Turkey and the hypocrisies of Europe

Turkey and the hypocrisies of Europe
By Fred Halliday
Open Democracy, UK
Dec 16 2004
Fred Halliday dissects four underlying arguments against Turkey’s
admission to the European Union – and finds them all wanting.
The European Union is attempting to create common European
institutions and policy: a worthy and desirable project, if a pale
reflection of the original, liberal-internationalist aims of the
1950s. It has agreed two momentous decisions in 2004: the inclusion
of ten new member-states, and the foundation of its legal identity
embodied in a new constitution. Now, at a summit in Brussels on 16-17
December 2004, it faces a third: whether to open negotiations with
Turkey that will lead to that country’s membership of the European
Union.
There are, however, few sights so undignified as that of European
states in a condition of moral indignation, and the unseemly debate
over this major strategic issue has not just divided but shamed many
Europeans. While some states – led by the United Kingdom and Spain –
wish to proceed with serious negotiations with Turkey, and others
take a more ambiguous or even hostile stance, the argument reveals
more about the European “community” than about the Turkey it has been
preparing to judge.
Europe’s moral foundations
A rhetorical device favoured by opponents of Turkish entry is to
affirm the “Christian” (or “Judaeo-Christian”) foundations of Europe.
The former French president, Giscard d’Estaing; the current Italian
prime minister, Silvio Berlusconi; the European Union commissioner
for the internal market, Fritz Bolkestein; leaders of the opposition
CDU in Germany, Angela Merkel and Edmund Stoiber – are just some of
those who invoke this alleged religious-historic identity.
The argument ignores three basic realities. First, the cultural,
political and linguistic origins of European lie in Greece and Rome,
and long predate Christianity (the word “democracy” is found nowhere
in the Bible). Moreover, Christianity and Judaism are in their origin
not European at all, but – itself a testament to 2,000 years of
interaction – religions that originated and have long flourished in
the middle east.
Second, Muslim empires – and in particular the Ottoman, precursor of
the Turks – have a record of historic tolerance of Jews and other
minorities that (while open to considerable criticism) is far
superior to that of Christian Europe. Indeed, the permanent Jewish
population of around 50,000 in modern Turkey, descendants of those
expelled by Christian Spain in 1492, is testimony to one of the best
records of toleration of Jews of any country.
Third, the contemporary culture of Europe is not in any meaningful
sense Christian; it is, rather, secular in tone and content if not
actually hostile to religion.
The prominent European political figures cited above may concede
these points, but then shift the argument to the defence of certain
basic European principles like equality between men and women. Yet
here, no one examining the record of the Vatican, for example – from
its 1968 encyclical Humanae Vitae to the letter to Catholic bishops
on 1 August 2004 and its catastrophic policy on contraception and
Aids – can believe that this variant of Christianity is compatible
with core modern, human, values.
History’s shadow
Many opponents of Turkish entry to the European Union question
whether Turkey (or Islam) is part of Europe. The truth is that in
terms of its cultural and religious presence Islam has been integral
to Europe for over 1,000 years – including 800 years in Spain and at
least 600 years in the Balkans and Russia.
What is true of religion is equally so for power politics: the
Ottoman empire was a component of the European great-power system,
variously allied with Britain and France (against Russia in the
Crimean war of 1853-56) and with Germany (against Britain and France
in the first world war).
Even more important, in the past century Europe has been unable to
insulate itself from the process of politics in Turkey itself. Turkey
played the key role in detonating the explosion of 1914 – one that
destroyed the old European order and led to the European civil war of
1914-1991 from which we are just emerging. Its precedent lay in a
fundamental event of modern European and middle-eastern history, the
Young Turk revolution of 1908. This event led to the Balkan wars of
1911-1913, from which emerged the radical Serbian nationalism that
killed Archduke Ferdinand in Sarajevo in June 1914.
This is a reminder that the modern politics of Europe are
inextricably shaped not by the fantasies of Brussels – capital of a
country that has pioneered a radical form of ethnic-political
separatism – but by the condition of the middle east. There are many
illustrations of the point: the impact of the Algerian war on France
in the late 1950s, of Afghanistan on the Soviet Union in the 1980s,
and of Morocco on Spain in the 1920s and again on 11 March 2003.
Whether or not the EU opens the way to Turkish membership, intimate
bonds tie Europe to events in its neighbouring region.
Does Turkey qualify?
The discussion of Turkish membership of the European Union is
dominated by the legal and constitutional requirements Turkey is
expected to meet in order to qualify. Where these reflect progress in
implementing the rule of law, ending torture, ensuring the rights of
women, and creating a reasonable federal solution to the Kurdish
question, then – as the Turkish writer Soli Özel has written – many
