TBILISI: President’s press service denies Saakashvili addressed

The Messenger, Georgia
Oct 3 2004
President’s press service denies Saakashvili addressed Karabakh issue
Official Tbilisi rejects reports that President Mikheil Saakashvili
made harsh statements about Nogorno-Karabakh in a phone conversation
with the Prime Minister of Turkey Recep Erdogan, Prime News reports.
According to the president’s press service, the sides discussed the
necessity of dialogue between Azerbaijan, Georgia and Armenia, but
did not mention Nogorno-Karabakh.
The announcement came in response to reports by France Press and the
Turkish agency Anadolus that during the phone conversation Mikheil
Saakashvili stated, “to maintain peace between Armenia and
Azerbaijan, the Karabakh occupation must be stopped.”

BAKU: Armenia-Azerbaijan, NK problem focused

Azer Tag, Azerbaijan State Info Agency
Oct 5 2004
ARMENIA-AZERBAIJAN, NAGORNY KARABAKH PROBLEM FOCUSED
[October 05, 2004, 23:24:44]
Foreign minister of Azerbaijan Republic Elmar Mammadyarov met the
heads of OSCE missions on Azerbaijan, Georgia and Armenia, Maurizio
Pavesi, Roy Reeve, and Vladimir Priakhin, press service of the
Ministry told AzerTAj.
The OSCE representatives highlighted on the activity of the
structure, on the political, economic, safety issues the missions
have discussed, on the work done and negotiations carried out and all
aspects of the Armenia-Azerbaijan, Nagorny Karabakh conflict.
Minister Elmar Mammadyarov once again explained position of the
Azerbaijani side related to the conflict, and updated the heads of
missions on the latest Astana talks. He underlined that settlement of
the Armenian families if the occupied Azerbaijan territories
contradict the international legal principles and called on OSCE to
protest it.
At the same time, he expressed confidence that with the help of
international community, the problem would find its peaceful
solution.
Also were exchanged views on a number of other issues of mutual
interest.

Following in the footsteps of Nansen

Norway.org, Norway
Oct 5 2004
News
Following in the footsteps of Nansen
Norway congratulates the UN High Commissioner for Refugees (HCR) on
50 years of outstanding service to the world.
News of Norway, issue 1, 2001
Issues related to refugees have been important to Norway since
Fridtjof Nansen was appointed as the first Commissioner of the UN
committee from 1922. He helped to repatriate prisoners of war from
World War I, Russian peasants fleeing famine and revolution and
Greeks, Turks and Armenians uprooted by ethnic conflict.
The Nansen Passport, the first ever internationally recognised
document for refugees, was an initiative designed to give practical
support to those unable to return home. It illustrates the
combination of compassion and diplomatic acuity that enabled Nansen
to set refugee issues firmly on the global agenda. And it was backed
up by action when Nansen persuaded countries to accept quotas of
refugees and support them in their efforts to build a new life in
peace.
Norway – key contributor
‘I congratulate UNHCR for their efforts. The only sad thing is that
the world still, as when the HCR was started, needs an organization
such as this one. Originally, we hoped it would only be needed for a
few years,’ said Jagland.
Norway is one of the key contributors to the organization with an
annual contribution of $37 million, and an extra $2.75 million given
directly to the High Commissioner’s office.
In 1947 several Norwegian voluntary organisations joined forces and
established an umbrella organisation which in 1953 was named the
Norwegian Refugee Council. In response to new refugee situations, the
Norwegian Refugee Council established in the early 1990s a roster of
expert personnel to assist the UN on short notice in its efforts to
quickly be present in refugee emergency situations around the world.
No cause for celebration
Marking its 50th anniversary, the UN refugee agency declared that
while its longevity is nothing to celebrate, the courage and
contributions of the world’s millions of refugees deserve everyone’s
respect.
‘UNHCR’s 50th anniversary is, in itself, no cause for celebration,’
said High Commissioner Sadako Ogata, who after a 10-year term is now
replaced by Mary Robinson, former President of Ireland.
‘In fact, our longevity is a reflection of the international
community’s failure to prevent prejudice, persecution, poverty and
other causes of conflict and displacement, so we are marking this
anniversary year by highlighting the courage and contributions of
millions of refugees around the world,’ Ogata said during a news
conference in Geneva.
With a staff of more than 5,000 people in 120 countries, UNHCR
currently cares for 22.3 million refugees and displaced peoples in
some of the most difficult and dangerous places on earth. The UNHCR
has twice won the Nobel Peace Prize for its efforts on behalf of the
displaced.
Raising public awareness
To mark its 50 years of work, UNHCR supporters worldwide are holding
a series of events over the next 6 months focused on promoting
respect for refugees. The agency has launched a global public
awareness campaign featuring several prominent former refugees in
print and television spots.
The anniversary events will culminate in a sound and light show at
the Statue of Liberty in New York Harbor on June 20, which has been
designated by the UN General Assembly as the first World Refugee Day.
Ms. Ogata will award one of five Nansen medals being given this year.
The Nansen medal is an annual award given by the UNHCR for
contributions to the refugee cause. Describing the award’s objective
at the first Nansen Medal Award ceremony in 1955, High Commissioner
van Heuven Goedhart said: ‘It is our deepest hope that this annual
ceremony will not only keep alive the memory of the greatest man who
ever served the cause of refugees, but also draw attention to the
problems he confronted and the energy with which Nansen sought to
overcome them.’
Gallery of Prominent Refugees
In recognition of the UNHCR’s anniversary, a ‘Gallery of Prominent
Refugees’ is on display at the UNHCR-50 Foundation web site. The
gallery showcases more than 100 current and former refugees who have
achieved special status within a community.
In recognition of the importance of education to refugees, the High
Commissioner used the 50th anniversary to launch the Refugee
Education Trust (RET), an independent fund created to provide
post-primary education to young refugees in developing countries. The
RET will be the lasting legacy of the 50th anniversary year.

