Iraq’s shrinking Christian minority struggles to survive

Iraq’s shrinking Christian minority struggles to survive
Agence France Presse — English
October 16, 2004 Saturday 4:44 PM GMT
BAGHDAD Oct 16 — The coordinated attacks on five Baghdad churches
Saturday sent tremors through Iraq’s small Christian community, which
finds itself being set adrift amid a tide of rising Islamic extremism.
The dawn attacks across Baghdad caused no casualties but were the
latest assault on Iraq’s ethnic mosaic as insurgents seek to sow
dissension among Iraq’s Muslim majority and dwindling Christian
community.
Five explosions in the span of an hour was one more blow to an
embattled minority that was shrinking even before the recent spate
of attacks.
The community stood at 1.4 million people according to a 1987 census
but has since shrivelled to 700,000 during a turbulent period of war
and years of crippling sanctions.
“The attackers have one goal: sowing strife in the heart of Iraqi
society. But they will not destroy our unity,” said Yunadam Kanna,
a Christian representative in Iraq’s interim parliament.
“Churches are easy targets because they are places of worship open
to all.””
Iraq’s Christian community, numbering just three percent of Iraq’s
25 million population, has been heavily targeted in the unrest that
has swept Iraq following last year’s US-led invasion and some have
picked up and left.
At the start of August, four attacks against Christian targets in
Baghdad and two others in Mosul left 10 people dead and 50 injured in
what the government said was the work of suspected al-Qaeda operative
Abu Mussab al-Zarqawi.
Liquor stores, owned by Christians, have been blown up by Islamic
militants. And Christian families, many considered wealthy by Iraqi
standards, have been targeted by kidnappers for huge ransoms.
Following the August bombings, Iraq’s Displacement and Migration
Minister Pascale Icho Warda, herself a Christian, said 40,000
Christians had left Iraq.
Shocked by the latest outbreak of violence, the patriarch of the
Chaldean Church, Monsignor Emmanuel Delly, said: “If the government
is powerless, what can we do.
“We call on them (attackers) not to touch the holy sites.”
Iraq’s provisional constitution, signed in March, guarantees freedom
for all religions, but it has not assuaged the anxieties of the
small community amid the torrent of violence and identity politics
sweeping Iraq.
The 1970 constitution adopted under the old regime also guaranteed
freedom of religion and prohibited any religious discrimination.
It also acknowledged that the people of Iraq consisted of “two
principal nationalities,” Arab and Kurd, and “other nationalities”
whose rights were considered legitimate.
In December 1972, the head of the ruling Baath Party identified these
by decree as the Assyrians, Chaldeans and Syriacs.
The Chaldeans, whose 600,000 people represent the majority of
Christians in Iraq, are an oriental rite Catholic community.
Their church emerged from the Nestorian doctrine, which it renounced
in the 16th century while preserving its rites. Former deputy prime
minister Tareq Aziz, currently in US custody, is the best known of
the Chaldeans.
The Assyrians, believed to number about 50,000, are Christians who
remained faithful to the Nestorian doctrine.
The Nestorian church became a dissident movement in 431 AD after
the Council of Ephesus. They affirm that Christ has two separate
personalities — namely human and divine — and not a single
personality possessing both human and divine nature as Roman
Catholicism and Orthodoxy believe.
In Iraq, there are also Catholic and Orthodox Syriacs, Catholic and
Orthodox Armenians, and since the time of the British mandate after
World War I, Protestants, Anglicans and Roman Catholics.
Many Iraqi Christians still speak Aramaic-Syriac, a dialect of Aramaic,
the language of Christ. During the 1970s, bilingual cultural magazines
in Arabic and Syriac were published and radio and television programmes
were transmitted in Aramaic.
In the northern region of Kurdistan, Christians number about 150,000,
mostly Chaldeans.
Since the fall of former president Saddam Hussein’s secular regime,
many of Iraq’s Christians have kept a lower profile for fear of being
equated with the largely Christian US-led forces in the country.