Turks welcome the changes.
The Turkish state’s deficiencies over human rights and the rule of
law explain its civil society’s enthusiasm about Europe. This civil
society wants to accelerate a democratic process in the country.
Europe should help it – but Europe (witness Berlusconi’s great escape
from corruption charges and the illegalities of party funding in
France) has little moral authority to lecture the world about
political standards.
Indeed, it could be said that in key respects Turkey is too European,
in that it shares with France a rigid and (for human rights)
lamentable concept of state secularism. The French proclaim
themselves defenders of secularism as if their 1905 legislation had
patented the idea, but forget that clothing bans (as in the country’s
new law forbidding the wearing of religious apparel in schools) are
valid under international law only if they relate directly to
national security – certainly not the case over the hijab. There is
only one consistent, universalist and secular position on the wearing
of religious headwear – for Muslims, Catholic nuns, or Orthodox
Jewish haredim alike: to be against it, but to defend the right to
wear it.
The argument over whether Turkey qualifies for the European Union
often spills over into other important areas: Cyprus and the Armenian
genocide.
The Cyprus question remains unresolved but to hold Turkey of all
countries responsible for the current impasse is grotesque. Turkey is
certainly responsible for abuses in the years after the island’s
independence in 1960, but its main agonies lie in the conflict and
partition of 1974, when Greek Cypriot nationalists helped by Athens
organised an illegal coup that provoked a Turkish invasion. It is
that intransigent and manipulative Greek nationalism which in early
2004 blocked a reasonable settlement proposed, after lengthy
negotiations, by Kofi Annan. The Turks are right to say that the
United Nations, not the European Union, must find a solution to
Cyprus.
The issue of the Armenian genocide is one that Turkish nationalism
has refused to acknowledge. The best way to proceed in resolving it
is not through inter-state confrontation but to work with those
Turkish historians and writers who are prepared to recognise what
happened on developing a common, and documented, account of the
events of 1915.
A focus on the genocide serves, moreover, to absolve Europe
(including Russia and Turkey itself) from a comparably grave injury
to the Armenians – their confinement in the aftermath of 1918 to a
landlocked mini-state around Yerevan. In any case, Europe cannot
easily make official recognition of the Armenian genocide a condition
of Turkish entry without exposing its own hypocrisy: Germany’s record
in Namibia in 1904 and Europe in the 1940s, Italy’s in Libya after
1911, Belgium’s in the Congo in the 1900s, Spain’s in the Americas
and Portugal’s in Africa after 1500, are sufficient evidence.
A modicum of post-imperial self-criticism – including the Turks as
inheritors of the Ottoman empire – is in order here. This would
encompass two further issues that are currently less discussed than
Cyprus or Armenia: Kurdish rights in Turkey, and Turkey’s role in the
Kurdish areas of northern Iraq.
A question of culture
All sides in the debate over Turkey and the European Union seem to
want to invoke a fixed – “essential” or “true” – version of European
culture to which Turks, and Muslim immigrants in general, should
adhere. Proponents of Turkish entry see this culture as open and
cosmopolitan; opponents see it (or its Leitkultur (“leading
culture”), as espoused by the CDU) as incompatible with Islam.
The argument that every society and political system needs a
Leitkultur is not in itself invalid, and most people in Turkey would
agree with its presupposition. What is in question is how this
Leitkultur is defined. European culture is no more frozen in time
than are Europe’s external frontiers; rather, it is a set of
possibilities that modern society and politics can define. All
cultures (including Muslim ones) can be open or closed, and all can
and do change.
European arrogance over Turkey is a definite barrier to the deeper
opening that the 17 December decision should register. This is
evident too in the comprehensive ignorance of Turkey among many of
Europe’s politicians, commentators and intellectuals. How many
pontificating voices know the basic facts of Ottoman and Turkish
history, including repeated violations inflicted by the country’s
Christian neighbours over the last three centuries, culminating in
the attempted subjugation of the country by Britain, France and Italy
after the first world war? How many know the tiles of Iznik, the
films of Yilmaz Güney and Handan Ipekci, the poems of Nazim Hikmet
and Orhan Veli Kanik, the novels of Yasar Kemal and Orhan Pamuk – or
even the joys of Imam Bayildi? Such historical and knowledge might
teach a lot about politics also.
In short, Europe’s decision over Turkey – and the wider issues of
coexistence, multiculturalism and different values it signifies – is
not for Turkish citizens and Turkish immigrants to learn German or
English (which they or their children will anyway) but for Europeans
to learn Turkish – and perhaps eat köfte at least once a week. The
more Turks and Europeans mix and mingle, the more the truths of their
shared past, present, and future will emerge.
–Boundary_(ID_ZAhjc4qUOpNtgt6kXzkL7g)–
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