TCK Protects the State Not Media

KurdishMedia, UK
Oct 5 2004
TCK Protects the State Not Media

05/10/2004 Bianet.org – By Erol Onderoglu
The improvements brought about by [Turkey’s]harmonization regulations
to articles on “dangerous provocation” and “insulting the state,”
have been kept in the new TCK [Turkish Penal Code]. But the new law
brings about new crimes for the media members including Internet
reporters.
BIA (Ankara) – The new Turkish Penal Code (TCK), which is still
awaiting approval by the president, is likely to result in serious
practical problems, although it encompasses some improvements on the
freedom of media and expression.
The improvements brought about by harmonization regulations to
articles 312 and 159 of TCK on “dangerous provocation” and “insulting
the state,” have been kept in the new version. But the new TCK
expanded the channels through which the members of the media can be
legally charged.
Regulations on “encouraging for committing suicide,” “confidentiality
of communications,” “insult,” “the confidentiality of private life,”
“crimes against social peace,” “obscenity,” “affecting prices,”
“crimes against the court,” “genital examination,” “putting people
off from serving in the military,” “acting against basic national
interests,” and “state secrets,” may be used as examples.
“Insulting” state officials
For example, article 125 on “insult,” states that “an individual who
hurts one’s honor, dignity and reputation, will be sentenced to three
months to two years in prison or handed a fine.” Section 3/a of the
same article includes a regulation, which would affect publications
or broadcasts in criticism of a state official because of their jobs.
Accordingly, the minimum sentence for committing this crime “against
a state official because of his/her post,” is a year in prison.
Internet is in TCK
While the implementation of these regulations are awaited, Internet
reporting, which the TCK defines as new media, may lead to problems
in implementation due to a lack of technical, corporate and legal
shortcomings.
Under the title, “Crimes in the Information Technologies Field,”
there is a list of crimes including, “Penetrating into information
technology system,” “hindering or disrupting information technology
systems, and erasing or changing data.”
Fine under Press Law, prison sentence under TCK
In contrast to the Press Law, which states prison sentences may be
commuted to fines with few exceptions, the new TCK brings about
increased prison sentences for the media members. For that reason,
TCK and the Press Law reflect a different psyche and mentality.
For example, article 19 of the Press Law No: 5187 states that
“individuals who publish opinions on a judge or court proceedings
while the court trial is still continuing and before a ruling has
been made,” will be fined 2 billion Turkish liras (USD 1,300) to 50
billion Turkish liras (USD 33,300). The fine may not be less than 10
billion Turkish liras (USD 6,700) in regional broadcasts and 20
billion Turkish liras (USD 13,300) in widespread broadcasts.
However, article 288 of TCK on “attempting to influence a fair trial”
envisages a “prison sentence from six months to three years.”
Paragraph 2 introduces a heavier sentence for “media organizations.”
15 years in prison for acting against “basic national interests”
Under paragraph 8 of article 220 on “setting up an organization with
the aim of committing a crime,” individuals disseminating propaganda
for an organization or its goals, are sentenced to a year to three
years in prison. The prison sentence is scaled up by half when the
propaganda is made through by media organs.
Another article that was being criticized during the drafting period
was article 305 on “acting against basic national interests.”
This article, aimed at being used to convict people for defending,
for example, the withdrawal of Turkish troops from Cyprus, or for
recognizing the Armenian genocide, was approved by the parliament.
Under this article, individuals who get financing from foreign
individuals or institutions either for him/herself or for someone
else, with the aim of acting against basic national interests, will
be sentenced to three years to ten years in prison and a fine.
If the “financing is received or promised for disseminating
propaganda through the media,” the prison sentence is scaled up by
half.
“Putting people off from serving in the military”
The article on “putting people off from serving in the military,”
which has caused controversy in the past, has not been removed from
the TCK. Under article 318, “individuals who act, inspire, or suggest
things that would put people off from serving in the military, will
be sentenced to six months to two years in prison.” The sentence is
scaled up by half if committed through the media.
Paragraph 2 of article 133 on “listening to and recording people’s
conversations,” states “an individual can be sentenced up to six
months in prison or fined, for secretly recording a conversation
between others without their consent.” Under paragraph 3, the
sentence is scaled up by half for members of the media. (EO/YS/EA/YE)

