NKR LEADER, BRITISH MPS DISCUSS SITUATION IN KARABAKH
Artsakh State TV, Stepanakert
21 Oct 04
October
NKR (Nagornyy Karabakh Republic) President Arkadiy Gukasyan received
members of the British interparliamentary union lead by a member of
the House of Commons, Gordon Marsden, on 20 October.
During the meeting, the NKR president underlined that the visit of
British parliament members was a good opportunity for the people and
leadership of the NKR to inform the international community about
processes going on there.
President Gukasyan filled the British parliamentarians in on the NKR’s
achievements in building democracy based on the rule of law. Arkadiy
Gukasyan noted the importance of creating appropriate conditions for
developing the NGO sector in the republic as a key component of civic
society.
Touching upon the principles of the Nagornyy Karabakh conflict
settlement, the NKR president underlined that the most important goal
for the NKR authorities was to prevent the resumption of military
operations and provide the security of the Nagornyy Karabakh
population.
The NKR president also reassured the visitors of his adherence to the
further development of the NKR economy and creation of decent living
conditions. Gukasyan said this would have a positive impact on the
process of democratization in the NKR.
For his part, Gordon Marsden said that the visit to Nagornyy Karabakh
helped them get more detailed information about the life in the
republic. He also noted that the goal of the visit was to find about
the possibilities for international organizations to implement
humanitarian projects and strengthen civic society in Nagornyy
Karabakh, which became possible after meetings with representatives of
NGOs of the republic.
(Video showed the meeting)
Category: News
BAKU: Companies for cellular services in NK must contact Azeri Min.
Assa-Irada, Azerbaijan
Oct 21 2004
Companies to provide cellular services in Upper Garabagh must contact
Ministry
If `Garabagh Telecom’ wants to provide mobile communication services
in the occupied Upper Garabagh region, it must appeal to the Ministry
of Communications and Information Technologies first, Minister Ali
Abbasov told AssA-Irada.
He said that the Ministry has appealed to the International GSM
Association over the illegal activity of Garabagh Telecom and that
the latter will lost its membership in the entity this July.
Abbasov said that this company has already filed an appeal in this
connection, and if it is approved, the company’s membership may be
restored.
`They allege that the Ministry is not capable of providing mobile
communication services in Upper Garabagh’, he said.
Abbasov added that the Ministry has approached the GSM Association
again saying that if Garabagh Telecom sends a proposal to the
Ministry on providing cellular communication services, it will be
considered.*
La Turquie va signer le traite de Rome instaurant la CPI
Agence France Presse
20 octobre 2004 mercredi 10:44 PM GMT
La Turquie va signer le traité de Rome instaurant la CPI
PARIS 20 oct
Le Premier ministre turc Recep Tayyip Erdogan a annoncé mercredi soir
à Paris que la Turquie allait signer et ratifier le traité de Rome
instituant la Cour pénale internationale (CPI), chargée de juger les
crimes de guerre et contre l’humanité.
“La Turquie va signer et ratifier le traité de Rome” créant la CPI, a
annoncé le dirigeant turc lors d’un débat organisé par l’Institut
français des relations internationales (IFRI).
Le ministre répondait à une question posée par l’ancien ministre de
la Justice socialiste Robert Badinter, instigateur de l’abolition de
la peine de mort en France en 1981.
Etablie par ce traité du 17 juillet 1998, signé par 94 Etats, la CPI,
dont le siège est à La Haye, a démarré son activité le 1er juillet
2002.
La CPI est chargée de juger les responsables de génocides, crimes de
guerre et crimes contre l’humanité.
Lors de ce dîner-débat organisé dans le musée d’Orsay à l’occasion du
25ème anniversaire de l’IFRI, M. Erdogan a, par ailleurs, contesté la
réalité du génocide arménien.
“Ceux qui prétendent qu’il y a eu un génocide arménien n’ont pas eu
l’occasion d’étudier les archives ottomanes”, a-t-il dit. “S’ils le
font, ils verront qu’il y a des tableaux très différents”, a-t-il
affirmé.
“Cette question ne peut être pas être résolue par une méthode
parlementaire mais par une méthode scientifique, par les historiens”,
a-t-il poursuivi. “En utilisant une approche idéologique,
émotionnelle, raciste, on complique la tche”, a-t-il souligné,
répondant à une question posée par Simone Veil, ancienne présidente
du Parlement européen et ancienne déportée par les nazis.
