of Artsakh can become the basis for a sustainable settlement of the conflict and the establishment of just and lasting peace and stability in the region.

We also recall that the authorities of the Republic of Artsakh have always advocated a comprehensive settlement of the Azerbaijan-Karabakh conflict through negotiations. The Republic of Artsakh remains open to discussing all components of the conflict and reasonable proposals aimed at a peaceful settlement, in an agreed and internationally recognised negotiation format, based on the equal rights of the parties and in the presence of strong international guarantees for the implementation of their obligations.”

Opposition MP: Artsakh leaders continue to help Pashinyan surrender it to Azerbaijan

Panorama
Armenia – May 16 2023

Opposition MP Tigran Abrahamyan accused the Artsakh leadership of supporting Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan’s efforts to give away Artsakh to Azerbaijan.

The Artsakh Foreign Ministry on Monday reacted harshly to European Council President Charles Michel’s remarks following the latest talks between the Armenian and Azerbaijani leaders in Brussels.

“The EU leadership continues to ignore the legitimate rights and interests of the people of Artsakh and is guided solely by their own geopolitical and short-term interests in the region to the detriment of the values of democracy and human rights declared by the European Union,” it said in a statement.

Pashinyan stopped championing the Artsakh Armenians’ right to self-determination last year and has spoken instead of the need to protect their “rights and security” since then.

Meanwhile, the Artsakh statement contained no criticism of Pashinyan and his government.

“Charles Michel’s remarks only indicate the current agenda and the talks that were held, Meanwhile, the Armenian authorities, at least, have not stated otherwise,” Abrahamyan, the secretary of the opposition Pativ Unem faction, wrote on Facebook on Tuesday.

He stressed neither the Artsakh president nor any of the Artsakh officials who held a rally in Stepanakert on Monday refrained from criticizing Pashinyan’s “disgraceful policy of surrendering Artsakh to Azerbaijan.”

“Despite harsh criticism of Pashinyan from various groups of Artsakh’s society, the Artsakh authorities continue to support Pashinyan in his efforts to surrender Artsakh [to Azerbaijan],” the deputy stated.