CIS defense/security commission to meet in Yerevan

ITAR-TASS, Russia
Oct 5 2004
CIS defense/security commission to meet in Yerevan

YEREVAN, October 6 (Itar-Tass) – The permanent commission for
defense and security of the CIS Inter-parliamentary assembly will
meet in the Armenian capital on Wednesday to discuss defense
cooperation and the fight against terrorism.
Simultaneously, the chairpersons of the CIS parliamentary commissions
for defense will gather for a conference here.
The participants in both forums will meet with Armenian President
Robert Kocharyan and head of Armenia’s Apostolic church Catholicos
Garegin II.

Yerevan’s University Honors Bulgaria’s President

Novinite, Bulgaria
Oct 6 2004
Yerevan’s University Honors Bulgaria’s President

Bulgaria’s President Georgi Parvanov will receive the Doctor Honoris
Causa academic title of the Yerevan’s State University.
Bulgaria’s President Georgi Parvanov will receive the Doctor Honoris
Causa academic title of the Yerevan’s State University later on
Wednesday.
During the second day of his visit to Armenia Parvanov will lay a
wreath at the Monument of the victims of the Armenian genocide. He
will also visit the “Peyo Yavorov” school, where he will meet
representatives of the Bulgarian community in Armenia.
President Georgi Parvanov is at an official visit to Armenia October
5-7, to be followed by a two-day stop at Azerbaijan October 7-8.
Parvanov is scheduled to confer with counterparts and other state
officials, together with the Transport and Communications Minister
Nikolai Vassilev and the mayors of several cities who accompany
him.Business forums and bilateral agreement signing ceremonies are
also on the agenda of the visit.

Artist brings color to walls of Civic Arts Plaza garage

Ventura County Star, CA
Oct 6 2004
Artist brings color to walls of Civic Arts Plaza garage
By Grace Lee, [email protected]
October 6, 2004
In the corner of the Thousand Oaks Civic Arts Plaza parking
structure, world renowned artist Hakob “Jack” Jambazian studied a
wall awash in colors Tuesday.
For about a week, Jambazian has been transforming an interior wall of
the parking structure with a mural of reds, blues and yellows. In the
center of the wall, the figure of composer raises his arms in fluid
lines above a score. Ballet dancers hold their poses; musical notes
scroll across the wall.