De nombreux hommes politiques réclament en France, où vit une
communauté d’origine arménienne nombreuse (450 000 personnes), que la
Turquie reconnaisse le génocide arménien de 1915. Le Parlement
français a voté en 2001 une loi reconnaissant le génocide arménien.
Enfin, M. Erdogan a appelé la France à soutenir la candidature turque
à l’Union européenne.
“Entre deux pays (la France et la Turquie) qui ont une telle
alliance, on ne peut s’attendre qu’à une solidarité entre eux”,
a-t-il lancé. “Nous nous retrouvons ensemble dans toute une série
d’institutions internationales”, a-t-il ajouté, citant notamment
l’Otan et l’OCDE. “Il est inconcevable que l’on puisse ne pas se
retrouver encore ensemble au sein de l’Union européenne”, a poursuivi
M. Erdogan.
Le Premier ministre turc effectue une visite privée de deux jours à
Paris à l’invitation de l’Ifri.
La Turquie dans l’UE, oui si…
Libération , France
20 octobre 2004
La Turquie dans l’UE, oui si…;
L’Europe devrait proposer à Ankara une voie rigoureuse vers la
démocratisation.
by NEZAN Kendal; Kendal Nezan, président de l’Institut kurde de
Paris.
Le débat passionnel qui s’engage un peu partout en Europe sur la
Turquie révèle une hostilité profonde de l’opinion vis-à-vis de son
adhésion à l’Union. Cette hostilité qui dépasse les clivages
politiques traditionnels est compréhensible. Elle ne saurait être
réduite aux seuls préjugés culturels et religieux ou à des réactions
de peur. La Turquie a une mauvaise image dans l’inconscient des
Européens, y compris dans des pays qui n’ont pas eu à souffrir du
passé ottoman des Turcs et qui n’ont pas de contentieux particulier
avec Ankara, et elle en porte la responsabilité.
Elle récolte aujourd’hui les fruits amers des violations massives des
droits de l’homme et de la persécution des minorités pratiquées par
ses gouvernements successifs tout au long du XXe siècle. Du déni du
génocide arménien à l’épuration de l’Anatolie de sa population
grecque autochtone, aux massacres et déplacements forcés des Kurdes
reniés dans leur identité et leur culture, à la répression des
dissidents s’écartant de l’idéologie nationaliste officielle et
intolérante, la liste de ces crimes est longue. Les Etats européens,
au nom de la Realpolitik, des impératifs de la guerre froide ou de
simples intérêts mercantiles, se sont accommodés de ces pratiques.
Pas la conscience publique tenue constamment en éveil par les
victimes du régime turc et les ONG des droits de l’homme. Les coups
d’Etat militaires quasi décennaux avec leur cortège de rafles,
d’exécutions sommaires, de réfugiés politiques, des procès
inquisitoriaux intentés à des intellectuels, des journalistes, des
élus du peuple comme Leyla Zana, y ont laissé des empreintes
profondes. Dans l’inconscient occidental, la Turquie reste encore le
pays de Midnight Express, un Etat capable de faire parler le turc à
quiconque sous la torture, selon l’inoubliable sketch de Coluche. Un
Etat qui a embastillé et forcé à l’exil ses plus grands artistes
comme Nazim Hikmet et Yilmaz Güney.
Tout cela, c’est du passé, il faut regarder l’avenir car la Turquie
est en train de changer, semble nous dire la Commission européenne,
qui, dans son rapport, dresse un tableau des “modifications apportées
aux systèmes politiques et juridiques turcs qui s’inscrivent dans un
processus de longue durée”. En quoi consistent-elles ?
La Constitution imposée par l’armée en 1982 a été amendée, ses
dispositions les plus liberticides supprimées, mais son esprit reste
autoritaire, et elle conserve toujours, dans son préambule, “le
concept de nationalisme” et “les principes et réformes d’Ataturk
[…], guide immortel et héros incomparable”, comme idéologie
officielle intangible de l’Etat, tout comme le marxisme-léninisme
était un dogme de la Constitution soviétique.
Le nouveau code pénal, qui remplace celui emprunté dans les années
1930 à l’Italie de Mussolini, est dans le contexte turc une avancée
démocratique importante, malgré certains articles potentiellement
dangereux pour la liberté d’expression. La suppression des cours de
sûreté de l’Etat, la levée de l’état d’exception dans les provinces
kurdes, l’abolition de la peine de mort, sont des progrès indéniables
à inscrire dans le bilan de l’actuel gouvernement turc qui cependant,
malgré sa volonté affichée, n’a pu réduire sensiblement la pratique
de la torture.