ANKARA: Armenian Patriarch believes Turkey to get accession date on

Armenian Patriarch believes Turkey to get accession date on 17 December
Anatolia news agency, Ankara
16 Dec 04
Istanbul, 16 December: Mesrob II, Patriarch of Armenian community
in Turkey, said on Thursday [16 December] that he always advocated
Turkey’s membership to the European Union (EU). He said he believed
the EU would give a date to Turkey on 17 December to start full
membership negotiations.
Mesrob II told AA [Anatolia] correspondent that he shared the view that
the EU was not a Christian club, and noted: “Religion and religious
culture have become a tool of politics both for the EU and the Turkish
politicians more than necessary. Parliaments of the EU member countries
do not make decisions according to the doctrines of the Bible and
the Turkish parliament does not make its decisions according to
Koran. Integration of the EU and Turkey would be for the interest of
the region, the world and the peace among the civilizations.”
Replying to a question about the attitude of the Armenians living
in France, putting forward the allegations of “so-called Armenian
genocide”, towards Turkey’s EU membership, Mesrob II said: “The
disaster in 1915 is an issue which can be abused. To this end,
the foreigners will bring this issue on the agenda when they have
the opportunity. The issue should be excluded from being an issue
of exploitation soon by starting official and unofficial dialogue
process.”
“Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan in an earlier
statement said this was the job of historians and should be left to
historians. His statements are extremely realistic. Meeting face
to face with history is important for building of future on solid
basis. People can not embrace each other before making peace. Dialogue
process should be initiated,” Mesrob II said.