“When you come from the theater, in the corner you can see two
figures, a composer and ballerina,” Jambazian said.
The Armenian-born artist has a body of work that includes
restorations of oil paintings, stained glass and engravings all over
the world.
He designed and executed the engraving of the angels on the glass
doors of the donor wall at the Cathedral of Our Lady of the Angels in
Los Angeles. He also restored all of the antique European stained
glass panels brought from the original cathedral.
Surrounded by ladders beside the stairwell, Jambazian was making
progress on a mural aimed at both adding beauty near the city’s
cultural and civic center and raising money as well.
Harry Selvin, a board member of the Civic Arts Plaza Foundation,
worked for about eight years on a plan to create murals throughout
the structure. It was his hope that patrons of the arts would finance
individual pieces of artwork and make a donation to the foundation.
In return, the donors would receive recognition for their
contribution.
“I came up with the idea of putting murals on the walls when I saw
the freeways and their gorgeous murals. And it gave me the
inspiration to suggest we do it at our theater,” Selvin said.
Getting to this point was a major challenge, Selvin said.
“I don’t think anybody could visualize what this would be or how to
do it. Many of them looked at the idea and said it was really nice.
But that’s as far as it went,” he said.
Finally, with the 10th anniversary of the Civic Arts Plaza to be
celebrated later this month, Selvin decided to tackle one of the
biggest challenges.
“I found a sponsor to pay for it. That was me,” he said. He declined
to say how much it cost him to hire an internationally known artist,
but he said he hoped the mural would inspire others to commission
portions of the structure.
His plan is to invite local artists to submit renderings to the
Alliance for the Arts, the financial arm of the foundation. The
foundation would then offer potential patrons to sponsor works.
The mural will likely be completed in about six weeks.
“It’s just starting to go up and I think it’s absolutely phenomenal,
just incredible,” Selvin said. “When the theater clients and the city
hall clients park their cars and to in and out, they will be
absolutely thrilled and inspired and motivated.”
Tom Mitze, director of the city’s theaters department, said the
unfinished mural has already drawn attention.
“It’s amazing. Everyone’s stopping and looking at it and commenting,”
he said. “It was just a concrete wall.”
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

ANKARA: Reactions Of Business Circles To E.U. Report

Turkish Press
Oct 6 2004
Reactions Of Business Circles To E.U. Report
ISTANBUL/ANKARA – Turkish business circles assessed the Progress
Report of the European Commission about Turkey which was published
today.
Turkish Industrialists’ and Businessmen’s Association (TUSIAD)
released a statement and said, ”a historical progress was recorded
in relations between Turkey and the European Union (EU) with the
report.”
”Turkey, which advances on negotiation process with the EU, will
have important political, economic and social contributions to the
future of Europe,” said the statement.
TUSIAD said, ”the decision is a test for the EU in the aspects of
political maturity and democratic ethic.”
Meanwhile, the Independent Industrialists’ and Businessmen’s
Association (MUSIAD) Chairman Omer Bolat said regarding the report
that according to the expressions in the report, full membership
seemed to take a long way for Turkey.
”Turkey enters a new process but full membership is not close,”
added Bolat.
Bolat said, ”the EU pursued its unwillingness and double standards
about Turkey.” He added, ”foreign policy of Turkish government
should not be indexed only to the EU.”
Meanwhile, Ankara Chamber of Commerce (ATO) Chairman Sinan Aygun said
regarding the report that details in the report were not known.
”They say ‘we make you EU member but we will not permit you to move
within the EU’. It is like an invitation of someone to a meal but not
allowing him to eat. I think this attitude is wrong. They present
special status as if it were a normal condition. Which of the EU
members do not have free movement permit?” said Aygun.
Aygun said, ”they say there are many missions to accomplish. What
will happen about Cyprus, Aegean, southeast, minority and human
rights issues? Will they ask us to accept so-called Armenian
genocide? Will they ask us to open a seminary? We cannot see them
clearly.”

Athens: EU Parl. Majority Accepts Proposal on Turkey’s Access Negot.