Réaliste, la Commission européenne nous prévient qu'”il faudra encore
du temps avant que l’esprit des réformes soit pleinement reflété dans
les attitudes des instances exécutives et judiciaires, à tous les
niveaux et dans l’ensemble du pays”.
Les Kurdes, comme d’habitude, sont les oubliés de ces négociations
interétatiques. La Commission évalue leur nombre entre 15 et 20
millions, soit près du tiers de la population totale de la Turquie.
Après des années de tergiversations, le gouvernement turc leur
accorde magnanimement le droit d’organiser des cours privés de kurde
pour adultes et une émission quotidienne de 45 minutes diffusée au
petit matin sur une chaîne publique, sous-titrée en turc, composée de
musique et d’informations officielles. Aucun progrès n’est enregistré
dans le processus de retour de 3 millions de déplacés kurdes et de la
reconstruction des 3 428 villages kurdes évacués et détruits par
l’armée turque. Et pour cause : la politique fondamentale de l’Etat
reste toujours la dispersion des Kurdes et leur assimilation forcée
afin de parvenir, à terme, à forger une Turquie culturellement
homogène.
Bref, sur la question kurde, qui est au coeur même de la
problématique des droits de l’homme, de la démocratisation de la
Turquie et de ses relations avec son voisinage, les avancées restent
infinitésimales et symboliques, juste de quoi ne pas désespérer
Bruxelles qui n’a pas le courage d’inviter Ankara à reconnaître à ses
citoyens kurdes des droits comparables à ceux qu’il revendique pour
les quelque 150 000 Turcs chypriotes.
Dès lors, il n’est pas étonnant que les réformes turques, en dépit de
leur nombre et de leur rythme, paraissent, pour une large partie de
l’opinion, relever plus du ravalement de façade que d’un processus de
démocratisation véritable. On est loin d’une stratégie de rupture
avec le passé.
Malgré ce bilan mitigé, la Commission recommande l’ouverture de
négociations afin d’encourager les efforts des réformateurs turcs et
semble miser sur la dynamique d’adhésion pour régler les dossiers qui
posent actuellement problème.
Curieusement, ce sont les partis conservateurs, qui, pendant des
décennies, s’affichaient comme des alliés fidèles d’Ankara, qui se
montrent aujourd’hui hostiles aux négociations, et les principales
victimes du régime turc qui demandent un dialogue critique avec
Ankara.
Ainsi, selon un récent sondage, 90 % des Kurdes de Turquie se disent
favorables à l’entrée de leur pays dans l’Union européenne car
celle-ci est perçue par eux comme un espace supranational de paix, de
démocratie et de prospérité susceptible de sauver la Turquie de ses
démons nationalistes et militaristes. Ils espèrent aussi, qu’à terme
ils parviendront à obtenir des droits et libertés comparables à ceux
dont jouissent aujourd’hui Basques, Catalans et Ecossais dans
l’Europe démocratique. De plus, le fait qu’à la suite de l’adhésion
turque la frontière de l’Union passe au milieu du Kurdistan donne aux
Kurdes des pays voisins des raisons d’espérer la démocratisation, par
effet de contagion, de leurs Etats respectifs. Les Grecs se disent
également favorables à l’intégration d’Ankara et cette position a
déjà contribué à une nette amélioration de leurs relations avec leurs
voisins turcs.
A l’intérieur de la société turque, outre l’élite déjà occidentalisée
d’Istanbul et de la côte égéenne, la mouvance islamique incarnée par
le parti conservateur AK actuellement au pouvoir place ses espoirs
dans le processus européen qui lui sert notamment de levier pour
démilitariser le régime et réduire la tutelle pesante d’une armée se
conduisant en propriétaire ultime de l’Etat, prête à sévir pour
trahison contre tous ceux s’écartant de la “voie d’Ataturk”.
Si Turcs, Kurdes et Grecs trouvent leurs intérêts dans l’adhésion
turque à l’Union, quel intérêt aurait celle-ci à intégrer un pays de
70 millions d’habitants pauvres et musulmans, de surcroît situé dans
une région instable et infestée de conflits ? Avec un PIB
représentant environ 2 % du PIB de l’Europe des Vingt-Cinq, l’apport
économique turc restera modeste. Contrairement à ce que, par
méconnaissance de l’histoire de la région, affirment certains
stratèges en chambre, l’intérêt géopolitique reste également limité :
à l’exception, peut-être, de l’Azerbaïdjan, l’influence turque est à
peu près nulle dans le Caucase et en Asie centrale. Et en raison de
son passé ottoman, de son alliance avec les Etats-Unis et Israël, la
Turquie n’a pas d’influence significative au sein du monde musulman.