First Public Forum Of Javakhk Presents Problems Of Region and Ways O

FIRST PUBLIC FORUM OF JAVAKHK PRESENTS PROBLEMS OF REGION AND WAYS OF THEIR
SOLVEMENT
AKHALKALAKI, December 16 (Noyan Tapan). The first public forum
held upon the initiative of the Armenian public organizations of
Samtskhe-Javakheti was held in Akhalkalaki on December 11. The
socio-economic problems of the region were discussed during the
forum. The issues of language, culture, self-government will be
discussed during the next forums.
The name of the forums, i.e “Integration, not Assimilation” the
Armenian public organizations of Javakhk explained by the fact that
the Armenian population of the region, which wasn’t against the
integration of the krai into Georgia, at the same don’t agree with
the policy of “integration” carried out by the central authorities,
which leads to assimilation in reality.
According to the A-Info Agency, participants of the forum listened
to the reports of two experts on socio-economic issues of the region
Ashot Shipaktsian and Artashes Palangian. Rapporteurs touched upon the
discriminating policy of the central Georgian authorities, as a result
the region populated by the Armenians is in so grave socio-economic
condition now.
In the approved resolution the forum presents the socio-economic
problems facing Javakhk, establishing that Samstskhe-Javakheti yielded
to other regions of the country on the indices of human development
greatly. Such problems are enumerated: unemployment, migration,
the collapse of the public health system, the low level of social
defense, the deepening of poverty, state of roads, fuel and energy
crisis, etc. The resolution emphasizes that the participation of the
national minorities in the public and political life of the country
and in the solution of the socio-economic problems isn’t provided.
The forum expressed worry about the fact that “the available problems
and the susceptibilities of the Georgian authorities’ policy in the
spheres of national minorities’ rights and demography (…) can damage
the international authority of Georgia and the development of democracy
in the country, the unsolved socio-economic and other problems can
strike a blow to the integration of the national minorities into
society, delays in the resoution of accumulated problems can create
new unwished tension, the atmosphere, which is explosive without this,
is becoming more heated as a result of the nationalistic propaganda
of some mass medias and public and political organizations.”
The resolution suggests the ways of the improvement of the situation,
including the creation of jobs, the development of transport and other
infrastructures, the repairs of highways connecting the region with the
seaside regions of Georgia, with Tbilisi and Armenia, as well as the
overhaul of inter-village roads, the application of new technologies
in the sphere of agriculture, the provision of the agricultural
products processing in the provinces, the rapid resolution of the
irrigation problem, the reconstruction and resumption of the work of
Akhalkalaki airport.
The forum thinks it is necessary that the measures contributing to
the formation, strengthening and preservation of the atmosphere of
tolerance in the international problems should be undertaken. The
forum also emphasizes the importance of cooperation with the
international organizations, which are engaged in the issues of
democracy development, human development, human rights protection
and economic integration.
The Council is charged with the establishment of the particularized
committee that should elaborate the program on the socio-economic
development of Samtskhe-Javakheti to present it to the corresponding
bodies interested in it. Besides, the forum decided to apply to the
central Georgian authorities and the local self-governmental bodies
once again with hope for multilateral discussion and the solution
of problems, as well as decided to cooperate with the international
structures, donor-countries, a well as public organizations and mass
medias, Armenian public organizations operating in Georgia.

Europarliament Demands From Turkey Recognition Of Armenian Genocide

EUROPARLIAMENT DEMANDS FROM TURKEY RECOGNITION OF ARMENIAN GENOCIDE
STRASBOURG, December 15 (Noyan Tapan). On December 15, the
Europarliament with 407 votes for and 262 votes against made amendments
and adopted a resolution on Turkey’s joining the EU written by a
Dutch deputy Camiel Eurlings.
According to the European Armenian Federation for Justice and
Democracy, the Europarliament addresses the Armenian issues at least in
8 points of the resolution. The amendments proposed in this connection
have been written by parliamentarians who represent 5 factions.
In the final version of the resolution the Europarliament asks Turkey
to be reconciled to the Armenian people by recognizing the Armenian
genocide and calls on the European Council and the European Commission
to demand that Turkey officially recognize the historic reality of
the genocide and lift without delay the blockade imposed on Armenia.
Amendment No.18 on the Armenian genocide, which was written by deputies
Fransis Wurts and Dimitrios Papadimoulids, was adopted with 395 votes
for and 273 votes against.
Amendment No.83 written by Jaques Toubou and some other deputies was
adopted with 332 votes for and 325 votes against and calls on the
European Commission and the European Council to demand that Turkey
recognize the Armenian genocide and lift without delay the blockade
imposed on Armenia “in accordance with the European Council resolutions
adopted in 1987 and 2004.”
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