Athens News Agency, Greece
Oct 7 2004
EU Parliament majority accepts Commission proposal on Turkey’s
accession negotiations
The majority of the political parties participating in the EU
Parliament responded positively to the European Commission’s proposal
regarding the beginning of EU accession negotiations for Turkey
during a parliamentary session held here on Wednesday.
Head of the European People’s Party (EPP) Hans-Gert Petering said
that the EPP – although there are divergent opinions within the party
– agrees that if Turkey becomes an EU member then it will be
different in terms of geography and living standards than what it is
today. The EPP recognises the efforts Turkish Prime Minister Tayyip
Erdogan has made to date, but emphasised that much still needs to be
done. He also criticised the EU’s Commissioner for Enlargement
Guenter Verheugen for recently saying that torture is not carried out
in Turkey on a regular basis.
Petering said that members of the EPP insist that if negotiations
begin the result must be open-ended: either full accession or no
accession, adding that it would be good to include the possibility of
establishing a privileged alliance with Turkey. Additionally, even if
Turkey does not become an EU member, this would be no excuse for the
halting of democratic reforms, he said.
Martin Schultz, head of the Socialist Group is also in favour of
negotiations for Turkey’s EU membership to begin, pointing out that
this does not necessarily guarantee accession. He said that if a
Muslim community could consider the European Union their union, then
the foundations for peace in the 21st century will be set.
Schultz also emphasised that progress checks surrounding the
criteria Turkey must meet should be conducted frequently, and said
that if reforms were not proceeding smoothly then negotiations should
be suspended.
Head of the Alliance of Liberals and Democrats Graham Watson said
that the majority of his party approved of the European Commission’s
proposal for negotiations to begin, but there are many who doubt
Turkey. He added that a conflict of culture must be avoided but also
noted that Turkey must make some dramatic changes (ie., human rights,
respect for the rule of law, opening up of the economy). He stressed
that the beginning of negotiations does not necessarily mean a happy
ending. Watson also emphasised that the EU must treat Turkey in the
same way as any other country-candidate, but that protection of human
rights in the country must be closely monitored.
Daniel-Kohn Bendit, head of the Group of the Greens, was more
positive, supporting the beginning of negotiations, without placing
emphasis on the possibility of a failed accession attempt.
Francis Wurtz of the European United Left was also supportive of
Turkey’s European potential, saying that Turkey’s EU accession could
serve as a bridge between the West and the Middle East, contributing
to establishing peace in a region plagued by “war and chaos”. He also
said that using Turkey as a scapegoat would be a mistake, but
acknowledged that there are a series of issues Turkey must resolve.
These include certain clauses of the new penal code, which according
to Wurtz, pose a threat to freedom of expression; the Turkish
occupation forces in Cyprus and the Turkish authorities’ refusal to
recognize the Armenian genocide.
Jens Peter Bonde of the Independence/Democracy Group opposed
Turkey’s EU prospects, stressing that Turkey’s values are not in line
with those of the EU. Instead, he suggested that in 2009 – and once
the EU constitution is in place – the EU can establish an open and
flexible cooperation with Turkey.
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

BAKU: Armenia postpones talks on Upper Garabagh conflict

Azer News, Azerbaijan
Oct 7 2004
Armenia postpones talks on Upper Garabagh conflict

Yerevan has put forth an initiative to postpone the talks over the
Upper Garabagh conflict after the meeting of Azerbaijani and Armenian
Presidents in Astana. Commenting on the matter, Azeri Deputy Foreign
Minister Araz Azimov confirmed the fact that the
Armenian side had requested a delay to analyze the outcome of the
negotiations held thus far. It is not clear yet when the talks will
continue, he said. Azimov said there is no need for a meeting of
Azerbaijani and Armenian presidents’ special envoys, as all issues
related to the conflict settlement are discussed during regular
meetings of the two countries’ foreign ministers. At the Astana
summit Azerbaijan called on Armenia to recognize its territorial
integrity and withdraw its armed forces from the occupied lands.
Azimov stressed that the Azerbaijani government is ready to ensure
the security of the Armenian community in Upper Garabagh if Armenia
accepts the terms put forward by Azerbaijan.
Turkey’s mediation
Azerbaijani, Turkish and Armenian Foreign Ministers did not meet in
New York, as expected, but such a meeting may be held in the
foreseeable future. Azeri Foreign Minister Elmar Mammadyarov said the
meeting was postponed for technical reasons and it will now depend on
Turkey whether or not it will take place. Turkish Foreign Minister
Abdullah Gul said his country would continue making efforts to ensure
the talks continue and a trilateral meeting is held. Although the
three ministers did not meet in the United States, the Turkish
Foreign Minister held bilateral meetings with his Azerbaijani and
Armenian counterparts. Ways of settling the Upper Garabagh conflict
and the role of the United Nations in this process were discussed.
During his meeting with Armenian Foreign Minister Oskanian, Turkish
Minister Gul took interest in the results of the meeting held by the
Azeri and Armenian presidents in Astana.