En vérité, en Asie mineure, qui constitue 97 % du territoire de la
Turquie, les seuls voisins terrestres des Turcs sont des Kurdes.
L’Empire ottoman, qui l’avait bien compris, avait accordé une large
autonomie aux princes kurdes pour obtenir leur soutien. Cette réalité
reste encore incontournable car les ressources hydrauliques des
bassins de l’Euphrate et du Tigre sont situées au Kurdistan et les
oléoducs destinés à transporter le pétrole du Caucase et de l’Irak
doivent traverser le pays kurde avant d’arriver au port turc de
Ceyhan.
A regarder de près, le véritable intérêt pour l’Europe de l’adhésion
de la Turquie serait de pacifier et sécuriser ses frontières
orientales. Si dans ses négociations avec Ankara elle parvenait à
convaincre les dirigeants turcs de l’intérêt pour tous de trouver une
solution à la question kurde, de reconnaître le génocide arménien
pour apurer le passé et de régler à l’amiable leurs différends avec
la Grèce, la paix, la justice et la démocratie auraient fait
d’immenses progrès dans une région qui en a bien besoin. Alors, une
Turquie en paix avec ses populations et avec ses voisins devrait
avoir toute sa place en Europe.
Après avoir réconcilié Allemands et Français, Polonais et Allemands,
la construction européenne pourrait ainsi réaliser le miracle de
réconcilier à ses confins Grecs, Turcs, Kurdes et Arméniens.
Une telle ambition historique comporte certainement des risques dont
certains, comme le poids démographique ou la libre circulation des
personnes, peuvent être réglementés et gérés. Elle aura aussi un
coût, évalué à quelque 25 milliards d’euros à l’horizon 2020, qui
reste fort modeste par rapport aux 200 milliards de dollars déjà
dépensés par les Américains dans leur entreprise d’instaurer la
démocratie en Irak.
Une Europe frileuse, sans vision ni ambition finirait par devenir un
club de retraités de l’Histoire. Une Europe ouverte et ambitieuse
devrait proposer à Ankara des négociations avec une feuille de route
rigoureuse en matière de démocratisation, de droits de l’homme, du
règlement du problème kurde, etc. et assumer des risques qui restent
raisonnables car si la Turquie fait l’effort de remplir effectivement
ces conditions elle ne sera plus la même et pourrait être une chance
pour l’Europe. Si, en raison des pesanteurs de son régime, elle
tergiverse ou refuse l’effort requis, la balle restera dans son camp
mais le processus aura tout de même permis quelques avancées pour la
population. Un “oui, si” laisserait la place à l’espoir, et de
l’espoir on en a tous bien besoin.
Oskanian Makes Discordant Statements
OSKANIAN MAKES DISCORDANT STATEMENTS
Azg/am
22 Oct 04
Foreign minister Vartan Oskanian is making discordant statements these
days about Turkey’s possible membership in EU, Armenia’s blockade and
Armenian-Turkish relations.
“There are no diplomatic relations between Armenian and Turkey today,
and the border is closed putting Armenia in a tough situation”,
ITAR-TASS quoted Vartan Oskanian as saying this in Rome on
October19. Oskanian noted at the round table called “South Caucasus:
Stability and Safety” organized by the Italian I nstitute of Foreign
Affairs and the Armenian embassy to Italy that Turkey’s integration to
EU will open a new door for Yerevan-Ankara relations.
The CNN-Turk touched on Oskanian’s speech. “We wish that the
Armenian-Turkish border-gate opened. The fact that we have no
border-gate with Turkey and Azerbaijan causes lot of troubles. Armenia
is a European state by its spirit and is taking important steps to
reach European standards. Turkey’s membership to EU will bring
Europe’s borders closer to Armenia. Acknowledgment ofthe Armenian
Genocide is not a precondition for starting talks with Ankara”,
Oskanian said.
A press release spread by Foreign Ministry’s press center reads: “The
minister touched on Turkey’s membership to EU and presented Armenia’s
position on the issue”. But the press release keeps silent about
Oskanian’s speech. That’s why we turned to ITAR-TASS and CNN-Turk for
details.
Minister Oskanian’s words uttered in Rome do not correspond with his
statement at a press conference a month ago that Armenia’s economy
will develop without either oil or gas pipelines and even in a
blockade.