Armenia’s defense minister meets top U.S. diplomat

Armenia’s defense minister meets top U.S. diplomat
Associated Press Worldstream
October 16, 2004 Saturday 11:45 AM Eastern Time
YEREVAN, Armenia — Armenia’s defense minister met with a visiting
U.S. diplomat Saturday to discuss prospects for military cooperation.
Defense Minister Serzh Sarkisian told U.S. Deputy Assistant Secretary
of State Laura Kennedy that Armenia values military ties with the
United States and hopes to develop them. Kennedy, in turn, thanked
the Armenian government for its readiness to send peacekeepers to Iraq.
Armenian President Robert Kocharian pledged the troops during a visit
to Poland last month, but the nation’s prime minister said Friday
that it was up to the Constitutional Court and parliament to make
the final decision on sending some 50 troops.
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Georgia, Azerbaijan connect sections of key oil pipeline

Georgia, Azerbaijan connect sections of key oil pipeline
Associated Press Worldstream
October 16, 2004 Saturday 11:45 AM Eastern Time
BAKU, Azerbaijan — The presidents of Azerbaijan and Georgia on
Saturday presided over the welding of two sections of a strategic oil
pipeline seen as key to reducing Western dependence on Middle East oil.
Attending the ceremony on the border between the two ex-Soviet
republics, Azerbaijan’s President Ilham Aliev and Mikhail Saakashvili
of Georgia hailed the US$3.6-billion Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan pipeline as
essential both for their countries and the entire region.
“This pipeline will help create new opportunities for our peoples,
and attract major resources,” Aliev said. “It will also contribute
significantly to the region’s security.”
Stephen Mann, the U.S. State Department envoy for Caspian energy
development, attended the ceremony. Mann sought to dismiss fears
about the pipeline’s security, saying it was being built far from
the zones of conflicts in the region.
Azerbaijan has been unable to solve a conflict over its
Nagorno-Karabakh enclave, which has been under Armenian control since
1994, and Georgia has been haunted by conflicts in its breakaway
provinces of Abkhazia and South Ossetia, which have run their own
affairs since the early 1990s.
The 1,760-kilometer (1,100-mile) pipeline runs from Baku, Azerbaijan,
to the Turkish port of Ceyhan, where oil from Azerbaijan’s Caspian
Sea fields will be loaded onto tankers for Western markets.
It is set to begin operation next year.

Ultra-orthodox Jews ‘must stop religious abuse’

Ultra-orthodox Jews ‘must stop religious abuse’
Conal Urquhart in Jerusalem
The Observer
Sunday October 17, 2004*
Jerusalem’s Christian community has demanded that Jewish leaders and
the Israeli government take action against what they claim is growing
harassment of their clergy by religious Jews.
Christians say ultra-Orthodox Jewish students spit at them or at the
ground when they pass. There have also been acts of vandalism against
statues of the Virgin Mary.
The harassment came to a head last week when a Jewish student spat
at Armenian Archbishop Nourhan Manougian and ripped off his crucifix,
whereupon the archbishop slapped him. The police questioned both men.
Mainstream Israeli opinion has been revolted by the revelations of
the abuse of Christian clergy. Avraham Poraz, the interior minister,
condemned the trend of spitting at the cross and those wearing it,
saying it was ‘intolerable’ and that he was ‘revolted’ by it. A former
chief rabbi also voiced his outrage.
All the Christian groups complain of harassment, but the Armenians
bear the brunt. Armenian clergymen said that, when they complained
to the interior minister seven months ago, he told them: ‘Most Jews
have a big problem with them as well.’
The 3,000-strong community live in the Armenian quarter and many Jews
walk through it on their way from west Jerusalem to the Wailing Wall
or Western Wall.
Father Pakrad Bourjekian, a spokesman for the Armenian church, said the
attack was an extreme example of the harassment they receive every day.
‘Every day the fanatical Jews turn their face to the wall or spit on
the ground or at us when they see the crucifix,’ he said.
The Christians admit that it is only a minority who carry out the
abuse, but they feel that the issue is being ignored by religious
leaders.
Bishop Aris Shirvanian of the Armenian church said: ‘The majority are
courteous or indifferent. The problem is the very religious. It’s a
question of education. What must these people be learning to behave
like this?’
The old city of Jerusalem is buzzing with rumours that young Armenians
will take revenge for the attack and the daily indignities suffered
by their priests.
Bishop Aris acknowledged that there was a danger of reprisals. ‘We
are trying to control our young people and we are succeeding. But
the question is that there is no one in the Jewish community trying
to control their fanatics,’ he said.
Father Pakrad added: ‘There is no hierarchy. Anyone can become a rabbi,
set up an institution, get funds from abroad and teach what they like.’
Jerusalem has always been a city of conflict. Even the old Christian
churches – the Armenian, Orthodox, Coptic, Syrian, Ethiopian and
Catholic – are known for their disputes, which regularly result
in brawls.
In the current dispute, the Muslims, the old city’s biggest group,
are for once not involved. ‘I do not think these Jews would dare spit
at a Muslim sheikh; the whole city would explode. We are only a small
group, so it easy to bully us,’ said Bishop Aris.
Guardian Unlimited © Guardian Newspapers Limited 2004