“I Have Fully Lived All Years,” Gohar Gasparian Says

“I HAVE FULLY LIVED ALL YEARS,” GOHAR GASPARIAN SAYS
YEREVAN, December 15 (Noyan Tapan). On December 15, the glorification
evening of famous opera singer Gohar Gasparian, USSR People’s Artist,
laureate of state prizes, will be organized in the Yerevan Chamber
Music House after Komitas.
According to RA NA Public Relations Department, the previous
day, the singer’s birthday, Hranush Hakobian, Chairwoman of RA NA
Standing Commission on Science, Education, Culture and Youth Affairs,
Heghine Bisharian and Ararat Malkhasian, members of the commission,
visited the singer and congratulated her on the occasion of her
80th anniversary. They said warm words in the memory of her husband,
Tigran Levonian, as well. By the way, Tigran Levonian’s birthday is
also on December 14.
According to the great singer, she has fully lived all years, doesn’t
want to bring back anything from her past, she misses her late husband
and needs him very much.

Presentation Of “Fatal Toys” Video Film Takes Place In Etchmiadzin

PRESENTATION OF “FATAL TOYS” VIDEO FILM TAKES PLACE IN ETCHMIADZIN
ETCHMIADZIN, December 15 (Noyan Tapan). The “Fatal Toys” video
film was presented in the patriarchate of the Mother See of Holy
Etchmiadzin. The film is dedicated to the children who became disabled
because of the mines and other uncontrolled ammunition left after
the war in the Nagorno Karabakh Republic and border regions. About 10
children tell what happened to them and speak about their problems in
the 30-minute film. Photographer German Avagian’s works, photographs
and stories of disabled children put down by him were used in the film.
“The war is still going on in Nagorno Karabakh, occupied territories
and other border regions of Armenia,” Tigran Paskevichian, Director
of Shoghakat TV company, the author of the film, said in his opening
speech. He also said that they intend to publish a book representing
the stories of these children and showing the arms crippling them
with their characteristics.
Catholicos of All Armenians Karekin II was also present at the
presentation. In his speech he praised the film and thanked its
producers.
The film was produced by the Shoghakat TV company with the grant of
the Internews NGO.

His Holiness Karekin II Expresses Satisfaction With Careful Attitude

HIS HOLINESS KAREKIN II EXPRESSES SATISFACTION WITH CAREFUL ATTITUDE
OF RF AUTHORITIES TO ARMENIAN COMMUNITY
ETCHMIADZIN, December 16, (Noyan Tapan). On December 15, His Holiness
Karekin II, Supreme Patriarch and Catholicos of All Armenians received
Mr. Boris Grislov, President of the State Duma (Parliament) of the
Russian Federation.
His Holiness welcomed the honored guest to the Mother See of Holy
Etchmiadzin and reflected on the increasing cooperation between
Armenia and Russia in economic and cultural spheres. Thanking His
Holiness for the audience, Mr. Grislov informed the Catholicos of
the details of his recent visit to Armenia and the agreements which
were made between the two governments.
His Holiness and Mr. Grislov also spoke of the close ties that exist
between the Armenian Apostolic and Russian Orthodox Churches. Offering
his best wishes to the President of the Duma, the Catholicos of All
Armenians extended his appreciation to the Russian authorities for
their care and attention to the Armenian community in Russia.
Present for the meeting were His Grace Bishop Yeznik Petrossian,
Director of Inter-Church Relations for the Mother See; Mher
Shahnazarian, president of the standing committee for defense,
national security and internal affairs for the National Assembly
of the Republic of Armenia; and Anatoly Dryukov, Ambassador of the
Russian Federation to Armenia.

His Holiness Aram I Receives Dean Of Political Science Department Of

HIS HOLINESS ARAM I RECEIVES DEAN OF POLITICAL SCIENCE DEPARTMENT OF AMERICAN
UNIVERSITY OF BEIRUT
ANTELIAS, LEBANON, December 15 (Noyan Tapan). Dr. Farid El Khazen, the
Dean of the Political Science Department of the American university
of Beirut, met on December 14 His Holiness Aram I, Catholicos of
Great House of Cilicia.
According to the Press Office of the the Armenian Catholicosate of
Cilicia, the agenda of the meeting covered issues related to the local
political life, the prevailing situation in Iraq and peace process,
as well as the question of membership of Turkey in European community.
Dr. Farid El Khazen is a well known politician and a key member of
the opposition in Lebanon.
Dr. Khazen was accompanied by Dr. Nora Bayrakdarian, a member of the
Ecumenical Relations’ Committee of the Catholicosate.