Vartan Oskanian certainly new the audience before which he was
standing but Armenian officials’ statements very often contain
contradiction especially in case of Armenia-Turkish relations.
Oskanian declares Turkey’s integration to EU as beneficial for
Armenian-Turkish relations in Rome whereas in Yerevan, October 11, he
stated that Turkey is unworthy of EU admittance talks. “A country that
has blockaded Armenia and has recently passed a law making the
recognition of the Armenian Genocide, as well as any claim to withdraw
Turkish forces from Cyprus, a criminal act isnot worthy even the
negotiations for EU accession. We think that Turkey is not ready for
that”, Oskanian said.
Defense Minister Serge Sargsian in his turn told Marko Zakera, deputy
chairman of East European Union, that Armenia considers Turkey’s
membership in EU favorable.
As opposed to Yerevan, Ankara hews to its chosen line in relations
with Armenia. This is a policy of blockade and threats.
It seems that Armenia also has a straightforward Turkish policy: not
to put forward preconditions for starting diplomatic relations. But
Armenian officials become shaky when it comes up to Turkey’s
admittance to the EU. Europe in its turn considers the “Armenian
factor” a trifling issue. Europe is not going to ask Armenia or
Diaspora whether to admit Turkey or not. The “Armenian factor” may
become a subject of bargain at best.
By Tatoul Hakobian
Georgia New Edu. Law: Do Javakhk’s Demographic Changes Stand Behind?
GEORGIA’S NEW EDUCATIONAL LAW
Do Javakhk’s Demographic Changes Stand Behind?
Azg/am
22 Oct 04
Dali Aghdgomeladze is a teacher of Georgian in one of Akhalkalak’s
schools. She speaks Armenian brilliantly. I asked her whether
Georgian is ignored in Javakhk. “Some people try to picture it like
that but there is no ignorancein fact. Everything hangs on parents and
families. When parents explain children that they should learn
English, Georgian, they do so”, Dali said.
Georgian language has been a school subject in the schools of Javakhk
since the Soviet times but only 1 out of 100 school graduates knew
Georgian letters. Though Georgia’s new authorities make efforts to
teach Georgian to Armenians of Javakhk there is hardly any progress
today. There were cases when teachers sent from Tbilisi to remote
villages of Javakhk learnt Armenian but none of pupils learnt
Georgian.
But Georgia’s “rose” leaders never give up. A draft law on “Public
Education of Georgia” is to be discussed in the parliament in near
future. “81 per cent of Javakhk’s population is acquainted with the
coming changes and support reforms”, Haravayin Darpas, Javakhk’s
Armenian newspaper quoted education minister Kakha Lomaya as
saying. “Those who understand the meaning and purpose of the reforms
support the project. But there are also people opposing it. Those are
the corrupted directors of schools”, Lomaya said.
The draft law was not welcomed in Javakhk and in Azeri populated Kvemo
Kartli. “We are against this project, as well as Azeris”, Levon
Levanian, representative of Georgia’s ombudsman to Akhalkalak and
Ninotsminda, said. He said that law’s 3d article’s 5th and 6th points
are the most worrying.
The 5th point reads: “Georgian is the teaching language in all
educational establishments. Abkhaz language together with Georgian is
the teaching language of Abkhazia”. The 6th point reads: “If the
language of an educational establishment does not correspond to the
mother tongue of a pupil, the guardians’ board may include programs of
teaching pupil’s mother tongue or else subjects in the mother tongue
but only within the frames of the current financial support of the
state”.
In case the law is passed, all subjects at the schools of Javakhk will
be taught in Georgian except for Armenian language and literature. 99
per centof teachers of Javakhk’s schools do not know Georgian, and one
can hardly fancy an Armenian teacher explaining to Armenian pupils
Mendeleyev’s law in Georgian.
People think in Akhalkalak that the new educational law has a
far-reaching aim of shifting the region’s demography. Head of Virk
Party Davit Rstakian says: “The state pays 500 lari ($270) those who
will come to teach in Georgian. There is a guileful aim behind the
law: an attempt to change Javakhk=80=99s demographic picture. As soon
as the law is passed, hundreds of teachers will come to the region
with their families and Armenian teachers will drop out of the
schools”.
“Georgians always note that Georgia is in the 2d place with number of
Armenian schools after Armenia. That’s true but that is not due to
Georgians but comes from Armenians habit of living in communities. The
fact that Armenians inhabit whole regions has been disturbing all
Georgian governments since 1918. They made every effort to bar the
Armenians. They succeeded in Akhaltskha”, Rstakian says.