Russian minister points up “strategic” Tajikistan military base

Russian minister points up “strategic” Tajikistan military base
ITAR-TASS news agency, Moscow
16 Oct 04
Dushanbe, 16 October: The Russian military base that is due to
open in Tajikistan on 17 October will have “an important strategic
significance” for ensuring regional security, Russian Defence Minister
Sergey Ivanov told an ITAR-TASS correspondent today, following the
talks with his Tajik counterpart, Sherali Khayrulloyev.
“The base, which is being set up under the Collective Security
Treaty Organization CSTO; members are Armenia, Belarus, Kazakhstan,
Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan and Russia , will become a main component of
the rapid deployment forces in Central Asia,” he said.
The minister said the base would include the 201st Russian Motor-Rifle
division and the Norak optical-electronic tracking station some 120
km southeast of Dushanbe and would definitely be reinforced by an
air squadron as well. Sergey Ivanov also added that the base would
comprise approximately 5,000 servicemen.
“Its combat potential will be tested as early as 2005, in the course
of CSTO military exercises planned in Tajikistan” he said. He added
that with the formation of the base, there would more opportunities
to provide “more military as well as military and technical assistance
to the Tajik armed forces”.
Commenting on the 201st division, the Russian defence minister said:
“The personnel of the division have accomplished all the targets set.”
“During Tajikistan’s tragic period (the five-year civil war of
1992-97 ), the division demonstrated high military preparedness and
its ability to accomplish the tasks set,” Sergey Ivanov concluded.

TBILISI: Georgia Stops Armenia-Bound Russian Military Lorries – TVRe

GEORGIA STOPS ARMENIA-BOUND RUSSIAN MILITARY LORRIES – TV REPORT
Rustavi-2 TV, Tbilisi
16 Oct 04
Why has Russia been briefly opening and then closing again the Zemo
Larsi (Verkhniy Lars) checkpoint (on the Georgian-Russian border)? An
unofficial report in today’s Russian media said that the checkpoint was
opened for only 30 minutes this morning to allow passage of Russian
military lorries. These lorries are carrying freight for the Russian
military bases in Armenia.
However, the Georgian side said that they were waiting for an
official notification from Russia about the permanent opening of the
checkpoint. They are not going to let only Russian military vehicles
cross the border.
From: Baghdasarian

Moscow lays Armenian Cathedral foundation stone

MOSCOW LAYS ARMENIAN CATHEDRAL FOUNDATION STONE
RIA Novosti, Russia
Oct 16 2004
MOSCOW, October 16 (RIA Novosti) – Moscow will soon have another
cathedral, whose foundation stones were consecrated today. The new
shrine will belong to the New Nakhichevan and the Russian dioceses
of the Armenian Apostolic Church.
Mayor Yuri Luzhkov addressed the congregation to congratulate the
Moscow ethnic Armenian community, soon to receive a majestic house
of prayer. He pointed out close links of the Russian and Armenian
nations throughout many centuries, and highlighted an honorable
Armenian contribution to Russian culture, research and industry.
The mayor thanked Alexis II, Patriarch of Moscow and All Russia,
Primate of the Russian Orthodox Church, for his stances on other
Christian denominations, which promote Christian unity.
Alexis II and Garegin II, Catholicos of All Armenians, laid a
commemorative capsule in the cathedral foundation.
Mutual understanding and friendly partnership are characteristic
of present-day Russian-Armenian relations. The Russian and Armenian
Churches are exchanging their ample experience and precious spiritual
heritage, said Garegin II.
“Friendly ties between our Churches and flocks will strengthen here,”
added Alexis II.
The cathedral will be essential part of an upcoming Armenian Cultural
Center. It will have a residence of the Patriarchal Exarch of the
Armenian Apostolic Church in Moscow, an educational center plus Sunday
school, a library, a conference hall, and a club-total floor space
22,000 square meters.