Aram I:”How Is It Possible To Accept Turkey In European Community Wh

ARAM I: “HOW IS IT POSSIBLE TO ACCEPT TURKEY IN EUROPEAN COMMUNITY
WHEN IT STILL IGNORES GENOCIDE COMMITTED AGAINST ARMENIAN PEOPLE”
ANTELIAS, LEBANON, December 15 (Noyan Tapan). In the context of a
telephone interview with a European press agency, and in answering to a
question concerning the membership of Turkey in European community, His
Holiness Aram I, Catholicos of Cilicia, expressed his concern and said:
“European community was not established only on economic interests
and political collaboration. It is fundamentally a community of human
values which ensure the identity, integrity and unity of Europe,
and give a particular place and role to Europe in international
community. Among these values human rights occupy an important place”.
According to the Press Office of the Armenian Catholicosate of Cilicia,
His Holiness Aram I raised a great doubt and concern about the way
the human rights are respected in Turkey. He said: “To what degree
and in what way the human rights values are accepted, respected and
practiced in and by Turkey? Turkey still ignores its immediate past;
it still rejects to recognize the Genocide which was planned and
executed by the Ottoman Turkey in 1915. I believe that the recognition
of the Armenian Genocide by Turkey is not only an “Armenian problem”;
it is a problem that pertains to the entire international community,
since it is a problem of justice and human rights. The recognition of
the Armenian Genocide by Turkey must be taken very seriously by Europe
as Turkey is trying by all means to become a full member of Europe”.
Then concluding his remarks, said: “In this globalized world of ours
nations, religions, cultures and civilizations must live together
on the basis of peaceful coexistence. But living together as good
neighbors and as part of broader community implies to accept our fault,
to affirm the truth and recognize the rights of the others. In fact,
the real community is built on the basis of mutual trust and by doing
justice. Therefore, it is my firm expectation that beyond economic and
political interests Europe will continue to remain firmly attached to
basic human values. It is the expectation and hope of Armenians all
over the world that the present Turkey reaffirm the truth, accepting
the historical reality by recognizing the Armenian Genocide”.
In answering to a question related to the recent pressures and
difficulties surrounding the Ecumenical Patriarchate, in Turkey,
His Holiness Aram I said: “Here is another concrete example of the
way the human rights are respected in Turkey. The World Council of
Churches and the Conference of the Churches in Europe have publicly
expressed their concern on this matter expressing their solidarity
with the Ecumenical Patriarch”.
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Raffi Portakal Brings Works Of Picasso,Dali And Other World-Famed Ar

RAFFI PORTAKAL BRINGS WORKS OF PICASSO, DALI AND OTHER WORLD-FAMED ARTISTS IN TURKEY
ISTANBUL, December 16 (Noyan Tapan). “Raffi Portokal, a specialist of
art and an organizer of auctions on the sail of art works, realized
his dream, i.e to familiarize art-lovers of Turkey to the creation
of the most famous and most talented artists of the world,” Istanbul
“Marmara” newspaper writes.
These days the “Portakal” hall is turned to a show-room and guarded
by the strongest security measures, as one may watch Picasso’s “Man
with Pipe”, Salvador Dali’s “Magic – Seven Ats”, Raul Dyufi “Harbor
Fishers” and other works of 15 world-famed artists of the West.
Raffi Portakal said during his interview given to the “Zaman” newspaper
that it is time now to represent the Turkish art abroad and the foreign
art in Turkey. He expressed hope that all the art-lovers would visit
the exhibition and watch the originals of the greatest artists’ works.