Levanian is also concerned but is suspicious whether Georgians will
stand Javakhk’s winter. “Even if they inhabit region with Georgians
they will hardly stay here. It’s awfully cold here. The government has
already sent few dozens of teachers this year, we’ll see if they will
stand the cold or not”, he says.
A branch of Georgia’s state university opened in Akhalkalak 3
yearsago. “They teach only in Georgian at the university and 100-150
students come tostudy from all over Georgia annually. The state
provides good conditions for them. The state attempts to change
demography of Javakhk artificially. The university will release
semi-educated Armenians, because they don’t know Georgian, and
well-educated Georgians. The latter ones will settle in Javakhk for
5-6 years for their studies, will occupy positions and eventually stay
here”, a resident of Akhalkalak, Vartan Hakobian, says.
Artur Yeremian, head of Akhalkalak Region’s Administration, noticesno
sign of Javakhk’s demographic shift. “We know from the experience that
only Armenians can endure Javakhk’s conditions”, he says reminding
that in 1989 newly inhabited Georgians could stand only one winter and
soon left, leaving the houses especially made for them.
By Tatoul Hakobian
MFA: The official visit of Foreign Minister Oskanian to
MINISTRY OF FOREIGN AFFAIRS OF THE REPUBLIC OF ARMENIA
PRESS AND INFORMATION DEPARTMENT
375010 Telephone: +3741. 544041 ext 202
Fax: +3741. .562543
Email: [email protected]:
The official visit of Foreign Minister Oskanian to Italy
Today, in course of his official visit to Italy, Minister Oskanian had
meetings with municipal authorities and business circles of Venice. The
General Secretary of the Venice Trade Chamber, Romano Tiotso, and local
businessmen received the minister. The talks were held about the necessity
of starting Armenian-Italian relations at the regional level.
Both sides marked the close historical ties and traditions between Venice
and Armenia, in which the role of the Mkhitarians’ Unity is significant in
our days. The two sides also underlined the importance of bilateral
cooperation in the sphere of small and medium-size business. In this field,
winemaking, agricultural production, tourism, and light industry were
considered as the most viable arenas.
The two sides agreed to arrange mutual visits of business groups, exchange
of experts, and business forums, in order to elaborate concrete programs of
cooperation. Minister Oskanian then met with local press.
In the afternoon, a meeting was held with the municipal authorities. In the
course of the meeting, Minister Oskanian expressed his gratitude to the
municipal authorities for their care for the Mkhitarians’ Unity, which held
a crucial role in maintaining the Armenian institutions of S. Ghazar island.
Official Replies to Public Anger at Registration of Jehovah’s Witn.
ARMENIAN OFFICIAL REPLIES TO PUBLIC ANGER AT REGISTRATION OF JEHOVAH’S
WITNESSES
Arminfo
21 Oct 04
YEREVAN
There is nothing illegal in the official registration of the Jehovah’s
Witnesses religious sect, the head of the Armenian government
department for ethnic minorities and religion, Granush Kharatyan, told
a news conference today.
Kharatyan expressed her surprise at the angry reaction from part of
the public caused by the recent registration of this religious
sect. In this connection, she said that no-one had protested against
the registration and activities of Pentecostalists, Protestants or
Jews in Armenia.
“During their ceremonies, Jews call for anti-Christian
actions. However, nobody has ever been concerned about them,” she
said. Also, under Armenia’s laws, a religious sect cannot be denied
registration unless its charter contradicts the law. The charter of
Jehovah’s Witnesses fully complies with the law, as the Armenian
Justice Ministry itself has said.
At the same time, Kharatyan said that the law on religion signed in
1991 is not completely perfect as it does not ban religious ceremonies
hostile to other faiths.
“Our job is not to fight religious sects but oversee them,” Kharatyan
said. “But you cannot oversee something if there is no appropriate
legislation. However, we will withstand this outrage caused by the
(registration) of Jehovah’s Witnesses.”
Haigazian University Celebrates the First Event of 50th Anniv.
Public Relations Director
Contact: Mira Yardemian
Haigazian University
Rue Mexique – Kantari
P.O. Box 11-1748
Riad El-Solh 1107 2090
Beirut – Lebanon
Haigazian University Celebrates the First Event of Its
50th Anniversary: Founders’ Day
On October 18, 2004, at 12:00 pm, the hall of the First Armenian
Evangelical Church in Beirut was full of anticipation as students,
alumni, faculty, staff, press, guests and others gathered to take part
in Haigazian University’s Founders’ Day, the kick-off event of each
academic year. But among the guests this year were the Ambassador of
Armenia in Lebanon, Mr. Areg Hovanessian, and the keynote speaker of
the occasion, the President of the Lebanese Press Federation,
Mr. Mohammad Baalbaki.