International Community Ready To Acknowledge Karabakh’s Independence

ARMENIAN FOREIGN MINISTER SAYS INTERNATIONAL COMMUNITY READY TO ACKNOWLEDGE KARABAKH`S INDEPENDENCE
Noyan tapan
YEREVAN, 16.10.04. The international community has come to terms
with Nagorno-Karabakh’s secession from Azerbaijan and is ready
to recognize its de facto independence, Foreign Minister Vartan
Oskanian declared on 13 October in response to a question from an
Armenian parliamentarian. “Whereas six years ago nobody was letting
us even dream about Karabakh not being part of Azerbaijan [under a
future peace accord], today not only we but also the international
community, including the co-chairs of the [Organization for Security
and Cooperation in Europe’s] Minsk Group, are freely talking about
that,” he said.
“Today the fact of Karabakh not being part of Azerbaijan is real, and
the international community looks at it in a very normal manner. This
doesn’t mean they will publicly affirm it. But I can state for certain
that they consider that option a real one.”
Oskanian was apparently alluding to a Karabakh peace agreement
worked out during talks in Paris and Florida during the spring of
2001. According to Western press reports, the plan put forward by
French, Russian, and U.S. mediators called for Karabakh’s formal
incorporation into Armenia in return for the latter guaranteeing a
transport corridor between Azerbaijan and its Nakhichevan exclave. The
Armenian side maintains that the two sides came close to signing
that accord, but that Azerbaijan’s former President Heidar Aliyev
backtracked on the deal. However, Baku claims that no such agreements
were reached at the time.

BAKU: List of foreign companies cooperating with Karabakh prepared

Azer Tag, Azerbaijan
Oct 16 2004
LIST OF FOREIGN COMPANIES COOPERATING WITH NAGORNY KARABAKH PREPARED
[October 15, 2004, 23:36:17]
The list of the foreign companies, which cooperate with the occupied
Nagorny Karabakh region of Azerbaijan has been prepared, pres service
of the foreign minister told AzerTAj.
The list is headed by Daewoo-Unitel Uzbek-Korean mobile joint
enterprise that has been registered in Uzbekistan. It cooperates with
the “Karabakhtelecom” company in the frame of international roaming and
SMS service. To this end, embassy of Azerbaijan to Uzbekistan could
take the relevant information, symbols and text from the advertising
materials that presented Nagorny Karabakh as an independent state.
Ukraine’s “Kievstar”, Italy’s Gruppo Telecom Mobile SPA also cooperate
there in the field of roaming and SMS service.
Another Italia-based Vodefon Omnitel N.V. Italian-British joint mobile
company, the French Pernod Richard Company, World Postal Union are
also in the list. The Pernod Richard Company also cooperates with the
“Karabakh Gold” Company in the field of grapes export. The Pernod
Ricrad is the owner of Yerevan brandy factory.
After completion of the list, MFA of Azerbaijan will undertake certain
measures in accordance with the international laws.