Beginning with the Lebanese National Anthem, followed by the
invocation of the Campus Minister, the Rev. Nishan Bakalian, the
Vice-Chairman of the University’s Board of Trustees, the Rev. Robert
Sarkissian, announced the official commencement of the 50th
anniversary celebrations. He assured the audience of the board’s
commitment to the founding principles and mission of Haigazian
University.
In her tribute to the Founders, the Dean of Arts & Sciences, Dr. Arda
Ekmekji, highlighted the factors leading to the foundation of the
University 50 years ago: the need to prepare Armenian Evangelical high
school students for university admission, the efforts of churches in
the Union of Armenian Evangelical Churches of the Near East (UAECNE),
and its then-president, the late Rev. Hovhannes Aharonian, and the
$25,000 grant of Mr. Steven Mehagian to the Armenian Missionary
Association of American (AMAA) in New York, giving birth to the
project in October 1955. Other significant names, such as Stephen
Philibosian, the Rev. Puzant Kalfayan and the AMAA, were mentioned as
maintaining an ongoing interest in the college.
The Rev. Dr. Armenag Haigazian, in whose name the university was
named, was a graduate of Yale University, a distinguished educator,
theologian, linguist, pastor, writer, musician and photographer. Until
his deportation by the Kemalist forces in 1921, he was the much-loved
and respected president of the Jenanyan Apostolic Institute in Konya,
Turkey. All of these attributes of this prominent academic justify the
fact the University was named in his honor.
Afterwards, the audience enjoyed a solo, `My Tribute’ by Andrae
Crouch, powerfully delivered by vocalist Houry Apartian, and
accompanied on the keyboard by Haigazian student Vartan Agopian.
The Director of the Student Life, Mr. Antranik Dakessian, introduced
the Student of the Year for 2004, Mr. Abdel Khaleq Abdel Khaleq, who
in his address acknowledged that Haigazian University has enriched
students not only with excellent education, but also with high ethical
and moral standards. He considered Haigazian his second home, where he
shared with fellow students his goals and experiences, and most
importantly got acquainted with the Armenian culture. Considering that
a well-rounded university education consists of the balanced
acquisition of academic knowledge, social experience and spiritual
well-being, he urged the new students to get involved in activities
and clubs of the university.
The Dean of Business Administration and Economics, Dr. Fadi Asrawi,
remembered the Rocket Society of Haigazian College by a very
interesting slide presentation: Founded at the College in November
1960, the Haigazian Rocket Society was organized for two aims: one, to
interest and acquaint students with this new field of study; and two,
to research the properties and performance of specific propellants and
the construction design of rocket propulsion systems. During the first
year five students participated. This number increased considerably
during the years following, and in the summer of 1962 it became a
national project, adopted by the Lebanese government, under the name
`The Lebanese Rocket Society’. Of particular note was that the
ballistics expert appointed by the Lebanese Army at that time to the
Society, General Youssef Wehbe, was in the audience, and offered his
own reflections on the Society.
The keynote speaker, the President of the Press Federation,
Mr. Mohammad Baalbaki, eloquently delivered his speech and emphasized
on the role that the Armenian community in general, and Haigazian
University in particular, played in the history of Lebanon, in the
years of the Lebanese civil war, and its positive and exemplary
contribution to Lebanese society. He commented that although
Dr. Armenag Haigazian has passed away, his memory and deeds are
perpetuated through the philosophy of Haigazian University, which in
itself is a `Rocket’ in the field of knowledge and higher education.
Finally, the president of the University, Rev. Dr. Paul Haidostian,
offered words in which he considered the namesake of the university,
Dr. Armenag Haigazian, as symbolically a founder behind the founders,
since he as a person embodied the motto of the university: truth,
freedom and service. Truth – Rev. Haigazian had a true and
comfortable sense of belonging to his people and his cultural
context. Likewise, truth at Haigazian University starts with the
discovery of the self, and God. Freedom – Regrettably, Armenag
Haigazian’s Ottoman context did not allow this in the early twentieth
century. With Armenian identity and Lebanese outlook, the University
was able to integrate the Armenians with the non-Armenians, as well as
initiating in the early 60s a scientific symbol of freedom, that is, a
series of rockets called the `Cedar’. Service – Rev. Haigazian’s
significance was in putting all his knowledge and characteristics in
the service of people and God. This sense of service in the University
today derives from our faith in God.
The president continued by acknowledging a number of significant
people present in the audience: Mrs. Maggie Matossian, a member of the
Board of Directors of Haigazian since the very first years, and later
the founder of the Women’s Auxiliary; two of the 43 original students
who were the first class to register in 1955; and General
Wehbe. Finally he expressed gratitude to the many people in Lebanon
and the USA, who have worked, prayed, paid, planned, thought for
Haigazian or received higher education in it.
Following the Alma Mater, sung by Ms. Apartian, the attendees
proceeded to the Matossian Gallery in the Mugar Building, where
archival documents and photographs of 50 years of Haigazian’s history
had been newly put on display.
If only Derrida hadn’t died
Turkish Daily News
21 October 2004
If only Derrida hadn’t died
Gunduz Aktan
Debates concerning our membership in France have gone beyond the reasonable
with all the political parties and movements divided. Everyone is offering
an excuse depending upon their political convictions. A racist like Le Pen
and a Jewish socialist like Laurent Fabius find themselves defending the
same opinion.
In parliamentary debates on our membership held on Oct. 15 — brought
forward by the government — many criticisms were aired, but no vote —
which would have been unfavorable to us — was taken. This way, the
possibility of Turkey getting a date to start negotiations at the European
Union summit on Dec. 17 was kept alive.
Meanwhile, President Jacques Chirac is trying to insert an article in the
Constitution allowing a referendum on the accession treaty that will be
signed at the end of the negotiations. This will nullify France’s
international responsibilities that started with the Ankara Treaty signed in
1963, and ask the French people to have their say in violation of the
principle of “pacta sun servanda.”
On the other hand, the argument that “all negotiations are open-ended” is
also wrong. They are asking us to accept, right from the beginning, that
even if we fulfill all the clauses of the negotiations, which may last 10 to
15 years, we might not become members due to unrelated reasons.
There are those who oppose Turkey’s membership in every EU country. However,
none are carried away with their opposition like in France. If Turkey is too
large, populous, situated in a tough location, or is Muslim, this fact is
evident to all the other 24 members, not only to France. Moreover, Turkey
did not acquire these characteristics yesterday — so what’s wrong with
France?
Had Derrida been alive, he would have applied the method of deconstruction
to this bizarre phenomenon in his country. This method, in very general
terms, is based on the creation of a conceptual construction by the
exclusion of its opposite concept. In other words, it is necessary to
exclude the concept of fascism and racist anti-Semitism, as opposed to the
constituent concept of democracy and respect for human rights in order to
realize an integration which would prevent a war like World War II.
In this respect, countries like Turkey that are to become EU members have to
implement democracy and human rights. Turkey is expected to grant rights to
“minorities” like the Kurds and to face the “Armenian genocide” claims, just
like they faced the Jewish Holocaust.
Derrida, who was well acquainted with Freud, would have immediately realized
that Europe was not isolating abstract concepts as the opposite of
“democracy-human rights-minority rights,” but rather Turkey and the Turkish
people as representing these concepts.
The anti-Turkish groups in France and elsewhere believe that Turkey’s
anti-democratic system is based on its founding ideology of Kemalism, will
not change and believe that those who conducted the so-called “genocide” on
Armenians would not grant Kurds any rights. This “unchangeable” character
attributed to us constitutes the proof that we are subjected to exclusion.
According to Freud, the material repressed in the unconscious remains
unchanged there. On the day you return having changed, they do their outmost
not to believe you.
France has another problem with us: We are closer to France than any other
EU member. The Republic of Turkey was influenced by the French Revolution.
French enlightenment and positivism have become an integral element of our
souls. In order to believe that it is the one and only, France
narcissistically exaggerates the minor differences. By projecting the
anti-Semitism of the Vichy regime and the sins of French nationalism
committed in Algeria onto the excluded Turks, “purified” France becomes a
part of the unification of Europe. It believes that the excluded or
repressed material projected onto us would return to the EU through our
membership and that this would be the end of the EU. France fears that its
vision or illusion of the EU will end with our membership.
Derrida used to say that at the end of the deconstruction process a
synthesis would be produced by the amalgamation of the interiorized concept
with the excluded one and that this new concept, which would reflect the
realities, would bring about justice.
This will be the greatest contribution our membership will make to the EU.
NOTE: This article appears in daily Radikal and, after being translated by
the Turkish Daily News staff, in the Turkish Daily News on the same day.