BAKU: Azeri Pundits Divided On President’s Success In First Year InP

AZERI PUNDITS DIVIDED ON PRESIDENT’S SUCCESS IN FIRST YEAR IN POWER
Ekho, Baku
15 Oct 04
No serious changes for the better have taken place in Azerbaijan
during President Ilham Aliyev’s first year in power, independent
political analyst Eldar Namazov has said. Namazov said that Ilham
Aliyev had failed to live up to the voters’ expectations – there is no
well-thought-out strategy to democratize the country, nor is there a
team capable of implementing this strategy. However, an official from
the ruling New Azerbaijan Party, Bahar Muradova, said that the public’s
trust in the president had increased and Ilham Aliyev had proved to
be “a global politician”. Another political expert, Zardust Alizada,
said that the president had promised to be faithful to his father
ex-President Heydar Aliyev’s policies and had kept his word. Thus,
“the past year was in no way different from previous years”. Political
analyst Inqilab Ahmadov praised the incumbent president for focusing
on regional development but said Aliyev failed to demonstrate a new
approach to economic reforms. The following is the text of S. Rza’s
report by Azerbaijani newspaper Ekho on 15 October headlined “What
did the past year bring to us?”; subheadings have been inserted
editorially:
It has been exactly a year since Ilham Aliyev headed our country. Ekho
has asked well-known politicians and experts to comment on the results
of the first year of the incumbent president’s tenure.
“Global-level politician”
The deputy executive secretary of the ruling New Azerbaijan Party,
Bahar Muradova, believes that the passed year has once again
proved that the policies of (late President) Heydar Aliyev will
be successfully continued. In addition, the public’s trust in the
president, whom they elected on 15 October 2003, has strengthened
over the past year.
“The incumbent president strengthened further the country’s
independence. In addition, he managed to step up domestic
stability. Ilham Aliyev achieved great success also in the economic
policy and in the implementation of the regional development
programme. Achievements in the country’s social sphere over the past
year have once again proved that the Azerbaijani people made the
right choice. Apart from this, the past year showed that the president
was interested in not only foreign policy issues directly related to
Azerbaijan but in global processes as well. He is trying to resolve
all these issues by providing quite important advice. Thus, he again
proved to be ‘a global-level politician’. The president once again
asserted in the past year that the country’s position on the Nagornyy
Karabakh conflict could not be changed. Ilham Aliyev demonstrated a
firm position in this connection and made it clear that the problem
could be resolved provided that Azerbaijan’s territorial integrity
is observed.”
No changes for better
Political analyst Eldar Namazov, head of the civil forum For
Azerbaijan, is less optimistic about the passed year. He said that
the expectations of the voters who hoped that reforms would be
launched in the country after the election of a new leader did not
come true. No changes have taken place in the economy. Namazov said
that at the same time there were serious doubts over whether there
was a well-thought-out strategy to democratize the country. “It is
also obvious that there is lack of a team that could implement this
programme,” he said.
Namazov said that it was next to impossible to differentiate between
foreign policy issues and processes inside the country. “Azerbaijan’s
image is mainly formed on the basis of what is happening inside
the country. There are no serious changes for the better in this
regard. The country is still on the crossroads, as it was ahead of
the presidential elections.”
The political analyst believes that the cancellation of NATO exercises
in Azerbaijan was the gravest mistake in the foreign policy in the
past year. “This undoubtedly inflicted serious damage to Azerbaijan in
the Euro-Atlantic space.” In Namazov’s opinion, this was a serious
mistake of the country’s authorities. “It is still unclear what
countries and directions are our priorities. There remained more
questions than answers in the foreign policy in the past year.”
Employment cornerstone of president’s economic policy
“A year is not a very big period of time in terms of economic
achievements in order to assess all its parameters. But something still
can be said about some tendencies,” Inqilab Ahmadov, director of the
Institute for Economic Analysis, said. There are some moments which
can be viewed as achievements of the incumbent president. Certain
contours and directions became clear over the past year. First,
more attention is paid to regional development. To some extent, this
was the result of the endorsed regional development programme. In
fact, regional development was in the focus of the government. Some
facilities were opened and investment projects were launched in the
regions with state assistance. The country’s leadership tends to boost
employment in the regions. Employment became the cornerstone of the
government’s economic policy.”
The expert said that the country’s oil sector was developing quite
successfully. “The newly-elected president was lucky over the past
year to some extent. Oil prices have surged recently. The price of
Azerbaijani oil exceeds 50 dollars (per barrel). This resulted in
more funds being channelled into the social sphere.”
However, the expert regrets that in the past year “we did not witness
a conceptual new approach to economic reforms. Apart from this, no
active steps were taken towards structural reforms. The institutional
activities of the country’s economy were not reformed. These major
issues were not dealt with in the past year.” Ahmadov said that they
might be dealt with next year.
Commenting on employment, the expert stressed that the
figures advertised by officials did not point to a qualitative
change in this issue. “Many statistical data are sometimes
contradictory. Unfortunately, private business has not really
reached the regions. Employment in the country’s regions was mainly
subsidized. Increasing prices are becoming quite a serious problem. We
will be speaking more often about this problem next year when it
really becomes a pressing issue. This is of course connected with an
increase in social payments both from the budget and non-budgetary
funds. But this is not the only factor causing the increase in
prices. The monopoly problem still remains in the country’s economy,
and it was not resolved in the past year.”
Faithful to father’s line
Political analyst Zardust Alizada believes that “the past year was
noted for the fact that the new president continued the political
line of national leader Heydar Aliyev. This in fact means giving
away the country to foreign companies for plundering, trampling
upon all freedoms and putting full pressure on the press.” All this,
the political analyst said, has been going on recently.
Commenting on the president’s personnel policy over the past year,
Alizada compared it to the rules of the Weakest Link TV show. “As a
rule, those who did not suit other team members were ousted from the
ruling team.” He cited the dismissal of National Security Minister
Namiq Abbasov as an example. “The replacement of the professional cheka
(Soviet secret police) member with an Interior Ministry employee
clearly shows what the authorities are interested in. They are
interested solely in having a monopoly on money and hence on power.
“At the same time, the situation around the Nagornyy Karabakh conflict
remains unchanged. A stride backward was made in people’s respect for
their government. This happened despite the purely external signs of
prosperity that was possible thanks to oil money. The past year was in
no way different from previous years. The president was quite sincere
saying on many occasions that he would continue his father’s line. And
he kept his word. The president is persistently enforcing the ideology
of Heydarism, posting his father’s portraits everywhere. The goal is
to idolize the ex-president. This finally points to the authorities’
lack of ideology.”
Alizada said that the president had signed several pardoning decrees
in the past year. “These steps were taken under external pressure
from international structures.”
The authorities have been imitating creating new jobs over the
past year. “Despite everything, people are trying to survive and
are doing something independently.”
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress